Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 120; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1105
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 29 Jan 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5560/2024
- Sections
- 401, 397, 372, 302, 401(3), 401(5), 378, 162, 145, 164, 148, 34
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1105 : 2025 INSC 120 Mahabir & Ors.
v.
State of Haryana (Criminal Appeal No(s). 5560-5561 of 2024)
29 January 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned judgment and order of conviction in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction u/s.401 r/w. s.397 of the CrPC; Whether Proviso to s.372 of CrPC creates a right in favour of victim; Is Proviso to s.372 of CrPC an exception; Is Proviso to s.372 is retrospective in operation.
Headnotes† Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.401 r/w. s.397 – In the Criminal Revision Application No. 194 of 2006 filed by the original de facto complainant before the High Court against the judgment and order of acquittal passed by the trial Court came to be allowed and the appellants herein were held guilty of the offence of murder punishable u/s.302 of IPC – Correctness: Held: s.401 reads the High Court’s powers of revision – s.401(3) lays down that nothing in this section shall be deemed to authorize a High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction – The bar u/s.401(3) CrPC is categorical and express – For High Court to treat the revision as an appeal, the condition laid down u/s.401(5) CrPC are required to be fulfilled i.e. when the High Court is satisfied that application for revision was made under the erroneous belief that no appeal lies and in the interest of justice, the High Court may treat the application for revision as a petition of appeal – A reasoned, speaking order was required to be passed recording that conditions u/s.401(5) were fulfilled – However, in the instant case no such procedure was adopted – The general provision on appeals is s.372 CrPC which says that no appeal was permissible other than provided for, in law – The Proviso to s.372 CrPC had not * Author 1106 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports yet come into effect as on 19.01.2006 when the revision petition was filed, for it was added only w.e.f. 31.12.2009 – The statutory right of appeal by a victim against such acquittal arose only from the date of the amendment w.e.f. 31.12.2009 – As the said revision was filed by the father of the deceased on 19.01.2006 well before the above amendment, such right was not available at the relevant point of time – Therefore, the very first condition u/s.401(5) itself would not have been possible to be fulfilled, i.e. the right of the victim to appeal did not lie under the Code at the time of filing the revision petition – As regards appeals against acquittals, the relevant provision for appeals, and specifically for appeal to the High Court are detailed out u/s.378 CrPC – Thus, only the State had the statutory right to appeal against the order of acquittal in 2006, and indisputably, the State did not file appeal challenging the said order of acquittal – Thus, the High Court committed an egregious error in reversing the acquittal and passing an order of conviction in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction and that too without affording any opportunity of hearing to the appellants herein. [Paras 33, 35, 36, 37, 38, 46] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Proviso to s.372 – A right created in favour of victim:
Held: The significant development that has taken place in this provision is that a ‘proviso’ was added by the Amending Act No.5 of 2009 – The plain reading of the statement of objects and reasons for introducing the proviso to s.372 CrPC makes it clear that it wanted to confer certain rights on the victims – It has been noted therein that the victims are the worst sufferers in a crime, and they don't have much role in the court proceedings – They need to be given certain “rights” and compensation, so that there is no distortion of the criminal justice system – This, by itself, is clear that the object of adding this proviso is to create a right in favour of the victim to prefer an appeal as a matter of right – It not only extends to challenge the order of acquittal, but such appeal can also be filed by the victim if the accused is convicted for a lessor offence or if the inadequate compensation has been imposed – Thus, it is clear as per the golden rule of interpretation, that the ‘proviso’ is a substantive enactment, and is not merely excepting something out of or qualifying what was excepting or goes before – Therefore, by adding the ‘proviso’ in s.372 of CrPC by this amendment, a right has been created in favour of the victim. [Paras 52, 53, 54] [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1107Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Proviso to s.372 – Is Proviso to s.372 an exception:
Held: Given the text of s.372 and the scheme of the Act, it is clear that the proviso establishes an independent right, and must be interpreted within that framework – s.372 forbids appeals unless otherwise authorized by the Code, or by another law – The proviso, however, states that the victim shall have the right to appeal under certain circumstances – Given the rule enacted in s.372, it cannot be said that the proviso to that provision carves out an exception to the rule – According to the rule in s.372, appeals must be in accordance with the Code; according to the proviso - which is itself part of the Code - victims have the right to appeal under certain circumstances – The proviso to s.372 dispenses with the requirement of leave in case it is the victim who is appealing – While s.372 enacts that no appeal shall lie except as provided for by the Code, it refers to the various provisions of Chapter 29, including the proviso, each of which prescribe the requirements and procedures for appeals under different circumstances – The proviso, therefore, is not an exception to s.372, but a stand-alone legal provision. [Para 67] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Is Proviso to s.372 is retrospective in operation:
