In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Limited Through Its Managing Director, Acharya Balkrishna and Baba Ramdev in the Matter of:indian Medical Association and Anr v. Union of India and Others
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 605; [2024] 8 S.C.R. 401
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Hima Kohli, Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah
- Decided
- 13 Aug 2024
- Case number
- SUO MOTO CONTEMPT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 4/2024
- Sections
- 2, 3, 12(1), 12
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 401 : 2024 INSC 605 In Re : Patanjali Ayurved Limited Through Its Managing Director, Acharya Balkrishna and Baba Ramdev In The Matter Of: Indian Medical Association and Another v.
Union of India and Others Suo Motu Contempt Petition (Civil) No. 4 of 2024 In Writ Petition (Civil) No. 645 of 2022 13 August 2024 [Hima Kohli* and Ahsanuddin Amanullah, JJ.] Issue for Consideration In violation of the undertaking dtd. 21.11.2023 given to this Court, the proposed contemnors held a press conference on 22.11.2023 making casual public statements regarding the efficacy of particular medicines manufactured by them and making derogatory statements in respect of other systems of treatment; and also continued to issue misleading advertisements. Conduct of the proposed contemnors, if was in wilful breach of the undertaking given to the Court and contumacious.
Headnotes† Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 – In the writ petition filed by Indian Medical Association, the proposed contemnors gave an undertaking dtd. 21.11.2023 to this Court that Patanjali shall not violate any laws relating to advertising or branding of products manufactured and marketed by it and that no casual statements claiming medicinal efficacy or against any system of medicine will be released to the media – However, in violation thereof they held a press conference on 22.11.2023 and further continued issuing misleading advertisements and make incorrect assertions and misrepresentations describing their various products as a permanent solution to particular ailments specifically listed in the Schedules appended to the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisement) Act, 1954 and the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisement) Rules, 1955 – Suo motu contempt proceedings initiated – If the proposed contemnors committed wilful breach of the undertakings given to the Court:
* Author 402 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Held: Despite the clear, categorical and unambiguous assurance given by Patanjali to the Court and knowing that the said assurance was given by its counsel on instructions and further, that Patanjali was bound down to such an assurance, there was no justification for the proposed contemnors to have called for a Press Conference on the very next day, i.e., on 22.11.2023 – The proposed contemnors were aware of the undertaking given on their behalf, still a positive assertion was made by them in the Press Conference that they have medicines that could cure blood pressure, thyroid, type-I diabetes and asthma which was in violation of the provisions of the DMR Act and Rules – Describing the products manufactured by Patanjali as a “permanent solution” in respect of ailments listed in the Schedule appended to the DMR Act and Rules which prohibit advertisement of drugs for treatment of particular diseases and disorders including those that were referred to by the proposed contemnors in the Press Conference, again amounted to violating the undertaking given to the Court – Furthermore, within a week of the order passed by this Court, the proposed contemnors published advertisements in the daily newspapers on 04.12.2023, yet again claiming that they manufactured medicines that could cure diseases like high blood pressure, sugar, asthma, thyroid, arthritis listed in the Schedules appended to the DMR Act and DMR Rules and are specifically prohibited for advertisement, so as to prevent the public from being misled – The advertisement in question was clearly a violation of the undertaking given by the proposed contemnors – On facts, though the initial conduct of the proposed contemnors prior to their tendering an apology to the Court showed that the same was in violation of the undertakings given, subsequent thereto, after they tendered an unqualified apology to this Court, efforts were made by them to take steps to make amends by expressing regret for their conduct on affidavit and in person and also by taking steps to publicize the apology tendered by them through advertisements published prominently in the National and Regional newspapers – After this Court rejected the first attempt made by them to offer a qualified apology, their subsequent conduct demonstrates that they have made sincere efforts to purge themselves – Apology tendered is accepted and the matter is closed – Proposed contemnors cautioned to strictly abide by the terms of their undertakings – Contempt notices issued to the proposed contemnors discharged, contempt proceedings closed. [Paras 52-54, 60-62] Contempt of Court – Apology – Qualified/conditional apology vis-à-vis unconditional apology:
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 403In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others Held: Any apology tendered by a party in contempt proceedings must be unconditional and unqualified – Such an apology must also demonstrate that it has been made with a bona fide intention and not just to wriggle out of a tight situation – There cannot be a justification and an apology – The two things are incompatible and do not go hand-in-hand – In the present case, though the proposed contemnor purportedly tendered an unqualified apology on behalf of Patanjali for the breach of statement recorded in the order dated 21.11.2023, the said affidavit was rejected as the deponent had tried to justify his conduct by seeking to offer an explanation for the advertisements issued, which is impermissible – Thus, the conditional apology tendered by the proposed contemnor was rejected. [Paras 43, 55] Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 – Constitution of India – Article 129 – Power of contempt – Exercise of – Discussed.
Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 – s.2(b) – Wilful disobedience – Civil contempt – When committed – Circumstances enumerated. Words and Phrases – “Undertaking” – Definition discussed – Undertaking given by an Advocate on behalf of a client: Held: If duly and properly given has the same effect as one given by the client – Whether a statement made by a party or its counsel could amount to an undertaking, would depend on the words used in the statement made and the facts and circumstances of a case – If a party or the advocate acts in such a manner so as to convey to the Court a firm conviction that an undertaking is being given regardless of the fact that the word “undertaking” has not been specifically mentioned, that party will be bound down and it will be no answer that he did not think that he was giving it or that he was misunderstood – Furthermore, an undertaking given to the Court has the same force as an order of the Court and breach thereof would amount to contempt in the same manner as a breach of an injunction. [Para 50] Case Law Cited Murray and Company v. Ashok Kr. Newatia and Another [2000] 1 SCR 367 : (2000) 2 SCC 367; Pushpaben and Another v. Narandas Badiani and Another [1979] 3 SCR 636 : (1979) 2 SCC 394; Reliance Petrochemicals Limited v. Proprietors of Indian Express Newspapers, Bombay Pvt. Ltd. and Others [1988] Supp. 3 SCR 212 : (1988) 4 SCC 592; Anil Ratan Sarkar and Others v. 404 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Hirak Ghosh and Others [2002] 2 SCR 346 : (2002) 4 SCC 21; Ram Kishan v. Tarun Bajaj and Others [2014] 1 SCR 538 : (2014) 16 SCC 204; Hon’ble Shri Justice C.S. Karnan, in Re (2017) 7 SCC 1; Chairman, West Bengal Administrative Tribunal and Another v. SK. Monobbor Hossain and Another (2012) 11 SCC 761; Patel Rajnikant Dhulabhai and Another v. Patel Chandrakant Dhulabhai and Others [2008] 10 SCR 1169 : (2008) 14 SCC 561; Rama Narang v. Ramesh Narang and Another [2006] 3 SCR 1068 : (2006) 11 SCC 114; Balwantbhai Somabhai Bhandari v. Hiralal Somabhai [2023] 11 SCR 1064 : (2023) SCC OnLine SC 1139; Niaz Mohammad and Others v. State of Haryana and Others [1994] Supp. 3 SCR 720 : (1994) 6 SCC 332; Ashok Paper Kamgar Union v. Dharam Godha and Others (2003) 11 SCC 1; Babu Ram Gupta v. Sudhir Bhasin and Another [1979] 3 SCR 685 : (1980) 3 SCC 47; M.Y. Shareef and Another v. Hon’ble Judges of the High Court of Nagpur and Others [1955] 1 SCR 757 : (1954) 2 SCC 444; Priya Gupta and Another v. Additional Secretary, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and Others [2012] 12 SCR 818 : (2013) 11 SCC 404; Bal Kishan Giri v. State of Uttar Pradesh [2014] 6 SCR 545 : (2014) 7 SCC 280; T.M.A. Pai Foundation and Others v. State of Karnataka and Others [1995] Suppl. 1 SCR 283 : (1995) 4 SCC 1 – referred to.
Suman Chadha and Another v. Central Bank of India (2018) SCC OnLine Del 11536 – referred to.
Parashuram Detaram Shamdasani v. King-Emperor (1945) A.C. 264; M v. Home Office (1992) Q.B. 270 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals cited Black’s Law Dictionary, Fifth Edition; Osborn’s Concise Law Dictionary, 10th Edition.
List of Acts Contempt of Courts Act, 1971; Constitution of India; Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisement) Act, 1954; Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisement) Rules, 1955. List of Keywords Contempt; Contempt of Court; Proposed contemnors; Misleading advertisements; Misleading advertisements by Patanjali; Undertaking; Breach of an undertaking; Contumacious conduct/acts; Wilful disobedience; Civil contempt; Disobedience of judgement/ [2024] 8 S.C.R. 405In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others decree, direction/order/writ/other process of a Court; Wilful breach of an undertaking given to the Court; Violation of an undertaking given to the Court; Undertaking given by Advocate on behalf of a client; Apology; Qualified apology; Conditional apology; Unconditional apology; Unqualified apology.
Case Arising From INHERENT JURISDICTION: Suo Motu Contempt Petition (Civil) No.4 of 2024 In Writ Petition (Civil) No.645 of 2022 Appearances for Parties By Courts Motion.
Mukul Rohatgi, Vipin Sanghi, Balbir Singh, Sr. Advs., Simranjeet Singh, Gautam Talukdar, Raushal Kumar, Ms. Apurbaa Dutta, Ms. Neha Gupta, Ms. Smita Jain, Rishabh Pant, Rohit Gandhi, Naman Tandon, Yajat Gulia, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Hima Kohli, J.
1. This order shall dispose of the suo motu contempt proceedings initiated by this Court against the proposed contemnors, Patanjali Ayurved Limited,1 Acharya Balkrishna, Managing Director of Patanjali and Baba Ramdev. The circumstances leading to initiation of contempt proceedings against the aforesaid parties needs some elucidation.
A. BACKDROP
2. Indian Medication Association,2 the petitioner in the writ petition3 has invoked Article 32 of the Constitution of India for raising a grievance against Patanjali, its Managing Director – Acharya Balkrishna and its primary proponent, Baba Ramdev stating that they have been 1 For short ‘Patanjali’ 2 In short “IMA”
3 Writ Petition (Civil) No. 645 of 2022 406 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports indulging in a campaign of misinformation and disparagement against the modern system of medicine in an orchestrated and systematic manner resulting in misleading the common man. IMA has claimed that despite lodging multiple complaints and submitting several representations to the Union of India and the State Authorities, they have declined to take any concrete action, thus compelling them to approach this Court for relief.
