Brs Ventures Investments Ltd. v. Srei Infrastructure Finance Ltd. & Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 548; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2143
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Pankaj Mithal
- Decided
- 23 Jul 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4565/2021
- Sections
- 7, 140, 63, 41, 36(4), 18, 128, 391, 60(2), 126, 133, 134
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 2143 : 2024 INSC 548 BRS Ventures Investments Ltd.
v.
SREI Infrastructure Finance Ltd. & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 4565 of 2021)
23 July 2024 [Abhay S. Oka* and Pankaj Mithal, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the payment of Rs.38.87 crores to the financial creditor under the resolution plan of the corporate guarantor will extinguish the liability of the principal borrower/corporate debtor to pay the entire amount payable under the loan transaction after deducting the amount paid on behalf of the corporate guarantor in terms of its resolution plan; whether a holding company is the owner of the assets of its subsidiary and can the assets of the subsidiaries be included in the resolution plan of the holding company; can the financial creditor file simultaneous/separate applications under Section 7 of the IBC against the corporate debtor and the corporate guarantor as well.
Headnotes† Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – ss.7, 31 – Contract Act, 1872 – ss.126, 128, 133-139 – 1st respondent-financial creditor granted a loan of Rs.100 crores to the 2nd respondentcorporate debtor – Corporate guarantee furnished by ACIL-Corporate Guarantor – Corporate debtor defaulted payment of the loan – s.7 application filed against Corporate Guarantor – Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) against the Corporate Guarantor commenced, Rs.38.87 crores paid to the financial creditor under the resolution plan – Corporate debtor, if liable to pay the entire amount payable under the loan transaction after deducting the aforesaid amount paid on behalf of the corporate guarantor:
Held: Yes – Payment of Rs.38.87 crores to the financial creditor under the resolution plan of the corporate guarantor will not extinguish the liability of the corporate debtor to pay the entire amount payable under the loan transaction after deducting the amount paid on behalf of the corporate guarantor in terms of * Author 2144 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports its resolution plan – As far as the guarantee is concerned, the liability of the surety and the principal debtor is co-extensive – The creditor has remedies available to recover the amount payable by the principal borrower by proceeding against both or any of them – The creditor can proceed against the guarantor first without exhausting its remedies against the principal borrower – If the creditor recovers a part of the amount guaranteed by the surety from the surety and agrees not to proceed against the surety for the balance amount, that will not extinguish the remaining debt payable by the principal borrower and the creditor can proceed against the principal borrower to recover the balance amount – Where a company furnishes a corporate guarantee for securing a loan taken by another company and if the CIRP of the corporate guarantor ends in a resolution plan, it will bind the creditor of the corporate guarantor – The corporate guarantor’s liability may end in such a case by operation of law – However, such a resolution plan of the corporate guarantor will not affect the liability of the principal borrower to repay the loan amount to the creditor after deducting the amount recovered from the corporate guarantor or the amount paid by the resolution applicant on behalf of the corporate guarantor as per the resolution plan – View taken by NCLAT cannot be faulted. [Paras 14, 15, 17, 28] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – ss.7, 60 – Contract Act, 1872 – Simultaneous proceedings against the Corporate Debtor and the Guarantor – Permissibility:
Held: Is permissible – Consistent with the basic principles of the Contract Act that the liability of the principal borrower and surety is co-extensive, the IBC permits separate or simultaneous proceedings to be initiated u/s.7 by a financial creditor against the corporate debtor and the corporate guarantor. [Para 19] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – ss.18(1) Explanation(b), 36(4)(d) – Whether a holding company is the owner of the assets of its subsidiary – Can the assets of the subsidiaries be included in the resolution plan of the holding company – Whether the assets of the 2nd respondent-corporate debtor were a part of the CIRP in respect of ACIL-Corporate Guarantor (holding company of the corporate debtor):
Held: No – NCLAT rightly held that the resolution plan took care only of the investments of ACIL in the subsidiaries and not the assets of subsidiaries – Assets of a subsidiary company cannot [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2145BRS Ventures Investments Ltd. v.
