Prabir Purkayastha v. State (Nct of Delhi)
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 414; [2024] 6 S.C.R. 666
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 15 May 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 2577/2024
- Sections
- 43B(1), 19(1), 19, 43A, 153A, 50, 45, 167, 43C, 57, 167(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 6 S.C.R. 666 : 2024 INSC 414 Prabir Purkayastha v.
State (NCT of Delhi)
(Criminal Appeal No. 2577 of 2024)
15 May 2024 [B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the arrest and subsequent remand of the accusedappellant was vitiated as the copy of the remand application was not provided to him or his counsel before passing of the order of remand thus, not informing him of the grounds of arrest in writing.
Headnotes Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 – Constitution of India – Articles 22(1) and 22(5) – FIR registered u/ss.13, 16, 17, 18, 22C, UAPA r/w ss.153A, 120B, IPC – Appellant was arrested in connection therewith however, the arrest memo did not contain the ‘grounds of arrest’ – Appellant subsequently remanded to police custody by Remand Judge – Grounds of arrest were thus, not furnished to the appellant at the time of his arrest and before remanding him to police custody – Arrest and the police custody remand challenged by the appellant – Rejected by Single Judge of the High Court by impugned judgment – Validity:
Held: Requirement to communicate the grounds of arrest or the grounds of detention in writing to a person arrested in connection with an offence or a person placed under preventive detention as provided under Articles 22(1) and 22(5) of the Constitution of India is sacrosanct and cannot be breached under any situation – Non-compliance of this constitutional requirement and statutory mandate would lead to the custody or the detention being rendered illegal – Grounds of arrest must be communicated in writing to the person arrested of an offence at the earliest – Arrest memo nowhere conveyed the grounds on which the appellant was being arrested – It was simply a proforma indicating the formal ‘reasons’ for which [2024] 6 S.C.R. 667Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) he was being arrested – Copy of the FIR was provided to the Advocate representing the accused for the first time on 5.10.2023 – Appellant was arrested on 3.10.2023 at 5:45 p.m. as per the arrest memo – Investigating Officer (IO) had a clear window till 5:44 p.m. on 4.10.2023 for producing the appellant before the Magistrate concerned and to seek his police custody remand, if required – The advocate of the appellant presented himself at the police station on 3.10.2023 after the appellant was arrested and his mobile number was available with the IO however, the appellant was presented before the Remand Judge at his residence sometime before 6:00 a.m. on 3.10.2023 – A remand Advocate was kept present in the Court purportedly to provide legal assistance to the appellant – This entire exercise was done in a clandestine manner and was a blatant attempt to circumvent the due process of law; to confine the accused to police custody without informing him the grounds on which he was arrested; deprive him of the opportunity to avail the services of the legal practitioner of his choice so as to oppose the prayer for police custody remand, seek bail and also to mislead the Court – The accused having engaged an Advocate to defend himself, there was no reason as to why, information about the proposed remand application was not sent in advance to his Advocate – The remand application was transmitted to the advocate of the appellant after the remand was granted by the Remand Judge which was at 6:00 a.m. as per the remand order dtd. 4.10.2023 – The remand order recorded that the copy of the remand application was sent to the Advocate engaged by the appellant through WhatsApp – These lines give a clear indication of subsequent insertion – The order of remand had already been passed at 6:00 a.m. and hence, the subsequent opportunity of hearing, if any, provided to the counsel was nothing but an exercise in futility – The copy of the remand application in the purported exercise of communication of the grounds of arrest in writing was not provided to the appellant or his counsel before passing of the order of remand dtd. 4.10.2023 which vitiated his arrest and subsequent remand – Arrest of the appellant followed by remand order dtd. 4.10.2023 and the impugned order passed by the High Court are invalid and are quashed and set aside – Appellant entitled to be released from custody by applying the ratio in Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India and Others [2023] 12 SCR 714. [Paras 30, 33, 34, 36, 39, 50, 51] 668 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 – s.43B(1) – Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 – s.19(1) – Constitution of India – Article 22(1) – Appellant