Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 148; [2024] 2 S.C.R. 1001
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Sanjiv Khanna, Justice Sarasa Venkatanarayana Bhatti
- Decided
- 28 Feb 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7257/2011
- Sections
- 194, 182, 119, 2042, 285, 204, 163, 2, 1, 4
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:23 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
* Author [2024] 2 S.C.R. 1001 : 2024 INSC 148 Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited)
v.
Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another (Civil Appeal No. 7257 of 2011)
28 February 2024 [Sanjiv Khanna* and S.V.N. Bhatti, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The liability to deduct tax at source u/s.194-H, Income Tax Act, 1961 on the amount which, as per the Revenue, is a commission payable to an agent by the assessees-cellular mobile telephone service providers under the franchise/distributorship agreement between the assessees and the franchisees/distributors. Headnotes Income Tax Act, 1961 – s.194-H – When not attracted – Assessees entered into franchise or distribution agreements and sold start-up kits, recharge vouchers at a discounted price to the franchisee/distributors – As per Revenue, the difference between ‘discounted price’ and ‘sale price’ in the hands of the franchisee/distributors being in the nature of ‘commission or brokerage’ was the income of the franchisee/ distributors, the relationship between the assessees and the franchisee/distributor was in the nature of principal and agent, and thus, the assesses were liable to deduct tax at source u/s.194-H – As per the assessees, neither the discount was a ‘commission or brokerage’ u/Explanation (i) to s.194-H nor were the franchisees/distributors their agents:
Held: Whether in law the relationship between the parties is that of principal-agent is answered by applying s.182, Contract Act, 1872 – The obligation to deduct tax at source in terms of s.194-H arises when the legal relationship of principal-agent is established – Contractual obligations of the distributors/franchisees, do not reflect a fiduciary character of the relationship, or the business being done on the principal’s account – Franchisees/distributors earn their income when they sell the prepaid products to the retailer or the end-user/customer – Their profit consists of the difference between the sale price received by them from the 1002 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports retailer/end-user/customer and the discounted price at which they ‘acquired’ the product – Though the discounted price is fixed or negotiated between the assessee and the franchisee/ distributor, the sale price received by the franchisee/distributor is within their sole discretion – Assessee has no say in this matter – Assessee does not at any stage either pay or credit the account of the franchisee/distributor with the income by way of commission or brokerage on which tax at source u/s.194-H is to be deducted – Expression “direct or indirect” used in s.194-H Explanation (i) is no doubt meant to ensure that “the person responsible for paying” does not dodge the obligation to deduct tax at source, even when the payment is indirectly made by the principal-payer to the agent-payee however, deduction of tax at source in terms of s.194-H is not to be extended and widened in ambit to apply to true/genuine business transactions, where the assessee is not the person responsible for paying or crediting income– Assessees neither pay nor credit any income to the person with whom he has contracted and are not privy to the transactions between distributors/franchisees and third parties– It is impossible for the assessees to deduct tax at source and comply with s.194-H, on the difference between the total/sum consideration received by the distributors/ franchisees from third parties and the amount paid by the distributors/franchisees to them – Payee receives payment when the third party makes the payment – This payment is not the payment received or payable by the assessee as the principal – The distributor/franchisee is not the trustee who is to account for this payment to the assessee as the principal – Assessees not under legal obligation to deduct tax at source on the income/profit component in the payments received by the distributors/franchisees from the third parties/ customers, or while selling/transferring the pre-paid coupons or starter-kits to the distributors – s.194-H not applicable to the facts and circumstances of this case – Judgments of High Courts of Delhi and Calcutta set aside. [Paras 6, 29, 31, 34, 36, 37 and 42] Contract Act, 1872 – s.182 – ‘agent’ and ‘principal’ – Whether a legal relationship of a principal and agent exists, factors to be taken into consideration:
Held: (a) The essential characteristic of an agent is the legal power vested with the agent to alter his principal’s legal [2024] 2 S.C.R. 1003Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another relationship with a third party and the principal’s co-relative liability to have his relations altered – (b) As the agent acts on behalf of the principal, one of the prime elements of the relationship is the exercise of a degree of control by the principal over the conduct of the activities of the agent – This degree of control is less than the control exercised by the master on the servant, and is different from the rights and obligations in case of principal to principal and independent contractor relationship – (c) The task entrusted by the principal to the agent should result in a fiduciary relationship – The fiduciary relationship is the manifestation of consent by one person to another to act on his or her behalf and subject to his or her control, and the reciprocal consent by the other to do so – (d) As the business done by the agent is on the principal’s account, the agent is liable to render accounts thereof to the principal – An agent is entitled to remuneration from the principal for the work he performs for the principal – Other relevant aspects/considerations, discussed. [Paras 8, 9] Income Tax Act, 1961 – Explanation (i) to s.194-H:
Held: The words “direct” or “indirect” in Explanation (i) to s.194-H are with reference to the act of payment – The legislative intent to include “indirect” payment ensures that the net cast by the section is plugged and not avoided or escaped, albeit it does not dilute the requirement that the payment must be on behalf “the person responsible for paying”– This means that the payment/ credit in the account should arise from the obligation of “the person responsible for paying” – The payee should be the person who has the right to receive the payment from “the person responsible for paying” – Further, explanation (i) to s.194-H, by using the word “indirectly”, does not regulate or curtail the manner in which the assessee can conduct business and enter into commercial relationships – Neither does the word “indirectly” create an obligation where the main provision does not apply – The tax legislation recognises diverse relationships and modes in which commerce and trade are conducted, albeit obligation to tax at source arises only if the conditions as mentioned in s.194-H are met and not otherwise – This principle does not negate the compliance required by law – Latter portion of the Explanation
(i) to s.194-H is a requirement and a pre-condition – It should not be read as diminishing or derogating the requirement of 1004 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the principal and agent relationship between the payer and the recipient/payee. [Paras 4, 5 and 34] Income Tax Act, 1961 – Issue as regards the liability to deduct tax at source u/s.194-H on the amount which, as per the Revenue, is a commission payable to an agent by the assessees under the franchise/distributorship agreement between the assessees and the franchisees/distributors – Plea of the Revenue relying upon the decision of this Court in Singapore Airlines Ltd. and Another v. Commissioner of Income Tax [2022] 9 SCR 1 that assessees would be liable to deduct tax at source even if they are not making payment or crediting the income to the account of the franchisee/ distributor:
Held: Rejected – When the obligation, and the time and manner in which the tax is mandated by law to be deducted at source, is fixed by the statute, the same cannot be shifted/altered/modified or postponed on a concession in the court by the Revenue – The concession may be granted, when permissible, by way of a circular issued in accordance with s.119 – Decision in Singapore Airlines Limited can not be read in the manner as suggested by the Revenue. [Para 38] Franchise agreement and distributorship agreement – Distinction – Legal position of a distributor different from agent – Distributor, an independent contractor:
Held: Legal position of a distributor, it is to be generally regarded as different from that of an agent – The distributor buys goods on his account and sells them in his territory – In such cases, distributor is an independent contractor – Unlike an agent, he does not act as a communicator or creator of a relationship between the principal and a third party – Franchise agreements are normally considered as sui generis, though they have been in existence for some time – They provide a mechanism whereby goods and services may be distributed – In franchise agreements, the supplier or the manufacture, i.e. a franchisor, appoints an independent enterprise as a franchisee through whom the franchisor supplies certain goods or services – There is a close relationship between a franchisor and a franchisee because a franchisee’s operations are closely regulated, and this possibly is a distinction between a franchise agreement and a [2024] 2 S.C.R. 1005Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another distributorship agreement – Franchise agreements are extremely detailed and complex – Notwithstanding the strict restrictions placed on the franchisees, the relationship may in a given case be that of an independent contractor – Facts of each case and the authority given by ‘principal’ to the franchisees matter and are determinative – Further, an independent contractor is free from control on the part of his employer, and is only subject to the terms of his contract – But an agent is not completely free from control, and the relationship to the extent of tasks entrusted by the principal to the agent are fiduciary – As contract with an independent agent depends upon the terms of the contract, sometimes an independent contractor looks like an agent from the point of view of the control exercisable over him, but on an overview of the entire relationship the tests specified in clauses