SREI Infrastructure Finance Ltd. & Anr.
be part of the resolution plan of the holding company – A holding company and its subsidiary are always distinct legal entities – The holding company would own shares of the subsidiary company, but this does not make the holding company the owner of the subsidiary’s assets – By virtue of the CIRP process of ACIL, the 2nd respondent-corporate debtor does not get a discharge, and its liability to repay the loan amount to the extent to which it is not recovered from the corporate guarantor did not extinguish. [Paras 20, 21] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Contract Act, 1872 – s.140 – Rights of surety on payment or performance – “upon payment or performance of all that he is liable for”; ‘all that he is liable’ – Liability of ACIL-Corporate Guarantor was to the extent of the entire amount repayable by the 2nd respondentcorporate debtor – In the CIRP of ACIL, the appellant- Resolution Applicant of ACIL paid Rs.38.87 crores only to the 1st respondent-financial creditor on behalf of ACIL – Plea of the appellant that it has the right of subrogation over the right of the financial creditor over the corporate debtor in respect of its dues as well as the security provided to the financial creditor of the mortgage in respect of SEZ land:
Held: Rejected – Only the liability of ACIL under the corporate guarantee to repay the loan to the financial creditor was extinguished on the payment of Rs.38.87 crores – By the involuntary act of the creditor of accepting part of the amount from the surety in the discharge of the entire liability of the surety, even if s.140 is attracted, it will confer on the guarantor or the appellant the right to recover only the aforesaid amount from the corporate debtor – The subrogation will be only to the extent of the amount recovered by the creditor from the surety – Notwithstanding the subrogation to the extent of the amount paid on behalf of the corporate guarantor by the resolution applicant, the right of the financial creditor to recover the balance debt payable by the corporate debtor is in no way extinguished. [Para 25] Case Law Cited Lalit Kumar Jain v. Union of India & Ors. [2021] 3 SCR 1075 : (2021) 9 SCC 321; Bacha F. Guzdar v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay [1955] 1 SCR 876; Vodafone International Holdings BV v. Union of India & Anr. [2012] 1 SCR 573 : (2012) 6 SCC 613 – relied on.
2146 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Amit Lal Goverdhan Lalan v. State Bank of Travancore & Ors. [1968] 3 SCR 724; Economic Transport Organization, Delhi v. Charan Spinning Mills Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. [2010] 2 SCR 887 : (2010) 4 SCC 114; Lala Kapurchand Godha & Ors. v. Mir Nawab Himayatalikhan Azamjah [1963] 2 SCR 168; Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments Welfare Association & Ors. v. NBCC (India) Ltd. & Ors. [2021] 12 SCR 603 : (2022) 1 SCC 401; Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Ltd. v. Satish Kumar Gupta & Ors. [2019] 16 SCR 275 : (2019) SCC Online SC 1478; Laxmi Pat Surana v. Union of India & Anr. [2021] 2 SCR 924 : (2021) 8 SCC 481; Punjab National Bank Ltd. v. Shri Vikram Cotton Mills & Anr. [1970] 2 SCR 462 : (1970) 1 SCC 60; State Bank of India v. V. Ramakrishnan & Anr. [2018] 10 SCR 974 : (2018) 17 SCC 394 – referred to.
Shib Charan Das v. Muqaddam & Ors., AIR 1936 ALL 62; Kadamba Sugar Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Devru Ganapathi Hegde Bhairi, 1993 SCC Online KAR 7; Maitreya Doshi v. Anand Rathi Global Finance Ltd. & Anr. [2022] 15 SCR 536 : (2022) SCC Online SC 1276; Darbari Lal & Anr. v. Mahbub Ali Mian & Ors. (1927) SCC Online ALL 121 – referred to.
State Bank of India v. Ghanshyam Surajbali Kurmi (2022) SCC Online NCLT 14567 – referred to.
List of Acts Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016; Contract Act, 1872. List of Keywords Principal borrower/corporate debtor; Financial creditor; Corporate guarantor; Resolution plan of the corporate guarantor; Liability of Corporate Guarantor; Corporate guarantor’s liability; Balance debt; Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP); Subrogation; Holding company; Subsidiary; Owner; Assets of subsidiary; Corporate guarantee; Guarantor; Surety; Resolution plan of the holding company; Distinct legal entities.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 4565 of 2021 From the Judgment and Order dated 11.05.2021 of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, Delhi in CAAT(I)-1109 and 1096 of 2020 [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2147BRS Ventures Investments Ltd. v.
SREI Infrastructure Finance Ltd. & Anr.