placed reliance on the judgment in Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India and Others [2023] 12 SCR 714 to contend that in the said case s.19(1) of PMLA which is pari materia to s.43B(1) of the UAPA was interpreted and it was held that if the initial arrest is not in conformity with law, mere passing of successive remand orders would not be sufficient to validate the same: Held: There is no significant difference in the language employed in Section 19(1) of the PMLA and Section 43B(1) of the UAPA – The provision regarding the communication of the grounds of arrest to a person arrested contained in Section 43B(1) of the UAPA is verbatim the same as that in Section 19(1) of the PMLA – The contention advanced by the respondent that there are some variations in the overall provisions contained in Section 19 of the PMLA and Section 43A and 43B of the UAPA would not have any impact on the statutory mandate requiring the arresting officer to inform the grounds of arrest to the person arrested under Section 43B(1) of the UAPA at the earliest because, the requirement to communicate the grounds of arrest is the same in both the statutes – Both the provisions find their source in the constitutional safeguard provided under Article 22(1) of the Constitution – Hence, applying the golden rules of interpretation, the provisions which lay down a very important constitutional safeguard to a person arrested on charges of committing an offence either under the PMLA or under the UAPA, have to be uniformly construed and applied – The interpretation of statutory mandate laid down in Pankaj Bansal on the aspect of informing the arrested person the grounds of arrest in writing has to be applied pari passu to a person arrested in a case registered under the provisions of the UAPA. [Paras 17, 19] Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 – Constitution of India – Articles 20, 21 and 22 – Right to be informed about grounds of arrest in writing – Purpose:
Held: Any person arrested for allegation of commission of offences under the provisions of UAPA or for that matter any other offence(s) has a fundamental and a statutory right to be informed about the grounds of arrest in writing and a copy of such written grounds of arrest have to be furnished to the [2024] 6 S.C.R. 669Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) arrested person as a matter of course and without exception at the earliest – The purpose of informing to the arrested person the grounds of arrest is salutary and sacrosanct inasmuch as, this information would be the only effective means for the arrested person to consult his Advocate; oppose the police custody remand and to seek bail – Any other interpretation would tantamount to diluting the sanctity of the fundamental right guaranteed u/ Article 22(1) – The Right to Life and Personal Liberty is the most sacrosanct fundamental right guaranteed u/Articles 20, 21 and 22 – Any attempt to violate such fundamental right, guaranteed by Articles, 20, 21 and 22 of the Constitution of India, would have to be dealt with strictly – The right to be informed about the grounds of arrest flows from Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India and any infringement of this fundamental right would vitiate the process of arrest and remand – Mere fact that a charge sheet has been filed in the matter, would not validate the illegality and the unconstitutionality committed at the time of arresting the accused and the grant of initial police custody remand to the accused – The plea of the respondent that there was no requirement under law to communicate the grounds of arrest in writing to the appellant is rejected. [Paras 20-22] Criminal Law – Arrest memo – ‘reasons for arrest’ vis-à-vis ‘grounds of arrest’ – ‘grounds of arrest’ cannot be equated with the ‘reasons of arrest’:
Held: There is a significant difference in the phrase ‘reasons for arrest’ and ‘grounds of arrest’ – The ‘reasons for arrest’ as indicated in the arrest memo are purely formal parameters, viz., to prevent the accused person from committing any further offence; for proper investigation of the offence; to prevent the accused person from causing the evidence of the offence to disappear or tempering with such evidence in any manner; to prevent the arrested person for making inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case so as to dissuade him from disclosing such facts to the Court or to the Investigating Officer – These reasons would commonly apply to any person arrested on charge of a crime whereas the ‘grounds of arrest’ would be required to contain all such details in hand of the Investigating Officer which necessitated the arrest of the accused – Simultaneously, the grounds of arrest informed in writing must convey to the arrested accused all basic facts on 670 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports which he was being arrested so as to provide