Held: In view of the various Supreme Court decisions, it is clear that a statute which affects substantive rights is presumed to be prospective in operation – In view of the aforesaid, the amendment so made in s.372 CrPC by adding a proviso in the year 2009 creating a substantive right of appeal is not retrospective in nature – A statute which creates new rights shall be construed to be prospective in operation unless otherwise provided, either expressly or by necessary implication – In the instant case, it is, therefore, clear that in the year 2006 when the judgement of acquittal was passed, the de facto complainant had no right to challenge the impugned order passed in 2006 by way of filing the appeal – In such circumstances sub section (5) of s.401 CrPC has no application in the present case. [Paras 68-72] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s.162 – Evidence Act, 1872 – s.145:
1108 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: The trial courts cannot independently use statements made to the police that have not been proven, nor can it base its questions on such statements if they conflict with the witness's testimony in court – The phrase 'if duly proved' in s.162 of the CrPC indicates that the statements of witnesses recorded by the police cannot be immediately admitted as evidence or examined – They must first be proven through eliciting admissions from the witness during cross-examination and also during the cross-examination of the Investigating Officer – While statements made to the Investigating Officer can be used for contradiction, this can only be done after strict compliance with s.145 of the Evidence Act – This requires drawing attention to the specific parts of the statement intended for contradiction – This is what is required u/s.145 of the Evidence Act but even where a witness is confronted by his previous statement and given an opportunity to explain that part of the statement that is put to him does not constitute substantive evidence – There is a catena of decisions laying down the principle in law that the material elicited as contradiction by use of s.145 of the Indian Evidence Act is not substantive evidence – Even in regard to the statement recorded u/s.164 of the CrPC by authorised Magistrate, it has been held accordingly – Therefore, the fact that the contradictions are proved through the investigating officers though the witnesses have denied having made such statements, does not translate the contradictions into substantive evidence – Unless there is substantive evidence, it cannot be acted upon legally particularly to base a conviction. [Paras 80, 81] Unlawful detention – Principle established:
Held: The principle is well established that in cases where there can be no dispute of facts, the constitutional courts have the power to award compensation in case a person has been deprived of his life and liberty without following the procedure established by law. [Para 84] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Public Prosecutors – Appointment should be on the basis of merit:
Held: The AGPs and APPs in respective High Courts should be appointed solely on the merit of the person – The State Government owes a duty to ascertain the ability of the person; how proficient the person is in law, his overall background, his integrity etc. – Public Prosecutor holds a “Public Office” – The primacy given to [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1109Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana him under the Scheme of CrPC has a “special purpose” – Certain professional, official obligations and privileges are attached to his office – His office may also be termed as an office of profit as he remains disqualified to contest the election so long he holds the office though permanency is attached to the office and not to the term of his office – His duties are of public nature – He has an “independent and responsible character” – He holds the public office within the scope of a “quo warranto proceedings” – Prosecutor is not a part of investigating agency but is an “independent statutory authority” – He performs statutory duties and functions – He holds an office of responsibility as he has been enclothed with the power to withdraw the prosecution of a case on the directions of the State Government. [Paras 92, 94] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – Public Prosecutors – Importance of the office of the Public Prosecutor – discussed. Case Law Cited Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v. State of Bihar (now Jharkhand) & Anr. [2002] Supp. 1 SCR 495 : (2002) 6 SCC 650; Joseph Stephen & Ors. v. Santhanasamy & Ors. [2022] 8 SCR 182 : (2022) 13 SCC 115; Ganesha v. Sharanappa & Anr. [2013] 12 SCR 400 : (2014) 1 SCC 87; Santhakumari & Ors. v. State of Tamil Nadu & Ors. (2023) 15 SCC 440; A.N. Sehgal & Ors. v. Raje Ram Sheoran & Ors. [1991] 2 SCR 198 : AIR 1991 SC 1406; S. Sundaram Pillai & Ors. v. V.R. Pattabiraman & Ors. [1985] 2 SCR 643 : AIR 1985 SC 582; State of Bombay & Anr. v. United Motors (India) Limited & Ors. [1953] 1 SCR 1069 : (1953) 1 SCC 514; State of Kerala & Anr. v. B. Six Holiday Resorts Private Ltd. & Ors. [2010] 3 SCR 1 : (2010) 5 SCC 186; Mallikarjun Kodagali (Dead) represented through Legal Representatives v. State of Karnataka & Ors. [2018] 13 SCR 1 : (2019) 2 SCC 752; Hitendra Vishnu Thakur & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. [1994] Supp. 1 SCR 360 : (1994) 4 SCC 602; Sudhir G. Angur & Ors. v. M. Sanjeev & Ors. [2005] Supp. 4 SCR 851 : (2006) 1 SCC 141; Anees v. State Government of NCT [2024] 6 SCR 164 : 2024 SCC OnLine SC 757; D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal (1996) Supp. 10 SCR 284 : (1997) 1 SCC 416; Nilabati Behera v. State of Orisa & Ors. [1993] 2 SCR 581 : (1993) 2 SCC 746 – relied on.
