High Court Bar Association, Allahabad v. State of U.P. & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 150; [2024] 2 S.C.R. 946
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 5 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice Pankaj Mithal, Justice Manoj Misra
- Decided
- 29 Feb 2024
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 3589/2023
- Sections
- 254, 482, 309
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 2 S.C.R. 946 : 2024 INSC 150 High Court Bar Association, Allahabad v.
State of U.P. & Ors.
Criminal Appeal No. 3589 of 2023 29 February 2024 [Dr Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI, Abhay S. Oka,* J. B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra and Pankaj Mithal,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration What is the object behind passing interim orders; Whether the High Courts are empowered to vacate or modify interim relief; Whether an interim order can come to an end automatically only due to the lapse of time; What is the scope of exercise of powers u/Art. 142 of the Constitution; Position of the High Courts and its power of superintendence; Whether the Court should deal with an issue not arising for consideration; Effect of directions issued by the Constitutional Courts to decide pending cases in a timebound manner; Whether the Supreme Court, in the exercise of its jurisdiction u/Art. 142 of the Constitution of India, can order automatic vacation of all interim orders of the High Courts of staying proceedings of Civil and Criminal cases on the expiry of a certain period; Whether the Supreme Court, in the exercise of its jurisdiction u/Art. 142 of the Constitution of India, can direct the High Courts to decide pending cases in which interim orders of stay of proceedings has been granted on a day-to-day basis and within a fixed period; Procedure to be adopted by High Courts while passing interim order of stay of proceedings and for dealing with the applications for vacating interim stay.
Headnotes Interim Orders – Object of:
Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) An order of interim relief is usually granted in the aid of the final relief sought in the case – An occasion for passing an order of stay of the proceedings normally arises when the High Court is dealing with a challenge to an interim or interlocutory order passed during the pendency of the main case before a trial or appellate Court – The High Court can grant relief of the stay of hearing of the main [2024] 2 S.C.R. 947High Court B a r A s s o c i a t i o n , A l l a h a b a d v . State o f U .P. & O r s . proceedings on being satisfied that a prima facie case is made out and that the failure to stay the proceedings before the concerned Court in all probability may render the remedy adopted infructuous – When the High Court passes an interim order of stay, though the interim order may not expressly say so, the three factors, viz; prima facie case, irreparable loss, and balance of convenience, are always in the back of the judges’ minds – Though interim orders of stay of proceedings cannot be routinely passed as a matter of course, it cannot be said that such orders can be passed only in exceptional cases – Nevertheless, the High Courts, while passing orders of stay in serious cases like the offences under the PC Act or serious offences against women and children, must be more cautious and circumspect. [Para 13] Interim Orders – Whether the High Courts are empowered to vacate or modify interim relief:
Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) The High Courts are always empowered to vacate or modify an order of interim relief passed after hearing the parties on the following, amongst other grounds: - (a)If a litigant, after getting an order of stay, deliberately prolongs the proceedings either by seeking adjournments on unwarranted grounds or by remaining absent when the main case in which interim relief is granted is called out for hearing before the High Court with the object of taking undue advantage of the order of stay; (b)The High Court finds that the order of interim relief is granted as a result of either suppression or misrepresentation of material facts by the party in whose favour the interim order of stay has been made; and (c) The High Court finds that there is a material change in circumstances requiring interference with the interim order passed earlier – In a given case, a long passage of time may bring about a material change in circumstances – These grounds are not exhaustive – There can be other valid grounds for vacating an order of stay. [Para 15] Interim Orders – Whether an interim order can come to an end automatically only due to the lapse of time:
Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) Elementary principles of natural justice, which are well recognised in jurisprudence, mandate that an order of vacating interim relief or modification of the interim relief is passed only after hearing all 948 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the affected parties – An order of vacating interim relief passed without hearing the beneficiary of the order is against the basic tenets of justice – Application of mind is an essential part of any decision-making process – Therefore, without application of mind, an order of interim stay cannot be vacated only on the ground of lapse of time when the litigant is not responsible for the delay – An interim order lawfully passed by a Court after hearing all contesting parties is not rendered illegal only due to the long passage of time. [Para 16] Constitution of India – What is the scope of exercise of powers u/Art. 142 of the Constitution:
Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) Important parameters for the exercise of the jurisdiction u/Art. 142 of the Constitution of India which are relevant for deciding the reference are as follows: (i) The jurisdiction can be exercised to do complete justice between the parties before the Court – It cannot be exercised to nullify the benefits derived by a large number of litigants based on judicial orders validly passed in their favour who are not parties to the proceedings before this Court; (ii) Article 142 does not empower this Court to ignore the substantive rights of the litigants;
