Yash Developers v. Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 559; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 1443
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Aravind Kumar
- Decided
- 30 Jul 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 8127/2024
- Sections
- 13, 13(2), 12, 3, 2, 3A(2), 3B
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 1443 : 2024 INSC 559 Yash Developers v.
Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 8127 of 2024)
30 July 2024 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha* and Aravind Kumar, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Development agreement in favour of the appellant was terminated by the Apex Grievance Redressal Committee (AGRC) exercising its power under Section 13 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971. Order of termination upheld by the High Court. Issue as regards scope of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution against an order passed under Section 13; accountability of officers exercising power coupled with duty under Section 13; Performance audit of Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971.
Headnotes† Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – s.13 – Constitution of India – Article 226 – Rehabilitation of slum dwellers – Appellant was appointed as a developer by respondent no. 1 – However, development was prolonged for over two decades – Development agreement terminated by the statutory authority – Apex Grievance Redressal Committee (AGRC) – Validity of the said power exercised by the AGRC – Order of termination upheld by the High Court – Plea of the appellant that the delay in implementation of the project was in various phases between 2003 to 2011, 2011 to 2014 and 2014 to 2019 due to various reasons inter alia long-drawn litigation with a competing builder, delay in obtaining the environmental clearances or the delay due to non-cooperation of certain slum dwellers, in which the appellant had no role and was not at all responsible for: Held: Under s.13(2), Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) has the power to redevelop the project if it is satisfied that the development is not proceeding within the time specified – This power of SRA * Author 1444 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports is coupled with a duty to ensure that the project is completed within time – The provision is a statutory incorporation of time integrity in the performance of the duty – SRA is accountable for the performance of this duty – The primary responsibility to implement s.13 and allied provisions and to monitor compliances of schemes and agreements vests with the CEO – If the actions of CEO are based on the directions of the SRA, then the SRA must equally bear the responsibility – A writ of mandamus would lie against the concerned authorities if they do not perform the statutory duty of ensuring that the project is completed within the time prescribed – Delay of 8 years in resolving disputes with a competing builder cannot be a justification under any circumstance – Appellant being a developer fully understands the process of obtaining environmental clearances while other sanctions and permissions are pending, and it was for him to make all the necessary arrangements – Non-cooperation of some of the members cannot be a ground for delaying the project from 2014 to 2019 – AGRC and High Court correctly held that the delay caused due to the sanction of the draft development plan for the construction of the road cannot be a justification for delaying the project from 2015 to 2019 – Justifications given by the appellant for delaying the project, rejected – No merit in the present appeal, costs imposed – Though the justifications for delay are rejected, but there was dereliction of the statutory duty of the SRA in ensuring that the project is completed within time – There was negligence on the part of CEO and the SRA and they are accountable for their actions. [Paras 13, 14.1, 24, 26, 27] Constitution of India – Article 21 – Right to life – Slum Rehabilitation Scheme – Rehabilitation of slum dwellers: Held: Execution of the project under the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme cannot be viewed as a real estate development project – There is a public purpose involved inextricably connected to the right to life of some of our brother and sister citizens living in pathetic conditions. [Para 27] Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971 – Performance audit of – Litigation under the Act, worrisome – Directions for comprehensive statutory audit issued – Problem with the statutory scheme w.r.t issues such as identification and declaration of land as a slum; identification of slum dwellers; selection of a developer; [2024] 7 S.C.R. 1445Yash Developers v.
Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors. apportionment of the slum land between redevelopment area and sale area; obligation to provide transit accommodation for the slum dwellers pending redevelopment; issues of lack of independence and objectivity in the functioning of statutory authorities; effectiveness of statutory remedies; judicial review proceedings under Art. 226 cannot be a long-term solution: Held: The problems arising out of the statutory scheme and policy framework should have come under review by the State of Maharashtra – Assessment of the working of the statute to realise if its purpose and objective achieved or not is the implied duty of the executive government – Reviewing and assessing the implementation of a statute is an integral part of Rule of Law – It is in recognition of this obligation of the executive government that the constitutional courts have directed governments to carry performance audit of statutes – Role of judiciary elaborated – Chief Justice of the Bombay High Court requested to constitute a bench to initiate suo motu proceedings for reviewing the working of the statute to identify the cause of the problems indicated. [Para 35, 42] Judicial review – Directions for review and assessment of the implementation of a Statute – Justification:
Held: Constitutional courts are fully justified in giving such directions as they are in a unique position of perceiving the working of a statute while exercising judicial review, during which they could identify the fault-lines in the implementation of a statute. [Para 37] Case Law Cited Susme Builders Pvt. Ltd. v. CEO, Slum Rehabilitation Authority & Ors. [2018] 1 SCR 1 : (2018) 2 SCC 230; Vijay Rajmohan v. CBI [2022] 19 SCR 563 : (2023) 1 SCC 329; State of Haryana v. Mukesh Kumar [2011] 14 SCR 211 : (2011) 10 SCC 404; Pravin Electricals (P) Ltd. v. Galaxy Infra & Engineering (P) Ltd. [2021] 1 SCR 1162 : (2021) 5 SCC 671; Preeti Gupta v. State of Jharkhand [2010] 9 SCR 1168 : (2010) 7 SCC 667; Arif Azim Co. Ltd. v. Aptech Ltd. [2024] 3 SCR 73 : (2024) 5 SCC 313; Public Interest Foundation v. Union of India [2018] 10 SCR 141 : (2019) 3 SCC 224 – referred to.
Galaxy Enterprises v. State of Maharashtra (2019) SCC OnLine Bom 897; Tulsiwadi Navnirman Co-op Housing Society Ltd. & Anr. 1446 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports v. State of Maharashtra & Ors., 2008 (1) Bom.C.R.1; New Janta SRA CHS Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra (2019) SCC Online Bom 3896 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Justice in Adapting to Change, in R.W.M. Dias, JURISPRUDENCE, 305-327 (5th edn., 2013).
List of Acts Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Section 13 of the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971; Judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution; Development agreement; Developer; Performance audit of statute; Order of termination; Comprehensive statutory audit; Rehabilitation of slum dwellers; Delay in implementation of the project; Development agreement terminated; Redevelopment of the project; Rehabilitation building; Environmental clearance; Development plan; Builders; Slum Rehabilitation Scheme; Right to life.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE/INHERENT JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 8127 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 14.10.2022 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay in WPL No.18022 of 2021 With Contempt Petition (Civil) No. 217 of 2024 In SLP (C) No. 20844 of 2022 Appearances for Parties Kapil Sibal, Sr. Adv., C.U. Singh, Vikas Mehta, Adit Nair, Prakash Shah, Ranbir Singh, Abhik Chimni, Ms. Rupali Samuel, Kartik, Advs. for the Appellant.
Sanjay Kharde, Shekhar Naphade, C.A. Sunderam, Dama Seshadri Naidu, Dhruv Mehta, Huzeifa Ahmadi, Vinay Navare, Sr. Advs., Satyajeet Kharde, Sunil Kumar Verma, Anirudha Joshi, Shashibhushan P. Adgaonkar, Ms. Pradnya S. Adgaonkar, Aaditya [2024] 7 S.C.R. 1447Yash Developers v.
Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors. Aniruddha Pande, Ms. Rukmini Bobde, Siddharth Dharmadhikari, Bharat Bagla, Sourav Singh, Aditya Krishna, Ms. Preet S. Phanse, Adarsh Dubey, Ms. Soumya Priyadarshinee, Ankit Ambasta, Amit Srivastava, Amlaan Kumar, Saket Sikri, Aman Vachher, Dhiraj, Ashutosh Dubey, Ms. Anshu Vachher, Ms. Abhiti Vachher, Akshat Vachher, Ms. Smriti Puri, Amit Kumar, P. N. Puri, Anil Nag, Zulfikar Ali, Mrs. Jaya, Ms. Monica Saini, Amit Agnihotri, Ms. Priyanka Midha, Ms. Priya Misra, M. Yogesh Kanna, Ms. Anshula Vijay Kumar Grover, Ms. Rucha Deshpande, Rajeev Maheshwaranand Roy, Nilesh Kumar, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, J.