Appearances for Parties Jaideep Gupta, Sr. Adv., Ajay Gaggar, Amarjit Singh Bedi, Yashwant Gaggar, Ms. Racheeta Chawla, Ms. Riddhi Bose, Ms. Anindita Mitra, Advs. for the Appellants.
Navin Pawa, Sr. Adv., Abhimanyu Bhandari, Arav Pandit, Thakur Ankit Singh, Ms. Rooh-e-hina Dua, Shamik Shirishbhai Sanjanwala, Raheel Patel, Shantanu Parmar, Advs. for the Respondents. Darius Khambata, Sr. Adv., Ritin Rai, Rishabh Parikh, Tirth Nayak, Vinam Gupta, Advs. for the Intervenor.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Abhay S. Oka, J.
FACTUAL ASPECTS
1. The 2nd respondent–Gujarat Hydrocarbon and Power SEZ Limited, is a corporate debtor. The corporate debtor approached the 1 st respondent–SREI Infrastructure Finance Limited (the financial creditor), for a grant of a loan. Under the agreement dated 5 th January 2011, the financial creditor granted the corporate debtor a loan of Rs.100 crores for setting up a SEZ project. The corporate debtor is a subsidiary of M/s. Assam Company India Limited (ACIL). The loan granted by the financial creditor to the corporate debtor was secured by a mortgage made by the corporate debtor of its leasehold land and a pledge of shares of the corporate debtor and ACIL. The loan was also secured by the corporate guarantee dated 5th January 2011 furnished by ACIL. The financial creditor filed an Original Application before the Debt Recovery Tribunal-I, Kolkata (for short, ‘the DRT’) to recover the outstanding loan amount. On 24 th March 2015, a “debt repayment and settlement agreement” was executed to which the financial creditor, the corporate debtor and ACIL (the guarantor) were parties. On account of the default committed by the corporate debtor, the financial creditor invoked the corporate guarantee of ACIL. Thereafter, an application under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (for short, ‘the IBC’) was filed concerning ACIL as the guarantee was not honoured. The adjudicating authority vide order dated 26th October 2017 admitted the 2148 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports said application. Thus, the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (for short, ‘CIRP’) of ACIL commenced. The 1 st respondent-financial creditor filed a claim of Rs.648.81 crores, out of which the claim of Rs.357.29 crores was admitted towards the claim by the Interim Resolution Professional (for short, ‘IRP’). After the appointment of the Resolution Professional (RP), the claim amount of the 1 st respondent financial creditor was reassessed at Rs.241.27 crores inclusive of the principal amount of Rs.100 crores. The appellant is the successful Resolution Applicant of ACIL. The appellant submitted a resolution plan. The resolution plan was approved on 13th August 2018 by the Committee of Creditors (for short, ‘the COC’), which was approved by the adjudicating authority by the order dated 20th September 2018. The order of the adjudicating authority was confirmed in appeal by the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (for short, ‘the NCLAT’). The appellant paid Rs.38.87 crores to the 1st respondentfinancial creditor, against the admitted claim of Rs.241.27 crores in full and final settlement of all its dues and demands submitted in the resolution plan.
2. On 10 th February 2020, the 1 st respondent financial creditor filed an application under Section 7 of the IBC against the 2nd respondent corporate debtor. The claim of the 1 st respondent-financial creditor was of Rs.1428 crores, which is claimed to be the balance amount payable to the financial creditor under the loan facility of Rs.100 crores. By the order dated 18 th November 2020, the adjudicating authority admitted the application under Section 7 of the IBC. Aggrieved by the said order, the appellant preferred an appeal before the NCLAT. A suspended Director of the corporate debtor also preferred an appeal against the said order of the adjudicating authority. By the impugned judgment of the NCLAT, both appeals have been dismissed.
3. M/s. Zaveri & Co. Pvt. Ltd. has filed I.A. No.11685 of 2023 for intervention. It is stated in the application that the applicant and other interested parties had submitted the resolution plan of the 2nd respondent-corporate debtor. A final resolution plan was submitted by the applicant on 23 rd August 2021, proposing to pay a sum of Rs.135 crores within a period of 15 months to the creditors of the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor. The COC of the 2 nd respondentcorporate debtor approved the resolution plan of the applicant on [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2149BRS Ventures Investments Ltd. v.
SREI Infrastructure Finance Ltd. & Anr.