B. PROCEEDINGS DATED 21 ST NOVEMBER, 2023
3. Notice was issued on the writ petition on 23rd August, 2022. On 21st November, 2023, this Court passed the following order : “2. After some arguments were canvassed by counsel afore-noted, on the serious points emanating herein, at the request of the Court, Mr. K.M. Nataraj, learned ASG has very fairly submitted that he may be permitted to obtain instructions, after full and effective consultation with the authorities concerned insofar as checking of incorrect assertions/misrepresentation for various products with regard to their purported medicinal efficacy is concerned, as also the measures which may be put in place for statements released through the media, both electronic and print, presently confined to the Respondent No.5.
3. Mr. Poovayya, learned senior counsel for the Respondent No.5, on instructions, assures this Court that henceforth there shall not be any violation of any law(s), especially relating to advertising or branding of products manufactured and marketed by it and, further, that no casual statements claiming medicinal efficacy or against any system of medicine will be released to the media in any form. The Respondent No.5 is bound down to such assurance.
4. It is made clear that the suit(s) pending on issues pertaining inter-se, that is, between the petitioners/other persons and the Respondent No.5 have not been stayed, and shall not be hindered only by reason of the pendency of the present writ petition.”
(emphasis added)
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 407In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others
C. PROCEEDINGS DATED 27 TH FEBRUARY, 2024
4. On 27th February, 2024, learned counsel appearing for IMA drew the attention of this Court to some advertisements published by Patanjali in a newspaper and the transcription of a Press Conference conducted by Baba Ramdev and Acharya Balkrishna on 22nd November, 2023, i.e., on the very next day to passing of the order by this Court on 21 st November, 2023 and submitted that despite an assurance given on behalf of Patanjali and recorded in the order passed on 21st November, 2023, the aforesaid parties were continuing to make incorrect assertions and misrepresentations in respect of various products marketed by them by describing the said products as a permanent solution to particular ailments that have been specifically listed in the Schedules appended to the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisement) Act, 1954 4 and the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisement) Rules, 1955. 5
5. In view of the above, this Court expressed a prima facie view that Patanjali had violated the undertaking given to the Court on 21st November, 2023 and issued a notice to show cause to Patanjali and its Managing Director as to why contempt of court proceedings be not issued against them. The relevant extract of the order passed on 27th February, 2024, is as follows:
“3. Today, Mr. P.S. Patwalia, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioners states that his briefing counsel proposes to file some newspaper advertisements in the daily newspaper “The Hindu” published on 04 th December, 2023 (i.e. after the date of passing the order on 21 st November, 2023) and a You Tube link and transcription of a Press Conference headed by Baba Ramdev and Acharya Balkrishna (Managing Director of the respondent no.5) conducted on 22 nd November, 2023 (i.e. on the very next day of the passing of the order on 21st November, 2023).
4. It is submitted on behalf of the petitioners that the aforesaid documents amply demonstrate that the respondent no.5 is continuing to make incorrect assertions 4 For short ‘DMR Act, 1954’ 5 For short ‘DMR Rules, 1955’ 408 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports and misrepresentations in respect of its various products in the market by describing the said products as a permanent solution to such of the ailments that have been specifically listed in the Schedule appended to the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisements) Act, 1954 and the Schedule appended to the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisements) Rules, 1955.
5. We may note that Section 3(d) of the 1954 Act prohibits advertisement of certain products for treatment of certain diseases and disorders, including thereof diabetes (Sr. No.9), Heart Diseases (Sr. No.26), High or Low Blood Pressure (Sr. No. 27) and Obesity (Sr. No. 38) and Asthma (Appended to the 1955 Rules at Sr. No.1).
6. The aforesaid advertisement as referred to by learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners and those that form part of the documents enclosed with an anonymous letter dated 15th January, 2024, addressed to Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India with copies marked to two other Hon’ble Judges of this Court including one of us (Ahsanuddin Amanullah, J.) show that the said advertisements were issued and Press Conferences held after the order was passed on 21 st November, 2023. The aforesaid documents handed over by learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners and the anonymous letter dated 15th January, 2024, are taken on record. Copies thereof have been furnished to learned counsel for the respondents.
7. Prima facie, this Court is of the opinion that the respondent no.5-Patanjali Ayurved Limited has violated the undertaking given by it and recorded in the order dated 21 st November, 2023.
8. Issue notice as to why Contempt of Court proceedings should not be initiated against the respondent no.5 and its Managing Director-Acharya Balkrishna. Memo of parties shall be drawn by the Registry.
9. Mr. Simranjeet Singh, learned Counsel appearing on behalf of Mr. Gautam Talukdar, Advocate on Record, [2024] 8 S.C.R. 409In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others accepts notice on behalf of the respondent no.5- Patanjali Ayurved Limited and its Managing Director and seeks time to file a reply.
10. Reply be filed within two weeks with a copy to learned counsel for the petitioners and other respondents.
xxx xxx xxx
14. Till further orders, the respondent no.5-Patanjali Ayurved Limited is restrained from advertising or branding of products manufactured and marketed by it which are meant to cure the diseases/disorders/ conditions specified in the 1954 Act and 1955 Rules.
Respondent no.5 and its officers are also cautioned to refrain from making any statements against any system of medicine in the media (both electronic and print)
in any form, as undertaken on 21 st November, 2023.”