him an opportunity of defending himself against custodial remand and to seek bail – Thus, the ‘grounds of arrest’ would invariably be personal to the accused and cannot be equated with the ‘reasons of arrest’ which are general in nature. [Para 49] Constitution of India – Article 141 – Plea of the respondent that the judgment in Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India and Others [2023] 12 SCR 714 relied upon by the accusedappellant would not apply to the proceedings of remand made on 4.10.2023 as the appellant was remanded to police custody on 4.10.2023 whereas the judgment in Pankaj Bansal was uploaded on the website of Supreme Court in the late hours of 4.10.2023 and hence, the arresting officer could not be expected to ensure compliance of the directions given therein and thus, the alleged inaction of the IO in furnishing the grounds of arrest in writing to the appellant cannot be called into question as the judgment in Pankaj Bansal was uploaded and brought in public domain after the remand order had been passed:
Held: Said plea is misconceived – Indisputably, the appellant was remanded to police custody on 4.10.2023 whereas the judgment in the case of Pankaj Bansal was delivered on 3.10.2023 – Merely on a conjectural submission regarding the late uploading of the judgment, the respondent cannot be permitted to argue that the ratio of Pankaj Bansal would not apply to the present case – Once this Court has interpreted the provisions of the statute in context to the constitutional scheme and has laid down that the grounds of arrest have to be conveyed to the accused in writing expeditiously, the said ratio becomes the law of the land binding on all the Courts in the country by virtue of Article 141 of the Constitution of India. [Para 45] Constitution of India – Article 22(5), 22(1) – Respondent referring to language of Article 22(5) contended that even in a case of preventive detention, the Constitutional scheme does not require that the grounds on which the order of detention has been passed should be communicated to the detenue in writing:
Held: Said submission is ex facie untenable in eyes of law – It has been the consistent view of this Court that the grounds on [2024] 6 S.C.R. 671Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) which the liberty of a citizen is curtailed, must be communicated in writing so as to enable him to seek remedial measures against the deprivation of liberty – The language used in Article 22(1) and Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India regarding the communication of the grounds is exactly the identical – Neither of the constitutional provisions require that the ‘grounds’ of “arrest” or “detention”, as the case may be, must be communicated in writing – Thus, interpretation to this important facet of the fundamental right as made by the Constitution Bench in Harikisan v. State of Maharashtra and Others [1962] Supp. 2 SCR 918 while examining the scope of Article 22(5) of the Constitution of India would ipso facto apply to Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India insofar the requirement to communicate the grounds of arrest is concerned. [Paras 27-29] Case Law Cited Harikisan v. State of Maharashtra and Others [1962] Supp. 2 SCR 918 : 1962 SCC OnLine SC 117 – followed.
Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India and Others [2023] 12 SCR 714 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1244; Roy V.D. v.
State of Kerala [2000] Supp. 4 SCR 539 : (2000) 8 SCC 590; Lallubhai Jogibhai Patel v. Union of India and Ors. [1981] 2 SCR 352 : (1981) 2 SCC 427 – relied on.
Ram Kishor Arora v. Directorate of Enforcement [2023] 16 SCR 743 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1682 – referred to.
List of Acts Unlawful Activities(Prevention) Act, 1967; Constitution of India; Penal Code, 1860.
List of Keywords Remand application; Order of remand; Arrest memo; Grounds of arrest; Grounds of detention; Informing grounds of arrest in writing; Communication of grounds of arrest to person arrested; Police custody remand; Custodial remand; Right to be informed about grounds of arrest; ‘Reasons for arrest’; ‘Grounds of arrest’; Preventive detention; Order of detention; Order of detention communicated to detenue in writing; Custody or detention illegal; Right to Life and Personal Liberty; Fundamental right. 672 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 2577 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 13.10.2023 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in CRLMC No. 7278 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Kapil Sibal, Siddharth Aggarwal, Sr. Advs., Arshdeep Singh Khurana, Nitin Saluja, Harsh Srivastava, Harshit Mahalwal, Sidak Singh Anand, Manan Khanna, Nikhil Pawar, Ms. Saujanya Shankar, Ms. Rupali Samual, Ms. Pinky Dubey, Ms. Simran Khurana, Ms. Ishita Soni, Ms. Pranya Madan, Saahil Mongia, Advs. for the Appellant.