Table of Contents* I. Introduction :...................................................................... 2 II. Scope of Judicial Review against an order under Section 13 of the Act:........................................................................ 4 III. Accountability of officers exercising power coupled with duty under Section 13:................................................. 11 IV. Submissions and Analysis:.............................................. 13
(i) The first phase of delay is between 2003 and 2011..... 14
(ii) The second phase relates to the delay in obtaining necessary permissions, approvals and environmental clearances from 2011 to 2014......................................... 17
(iii) The third phase of delay relates to the alleged non-cooperation of certain slum dwellers leading to the stalling of the project from 2014 to 2019................. 18
(iv) The next period of inaction is from 2015 to 2017.
This is sought to be justified on the ground that the Municipal Corporation sanctioned a road that may pass through the property and published the draft development plan (DP) on 25.02.2015........................... 20
(v) Re: Appellant did not have the financial resources..... 21 * Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
1448 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(vi) Re: Submission on maintainability of proceedings before AGRC................................................................... 25
(vii) Re: Locus or conflict of respondent no.6.............. 27 V. Findings:......................................................................... 28 VI. Conclusion:...................................................................... 32 VII. Re : Performance audit of statute:.................................. 32
1. Leave granted.
I. Introduction:
2. The present controversy is a manifestation of common battles between competing real estate developers under the pretext of rehabilitating slum dwellers under the Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971.1 In the year 2003, the appellant was appointed as a developer by respondent no. 1, a cooperative Housing Society of slum dwellers having their hutments on the subject land in Borivali, Mumbai which was declared as a ‘slum area’ under the Act. As the development was unduly prolonged for over two decades, the development agreement in favour of the appellant was terminated by the Apex Grievance Redressal Committee 2 by its order dated 04.08.2021. The order of termination was challenged by the appellant before the Bombay High Court.3
3. The Bombay High Court formulated the following issues: “(i) A developer being removed on the non-fulfillment of the basic requirement to commence construction of a slum rehabilitation building for a long period of 18 years, whether is not fatal to the object and intention of a statutory intent behind a Slum Rehabilitation Scheme.
(ii) Another question would be as to whether the right to shelter which is part of the slum dwellers’ right to livelihood guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution, can be 1 Hereinafter, referred to as the “Act”.
2 For short, the ‘AGRC’.
3 Writ Petition (L) No. 18022 of 2021.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 1449Yash Developers v.
Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors. continued to be nullified by such actions of unconscionable delay on the part of the developer, in not commencing construction of the slum project even by an inch more particularly when the nature of such work awarded to a developer for him is purely a commercial venture, for profit.”
4. Apart from the above two issues, the High Court highlighted the limited scope of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution against the decision of the statutory authority-AGRC. The High Court, however, proceeded to examine the facts in full detail and dismissed the writ petition on facts, as well as on law.4 Thus, the present appeal.
5. Even before us, the appellant argued the case only on facts, to the extent that we were under an illusion that we were hearing suit for specific performance involving an issue of ready and willingness. Having heard the learned counsels for the parties at length on facts, we will certainly deal with their submissions, but before that we must reiterate the limited scope of inquiry under Article 226 of the Constitution.
II. Scope of Judicial Review against an order under Section 13 of the Act:
6. In this case, as in any other public law proceedings, we are concerned with the legality and validity of the power exercised by the AGRC in terminating the development agreement with the appellant by its order dated 04.08.2021. This order is in exercise of power under Section 13 of the Act which is as under:
“13. Power of Competent Authority to redevelop clearance area:
(1) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (1) of Section 12 the Competent Authority may, at any time, after the land has been cleared of buildings in accordance with a clearance order, but before the work of redevelopment of that land has been commenced by the owner, by order, determine to redevelop the land at its own cost, if that Authority is satisfied that it is necessary in the public interest to do so.
4 By judgment dated 14.10.2022, reported as 2022 SCC Online Bom 3712, hereinafter referred to as the impugned Judgment.
1450 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(2) Where land has been cleared of the buildings in accordance with a clearance order, the Competent Authority, if it is satisfied that the land has been, or is being, redeveloped by the owner thereof in contravention of plans duly approved, or any restrictions or conditions imposed under sub-section (10) of Section 12, or has not been redeveloped within the time, if any, specified under such conditions, may, by order, determine to redevelop the land at its own cost.
Provided that, before passing such order, the owner shall be given a reasonable opportunity of showing cause why the order should not be passed.”
