K. Nirmala & Ors. v. Canara Bank & Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 634; [2024] 8 S.C.R. 868
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Hima Kohli, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 28 Aug 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9916/2024
- Sections
- 482
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 868 : 2024 INSC 634 K. Nirmala & Ors.
v.
Canara Bank & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 9916-9920 of 2024)
28 August 2024 [Hima Kohli and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether a person who joined the services of a Nationalized Bank/Government of India undertaking based on a certificate that identified him/her as belonging to a Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe in the State of Karnataka, pursuant to the State Government’s notifications, would be entitled to retain the position after the caste/ tribe was de-scheduled.
Headnotes† Service Law – Appellants were employed by respondent No.1-bank in the Scheduled Castes Category based on Caste Certificates obtained following due process of law, certifying that they belonged to the ‘Kotegara’ community, a synonymous caste which was made equivalent to the caste called ‘Kotegar Matri’ (included in the Scheduled Castes list) by a Circular issued by the State of Karnataka – However, in view of the decision of the Constitution Bench in Milind case holding that any inclusion/exclusion in or from the list of Scheduled Castes can only be made through an Act of Parliament u/Articles 341 and 342 of the Constitution of India, the State of Karnataka de-scheduled the castes of the appellants – Show cause notices issued to the appellants to show cause as to why their services be not terminated – Writ petitions filed by appellants, rejected by High Court – Interference with:
Held: Impugned judgments quashed and set aside – Proposed action of the respondent banks in issuing show cause notices to the appellants, is unsustainable and quashed – Circulars dated 11.03.2002 and 29.03.2003 were issued by State Government * Author [2024] 8 S.C.R. 869K. Nirmala & Ors. v. Canara Bank & Anr. protecting the employment of those who benefited by these Caste Certificates obtained prior to issuance of the aforesaid circulars – Thus, appellants are entitled to protection of their services by virtue of the circular dated 29.03.2003, as ratified by communication dated 17.08.2005 issued by the Ministry of Finance, which specifically extended protection to various castes including those which were excluded in the earlier Government circular dated 11.03.2002 and covered the castes such as Kotegara, Kotekshathriya, Koteyava, Koteyar, Ramakshathriya, Sherugara and Sarvegara, ensuring that individuals of these castes holding Scheduled Castes Certificates issued prior to de-scheduling would be entitled to claim protection of their services albeit as unreserved candidates for all future purposes – The aforesaid communication dated 17.08.2005 reinforced the protective umbrella to the concerned bank employees and also saved them from departmental and criminal action. [Paras 35, 37] Case Law Cited State of Maharashtra v. Milind and Others [2000] Supp. 5 SCR 65 : (2001) 1 SCC 4 – followed.
Chairman and Managing Director Food Corporation of India and Others v. Jagadish Balaram Bahira and Others [2017] 11 SCR 271 : (2017) 8 SCC 670 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Articles 341 and 342 of the Constitution of India; Government circular; De-scheduling of castes; Castes de-scheduled; State of Karnataka; Scheduled Caste (SC)/Scheduled Tribe (ST); Scheduled Castes Certificates; Castes redesignated under the list of SC/ST; Scheduled Castes Category; Caste Certificates; ‘Kotegara’ community, ‘Kotegar Matri’; Synonymous caste; Scheduled Castes list; Show cause notices; Nationalized Bank/ Government of India undertaking; False or fake Caste Certificates; Government Circulars.
870 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal Nos. 9916-9920 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 24.04.2019 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in WA Nos. 189, 190, 191, 192 and 193 of 2019 With Civil Appeal Nos. 9922, 9923-9924 and 9921 of 2024 Appearances for Parties K.V. Dhananjay, A Velan, Ms. Navpreet Kaur, Dheeraj SA, Vikash Chandra Shukla, Seetharaman Venkat, Aishvary Vikram, Tarun Gulia, Ajay Awasthi, Siddhartha Relan, Mukul Rathor, Anil Katarki, Ms. Veena Katarki, Anurag Katarki, Deva Vrat Anand, T. R. B. Sivakumar, Advs. for the Appellants.
Nishant Patil, A.A.G., Dhruv Mehta, Sr. Adv., Rajesh Kumar Gautam, Anant Gautam, Ms. Nishi Sangtani, Samir Mudgil, R.P. Daida, Ms. Kavitoli G Yeptho, Ms. Likivi Jakhalu, Kushagra Nilesh Sahay, Arvind Ray, Tridibe Bose, Karanveer Singh Anand, M/s. Khaitan & Co., Rahul Ranjan Verma, Ms. Ashmita Bisarya, Nirmal Kumar Ambastha, D. L. Chidananda, Vignesh Adithiya S, Ayush P Shah, V. N. Raghupathy, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. This batch of appeals, which involves identical questions of fact and law, arises from the judgments delivered by the Division Bench of the High Court of Karnataka, as listed in the table below. Given the similarities, the appeals have been heard together and are being decided collectively.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 871K. Nirmala & Ors. v. Canara Bank & Anr. SLP No(s). Writ Appeal No(s).