Suryaprakash V Raju, A.S.G., Zoheb Hussain, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, Annam Venkatesh, Kanu Agrawal, Arkaj Kumar, Advs. for the Respondent.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The instant appeal by special leave is preferred on behalf of the appellant for assailing the order dated 13th October, 2023 passed by learned Single Judge of the High Court of Delhi whereby the learned Single Judge dismissed the Criminal Miscellaneous Case No. 7278 of 2023 filed by the appellant seeking the following directions: - “A. Declare the arrest of the Petitioner as illegal and in gross violation of the fundamental rights of the Petitioner guaranteed under Article 21 and 22 of the Constitution of India in relation to FIR No. 224/2023 dated 17.08.2023 PS Special Cell, Lodhi Road, Delhi Police;
B. Declare and set aside the Remand Order dated 04.10.2023 passed by the Ld. Special Judge, Patiala House Court as null and void as the same being passed in complete violation of all constitutional mandates including failure to consult and to be defended by legal practitioner of his choice during the Remand Proceedings, being [2024] 6 S.C.R. 673Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) violative of Petitioner’s right guaranteed under Article 22 of the Constitution of India.
C. Direct immediate release of the Petitioner from custody in FIR No. 224/2023 dated 17.08.2023 PS Special Cell, Lodhi Road, Delhi Police.”
Brief Facts: -
3. The officers of the PS Special Cell, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi carried out extensive raids at the residential and official premises of the appellant and the company, namely, M/s. PPK Newsclick Studio Pvt. Ltd. (“said company”) of which the appellant is the Director in connection with FIR No. 224 of 2023 dated 17 th August, 2023 registered at PS Special Cell, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi for the offences punishable under Sections 13, 16, 17, 18, 22C of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (for short “UAPA”) read with Section 153A, 120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter being referred to as the ‘IPC’). During the course of the search and seizure proceedings, numerous documents and digital devices belonging to the appellant, the company and other employees of the company were seized. The appellant was arrested in connection with the said FIR on 3 rd October, 2023 vide arrest memo (Annexure P-7) prepared at PS Special Cell, Lodhi Colony, New Delhi.
4. It is relevant to mention here that the said arrest memo is in a computerised format and does not contain any column regarding the ‘grounds of arrest’ of the appellant. This very issue is primarily the bone of contention between the parties to the appeal.
5. The appellant was presented in the Court of Learned Additional Sessions Judge-02, Patiala House Courts, New Delhi (hereinafter being referred to as the ‘Remand Judge’) on 4 th October, 2023, sometime before 6:00 a.m. which fact is manifested from the remand order (Annexure P-1) placed on record of appeal with I.A. No. 217857 of 2023. The appellant was remanded to seven days police custody vide order dated 4 th October, 2023.
6. The proceedings of remand have been seriously criticized as being manipulated by Shri Kapil Sibal, learned senior counsel for the appellant and aspersions of subsequent insertions in the remand order have been made. Hence, it would be apposite to reproduce the remand order dated 4 th October, 2023 in pictorial form so as to form a part of this judgment.
674 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports [2024] 6 S.C.R. 675Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi)
7. The appellant promptly questioned his arrest and the police custody remand granted by the learned Remand Judge vide order dated 4th October, 2023 by preferring Criminal Miscellaneous Case No. 7278 of 2023 in the High Court of Delhi which stands rejected by the learned Single Judge of the High Court of Delhi vide judgment dated 13th October, 2023. The said order is subjected to challenge in this appeal by special leave.
