New India Assurance Company Ltd. Through Its Manager v. M/S Tata Steel Ltd.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 356; [2024] 5 S.C.R. 285
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice K.V. Viswanathan
- Decided
- 30 Apr 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2759/2009
- Sections
- 64
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 5 S.C.R. 285 : 2024 INSC 356 New India Assurance Company Ltd.
Through its Manager v.
M/s Tata Steel Ltd.
(Civil Appeal No. 2759 of 2009)
30 April 2024 [Surya Kant and K.V. Viswanathan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration A claim for 35.08 crores was filed by the insured after the ‘20 Hi Cold Rolling Mill’ was totally destroyed due to fire. Since running of the company was important, the Insured got a new 6 Hi Cold Rolling Mill installed in its unit and commenced production. Admittedly, based on the interim report of the surveyors, a sum of Rs.4,92,80,905/was released in favour of the Insured by NIACL-insurer. Thereafter, the Insured gave consent for receiving Rs.20.95 Crores as net adjusted loss. However, the NIACL computed depreciation at 60% and settled the claim on 03.01.2003 stating the loss amount as Rs.7.88 Crores. The issues arising for consideration are as follows:
(i) Was the Reinstatement Value Clause part of the policy; (ii) Was NIACL justified in computing loss on depreciation basis and fixing depreciation at 60%; (iii) Is the Insured justified in claiming reinstatement value by placing reliance on the judgment in Oswal Plastic Industries.
Headnotes Insurance – Reinstatement value clause – Whether the memorandum consisting of the Reinstatement Value Clause was a part of the policy – The Insured contended that the memorandum containing the Reinstatement Value Clause was not part of the policy:
Held: The contention of the insured rejected – This is for the reason that before the NCDRC in the written statement filed by the NIACL it was specifically pleaded that copy of the fire policy was not attached with the Reinstatement Value Clause issued along with the policy, so the answering Respondent-insurer (NIACL) was filing the copy of the policy with complete terms and conditions and clauses along with the written statement – In the replication filed by the Insured, there was no denial of this averment. [Paras 31 and 32] 286 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Insurance – Computation of loss on depreciation basis – Was NIACL justified in computing loss on depreciation basis and fixing depreciation at 60%:
Held: It emerges clearly that under the main terms of the policy the company was to pay the Insured the value of the property at the time of happening of the destruction (except where NIACL opts to reinstate) – There was a special memorandum attached to the policy – That memorandum was the Reinstatement Value Clause which substituted the basis upon which the amount was payable from the value on the date of destruction to the cost of replacing or reinstating the property i.e. property of the same kind or type but not superior or more extensive than the insured property when new – However, as it transpires the said memorandum ceased to have any force since the Insured was unable and unwilling to replace or reinstate the property – Special Provision 4 (b) of the memorandum applied and rendered the Reinstatement Value Clause ineffective – Also, the Insured under Clause 6(b) of the conditions had an obligation to give NIACL all such further particulars, plans, specifications, books, vouchers and invoices with respect to the claim – It is sufficiently brought out that in spite of the surveyors writing to the Insured repeatedly (on 14.12.1998, 03.05.2002, 24.06.2002 and 07.08.2002), there was no information forthcoming from the Insured about the invoices as proof of the value of the damaged equipment and the cost of the new equipment – Instead, the insured originally undertook that they will reinstate the damaged property; received the on account payment of Rs.4,92,80,905/- and informed NIACL that they have placed order for repair of 20 Hi Cold Rolling Mill – Thereafter by their letter of 16.06.1999, the Insured sought assessment of net adjusted loss at Rs.20.95 Crores – The surveyors of NIACL kept asking for the basic and relevant particulars, the Insured without furnishing the same kept asking for the settlement of the money – NIACL did not completely repudiate the claim – NIACL cannot be faulted for resorting to depreciation method – NIACL was also justified in writing the letter of 12.11.2002 (to increase the depreciation to 60%) because after reviving the demand to reinstate the plant, the Insured failed to furnish the documents required and even admittedly the plant as allegedly reinstated was of 6 Hi Cold Rolling Plant and not 20 Hi Cold Rolling Plant – An additional affidavit was also filed by NIACL before NCDRC to clarify the established practice for computing depreciation – The base figure of Rs. 20.09 crores was kept intact – Insured stood to gain by keeping figure at Rs. 20.09 [2024] 5 S.C.R. 287New India Assurance Company Ltd. Through its Manager v. M/s Tata Steel Ltd.
