Bar of Indian Lawyers Through Its President Jasbir Singh Malik v. D. K. Gandhi Ps National Institute of Communicable Diseases and Anr.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 410; [2024] 6 S.C.R. 484
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bela M. Trivedi, Justice Pankaj Mithal
- Decided
- 14 May 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2646/2009
- Sections
- 2(42), 2(1), 29, 30, 2(11), 138, 2, 50, 16, 188, 189
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:22 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 6 S.C.R. 484 : 2024 INSC 410 Bar of Indian Lawyers Through its President Jasbir Singh Malik v.
D. K. Gandhi PS National Institute of Communicable Diseases and Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 2646 of 2009)
14 May 2024 [Bela M. Trivedi* and Pankaj Mithal,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to whether a complaint alleging “deficiency in service” against advocates practising legal profession, would be maintainable under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 as reenacted in 2019; whether “Service” hired or availed of an advocate would fall within the definition of “Service” contained in the C.P. Act, 1986/2019; whether the legislature ever intended to include the professions or services rendered by the professionals within the purview of the CP Act 1986 as re-enacted in 2019; whether the legal profession is sui generis; and whether service hired or availed of an advocate could be said to be the service under “contract of personal service” so as to exclude it from the definition of “Service” contained in s. 2(42) of the CP Act 2019.
Headnotes† Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – Complaint alleging “deficiency in service” against Advocates practising Legal Profession – Maintainability – District Forum held that it had the jurisdiction to adjudicate upon the dispute between the parties and decided the complaint in favour of the complainant – However, the State Commission held that the services of lawyers/advocates did not fall within the ambit of “service” defined u/s. 2(1)(o) of the 1986 Act – In Revision, the National Commission held inter alia that if there was any deficiency in service rendered by the Advocates/Lawyers, a complaint under the 1986 Act would be maintainable – Correctness:
Held: Services hired or availed of an Advocate would be that of a contract ‘of personal service’ and would thus, stand excluded from the definition of “service” contained in the s. 2(42) of the CP [2024] 6 S.C.R. 485Bar of Indian L a w y e r s T h r o u g h i t s P r e s i d e n t J a s b i r Singh M a l i k v . D . K . G a n d h i P S National Institute o f Communicable D i s e a s e s a n d A n r . Act, 2019 – In view thereof, the complaint alleging “deficiency in service” against Advocates practising legal profession would not be maintainable under the CP Act, 2019 – Thus, the impugned judgment passed by the National Commission set aside [Paras 42, 43] – Held: Per Pankaj Mithal, J. (Concurring) In the era of globalization, a law has to be applied in context with the prevailing situation of the country, nonetheless, on the basis of the common resolution of the UNO, laws must have a uniform application in all nations – It is, thus, essential that the consumer protection laws in all countries may somewhat have universal application and be confined to ‘consumers’ only i.e. to the persons who buys any goods for consideration or hires or avails of any service for consideration, impliedly excluding the professional services especially that of a lawyer – In doing so, in India also the services of professionals more particularly that of lawyers have to be excluded from consumer protection law in accordance with the intention expressed in enacting the same – Legislature in India as in some other countries, had not intended to include the services rendered by the professionals especially the lawyers to their client within the purview of CP Act, 1986 and re-enacted in 2019 – Thus, the view taken by the National Commission that complaint would be maintainable in CP Act, 1986, in respect of deficiency in service rendered by the lawyers, is incorrect and is set aside. [Paras 24-28] Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – Legislature, if intended to include the Professions or services rendered by the Professionals within the purview of the CP Act 1986/2019:
Held: The very purpose and object of the CP Act 1986 as reenacted in 2019 was to provide protection to the consumers from unfair trade practices and unethical business practices – Legislature never intended to include either the Professions or the services rendered by the Professionals within the purview of the said Acts – Other object of the Act was to provide to the consumers timely and effective administration and settlement of their disputes arising out of the unfair trade and unethical business practices – If the services provided by all the Professionals are also brought within the purview of the Act, there would be flood-gate of litigations in the commissions/forums established under the Act, and the very object of Act would be frustrated – Legislative draftsmen are presumed to know the law and there is no reason to assume that the legislature intended to include the Professions or the 486 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Professionals or the services provided by them within the ambit of the CP Act – Any interpretation of the Preamble or the scheme of the Act for construing ‘Profession’ as ‘Business’ or ‘Trade’; or ‘Professional’ as ‘service provider’ would be extending the scope of the Act which was not intended, rather would have a counter productive effect. [Paras 42, 19, 20, 18] Legal Profession – Legal Profession is sui generis or is different from the other Profession:
Held: Having regard to the role, status and duties of the Advocates as the professionals, the legal profession is sui generis i.e unique in nature and cannot be compared with any other profession – Legal profession is different from the other professions for the reason that what the Advocates do, affects not only an individual but the entire administration of justice, which is the foundation of the civilized society – Legal profession is a solemn and serious profession, and has always been held in very high esteem – Their services in making the judicial system efficient, effective and credible, and in creating a strong and impartial Judiciary, which could not be compared with the services rendered by other professionals [Paras 42, 30] – Held: Per Pankaj Mithal, J. (Concurring) Profession of law, as such, is regarded as sui generis i.e. which is unique – It is distinct from all other professions and is one of its own kind. [Para 3] Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – s. 2(42) – Service hired or availed of an Advocate, if could be said to be the service under a “contract of personal service” so as to exclude it from the definition of “Service” contained in s. 2(42): Held: Service hired or availed of an Advocate is a service under “a contract of personal service,” and thus, would fall within the exclusionary part of the definition of “Service” contained in s. 2(42) – Greater the amount of direct control exercised over the person rendering the services by the person contracting for them, the stronger would be the grounds for holding it to be a “contract of service” – Considerable amount of direct control is exercised by the Client over the manner in which an Advocate renders his services during the course of his employment. [Paras 42, 39, 41] Reference to larger Bench – Three-Judge Bench decision in *Indian Medical Association vs. V.P. Shantha & Others holding inter alia that the wide amplitude of the definition of ‘service’ in the main part of s. 2(1)(o) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 [2024] 6 S.C.R. 487Bar of Indian L a w y e r s T h r o u g h i t s P r e s i d e n t J a s b i r Singh M a l i k v . D . K . G a n d h i P S National Institute o f Communicable D i s e a s e s a n d A n r . would cover the services rendered by Medical Practitioners within the said s. 2(1)(o) of the Act – Correctness:
Held: Having regard to the history, object, purpose and the scheme of the CP Act and that neither the “Profession” could be treated as “business” or “trade” nor the services provided by the “Professionals” could be treated at par with the services provided by the Businessmen or the Traders, so as to bring them within the purview of the CP Act, the decision in *Indian Medical Association vs. V.P Shantha’s case to be revisited and considered by a larger bench – Thus, matter referred to Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India for consideration – Supreme Court Rules – Order VI r 2. [Paras 21, 24] Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – Scope and object of – Intention of the legislature: Held: The said Act was enacted to provide for the better protection of the interests of the consumers against their exploitation by the traders and manufacturers of the consumer goods, and to help consumers in getting justice and fair treatment in the matter of goods and services purchased and availed by them in a market dominated by large trading and manufacturing bodies – Reasons for re-enacting the CP Act, 2019 by the Legislature, were certain shortcomings found in the CP Act 1986 while administering the said Act, and due to the emergence of global supply chains, rise in international trade and rapid development of ecommerce leading to new systems for goods and services, new options and opportunities had become available to the consumers – New forms of unfair trade and unethical business practices also came to be developed, which made the consumers more vulnerable – Furthermore, there was not a whisper in the statement of objects and reasons either of the CP Act, 1986 or 2019 to include the Professions or the Services provided by the Professionals like Advocates, Doctors etc. within the purview of the Act – Professionals could not be called Businessmen or Traders, nor Clients or Patients be called Consumers. [Paras 12, 14, 15] Words and phrases – Definition of term “Profession” – Meaning and explanation of:
Held: “Profession” would require advanced education and training in some branch of learning or science – Nature of work is also skilled and specialised one, substantial part of which would be 488 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports mental rather than manual – Thus, having regard to the nature of work of a professional, which requires high level of education, training and proficiency and which involves skilled and specialized kind of mental work, operating in the specialized spheres, where achieving success would depend upon many other factors beyond a man’s control, a Professional cannot be treated equally or at par with a Businessman or a Trader or a Service provider of products or goods as contemplated in the Consumer Protection Act – Similarly, services rendered by Businessman or Trader to consumers with regard to his goods or products cannot be equated with the Services provided by Professional to his clients with regard to his specialized branch of profession. [Paras 15, 18] Legal profession – Justice Delivery System and the evolving jurisprudence – Role of Advocates:
Held: Legal profession cannot be equated with any other traditional professions – It is not commercial in nature but is essentially a service oriented, noble profession – Role of Advocates is indispensable in the Justice Delivery System – Evolution of jurisprudence to keep the Constitution vibrant is possible only with the positive contribution of the Advocates – Advocates are expected to be fearless and independent for protecting the rights of citizens, for upholding the Rule of law and also for protecting the Independence of Judiciary – People repose immense faith in the Judiciary, and the Bar being an integral part of the Judicial System has been assigned a very crucial role for preserving the independence of the Judiciary, and in turn the very democratic set up of the Nation – Advocates are perceived to be the intellectuals amongst the elites and social activists amongst the downtrodden, thus are expected to act with utmost good faith, integrity, fairness and loyalty while handling the legal proceedings of his client – Being a responsible officer of the court and an important adjunct of the administration of justice, an Advocate owes his duty not only to his client but also to the court as well as to the opposite side [Para 29] – Held: Per Pankaj Mithal, J. (Concurring) Profession of law is a noble profession having an element of duty towards the court – Lawyers perform multi-faceted duties – They not only have a duty towards the client or their opponents but they have a paramount duty to assist the court as well – In a way, they are officers as well as ambassadors of the court – Thus, in rendering such kind of a duty to enable the courts to come to a [2024] 6 S.C.R. 489Bar of Indian Lawyers Through its President Jasbir Singh Malik v. D. K. Gandhi PS National Institute of Communicable Diseases and Anr. just conclusion, it may be possible that at times, the lawyers may earn displeasure of the client while assisting the court. [Para 2] Advocates Act, 1961 – Advocate – Legal Practitioner – Definition of, and explanation:
Held: Advocate is included in the definition of “Legal Practitioner” but legal practitioner is not included in the definition of Advocate – Advocate is one who has been entered in any roll under the provisions of the Advocates Act – Law relating to legal practitioners and to provide for the constitution of Bar Councils and an All-India Bar is covered under the Advocates Act, 1961 – As per s. 29, there is only one class of persons entitled to practice the profession of law, namely Advocates, and as per s. 30, every advocate whose name is entered in the State roll is entitled as of right to practice in all Courts including the Supreme Court and before any Tribunal or any other authority or person before whom such advocate is by or under any law for the time being in force entitled to practice – Comprehensive provisions are contained in the Advocates Act, 1961 and the Bar Council of India Rules to take care of the professional misconduct of the Advocates, and prescribing the punishments if they are found guilty of professional or other misconduct by the Disciplinary Committees of the State Bar Council or the Bar Council of India. [Para 34] Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – s. 2(1)(o) – Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – s. 2(42) – Definition of “Service” contained in s. 2(1)(o) of the CP Act 1986 and in s. 2(42) of the CP Act 2019 – Elucidation:
Held: Definition of “Service” contained in s. 2(1)(o) of the CP Act 1986 and in s. 2(42) of the CP Act 2019 is the same – Definition of ‘service’ is divided into three parts-first part is explanatory in nature and defines service to mean service of any description which is made available to the potential users; the second part is inclusionary part, which expressly includes the provision of facilities in connection with the specific services; and the third part is exclusionary part which excludes rendering of any service free of charge or under a contract of personal service. [Paras 35, 37] Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – s. 2(1)(g) – Consumer Protection Act, 2019 – s. 2(11) – Definition of ‘Deficiency’ in s. 2(1)(g) of 1986 Act and s. 2(11) of 2019 Act:
Held: There is slight difference in the definition of ‘Deficiency’ in s. 2(1)(g) of 1986 Act and s. 2(11) of 2019 Act. [Para 36] 490 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Advocates – Relationship between an Advocate and his Client – Nature of control – Unique attributes:
Held : Advocates are generally perceived to be their client’s agents and owe fiduciary duties to their clients – Advocates are fastened with all the traditional duties that agents owe to their principals – Advocates have to respect the client’s autonomy to make decisions at a minimum, as to the objectives of the representation – Advocates are not entitled to make concessions or give any undertaking to the Court without express instructions from the Client – It is the solemn duty of an Advocate not to transgress the authority conferred on him by his Client – Advocate is bound to seek appropriate instructions from the Client or his authorized agent before taking any action or making any statement or concession which may, directly or remotely, affect the legal rights of the Client – Advocate represents the client before the Court and conducts proceedings on behalf of the client – He is the only link between the court and the client – Thus, his responsibility is onerous – He is expected to follow the instructions of his client rather than substitute his judgment – Thus, a considerable amount of direct control is exercised by the Client over the manner in which an Advocate renders his services during the course of his employment. [Para 41] Consumer Protection Laws – Exclusion of lawyers from Consumer Protection Laws – International practice/norms – Discussed. [Paras 6-9, 13-15, 17, 24] Per Pankaj Mithal, J. (Concurring)
Case Law Cited In the judgment of Bela M. Trivedi, J.
Indian Medical Association v. V.P. Shantha & Others [1995] Supp. 5 SCR 110 : (1995) 6 SCC 651 – To be revisited.
State of Karnataka v. Vishwabharathi House Building Coop. Society and Others [2003] 1 SCR 397 : (2003)
2 SCC 412; Common Cause, A Registered Society v.
Union of India and Others [1993] 1 SCR 10 : (1997) 10 SCC 729; Lucknow Development Authority v. M.K. Gupta [1993] Supp. 3 SCR 615 : (1994) 1 SCC 243; Laxmi Engineering Works v. P.S.G. Industrial Institute [1995] 3 SCR 174 : (1995) 3 SCC 583; State of West Bengal [2024] 6 S.C.R. 491Bar of Indian Lawyers Through its President Jasbir Singh Malik v. D. K. Gandhi PS National Institute of Communicable Diseases and Anr. v. Subodh Gopal Bose & Others [1954] 1 SCR 587 :
AIR 1954 SC 92; Triveniben v. State of Gujarat [1989] 1 SCR 509 : (1989) 1 SCC 678; Byram Pestonji Gariwala v. Union Bank of India and Others [1991] Supp. 1 SCR 187 : (1992) 1 SCC 31; R. Muthukrishnan v. Registrar General, High Court of Judicature at Madras [2019] 1 SCR 589 : (2019) 16 SCC 407; State of U.P and Others v. U.P. State Law Officers Association and Others [1994] 1 SCR 348 : (1994) 2 SCC 204; Dharangadhra Chemical Works Ltd. v. State of Saurashtra and Others [1957] 1 SCR 152 : AIR 1957 SC 264; Himalayan Cooperative Group Housing Society v. Balwan Singh and Others [2015] 4 SCR 616 : (2015) 7 SCC 373 – referred to.
Simmons v. Heath Laundry Company (1924) 1 KB 762 – referred to.
In the judgment of Pankaj Mithal, J.
Om Prakash v. Assistant Engineer, Haryana Agro Industries Corporation Ltd. and Anr. [1994] 3 SCR 463: (1994) 3 SCC 504; Laureate Buildwell (P) Ltd. v.
Charanjeet Singh [2021] 6 SCR 673 : (2021) 20 SCC 401 – referred to.
D’Orta-Ekenaike v. Victoria Legal Aid (2005) 223 CLR 1. Books and Periodicals Cited In the judgment of Bela M Trivedi, J.