1110 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Jang Sing v. Brij Lal and Others [1964] 2 SCR 145 : AIR 1966 SC 1631; Manharibhai Muljibhai Kakadia & Anr v. Shaileshbhai Mohanbhai Patel & Ors. [2012] 8 SCR 1015 : (2012) 10 SCC 517; Bal Manohar Jalan v. Sunil Paswan & Anr. [2014] 7 SCR 900 : (2014) 9 SCC 640; Nandini Satpathy v. P.L. Dani & Anr. [1978] 3 SCR 608 : (1978) 2 SCC 424; Government of Andhra Pradesh & Ors. v. P. Laxmi Devi [2008] 3 SCR 330 : (2008) 4 SCC 720; Super Cassettes Industries Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. [2009] 14 SCR 627 : (2009) 10 SCC 531; Ramesh Kumar Soni v. State of Madhya Pradesh [2013] 1 SCR 1129 : (2013) 14 SCC 696; Kiran Bedi v. Committee of Inquiry & Anr. [1989] 1 SCR 20 : (1989) 1 SCC 494; Vishwanath Agrawal v. Sarla Vishwanath Agrawal [2012] 7 SCR 607 : (2012) 7 SCC 288 – referred to.
Shiv Bhagwan Moti Ram Saraoji v. Onkarmal Ishar Dass AIR 1952 Bom 365 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Law Commission of India's 154th Report, 1996.
List of Acts Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Evidence Act, 1872.
List of Keywords High Court’s powers of revision; Revision as an appeal; Golden Rule of Interpretation; Substantive Enactment; Compensation; Proviso’s retrospective Operation; Proviso’s prospective in operation; Revisional Jurisdiction; Cross-Examination; Contradiction; Substantive Evidence; Investigating Officer; Public Prosecutor; Criminal Law enforcement system; Statutory duties; Section 401 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Section 372 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Proviso to section 372 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973; Unlawful detention.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No(s). 5560-5561 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 27.08.2024 and 02.09.2024 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CRR No. 194 of 2006 [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1111Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Ms. Indira Unninayar, Mrs. Rukhsana Choudhury.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Samar Vijay Singh, Ms. Sabarni Som, Keshav Mittal, Fateh Singh. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
1. Since the issues raised in both the captioned appeals are the same and the challenge is also to the self-same judgement and order passed by the High Court, those were taken up for hearing analogously and are being disposed of by this common judgement and order.
2. We may clarify that the Criminal Appeal No. 5560 of 2024 arises from the judgement and order passed by the High Court, reversing the acquittal and holding the appellants herein guilty of the offence of murder. Whereas Criminal Appeal No. 5561 of 2024 arises from the order of sentence, which ultimately came to be passed by the High Court.
3. These appeals arise from the judgement and order passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh dated 27.08.2024 in Criminal Revision Application No. 194 of 2006 by which the criminal revision filed by the original de facto complainant against the judgment and order of acquittal passed by the trial court came to be allowed and the appellants herein were held guilty of the offence of murder punishable under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (for short, “the IPC”) and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life and fine of Rs. 50,000/- each and further, rigorous imprisonment for 3 months in default of payment of fine.
4. “There is no higher principle for the guidance of the court than the one that no act of courts should harm a litigant and it is the bounden duty of the courts to see that if a person is harmed by a mistake of the court he should be restored to the position he would have occupied, but for that mistake.”
1112 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
5. The above is aptly summed up in the maxim “actus curiae neminem gravabit”. It implies that judicial actions should not unfairly harm any party and that courts should act judiciously to prevent errors that could lead to injustice. (Jang Sing v. Brij Lal and Others reported in AIR 1966 SC 1631).
6. We need not delve much into the facts of the present case as our order dated 13.12.2024 gives more than a fair idea as to how these appeals have come up before us. The order reads thus:
“3. The three appellants herein along with three other co-accused were put to trial for the offence of murder punishable under Section 302 read with Section 148 and 149 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. On conclusion of the trial, the Trial Court held two co-accused guilty of the alleged crime, whereas the other four, including three appellants herein, came to be acquitted.
4. The State did not deem fit to challenge the acquittal of the three appellants herein. One of the convicts went in appeal before the High Court and the father of the deceased in turn invoked the revisional jurisdiction of the High Court under Section 401 read with Section 397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 seeking to challenge the acquittal of the three appellants herein. It appears that the appeal filed by one of the convicts against his order of conviction came to be dismissed despite the fact that the convict had already passed away.