(a) to (d) in paragraph 8 may not be satisfied – The distinction is that independent contractors work for themselves, even when they are employed for the purpose of creating contractual relations with the third persons – An independent contractor is not required to render accounts of the business, as it belongs to him and not his employer. [Paras 39, 40] Law relating to agency – Exclusion of servants and independent contractors:
Held: ‘Agent’ denotes a relationship that is very different from that existing between a master and his servant, or between a principal and principal, or between an employer and his independent contractor – Although servants and independent contractors are parties to relationships in which one person acts for another, and thereby possesses the capacity to involve them in liability, yet the nature of the relationship and the kind of acts in question are sufficiently different to justify the exclusion of servants and independent contractors from the law relating to agency – Term ‘agent’ should be restricted to one who has the power of affecting the legal position of his principal by the making of contracts, or the disposition of the principal’s property; viz. an independent contractor who may, incidentally, also affect the legal position of his principal in other ways – This can be ascertained by referring to and examining the indicia mentioned in clauses (a) to (d) in paragraph 8 of this judgment – It is in the restricted sense in which the term agent is used in Explanation (i) to s.194-H of the Income Tax Act, 1961. [Para 41] 1006 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Doctrine/Principles – Doctrine of presumption against doubtful penalisation:
Held: The deduction of tax provisions should be programmatically and realistically construed – In case of a legal or factual doubt in a given case, the assessee can rely on the doctrine of presumption against doubtful penalisation – Whether or not the said doctrine should be applied will depend on facts and circumstances of the case, including the past practice followed by the assessee and accepted by the department – When there is apparent divergence of opinion, to avoid litigation and pitfalls associated, it may be advisable for the Central Board of Direct Taxes to clarify doubts by issuing appropriate instruction/circular after ascertaining view of the assesses and stakeholders. [Para 35] Words and expressions – ‘power’; ‘authority’.
Case Law Cited Singapore Airlines Ltd. and Another v. Commissioner of Income Tax, [2022] 9 SCR 1 : (2023) 1 SCC 497 – dsitinguished.
Bhopal Sugar Industries Limited v. Sales Tax Officer, Bhopal, [1977] 3 SCR 578 : (1977) 3 SCC 147;
Commissioner of Income Tax, Ahmedabad and Others v.
Ahmedabad Stamp Vendors Association, (2014) 16 SCC 114; Ahmedabad Stamp Vendors Association v. Union of India, (2002) 257 ITR 202 (Guj.); Director, Prasar Bharati v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Thiruvananthapuram, [2018] 3 SCR 287 : (2018) 7 SCC 800; Securities and Exchange Board of India v. Sunil Krishna Khaitan and Others, [2022] 18 SCR 987 : (2023) 2 SCC 643 – referred to.
Commissioner of Income Tax v. Singapore Airlines Ltd., (2009) 319 ITR 29 – referred to.
Labreche v. Harasymiw, (1992) 89 DLR (4th) 95 at 107 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited F.E. Dowrick, The Relationship of Principal and Agent, 17 MLR 24, 37 (1954); Restatement (Third) Of Agency (American Law Institute Publishers 2007); Warren A.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 1007Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another Seavey, The Rationale of Agency, 29 YALE L.J. 859, 866 (1920); G.H.L. Fridman, The Law of Agency 33 (Butterworths, 7 ed. 1996) – referred to.
List of Acts Income Tax Act, 1961; Contract Act, 1872; Indian Telegraph Act, 1885.
List of Keywords Liability to deduct tax at source; Cellular mobile telephone service providers; Agent; Principal; Franchise/distributorship agreement; Commission; Brokerage; Power; Authority; Fiduciary character of the relationship; Servants; Independent contractor; Independent agent; Law relating to agency; Doctrine of presumption against doubtful penalisation.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.7257 of 2011 With Civil Appeal Nos. 2652-2653, 4949-4950, 4947-4948 of 2015, 7455 of 2018, 111, 2860 of 2021, 8902 of 2022, 7729, 7735, 7736, 7737, 7738, 7739, 7740, 7741, 7742, 7743, 7679, 7680, 7681, 7682, 7744, 7745, 7746, 7747, 7748, 7848, 7849, 7852, 7853, 7854, 7855, 7856, 7857, 7859 of 2023, 3514, 3515, 3516 And 3517 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 19.05.2011 of the High Court at Calcutta in ITA No.222 of 2006 Appearances for Parties Balbir Singh, N. Venkatraman, A.S.Gs., Arvind P. Datar, Ajay Vohra, Arijit Prasad, Kavin Gulati, Sr. Advs., Kumar Visalaksh, Udit Jain, Archit Gupta, Arihant Tater, Ajitesh Dayal Singh, Praveen Kumar, Harish Pandey, Raj Bahadur Yadav, Digvijay Dam, V.C. Bharathi, Santosh Kumar, Rupesh Kumar, Prahlad Singh, Alka Agarwal, Ms. Ankita Anilkumar Singh, Deepak Kumar, Indrajit Prasad, Shyam Gopal, Aditya Rathore, Naman Tandon, Samarvir Singh, Prasenjeet Mohapatra, Sachit Jolly, Ms. Anuradha Dutt, Ms. Disha Jham, Ms. Soumya Singh, Ms. B. Vijayalakshmi Menon, Abhishek Vikas, Mahesh Agarwal, Rishi Agrawala, Ms. Sayree Basu Mullick, Ms. Madhvi Agarwal, M.S. Ananth, Ms. Sayree Basu Mullik, Abhinabh Garg, E.C. Agrawala, Advs. for the appearing parties.