30 th August 2021. As required by the approved resolution plan, the applicant has furnished a bank guarantee of Rs.2 crores on 3rd September 2021.
SUBMISSIONS OF THE APPELLANT
4. Mr. Jaideep Gupta, the learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant, submitted that in the CIRP of ACIL, the appellant’s resolution plan was duly approved. As per the resolution plan, a sum of Rs.38.87 crores was paid to the 1 st respondent-financial creditor, which was in full and final settlement of the dues of the 1 st respondent-financial creditor. He submitted that upon such payment being made by the appellant, Section 140 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 (for short, ‘the Contract Act’) would squarely apply as the rights of the 1 st respondent-financial creditor shall stand subrogated in favour of the appellant. Therefore, through ACIL, the appellant would step into the shoes of the 1 st respondent-financial creditor. He would, thus, submit that the appellant has the right of subrogation over the right of the financial creditor over the principal borrower (corporate debtor) in respect of its dues as well as the security provided to the financial creditor of the mortgage in respect of SEZ land. He submitted that upon payment of Rs.38.87 crores to the 1 st respondent-financial creditor, as a full and final settlement of its total dues of Rs.241.27 crores, the appellant has now stepped into the shoes of the 1 st respondent-financial creditor. He relied on this Court’s decision in the case of Amit Lal Goverdhan Lalan v. State Bank of Travancore & Ors. 1
5. The learned senior counsel further submitted that for attracting Section 140 of the Contract Act, the payment by the guarantor does not have to be of the entire amount due from the principal debtor. Even a partial payment made in the full and final settlement is sufficient to trigger the principle of subrogation. He placed reliance on a decision of the Allahabad High Court in the case of Shib Charan Das v. Muqaddam & Ors. 2 He submitted that the High Court of Karnataka, in the case of Kadamba Sugar Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Devru Ganapathi Hegde Bhairi3 has held that acceptance of the 1 [1968] 3 SCR 724
2 AIR 1936 ALL 62
3 1993 SCC Online KAR 7 2150 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports lesser amount by the creditor under the complete satisfaction of the dues paid by the surety, entitled surety to the right of subrogation. The surety is entitled to all the rights of the creditor against the principal debtor. He also relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Economic Transport Organization, Delhi v. Charan Spinning Mills Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.4
6. He submitted that upon receipt of Rs.38.87 crores from the guarantor, the debt repayable to the 1 st respondent financial creditor has been discharged. The 1st respondent financial creditor is now estopped from enforcing the remaining part of the debt from the 2 nd respondentcorporate debtor in view of Section 63 read with Section 41 of the Contract Act. The 1st respondent financial creditor applied Section 7 of the IBC against the 2nd respondent corporate debtor, though the entire debt of the 1st respondent financial creditor has been discharged. Moreover, there is a right of subrogation. He relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Lala Kapurchand Godha & Ors. v. Mir Nawab Himayatalikhan Azamjah. 5
SUBMISSIONS OF THE 1 ST RESPONDENT – FINANCIAL
CREDITOR
7. Mr Abhimanyu Bhandari, the learned counsel appearing for the 1 st respondent-financial creditor, has taken us through the impugned orders. He pointed out that the resolution plan of the 2 nd respondentcorporate debtor has been approved by the adjudicating authority by the order dated 19 th September 2023. He submitted that no payment was made against the claim raised by ACIL as it was an unsecured financial creditor primarily because the liquidation value of the 2nd respondent-corporate debtor is much lower than the total claim amount of the secured financial creditors. He pointed out that the main grievance of the appellant is that the institution of corporate insolvency has been upheld against the 2nd respondent-corporate debtor, for the assets allegedly part of the CIRP of ACIL, which is the holding company of the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor. He pointed out that under Section 36(4) of the IBC, the assets of the subsidiary of the corporate debtor cannot be included in the liquidation estate assets. He invited our attention to Section 18 4 [2010] 2 SCR 887 : (2010) 4 SCC 114 5 [1963] 2 SCR 168 [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2151BRS Ventures Investments Ltd. v.