(iii) While exercising the jurisdiction u/Art. 142 of the Constitution of India, this Court can always issue procedural directions to the Courts for streamlining procedural aspects and ironing out the creases in the procedural laws to ensure expeditious and timely disposal of cases – However, while doing so, this Court cannot affect the substantive rights of those litigants who are not parties to the case before it – The right to be heard before an adverse order is passed is not a matter of procedure but a substantive right; and (iv) The power of this Court u/Art. 142 cannot be exercised to defeat the principles of natural justice, which are an integral part of jurisprudence. [Para 37] Constitution of India – Position of the High Courts and its power of superintendence:
Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) A High Court is also a constitutional Court – It is well settled that it is not judicially subordinate to the Supreme Court – A High Court is constitutionally independent of the Supreme Court of India – The power of the High Court u/Art. 227 of the Constitution to have [2024] 2 S.C.R. 949High Court B a r A s s o c i a t i o n , A l l a h a b a d v . State o f U .P. & O r s . judicial superintendence over all the Courts within its jurisdiction will include the power to stay the proceedings before such Courts – By a blanket direction in the exercise of power u/Art. 142 of the Constitution of India, the Supreme Court cannot interfere with the jurisdiction conferred on the High Court of granting interim relief by limiting its jurisdiction to pass interim orders valid only for six months at a time – Putting such constraints on the power of the High Court will also amount to making a dent on the jurisdiction of the High Courts u/Art. 226 of the Constitution, which is an essential feature that forms part of the basic structure of the Constitution. [Paras 23 and 24] Practice and Procedure – Whether the Court should deal with an issue not arising for consideration:
Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) In the case of Sanjeev Coke Manufacturing Company, a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court held that (Judges) are not authorised to make disembodied pronouncements on serious and cloudy issues of constitutional policy without battle lines being properly drawn – Judicial pronouncements cannot be immaculate legal conceptions – It is but right that no important point of law should be decided without a proper lis between parties properly ranged on either side and a crossing of the swords – It is inexpedient for the Supreme Court to delve into problems which do not arise and express opinion thereon. [Para 25] Constitution of India – Art. 226 (3) – Making of an application for vacating interim relief:
Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) On its plain reading, clause (3) is applicable only when an interim relief is granted without furnishing a copy of the writ petition along with supporting documents to the opposite party and without hearing the opposite party – Even assuming that clause (3) is not directory, it provides for an automatic vacation of interim relief only if the aggrieved party makes an application for vacating the interim relief and when the application for vacating stay is not heard within the time specified – Clause (3) will not apply when an interim order in a writ petition u/Art. 226 is passed after the service of a copy of the writ petition on all concerned parties and after giving them an opportunity of being heard – It applies only to ex-parte ad interim 950 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports orders. [Para 26] Per Pankaj Mithal, J. (concurring) It is noticeable that u/Art. 226(3) of the Constitution of India, the automatic vacation of the stay order envisages making of an application to the High Court for the vacation of the interim stay order – Therefore, filing of an application for vacating the stay order is a sine qua non for triggering the automatic vacation of the stay order u/Art. 226(3) if such an application is not decided within the time prescribed of two weeks. [Para 6] Directions by Supreme Court – Effect of directions issued by the Constitutional Courts to decide pending cases in a timebound manner – The three Judges Bench of the Supreme Court issued various directions in Asian Resurfacing – The net effect of the directions issued in paragraphs 36 and 37 of Asian Resurfacing is that the petition in which the High Court has granted a stay of the proceedings of the trial, must be decided within a maximum period of six months – If it is not decided within six months, the interim stay will be vacated automatically, virtually making the pending case infructuous: Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) The Constitution Benches of the Supreme Court have considered the issue of fixing timelines for the disposal of cases in the cases of Abdul Rehman Antulay and P. Ramachandra Rao – The principles laid down in the decision will apply even to civil cases before the trial courts – The same principles will also apply to a direction issued to the High Courts to decide cases on a day-to-day basis or within a specific time – Thus, the directions of the Court that provide for automatic vacation of the order of stay and the disposal of all cases in which a stay has been granted on a day-to-day basis virtually amount to judicial legislation – The jurisdiction of this Court cannot be exercised to make such a judicial legislation – Only the legislature can provide that cases of a particular category should be decided within a specific time – There are many statutes which incorporate such provisions – However, all such provisions are usually held to be directory – A judicial notice will have to be taken of the fact that in all the High Courts of larger strength having jurisdiction over larger States, the daily cause lists of individual Benches of the cases of the aforesaid categories are of more than a hundred matters – Therefore, once a case is entertained by the High Court and the stay is granted, the case has a long life – The High Courts cannot be expected to [2024] 2 S.C.R. 951High Court B a r A s s o c i a t i o n , A l l a h a b a d v . State o f U .P. & O r s . decide, on a priority basis or a day-to-day basis, only those cases in which a stay of proceedings has been granted while ignoring several other categories of cases that may require more priority to be given – Therefore, constitutional Courts should not normally fix a time-bound schedule for disposal of cases pending in any Court – The pattern of pendency of various categories of cases pending in every Court, including High Courts, is different – The situation at the grassroots level is better known to the judges of the concerned Courts – Therefore, the issue of giving out-of turn priority to certain cases should be best left to the concerned Courts – The orders fixing the outer limit for the disposal of cases should be passed only in exceptional circumstances to meet extraordinary situations. [Paras 28, 29, 30, 32, 33] Constitution of India – Interim Orders – (i) Whether the Supreme Court, in the exercise of its jurisdiction u/Art. 142 of the Constitution of India, can order automatic vacation of all interim orders of the High Courts of staying proceedings of Civil and Criminal cases on the expiry of a certain period; (ii) Whether the Supreme Court, in the exercise of its jurisdiction u/Art. 142 of the Constitution of India, can direct the High Courts to decide pending cases in which interim orders of stay of proceedings has been granted on a day-to-day basis and within a fixed period:
Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) The three Judges Bench of the Supreme Court decided the case of Asian Resurfacing and issued directions in paragraphs 36 and 37 – The direction issued in paragraph 36 was regarding automatic vacation of stay and direction in paragragh 37 was for conducting day-to-day hearing within a time frame – The present Bench of the Judges does not concur with the three judges Bench which decided the case of Asian Resurfacing and issued directions in paragraphs 36 and 37 – Both directions were issued in the exercise of jurisdiction u/Art.142 of the Constitution – There cannot be automatic vacation of stay granted by the High Court – The direction issued (in the case of Asian Resurfacing) to decide all the cases in which an interim stay has been granted on a day-to-day basis within a time frame is also not approved – Blanket directions cannot be issued in the exercise of the jurisdiction u/Art. 142 of the Constitution of India – Both the questions framed above are answered in the negative. [Paras 12, 36] 952 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Interim Orders – Stay order cannot be automatically vacated: Held: Per Pankaj Mithal, J. (concurring): The stay order granted in any proceedings would not automatically stand vacated on the expiry of a particular period until and unless an application to that effect has been filed by the other side and is decided following the principles of natural justice by a speaking order – It is expedient in the interest of justice to provide that a reasoned stay order once granted in any civil or criminal proceedings, if not specified to be time bound, would remain in operation till the decision of the main matter or until and unless an application is moved for its vacation and a speaking order is passed adhering to the principles of natural justice either extending, modifying, varying or vacating the same. [Paras 7 and 8] Practice and Procedure – Procedure to be adopted by High Courts while passing interim order of stay of proceedings and for dealing with the applications for vacating interim stay: Held: (Per Abhay S. Oka, J. for himself and Dr. Dhananjaya Y. Chandrachud, CJI., J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, JJ.) To avoid any prejudice to the opposite parties, while granting ex-parte adinterim relief without hearing the affected parties, the High Courts should normally grant ad-interim relief for a limited duration – After hearing the contesting parties, the Court may or may not confirm the earlier ad-interim order – Ad-interim relief, once granted, can be vacated or affirmed only after application of mind by the concerned Court – Hence, the Courts must give necessary priority to the hearing of the prayer for interim relief where adinterim relief has been granted – Though the High Court is not expected to record detailed reasons while dealing with the prayer for the grant of stay or interim relief, the order must give sufficient indication of the application of mind to the relevant factors – An interim order passed after hearing the contesting parties cannot be vacated by the High Court without giving sufficient opportunity of being heard to the party whose prayer for interim relief has been granted – Even if interim relief is granted after hearing both sides, as observed earlier, the aggrieved party is not precluded from applying for vacating the same on the available grounds – In such a case, the High Court must give necessary priority to the hearing of applications for vacating the stay, if the main case cannot be immediately taken up for hearing – Applications for vacating interim reliefs cannot be kept pending for an inordinately long time. [Paras 34 and 35] [2024] 2 S.C.R. 953High Court Bar Association, Allahabad v. State of U.P. & Ors. Case Law Cited Asian Resurfacing of Road Agency Private Limited & Anr. v. Central Bureau of Investigation, [2018] 2 SCR 1045 : (2018) 16 SCC 299 – Reconsidered.
Prem Chand Garg & Anr. v. The Excise Commissioner, U.P. and Ors., [1963] Suppl. 1 SCR 885 : (1962)
SCC Online SC 37; Supreme Court Bar Association v. Union of India & Anr., [1998] 2 SCR 795 : (1998) 4 SCC 409; L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India & Ors., [1997] 2 SCR 1186 : (1997) 3 SCC 261; Sanjeev Coke Manufacturing Company v. M/s. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd.
& Anr, [1983] 1 SCR 1000 : (1983) 1 SCC 147; Abdul Rehman Antulay & Ors. v. R.S. Nayak & Anr, [1991] Suppl. 3 SCR 325 : (1992) 1 SCC 225; P. Ramachandra Rao v. State of Karnataka, [2002] 3 SCR 60 : (2002) 4 SCC 578 – followed.
Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr. v. Pepsi Foods Limited, [2021] 4 SCR 1 : (2021) 7 SCC 413;
Tirupati Balaji Developers (P) Ltd. & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Ors., [2004] Suppl. 1 SCR 494 : (2004) 5 SCC 1 – relied on.