(emphasis added)
D. PROVISIONS OF DMR ACT AND DMR RULES
6. For purposes of ready reference, the provisions of Sections 3 and 4 of the DMR Act, 1954 are extracted below :
“3. Prohibition of advertisement of certain drugs for treatment of certain diseases and disorders.—Subject to the provisions of this Act, no person shall take any part in the publication of any advertisement referring to any drug in terms which suggest or are calculated to lead to the use of that drug for—
(a) the procurement of miscarriage in women or prevention of conception in women; or
(b) the maintenance or improvement of the capacity of human beings for sexual pleasure; or
(c) the correction of menstrual disorder in women; or
(d) the diagnosis, cure, mitigation, treatment or prevention of any disease, disorder or condition specified in the Schedule, or any other disease, disorder or condition (by whatsoever name called) which may be specified in the rules made under this Act:
410 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Provided that no such rule shall be made except—
(i) in respect of any disease, disorder or condition which requires timely treatment in consultation with a registered medical practitioner or for which there are normally no accepted remedies; and
(ii) after consultation with the Drugs Technical Advisory Board constituted under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 (23 of 1940), and if the Central Government considers necessary, with such other persons having special knowledge or practical experience in respect of Ayurvedic or Unani systems of medicines as that Government deems fit.]
4. Prohibition of misleading advertisements relating to drugs.—Subject to the provisions of this Act, no person shall take any part in the publication of any advertisement relating to a drug if the advertisement contains any matters which—
(a) directly or indirectly gives a false impression regarding the true character of the drug; or
(b) makes a false claim for the drug; or (c) is otherwise false or misleading in any material particular.
THE SCHEDULE
[See Sections 3(d) and 14] S. No. Name of the disease, disorder or condition *****
9. Diabetes.
******
26. Heart diseases.
27. High or low blood pressure.
*******
38. Obesity.”
7. Rule 6 of the DMR Rules, 1955 states as follows:
“[6] Prohibition of Advertisement of Drugs for Treatment of Disease, etc.– No person shall also take part in the [2024] 8 S.C.R. 411In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others publication of any advertisement referring to any drug in terms which suggest or are calculated to lead to the use of that drug for the diagnosis, cure, mitigation, treatment or prevention of any disease, disorder, or condition specified in the Schedule annexed to these rules.
SCHEDULE
(See Rule 6)
1. Asthma ***]”
E. ADVERTISEMENT PUBLISHED IN THE NEWSPAPER ON
4TH DECEMBER, 2023
8. It is noteworthy that Patanjali had published an advertisement in the daily newspaper on 4 th December, 2023 (copy whereof was subsequently filed by the petitioner/IMA under index dated 6th February, 2024), that spoke of “completely curing” lakhs of people of diseases like high blood pressure, sugar, thyroid, arthritis, asthma, etc. Similarly, the advertisement claimed to have “completely cure patient suffering from failure of liver, kidney, heart and brain”. The advertisement as published by Patanjali on 4th December, 2023 with a photograph of Baba Ramdev prominently displayed in it, is extracted below : 412 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
9. In the advertisement, Patanjali also displayed packages of medicines sold by it under the names of “BP GRIT”, “Madhu GRIT” and “Liva Amrit Advance” and declared that they offer permanent solution for curing ailments such as sugar, BP and liver problems. F. T R A N S C R I P T I O N O F T H E P R E S S C O N F E R E N C E CONDUCTED ON 22nd NOVEMBER, 2023
10. We may also refer to the transcription of the statements made by Baba Ramdev in a Press Conference conducted by Patanjali on 22 nd November, 2023, i.e., on the very next day to this Court passing the order on 21 st November, 2023, recording the undertaking given by learned counsel for Patanjali that there shall be no violation of any law relating to advertising or branding of products manufactured and marketed by Patanjali and that no casual statements claiming medicinal efficacy or against any system of medicine will be released to the media in any form. In the said transcription, Baba Ramdev alluded to the aforesaid order passed by this Court and asserted that a group of doctors were making false propaganda claiming that “there is cure for diseases like BP, sugar, thyroid, asthma, arthritis, liver and kidney failure”, that they have “discontinued insulin for more than a crore people”; that “children with type-1 diabetes have been cured” and that “we cure blood pressure, thyroid, type – 1 diabetes, asthma and turn CRP positive to negative”. Referring to the order passed by this Court on 21 st November, 2023, Acharya Balkrishna made a statement in the very same Press Conference, that “Corona could not be cured by allopathy…….” and that “Coronil has not only protected the family but also followed all protocols and rules”.
G. PROCEEDINGS DATED 19 TH MARCH, 2024
11. In the light of the endorsement made by Baba Ramdev of the advertisement issued by Patanjali that had given an Undertaking to this Court on 21 st November, 2023, the scope of the contempt proceedings initiated by this Court on 27 th February, 2024, was expanded. On 19 th March, 2024, notice to show cause was issued to Baba Ramdev calling upon to him to state as to why contempt proceedings should not be initiated against him as well for violation of the provisions of Sections 3 and 4 of the DMR Act, 1954 and Rule 6 of the DMR Rules, 1955. Learned counsel appearing for Patanjali and Acharya Balkrishna accepted notice on behalf of the proposed [2024] 8 S.C.R. 413In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others contemnor, i.e., Baba Ramdev and sought time to file replies. The relevant extract of the order passed on 19th March, 2024 is as follows : “1. On the last date of hearing, notice to show cause was issued to the respondent No.5 and its Managing Director- Acharya Balkrishna (respondent No.6) as to why contempt of court proceedings be not initiated against them for violating the order dated 21st November, 2023. At the request of learned counsel appearing for the aforesaid respondent, a period of two weeks’ was granted to file a reply. The reply is not on record.