SREI Infrastructure Finance Ltd. & Anr.
of the IBC, which contains the duties of IRPs. He submitted that if there is a resolution of a corporate debtor, the assets of any of its subsidiaries will not be included in the scope of the resolution process. He submitted that the holding company and its subsidiaries are distinct legal persons, and the holding company does not own the subsidiary’s assets. The learned counsel relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Vodafone International Holdings BV v. Union of India & Anr. 6 He also relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Jaypee Kensington Boulevard Apartments Welfare Association & Ors. v. NBCC (India) Ltd. & Ors. 7 Inviting our attention to the information memorandum in the CIRP of ACIL, he submitted that the same did not contain the particulars of the assets of the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor. It was specifically stated therein that the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor was still to unlock the value of the land, that is, the value of the investment made by ACIL. It was disclosed that the 2nd respondent-corporate debtor was a 51% subsidiary of ACIL. The assets and liabilities of ACIL, disclosed in the information memorandum, did not include the assets and liabilities of the subsidiaries. Therefore, the assets and liabilities of the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor were not part of CIRP of ACIL. He also pointed out the definition clause in the resolution plan. The liquidation value of ACIL was shown as Rs.360 crores, and the financial value did not include its subsidiaries’ income. It is expressly provided in clauses 13.1 and 13.3 of the resolution plan that all the assets of ACIL shall stand extinguished, and the corporate guarantee of ACIL would also be extinguished. There is a specific clause that no right of subrogation shall be available to the existing guarantors. He submitted that only a sum of Rs.38.87 crores was given to the 1 st respondent-financial creditor. Therefore, the liability of the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor concerning the balance amount continued to exist.
8. He invited our attention to the decision of this Court dated 21 st May 2021 in the case of Lalit Kumar Jain v. Union of India & Ors. 8 This judgment lays down that it is open for the creditors to move against personal guarantors under the IBC. He submitted 6 [2012] 1 SCR 573 : (2012) 6 SCC 613 7 [2021] 12 SCR 603 : (2022) 1 SCC 401 8 [2021] 3 SCR 1075 : (2021) 9 SCC 321 2152 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports that because the liability of the guarantor is co-extensive with the corporate debtor, this Court held that the approval of a resolution plan of the corporate debtor does not ipso facto discharge guarantors of the corporate debtor of their liabilities under the contract of guarantee. It was held that by involuntary process or due to liquidation or insolvency proceedings, corporate guarantors are not absolved of their liability, which arises out of an independent contract. In this case, the entire outstanding amount payable by the 2 nd respondentcorporate debtor has not been recovered from ACIL. Therefore, there is no bar on the 1st respondent-financial creditor to proceed against the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor for the remaining amount. In this case, the 1 st respondent-financial creditor first moved against the guarantor and, after exhausting the remedies against the guarantor, filed an application under Section 7 against the 2 nd respondentcorporate debtor. Merely because the creditor has made a partial recovery from the guarantor, it does not absolve the corporate debtor of his financial obligations. Reliance was placed upon a decision of this Court in the case of Maitreya Doshi v. Anand Rathi Global Finance Ltd. & Anr. 9
9. Regarding the plea of subrogation, the learned counsel pointed out that the plea was never raised before the adjudicating authority and the NCLAT. The ground of subrogation was made by way of an amendment to the memorandum of this appeal; therefore, the contention not raised earlier cannot be considered at this stage. He pointed out that the COC and the adjudicating authority have already approved the resolution plan for the 2nd respondent-corporate debtor. He submitted that this Court had settled this issue in the case of Committee of Creditors of Essar Steel India Ltd. v. Satish Kumar Gupta & Ors.10 He relied upon a decision of the Hyderabad Bench of the NCLT in the case of State Bank of India v. Ghanshyam Surajbali Kurmi, 11 which covered the issue.
SUBMISSIONS OF INTERVENORS
10. Mr. Darius Khambata, the learned senior counsel appearing for the intervenor, also made detailed submissions. He pointed out that under 9 [2022] 15 SCR 536 : 2022 SCC Online SC 1276 10 [2019] 16 SCR 275 : 2019 SCC Online SC 1478 11 2022 SCC Online NCLT 14567 [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2153BRS Ventures Investments Ltd. v.
SREI Infrastructure Finance Ltd. & Anr.