crores – The depreciation at 60% upheld – Thus, the NIACL rightly ordered the settlement of the claim on 03.01.2003 stating the loss amount as Rs.7.88 Crores and ordering the balance amount of 2.88 crores be paid after adjusting the on account payment. [Paras 57, 58, 59, 66, 68, 69, 70, 71] Insurance – Is the Insured justified in claiming reinstatement value by placing reliance on the judgment in Oswal Plastic Industries:
Held: No clause similar to the memorandum of reinstatement value clause appears to have existed in Oswal Plastic Industries – Oswal Plastic Industries has no application to the facts of the present case. [Para 75] Case Law Cited Oswal Plastic Industries v. Manager, Legal Deptt N.A.I.C.O. Ltd. [2023] 1 SCR 985 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 43; Sri Venkateswara Syndicate v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. [2009] 14 SCR 57 : (2009) 8 SCC 507;
Dharmendra Goel v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. [2008] 11 SCR 578 : (2008) 8 SCC 279; Sumit Kumar Saha v. Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd. [2019] 1 SCR 763 : (2019) 16 SCC 370 – held inapplicable.
List of Acts Insurance Act, 1938; IRDA (Protection of Policyholders’ Interests) Regulations, 2002.
List of Keywords Insurance; Reinstatement value clause; Report of the surveyors; Net adjusted loss; Consumer Complaint; Depreciation; Computation of loss on depreciation basis; Cost of replacing or reinstating the property. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2759 of 2009 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.08.2008 of the National Consumers Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi in CC No. 233 of 2000 With Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 10001 of 2009 and Civil Appeal Nos. 5242-5243 of 2009 288 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Joy Basu, Sanjay Jain, Sr. Advs., Ms. Nandini Gore, Ms. Sonia Nigam, Akhil Abraham Roy, Mohammad Shahyan Khan, Arvind Thapliyal, Siddhant Grover, Surya Kapoor for M/S. Karanjawala & Co., Vishnu Mehra, Ms. Manjeet Chawla, Ms. Harshita Sukhija, Nishank Tripathi, Yuvraj Sharma, Ms. Palak Jain, Mrs. Manik Karanjawala, Mrs. Usha Pant Kukreti, Advs. for the appearing parties.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment K.V. Viswanathan, J.
1. Leave granted in SLP (Civil) No. 10001 of 2009.
2. I.A. No. 48152 of 2022 in Civil Appeal No. 2759 of 2009 is filed by the Respondent [earlier known as M/s Bhushan Steel and Strips Ltd, hereinafter referred to as the “Complainant” or the “Insured”] seeking change of its name in the proceedings to ‘Tata Steel Ltd’. The Complainant/Insured has filed similar IAs in the connected appeals filed by it. It is stated that the name of the Complainant/Insured was changed to ‘Bhushan Steel Ltd’ in the year 2007. Thereafter while these appeals were pending, the company underwent a Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process and was successfully taken over by ‘Tata Steel Ltd’ on 27.11.2018 and was renamed as ‘Tata Steel BSL Ltd’. Thereafter, it is seen that the Complainant/ Insured further underwent a merger/amalgamation and was finally merged/amalgamated with ‘Tata Steel Ltd’ w.e.f. 11.11.2021. In view of the said facts, all the applications for change of name are allowed.
3. These are four Civil Appeals arising out of the proceedings in Original Petition No. 233 of 2000 before the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi [“NCDRC”].
4. Civil Appeal No. 2759 of 2009 has been filed by the New India Assurance Company Limited [hereinafter referred to as “NIACL” or the “Insurer” or the “Insurance Company”] challenging the order dated 05.08.2008 of the NCDRC. By the said order, the NCDRC partly allowed the complaint of the Insured. The NCDRC awarded an amount of Rs.13,15,27,000/- with interest at 10% per annum from the expiry of two months since the submission of survey report dated [2024] 5 S.C.R. 289New India Assurance Company Ltd. Through its Manager v. M/s Tata Steel Ltd.