5. In the revision application, which was filed by the father of the deceased, the High Court held all the three appellants herein guilty of the alleged offence of murder and sentenced them to undergo life imprisonment. We are informed that they were taken into custody on the very same day the judgment was pronounced by the High Court and now they are serving the sentence as imposed by the High Court.
6. We are not able to understand, on what basis the High Court in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction under Section 401 read with Section 397 of the Code of Criminal Procedure could have converted the finding of acquittal into one of conviction. Sub-Section (3) of Section 401 [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1113Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana reads thus: “(3) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to authorize a High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction.”
7.There is one another feature which has disturbed us.
According to the learned counsel the High Court proceeded ex-parte without issuing notice to the three appellants herein in the revision petition, who had already been acquitted by the Trial Court.
8. We are also informed that the father of the deceased, who had filed the revision application before the High Court had also passed away much before the judgment of the High Court.
9. Issue notice to the State of Haryana, returnable on 19th December, 2024.
10. In such circumstances referred to above, all the three appellants are ordered to be released on bail.
The substantive order of sentence passed by the High Court is suspended till further orders. Accordingly, IA No. 285726/2024 stands disposed of.
11. Registry to call for the records and proceedings of the Sessions Case No. 4 of 1988/2005, disposed of by Additional Sessions Judge, Rewari, from the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh.”
CASE PUT UP BY THE APPELLANTS HEREIN
7. The case pertains to an incident dated 13.03.1998. It was a day of Holi festival. The incident was first reported by one Dharampal to the police at 2:55 p.m. on 13.03.1998 itself within two hours of the incident, stating that one Om Parkash s/o Shiv Lal (Complainant) and Om Parkash S/o Chandgi Ram (deceased) had assaulted him, Murti w/o Ram swarup and Usha, W/o Dayanand respectively. Dharampal alleged that the two assailants climbed on to the roof of his house and caught hold of him and in the scuffle, both of them fell down from the roof and both of them also suffered injuries.
8. However, the complaint lodged by Dharampal referred to above was neither investigated nor any FIR was registered, for the reasons best known to the Police.
1114 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
9. Instead, an FIR came to be registered on the statement of the above-mentioned Om Parkash S/o Shiv Lal (the Complainant) on 14.03.1998 i.e. one day later, implicating inter alia, the appellants herein. This was followed by a further statement dated 15.03.1998, naming Dharampal and Sri Chand, a senior citizen who walked with the aid of a walking stick (baint) as accused.
10. Upon appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence adduced in the trial, the Sessions Court held that the prosecution had failed to prove its case against the appellants/accused viz. Mahabir, Raj Kumar, Dayanand and Krishan Kumar beyond reasonable doubt, and accordingly, acquitted them vide its judgment and order dated 05.10.2005 passed in Sessions Case No. 4 of 1998/2005. The Sessions Court, however, convicted Dharampal of the offence under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC. Since co-accused Sri Chand passed away during the trial, the proceedings against him stood abated.
11. No appeal was preferred by the State of Haryana against the said judgment dated 05.10.2005 acquitting the appellants herein.
12. On 19.01.2006, Chandgi Ram, father of deceased Om Parkash, preferred Criminal Revision being CRR-194-2006 (O&M), seeking to challenge the acquittal of the appellants viz. Mahabir, Raj Kumar, Dayanand and Krishan Kumar.
13. The convict Dharampal filed Criminal Appeal being CRA-752-DB-2005 (O&M) against the judgment of conviction dated 05.10.2005 and order on sentence dated 08.10.2005.
14. Accused Raj Kumar s/o Raghbir Singh passed away on 24.02.2015. The order dated 07.11.2019 indicates that service could not be effected upon the appellants (respondents in the said Revision Petition, CRR-194-2006), due to non-payment of process fee. As on 12.07.2022 too, the appellants who were respondents in the revision petition were not served with the copy of the revision petition. The counsel for the revisionist also informed the High Court that he had no instructions in the matter. In December 2023, the revisionist Chandgi Ram passed away; thus, there was no revisionist before the High Court from the date of demise onwards, as well as, on the date of final hearing. In February 2024, the convicted-accused, Dharam Pal, also passed away. Hence, his conviction appeal also [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1115Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana stood abated, however, the same was not brought to the notice of the High Court by the State.
15. On 21.08.2024, the High Court passed an order that since the revisionist was not being represented by any counsel, the Court was appointing legal aid counsel to assist the Court on behalf of the revisionist in the revision petition. The Court further directed that the legal aid counsel be supplied with the Paper book. On behalf of the accused (appellants), a counsel was appointed to assist the Court (without any corresponding order to supply the paper book to him). Arguments were heard on the same day. The revision petition and the conviction appeal were decided by the High Court and by a common judgment and order dated 27.08.2024, the CRA-752- DB-2005 filed by Dharampal was dismissed (O&M) and CRR-194- 2006 (O&M) was allowed.
