Abdul Rejak Laskar v. Mafizur Rahman & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 1023; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1911
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 19 Dec 2024
- Case number
- No. 14805/2024
- Sections
- 154(1), 97, 154, 100, 4, 9, 54, 99, 57, 96, 62
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1911 : 2024 INSC 1023 Abdul Rejak Laskar v.
Mafizur Rahman & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 14805 of 2024)
20 December 2024 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The High Court held that the s.154(1)(e) of the the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886 bars the civil court from exercising its jurisdiction; whether the High Court committed any error in taking view that the suit filed by the appellant herein was barred u/s.154(1)(e) of the Regulation, 1886.
Headnotes† Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886 – s.154(1)(e)
and s.97 – Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Or.XX, r.18 – The Appellate Court vide order dated 20.04.1993 passed in Title Appeal No. 59/1990 held that the appellant herein was entitled to a decree for declaration of right, title and interest and also joint possession of suit land along with other co-pattadars – The decree passed by the First Appellate Court attained finality – The Plaintiff instituted the Partition Case No. 45/99- 2000 before the Additional Deputy Commissioner seeking imperfect partition of the suit land under the the Regulation, 1886 – The Additional Deputy Commissioner declined to partition the suit land on the ground that the plaintiff was not in actual possession of the land and there was no consent from the other co-sharer of the land – Thereafter, the plaintiff instituted a civil suit, however, the same was dismissed on the ground that the plaintiff was not entitled to seek imperfect partition in view of the bar encoded in s.154(1)(e) of the Regulation, 1886 – The High Court held that the s.154(1)(e) of the the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886 bars the civil court from exercising its jurisdiction – Correctness: *Author 1912 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: The jurisdiction of the civil court u/s.154(1)(e) would be barred only if an imperfect partition suit is otherwise maintainable u/s.97 – To maintain a suit for imperfect partition u/s.97, the appellant has to fulfill two conditions stipulated therein – a) First, the person seeking partition should be in actual possession of the property in respect of which he seeks partition, and; b) Secondly, the co-sharers may not be ready and willing to give their consent and if the person seeking partition is not in actual possession then no other remedy is available to him except to go before the civil court and seek partition on the basis of his own title as a co-owner – A reference in this connection may be made to a decision of the Calcutta High Court in Musstt. Rukeya Banu & Ors. v. Musstt. Nazira Banu & Ors. where it was pointed out that a partition, whether perfect or imperfect, of revenue-paying properties must be made by the Revenue authorities – This follows from a conjoint reading of Sections 96 and 154(1)(e) of the Regulation, 1886 respectively – However, the jurisdiction of the civil court to determine the right of the parties to the property in dispute as well as shares to which they are entitled has not been taken away by the Regulation in question, and it is for the civil court to decide whether the property is or is not liable to partition – The same view applies to other clauses of Section 154 – The parties to a suit are entitled to obtain a declaration from the civil court that they have got the right to obtain from the revenue authorities a separation and allotment of their shares in the estate according to their proportionate rights – It is the civil court which will decide whether the plaintiff is entitled to seek partition and to what extent – If it is found by the court that revenue paying properties have to be partitioned among the parties, the court may declare the share of each of the parties and leave them to go to the revenue authorities for making the necessary performance – Further in various decisions of Gauhati High Court, it is clarified that the bar created by s.154(1) does not preclude suits based on title to the property from being within the jurisdiction of civil courts – The impugned judgment of the High Court is accordingly set aside for not being sustainable in law. [Paras 52, 53-57] Partition – Perfect or imperfect:
Held: Partition is either perfect or imperfect – Perfect partition means division of a revenue paying estate into two or more such [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1913Abdul Rejak Laskar v. Mafizur Rahman & Ors. estates each separately liable for revenue assessed thereon – Imperfect partition means the division of a revenue paying estate into two or more portions jointly liable for the revenue assessed thereon entire estate. [Para 23] Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886 – Chapter VI, s.100 – Perfect partition and imperfect partition:
Held: Chapter VI of the Regulation, 1886 deals with the procedure for carrying out “perfect partition” and “imperfect partition” of a revenue paying estate on the basis of an application made before the Deputy Commissioner – Section 100 of the Regulation, 1886, however, provides that when there is objection as regards the question of title, the Deputy Commissioner will stay his hand in the matter and such objection would be determined by a civil court of competent jurisdiction. [Para 24] Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – s.4 – When CPC is in conflict with Special or Local law:
Held: The plain reading of the said provision would indicate that when anything in the CPC is in conflict with anything in the special or local law or with any special jurisdiction or power conferred or in the special form of procedure prescribed by or under any other law, the Code will not (in the absence of any specific provision to the contrary) prevail so as to override such inconsistent provisions – When there is no conflict between the special or local law and the Code, the Code will apply. [Para 34] Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – s.9 – Jurisdiction of Civil Court: Held: Section 9 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 provides that whenever a question arises before the civil court whether its jurisdiction is excluded expressly or by necessary implication, the Court naturally feels inclined to consider whether the remedy afforded by an alternative provision prescribed by any special statute is sufficient or adequate – In cases where exclusion of the civil court's jurisdiction is expressly provided for, the consideration as to the scheme of the statute in question and the adequacy or sufficiency of the remedy provided for by it may be relevant but cannot be decisive – Where exclusion is pleaded as a matter of necessary implication such consideration would be very important 1914 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and in conceivable circumstances might become even decisive. [Para 29] Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – s.54 – Partition of estate or separation of share:
Held: The plain reading of the s.54 would indicate that the same deals with a case in which a civil court can pass a decree but cannot itself execute it – The execution has to be effected by the Collector – Civil courts have under this Section, jurisdiction to try and decide suits for partition or separate possession of share of estates assessed to payment of revenue to Government but have no power to execute decree passed in such suits – The decree that may be passed by the civil court would declare the rights of the several parties interested in the property, but the decree should direct the actual partition to be made by the Collector or any officer subordinate to him authorized on that behalf. [Para 35] Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – Or.XX, Rule 18 – Decree in suit for partition of property or separate possession of a share: Held: The said rule allows the court to determine the rights of parties with respect to land in the civil court and to pass a preliminary decree, decree in the rights of several parties interested in the property – When actual partition is to be effected, in pursuance of the declaration of the rights of the parties in land, the civil court has to refer the matter to the Collector or any officer subordinate to him authorized to act on behalf of the Collector – Sub-rule (1) refers to partition decrees relating to a “estate assessed to Government revenue” referred to in Section 54 of the Code, while sub-rule
(2) deals with partition decrees relating to any other immovable property or movable property. [Paras 38, 39] Suit – Partition – Types of decrees issued by the Court: Held: In a suit for partition, the court may issue three types of decrees to put the issue to rest: preliminary decree, composite decree (partly preliminary & partly final), and final decree – The purpose of a suit for partition or separation of a share is two-fold: a) First, declaration of plaintiff's share in the suit properties under the preliminary decree, and; b) Secondly, division of his share by metes and bounds which would take place under the final decree. [Para 40] [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1915Abdul Rejak Laskar v. Mafizur Rahman & Ors. Case Law Cited Muthangi Ayyana v. Muthangi Jaggarao & Ors (1977) 1 SCC 241; Dhulabhai & Ors. v. State of M.P. & Anr. [1968] 3 SCR 662; Shankar Balwant Lokhande (Dead) by LRs. v. Chandrakant Shankar Lokhande & Anr. (1995) 2 SCR 776 : AIR 1995 SC 1211; Venkata Reddy & Ors. v. Pethi Reddy [1963] Supp. SCR 616 : AIR 1963 SC 992 – referred to.
Ramagouda Rudregouda Patil v. Lagmavva, 1984 SCC Online Kar 192; Thanda Bala Choudhury and Anr. v. Birendra Kumar Choudhury, 2002 SCC OnLine Gau 26; Daulatram Lakhani v. State of Assam and Ors., 1989 (1) G.L.J. 37; Gauri Shankar Agarwalla v. Madanlal Agarwalla and Ors., 2010 SCC OnLine Gau 465; Moimunnessa v. Faizur Rahman & Ors. (1987) 2 GLR 28; Secretary of State, Represented by the Collector of South Arcot v. Mask & Company AIR 1940 Privy Council 105; Guran Ditta L. v. T.R. Ditta AIR 1935 PC 12; Musstt. Rukeya Banu & Ors. v. Musstt. Nazira Banu & Ors. AIR 1928 Cal 130; Ka Trily Tariang v. U. Resdrikson Lyngdoh and Ors. (1984) 2 G.L.R. 8 – referred to. List of Acts Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
List of Keywords Suit; Partition; Civil Court; Declaration of right, title and interest; Types of decrees; Preliminary decree; Composite decree; Final decree; Jurisdiction of civil court; Perfect partition; Imperfect partition; Section 154(1)(e) of the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886; Section 97 of Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 14805 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 22.08.2022 of the Gauhati High Court in RSA No. 243 of 2014 Appearances for Parties Parthiv K. Goswami, Sr. Adv., Kaushik Choudhury, Saksham Garg, Jyotirmoy Chatterjee, Advs. for the Appellant.