11.12.2001, payable to the Insured. The amount already paid by the Insurance Company was ordered to be adjusted and a cost of Rs. 50,000/- was also awarded to the Insured. NIACL, in this Appeal, is aggrieved with the finding that the Complainant’s claim must be settled, based on calculating depreciation at the rate of 32% - and not 60%.
5. The Civil Appeal arising out of SLP(Civil) No. 10001 of 2009 has been filed by the Insured/Complainant. The grievance here is against the dismissal of Misc. Application No. 298 of 2008 in Original Petition No. 233 of 2000 seeking review of the order dated 05.08.2008.
6. Civil Appeal Nos. 5242-5243 of 2009 have been filed by the Insured/ Complainant against the main order dated 05.08.2008 (passed in O.P. No. 233 of 2000) and order dated 29.08.2008 (allowing the application for rectification and correcting the figure awarded to Rs. 13,51,27,000/- instead of Rs. 13,15,27,000/-) respectively.
7. The grievance pleaded by the Insured/Complainant in its connected appeals is that the compensation awarded ought to have been greater because, according to it, the base figure on which the depreciation of 32% was computed should have been Rs.28 Crores and not Rs.20,09,95,000/-. The claim was that, so computing, the amount payable by NIACL should have been Rs. 18.91 Crores.
Brief Summary of Facts:
8. The Insured had taken an insurance policy from NIACL for the entire machinery and equipment of its mill by paying a premium of Rs.62,09,655/-. The policy was for the period 29.09.1998 to 28.09.1999. According to the Insured, due to a fire accident on 12.12.1998, the ‘20 Hi Cold Rolling Mill’ fitted with imported equipment was fully destroyed resulting in a loss of Rs. 35.08 crores. The incident of fire was intimated to NIACL on 12.12.1998 itself. Surveyors ‘M/s R.K. Singhal and Company Pvt. Ltd.’ and subsequently ‘M/s A.K. Govil and Associates’ and ‘M/s P.C. Gandhi’ were appointed by NIACL. A claim for Rs. 35.08 crores was filed on 29.01.1999. According to the Insured, this was based upon the quotations received from various manufacturers of the said machinery and the complete details of cost for replacing and/or repairing the machines.
290 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
9. The Insured also pleaded that since the running of the company was important, it got a 6 Hi Cold Rolling Mill installed in its unit and commenced production by spending Rs.29.60 crores apart from excise duties.
10. Admittedly, based on the interim report of the surveyors, a sum of Rs.4,92,80,905/- was released in favour of the Insured by NIACL on 24.03.1999. According to the Insured, after the release of the amount, it placed an order with ‘M/s Flat Products Equipments (India) Limited’ [“M/s Flat Products”] for reinstating the 20 Hi Cold Rolling machine by replacing the totally damaged and partially damaged parts for a total sum of Rs.25 crores, and paid Rs.3,75,00,000/- to M/s Flat Products by way of advance payment. Further, a sum of Rs.47.50 lacs on account of inspection charges of mill housing and Rs. 25 lacs for transportation of mill housing were also paid. According to the Insured, though it lost more than Rs. 25 crores, in view of the persistence from the Insurance Company, vide letter dated 16.06.1999, it gave consent for receiving Rs.20.95 Crores as net adjusted loss to avoid loss of time.
11. According to the Insured, since no response was forthcoming and the balance amount was not released, Consumer Complaint bearing Case No. 233 of 2000 was filed by the Insured before the NCDRC on 30.05.2000.
12. According to NIACL, after receipt of the information about the fire accident on 12.12.1998, NIACL immediately appointed the surveyors and soon thereafter, on the basis of the interim survey report, onaccount payments were made. The Joint Surveyors submitted their report on 11.12.2001. The vigilance complaints were also closed on 18.01.2002.
13. According to NIACL, it was only on 27.03.2002 that the Insured informed NIACL about the fact of having already installed a new 6 Hi Cold Rolling Mill and requested them for joint inspection with the surveyors. In the Joint Surveyors’ Report of 11.12.2001, the loss was assessed at Rs.19.55 crores on replacement basis and Rs.13.51 crores on depreciation basis. The surveyors, on 03.05.2002, requested the Complainant to furnish several information for which there was no response. It was contended by NIACL that the plea of the Insured in their letter of 27.03.2002 that it had placed an order for cold rolling mill on 11.01.1999 and the same was installed in [2024] 5 S.C.R. 291New India Assurance Company Ltd. Through its Manager v. M/s Tata Steel Ltd.