Submissions on behalf of the appellant: -
8. Shri Kapil Sibal, learned senior counsel representing the appellant canvassed the following submissions in order to question the proceedings of arrest and remand of the appellant: -
(i) That the FIR No. 224 of 2023 (FIR in connection of which appellant was arrested) is virtually nothing but a second FIR on same facts because prior thereto, another FIR No. 116 of 2020 dated 26 th August, 2020 had been registered by PS EOW, Delhi Police (“EOW FIR”) alleging violation of Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) regulations and other laws of the country by the appellant and the company, thereby causing loss to the exchequer. A copy of the said FIR was, however, not provided to the appellant. By treating the EOW FIR as disclosing predicate offences, the Directorate of Enforcement (for short “ED”) registered an Enforcement Case Information Report (for short ‘ECIR’) for the offences punishable under Sections 3 and 4 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (for short ‘PMLA’). The ED carried out extensive search and seizure operations at various places including the office of the company-M/s. PPK Newsclick Studio Pvt. Ltd., of which the appellant is the Director.
(ii) The company assailed the ECIR by filing Writ Petition (Crl.) Nos. 1129 of 2021 and 1130 of 2021 wherein interim protection against coercive steps was granted by High Court of Delhi on 21 st June, 2021. The appellant was also provided interim protection in an application seeking anticipatory bail vide order dated 7 th July, 2021.
(iii) The FIR No. 224 of 2023 has been registered purely on conjectures and surmises without there being any substance in the allegations set out in the report. The contents of the FIR which were provided to the appellant at a much later stage 676 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports discloses a purely fictional story without any fundamental facts or material warranting registration of the FIR.
(iv) Admittedly, the copy of FIR No. 224 of 2023 was neither made available in the public domain nor a copy thereof supplied to the appellant until his arrest and remand which is in complete violation of the fundamental Right to Life and Personal Liberty enshrined in Articles 20, 21 and 22 of the Constitution of India.
(v) Shri Sibal pointed out that the learned Remand Judge, vide order dated 5th October, 2023, allowed the application filed by the appellant seeking certified copy of the said FIR which was provided to the learned counsel for the appellant in the late evening on 5th October, 2023, i.e., well after the appellant had been remanded to police custody.
(vi) That the grounds of arrest were not informed to the appellant either orally or in writing and that such action is in gross violation of the constitutional mandate under Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India and Section 50 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter being referred to as the ‘CrPC’).
(vii) Reliance was placed by the learned senior counsel on the judgment of this Court in Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India and Others 1 and it was contended that the mere passing of successive remand orders would not be sufficient to validate the initial arrest, if such arrest was not in conformity with law. Learned senior counsel urged that this Court in the case of Pankaj Bansal (supra) interpreted the provision of Section 19(1) of PMLA which is pari materia to the provisions contained in Section 43B(1) of the UAPA. Thus, the said judgment fully applies to the case of the appellant.
(viii) Shri Sibal referred to the observations made in the judgment of Pankaj Bansal (supra) and urged that since the grounds of arrest were not furnished to the appellant at the time of his arrest and before remanding him to police custody, the continued custody of the appellant is rendered grossly illegal and a nullity in the eyes of law because the same is hit by the mandate of Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India.
1 [2023] 12 SCR 714 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1244 [2024] 6 S.C.R. 677Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi)
(ix) Shri Sibal further urged that the view taken by a two-Judge Bench of this Court in Ram Kishor Arora v. Directorate of Enforcement 2 holding the judgment in Pankaj Bansal (supra) to be prospective in operation would also not come in the way of the appellant in seeking the relief. He pointed out that the judgment in the case of Pankaj Bansal (supra) was pronounced on 3rd October, 2023 whereas the illegal remand order of the appellant was passed on 4th October, 2023 and hence, the law laid down in the case of Pankaj Bansal (supra) is fully applicable to the case of the appellant despite the interpretation given in Ram Kishor Arora (supra).
(x) That the arrest of the appellant is in gross violation of the provisions contained in Article 22 of the Constitution of India, hence, the appellant is entitled to seek a direction for quashment of the remand order and release from custody forthwith.
(xi) That the action of the Investigating Officer in arresting and in seeking remand of the appellant is not only mala fide but also fraught with fraud of the highest order.