Black’s Law Dictionary, 11th Edition; “Jackson and Powell on Professional Liability” 2nd supplement to the 7th edition – referred to.
List of Acts Consumer Protection Act, 1986; Consumer Protection Act, 2019; Legal Practitioners Act, 1879; Bombay Pleaders Act, 1920; Indian Bar Councils Act, 1926; Advocates Act, 1961; Supreme Court Rules. List of Keywords Deficiency in service; Service hired or availed of an Advocate; Definition of Service; Professions or services rendered by the Professionals; Legal Profession, sui generis; Service under contract 492 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of personal service; Unfair trade practices and unethical business practices; Timely and effective settlement of consumers’ disputes; ‘Profession’ as ‘Business’ or ‘Trade’; ‘Professional’ as ‘service provider’; Exclusionary part of the definition of “Service”; Reference to larger Bench; Decision to be revisited; Justice Delivery System; Role of Advocates; Independence of Judiciary; Relationship between an Advocate and his Client; International practices; Duty of advocates/lawyers towards the court.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2646 of 2009 From the Judgment and Order dated 06.08.2007 of the National Consumers Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi in RP No.1392 of 2006 With Civil Appeal Nos. 2647, 2648 and 2649 of 2009, Civil Appeal No. 6959 of 2011 and Civil Appeal No. 8214 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Guru Krishna Kumar, Narender Hooda, Manoj Swarup, Rakesh Tikku, V. Giri, Jaideep Gupta, Shekhar Naphade, Dr. Adish C. Aggarwala, Sukumar Pattjoshi, Arijit Prasad, Jayant Bhushan, Dinesh Kumar Goswami, S. Wasim Ahmed Quadri, Vikas Singh, Ramkrishna Viraragvan, Vivek Subba Reddy, V.K. Singh, Sr. Advs., Ashok Kumar Singh, Shantwanu Singh, Ms. Pragya Singh, Akshay Singh, Rahul Dubey, Daya Krishan Sharma, D K Sharma, Rohit Vats, Yashdeep, Akshay Amritanshu, Samyak Jain, Ayush Raj, Ankit Swarup, Neelmani Pant, Ms. Apoorva Singh, Rishi Bhargava, Ms. Yashvi Aswani, Jasbir Singh Malik, Ms. Chandni Sharma, Shaurya Lamba, Varun Punia, K. Maruthi Rao, Mrs. Anjani Aiyagari, Gaurav Yadava, Mohinder Jit Singh, Hardik Rupal, Satyam Aneja, Ms. Suveni Bhagat, Ms. Vishwaja Rao, Rahul Narang, Harshed Sundar, Nihar Dharmahikari, Shubham Rana, Piyush Goel, Mrs. Sunita Sharma, Ms. N. Annapoorani, Devvrat, Manoj K. Mishra, Snehashish Mukherjee, Ms. Rashmi Malhotra, Puneet Singh Bindra, Sachin Sharma, Ms. Harshita Sharma, Ms. Sachita Chawla, Ms. Swati Setia, Devesh Kumar Agnihotri, Rohit Pandey, Meenesh Kumar Dubey, Ms. Yugandhara Pawar Jha, Amrendra Kumar Singh, Vibhu Shanker Mishra, Kumar Gaurav, Shashank Shekhar, Vikas Gupta, [2024] 6 S.C.R. 493Bar of Indian Lawyers Through its President Jasbir Singh Malik v. D. K. Gandhi PS National Institute of Communicable Diseases and Anr. Pratap Venugopal, Chanchal Kumar Ganguli, Manish Goswami, Upendra Mishra, Ratnesh Kumar, Meghraj Singh, Pradeep Kumar Yadav, Pankaj Kumar, Pankaj Singh, Munawwar Naseem, Siddharth, Mukes Kumar, Subhendu Adikari, Siddharth Batra, Rhythm Katyal, Ms. Archna Yadav, Chinmay Dubey, Ms. Shivani Chawla, Pratyush Arora, Ashutosh Chugh, Rajesh Srivastava, Gaurav Verma, M/S. Krishna & Nishani Law Chambers, Anil C Nishani, H. M. Harish, Krishna M Singh, Nikhil Jain, Rajiv Kumar, K Krishna Kumar, Vishwesh R Murnal, P. Prasanna Kumar, Ajit Achappa, Kiran Kumar, Hitesh Kumar Sharma, S.K. Rajora, Akhileshwar Jha, Amit Kumar Chawla, Sandeep Singh Dhingra, Ms. Niharika Dewivedi, Ms. Priya Singh, Sanjay Singh, Ms. Kavita Singh, Advs. for the appearing parties. Petitioner-in-person Respondent-in-person Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Bela M. Trivedi, J.
1. An important question of law pertaining to the Legal Profession as a whole that has fallen for consideration before this Court is – whether a complaint alleging “deficiency in service” against Advocates practising Legal Profession, would be maintainable under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 as re-enacted in 2019? In other words, whether a “Service” hired or availed of an Advocate would fall within the definition of “Service” contained in the C.P. Act, 1986/2019, so as to bring him within the purview of the said Act?
2. The present set of Appeals emanate from the impugned order dated 06.08.2007 passed by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC), New Delhi in Revision Petition No.1392/2006, in which the NCDRC has held inter alia that if there was any deficiency in service rendered by the Advocates/Lawyers, a complaint under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (for short “CP Act, 1986”) would be maintainable.