September-October, 1999 at the cost of Rs. 31.37 crores and the prayer that the replacement should be treated as reinstatement, is completely unacceptable. The machine installed is 6 Hi Cold Rolling as against the damaged mill which was 20 Hi Cold Rolling. According to NIACL, the claim has been rightly settled at Rs.7.88 Crores. Proceedings before the NCDRC:
14. Though several other points were argued before us by the Insured, the point canvassed before the NCDRC [and pleaded in the Insured’s connected Appeals] related only to the calculation of depreciation. The argument taken by the Insured before the NCDRC was that NIACL was not justified in computing depreciation at 60% while the surveyors in the reports had recommended 32% as depreciation. The NCDRC observed that the effort by the Insured to install a lesser capacity 6 Hi Cold Rolling Mill was an effort in desperation. It also found the claim to be genuine. Addressing the issue of depreciation, it held that after the initial recommendation in the Joint Surveyors’ Report dated 11.12.2001 of computing 32% depreciation, the surveyors were persuaded by the letter of the Insurance Company dated 12.11.2002 to increase the depreciation to 60%. An additional affidavit was called for from the NIACL to justify the depreciation at 60%. After perusing the affidavit, the NCDRC held that there were no standard guidelines for calculating depreciation and that it had been calculated differently for different units. According to the NCDRC, the affidavit quoted the instances of very high depreciation just to suit the convenience of NIACL. It may be mentioned that the affidavit relied on certain cases where depreciation was computed at a maximum rate up to 75% - 80%. The NCDRC held that the issuance of the letter of the Insurance Company to the Surveyors seeking revision of calculation was issued eleven months after the Joint Surveyors’ Report dated 11.12.2001 and that this was not a healthy practice. So holding, it maintained the depreciation at 32% and directed the payments as noted above. Appeal to this Court:
15. The appeal by NIACL seeks depreciation to be fixed at 60%. The Insured also in its appeals has focused only on the issue of depreciation with the argument being that the base figure on which 32% depreciation was calculated should have been Rs.28 crores and not Rs.20.09 crores. There are no other grounds raised in the memo of the appeal.
292 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
16. However, the Insured during the course of submission, while candidly admitting that no other point had been raised in the memo of appeal, relied on the judgment in Oswal Plastic Industries v. Manager, Legal Deptt N.A.I.C.O. Ltd., [2023 SCC OnLine SC 43] to contend that the reinstatement value should have been awarded in full and that in the case of reinstatement value no question of depreciation arises. This argument has been dealt with herein below at an appropriate stage. Contentions of NIACL:-
17. Appearing for NIACL, learned Senior Counsel Mr. Sanjay Jain contended that the insurance policy had a special condition in the form of Reinstatement Value Clause; that there are two methods of settlement of a claim depending on the nature of the policy, namely, the reinstatement value basis and market value basis (or depreciation basis); that under the Reinstatement Value Clause, the method of indemnity was to be the “cost of replacing or reinstating the same i.e. property of the same kind or type but not superior or more extensive than the insured property when new”; that the reinstatement was to be carried out by the Insured within 12 months or within such further extended time; that para 2 of the Special Provisions provided that until expenditure has been incurred by the Insured in replacing/ reinstating the damaged property, the Insurance Company shall not be liable to pay any amount in excess of the amount which would have been payable under the policy, if the said reinstatement clause had not been incorporated; para 4 of the Special Provisions provided that if the Insured expressed its intention to replace/reinstate the damaged property and the Insured is unable or unwilling to replace the damaged property on the same or another site, the reinstatement clause was to be rendered ineffective.