Date of Impugned Judgement Concerned Respondents/ Employer Community (Scheduled Caste/ Scheduled Tribe)
Special Leave Petition(C)
No. 13484- 13488 of Writ Appeal No. 189-193 of 2019 24th April, The Canara Bank of India Kotegara (SC)
Special Leave Petition(C)
No. 19877 of 2019 Writ Appeal No. 2253 of 2018 (S-R)
3rd July, The Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd.
Kuruba (ST)
Special Leave Petition(C)
No. 23500- 23501 of Writ Appeal No. 3666 of
2016(S-DIS)
c/w Writ Appeal No.
3483 of 3rd July, The Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd.
Kuruba (ST)
Special Leave Petition(C)
No. 13453 of 2019 Writ Appeal No. 316 of 24th April, The Canara Bank of India Kotegara (SC)
Civil Appeals arising out of SLP (C) No(s). 13484-13488 of 2019 shall be treated as the lead matter. The outcome of these appeals shall govern all the connected matters.
4. The common thread that runs through these matters is as to whether a person who joined the services of a Nationalized Bank/Government of India undertaking based on a certificate that identified him/her as belonging to a Scheduled Caste(‘SC’)/Scheduled Tribe(‘ST’) in the State of Karnataka, pursuant to the State Government’s notifications, 872 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports would be entitled to retain the position after the caste/tribe has been de-scheduled. The situation has arisen on account of the State of Karnataka re-designating some castes under the list of SC/ST, inspite of the fact that this jurisdiction is exclusively conferred upon the Parliament by virtue of the scheme under Articles 341 and 342 of the Constitution of India.
5. In brief, the individual details of the appellants in the lead matter are detailed below: - S.
No.
Name of the Appellant herein Date of Issuance of Caste Certificate Date of Joining Service
1. K. Nirmala/Appellant No. 1 6th February, 26th December,
2. K.V. Shankar/ Appellant No. 2 17th March, 20th July, 1981
3. D.K. Prabhakar/ Appellant No. 3 17th March, 24th March, 1981
4. S. Suresh/Appellant No. 4 2nd March, 23rd March, 1981
5. Muktha S. Rao/ Appellant No. 5 30th November, 30th November,
6. As evident from the table above, appellant Nos. 1 to 5 in Civil Appeals @ SLP(C) Nos. 13484-13488 of 2019 were employed by the Canara Bank(hereinafter referred to as ‘respondent No.1-bank’) in the Scheduled Castes Category based on Caste Certificates, certifying that they belonged to the ‘Kotegara’ community, a synonymous caste which was made equivalent to the caste called ‘Kotegar Matri’ (included in the Scheduled Castes list) by a Government circular dated 21 st November, 1977 issued by the State of Karnataka. It is undisputed that the appellants duly obtained these Caste Certificates in accordance with the prevailing Government circular.
7. A Constitution Bench of this Court in State of Maharashtra v. Milind and Others,1 held that the State Government has no authority to 1 [2000] Supp. 5 SCR 65 : (2001) 1 SCC 4 [2024] 8 S.C.R. 873K. Nirmala & Ors. v. Canara Bank & Anr. amend or modify the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes list published under Articles 341 and 342 of the Constitution of India. A caste can only be classified as a Scheduled Caste or a Scheduled Tribe or a Socially and Educationally Backward Caste when the Presidential Order is issued to that effect in exercise of the powers prescribed under Articles 341, 342, and 342A of the Constitution of India respectively. In Milind (supra), this Court held as below: - “15. Thus, it is clear that States have no power to amend Presidential Orders. Consequently, a party in power or the Government of the day in a State is relieved from the pressure or burden of tinkering with the Presidential Orders either to gain popularity or secure votes. Number of persons in order to gain advantage in securing admissions in educational institutions and employment in State services have been claiming as belonging to either Scheduled Castes or Scheduled Tribes depriving genuine and needy persons belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes covered by the Presidential Orders, defeating and frustrating to a large extent the very object of protective discrimination given to such people based on their educational and social backwardness. Courts cannot and should not expand jurisdiction to deal with the question as to whether a particular caste, sub-caste; a group or part of tribe or sub-tribe is included in any one of the entries mentioned in the Presidential Orders issued under Articles 341 and 342 particularly so when in clause (2) of the said article, it is expressly stated that the said Orders cannot be amended or varied except by law made by Parliament. The power to include or exclude, amend or alter Presidential Order is expressly and exclusively conferred on and vested with Parliament and that too by making a law in that regard. The President had the benefit of consulting the States through Governors of States which had the means and machinery to find out and recommend as to whether a particular caste or tribe was to be included in the Presidential Order. If the said Orders are to be amended, it is Parliament that is in a better position to know having the means and 874 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports machinery unlike courts as to why a particular caste or tribe is to be included or excluded by law to be made by Parliament. Allowing the State Governments or courts or other authorities or Tribunals to hold inquiry as to whether a particular caste or tribe should be considered as one included in the schedule of the Presidential Order, when it is not so specifically included, may lead to problems. In order to gain advantage of reservations for the purpose of Article 15(4) or 16(4) several persons have been coming forward claiming to be covered by Presidential Orders issued under Articles 341 and 342. This apart, when no other authority other than Parliament, that too by law alone can amend the Presidential Orders, neither the State Governments nor the courts nor Tribunals nor any authority can assume jurisdiction to hold inquiry and take evidence to declare that a caste or a tribe or part of or a group within a caste or tribe is included in Presidential Orders in one entry or the other although they are not expressly and specifically included. A court cannot alter or amend the said Presidential Orders for the very good reason that it has no power to do so within the meaning, content and scope of Articles 341 and 342. It is not possible to hold that either any inquiry is permissible or any evidence can be let in, in relation to a particular caste or tribe to say whether it is included within Presidential Orders when it is not so expressly included.