Mohan Lal Magan Lal Thacker v. State of Gujarat, [1968] 2 SCR 685 : AIR 1968 SC 733; Raza Buland Sugar Co. Ltd. v. Municipal Board, Rampur, [1965] 1 SCR 970 : AIR 1965 SC 895; Kailash v. Nanhku & Ors, [2005] 3 SCR 289 : (2005) 4 SCC 480; Deoraj v. State of Maharashtra & Ors., [2004] 3 SCR 920 : (2004) 4 SCC 697; All India Judges’ Association & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors., [2002] 2 SCR 712 : (2002) 4 SCC 247;
Imtiyaz Ahmed v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors., [2017] 1 SCR 305 : (2017) 3 SCC 658 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978; Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988; Income Tax Act, 1961. List of Keywords Interim orders; Vacation or modification of interim relief; Automatic end of interim relief; Lapse of time; Enforcement of decrees and orders of Supreme Court and orders as to 954 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports discovery, etc; Interim orders of the High Courts; Interim orders of stay of proceedings; Day-to-day basis hearing; Position of the High Courts; High Court’s power of superintendence; Issue not arising for consideration; Deciding pending cases in a timebound manner; Effect of directions issued by the Constitutional Courts; Procedure to be adopted by High Courts while passing interim order; Applications for vacating interim stay.
Case Arising From CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.3589 of 2023 With Special Leave Petition (Crl.) Nos. 13284-13289 of 2023 and Criminal Appeal... Diary No. 49052 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 03.11.2023 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in A482 No. 28574 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Rakesh Dwivedi, VK Shukla, Kavin Gulati, S.G. Hasnain, Ravindra Singh, Dinesh Goswami, Sr. Advs., Shantanu Krishna, Nitin Sharma, Nikhil Sharma, Eklavya Dwivedi, Shantanu Sagar, Anukul Raj, Ankit Mishra, Harmeet Singh Ruprah, Abhinav Shrivastava, Manu Yadav, Himanshu Tyagi, Kumar Ayush, Ronak Chaturavedi, Ram Kaushik, Syed Mohd Fazal, Archit Mandhyan, Raman Yadav, Prabhat Ranjan Raj, Sidharth Sarthi, Anil Kumar, Gunjesh Ranjan, Animesh Tripathi, Anant Prakash, Mrs. Kanupriya Mishra, Amit Kumar Singh, Salil Srivastava, Shaurya Vardhan Singh, Ankit Dwivedi, Mrs. Mukti Chowdhary, Gyanendra Kumar, Mrs. Vijaya Singh, Shashwat Anand, Apoorv Mishra, Shashank Shukla, Ashutosh Thakur, Vaibhav Jain, Rituvendra Singh, Aniruddh Kumar, Rajrshi Gupta, Imran Ullah, Tarun Agarwal, Ankit Saran, Namit Srivastava, Rakesh Dubey, Swetashwa Agarwal, Javed H Khan, Praval Tripathi, Shariq Ahmed, Satwik Misra, Ishit Saharia, Ashish Singh, Amit Singh, Sanjay Kumar Singh, Piyush Kumar, Paritosh Kumar Singh, Pai Amit, N. Ashwani Kumar, Ms. Pankhuri Bhardwaj, Ms. Bhavana Duhoon, Ms. Ranu Purohit, Abhiyudaya Vats, Ms. Vanshika Dubey, Kushal Dube, Tathagata Dutta, P. Ashok, Advs. for the Appellant. Tushar Mehta, SG, Ajay Kumar Misra, Adv. Gen/Sr. Adv., Vijay Hansaria, Sr. Adv., Tanmaya Agarwal, Wrick Chatterjee, Mrs. Aditi [2024] 2 S.C.R. 955High Court B a r A s s o c i a t i o n , A l l a h a b a d v . State o f U .P. & O r s . Agarwal, Vinayak Mohan, Mahfooz Ahsan Nazki, Polanki Gowtham, Ms. Rajeswari Mukherjee, K.V. Girish Chowdary, T. Vijaya Bhaskar Reddy, Ms. Archita Nigam, Meeran Maqbool, Ms. Ruchi Guasain, Fuzail Ahmad Ayyubi, Ibad Mushtaq, Ms. Akanksha Rai, Ms. Anasuya Choudhury, Ms. Kavya Jhawar, Gaurav Mehrotra, Talha Abdul Rahman, Nadeem Murtaza, Akber Ahmed, Abhinit Jaiswal, Harsh Vardhan Mehrotra, Ms. Maria Fatima, Ms. Alina Masoodi, M. Shaz Khan, Adnan Yousuf Bhat, Ms. Anasuya Chaudhoury, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Abhay S. Oka, J.
Table of Contents* A. FACTUAL BACKGROUND .............................................. 2 I. Directions in Asian Resurfacing ................................ 2 II. Order of reference to Larger Bench .......................... 7 B. SUBMISSIONS ...................................................................... 8 C. ANALYSIS ............................................................................14 I. Object of passing interim orders ............................. 14 II. High Court’s power to vacate or modify interim relief.............................................................................. 16 III. Whether an interim order can come to an end automatically only due to the lapse of time ........... 17 IV. Scope of exercise of powers under Article 142 of the Constitution ................................................................ 21 V. P o s i t i o n o f H i g h C o u r t s a n d i t s p o w e r o f superintendence ...................................................... 29 VI. Whether the Court should deal with an issue not arising for consideration ....................................................... 32 VII. Clause (3) of Article 226 of the Constitution .......... 33 VIII. Directions issued by the constitutional Courts to decide pending cases in a time-bound manner ..... 34 * Ed Note : Pagination as per original judgment.