(xii) Referring to the remand order dated 4 th October, 2023, it was contended that the appellant was kept confined overnight by the Investigating Officer without conveying the grounds of arrest to him. He was presented in the Court of the learned Remand Judge on 4th October, 2023 in the early morning without informing Shri Arshdeep Khurana, the Advocate engaged on behalf of the appellant who was admittedly in contact with the Investigating Officer because he had attended the proceedings at the Police Station Lodhi Colony, post the appellant’s arrest. In order to clandestinely procure police custody remand of the appellant, the Investigating Officer, presented the appellant at the residence of learned Remand Judge before 6:00 a.m. by informing a remand Advocate Shri Umakant Kataria who had never been engaged by the appellant to plead his cause.
(xiii) Learned Remand Judge remanded the accused to police custody at 6:00 a.m. sharp as is evident from the remand order (supra). Shri Arshdeep Khurana, the appellant’s Advocate was informed 2 [2023] 16 SCR 743 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1682 678 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports about the order granting remand by a WhatsApp message at 7:07 a.m. but the same was an exercise in futility because there was no possibility that the learned Advocate could have reached the residence of the learned Remand Judge in time to oppose the prayer for remand.
(xiv) That, as a matter of fact, the remand application had already been accepted at 6:00 a.m. which fact is manifested from the time appended at the end of the remand order (supra). The learned Remand Judge signed the proceedings by recording the time as 6:00 a.m. Hence, there is no escape from the conclusion that the remand order was passed without supplying copy of the grounds of arrest to the appellant or the Advocate engaged by him. The appellant was intentionally deprived from information about the grounds of his arrest and thereby he and his Advocate were prevented from opposing the prayer of police custody remand and from seeking bail.
(xv) He further urged that the stand taken by the respondent that the grounds of arrest were conveyed to the learned counsel for the appellant well before the learned Remand Judge passed the remand order is unacceptable on the face of the record because the time of passing the remand order is clearly recorded in the order dated 4 th October, 2023 as 6:00 a.m. Admittedly, the grounds of arrest were conveyed to Shri Arshdeep Khurana, Advocate for the appellant well after 7:00 a.m. It was contended that the noting made by the learned Remand Judge in the order dated 4 th October, 2023 that the learned counsel for the appellant was heard on the application for remand is a subsequent insertion clearly visible from the remand order. The fact of subsequent insertion of these lines is fortified from the fact that the appellant had already been remanded to police custody by the time the Advocate was informed and the copy of the remand application containing the purported grounds of arrest was transmitted to him.
(xvi) That the foundational facts in the FIR No. 224 of 2023 are almost identical to the allegations set out in the EOW FIR. The appellant had been granted protection against arrest by the High Court of Delhi in the EOW FIR. Owing to this protection, the mala fide objective of the authorities in putting the appellant [2024] 6 S.C.R. 679Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) behind bars was not being served and, therefore, a new FIR No. 224 of 2023 with totally cooked up allegations came to be registered and the appellant was illegally deprived of his liberty without the copy of the FIR been provided and without the grounds of arrest being conveyed to the appellant.
9. On these grounds, Shri Sibal implored the Court to accept the appeal, set aside the impugned orders and direct the release of the appellant from custody in connection with the above FIR.
Submission on behalf of the respondent: -
10. Per contra, Shri Suryaprakash V. Raju, learned ASG, appearing for the respondent vehemently and fervently opposed the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the appellant and made the following pertinent submissions:-
(i) He urged that the judgment in the case of Pankaj Bansal (supra) has been held to be prospective in operation by this Court in the case of Ram Kishor Arora (supra).
(ii) The appellant was remanded to police custody on 4th October, 2023 whereas the judgment in the case of Pankaj Bansal (supra) was uploaded on the website of this Court in the late hours of 4 th October, 2023 and hence, the arresting officer could not be expected to ensure compliance of the directions given in the said judgment. He thus urged that the alleged inaction of the Investigating Officer in furnishing the grounds of arrest in writing to the appellant cannot be called into question as the judgment in Pankaj Bansal (supra) was uploaded and brought in public domain after the remand order had been passed.