FACTUAL MATRIX
3. The short facts in C.A. No.2649/2009, arising out of the impugned order passed by the NCDRC are that: - 494 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(i) The appellant is an Advocate by profession. The respondent Mr. D.K. Gandhi had hired the services of the appellant as an advocate for filing a Complaint in the Court of Metropolitan Magistrate, Tis Hazari Court, Delhi, against one Kamal Sharma under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, as the cheque for Rs.20,000/- issued by the said Kamal Sharma in favour of the respondent D.K. Gandhi was dishonoured.
(ii) During the course of the said complaint case, the accused Mr. Sharma agreed to pay the sum of Rs.20,000/- for the dishonoured cheque besides Rs.5,000/- as the expenses incurred by the complainant. It was alleged by the respondent (complainant) that though the appellant had received from the accused Mr. Sharma the DD/pay order for Rs.20,000/- and the crossed cheque of Rs.5,000/- on behalf of the respondent, the appellant did not deliver the same to the respondent and instead demanded Rs.5,000/- in cash from the respondent. The appellant also filed a suit for recovery of Rs.5,000/- in the court of Small Causes, Delhi raising a plea that the sum was due to him as his fees. Subsequently, the appellant gave the DD/pay order for Rs.20,000/- and cheque for Rs.5,000/- to the respondent, however, the payment of cheque for Rs.5,000/was stopped by the accused Mr. Sharma at the instance of the appellant. The respondent therefore filed a complaint before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, Delhi seeking compensation of Rs. 15,000/- in addition to the amount of cheque of Rs.5,000/-, as also Rs.10,000/- for the mental agony and harassment along with the cost. The appellant resisted the said complaint by filing a reply on 03.03.1998 raising a preliminary objection to the effect that the District Consumer Forum had no jurisdiction to adjudicate the dispute raised in the complaint as the Advocates were not covered under the provisions contained in the CP Act.
(iii) The District Forum, however, rejected the said preliminary objection, holding that it had the jurisdiction to adjudicate upon the dispute between the parties and further decided the complaint in favour of the respondent. The appellant being aggrieved by the said order had filed an appeal before the State Commission, which by the order dated 10.03.2006 allowed the [2024] 6 S.C.R. 495Bar of Indian Lawyers Through its President Jasbir Singh Malik v. D. K. Gandhi PS National Institute of Communicable Diseases and Anr. same holding that the services of lawyers/advocates did not fall within the ambit of “service” defined under section 2(1)(o) of the CP Act, 1986. The NCDRC, however in the Revision Application preferred by the respondent passed the impugned order as stated hereinabove.
(iv) Being aggrieved by the said impugned order passed by the NCDRC, the present set of appeals has been filed by the Bar of Indian Lawyers, Delhi High Court Bar Association, Bar Council of India, and by the appellant M. Mathias.
SUBMISSIONS
4. Since the issues involved in this batch of Appeals pertain to the Advocates practising in the various courts/tribunals and other legal forums of the country, a wide range of arguments were advanced before us. Having regard to the significance and sensitivity of the issues involved, we had appointed the learned Senior Advocate, Mr. V. Giri as an Amicus Curiae to assist the Court.
5. The broad submissions made by the learned Senior Counsels Mr. Narender Hooda, Mr. Guru Krishna Kumar, Mr. Manoj Swarup, Mr. Manan Mishra, Mr. Jaideep Gupta, Mr. Shekhar Naphade, Mr. Vikas Singh and learned counsel, Mr. D.K. Sharma may be summarized as under: -
(i) The Advocates Act, 1961 is a law dealing exclusively with the legal profession which provides a robust mechanism laying down professional standards for compliance and for determining professional misconduct.
(ii) The legal profession is a noble profession and not a business or trade. It is an extension of system of justice, and the success of judicial process depends on the independence of the Bar. Hence, its autonomy is needed to preserve the democracy and to keep judiciary strong.
(iii) A unique feature which distinguishes an Advocate from other professional is that an Advocate has a duty to the court and his peers, in addition to his duty to the client. He is not mere a mouthpiece but he has to exercise his own judgment for upholding the interest of his client by all fair, legal and reasonable means, and by being respectful to the court.
496 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(iv) The Bar Council of India and State Bar Councils are invested with the disciplinary powers. An error of judgment or mere negligence may not be a professional misconduct. In any case, the professional misconduct which subsumes cases of negligence, which is covered by the special law i.e., Advocates Act, 1961.
(v) The Advocates Act being special law would prevail over the CP Act so far as the conduct of Advocates are concerned.
(vi) The law of negligence recognizes that a professional would be held liable in a civil action for negligence and includes professionals of varied fields who possess special skill in that profession generally.
(vii) The legal professionals in United Kingdom can be sued for negligence by a way of regular civil action, however they would not be liable under the law dealing with consumer rights for trade/commercial activities.
(viii) Allowing consumer protection law to apply to the Advocates would open floodgates of unnecessary litigations and it would not be in the larger public interest to do so. It would also lead to multiple proceedings before multiple forums, reagitation of issues decided by a judicial body including the Supreme Court with potentially conflicting decisions.
(ix) The summary nature of proceeding under the consumer protection law with its accent on inexpensive and speedy remedy (though enacted with laudable objects for protection of consumers against trade and commercial activities), can become an easy tool for disgruntled litigants to knock at the doors of the consumer forums against the advocates. It would lead to speculative/vexatious claims, rather than seeking relief in respect of bona fide grievances against professional misconduct.