956 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports IX. Procedure to be adopted by High Courts while passing interim order of stay of proceedings and for dealing with the applications for vacating interim stay ...... 43 D. CONCLUSIONS ................................................................... 44
A. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
By the order dated 1st December 2023, a Bench of three Hon’ble Judges of this Court expressed a view that a decision of this Court in the case of Asian Resurfacing of Road Agency Private Limited & Anr. v. Central Bureau of Investigation1 requires reconsideration by a larger Bench.
I. Directions in Asian Resurfacing
1. In Asian Resurfacing1, this Court dealt with the scope of interference by the High Court with an order of framing charge passed by the Special Judge under the provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (for short, ‘the PC Act’). The issue was whether an order of framing charge was an interlocutory order. The High Court held that an order of framing charge under the PC Act was interlocutory. A Bench of two Hon’ble Judges of this Court, by the order dated 9th September 2013, referred the case to a larger Bench to consider the issue of whether the case of Mohan Lal Magan Lal Thacker v. State of Gujarat 2 was correctly decided. A Bench of three Hon’ble Judges held that the order of framing charge was neither an interlocutory nor a final order. Therefore, it was held that the High Court has jurisdiction in appropriate cases to consider a challenge to an order of framing charge. Furthermore, the High Court has jurisdiction to grant a stay of the trial proceedings. Thereafter, it proceeded to consider in which cases a stay of the proceedings ought to be granted. The Bench considered the question in the context of a criminal trial, particularly under the PC Act. In paragraphs 30 and 31, the Bench observed thus: “30. It is well accepted that delay in a criminal trial, particularly in the PC Act cases, has deleterious effect on the administration of justice in which the society has a 1 [2018] 2 SCR 1045 : (2018) 16 SCC 299 2 [1968] 2 SCR 685 : AIR 1968 SC 733 [2024] 2 S.C.R. 957High Court B a r A s s o c i a t i o n , A l l a h a b a d v . State o f U .P. & O r s . vital interest. Delay in trials affects the faith in Rule of Law and efficacy of the legal system. It affects social welfare and development. Even in civil or tax cases it has been laid down that power to grant stay has to be exercised with restraint. Mere prima facie case is not enough. Party seeking stay must be put to terms and stay should not be an incentive to delay. The order granting stay must show application of mind. The power to grant stay is coupled with accountability. [Siliguri Municipality v. Amalendu Das, (1984) 2 SCC 436, para 4 : 1984 SCC (Tax) 133; CCE v. Dunlop India Ltd., (1985) 1 SCC 260, para 5 : 1985 SCC (Tax) 75; State (UT of Pondicherry) v. P.V. Suresh, (1994) 2 SCC 70, para 15 and State of W.B. v. Calcutta Hardware Stores, (1986) 2 SCC 203, para 5]
31. Wherever stay is granted, a speaking order must be passed showing that the case was of exceptional nature and delay on account of stay will not prejudice the interest of speedy trial in a corruption case. Once stay is granted, proceedings should not be adjourned, and concluded within two-three months.”
(Emphasis added)
2. We have been called upon to decide the correctness of the view taken in paragraphs 36 and 37 of the said decision, which read thus: “36. In view of the above, situation of proceedings remaining pending for long on account of stay needs to be remedied. Remedy is required not only for corruption cases but for all civil and criminal cases where on account of stay, civil and criminal proceedings are held up. At times, proceedings are adjourned sine die on account of stay. Even after stay is vacated, intimation is not received and proceedings are not taken up. In an attempt to remedy this situation, we consider it appropriate to direct that in all pending cases where stay against proceedings of a civil or criminal trial is operating, the same will come to an end on expiry of six months from today unless in an exceptional case by a speaking order such stay is extended.
In cases where stay is granted in future, the same 958 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports will end on expiry of six months from the date of such order unless similar extension is granted by a speaking order. The speaking order must show that the case was of such exceptional nature that continuing the stay was more important than having the trial finalised. The trial court where order of stay of civil or criminal proceedings is produced, may fix a date not beyond six months of the order of stay so that on expiry of period of stay, proceedings can commence unless order of extension of stay is produced.
37. Thus, we declare the law to be that order framing charge is not purely an interlocutory order nor a final order. Jurisdiction of the High Court is not barred irrespective of the label of a petition, be it under Sections 397 or 482 CrPC or Article 227 of the Constitution. However, the said jurisdiction is to be exercised consistent with the legislative policy to ensure expeditious disposal of a trial without the same being in any manner hampered. Thus considered, the challenge to an order of charge should be entertained in a rarest of rare case only to correct a patent error of jurisdiction and not to reappreciate the matter. Even where such challenge is entertained and stay is granted, the matter must be decided on day-to-day basis so that stay does not operate for an unduly long period.