16. After coming to know about the judgment reversing the acquittal, the appellants surrendered/were taken into custody.
17. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellants are here before this Court with the present two appeals.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANTS
18. Ms. Indira Unninayar, the learned counsel submitted that despite an express statutory bar on reversing a finding of acquittal the High Court in violation of this statutory bar, reversed the acquittal into a conviction.
19. She submitted that the High Court in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction has undoubtedly the power to set aside the acquittal, but such interference is called for only in exceptional cases and that too only for the purpose of re-trial. However, it is not permissible to convert such acquittal to conviction. The only course left to it in such exceptional cases, is to order retrial, which, was not done.
20. She submitted that no right of appeal was available to the victim in law at the time the revision was filed and therefore, there was no scope for the court to even treat the revision as an appeal that ‘lay under the Code of Criminal Procedure (for short, “the CrPC” or “Code”)’ at the time as provided for under Section 401(5) above.
21. Despite an express statutory bar on any order being passed to the prejudice of the accused unless he has had an opportunity of being 1116 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports heard either personally or by pleader in his own defence, the High Court proceeded to hear and pronounce its judgment without adhering to the above. The above was also in violation of the principles of natural justice, the right to access the criminal justice system, and the constitutional right of the accused to be represented by a counsel of their choice under Articles 21 & 22(1) read with 20(3) respectively of the Constitution of India. Yet the matter proceeded without service upon the accused.
22. The revision petition was filed on 19.01.2006. However, the High Court’s order dated 07.11.2019, indicates that - Service could not be effected upon the appellants who were respondents in the said revision petition, CRR-194-2006, due to non-payment of process fee.
23. The order dated 12.07.2022 reflects that the appellants who were respondents in the revision petition were not served with the copy of the revision petition, as of 12.07.2022. The counsel for the revisionist had also informed the High Court that he had no instructions.
24. The order dated 21.08.2024 reflects that - since the revisionist was not represented by a validly engaged counsel, the High Court appointed a legal aid counsel to assist the Court on behalf of the deceased revisionist. The said counsel was supplied with the paper book. Arguments were heard on the same day and judgment was reserved.
25. By way of abundant caution, the appellants had approached the Registry of the High Court to obtain a ‘Copy of Service Report in CRR-194-2006’ on 3.10.2024 and the Registry replied on 14.10.2024 that ‘Required doc not available on DMS’ and ‘No Service Report is available in CRR-194-2006 in this file’.
26. Neither the Counsel appointed by the Court had a chance to peruse the record and prepare for any arguments to assist the Court, nor did he had any occasion or opportunity to confer/contact/consult with the appellants herein to seek instructions for defending their acquittal and contesting the revision petition, as he was appointed and asked to represent the accused/respondents there and then, on the very same day, that the arguments were heard and judgement reserved.
27. The above was in gross violation of the principles of natural justice as well as the appellants’ constitutional right to be represented by [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1117Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana a counsel of their own choice under Articles 21 & 22(1) respectively of the Constitution of India.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE OF HARYANA
28. The learned counsel appearing for the State submitted that the High Court in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction under Section 401 read with Section 397 of the CrPC could not have reversed the acquittal and passed an order of conviction. However he submitted that as sub section (5) to Section 401 provides that if an appeal lies under the CrPC, but an application for revision had been made to the High Court by any person and if the High Court is convinced that such application had been filed under the erroneous belief that no appeal lies thereto, then in the interest of justice the High Court can treat the application for revision as an appeal and deal with the same accordingly.
29. According to the learned counsel appearing for the State, the High Court in the case on hand, could have invoked sub section (5) of Section 401 and with the aid of the proviso to Section 372 of the CrPC could have treated the revision filed by the de facto complainant as an appeal. However, even for the purpose of invoking sub section
(5) to Section 401 CrPC, the High Court has to pass an appropriate order in that regard.
30. The learned counsel appearing for the State went to the extent of submitting that although the proviso to Section 372 CrPC was introduced sometime in 2009, i.e., after the judgment of acquittal yet the High Court could have given retrospective effect to the proviso to Section 372 and should have treated the revision application filed by the de facto complainant as an appeal under Section 372 of the CrPC.
ANALYSIS
31. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, the only question that falls for our consideration is whether the High Court committed any error in passing the impugned judgment and order of conviction in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction under Section 401 read with Section 397 of the CrPC.