(x) The legal profession is recognized as sui generis and stands out among other profession due to its distinctive nature, where the lawyers often find themselves operating in an environment where control is elusive. Unlike many other professions where practitioners may have a higher degree of control over their [2024] 6 S.C.R. 497Bar of Indian Lawyers Through its President Jasbir Singh Malik v. D. K. Gandhi PS National Institute of Communicable Diseases and Anr. surroundings, the lawyers frequently navigate through complex legal landscapes shaped by diverse factors.
(xi) One of the primary distinctions of legal profession is the inherent complexity of legal issues. Lawyers must grapple with intricate statutes, case laws and regulatory frameworks, which often lack definitive answers. Legal disputes frequently involve multiple parties with conflicting interests, further complicating the matters. Unlike some other professions where problems may have more straightforward solutions, the lawyers often face ambiguity and uncertainty in their work, making control over outcomes elusive.
(xii) The adversarial dynamics have an element of unpredictability, as outcomes depend not only on the lawyer’s skill and knowledge but also on the strategies employed by opposing counsel and the decisions of judges.
(xiii) Lawyers are bound by ethical and professional obligations that constrain their autonomy and control over their work. Adherence to the codes of conduct, client confidentiality, and obligations to the court limit the freedom of lawyers to act solely in their own interest or according to their preferences.
(xiv) Unlike any other profession, where professionals are in control of their surrounding fully, legal profession is the sole profession, where advocates have no control over their environment. The environment they work in is controlled by the presiding Judge.
(xv) The Bar Council of India Rules prescribe at least four sets of duty that a lawyer has to oblige, viz., Duty to the Court, Duty to the Client, Duty to Opponent and Duty to Colleagues, in no particular order. These duties are sometimes conflicting in nature, however whenever a conflict arises, the duty to court is considered to be paramount.
(xvi) Unlike the medical profession, where scientific standards exist to decide the standard of care, there is no universal standard of care or objective test that exists or can be prescribed as the threshold in the case of legal profession to adjudicate upon the question of abdication of duty to care.
498 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(xvii) Distinguishing the decision of this Court in Indian Medical Association vs. V.P. Shantha & Others 1 , it was sought to be submitted that there is a fundamental difference between the practice of law and the practice of medicine, as also the difference in the nature of professional-client relationship. The complexity of legal issues, and the diversity of legal contexts also would take the legal services rendered by the Advocates outside the purview of the services defined under the CP Act.
6. The learned Senior Advocate Mr. V. Giri - Amicus Curiae, submitted that the Advocates can be broadly classified into two categories based on the terms of their engagement and the nature of work being done by them for their clients – (1) Advocates engaged by clients to conduct their cases and then represent them before any court, tribunal or other forum, on the strength of a vakalatnama and (2) Advocates engaged by clients to provide their professional expertise for providing legal opinions, issuing legal notices, drafting agreements, etc. He submitted that the first category of advocates would not come within the purview of a service provider under the CP Act, as in that case the advocate acts as a representative or agent of the client. He further submitted that it is open to a party to plead and appear in person in the court, however when he executes a vakalatnama, he chooses to engage an Advocate as his agent, and the acts and statements of the advocate, in the course of his duties in the matter, are like the acts and statements of the principal i.e., the client himself. Such relationship cannot be equated to that of a “service provider” and a “consumer” as contemplated in the CP Act. However, the Amicus Curiae Mr. Giri fairly submitted that in the second category of Advocates i.e., the Advocates who are engaged by the clients outside the precincts of the court and outside the litigation process i.e., who are not engaged on the strength of a vakalatnama but engaged to provide legal services outside the court process, would come within the purview of a service provider, and any deficiency or shortcoming in the professional services rendered by such Advocates, completely outside the confines of the litigation process, would be covered under the CP Act.
1 [1995] Supp. 5 SCR 110 : (1995) 6 SCC 651 [2024] 6 S.C.R. 499Bar of Indian Lawyers Through its President Jasbir Singh Malik v. D. K. Gandhi PS National Institute of Communicable Diseases and Anr.
ANALYSIS
7. Though the question posed before us is, whether a complaint alleging “deficiency in service” against Advocates practising Legal Profession, would be maintainable under the Consumer Protection Act, having regard to the entire spectrum and scheme of the said Act, following further questions stem from the said question, which deserve consideration.
(i) Whether the Legislature ever intended to include the Professions or services rendered by the Professionals within the purview of the CP Act 1986 as re-enacted in 2019?
(ii) Whether the Legal Profession is sui generis?
(iii) Whether a Service hired or availed of an Advocate could be said to be the service under “a contract of personal service” so as to exclude it from the definition of “Service” contained in Section 2 (42) of the CP Act 2019?
8. For adverting to the first question, whether the Legislature ever intended to include the Professions or the services rendered by the Professionals within the purview of the CP Act 1986 as re-enacted in 2019, it would be germane to ascertain the legislative intention and to look back to the history, object and purpose of enacting the CP Act 1986. A three-Judge Bench in case of State of Karnataka vs. Vishwabharathi House Building Coop. Society and Others2, while dealing with the issue raised about the constitutional validity of the CP Act 1986, had elaborately considered the history, objects and purpose of enacting the said Act.