xxx xxx xxx
4. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, it is deemed appropriate to direct the presence of respondent No.6-Acharya Balkrishna on the next date of hearing. Further, having gone through the advertisements issued by the respondent No.5 in the teeth of the undertaking given to this Court on 21 st November, 2023 and on noticing that the said advertisements reflect an endorsement thereof by Baba Ramdev, it is deemed appropriate to issue notice to show cause as to why the contempt proceedings be not initiated against him as this Court is prima facie of the opinion that he too has violated the provisions of Section 3 and 4 of the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisements) Act, 1954 read with Rule 6 of the Drugs and Magic Remedies (Objectionable Advertisements) Rules, 1955.
5. Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior counsel appearing with Mr. Gautam Talukdar, learned Advocate on Record accepts notice on behalf of the proposed Contemnor-Baba Ramdev. Complete set of paper book be furnished to the learned counsel within two days.
6. Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior counsel appearing for the respondent No.5 and its Managing Director-respondent No.6 states on instructions that reply to show cause is ready and the same shall be filed during the course of the day. Copies thereof may be furnished to the learned 414 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports counsel for the petitioner as also to the Union of India and the same be filed by tomorrow, i.e. 20th March, 2024. xxx xxx xxx
11. The respondent No.6-Acharya Balkrishna shall remain present on the next date of hearing along with the proposed contemnor-Baba Ramdev.”
(emphasis added)
H. AFFIDAVITS DATED 20TH MARCH, 2024 AND 6TH APRIL, 2024
12. On 20th March, 2024, Acharya Balkrishna filed an affidavit, purportedly in compliance of the order passed by this Court on 27th February, 2024. In the said affidavit, in one breath the deponent offered an unqualified apology on behalf of Patanjali for the breach of the statement recorded in para 3 of the order dated 21st November, 2023 and in the other breath, tried to explain that the advertisement in question was meant to contain only general statements but inadvertently, included the offending statement and that the intention was only to exhort the citizens of the country to lead the healthier life by consuming the product of Patanjali. The contents of the aforesaid affidavit filed by Acharya Balkrishna are extracted below :
“3. The Deponent regrets that the advertisement in question which was meant to contain only general statements inadvertently included the offending sentences. The same was bona fide and added in routine course by the media department of the Respondent No. 5 Company. The personnel of the media department of the Respondent No. 5 Company were not cognizant of the order dated 21.11.2023.”
13. On perusing the aforesaid affidavit, this Court expressed its disinclination to accept the conditional apology tendered. At that stage, conscious of the fact that the aforesaid affidavit could not be treated as an unqualified apology, time was sought to file fresh affidavits. Thereafter, fresh affidavits were filed by Acharya Balkrishna and Baba Ramdev on 6 th April, 2024 wherein, identical averments were made by them. The said affidavits stated that :
“2. I am filing this Affidavit in supersession of my Affidavit dated 20.03.2024.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 415In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others
3. Pursuant to the order dated 27.02.2024, I entered appearance through Ld. Counsel on 19.03.2024 before this Hon’ble Court and tendered an unqualified apology for the breach of the statement recorded in Para 3 of the order dated 21.11.2023. In the affidavit filed on 20.03.2024, I further undertake to ensure that such offending advertisements shall not be issued in the future. I affirm that no further offending advertisements were issued after 27.02.2024.
4. I hereby tender an unconditional and unqualified apology for the breach of the statement recorded in para 3 of the order of this Hon’ble Court dated 21.11.2023. I further undertake and ensure that the said statement shall be complied with in letter and spirit and no such similar advertisements shall be issued.
5. I seek pardon for the aforesaid breach of the statement. I undertake to always uphold the majesty of law and majesty of justice.
6. That I sincerely regret the issue of advertisements from Respondent No. 5 which is an infraction of the order dated 21.11.2023. I tender my unconditional and unqualified apology in this regard, on my own behalf and that of Respondent No. 5 I never had any intention to violate orders of this Hon’ble Court. I state that no such lapse will occur in future. I will always uphold the Majesty of law.
7. I hereby tender an unconditional and unqualified apology for the press conference dated 22.11.2023 and undertake not to make any public statements which may amount to breach of the undertaking given as recorded in para 3 of the order dated 21.11.2023, therefore, seek apology of this Hon’ble Court for the aforesaid press Conference.”
I. PROCEEDINGS DATED 10 TH APRIL, 2024
14. In an endeavour to avoid appearing before this Court in terms of the directions issued on 19 th March, 2024, both, Acharya Balkrishna and Baba Ramdev moved separate applications6 for permission to appear 6 IA No. 78328 of 2024 and IA No. 77726 of 2024 416 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports virtually on a plea that they had pre-scheduled meetings at Dubai, UAE on 2 nd April, 2024 and therefore, they needed exemption from attending the Court hearing physically on 2 nd April, 2024. Enclosed with the said applications sworn on 30 th March, 2024, were the details of their travel summary issued at 2.16 PM, on 31st March, 2024.