1118 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF LAW
32. Section 397 CrPC reads thus:- “397. Calling for records to exercise powers of revision.—(1) The High Court or any Sessions Judge may call for and examine the record of any proceeding before any inferior Criminal Court situate within its or his local jurisdiction for the purpose of satisfying itself or himself; to the correctness, legality or propriety of any finding, sentence or order, recorded or passed, and as to the regularity of any proceedings of such inferior Court, and may, when calling, for such record, direct that the execution of any sentence or order be suspended, and if the accused is in confinement that he be released on bail or on his own bond pending the examination of the record. Explanation.—All Magistrates, whether Executive or Judicial, and whether exercising original or appellate jurisdiction, shall be deemed to be inferior to the Sessions Judge for the purposes of this sub-section and of section 398.
(2) The powers of revision conferred by sub-section (1) shall not be exercised in relation to any interlocutory order passed in any appeal, inquiry, trial or other proceeding.
(3) If an application under this section has been made by any person either to the High Court or to the Sessions Judge, no further application by the same person shall be entertained by the other of them.”
33. Section 401 CrPC reads thus:- “401. High Court’s powers of revision.—(1) In the case of any proceeding the record of which has been called for by itself or which otherwise comes to its knowledge, the High Court may, in its discretion, exercise any of the powers conferred on a Court of Appeal by sections 386, 389, 390 and 391 or on a Court of Session by section 307, and, when the Judges composing the Court of Revision are equally divided in opinion, the case shall be disposed of in the manner provided by section 392.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 1119Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana
(2) No order under this section shall be made to the prejudice of the accused or other person unless he has had an opportunity of being heard either personally or by pleader in his own defence.
(3) Nothing in this section shall be deemed to authorise a High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one conviction.
(4) Where under this Code an appeal lies and no appeal is brought, no proceeding by way of revision shall be entertained at the instance of the party who could have appealed.
(5) Where under this Code an appeal lies but an application for revision has been made to the High Court by any person and the High Court is satisfied that such application was made under the erroneous belief that no appeal lies thereto and that it is necessary in the interests of Justice so to do, the High Court may treat the application for revision as a petition of appeal and deal with the same accordingly.”
34. Section 401(3) says – “Nothing in this section shall be deemed to authorize a High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction.”
i. Thus, the bar is categorical and express.
35. Section 401(5) says – “Where under this Code an appeal lies but an application for revision has been made to the High Court by any person and the High Court is satisfied that such application was made under the erroneous belief that no appeal lies thereto and that it is necessary in the interests of justice so to do so, the High Court may treat the application for revision as a petition of appeal and deal with the same accordingly.”
i. For the High Court to treat the revision as an appeal, all of the above conditions were required to be fulfilled.
ii. And a reasoned, speaking order was required to be passed recording that they were fulfilled.
iii. However, no such procedure was adopted.
36. The general provision on appeals is Section 372 Cr PC which says – No appeal to lie unless otherwise provided. – No appeal shall lie 1120 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports from any judgment or order of a Criminal Court except as provided for by this Code or by any other law for the time being in force. i. Thus, no appeal was permissible other than provided for, in law.
37. The Proviso to the above had not yet come into effect as on 19.01.2006 when the revision petition was filed, for it was added only w.e.f. 31.12.2009. The Proviso says – [Provided that the victim shall have a right to prefer an appeal against any order passed by the Court acquitting the accused or convicting for a lesser offence or imposing inadequate compensation, and such appeal shall lie to the Court to which an appeal ordinarily lies against the order of conviction of such Court.] i. Thus, the statutory right of appeal by a victim against such acquittal arose only from the date of the amendment w.e.f. 31.12.2009. As the said revision was filed by the father of the deceased on 19.01.2006 well before the above amendment, such right was not available at the relevant point of time. ii. Therefore, the very first condition under Section 401(5) itself would not have been possible to be fulfilled, i.e. the right of the victim to appeal did not lie under the Code at the time of filing the revision petition.
38. As regards appeals against acquittals, the relevant provision for appeals, and specifically for appeal to the High Court, are detailed out below:
a. Section 378. Appeal in case of acquittal – Section 378 (1) says – Save as otherwise provided in sub-section (2), and subject to the provisions of sub-sections (3) and (5), b. The relevant section pertaining to an appeal to the High Court is Section 378(1)(b) which says – The State Government may, in any case, direct the Public Prosecutor to present an appeal to the High Court from an original or appellate order of an acquittal passed by any Court other than a High Court [not being an order under clause (a)] or an order of acquittal passed by the Court of Session in revision.].
i. Thus, only the State had the statutory right to appeal against the order of acquittal in 2006, and [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1121Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana ii. Indisputably, the State did not file appeal challenging the said order of acquittal.