Though no mandatory time-limit may be fixed, the decision may not exceed two-three months normally.
If it remains pending longer, duration of stay should not exceed six months, unless extension is granted by a specific speaking order, as already indicated.
Mandate of speedy justice applies to the PC Act cases as well as other cases where at trial stage proceedings are stayed by the higher court i.e. the High Court or a court below the High Court, as the case may be. In all pending matters before the High Courts or other courts relating to the PC Act or all other civil or criminal cases, where stay of proceedings in a pending trial is operating, stay will automatically lapse after six months from today unless extended by a speaking order on the above parameters.
Same course may also be adopted by civil and criminal [2024] 2 S.C.R. 959High Court B a r A s s o c i a t i o n , A l l a h a b a d v . State o f U .P. & O r s . appellate/Revisional Courts under the jurisdiction of the High Courts. The trial courts may, on expiry of the above period, resume the proceedings without waiting for any other intimation unless express order extending stay is produced.”
(Emphasis added)
3. A Miscellaneous Application was filed in the decided case, in light of the order passed on 4th December 2019 by the Learned Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pune. When the learned Magistrate was called upon to proceed with the trial on the ground of automatic vacation of stay after the expiry of a period of six months, the learned Magistrate expressed a view that when the jurisdictional High Court had passed an order of stay, a Court subordinate to the High Court cannot pass any order contrary to the order of stay. By the order dated 15th October 2020, this Court held that when the stay granted by the High Court automatically expires, unless an extension is granted for good reasons, the Trial Court, on expiry of a period of six months, must set a date for trial and go ahead with the same. Later, an attempt was made to seek clarification of the law laid down in the case of Asian Resurfacing 1. This Court, by the order dated 25th April 2022, did not apply the direction issued in Asian Resurfacing 1 to the facts of the case before it. An attempt was made to apply the directions to an order of stay of the order of the learned Single Judge of the High Court passed by a Division Bench in a Letters Patent Appeal.
II. Order of reference to Larger Bench
4. In the order of reference dated 1 st December 2023, in paragraph 10, this Court observed thus:
“10. We have reservations in regard to the correctness of the broad formulations of principle in the above terms. There can be no gainsaying the fact that a stay of an indefinite nature results in prolonging civil or criminal proceedings, as the case may be, unduly. At the same time, it needs to be factored in that the delay is not always on account of conduct of the parties involved. The delay may also be occasioned by the inability of the Court to take up proceedings expeditiously. The principle which 960 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports has been laid down in the above decision to the effect that the stay shall automatically stand vacated (which would mean an automatic vacation of stay without application of judicial mind to whether the stay should or should not be extended further) is liable to result in a serious miscarriage of justice.”
(Emphasis added)
5. We are called upon to decide the following questions: -
(a) Whether this Court, in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution of India, can order automatic vacation of all interim orders of the High Courts of staying proceedings of Civil and Criminal cases on the expiry of a certain period?
(b) Whether this Court, in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 142 of the Constitution of India, can direct the High Courts to decide pending cases in which interim orders of stay of proceedings has been granted on a day-to-day basis and within a fixed period?
B. SUBMISSIONS
6. The main submissions were canvassed by Shri Rakesh Dwivedi, the learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant in Criminal Appeal no.3589 of 2023. We are summarising the submissions of Shri Rakesh Dwivedi as follows:
a. Automatic Vacation of the interim order is in the nature of judicial legislation. This Court cannot engage in judicial legislation; b. Article 226 is a part of the basic structure of the Constitution of India, and it can neither be shut out nor whittled down by the exercise of powers under Articles 141 and 142;
c. The High Court is also a constitutional Court which is not judicially subordinate to this Court;
d. An order granting interim relief cannot be passed without an application of judicial mind. Application of mind is a pre-requisite of judicial decision making. The absence of application of mind would render a decision arbitrary. Similarly, an order vacating interim relief cannot be passed without the application of judicial mind;
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 961High Court B a r A s s o c i a t i o n , A l l a h a b a d v . State o f U .P. & O r s . e. If an interim order is to be passed, it should be initially for a short period so that there is an effective opportunity for the respondent to contest the same;
f. Two Constitution Benches in the cases of Abdul Rehman Antulay & Ors. v. R.S. Nayak & Anr.3 and P. Ramachandra Rao v. State of Karnataka 4 held that it is not permissible for this Court to fix the time limit for completion of a trial; g. No such directions could have been issued in the exercise of the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 142 of the Constitution of India;
h. Even under Article 226 (3) of the Constitution, an interim order cannot be automatically vacated unless a specific application is made for vacating the interim order;
i. A provision of automatic vacation of the Appellate Tribunal’s stay order was incorporated in Section 254 (2A) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short, ‘the IT Act’). It provided that if an appeal preferred before the Appellate Tribunal was not disposed of within 365 days, the stay shall stand vacated even if the delay in disposing of the appeal is not attributable to the assessee. This court struck down the provision in the case of Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr. v. Pepsi Foods Limited5 on the ground that it was manifestly arbitrary; and j. The automatic vacation of interim relief is unjust, unfair and unreasonable.