18. Adverting to the impugned judgment, learned Senior Counsel contended that the findings that (i) the insurer, out of sheer desperation, bought the 6 Hi configuration; (ii) the depreciation rate as calculated by the NIACL was erroneous; and (iii) NIACL’s letter to the surveyor asking for a revised calculation was not a healthy practice, are all erroneous findings which are completely untenable. According to learned Senior Counsel, the Insured in violation of the undertaking did not take any steps for reinstatement; that there was no delay on the part of the Insurance Company and in fact on account payment of Rs. 4,92,80,905/- had been released as early as [2024] 5 S.C.R. 293New India Assurance Company Ltd. Through its Manager v. M/s Tata Steel Ltd.
on 24.03.1999; that the NCDRC overlooked the fact that the Insured did not comeback to the Insurance Company with any information for about 08 months and only on 26.11.1999, followed by another letter of 10.02.2000 asked for extension of time limit for reinstatement of the insured property; that the same was accommodated by the NIACL and on 07.03.2000, an extension of 12 months was given and which time limit period was also not adhered to; that the Insured after receiving the interim payment claimed that Rs. 3.75 crores were advanced to M/s Flat Products and the said vendor neither repaired the insured property nor replaced the same; that nearly two years later on 28.06.2001, M/s Flat Products informed the Insured that they had lost their expertise and, as such, the delay could not be attributed to the NIACL; that the Insured informed the NIACL about having installed a 6 Hi Cold Rolling Mill (as against the insured property of 20 Hi Cold Rolling Mill), on 27.03.2002, without revealing the date of actual installation and without giving any comparable specification, which unilateral act cannot be termed as “an act of sheer desperation” as termed by the NCDRC.
19. It is submitted by the learned Senior Counsel that under the aforesaid circumstances, the Reinstatement Value Clause was rendered inoperative. However, the Insurance Company gave another opportunity to act in good faith and provide necessary specification and particulars, which were not provided for, in spite of the undertaking in the letter of 09.07.2002. Hence, by no stretch of imagination could the delay be attributable to the Insurance Company.
20. Insofar as the percentage of depreciation was concerned, it was contended that the NCDRC erroneously disregarded the affidavit filed by the Insurance Company clarifying the standard practice. On the finding about the practice adopted by the Insurance Company as “not being a healthy practice”, Mr. Sanjay Jain submitted that the NIACL gave ample opportunities to provide cogent material and it is only upon their failure to furnish the necessary documents, as obligated in the policy, that NIACL was constrained to settle the claim on market value basis by applying the necessary percentage of depreciation. It was contended that in the report of 11.12.2001, the joint surveyors, while arriving at the depreciation rate of 32%, did not have any material. Therefore, it was a prudent act on the part of the NIACL to arrive at a calculation on the basis of market value with the applicable rates of depreciation, after informing the 294 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports surveyors that the reinstatement method was not an option any longer. The learned Senior Counsel submitted that the claim was finally assessed by the surveyors, who in their survey report dated 07.12.2002 and after computing the balance life of ten years arrived at the depreciation rate of 60%. Hence, NIACL’s conduct in accepting that report could not be said to be arbitrary. It was argued that there was no disagreement on the surveyor’s report.
21. The learned Senior Counsel emphasized that even today, the Insured has no definite proof available with regard to the actual age of the mill and as to when it was procured from its vendor; or under what circumstances and condition the same was procured and other essential details. In this background, the assessment made by the surveyors, who are experts, could not be said to be illegal or untenable. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the recommendation of depreciation at 32% was at the stage when no material was forthcoming and was not supported by any cogent material and clarity on this aspect emerged only on the report of 07.12.2002. According to the learned Senior Counsel, ground (D) in Civil Appeal Nos.5242-5243 of 2009 records an admission of the Insured about the NCDRC rightly proceeding on depreciation basis.
22. Learned Senior Counsel submitted that there was no ambiguity and hence there is no room for the applicability of doctrine of contra proferentem. The survey report of 11.12.2001 was prepared at a premature stage with all relevant disclaimers. Alternatively, it was submitted that under Section 64 UM (2) of the Insurance Act, 1938, the NIACL was entitled to differ from the recommendation of the surveyor.
23. Learned Senior Counsel strongly refuted the reliance placed in the convenience compilation, by the Insured on the judgment in Oswal Plastic Industries (supra). Learned Senior Counsel contended that Oswal Plastic Industries (supra) was not a case with the Reinstatement Value Clause as a special condition. Learned Senior Counsel contended that unlike in Oswal Plastic Industries (supra), Clause 9 had no application to the facts of the present case. That in any event documents were not provided by the Insured to NIACL. Dealing with Regulation 9(3) of the IRDA (Protection of Policyholders’ Interests) Regulations, 2002 [“IRDA Regulations”], learned Senior Counsel submitted that the joint surveyors report dated 07.12.2002 was for all intents and purposes the original surveyors report and as [2024] 5 S.C.R. 295New India Assurance Company Ltd. Through its Manager v. M/s Tata Steel Ltd.
such Regulation 9(3) assuming it to be mandatory had no application. Alternatively, it was contended that Regulation 9(3) is only directory.