(iii) Without prejudice to the above, learned ASG urged that as per the appellant’s version set out in the pleadings filed before the High Court of Delhi, he was actually remanded to the police custody after 7:00 a.m. With reference to these pleadings, Shri Raju contended that the appellant cannot be heard to urge that he was remanded to the police custody in an illegal manner and without the grounds of arrest having been conveyed to him in writing.
(iv) Learned ASG referred to the provisions contained in Articles 22(1) and 22(5) of the Constitution of India and urged that 680 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports there is no such mandate in either of the provisions that the grounds of arrest or detention should be conveyed in writing to the accused or the detenue, as the case may be.
(v) He urged that the right conferred upon the appellant by Article 22(1) of the Constitution of India to consult and to be defended by a legal practitioner was complied with in letter and spirit because the relative of the appellant, namely, Shri Rishabh Bailey, was informed before producing the appellant before the learned Remand Judge. Admittedly, Shri Rishabh Bailey had intimated the appellant’s Advocate, Shri Arshdeep Khurana regarding the proposed proceedings of police custody remand of the appellant.
(vi) He urged that the Advocate transmitted a written objection against the prayer for police custody remand over WhatsApp through the Head Constable Rajendra Singh and the learned Remand Judge has taken note of the said objection opposing remand in the remand order dated 4 th October, 2023 and thus it would be futile to argue that the order granting remand is illegal in any manner.
(vii) Learned ASG further contended that now the investigation has been completed and charge sheet has also already been filed and, thus, the illegality/irregularity, if any, in the arrest of the appellant and the grant of initial police custody remand stands cured and hence, the appellant cannot claim to be prejudiced by the same.
(viii) He vehemently urged that there are significant differences in the language employed in Section 19 of the PMLA and Section 43A and 43B of the UAPA and, thus, the law as laid down by this Court in Pankaj Bansal (supra) does not come to the aid of the appellant in laying challenge to the remand order.
(ix) Learned ASG further urged that there is a presumption regarding the correctness of acts performed in discharge of judicial functions and hence, the noting recorded in the remand order dated 4 th October, 2023 that the Advocate for the appellant had been heard on the remand application and that the grounds of arrest had been conveyed to the appellant cannot be questioned or doubted. He thus implored the Court to dismiss the appeal and affirm the order passed by the High Court of Delhi. [2024] 6 S.C.R. 681Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT o f D e l h i ) Rejoinder on behalf of learned counsel for the appellant: -
11. Shri Sibal, learned senior counsel for the appellant submitted that the argument advanced by learned ASG that the provisions contained in Section 19 of the PMLA and Section 43A and 43B of the UAPA operate in different spheres, is misconceived. He urged that language of both the provisions is pari materia and hence, the law laid down in Pankaj Bansal (supra) fully covers the controversy at hand.
12. Shri Sibal emphasised that on a plain viewing of the order dated 4th October, 2023, it is clear that the lines indicating the sending of the copy of the remand application to the learned counsel for the appellant and the opportunity of hearing provided to the Advocate through telephone call have been subsequently inserted in the order. He thus urged that the plea advanced by Shri Raju, learned ASG that there is a presumption regarding the correctness of judicial proceedings cannot be accepted as a gospel truth in the peculiar facts of the case at hand. He contended that applying the same principle to the remand order dated 4 th October, 2023 is counter productive to the stand taken by learned ASG inasmuch as, the order records the time of passing as 6:00 a.m. whereas the Advocate was admittedly informed after 7:00 a.m. Thus, there was no possibility of the remand application being sent to the Advocate or he being heard before passing of the remand order. He, thus, reiterated his submissions and sought acceptance of the appeal.
Discussion and conclusion: -
13. We have given our thoughtful considerations to the submissions advanced at bar and have gone through the material placed on record.
14. Since, learned ASG has advanced a fervent contention regarding application of ratio of Pankaj Bansal (supra) urging that there is an inherent difference between the provisions contained in Section 19 of the PMLA and Section 43A and 43B of the UAPA, it would first be apposite for us to address the said submission.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.