7. Shri Tushar Mehta, the learned Solicitor General appearing for the State of Uttar Pradesh, supported the submissions of Shri Dwivedi. In addition, he submitted that:
a. As held by the Constitution Bench in the case of Raza Buland Sugar Co. Ltd. v. Municipal Board, Rampur6, laws of procedure are grounded in principles of natural justice, which require that no decision can be reached behind the back of a person and in his absence;
3 [1991] Suppl. 3 SCR 325 : (1992) 1 SCC 225 4 [2002] 3 SCR 60 : (2002) 4 SCC 578 5 [2021] 4 SCR 1 : (2021) 7 SCC 413 6 [1965] 1 SCR 970 : AIR 1965 SC 895 962 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports b. If the condition imposed by a provision of law to do a certain thing within a time frame is upon the institution and the consequences of that institution failing to comply with the condition are to fall upon someone who has no control over the institution, the provision of law will have to be construed as directory;
c. An interim relief order is always granted after considering the three factors: prima facie case, the balance of convenience and irreparable injury to the aggrieved party. Once a finding is recorded regarding the entitlement of the appellant/ applicant to get the order of stay, the order does not become automatically bad on the ground that it has lived for six months; and d. In the decision of this Court in Kailash v. Nanhku & Ors 7, it has been held that the process of justice may be speeded up and hurried, but fairness, which is the basic element of justice, cannot be permitted to be buried. The discretion conferred upon the High Court cannot be taken away by exercising power under Article 142 of the Constitution of India.
8. Shri Gaurav Mehrotra, the learned counsel appearing for the applicant in I.A. no.252872 of 2023 in Criminal Appeal no.3589 of 2023, in addition to the aforesaid submissions, relied upon a decision of the Constitution Bench in the case of Sanjeev Coke Manufacturing Company v. M/s. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. & Anr8, to contend that the Court should not decide any important question without there being a proper lis.
9. Shri Vijay Hansaria, the learned senior counsel appearing for the Gauhati High Court Bar Association, made the following submissions: a. As regards the interpretation of clause (3) of Article 226 of the Constitution of India, various High Courts have taken different views on the issue of whether the provision for automatic vacation of stay is mandatory or directory. He urged that the provision will have to be held as a directory;
7 [2005] 3 SCR 289 : (2005) 4 SCC 480 8 [1983] 1 SCR 1000 : (1983) 1 SCC 147 [2024] 2 S.C.R. 963High Court Bar Association, Allahabad v. State of U.P. & Ors. b. In Asian Resurfacing 1, the Court was dealing with a petition filed in the High Court arising from a prosecution under the PC Act. The cases of other categories were not the subject matter of challenge before this Court;
c. The power under Article 142 of the Constitution of India can be exercised for doing complete justice in any case or matter pending before it. The issue of the duration of the order of stay did not arise in the case of Asian Resurfacing1; and d. A successful litigant whose application for stay is allowed by the High Court cannot be prejudiced only on the ground that the High Court does not hear the main case within six months for reasons beyond the control of the said litigant.
10. Shri Amit Pai, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant in one of the appeals, while adopting the submissions, relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Deoraj v. State of Maharashtra & Ors.9 and contended that recourse is taken to the order of grant of interim relief as the conclusion of hearing on merits is likely to take some time. He submitted that the said object has not been considered in Asian Resurfacing1. He urged that passing an interim order of stay is a judicial act. Therefore, such an order must be vacated only by a judicial act.
11. Prof (Dr) Pankaj K Phadnis, representing the intervenor – Abhinav Bharat Congress, has filed written submissions. He has contended that he was not permitted to join the hearing through video conferencing. He has come out with the draft of Supreme Court Rules, 2024. His submissions, based on the draft, are entirely irrelevant.
C. ANALYSIS
12. We have no manner of doubt that the direction issued in paragraph 36 of Asian Resurfacing 1 regarding automatic vacation of stay has been issued in the exercise of the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 142 of the Constitution of India. Even the direction in paragraph 37 of conducting day-to-day hearing has been issued in exercise of the same jurisdiction. The effect of the direction issued in paragraph 36 is that the interim order of stay granted 9 [2004] 3 SCR 920 : (2004) 4 SCC 697 964 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in favour of a litigant stands vacated without even giving him an opportunity of being heard, though there may not be any default on his part.