24. Insofar as the cross appeal is concerned, the learned Senior Counsel contended that the claim for the base figure as Rs. 28 crores is absolutely unjustified, there being no cogent material to support the same. In fact, the stand of the Insured was that its vendor M/s Flat Products had expressed its inability due to loss of expertise and the same was conveyed two years after receiving the advance. For all these reasons, the learned Senior Counsel prayed that the appeal of NIACL be allowed and the appeals of the Insured be dismissed. Contentions of the Insured/Complainant: -
25. Mr. Joy Basu, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Insured, at the very outset, contended that the memorandum containing the Reinstatement Value Clause was never part of the policy document issued by the NIACL. This memorandum, according to the learned senior counsel, was never received by the Insured. Without prejudice to the same, it is contended that Clause 9 of the conditions in the policy has to be read in conjunction with the Reinstatement Value Clause. Since, as per para 4, the Reinstatement Value Clause got extinguished, Clause 9 of the conditions became applicable.
26. Learned Senior Counsel submitted that in terms of Clause 9 where reinstatement/repair is not possible, the surveyor’s assessment of reinstatement has to be complied with. Learned senior counsel relied on the judgment in Oswal Plastic Industries (supra). Learned Senior Counsel contended that the interpretation of Clause 9 was laid down only by the Oswal Plastic Industries (supra) judgment in January, 2023 and as such the Insured should be allowed to canvass the argument based on Oswal Plastic Industries (supra). According to learned Senior Counsel, the inability/failure to reinstate as contemplated in the last part of the Clause 9 is the failure of the NIACL. Learned Senior Counsel further contended that it is only with the hope of an expedited settlement that the Insured accepted the lower figure of Rs. 20.95 Crores. Calculating on reinstatement basis, the surveyors in their report of 11.12.2001 arrived at the figure of Rs. 19.55 crores without application of any depreciation. According to the Insured, the amount further due is Rs.11,80,87,699/-.
296 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
27. Alternatively, it is submitted by the learned Senior Counsel that even if the market value basis is to be applied, depreciation has to be calculated on the sum insured of Rs. 80 crores. To support this plea, learned Senior Counsel relied on Dharmendra Goel vs. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. (2008) 8 SCC 279. Further, without prejudice, it is contended that if depreciation was not to be calculated on the sum insured, then the depreciation has to be calculated on the cost of the new locally sourced 20 Hi Cold Rolling Machine which would cost Rs. 25 crores plus taxes totaling Rs 28 crores. Further, it is contended that the depreciation rate was 32% as mentioned by the surveyors in their report of 11.12.2001 and NIACL has not adduced any reasons for deviating from the recommendation of the surveyors. Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the surveyor’s response of 07.12.2002 was “a reluctant response from an embarrassed surveyor” to the letter of NIACL dated 12.01.2002 which, according to the learned senior counsel, was a letter by the insurer asking the surveyors to compute maximum depreciation. In any event, according to the learned Senior Counsel, the doctrine of contra proferentem applied and the interpretation in favour of the Insured should have been adopted. It was argued that there was a breach of Regulation 9(3) of the IRDA Regulations. So contending, the learned senior counsel prayed that the appeal of NIACL be dismissed and the cross appeals of the Insured be allowed.
Questions before this Court:
28. In the above background, the questions that arise for consideration are as follows:
i. Was the Reinstatement Value Clause part of the policy? ii. Was NIACL justified in computing loss on depreciation basis and fixing depreciation at 60%?
iii. Is the Insured justified in claiming reinstatement value by placing reliance on the judgment in Oswal Plastic Industries (supra)? iv. To what reliefs are the parties entitled?
Discussion and Reasons:
29. At the outset, it is important to set out the crucial clauses of the policy in question.
[2024] 5 S.C.R. 297New India Assurance Company Ltd. Through its Manager v. M/s Tata Steel Ltd.