(emphasis supplied)
7. Section 13(2) of the Act specifically empowers the competent authority to re-determine the agreement if it is satisfied that the re-development has not been done within the time specified. The provision is certainly a statutory incorporation of time integrity in the performance of the duty. We recognise this as a statutory duty of the competent authority to ensure that the project is completed within the prescribed time. We have no hesitation even in holding that a writ of mandamus would lie against the concerned authorities if they do not perform the statutory duty of ensuring that the project is completed within the time prescribed.
8. In Susme Builders Pvt. Ltd. v. CEO, Slum Rehabilitation Authority & Ors.,5 this Court held that Section 13(2) of the Act empowers the statutory authorities to take action and hand over the project to some other agency if the development is being delayed. The relevant portions of the judgment are as under:- “49. Otherwise, there would be an anomalous situation where the Society would have terminated its contract with Susme but the letter of intent issued by the SRA would continue to hold the field and it would be entitled to develop the land. The Society approached the SRA, in fact, asking it to take action against Susme. Since the SRA is the authority which issued the letter of intent, it will definitely have the power to cancel the letter of intent... 5 [2018] 1 SCR 1 : (2018) 2 SCC 230 [2024] 7 S.C.R. 1451Yash Developers v.
Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors. …
52. A bare reading of these provisions shows that in terms of clauses (c) and (d) of sub-section (3) of Section 3-A of the Slum Act, the SRA not only has the power, but it is duty-bound to get the slum rehabilitation scheme implemented and to do all such other acts and things as will be necessary for achieving the object of rehabilitation of slums. In this case, the SRA was faced with a situation where the slum-dwellers were suffering for more than 25 years and, therefore the action taken by SRA to remove Susme for the unjustified delay was totally justified.”
9. Case after case, the Bombay High Court has been ruling that, a) the developer is duty-bound to complete the project within the stipulated time and that b) the Slum Rehabilitation Authority (SRA) has not merely the power but a broader duty to ensure that the developer completes the project within time. We will refer to those judgments, not so much to certify that the issue is no more res-integra, but to emphasise that the rulings have not had the desired impact, much less compliance. The reason is that, neither the developer nor the authority is asked to face the consequences of their derelictions. That Section 13(2) is a power coupled with duty is clear from the judgments of this Court and many other judgments of the High Courts, however experience tells us that this recognition of a statutory duty in itself is not sufficient. Until and unless duty is identified with accountability, judicial review is ineffective.
10. In Galaxy Enterprises v. State of Maharashtra, 6 the Bombay High Court observed:
“53. The record reveals that what M/s Saral could do in eight years of its appointment, was to get the Annexure II, namely the list of the 73 eligible occupants certified from the MHADA. It was, thus, expected from the petitioner that the revalidation of Annexure II, which was possibly not a complex formality be undertaken at the earliest.
However this certainly did not happen and citing various reasons, which cannot be believed to be not attributable 6 2019 SCC OnLine Bom 897.
1452 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports to the petitioner, ultimately, the petitioner could not get the Annexure II certified only on 23 December 2013, which is after about eight years of the petitioner’s appointment. This fact itself raises a serious doubt as to the real intentions of the petitioner to undertake the scheme. The petitioner could not have simply blamed the authorities for the delay, as there is complete lack of concrete and/or any real steps which were to be taken by the petitioner to effectively seek different approvals, once the society had put the petitioner in the driver’s seat, in complete control of the project as rightly commented, in the impugned orders. Thus, the case of the petitioner, that from time to time steps were taken to implement the slum scheme as entrusted to it be the society cannot be accepted. These are the contentions of the petitioner, merely pointing out some movement of the files with the authorities. This was certainly not sufficient and what was required and expected by the petitioner was to take real effective steps to progress the slum redevelopment. The petitioner was expected to expeditiously obtain an Annexure II, as certified by the MHADA, thereafter obtain a LOI and then obtain a Commencement Certificate to start with the constructions and before that make a provision for temporary alternate accommodation for the slum dwellers to reside till completion of the scheme. There is not an iota of material to show that any such steps much less expeditiously were taken by the petitioner which will show the real bonafides of the petitioner to undertake the scheme.