1008 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sanjiv Khanna, J.
This common judgment decides the aforestated appeals preferred by the Revenue and the assessees, who are cellular mobile telephone service providers. The issue relates to the liability to deduct tax at source under Section 194-H of the Income Tax Act, 19611 on the amount which, as per the Revenue, is a commission payable to an agent by the assessees under the franchise/ distributorship agreement between the assessees and the franchisees/distributors. As per the assessees, neither are they paying a commission or brokerage to the franchisees/distributors, nor are the franchisees/distributors their agents. The High Courts of Delhi and Calcutta have held that the assessees were liable to deduct tax at source under Section 194-H of the Act, whereas the High Courts of Rajasthan, Karnataka and Bombay have held that Section 194-H of the Act is not attracted to the circumstances under consideration.
2. To avoid prolixity and repetition, we are not referring to the facts and arguments in the beginning, and will preface our judgment by reproducing Section 194-H of the Act and explaining its contours. The relevant portion of Section 194-H reads as under:
“194-H. Commission or brokerage.— Any person, not being an individual or a Hindu undivided family, who is responsible for paying, on or after the 1st day of June, 2001, to a resident, any income by way of commission (not being insurance commission referred to in Section 194-D) or brokerage, shall, at the time of credit of such income to the account of the payee or at the time of payment of such income in cash or by the issue of a cheque or draft or by any other mode, whichever is earlier, deduct income tax thereon at the rate of five per cent:
Provided that no deduction shall be made under this section in a case where the amount of such income or, 1 “The Act”, for short.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 1009Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another as the case may be, the aggregate of the amounts of such income credited or paid or likely to be credited or paid during the financial year to the account of, or to, the payee, does not exceed fifteen thousand rupees:
Provided further that an individual or a Hindu undivided family, whose total sales, gross receipts or turnover from the business or profession carried on by him exceed one crore rupees in case of business or fifty lakh rupees in case of profession during the financial year immediately preceding the financial year in which such commission or brokerage is credited or paid, shall be liable to deduct income tax under this section.
Provided also that no deduction shall be made under this section on any commission or brokerage payable by Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited or Mahanagar Telephone Nigam Limited to their public call office franchisees.
xx xx xx”
3. Section 194-H of the Act imposes the obligation to deduct tax at source, states that any person responsible for paying at the time of credit or at the time of payment, whichever is earlier, to a resident any income by way of commission or brokerage, shall deduct income tax at the prescribed rate The expression “any person (...) responsible for paying” is a term of art, defined vide Section 2042 of the Act. As per 2 204. Meaning of “person responsible for paying”.—For the purposes of the foregoing provisions of this chapter and Section 285, the expression “person responsible for paying” means—
(i) in the case of payments of income chargeable under the head “Salaries” other than payments by the Central Government or the Government of a State, the employer himself or, if the employer is a company, the company itself, including the principal officer thereof;
(ii) in the case of payments of income chargeable under the head “Interest on securities” other than payments made by or on behalf of the Central Government or the Government of a State, the local authority, corporation or company, including the principal officer thereof; (ii-a) in the case of any sum payable to a non-resident Indian, being any sum representing consideration for the transfer by him of any foreign exchange asset, which is not a short-term capital asset, the authorised person responsible for remitting such sum to the non-resident Indian or for crediting such sum of his Non-resident (External) Account maintained in accordance with the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (42 of 1999)], and any rules made thereunder; (ii-b) in the case of furnishing of information relating to payment to a non-resident, not being a company, or to a foreign company, of any sum, whether or not chargeable under the provisions of this Act, the payer himself, or, if the payer is a company, the company itself including the principal officer thereof;
(iii) in the case of credit or, as the case may be, payment of any other sum chargeable under the provisions of this Act, the payer himself, or, if the payer is a company, the company itself including the principal officer thereof.