Fire Policy “C”
In consideration of the insured name in the schedule hereto having paid to the New India Assurance Company Limited (hereinafter called the company)
the premium mentioned in the said schedule. THE COMPANY AGREES (subject to the Condition and Exclusions contained herein or endorsed or otherwise expressed hereon) that it after payment of the premium the property Insured described in the said schedule or any part of such property, be destroyed or damaged by:
1. Fire ……
6. ….. During the period of Insurance named in the said schedule or of any subsequent period in respect of which the insured shall have paid and the Company shall have accepted the premium required for the renewal of the policy the Company will pay to the insured the value of the property at the time of the happening of its destruction or the amount of such damage or at its opinion reinstate or replace such property or any part thereof.
Conditions ……
6. (i) On the happening of any loss or damage the insured shall forthwith give notice thereof to the company and shall within 15 days after the loss or damage or such further time as the Company may in writing allow in that behalf, deliver to the company;
a. A claim in writing for the loss or damage containing as particular an account as may be reasonably practicable of all the several articles or items or property damaged or destroyed, and of the amount of the loss or damage thereto respectively, having regard to their value at the time of the loss or, b. Particular of all other insurance, if any:
298 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports The insured shall also at all times at his own expense produce, procure and give to the company all such further particulars, plans, specifications, books, vouchers, invoices, duplicates or copies thereof, documents investigation reports (internal/external), proof and information with respect to the claim and the origin and cause of the insured perils and the circumstances under which the loss or damage occurred, and any matter touching the liability or the amount of the liability of the Company as may be reasonably required by or on behalf of the Company together with a declaration on Oath or in other legal form of the truth of the claim and of any matter connected therewith.
No claim under this policy shall be payable unless the terms of this condition have been complied with.
30. Two other important clauses viz., Clause 9 of the Conditions and the memorandum containing the Reinstatement Value Clause are extracted below at the appropriate place in the discussion. Answer to Question No (i) :-
31. There was a debate at the Bar as to whether the memorandum consisting of the Reinstatement Value Clause (extracted later in the judgment) was a part of the policy. The argument was raised by senior counsel for the Insured who contended that the memorandum containing the Reinstatement Value Clause was not part of the policy. We reject this contention at the outset. This is for the reason that before the NCDRC in the written statement filed by the NIACL, in para 3, it was specifically pleaded as under:
“The copy of the fire policy at pages 13 to 22 is a true copy of the policy issued by the Respondent. However, the Reinstatement Value Clause issued along with the policy is not attached to the same. The answering Respondent is filing herewith the copy of the policy with complete terms and conditions and clauses as Annexure R-1 to this written Statement.”
32. In the replication filed by the Insured, there was no denial of this averment. Hence, we reject the contention of the Insured that the [2024] 5 S.C.R. 299New India Assurance Company Ltd. Through its Manager v. M/s Tata Steel Ltd.
memorandum of the Reinstatement Value Clause was not the part of the policy. There are other factors which establish that the Reinstatement Value Clause was part of the Policy. They are discussed hereinbelow. Issue (i), set out above, is answered in favor of NIACL.
Discussion of Question No. (ii) :-
33. Coming back to the clauses in the insurance policy, it will be seen that the assurance in the opening clause of the policy was that NIACL will pay to the Insured the value of the property at the time of the happening of its destruction OR the amount of such damage OR at its option, reinstate or replace such property or any part thereof. In the conditions, it was incorporated that the Insured was at all times at its own expense to produce, procure and give to NIACL all such further particulars, plans, specifications, books, vouchers, invoices, duplicates or copies thereof, documents, investigation reports (internal/external), proof and information with respect to the claim and all matters provided for in Clause 6. It is also stipulated that no claim under this policy was payable unless the terms of this condition was complied with.