“5. Before adverting to the question as regard the competence of Parliament to enact the said Act, we may notice the history of legislation leading to enactment of the said Act.
6. The Secretary General, United Nations submitted draft guidelines for consumer protection to the Economic and Social Council (UNESCO) in 1983. The General Assembly of the United Nations upon extensive discussions and 2 [2003] 1 SCR 397 : (2003) 2 SCC 412 500 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports negotiations among governments on this scope and content thereof adopted the guidelines which inter alia provide for the following:
“Taking into account the interests and needs of consumers in all countries, particularly those in developing countries, recognizing that consumers often face imbalances in economic terms, educational level, and bargaining power, and bearing in mind that consumer should have the right of access to non-hazardous products, as well as the importance of promoting just, equitable and sustainable economic and social development, these guidelines for consumer protection have the following objectives:
(a) To assist countries in achieving or maintaining adequate protection for their population as consumers.
(b) To facilitate production and distribution patterns responsive to the needs and desires of consumers.
(c) To encourage high levels of ethical conduct for those engaged in the production and distribution of goods and services to consumers.
(d) To assist countries in curbing abusive business practices by all enterprises at the national and international levels which adversely affect consumers.
(e) To facilitate the development of independent consumer groups.
(f) To further international cooperation in the field of consumer protection.
(g) To encourage the development of market conditions which provide consumers with greater choice at lower prices.”
7. The framework for the Consumer Act was provided by a resolution dated 9-4-1985 of the General Assembly of the United Nations Organisation. This is known as “Consumer Protection Resolution No. 39/248”. India is a signatory to the said Resolution.
[2024] 6 S.C.R. 501Bar of Indian L a w y e r s T h r o u g h i t s P r e s i d e n t J a s b i r Singh M a l i k v . D . K . G a n d h i P S National Institute o f Communicable D i s e a s e s a n d A n r .
8. The said Act was enacted having regard to the aforementioned Resolution.
9. It seeks to provide for better protection of the interests of consumers and for the said purpose, to make provision for the establishment of Consumer Councils and other authorities for the settlement of consumer disputes and for matters connected therewith, as would appear from the Statement of Objects and Reasons of the Act.
10. It further seeks inter alia to promote and protect the rights of consumers such as— "(a) The right to be protected against marketing of goods which are hazardous to life and property;
(b) the right to be informed about the quality, quantity, potency, purity, standard and price of goods to protect the consumer against unfair trade practices;
(c) the right to be assured, wherever possible, access to variety of goods at competitive prices;
(d) the right to be heard and to be assured that consumers’ interests will receive due consideration at appropriate forums;
(e) the right to seek redressal against unfair trade practice or unscrupulous exploitation of consumers; and
(f) right to consumer education.””
9. The scope and object of the said legislation had also come up for consideration before this Court in Common Cause, A Registered Society vs. Union of India and Others3 in which it was observed: - “2. The object of the legislation, as the Preamble of the Act proclaims, is “for better protection of the interests of consumers”. During the last few years preceding the enactment there was in this country a marked awareness among the consumers of goods that they were not getting their money’s worth and were being exploited by both 3 [1993] 1 SCR 10 : (1997) 10 SCC 729 502 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports traders and manufacturers of consumer goods. The need for consumer redressal fora was, therefore, increasingly felt. Understandably, therefore, legislation was introduced and enacted with considerable enthusiasm and fanfare as a path-breaking benevolent legislation intended to protect the consumer from exploitation by unscrupulous manufacturers and traders of consumer goods. A three-tier fora comprising the District Forum, the State Commission and the National Commission came to be envisaged under the Act for redressal of grievances of consumers….”
10. In Lucknow Development Authority vs. M.K. Gupta 4 , it was observed in paragraph 2 as under: - “2. ……To begin with the preamble of the Act, which can afford useful assistance to ascertain the legislative intention, it was enacted, ‘to provide for the protection of the interest of consumers. Use of the word ‘protection’ furnishes key to the minds of makers of the Act. Various definitions and provisions which elaborately attempt to achieve this objective have to be construed in this light without departing from the settled view that a preamble cannot control otherwise plain meaning of a provision. In fact the law meets long felt necessity of protecting the common man from such wrongs for which the remedy under ordinary law for various reasons has become illusory. Various legislations and regulations permitting the State to intervene and protect interest of the consumers have become a haven for unscrupulous ones as the enforcement machinery either does not move or it moves ineffectively, inefficiently and for reasons which are not necessary to be stated. The importance of the Act lies in promoting welfare of the society by enabling the consumer to participate directly in the market economy. It attempts to remove the helplessness of a consumer which he faces against powerful business, described as, ‘a network of rackets’ or a society in which, ‘producers have secured power’ to ‘rob the rest’ and the might of public bodies which are 4 [1993] Supp. 3 SCR 615 : (1994) 1 SCC 243 [2024] 6 S.C.R. 503Bar of Indian Lawyers Through its President Jasbir Singh Malik v. D. K. Gandhi PS National Institute of Communicable Diseases and Anr. degenerating into storehouses of inaction where papers do not move from one desk to another as a matter of duty and responsibility but for extraneous consideration leaving the common man helpless, bewildered and shocked.…..”