(emphasis supplied)
8. Pursuant to the judgment in the case of Milind (supra), the Ministry of Finance, Department of Economic Affairs(Banking Division), Government of India in consultation with the Ministry of Welfare vide letter dated 12 th March 1987, declared the State of Karnataka circulars which included the ‘Kotegara’ caste in the list of Scheduled Castes in the State of Karnataka to be non-est. The letter addressed to the Chairman & Managing Director of the concerned authorities is reproduced herein below:- “......Persons belonging to Kotegara, Kote-Kshatriya are not entitled to get benefits as scheduled castes in Karnataka. These communities have never been(sic) treated as [2024] 8 S.C.R. 875K. Nirmala & Ors. v. Canara Bank & Anr. scheduled castes in Karnataka. The State Government have no power to make any amendment in the existing lists of lists, of SCs/STs can be done only through an Act of Parliament in view of Articles 341(2) and 342(2) of the constitution. In view of this, the orders issued by the Govt. of Karnataka to this effect does not have any validity. In view of the position explained above, persons belonging to Kotegara and Kote-Kshatriya who have been appointed against the vacancy reserved for scheduled castes cannot be treated as scheduled castes even at the time of their initial appointment because these community have never been treated as synonymous of Kotegar-Matri(sic) by the Government of India which is in the list of SSC in Karnataka. It is infact, entirely the responsible of employer Department to have the matter verified through the State Government, before accepting the claim of the candidates who have been appointed against the reserved posts.”
9. The Government of Karnataka issued a circular dated 11 th March, 2002 providing protection to individuals employed in State services who had obtained Caste Certificates based on a synonymous caste under the Government circulars, issued by the State. These individuals were to be treated as having been appointed under the General Merit(GM) category, effective from 11 th March, 2002. The said circular also provided that such candidates would not be eligible for future promotions or any other benefits as SCs/STs, although they could claim benefits under the respective Backward Classes to which they belonged. Although the ‘Kotegara’ community was not included in this circular, a subsequent circular dated 29th March, 2003 was issued by the Government of Karnataka, extending the benefits of the circular dated 11 th March, 2002 to individuals belonging to the Kotegara, Kotekshathriya, Koteyava, Koteyar, Ramakshathriya, Sherugara, and Sarvegara communities, who had obtained Caste Certificates in accordance with the earlier Government circulars.
10. It is also undisputed that the Caste Certificates held by the appellants were cancelled by the Competent Authority, namely the District Caste Verification Committee, and this decision was communicated to their respective employers. Subsequently, criminal proceedings were initiated against some of the appellants at the concerned police 876 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports station; however, these proceedings were quashed by the High Court while exercising jurisdiction under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973(hereinafter referred to as ‘CrPC’).
11. Respondent No. 2 i.e., Additional Director General of Police, Directorate of Civil Rights Enforcement Cell, intimated respondent No.1-bank to terminate the services of the appellants on the ground that they had secured employment based on fake Caste Certificates. In turn, respondent No.1-bank issued notices to the appellants calling upon them to show cause as to why their services should not be terminated. The appellants challenged the aforesaid notices by filing writ petitions before the High Court of Karnataka which came to be rejected.
12. Being aggrieved by the dismissal of their writ petitions, the appellants preferred intra-Court writ appeals before the learned Division Bench of the High Court against the order of the learned Single Judge. The Division Bench of the High Court dismissed the intra-Court appeals.
13. This batch of appeals by special leave has been preferred to assail the decisions of the learned Division Bench of the High Court of Karnataka, rejecting the writ appeals as indicated in the table above. Submissions on behalf of the appellants: -
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.