34. Clause 9 of the Conditions states that if NIACL, at its option, reinstate or replace the property damaged or destroyed, or any part thereof, instead of paying the amount of loss or damage, or join with any other company or Insurance in so doing, NIACL shall not be bound to reinstate exactly or completely but only as circumstances permit and in reasonably sufficient manner, and in no case shall NIACL be bound to spend more in reinstatement than it would have cost to reinstate such property as it was at the time of occurrence of such loss or damage nor more than the sum insured by the Company thereon. Clause 9 reads as follows:
“9. If the company at its option, reinstate or replace the property damaged or destroyed, or any part thereof, instead of paying the amount of the loss or damage, or join with any other company or insurance, in so doing, the company shall not be bound to reinstate exactly or completely but only as circumstances permit and in reasonably sufficient manner and in no case shall the company be bound to spend more in reinstatement than it would have cost to reinstate such property as it was at the time of the 300 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports occurrence of such loss or damage nor more than the sum insured by the Company thereon, If the Company so elect to reinstate or replace an property the insured shall at his own expense furnish the company with such plans, specifications, measurements, quantities and such other particulars as the company may require, and no acts done, or caused to be done, by the company with a view to reinstatement or replacement shall be deemed an election by the Company to reinstate or replace.
If in any case the Company shall be unable to reinstate or repair the property hereby insured, because of any municipal or other regulations in force affecting the alignment of streets or the construction of buildings or otherwise, the Company shall, in every such case, only be liable to pay such sum as would be requisite to reinstate or repair such property if the same could lawfully be reinstated to its former condition.”
35. To the policy is attached the memorandum of the Reinstatement Value Clause which reads as follows:
REINSTATEMENT VALUE CLAUSE
Attached to and forming part of policy No.
It is hereby declared and agreed that in the event of the property Insured under (Items Nos. of ) the within policy being destroyed or damaged, the basis upon which the amount payable under each of the said items of the policy is to be calculated, shall be the cost of replacing or reinstating on the same, i.e. property of the same kind or type but not superior or more extensive than the insured property when new subject to the following Special Provisions and subject also to the terms and conditions of the policy except manner as the same may be varied hereby.
SPECIAL PROVISIONS
1. The work of the replacement or reinstatement (which may be carried out upon another site and in any manner suitable to the requirements of the insured [2024] 5 S.C.R. 301New India Assurance Company Ltd. Through its Manager v. M/s Tata Steel Ltd.
subject to the liability of the Company not being thereby increased) must be commenced and carried out with reasonable dispatch and in any case must be completed within 12 months after the destruction or damage or within such further time as the company may (during the said 12 months) in writing allow;
otherwise no payment beyond the amount which would have been payable under the policy if this memorandum had not been incorporated therein shall be made.
2. Until expenditure has been incurred by the Insured in replacing or reinstating the property destroyed or damaged the company shall not be liable for any payment in excess of the amount which would have been payable under the policy if this memorandum had not been incorporated therein.
3. If at the time of replacement or reinstatement the sum representing the cost which would have been incurred in replacement or reinstatement if the whole of the property covered had been destroyed exceeds the sum insured thereon at the breaking out of any fire or at the commencement of any destruction of or damage to such property by any other peril insured against by this policy, then the Insured shall be considered as being his own insurer for the excess and shall bear a rateable proportion of the loss accordingly. Each item of the policy (it more than one) to which this Memorandum applies shall be separately subject to the foregoing provision.
4. This Memorandum shall be without force or effect if:
(a) The Insured fails to intimate to the company within 6 months from the date of destruction or damage or such further time as the Company may in writing allow, his intention to replace or reinstate the property destroyed or damaged.
(b) The Insured is unable or unwilling to replace or reinstate the property destroyed or damaged on the same or another site.
302 [2024] 5 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
36. The memorandum of the Reinstatement Value Clause stipulates that it was declared and agreed that in the event of the property Insured under the policy being destroyed or damaged, a. The basis upon which the amount payable under each of the said items of the policy is to be calculated, shall be the cost of replacing or reinstating on the same, i.e. property of the same kind or type but not superior or more extensive than the insured property when new subject to the following Special Provisions and subject also to the terms and conditions of the policy except manner as the same may be varied hereby.
b. The Special Provisions stipulate that the work of the replacement or reinstatement must be commenced and carried out with reasonable dispatch and in any case must be completed within 12 months after the destruction or damage or within such further time as the company may (during the said 12 months) in writing allow; otherwise no payment beyond the amount which would have been payable under the policy if this memorandum had not been incorporated therein shall be made.
c. Until expenditure has been incurred by the insured in replacing the property destroyed or damaged, the company shall not be liable for any payment in excess of the amount which would have been payable under the policy if this memorandum had not been incorporated therein.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.