54. In fact the petitioner kept the slum dwellers/society in dark on any of the steps alleged to be taken by the petitioner. There was no transparency in the petitioner’s approach with the slum-dwellers whose anxious, impatient and painful wait of so many years for the slum scheme to start was continuously staring at the petitioner’s right from the word go. This was not what was expected of a diligent developer. The slum schemes are expected to be taken and pursued by the developers for genuine and bonafide object and purpose to redevelop the slums as reflected in the rules which is for the mutual benefit namely the benefit of [2024] 7 S.C.R. 1453Yash Developers v.
Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors. the slum dwellers of being provided a permanent alternate accommodation and so far as the developer, to exploit the free sale component, which is nothing but a business consideration for the developer. If this be the long and short of a slum scheme what can be the intention of a developer to sit tight on a slum scheme and not take expeditious measures to undertake and complete the scheme. The reasons can be innumerable, if the reasons are attributable to the authorities, the developer has certainly remedies in law to be immediately resorted. No forum competent to entertain such complaints would refuse to look into such grievances when the very right to livelihood of the slum dwellers who are living in inhuman conditions, being a concomitant of Article 21 of the Constitution, is involved and which becomes a matter of urgent concern and of utmost priority. A developer cannot shut his eyes to all these factors and attributes, once appointed by the society. For the developer, there has be relentless action on day to day basis as any delay in not implementing the slum scheme is not only detrimental to the slum dwellers, but to the society at large. Delay in effective implementation of the slum scheme would defeat the very goal, the ideals and the purpose of the slum redevelopment scheme.
55. A perusal of the record indicates that the society is correct in contending that during the period from 2006 to 2016 i.e. for about 10 years the petitioner did not take any concrete steps towards implementation of the slum rehabilitation scheme and the petitioner had clearly failed to obtain a LOI for such a long period. The society, thus, was constrained to file the application dated 15 March 2016, under Section 13(2) of the Slums Act, praying for change of the petitioner as the developer. It is correct that Annexure-II was originally issued by MHADA on 16 April 1998. The petitioner was appointed as developer in the month of June 2006 and it clearly took about seven to eight years for the petitioner to obtain revised Annexure-II which was obtained on 23 December 2013.
Before the Chief Executive Officer and even before the appellate authority the petitioner has failed to show any 1454 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports justifiable reason as to why it took these many years for the petitioner to simply obtain a revised Annexure-II when as per norms issued by the Slum Rehabilitation Authority Annexure-II is required to be finalised within a period of four months when the hutment dwellers are below 500 in number. Further the record clearly indicates that even after obtaining the revised Annexure II, on 23 December 2013, the petitioner did not initiate immediate steps to obtain LOI for the next three years. There is, thus, much substance in the contention of the society that only after the society initiated proceedings under Section 13(2) of the Slums Act, the petitioner initiated steps to obtain a LOI.
...
57. There cannot be a myopic approach to these issues of a delay in implementation of a slum rehabilitation scheme. Things as they stand are required to be seen in their entirety. The only mantra for the slum schemes to be implemented is it’s time bound completion and a machinery to be evolved by the authorities, to have effective measures in that direction to monitor the schemes as a part of their statutory obligation to avoid delays. Non-commencement of the slum scheme for long years and substantial delay in completion of the slum schemes should be a thing of the past. In the present case, looked from any angle there is no plausible explanation forthcoming for the delay of so many years at the hands of the petitioner to take bare minimum steps to commence construction.
58. The authorities should weed away and reprimand persons who are not genuine developers and who are merely agents and dealers in slum schemes. These persons after get themselves appointed as developers, to ultimately deal/sell the slum schemes, as if it is a commodity. Any loopholes in the rules to this effect, therefore, are required to be sealed.
...
64. Thus, it is quite clear that inordinate delay is a sufficient ground for removal of a developer. There is neither any [2024] 7 S.C.R. 1455Yash Developers v.
Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors. perversity nor any illegality in the findings as recorded by both authorities below, in observing that the petitioner had grossly delayed the implementation of the slum scheme in question. The findings as recorded in the impugned order passed by the Apex Grievance Redressal Committee are also sufficiently borne out by the files produced before this Court…”
(emphasis supplied)
11. A Full Bench of the Bombay High Court in Tulsiwadi Navnirman Coop Housing Society Ltd. & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.,7 held that the SRA has been conferred with certain powers and each one of them is coupled with a duty. If the slum dwellers are eligible to be rehabilitated at the site and within a reasonable period, they cannot be left at the mercy of developers and builders. The slum dwellers cannot be expected to occupy a transit accommodation endlessly, without proper maintenance, and hygiene. An independent and impartial implementation, supervision and monitoring of the projects is the purpose for which the authority has been set up under the Act.