15. On noticing the evident discrepancies in the aforesaid affidavits and the documents enclosed therewith, it was pointed out that while the travel summary enclosing the air tickets of the proposed contemnors was dated 31 st March, 2024, the affidavits filed by them were sworn one day before the said date, i.e., on 30th March, 2024. This Court adversely commented on the aforesaid mismatch of dates and observed that it was an attempt on the part of the proposed contemnors to somehow evade their physical appearance before the Court. The relevant paras of the order passed on 10th April, 2024, are extracted below :
“1. Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior counsel appearing for the respondents No. 5, 6 and 7, proposed contemnors, submits that subsequent to filing affidavits dated 02 nd April, 2024, submitting qualified apologies to this Court for issuing misleading advertisements and releasing press statements contrary to the orders passed on 21 st November, 2023 and the undertakings given to this Court, the proposed contemnors have filed fresh affidavits on 06th April, 2024, tendering their unconditional apologies for the lapses on their part and they have sought pardon for the breach of statements made by them.
2. Having regard to the entire history of the matter and the past conduct of the respondents No. 5 to 7 – proposed contemnors, we have expressed our reservation about accepting the apologies offered in the latest affidavits filed by them. We have also pointed out to learned counsel appearing for the proposed contemnors that even after notices to show cause were issued to the respondents-proposed contemnors and they were directed to remain present before this Court, they attempted to wriggle out by moving applications seeking exemption from appearing on the pretext that they were travelling abroad. To demonstrate the said fact, in the affidavits filed by them alongwith [2024] 8 S.C.R. 417In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others the exemption applications on 30th March, 2024, they annexed tickets purportedly purchased by their travel agents for purposes of travelling abroad. Strangely enough, the said documents were issued the day after the aforesaid affidavits were sworn by them, i.e. on 31 st March, 2024.
3. When confronted with the said position on the last date of hearing, learned Senior counsel appearing for the respondents No. 5 and 7 – proposed contemnors had sought time to obtain clarifications. It has now been stated in the latest affidavits filed by the proposed-contemnors that admittedly, photocopies of the tickets were issued on a date after the affidavits were sworn and the said documents were annexed with the affidavits that were sworn on 30 th March, 2024 and filed on 31 st March, 2024. Fact remains that on the date when the affidavits were sworn, there were no such tickets issued. It is apparent that the respondents were trying to escape appearing personally before this Court in these proceedings, which is most unacceptable.”
(emphasis added)
J. PROCEEDINGS DATED 16 TH APRIL, 2024
16. On 16th April, 2024, both the proposed contemnors were present in Court and after interacting with them, the following order was passed: “1. Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior counsel appearing for the proposed Contemnors No.5 to 7 submits that to redeem themselves and demonstrate their bona fides, they propose to take some steps unilaterally. He requests one week’s time to revert back on the aforesaid aspect.
2. This Court has interacted with the proposed Contemnors No.6 and 7 for some time and have heard their submissions. Both of them have tendered their unqualified apology for having called a press conference immediately after an order was passed by this Court on 21st November, 2023 and for continuing to issue misleading advertisements and making derogatory statements in respect of other systems of 418 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports treatment. They seek to assure this Court that they will be careful in future and not violate the orders of the Court or the undertaking given to the Court or violate the provisions of law.
3. This aspect shall be considered on the next date.
4. At the request of the proposed Contemnors No.5 to 7, list on 23 rd April, 2024 at the top of the Board. The proposed contemnors shall remain present on the next date of hearing.”
(emphasis added)
17. This was followed by an affidavit filed by Acharya Balkrishna on 24 th April, 2024 stating inter alia as follows :
“2. That the Deponent herein in the affidavit filed on 06.04.2024, undertook to ensure that no further offending advertisements shall be issued as directed by this Hon’ble Court.
3. Further, I again tender my unconditional apology for the infraction of order dated 21.11.2023, and I regret that the advertisements were issued and I seek pardon of this Hon’ble Court. I tender my unconditional and unqualified apology in this regard once again.
4. I state that no such lapse will occur in future. I will always uphold the Majesty of the Court of law.
5. Furthermore, pursuant to the order dated 16.04.2024, the Deponent took an initiative to redeem himself voluntarily and in view of the same, the Deponent to took an initiative to publish public apologies in various National and Regional Newspapers with wide circulation across the country which were carried out on 22.04.2024. The said public apology which was published in several newspapers circulated across the nation is reproduced as below for ready reference:
“Patanjali Ayurved Limited fully respects the dignity of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. We sincerely apologize for the mistake of publishing [2024] 8 S.C.R. 419In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others advertisements and holding a press conference even after our advocates made a statement in the apex court. We are committed to not let such a mistake be repeated ever in future. We reassure you that we shall remain committed to uphold the constitution and dignity of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
Patanjali Ayurved Limited Haridwar, Uttarakhand.”
K. PROCEEDINGS DATED 23rd APRIL, 2024
18. On 23 rd April, 2024, learned counsel appearing for the proposed contemnors stated before this Court that some advertisements tendering unqualified apologies by the proposed contemnors had been published in the press a day before. When the newspaper cuttings were handed over to the Court for perusal, it was noticed that the apologies tendered were in a small box with such a fine print that it was impossible to read the apologies without using a magnifying glass. This attempt to downsize the advertisements, making them virtually illegible, had drawn an adverse comment from the Court. As time was sought to collate and file the documents and issue additional advertisements, the following orders were passed on 23 rd April, 2024 :
“1. Mr. Mukul Rohatgi, learned Senior counsel appearing for the proposed contemnors submits that some advertisements tendering unqualified apologies have been published in the press by the proposed contemnors for the lapses on their part, only yesterday. It is submitted that the same have been collated and shall be filed during the course of the day with copies furnished to learned counsel for the parties.