I. Object of passing interim orders
13. Before we examine the questions, we need to advert to the object of passing orders of interim relief pending the final disposal of the main case. The reason is that the object of passing interim order has not been considered while deciding Asian Resurfacing1 . An order of interim relief is usually granted in the aid of the final relief sought in the case. An occasion for passing an order of stay of the proceedings normally arises when the High Court is dealing with a challenge to an interim or interlocutory order passed during the pendency of the main case before a trial or appellate Court. The High Court can grant relief of the stay of hearing of the main proceedings on being satisfied that a prima facie case is made out and that the failure to stay the proceedings before the concerned Court in all probability may render the remedy adopted infructuous. When the High Court passes an interim order of stay, though the interim order may not expressly say so, the three factors, viz; prima facie case, irreparable loss, and balance of convenience, are always in the back of the judges’ minds. Though interim orders of stay of proceedings cannot be routinely passed as a matter of course, it cannot be said that such orders can be passed only in exceptional cases. Nevertheless, the High Courts, while passing orders of stay in serious cases like the offences under the PC Act or serious offences against women and children, must be more cautious and circumspect. An occasion for passing an order of stay of proceeding arises as it is not possible for the High Court to take up the case for final hearing immediately. While entertaining a challenge to an order passed in a pending case, if the pending case is not stayed, the trial or the appellate Court may decide the pending case, rendering the remedy before the High Court ineffective. Such a situation often leads to the passing of an order of remand. In our legal system, which is facing a docket explosion, an order of remand should be made only as a last resort. The orders of remand not only result in more delays but also increase the cost of litigation. Therefore, to avoid the possibility of passing an order of remand, the grant of stay of proceedings is called for in many cases.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 965High Court B a r A s s o c i a t i o n , A l l a h a b a d v . State o f U .P. & O r s . II. High Court’s power to vacate or modify interim relief
14. When a High Court grants a stay of the proceedings while issuing notice without giving an opportunity of being heard to the contesting parties, it is not an interim order, but it is an ad-interim order of stay. It can be converted into an interim order of stay only after an opportunity of being heard is granted on the prayer for interim relief to all the parties to the proceedings. Ad-interim orders, by their very nature, should be of a limited duration. Therefore, such orders do not pose any problem.
15. The High Courts are always empowered to vacate or modify an order of interim relief passed after hearing the parties on the following, amongst other grounds: -
(a) If a litigant, after getting an order of stay, deliberately prolongs the proceedings either by seeking adjournments on unwarranted grounds or by remaining absent when the main case in which interim relief is granted is called out for hearing before the High Court with the object of taking undue advantage of the order of stay;
(b) The High Court finds that the order of interim relief is granted as a result of either suppression or misrepresentation of material facts by the party in whose favour the interim order of stay has been made; and
(c) The High Court finds that there is a material change in circumstances requiring interference with the interim order passed earlier. In a given case, a long passage of time may bring about a material change in circumstances.
These grounds are not exhaustive. There can be other valid grounds for vacating an order of stay.
III. Whether an Interim Order can come to an end automatically only due to the lapse of time
16. Interim order of stay can come to an end: -
(a) By disposal of the main case by the High Court, in which the interim order has been passed. The disposal can be either on merits or for default or other reasons such as the abatement of the case; or 966 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
(b) by a judicial order vacating interim relief, passed after hearing the contesting parties on the available grounds, some of which we have already referred to by way of illustration.
Elementary principles of natural justice, which are well recognised in our jurisprudence, mandate that an order of vacating interim relief or modification of the interim relief is passed only after hearing all the affected parties. An order of vacating interim relief passed without hearing the beneficiary of the order is against the basic tenets of justice. Application of mind is an essential part of any decision-making process. Therefore, without application of mind, an order of interim stay cannot be vacated only on the ground of lapse of time when the litigant is not responsible for the delay. An interim order lawfully passed by a Court after hearing all contesting parties is not rendered illegal only due to the long passage of time. Moreover, the directions issued in Asian Resurfacing1 regarding automatic vacation of interim orders of stay passed by all High Courts are applicable, irrespective of the merits of individual cases. If a High Court concludes after hearing all the concerned parties that a case was made out for the grant of stay of proceedings of a civil or criminal case, the order of stay cannot stand automatically set aside on expiry of the period of six months only on the ground that the High Court could not hear the main case. If such an approach is adopted, it will be completely contrary to the concept of fairness. If an interim order is automatically vacated without any fault on the part of the litigant only because the High Court cannot hear the main case, the maxim “actus curiae neminem gravabit” will apply. No litigant should be allowed to suffer due to the fault of the Court. If that happens, it is the bounden duty of the Court to rectify its mistake.
17. In the subsequent clarification in the case of Asian Resurfacing 1, a direction has been issued to the Trial Courts to immediately fix a date for hearing after the expiry of the period of six months without waiting for any formal order of vacating stay passed by the High Court. This gives an unfair advantage to the respondent in the case before the High Court. Moreover, it adversely affects a litigant’s right to the remedies under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India. Such orders virtually defeat the right of a litigant to seek and avail of statutory remedies such as revisions, appeals, and applications under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, [2024] 2 S.C.R. 967High Court B a r A s s o c i a t i o n , A l l a h a b a d v . State o f U .P. & O r s . 1973 (for short, ‘Cr. PC’) as well as the remedies under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, ‘CPC’). All interim orders of stay passed by all High Courts cannot be set at naught by a stroke of pen only on the ground of lapse of time.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.