1010 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the clause (iii) of Section 204, in the case of credit or in the case of payment in cases not covered by clauses (i), (ii), (ii)(a), (ii)(b), “the person responsible for paying” is the payer himself, or if the payer is a company, the company itself and the principal officer thereof.
4. Explanation (i) to Section 194-H 3 of the Act defines the expressions ‘commission’ or ‘brokerage’, as:
“Explanation. — For the purposes of this section, —
(i) “commission or brokerage” includes any payment received or receivable, directly or indirectly, by a person acting on behalf of another person for services rendered (not being professional services) or for any services in the course of buying or selling of goods or in relation to any transaction relating to any asset, valuable article or thing, not being securities;”
Payment is received when it is actually received or paid. The payment is receivable when the amount is actually credited in the books of the payer to the account of the payee, though the actual payment may take place in future. The payment received or
(iv) in the case of credit, or as the case may be, payment of any sum chargeable under the provisions of this Act made by or on behalf of the Central Government or the Government of a State, the drawing and disbursing officer or any other person, by whatever name called, responsible for crediting, or as the case may be, paying such sum.
(v) in the case of a person not resident in India, the person himself or any person authorised by such person or the agent of such person in India including any person treated as an agent under Section 163.] Explanation. —For the purposes of this section, —
(a) “non-resident Indian” and “foreign exchange asset” shall have the meanings assigned to them in Chapter XII-A;
(b) “authorised person” shall have the meaning assigned to it in clause (c) of Section 2 of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (42 of 1999).
3 Sub-section 1 to Section 194-H of the Act can be interpreted as requiring deduction of tax at source on commission and brokerage, even when the principal and agent relationship does not exist between the parties. Explanation (i) to Section 194-H of the Act can be read as expanding and widening the scope of the provision of sub-section (1) to include in the ambit of brokerage and commission, payments made by the principal to the agent, when covered under the four corners of the said explanation. We would not like to pronounce on this aspect as it has not been argued by the Revenue, and it appears that the requirement of relationship of principal and agent has been read into the main section. Further, applying common or commercial parlance meaning to the terms ‘brokerage’ or ‘commission’, given the wide divergence in which it is understood, would lead to confusion and has pitfalls. Deduction of Tax provisions should be pragmatically and realistically construed, and not as enmeshes or by adopting catch-as-catchcan approach. When doubts exist, the Central Board of Direct Taxes may examine this question and may issue appropriate instructions/circular after ascertaining the views of assessees and other stakeholders. The decision should be clear, and we trust and hope that an obligation, if imposed, will be prospective. (See paragraph 34 of the judgment.)
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 1011Bharti Cellular L i m i t e d ( Now B h a r t i A i r t e l L i m i t e d ) v. A s s i s t a n t Commissioner o f Income T a x , Circle 5 7 , K o l k a t a a n d A n o t h e r receivable should be to a person acting on behalf of another person. The words “another person” refers to “the person responsible for paying”. The words “direct” or “indirect” in Explanation (i) to Section 194-H of the Act are with reference to the act of payment. Without doubt, the legislative intent to include “indirect” payment ensures that the net cast by the section is plugged and not avoided or escaped, albeit it does not dilute the requirement that the payment must be on behalf “the person responsible for paying”. This means that the payment/credit in the account should arise from the obligation of “the person responsible for paying”.
The payee should be the person who has the right to receive the payment from “the person responsible for paying”. When this condition is satisfied, it does not matter if the payment is made “indirectly”.4
5. The services rendered by the agent to the principal, according to the latter portion of Explanation (i) to Section 194-H of the Act, should not be in the nature of professional services. Further, Explanation
(i) to Section 194-H of the Act restricts application of Section 194- H of the Act to the services rendered by the agent to the principal in the course of buying and selling of goods, or in relation to any transaction relating to any asset, valuable article, or thing, not being securities. The latter portion of the Explanation (i) to Section 194- H of the Act is a requirement and a pre-condition. It should not be read as diminishing or derogating the requirement of the principal and agent relationship between the payer and the recipient/payee.
