Union of India & Ors. v. Lt. Col. Rahul Arora
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 672; [2024] 9 S.C.R. 186
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Prasanna Bhalachandra Varale, Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra
- Decided
- 9 Sept 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2459/2017
- Sections
- 57, 39, 45
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 9 S.C.R. 186 : 2024 INSC 672 Union of India & Ors.
v.
Lt. Col. Rahul Arora (Civil Appeal No. 2459 of 2017)
09 September 2024 [Prashant Kumar Mishra* and Prasanna Bhalachandra Varale, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Legality of the appointment of Judge Advocate who was admittedly junior to the respondent.
Headnotes† Service Law – Army Medical Corps – Respondent was charge-sheeted for: (i) extraneous consideration declaring an army recruit as ‘fit’ after previously declaring him ‘unfit’;
(ii) absenting himself without leave from 11.04.2004 to 19.04.2004; (iii) conduct of unbecoming of an officer and the character expected of his position – Upon conclusion of trial by General Court Martial and two of the three charges proven, he was dismissed from service – Armed Forces Tribunal upheld the findings of guilt – However, the High Court allowed the writ petition preferred by the respondent solely on the ground that an officer junior to the respondent has acted as Judge Advocate in GCM:
Held: Before the High Court, two different convening orders were produced – One by the appellant and the other one by the respondent – While the documents submitted by the appellant contained the reasons for appointing a junior as the Judge Advocate whereas in the convening order submitted by the respondent no such reason was mentioned – After comparing the documents, the High Court recorded a finding that the convening order Annexure R-I (produced by the appellant before the High Court) has been altered after the same was dispatched and received by the Headquarters Artillery Centre – The High Court specifically observed that once a document has been put in the course of transmission by the General Officer Commanding, Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, * Author [2024] 9 S.C.R. 187Union of India & Ors. v. Lt. Col. Rahul Arora Karnataka and Kerala area, the same could not be changed/altered or modified except after recording that there was a mistake, which needs correction – Once dispatched by the officer signing the same, the communication of the document is complete and any alteration in the document is unauthorised – It is quite apparent that the reason for culling out exception as held permissible by this Court in Charanjit Singh Gill case, was not mentioned in the document while the same was dispatched by the issuing authority and supplied to the respondent – Subsequent mentioning of the reason in the other document, after putting signatures by the issuing authority, was unauthorised and impermissible, the High Court has correctly held that the convening order suffers from incurable defect as held by this Court in Charanjit Singh Gill case – The legal position is thus well settled in Charanjit Singh Gill case that non recording of reasons of appointment of an officer junior in rank as a Judge Advocate in the convening order invalidates the Court Martial proceedings – The High Court has not committed any error of law in holding so in the facts and circumstances of the case. [Paras 8, 9] Case Law Cited Union of India & Anr. v. Charanjit Singh Gill [2000] 3 SCR 245 : (2000) 5 SCC 742 – relied on.
Union of India v. S.P.S. Rajkumar and Ors. [2007] 5 SCR 521 : (2007) 6 SCC 407 – referred to.
List of Acts Army Act; Army Rules.
List of Keywords Service Law; Army Medical Corps; Dismissal from service; Appointment of Judge Advocate; Convening orders; Alteration in document; Incurable defect in convening order; Non-recording of reasons in convening order; Court Martial Proceedings. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2459 of 2017 From the Judgment and Order dated 21.05.2014 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CWP No. 20380 of 2012 188 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties R Bala, Sr. Adv., Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Ashok Panigrahi, Ishaan Sharma, Aaditya Dixit, Advs. for the Appellants.
G.S. Ghuman, Harkirat Singh, Jatinder Pal Singh, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.
This appeal is directed against the order dated 21.05.2014 passed by the High Court of Punjab & Haryana in CWP No. 20380 of 2012. Under the said order, the High Court has set-aside the order passed by the Armed Forces Tribunal, Chandigarh, 1 which has dismissed the appeal of the respondent and upheld the findings and sentence awarded by the General Court Martial.2
2. The respondent was first commissioned in the Army Medical Corps3 as medical officer from 29.05.1978 to 31.07.1983. He was again commissioned as regular officer in AMC on 25.02.1987. In 1996, he was designated as Graded ENT Specialist and was then upgraded as classified Specialist ENT in the year 2001. In the month of February, 2002, the respondent was posted with Military Hospital, Secunderabad wherein he was required to examine new recruits being forwarded by various training centres.
3. In September, 2002 one Recruit/Soldier/GD K. Siddaiah alleged that the respondent paid money for reviewing its remarks “unfit ” to “review after 15 days”. The statement of the recruit was recorded by one Major Mrs. R.M.B. Mythilly who initiated AFMSF-7. The respondent was charge-sheeted, and three charges were framed against him, namely:
(i) The respondent, an ENT Specialist at a Military Hospital, had, for extraneous consideration declared an Army recruit, K. Siddaiah, as ‘fit’ after previously declaring him ‘unfit’. Consequently, the first charge against him was under Section 57(c) of the Army 1 ‘AFT’ 2 ‘GCM’ 3 ‘AMC’ [2024] 9 S.C.R. 189Union of India & Ors. v. Lt. Col. Rahul Arora Act for knowingly and with intent to defraud altering a document/ remarks in the AFMSF-7.
(ii) The second charge was under Section 39(a) of the Army Act for absenting himself without leave from 11.04.2004 to 19.04.2004.
(iii) The third charge was under Section 45 of the Army Act for conduct unbecoming of an officer and the character expected of his position.
4. Upon conclusion of trial by GCM and upon finding two out of three charges proven, the respondent was dismissed from service against which he preferred proceedings before AFT, which upheld the findings of guilt and the sentence of dismissal from service as awarded by the GCM. It is this order of the AFT which was assailed by the respondent before the High Court. The High Court allowed the writ petition preferred by the respondent solely on the ground that an officer junior to the respondent has acted as Judge Advocate in the GCM contrary to the law laid down by this Court in Union of India & Anr. vs. Charanjit Singh Gill.4
5. Assailing the impugned order of the High Court, Shri R. Bala, learned Senior Advocate for the appellant/Union of India has argued that there is no blanket prohibition on appointing an officer of lower rank than the charged officer to serve as Judge Advocate in a Court Martial. He would strenuously urge that in Charanjit Singh Gill (supra), this court has carved out an exception to the effect that “a Judge Advocate appointed with the Court Martial should not be an officer of a rank lower than that of the officer facing the trial unless the officer of such rank is not (having due regard to the exigencies of public service) available and the opinion regarding non-availability is specifically recorded in the convening order”. According to learned senior counsel, the present case falls within the above exception inasmuch as non-availability of an officer of equivalent or higher rank was specifically recorded in the convening order. It is also argued, referring to Army Rule 103 that a Court Martial shall not be invalid merely by reason of any invalidity in the appointment of the Judge Advocate officiating thereat. Reference is made to Union of India vs. S.P.S. Rajkumar and Ors.5 4 [2000] 3 SCR 245 : 2000 (5) SCC 742 5 [2007] 5 SCR 521 : 2007 (6) SCC 407 190 [2024] 9 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.