Section 128 of the Contract Act, the liability of a surety is co-extensive with that of the principal debtor unless there is something contrary to that in the contract. He relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Laxmi Pat Surana v. Union of India & Anr 12 on this behalf. He submitted that the guarantor’s liability is separate and distinct from the principal debtor as held by this Court in the case of Punjab National Bank Ltd. v. Shri Vikram Cotton Mills & Anr.13 This Court held that a binding obligation created under a composition under Section 391 of the Companies Act, 1956, between the company and its creditors, did not affect the liability of surety. He submitted that any variation in the contract between the creditor and guarantor does not discharge the principal debtor. If there is a variance made without the guarantor’s consent in the contract between the corporate debtor and the creditor, it amounts to the discharge of the guarantor as regards the transactions subsequent to the variance. He pointed out various provisions of the Contract Act regarding the discharge of a guarantor. Relying upon Section 60(2) of the IBC and a decision of this Court in the case of Lalit Kumar Jain,8 he urged that the IBC permits simultaneous petitions against the corporate debtor and corporate guarantor. He also invited our attention to Section 60(2) of the IBC. He relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of State Bank of India v. V. Ramakrishnan & Anr.14 He submitted that Section 140 of the Contract Act will be applicable only when the guarantor pays all that he is liable for under the contract of guarantee. He submitted that if the guarantor makes only a part payment of the debt, Section 140 will not have any application. He relied upon a decision of the Allahabad High Court in the case of Darbari Lal & Anr. v. Mahbub Ali Mian & Ors.15 He submitted that this proposition finds support even in the decision of the Allahabad High Court in the case of Shib Charan Das2 relied upon by the appellant. He pointed out that in the information memorandum of ACIL, the assets and liabilities of the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor were not included. The assets of the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor cannot be treated as a part of ACIL’s assets. He submitted that the resolution plan of ACIL has been prepared based on the information memorandum. 12 [2021] 2 SCR 924 : (2021) 8 SCC 481 13 [1970] 2 SCR 462 : (1970) 1 SCC 60 14 [2018] 10 SCR 974 : (2018) 17 SCC 394 15 (1927) SCC Online ALL 121 2154 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports He submitted that the information memorandum and the resolution plan must be consistent with Section 36(4)(d) of the IBC.
REPLY OF THE APPELLANT
11. Replying to the submissions made by the learned counsel appearing for the 1st respondent-financial creditor, the learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant reiterated his submissions on the applicability of Section 140 of the Contract Act. His submission is that the information memorandum indicates taking over the business of ACIL and the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor. He submitted that the business of the 2nd respondent-corporate debtor was included in the insolvency plan. He submitted that by the admission of an application under Section 7 against the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor, a valuable asset of ACIL has been taken away.
CONSIDERATION
12. Before we deal with the submissions canvassed across the Bar, we must note the issues formulated in the impugned judgment of the NCLAT. Based on the submissions made before it, two issues were framed, which read thus:
“13. Following issues arise in this appeal for our consideration:
(i) Whether the application under Section 7 of IBC is barred by limitation?
(ii) Whether the second Application under Section 7 of IBC is not maintainable against the Corporate Debtor as for the same debt and default, CIRP has already been taken place against the Corporate Guarantor and the Financial Creditor has accepted the amount in full and final settlement of all its dues?”
13. The present appellant did not canvas the issue of subrogation before the NCLAT. It is also not urged in the memorandum of appeal before the NCLAT. We may note here that the appellant has not seriously pressed the issue of the bar of limitation in this appeal. The NCLAT rendered the findings on both issues in favour of the respondents. There is no dispute that the 1 st respondent financial creditor had granted a loan of Rs.100 crores to the 2nd respondent corporate debtor. The loan was secured by the corporate guarantee furnished [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2155BRS Ventures Investments Ltd. v.
SREI Infrastructure Finance Ltd. & Anr.
by ACIL, which is the holding company of the corporate debtor. There is no dispute that the 2 nd respondent-corporate debtor committed a default in payment of the loan amount. Therefore, the guarantee was invoked by the 1st respondent-financial creditor, which led to the filing of an application under Section 7 of the IBC against ACIL. The CIRP of ACIL was completed, and the resolution plan was approved. The claim lodged by the 1 st respondent-financial creditor was of Rs.241.27 crores. However, as per the resolution plan, the 1 st respondent-financial creditor had to accept a haircut as it was provided therein that the 1 st respondent-financial creditor would get only a sum of Rs.38.87 crores from the resolution applicant. LIABILITY OF GUARANTOR / SURETY
14. As far as the guarantee is concerned, the law is very well settled. The liability of the surety and the principal debtor is co-extensive. The creditor has remedies available to recover the amount payable by the principal borrower by proceeding against both or any of them. The creditor can proceed against the guarantor first without exhausting its remedies against the principal borrower. Chapter VIII of the Contract Act contains provisions regarding indemnity and guarantee. Section 126 is relevant for our purposes, which reads thus: “126. “Contract of guarantee”, “surety”, “principal debtor” and “creditor”.— A “contract of guarantee” is a contract to perform the promise, or discharge the liability, of a third person in case of his default. The person who gives the guarantee is called the “surety”; the person in respect of whose default the guarantee is given is called the “principal debtor”, and the person to whom the guarantee is given is called the “creditor”. A guarantee may be either oral or written.”