6. It is settled by a series of judgments of this Court that the expression ‘acting on behalf of another person’ postulates the existence of a legal relationship of principal and agent, between the payer and the recipient/payee. 5 The law of agency is technical. Whether in law the relationship between the parties is that of principal-agent is answered 4 We are unable to visualize ‘indirect’ credit in the books of the payer to the account of the payee. Credit entry is required even in cases of set-off. Nevertheless, this judgment should not be read as laying down that ‘indirect’ credit in the books shall not require deduction of tax under Section 194-H of the Act. 5 Singapore Airlines Ltd. and Another v. Commissioner of Income Tax, [2022] 9 S.C.R. 1 : (2023) 1 SCC 497, ¶¶ 23-29.
1012 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports by applying Section 182 of the Contract Act, 1872 6 . Therefore, the obligation to deduct tax at source in terms of Section 194-H of the Act arises when the legal relationship of principal-agent is established. It is necessary to clarify this position, as in day to day life, the expression ‘agency’ is used to include a vast number of relationships, which are strictly, not relationships between a principal and agent.
7. Section 182 of the Contract Act, defines the words ‘agent’ and ‘principal’ and reads as under:
“182. “Agent” and “principal” defined.— An “agent” is a person employed to do any act for another, or to represent another in dealings with third persons. The person for whom such act is done, or who is so represented, is called the “principal”.”
Agency in terms of Section 182 exists when the principal employs another person, who is not his employee, to act or represent him in dealings with a third person. An agent renders services to the principal. The agent does what has been entrusted to him by the principal to do. It is the principal he represents before third parties, and not himself. As the transaction by the agent is on behalf of the principal whom the agent represents, the contract is between the principal and the third party. Accordingly the agent, except in some circumstances, is not liable to the third party.
8. Agency is therefore a triangular relationship between the principal, agent and the third party. In order to understand this relationship, one has to examine the inter se relationship between the principal and the third party and the agent and the third party. When we examine whether a legal relationship of a principal and agent exists, the following factors/aspects should be taken into consideration:
(a) The essential characteristic of an agent is the legal power vested with the agent to alter his principal’s legal relationship with a third party and the principal’s co-relative liability to have his relations altered. 7 6 “Contract Act”, for short.
7 F.E. Dowrick, The Relationship of Principal and Agent, 17 MLR 24, 37 (1954). [2024] 2 S.C.R. 1013Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another
(b) As the agent acts on behalf of the principal, one of the prime elements of the relationship is the exercise of a degree of control by the principal over the conduct of the activities of the agent. This degree of control is less than the control exercised by the master on the servant, and is different from the rights and obligations in case of principal to principal and independent contractor relationship.
(c) The task entrusted by the principal to the agent should result in a fiduciary relationship. The fiduciary relationship is the manifestation of consent by one person to another to act on his or her behalf and subject to his or her control, and the reciprocal consent by the other to do so.8
(d) As the business done by the agent is on the principal’s account, the agent is liable to render accounts thereof to the principal. An agent is entitled to remuneration from the principal for the work he performs for the principal.
9. At this stage, three other relevant aspects/considerations should be noted. First is the difference between ‘power’ and ‘authority’. The two terms though connected, are not synonymous. Authority refers to a factual position, that is, the terms of contract between the two parties. The power of the agent however, is not, strictly speaking, conferred by the contract or by the principal but by the law of agency. When a person gives authority to another person to do the acts which bring the law of agency into play, then, the law vests power with the agent to affect the principal’s legal relationship with the third parties. The extent and existence of the power with the agent is determined by public policy. The authority, as observed above, refers to the factual situation. The second consideration is that the primary task of an agent is to enter into contracts on behalf of his principal, or to dispose of his principal’s property. The factors mentioned in clauses (b) to (d) in paragraph 8 above flow, and are indicia of this primary task. Clauses (b) to (d) of paragraph 8 are useful as tests or standards to examine the true nature or character of the relationship. Lastly, the substance of the relationship between the parties, notwithstanding the nomenclature given by the parties to the relationship, is of primary importance. The true nature of the relationship is examined by reference to the functions, responsibility 8 Restatement (Third) of Agency (American Law Institute Publishers 2007). 1014 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports and obligations of the so-called agent to the principal and to the third parties.