11. Yet in Laxmi Engineering Works vs. P.S.G. Industrial Institute5 , it was held in paragraph 10 as under: - “10. A review of the provisions of the Act discloses that the quasi-judicial bodies/authorities/agencies created by the Act known as District Forums, State Commissions and the National Commission are not courts though invested with some of the powers of a civil court. They are quasi-judicial tribunals brought into existence to render inexpensive and speedy remedies to consumers. It is equally clear that these forums/commissions were not supposed to supplant but supplement the existing judicial system. The idea was to provide an additional forum providing inexpensive and speedy resolution of disputes arising between consumers and suppliers of goods and services. The forum so created is uninhibited by the requirement of court fee or the formal procedures of a court. Any consumer can go and file a complaint. Complaint need not necessarily be filed by the complainant himself; any recognized consumers’ association can espouse his cause. Where a large number of consumers have a similar complaint, one or more can file a complaint on behalf of all. Even the Central Government and State Governments can act on his/their behalf. The idea was to help the consumers get justice and fair treatment in the matter of goods and services purchased and availed by them in a market dominated by large trading and manufacturing bodies.
Indeed, the entire Act revolves round the consumer and is designed to protect his interest. The Act provides for “business-to-consumer” disputes and not for “business-tobusiness” disputes. This scheme of the Act, in our opinion, is relevant to and helps in interpreting the words that fall for consideration in this appeal.”
5 [1995] 3 SCR 174 : (1995) 3 SCC 583 504 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
12. Thus, considering the intention of the Legislature, the objects and reasons of the Act of 1986 it was repeatedly held that the said Act was enacted to provide for the better protection of the interests of the consumers against their exploitation by the traders and manufacturers of the consumer goods, and to help consumers in getting justice and fair treatment in the matter of goods and services purchased and availed by them in a market dominated by large trading and manufacturing bodies.
13. After several years of passing of the CP Act 1986, still many shortcomings in the said Act were noticed while administering various provisions of the said Act. Hence, the CP Act 1986 was repealed and the CP Act, 2019 came to be re-enacted. The statement of objects and reasons for re-enacting the said Act of 2019 reads as under:- “1. The Consumer Protection Act, 1986 (68 of 1986) was enacted to provide for better protection of the interests of consumers and for the purpose of making provision for establishment of consumer protection councils and other authorities for the settlement of consumer disputes, etc. Although, the working of the consumer dispute redressal agencies has served the purpose to a considerable extent under the said Act, the disposal of cases has not been fast due to various constraints. Several shortcomings have been noticed while administering the various provisions of the said Act.
2. Consumer markets for goods and services have undergone drastic transformation since the enactment of the Consumer Protection Act in 1986. The modern market place contains a plethora of products and services. The emergence of global supply chains, rise in international trade and the rapid development of e-commerce have led to new delivery systems for goods and services and have provided new options and opportunities for consumers.
Equally, this has rendered the consumer vulnerable to new forms of unfair trade and unethical business practices. Misleading advertisements, tele- marketing, multi-level marketing, direct selling and e-commerce pose new challenges to consumer protection and will require [2024] 6 S.C.R. 505Bar of Indian L a w y e r s T h r o u g h i t s P r e s i d e n t J a s b i r Singh M a l i k v . D . K . G a n d h i P S National Institute o f Communicable D i s e a s e s a n d A n r . appropriate and swift executive interventions to prevent consumer detriment. Therefore, it has become inevitable to amend the Act to address the myriad and constantly emerging vulnerabilities of the consumers. In view of this, it is proposed to repeal and re-enact the Act.”
14. It is trite to say that a reference to statement of objects and reasons is permissible for understanding the background, the antecedent state of affairs, the surrounding circumstances in relation to the statute, and the evil which the statute had sought to remedy. * As discernible from the statement of objects and reasons for re-enacting the CP Act, 2019, there were certain shortcomings found in the CP Act 1986 while administering the said Act, and at the same time, due to the emergence of global supply chains, rise in international trade and rapid development of e-commerce leading to new systems for goods and services, new options and opportunities had become available to the consumers. However, new forms of unfair trade and unethical business practices also came to be developed, which made the consumers more vulnerable. Misleading advertisements, telemarketing, multi-level marketing, e-commerce posed new challenges, which necessitated the Legislature to re-enact the Act.
15. There was not a whisper in the statement of objects and reasons either of the CP Act, 1986 or 2019 to include the Professions or the Services provided by the Professionals like Advocates, Doctors etc. within the purview of the Act. It is very well accepted proposition of the fact that Professionals could not be called Businessmen or Traders, nor Clients or Patients be called Consumers. It is also required to be borne in mind that the terms ‘business’ or ‘trade’ having a commercial aspect involved, could not be used interchangeably with the term ‘Profession’ which normally would involve some branch of learning or science. Profession as such would require knowledge of an advanced type in a given field of learning or science, or learning gained by a prolonged course of specialized study. As per Black’s Law Dictionary, 11 th Edition, “Profession” means “a vocation requiring advanced education and training; especially one of the three traditional Professions- Law, Medicine and the Ministry.” “Professional” means “someone who * State of West Bengal vs. Subodh Gopal Bose & Others, AIR 1954 SC 92 506 [2024] 6 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports belongs to a learned profession or whose occupation requires a high level of training and proficiency.”
16. According to Rupert M. Jackson and John L. Powell,* the Occupations which are regarded as Professions have four characteristics, viz.,
(i) the nature of the work which is skilled and specialized and a substantial part is mental rather than manual;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.