12. In New Janta SRA CHS Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra,8 the High Court considered the dispute between two rival societies claiming rights over a slum scheme. The Court observed as under:- “187. It thus cannot be accepted more particularly considering the provisions of Section 13(2) of the Slums Act that a slum society at its sole discretion and/or without any control and regulations by SRA can change the developer. If such a course of action is made permissible, considering the hard realities and the hundreds of developers being available to take over such schemes, it would create a chaos and it is likely that a situation is created, that the slum rehabilitation scheme never takes off and it is entangled into fights between two factions within the society and/or two rival developers. This is certainly not the object of the legislation. It would be too farfetched to read such draconian rights available to the Managing Committee or to general 7 2008(1) Bom.C.R.1.
8 2019 SCC Online Bom 3896.
1456 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports body of a society without any regulation, supervision and control of the SRA to change the developer. The SRA has all the powers not only to regulate and control such situations but to take a decision as to what is in the best interest of the slum dwellers and intended to achieve the object of the legislation.
188. Secondly it is not in dispute that the application of the petitioner for change of respondent no.5-developer was under Section 13(2) of the Slums Act. Having noted this provision in the foregoing paragraphs, Section 13(2) of the Slums Act would come into play only when the developer fails to adhere to the provisions of the development permissions granted by the SRA and a change of developer can be sought only when there is an inordinate delay or the construction carried on, is contrary to the sanctioned plans and/or the permissions. Considering this clear position falling under Section 13(2), in the context of this factual controversy as raised by the petitioner in regard to the consent of 70% of the slum dwellers being not available to respondent no.5, 1 am of the clear opinion that the view taken by both the authorities, in not accepting the petitioner’s contention, is required to be held to be correct and valid. “ III. Accountability of officers exercising power coupled with duty under Section 13:
13. Two facets of Section 13 (2) of the Act are that; a) the SRA has the power to redevelop the project if it is satisfied that the development is not proceeding within the time specified, and b) that power of SRA is coupled with a duty to ensure that the project is completed within time. We hold that the SRA is accountable for the performance of this duty. Accountability need not be superimposed by the text of a statute, it exists wherever power is granted to accomplish statutory purpose. In Vijay Rajmohan v. CBI,9 this Court held:- “34. Accountability in itself is an essential principle of administrative law. Judicial review of administrative action will be effective and meaningful by ensuring accountability of the officer or authority in charge.
9 [2022] 19 SCR 563 : (2023) 1 SCC 329 [2024] 7 S.C.R. 1457Yash Developers v.
Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors.
35. The principle of accountability is considered as a cornerstone of the human rights framework. It is a crucial feature that must govern the relationship between “duty bearers” in authority and “right holders” affected by their actions. Accountability of institutions is also one of the development goals adopted by the United Nations in 201510 and is also recognised as one of the six principles of the Citizens Charter Movement. 11
36. Accountability has three essential constituent dimensions: (i) responsibility, (ii) answerability, and (iii) enforceability. Responsibility requires the identification of duties and performance obligations of individuals in authority and with authorities. Answerability requires reasoned decision-making so that those affected by their decisions, including the public, are aware of the same. Enforceability requires appropriate corrective and remedial action against lack of responsibility and accountability to be taken. 12 Accountability has a corrective function, making it possible to address individual or collective grievances. It enables action against officials or institutions for dereliction of duty. It also has a preventive function that helps to identify the procedure or policy which has become nonfunctional and to improve upon it.”
14. For effective implementation of the principle of accountability of power under the Act, we identify the duties and performance obligations of the CEO. It is evident from the statutory scheme that the responsibility vests in the CEO, defined under Section 2 (b+a) read with Section 3A(2) of the Act. The CEO reports to the SRA, the duty of which is defined under Section 3B of the Act. One of the most important duties of the SRA is to ensure that the Slum Rehabilitation Scheme is implemented.
10 United Nations General Assembly Resolution 70/1 dated 25-9-2015. 11 Citizens Charter adopted by the Government in the “Conference of Chief Ministers of various States and Union Territories” held in May 1997 in New Delhi, available from https://goicharters.nic.in/public/website/ home.