10. An agent is distinct from a servant, in that an agent is subject to less control than a servant, and has complete, or almost complete discretion as to how to perform an undertaking. As Seavey said, ‘‘a servant (...) is an agent under more complete control than is a nonservant’’.9 The difference is “in the degree of control rather than in the acts performed. The servant sells primarily his services measured by time; the agent his ability to produce results.”10 This distinction can be criticised, for servants may have very wide discretion, and may not really be subject to control at all in practice, while agents may have their power to act circumscribed by detailed instructions.11
11. This Court in Bhopal Sugar Industries Limited v. Sales Tax Officer, Bhopal12 , has expounded the difference between principal-agent and principal-principal relationship, in the following words:- “5. … the essence of the matter is that in a contract of sale, title to the property passes on to the buyer on delivery of the goods for a price paid or promised. Once this happens the buyer becomes the owner of the property and the seller has no vestige of title left in the property. The concept of a sale has, however, undergone a revolutionary change, having regard to the complexities of the modern times and the expanding needs of the society, which has made a departure from the doctrine of laissez faire by including a transaction within the fold of a sale even though the seller may by virtue of an agreement impose a number of restrictions on the buyer, e.g. fixation of price, submission of accounts, selling in a particular area or territory and so on. These restrictions per se would not convert a contract of sale into one of agency, because in spite of these restrictions the transaction would still be a sale and subject to all the incidents of a sale. A contract of agency, however, differs essentially from a contract of sale inasmuch as an agent after taking delivery of the property 9 Warren A. Seavey, The Rationale of Agency, 29 YALE L.J. 859, 866 (1920). 10 Ibid.
11 G.H.L. Fridman, The Law of Agency 33 (Butterworths, 7 ed. 1996). 12 [1977] 3 SCR 578 : (1977) 3 SCC 147.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 1015Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another does not sell it as his own property but sells the same as the property of the principal and under his instructions and directions. Furthermore, since the agent is not the owner of the goods, if any loss is suffered by the agent he is to be indemnified by the principal. This is yet another dominant factor which distinguishes an agent from a buyer—pure and simple. In Halsbury’s Laws of England, Vol. 1, 4th Edn., in para 807 at p. 485, the following observations are made: “807. Rights of agent. —The relation of principal and agent raises by implication a contract on the part of the principal to reimburse the agent in respect of all expenses, and to indemnify him against all liabilities, incurred in the reasonable performance of the agency, provided that such implication is not excluded by the express terms of the contract between them, and provided that such expenses and liabilities are in fact occasioned by his employment.”
12. The aforesaid judgment in the context of distinction between a contract of sale and contract of agency observes that the agent is authorised to sell or buy on behalf of the principal, whereas the essence of contract of sale is the transfer of title of goods for the price paid or promised to be paid. In case of an agency to sell, the agent who sells them to the third parties, sells them not as his own property, but as a property of the principal, who continues to be the owner of the goods till the sale. The transferee is the debtor and liable to account for the price to be paid to the principal, and not to the agent for the proceeds of the sale. An agent is entitled to his fee or commission from the principal.
13. This distinction and test was referred to by this Court in Commissioner of Income Tax, Ahmedabad and Others v. Ahmedabad Stamp Vendors Association13, which is a case relating to Section 194-H of the Act. This Court had approved the decision of the High Court in Ahmedabad Stamp Vendors Association v. Union of India14. We may also refer to two more decisions of this Court. In the case
13 (2014) 16 SCC 114.
14 (2002) 257 ITR 202 (Guj.).
1016 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of Director, Prasar Bharati v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Thiruvananthapuram15, this Court has observed that the explanation appended to Section 194-H of the Act defining the expression ‘commission or brokerage’ is an inclusive definition giving wide meaning to the expression ‘commission’. The second decision is in the case of Singapore Airlines Limited v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Delhi 16, which we shall refer to subsequently in some detail as to its exact purport and ratio. However, at this stage, we would like to examine in some detail commercial relationships in the nature of an independent contractor, that are legally, principal to principal dealings.
14. The passage from Bhopal Sugar Industries Limited (supra) highlights the principles and the complexities involved in determining the correct nature of the legal relationship between a principal and an agent. Law permits individuals to enter into complex contracts incorporating multiple rights and obligations. The relationships between contacting parties have become multi-dimensional, which may not strictly fall within an employer-employee, principal-agent or principal-principal relationship. A singular contract may create different legal relationships and obligations. Independent contractors on occasion act for themselves, and at other times may be creating legal relations between their employers and third persons. For example, a solicitor may start by giving advice (independent contractor), and then as a consequence make a contract for his employer with another person (agent).