2. Needful shall be done within two days.
3. It is further stated that additional advertisements shall be published by the proposed contemnors tendering an unqualified apology for the lapses on their part within this week. As and when the said advertisements are issued and copies filed, the same shall be considered and appropriate orders passed.
420 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
4. List on 30 th April, 2024, at the top of the Board. The proposed contemnors shall continue to remain present on the next date of hearing.”
19. On 24 th April, 2024, an affidavit was filed by Acharya Balkrishna furnishing a list of the daily newspapers published by the proposed contemnors on 22 nd April, 2024, both in English and in Hindi. He further deposed that to redeem himself, he had voluntarily taken the initiative to publish fresh advertisements seeking public apology in various national and regional newspapers with wide circulation which were carried on 24 th April, 2024. The apologies published by the proposed contemnors extracted in para 7 of the affidavit, stated as follows:
“In the wake of on going matter before the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India (Writ Petition C. No. 645/2022), we in our individual capacity as well as on behalf of the Company, unconditionally apologise for the non-compliance or disobedience of directions/orders of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
We unconditionally extend the apology for holding meeting/ press conference dated 22.11.2023. We earnestly apologize for the mistake made in publishing our advertisements and it is our whole-hearted commitment that such errors will not be repeated. We undertake to abide by directions and instructions of the Hon’ble Court with due care and utmost sincerity. We undertake to uphold the majesty of the court and comply with applicable laws and directions of the Hon’ble Court of law/relevant authorities.
Patanjali Ayurved Limited, Acharya Balkrishna, Swami Ramdev Haridwar, Uttarakhand”
20. On 30th April, 2024, learned counsel for the proposed contemnors alluded to the aforesaid affidavit sworn by his clients and to the publications carried in various newspapers on 22 nd April, 2024 containing their apologies for the breach of the order passed by this Court on 21st November, 2023 and submitted that the apologies tendered by the proposed contemnors this time, were published in bold letters and the font size was legible.
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 421In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others
L. AFFIDAVIT DATED 16 TH MAY, 2024
21. On 14th May, 2024, on a query posed by the Court, time was sought on behalf of the proposed contemnors for permission to file affidavits setting out the steps that were being taken by them to bring down the advertisements of those products of Patanjali, licenses whereof had been suspended by the State of Uttarakhand and for recalling the said medicines sent for sale to stockists and other agencies. The proposed contemnors were permitted to file the said affidavits and orders on the suo motu contempt proceedings were reserved. Following is the relevant extract of the affidavit filed by Patanjali on 16 th May, 2024 :
"2. That in pursuance of the order dated 10.04.2024 of this Hon’ble Court, the State Government of Uttarakhand cancelled the manufacturing licenses of 14 ayurvedic medicines/formulations. The Respondent No. 5 is in the process of taking the appropriate remedy against the aid suspension order, mentioned hereinbelow, in terms of applicable law and further in light of the order dated 14.05.2024 passed by this Hon’ble Court.
3. That in light of the suspension order, the sale of these ayurvedic medicines/formulations has been stopped by Respondent No. 5 by issuing various directions to entities associated with it, details of which are mentioned hereinafter. It is relevant to state that the list of 14 medicines/formulations which has been suspended by the State Government of Uttarakhand are as follows :
S. No. Medicines
1. Swasari Gold
2. Swasari Vati
3. Bronchom
4. Swasari Pravahi
5. Swasari Avaleh
6. Mukta Vati Extra Power,
7. Lipidom
8. BP Grit 422 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
9. Madhugrit
10. Madhunashini Vati Extra Power
11. Livamrit Advance
12. Livogrit
13. Eyegrit Gold
14. Patanjali Drishti Eye Drop
4. That the sale of the aforesaid 14 ayurvedic medicines/ formulations by Respondent No. 5 on its online e-commerce platform patanjaliayurved.net was stopped on 09.05.2024.
5. That deponent states that it has also taken steps to remove the advertisements from its official verified social media accounts/handles in relation to the aforesaid 14 ayurvedic medicines/formulations and is taking steps to ensure that no advertisements qua the suspended medicines/formulations are available on the same.
6. Further, the Respondent No. 5 was selling the aforementioned ayurvedic medicines/formulations through-out India in its 5606 exclusive/franchise stores and has issued email of withdrawal dated 14.05.2024 to all the exclusive stores/franchises of the Respondent No. 5 across India for removal/withdrawal of the 14 ayurvedic medicines/formulations which were suspended vide order dated 15.04.2024 passed by the State Drug Licensing Authority Ayurvedic and Unani Services, Dehradun, Uttarakhand.
I. The Respondent has instructed the media platforms, associated with it as well as those specifically engaged by Respondent No. 5 for purchasing advertisement slots in print and electronic media to immediately stop the broadcasting of any advertisements in any form in relation to aforementioned medicines/ formulations. It is relevant to state herein that vide emails dated 14.05.2024, issued by [2024] 8 S.C.R. 423In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others Respondent No. 5 to advertising agency namely Vermillion Communication Private Limited, Rights Ad Communication Private Limited, Rights Ad Communication Private Limited, Combine Communications Private Limited as well as entities such as Sanskar Info TV Private Limited, Aastha Broad Casting Network Limited and Vedic Broadcasting Limited, necessary instructions have been issued to ensure that no advertisements qua the sale or promotion of the aforesaid 14 suspended ayurvedic medicines/ formulations be caried out in any publications either in print or electronic media.