12 See Office of United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Who will be Accountable? Human Rights and the Post-2015 Development Agenda, available from http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/ Publications/WhoWillBeAccountable.pdf 1458 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
14.1. The primary responsibility to implement Section 13 of the Act and allied provisions and to monitor compliances of schemes and agreements vests with the CEO. If the actions of CEO are based on the directions of the SRA, then the SRA must equally bear the responsibility. The CEO and/or the SRA must explain the delay in implementation, failing which, the consequences as determined by the court will follow.
PART-II
IV. Submissions and Analysis:
15. Returning to facts of the case, Mr. Kapil Sibal, learned senior counsel, appearing on behalf of the appellant, articulated the allegation of delay into six parts and in his inimitable style proceeded to explain how in each part, the appellant had no role and not at all responsible. We will deal with each phase of delay in the same manner as Mr. Sibal has presented the case before us.
16. (i) The first phase of delay is between 2003 and 2011. The relevant facts are as follows.
16.1. The appellant was appointed by respondent no.1 to develop the Project under a development agreement dated 20.08.2003, following which the appellant made a proposal for development on 11.12.2003. The Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai, however, assigned the re-development to a rival society, namely Omkareshwar Co-Operative Housing Society 13 and a developer, namely Siddhivinayak Developers 14 on 06.05.2004. Pursuant to this, on 07.09.2004, the SRA accepted the proposal given by Omkareshwar and Siddhivinayak for the development of the Property. After a long-drawn litigation between the appellant and respondent no. 1 on one side, and Omkareshwar and Siddhivinayak on the other, the CEO, SRA finally settled the dispute by its order dated 07.06.2011 and held that the appellant had the required 70% consent of individual slum dwellers to implement the project and also that the proposal of Omkareshwar was not valid as it was 13 Hereinafter, referred to as “Omkareshwar”.
14 Hereinafter, referred to as “Siddhivinayak”.
[2024] 7 S.C.R. 1459Yash Developers v.
Harihar Krupa Co-Operative Housing Society Limited & Ors. made after the proposal of respondent no.1. Dealing with the period, Mr. Sibal has submitted that multiple proceedings between the appellant and respondent no. 1 on one side and Omkareshwar and Siddhivinayak on the other consumed lot of time. While the High Court initially disposed of a writ petition recording a settlement that appellant and respondent no.1 are entitled to develop the Property, Omkareshwar challenged it leading to several rounds of litigation before the High-Powered Committee 15 and the High Court. The issue was laid to rest only on 07.06.2011 by an order of the CEO, SRA holding that the appellant enjoyed the consent of 70% of eligible slum dwellers and hence was qualified to be the developer. Mr. Sibal has submitted that the consequence of this litigation is that the LOI could be issued in favour of the appellant only on 29.06.2011, i.e. after this dispute was settled. The eight years’ delay in obtaining the LOI was inevitable and was not due to any fault of the appellant.
16.2. Per contra, Mr. C A Sundaram, learned senior counsel, appearing for the respondent no.6-Veena Developers, has submitted that the appellant did not have the financial capacity or the technical expertise to complete the project within the prescribed time of 3 years. It is due to this reason that the appellant was unable to commence construction even when all the requisite permissions and approvals had been obtained. Further, Mr. Huzefa Ahmadi, learned senior counsel, appearing for respondent nos.8-48, who are some of the slum dwellers, has submitted that the delay in the construction is entirely attributable to the appellant. He submitted that the appellant did not take any action to obtain the LOI anytime between 2003-2011.
16.3. While adjudicating on the delay in implementation of the project during 2003-2011, the AGRC relied on clause 11 of the development agreement dated 20.08.2003 requiring the appellant to complete the development of the project within three years from the issuance of the Commencement Certificate dated 14.07.2014.
15 Hereinafter, referred to as the “HPC”.
1460 [2024] 7 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
16.4. On the issue of delay from 2003 to 2011, the High Court examined the facts independently and upheld the findings of the AGRC. The High Court held that a delay cannot be viewed as reasonable. Further, the High Court held that the litigation with Omkareshwar did not prevent the appellant from starting the project, especially when the appellant had the consent of more than 70% of the slum dwellers at all material times. The High Court also observed that the appellant was not diligent in procuring the LOI.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.