A surety is also known as a guarantor. Section 128 reads thus: “128. Surety’s liability.— The liability of the surety is co- extensive with that of the principal debtor, unless it is otherwise provided by the contract.”
It lays down the fundamental principle that the liability of the surety is co-extensive with that of the principal debtor unless otherwise provided by the contract. Sections 133 to 139 deal with the discharge of surety, which read thus:
2156 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports “133. Discharge of surety by variance in terms of contract.— Any variance, made without the surety’s consent, in the terms of the contract between the principal debtor and the creditor, discharges the surety as to transactions subsequent to the variance.
134. Discharge of surety by release or discharge of principal debtor.— The surety is discharged by any contract between the creditor and the principal debtor, by which the principal debtor is released, or by any act or omission of the creditor, the legal consequence of which is the discharge of the principal debtor.
135. Discharge of surety when creditor compounds with, gives time to, or agrees not to sue, principal debtor.— A contract between the creditor and the principal debtor, by which the creditor makes a composition with, or promises to give time to, or not to sue, the principal debtor, discharges the surety, unless the surety assents to such contract.
136. Surety not discharged when agreement made with third person to give time to principal debtor.— Where a contract to give time to the principal debtor is made by the creditor with a third person, and not with the principal debtor, the surety is not discharged.
137. Creditor’s forbearance to sue does not discharge surety.— Mere forbearance on the part of the creditor to sue the principal debtor or to enforce any other remedy against him does not, in the absence of any provision in the guarantee to the contrary, discharge the surety.
138. Release of one co-surety does not discharge others.— Where there are co-sureties, a release by the creditor of one of them does not discharge the others;
neither does it free the surety so released from his responsibility to the other sureties.
139. Discharge of surety by creditor’s act or omission impairing surety’s eventual remedy.— If the creditor does any act which is inconsistent with the rights of the surety, or omits to do any act which his duty to the surety [2024] 7 S.C.R. 2157BRS Ventures Investments Ltd. v.
SREI Infrastructure Finance Ltd. & Anr.
requires him to do, and the eventual remedy of the surety himself against the principal debtor is thereby impaired, the surety is discharged.”
Thus, the law provides that if any variance is made without surety’s consent in the terms of the contract between the principal debtor and the creditor, it amounts to discharge of the surety as to the transactions subsequent to the variance. Under the provisions of Section 133, surety can be discharged only when there is a variance made in the terms of the contract between the principal debtor and the creditor. Section 134 contemplates a situation where the principal debtor is released by a contract between the creditor and the principal debtor. In such a case, the surety is discharged. If by any act or omission on the part of the creditor, the legal consequence of which is the discharge of the principal debtor, the surety stands discharged. Section 135 is based on the same principle on which Section 133 is based. If there is a contract between the creditor and the principal debtor by which the creditor makes a composition or promise with the principal debtor, or gives time to the principal debtor or agrees not to sue the principal debtor, it amounts to discharge of the surety provided the surety has not assented to such a contract. If the creditor contracts with a third party to give time to the principal debtor, and when the principal debtor is not a party to such a contract, the surety is not discharged. Section 137 lays down a settled principle that it is not necessary for the creditor to first sue the principal debtor or adopt a remedy against him. If the creditor omits to do that, unless there is a contract to the contrary, it will not amount to discharge of the surety. This means that without proceeding to recover the debt against the principal debtor, the creditor can proceed against the surety unless there is a contract to the contrary. Even if the creditor discharges one surety, it will not amount to the discharge of the other surety. There are two other contingencies provided under Sections 138 and 139. We are not concerned with these two contingencies in the present case.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.