PRECEDENTS EXPLAINING THE POSITION OF LAW
39. This Court in Bindeshwari Prasad Singh v. State of Bihar (now Jharkhand) & Anr. reported in (2002) 6 SCC 650, laid down that there is a limit on the powers of the High Court as a Revisional Court, prohibiting it from converting a finding of acquittal into one of conviction. Para 12 reads thus: - “12. We have carefully considered the material on record and we are satisfied that the High Court was not justified in reappreciating the evidence on record and coming to a different conclusion in a revision preferred by the informant under Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Subsection (3) of Section 401 in terms provides that nothing in Section 401 shall be deemed to authorize a High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction. The aforesaid sub-section, which places a limitation on the powers of the revisional court, prohibiting it from converting a finding of acquittal into one of conviction, is itself indicative of the nature and extent of the revisional power conferred by Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. If the High Court could not convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction directly, it could not do so indirectly by the method of ordering a retrial. It is well settled by a catena of decisions of this Court that the High Court will ordinarily not interfere in revision with an order of acquittal except in exceptional cases where the interest of public justice requires interference for the correction of a manifest illegality or the prevention of gross miscarriage of justice. The High Court will not be justified in interfering with an order of acquittal merely because the trial court has taken a wrong view of the law or has erred in appreciation of evidence. It is neither possible nor advisable to make an exhaustive list of circumstances in which exercise of revisional jurisdiction may be justified, but decisions of this Court have laid down the parameters of exercise of revisional jurisdiction by the High Court under Section 401 of the Code of Criminal Procedure in an appeal against 1122 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports acquittal by a private party. (See D. Stephens v. Nosibolla [1951 SCC 184 : AIR 1951 SC 196 : 1951 Cri LJ 510], K. Chinnaswamy Reddy v. State of A.P. [AIR 1962 SC 1788 : (1963) 1 Cri LJ 8] , Akalu Ahir v. Ramdeo Ram [(1973) 2 SCC 583 : 1973 SCC (Cri) 903], Pakalapati Narayana Gajapathi Raju v. Bonapalli Peda Appadu [(1975) 4 SCC 477 : 1975 SCC (Cri) 543 : AIR 1975 SC 1854] and Mahendra Pratap Singh v. Sarju Singh [AIR 1968 SC 707 : 1968 Cri LJ 665] .)”
40. This Court in Joseph Stephen & Ors. v. Santhanasamy & Ors. reported in (2022) 13 SCC 115, laid down that on a plain reading of sub-section (3) of Section 401 CrPC, it has to be held that sub-section
(3) of Section 401 CrPC prohibits/bars the High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction. Para 10 reads thus:- “10. Applying the law laid down by this Court in the aforesaid decisions and on a plain reading of sub-section (3) of Section 401CrPC, it has to be held that sub-section (3) of Section 401CrPC prohibits/bars the High Court to convert a finding of acquittal into one of conviction. Though and as observed hereinabove, the High Court has revisional power to examine whether there is manifest error of law or procedure, etc. however, after giving its own findings on the findings recorded by the court acquitting the accused and after setting aside the order of acquittal, the High Court has to remit the matter to the trial court and/or the first appellate court, as the case may be.”
41. This Court in Joseph Stephen (supra), holds that first, the High Court has to pass a judicial order to treat an application for revision as petition of appeal. The High Court has to pass a judicial order because sub-section (5) of Section 401 CrPC provides that if the High Court is satisfied that such revision application was made under the erroneous belief that no appeal lies thereto and that it is necessary in the interests of justice so to do. While treating the application for revision and to deal with the same as a petition of appeal, the High Court has to record the satisfaction as provided under sub-section
(5) of Section 401 CrPC. Para 14 reads thus:- “14. Now so far as the power to be exercised by the High Court under sub-section (5) of Section 401 CrPC, namely, [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1123Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana the High Court may treat the application for revision as petition of appeal and deal with the same accordingly is concerned, firstly the High Court has to pass a judicial order to treat the application for revision as petition of appeal. The High Court has to pass a judicial order because subsection (5) of Section 401 CrPC provides that if the High Court is satisfied that such revision application was made under the erroneous belief that no appeal lies thereto and that it is necessary in the interests of justice so to do. While treating with the application for revision as petition of appeal and deal with the same accordingly, the High Court has to record the satisfaction as provided under sub-section (5) of Section 401 CrPC. Therefore, where under the CrPC an appeal lies, but an application for revision has been made to the High Court by any person, the High Court has jurisdiction to treat the application for revision as a petition of appeal and deal with the same accordingly as per sub-section (5) of Section 401 CrPC, however, subject to the High Court being satisfied that such an application was made under the erroneous belief that no appeal lies thereto and that it is necessary in the interests of justice so to do and for that purpose the High Court has to pass a judicial order, may be a formal order, to treat the application for revision as a petition of appeal and deal with the same accordingly.”