15. In Labreche v. Harasymiw 17, Valin J. delineated the question of what an agency involves, stating that: (i) it refers to the power of the agent to affect the principal’s position. However, this is not the sole test, though it still remains one of the main criteria in determining whether someone is an agent. There are several features in the definition of an agent18. There can be several situations where one person represents or acts for another, but this does not create the relationship of principal and agent. It is only when the representation 15 [2018] 3 SCR 287 : (2018) 7 SCC 800.
16 [2022] 9 SCR 1 : (2023) 1 SCC 497.
17 (1992) 89 DLR (4 th ) 95 at 107.
18 See ¶8 of the judgment.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 1017Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another or action on another’s behalf affects the latter’s legal position, that is to say his rights against, or his liability towards, other people, that the law of agency applies; (ii) the second feature is the importance of the way in which law regards the relationship which is created. The effect of the law is that it regulates the way in which parties conduct themselves. The conduct of the parties is considered in terms of law, regardless of the language or nomenclature used by the parties. The true factual position must be investigated to determine whether a relationship of agency has come into existence between a set of parties or individuals.
16. The significant observation in the aforesaid judgment is that all kinds of interactions with third parties or interested parties, resulting from the introduction of the third parties with one who wishes a particular undertaking to be performed, may not be a result of an agency. For instance, a retail dealer or supplier of goods, obtains goods from a wholesale supplier or a manufacturer for subsequent resale to retail customers or suppliers who, in turn, deals with retail dealers or shopkeepers. Such ‘middlemen’ are sometimes referred to as ‘agents’, when in fact they are franchisees of the manufacturer or supplier, or are distributors of the manufactures’ goods, perhaps with a ‘sole agency’ or special dealership for his goods. Such ‘agents’ can be real buyers, acting as principals on their own behalf. Consequently, they are not liable to the manufacturer or supplier in the way an agent might be for failure of duty, nor do their contracts with other parties – whether it be suppliers, retail dealers or individual customers – hold the party who sold to them, liable, for any breach including misrepresentation or sale of defective goods. The seller’s contractual or tortious liability is different from the manufacturer’s liability on account of warranty/guarantee, statutory liability or even obligation to a third party who purchases the goods or avails services from/through the independent contractor. An agent renders service to the principal, who he/she represents, and therefore the principal, and not the agent, is liable to the third parties. Further, the money received by an independent contractor from his customers will belong to the independent contractor and not to the party who sold to him. The money will be a part of such independent contractor’s property in the event of his bankruptcy or liquidation. This may be the case even if the contract of sale is one of ‘sale or return’. It is important to avoid confusion, by applying the legal tests, that may arise where 1018 [2024] 2 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the functions of the ‘buyer’ – described as an ‘agent’ – is really as that of a ‘middleman’, and the necessary elements for creation of principal and an agent relationship are absent. Two level commercial transaction can result in an tripartite arrangement/agreement with respective rights and obligations, without any of the two parties having principal-agent relationship.
17. Clause (d) in paragraph 8 observes that the agent is liable to render accounts to the principal as the business done by the agent is on principal’s account. The agent is entitled to remuneration from the principal for the work he performs. To decide whether a contracting party acts for himself as an independent contractor, we may examine whether in the course of work, he intends to make profits for himself, or is entitled to receive prearranged remuneration. If the party is concerned about acting for himself and making the maximum profits possible, he is usually regarded as a buyer, or an independent contractor and not as an agent of the principal. This would be true even when certain terms and conditions have been fixed relating to the manner in which the seller conducts his business. We shall subsequently further elucidate on the characteristics of an independent contractor, and differentiate them from the principal-agent relationship.
18. We now turn to the facts of the present case. The assessees, as noticed above, are cellular mobile telephone service providers in different circles as per the licence granted to them under Section 4 of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885 19 by the Department of Telecommunications20, Government of India. To carry on business, the assessees have to comply with the licence conditions and the rules and regulations of the DoT and the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India.21 Cellular mobile telephone service providers have wide latitude to select the business model they wish to adopt in their dealings with third parties, subject to statutory compliances being made by the operators. As per the business model adopted by the telecom companies, the users can avail post-paid and prepaid connections. In the present case, we are only concerned with the business operations under the prepaid model.
19 The ‘1885 Act’, for short.
20 ‘DoT’, for short.
21 ‘TRAI’, for short.
[2024] 2 S.C.R. 1019Bharti Cellular Limited (Now Bharti Airtel Limited) v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 57, Kolkata and Another
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.