A true copy of the emails dated 14.05.2024 sent to Vermillion Communication Private Limited, Rights Ad Communication Private Limited as well as entities such as Sanskar Info TV Private Limited, Aastha Broad Casting Network Limited and Vedic Broadcasting Limited are annexed herewith and marked as ANNEXURE R-1 at pages 10 to 21.
II. Respondent No. 5 also issued emails of withdrawal dated 14.05.2024 to all franchise stores, Super Distributors & e-commerce partner (Fit India Organic Private Limited) of the Respondent No. 5 across India for removal/ withdrawal of the aforesaid 14 suspended medicines.
A true copy of the emails dated 14.05.2024 sent to franchise stores, Super Distributors & e-commerce partner (Fit India Organic Private Limited) are annexed herewith and marked as ANNEXURE R-2 at page 22 to 27.
III. Intimation emails dated 14.05.2024 were issued to social media companies to remove/withdraw all advertisements of aforesaid 14 ayurvedic medicine/formulations, if any, suspended 424 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports vide order dated 15.04.2024 passed by State Drug Licensing Authority Ayurvedic and Unani Services, Dehradun, Uttarakhand, wherein such posts have been issued by third party individuals/entities who are not associated with any of the Respondent No. 5 verified social media handles. The said request was made directly to the Social Media Intermediaries as Respondent No. 5 has not direct control on any such handle which belongs to third party individuals/entities and any notice/take down action can only be initiated by the Social media Intermediary themselves.
A true copy of the emails dated 14.05.2024 sent to social media platforms/companies namely, X (Twitter), YouTube, Google and Meta (Facebook & Instagram) are annexed herewith and marked as ANNEXURE R-3 at pages 28-35.
Copies of the aforesaid emails dated 14.05.2024 written to various agencies, media houses and social media platforms are tabulated hereinbelow for ready reference of this Hon’ble Court:
S. No. Medicines
1. Patanjali (Exclusive/Franchise Stores
2. Patanjali Super Distributors
3. Sanskar Group
4. Vermillion Team
5. Fit India (E Commerce Partner)
6. Meta (Facebook)
7. Google LLC
8. Meta (Instagram)
9. Rights Ad communication Private Limited
10. X Corp (Twitter)
11. Vedic Broadcasting Limited
12. YouTube (Google LLC)
[2024] 8 S.C.R. 425In Re: Patanjali Ayurved Ltd. Through Its Mangg. Dir., Acharya Balkrishna & Baba Ramdev in The Matter of: Indian Medical Asso. and another v. Union of India and others 13.
Combine Communications Private Limited
14. Aastha Broad Casting Network Pvt. Ltd.
7. Respondent No. 5 has further intimated/conveyed all its franchise and stores to withdraw/remove any offending advertisement material.
8. The Respondent No. 5 further states that it has the highest regard for the orders/directions passed by this Hon’ble Court and further it will comply with any other directions/instructions as directed by this Hon’ble Court in order to meet the compliance of orders passed by this Hon’ble Court.”
M. ARTICLE 129 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA AND
CONTEMPT OF COURTS ACT, 1971
22. Before examining the conduct of the proposed contemnors in the aforesaid background, we may note the relevant provisions of law. Article 129 of the Constitution declares the Supreme Court to be “a court of record” and states that it shall have all the powers of such a court including the power to punish for contempt of itself. The provisions of Contempt of Courts Act, 19717 and the Rules framed thereunder form a part of a special statutory jurisdiction that is vested in courts to punish an offending party for its contemptuous conduct. It needs no emphasis that the power of contempt ought to be exercised with caution, care and sparingly. The contemptuous act complained of must be such that would result in obstruction of justice, adversely affect the majesty of law and impact the dignity of the courts of law.
23. It must also be understood that contempt proceedings are sui generis inasmuch as the Law of Evidence and the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 are strictly inapplicable. At the same time, the procedure adopted during the contempt proceedings must be fair and just that is to say that the principles governing the Rule of law must be extended to the party against whom contempt proceedings have been initiated. The party must have every opportunity to place 7 For short ‘the Act’ 426 [2024] 8 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports its position before the Court. Such a party must not be left unheard under any circumstances.
24. In the above context, we may profitably refer to the observations made in Murray and Company v. Ashok Kr. Newatia and Another 8 wherein, this Court stated as follows:
“9………The purpose of contempt jurisdiction is to uphold the majesty and dignity of the courts of law since the image of such a majesty in the minds of the people cannot be led to be distorted. The respect and authority commanded by courts of law are the greatest guarantee to an ordinary citizen and the entire democratic fabric of the society will crumble down if the respect for the judiciary is undermined. It is true that the judiciary will be judged by the people for what the judiciary does, but in the event of any indulgence which can even remotely be termed to affect the majesty of law, the society is bound to lose confidence and faith in the judiciary and the law courts thus, would forfeit the trust and confidence of the people in general.”
(emphasis added)
25. In Pushpaben and Another v. Narandas Badiani and Another,9 this Court had highlighted the significance of the special jurisdiction under the Act in the following words:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.