42. This Court in Ganesha v. Sharanappa & Anr. reported in (2014) 1 SCC 87, in para 11, clarifies that :
“… Interference with the order of acquittal is called for only in exceptional cases – where there is manifest error of law of procedure resulting into miscarriage of justice, and, where the acquittal has been caused by shutting out evidence which otherwise ought to have been considered or where material evidence which clinches the issue has been overlooked. In such exceptional cases, the High Court can set aside an order of acquittal, but it cannot covert it into one of conviction. The only course left to the High Court in such exception cases, is to order retrial”.
43. This Court in Santhakumari & Ors. v. State of Tamil Nadu & Ors. reported in (2023) 15 SCC 440, laid down that the order passed by 1124 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the High Court is in the teeth of the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 401 of the CrPC as interpreted by this Court in Manharibhai Muljibhai Kakadia & Anr. v. Shaileshbhai Mohanbhai Patel & Ors. reported in (2012) 10 SCC 517. Paras 5 and 6 respectively read thus:- “5. Having considered the submissions, since it is not in dispute that the proposed accused were not served notice of the revision proceedings, the order passed by the High Court is in the teeth of the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 401 of the Code as interpreted by this Court in Manharibhai Muljibhai Kakadia [Manharibhai Muljibhai Kakadia v. Shaileshbhai Mohanbhai Patel, (2012) 10 SCC 517 : (2013) 1 SCC (Cri) 218] .
6. The decision in Manharibhai Muljibhai Kakadia [Manharibhai Muljibhai Kakadia v. Shaileshbhai Mohanbhai Patel, (2012) 10 SCC 517 : (2013) 1 SCC (Cri) 218] has also been followed in Bal Manohar Jalan v. Sunil Paswan [Bal Manohar Jalan v. Sunil Paswan, (2014) 9 SCC 640 :
(2014) 5 SCC (Cri) 256], wherein it was held : (Bal Manohar Jalan case [Bal Manohar Jalan v. Sunil Paswan, (2014) 9 SCC 640 : (2014) 5 SCC (Cri) 256] , SCC p. 644, para 9) “9. In the present case challenge is laid to the order dated 4-3-2009 at the instance of the complainant in the revision petition before the High Court and by virtue of Section 401(2) of the Code, the accused mentioned in the first information report get the right of hearing before the Revisional Court although the impugned order [Sunil Paswan v. State of Bihar, 2011 SCC OnLine Pat 600] therein was passed without their participation. The appellant who is an accused person cannot be deprived of hearing on the face of the express provision contained in Section 401(2) of the Code and on this ground, the impugned order [Sunil Paswan v. State of Bihar, 2011 SCC OnLine Pat 600] of the High Court is liable to be set aside and the matter has to be remitted.””
44. The decision in Manharibhai Muljibhai (supra) was referred to and relied upon in Bal Manohar Jalan v. Sunil Paswan & Anr. reported in (2014) 9 SCC 640, wherein it was inter alia, held that [2025] 1 S.C.R. 1125Mahabir & Ors. v. State of Haryana “The appellant who is an accused person cannot be deprived of hearing on the face of the express provision contained in Section 401(2) of the Code and on this ground, the impugned order of the High Court is liable to be set aside…”.
45. This Court in Nandini Satpathy v. P.L. Dani & Anr. reported in (1978) 2 SCC 424 held that the right to consult an advocate of choice shall not be denied to any person who is arrested. This does not mean that persons who are not under arrest or custody can be denied such right. The spirit and ethos of Article 22(1) is that it is fundamental to the rule of law that the service of a lawyer shall be available for consultation to the accused person under circumstances of near custodial interrogation. Moreover, the right against self-incrimination is best practiced & best promoted by conceding to the accused, the right to consult a legal practitioner of his choice. Lawyers’ presence is a constitutional claim in some circumstances of our country, and in the context of Article 20(3), is an assurance of awareness and observance of the right to silence.
46. Thus, it is as clear as a noonday that the High Court committed an egregious error in reversing the acquittal and passing an order of conviction in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction and that too without affording any opportunity of hearing to the appellants herein.
47. We could have closed this matter at this stage; however, we would like to explain the position of law in so far as the applicability of sub section (5) to Section 401 of the CrPC read with the provision to sub section 372 of the CrPC is concerned.
IS THE PROVISO TO SECTION 372 CRPC RETROSPECTIVE IN
OPERATION?
48. A very fabulous argument was canvassed on behalf of the State that the proviso to Section 372 of the CrPC is retrospective in operation. Therefore, although the revision was filed in 2006, yet as it came to be decided in 2014, the proviso to Section 372 CrPC was applicable. The High Court could have treated the revision application as an appeal under Section 372 at the instance of the complainant. If the High Court would have treated it as an appeal, then it would have been within its jurisdiction to reverse the acquittal and passed an order of conviction.
1126 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.