Ms. Mohna, Adv. for the Respondents.
1916 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.B. Pardiwala, J.
For the convenience of exposition, the present judgment is divided into the following parts:
INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX .................................................................. 2 B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT / PLAINTIFF .............................................................................. C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS / DEFENDANTS........................................................................ D. ANALYSIS ................................................................................ 15 i. What is Partition?............................................................... 16 ii. Order XX Rule 18 of the CPC........................................... 22 iii. When does Section 154(1)(e) bar the jurisdiction of civil courts?................................................................................ E. CONCLUSION ........................................................................ 41
1. Leave granted.
2. This appeal arises from the judgment and order passed by the Gauhati High Court in Regular Second Appeal No. 243/2014 dated 22.08.2022, by which the second appeal filed by the respondents herein (original defendants) came to be allowed thereby setting aside the Judgment and order passed by the First Appellate Court and restoring the Judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.
3. For the sake of convenience, the appellant – herein shall be referred to as the original plaintiff and the respondents – herein shall be referred to as the original defendants.
* Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1917Abdul Rejak Laskar v. Mafizur Rahman & Ors.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
4. The facts giving rise to this appeal may be summarized as under. a. It is the case of the appellant herein (original plaintiff) that sometime in 1973, the respondents herein (original defendants nos. 1 and 2 respectively) acquired ownership of 02 katha and 10 lechas of land of one Javed Ali by inheritance. Pursuant thereto, the respondent nos. 1 and 2 respectively as joint owners took over possession of their respective shares each admeasuring 01 katha and 05 lechas.
b. The respondent no. 1 herein vide two separate registered sale deeds dated 18.05.1977 and 25.07.1977 respectively sold his entire 01 katha and 05 lechas of the land in Dag No. 787 of PP No. 127 situated in Nagaon to the appellant herein in the following manner:
i. Registered sale deed no. 3198/77 for 01 katha of land. ii. Registered sale deed no. 6292/1977 for 05 lechas of land. c. Possession over the said portion of the land was handed over to the plaintiff. However, soon thereafter, defendant nos. 1 and 2 tried to forcibly dispossess the plaintiff from the suit property. d. Aggrieved by the forcible dispossession, the appellant herein instituted Title Suit No. 67/1979 for confirmation of his right, title and interest and declaration of possession over the suit land admeasuring 01 katha 05 lechas covered by Dag. No. 787. e. The Title Suit No. 67/79 instituted by the plaintiff came to be decreed in favour of the plaintiff vide judgement and order dated 29.06.1981. Aggrieved by the same, the defendants preferred an appeal against the judgment. The appeal came to be allowed and the matter was remanded back to the Trial Court for fresh consideration in light of the non-joinder of necessary parties. f. Upon fresh trial subsequent to the aforesaid judgment, Title Suit No. 67/79 instituted by the plaintiff came to be dismissed by the court of Munsif vide judgement dated 17.09.1990 holding that although the appellant had acquired right, title and interest over the suit property yet no effective decree could be passed due to non-joinder of necessary parties.
1918 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports g. In view of the aforesaid, the plaintiff herein preferred Title Appeal No. 59/1990 before the Assistant District Judge, Nagaon, Assam seeking to challenge the judgment and order passed by the court of Munsif referred to above.
h. The Appellate Court vide order dated 20.04.1993 passed in Title Appeal No. 59/1990 held that the appellant herein was entitled to a decree for declaration of right, title and interest and also joint possession of suit land along with other co-pattadars. However, the Appellate Court held that as the appellant could not be delivered possession of the suit land, he would be at liberty to seek appropriate remedy, seeking partition of the suit land. i. The defendants herein preferred Second Appeal No. 77 of 1993 before the Gauhati High Court which came to be dismissed vide judgment and order dated 22.10.1998. As a result, the decree passed by the first appellate court attained finality. j. As the plaintiff was granted only joint possession of the suit property vide order dated 20.04.1993, he instituted the Partition Case No. 45/99-2000 before the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Nagaon, seeking imperfect partition of the suit land under the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886 for short, “the Regulation, 1886”.
k. The Additional Deputy Commissioner vide his order dated 12.07.2004 declined to partition the suit land on the ground that the plaintiff was not in actual possession of the land and there was no consent from the other co-sharer of the land.
l. The plaintiff, in such circumstances referred to above, instituted Title Suit No. 83 of 2004 before the Civil Judge Nagaon, praying for delivery of a Khas possession of land measuring 01 kathas 05 lechas to the appellant herein after partition of the land and also prayed for appointment of a commissioner for effecting the partition. The reliefs prayed for in the suit are as under: “It is, therefore, prayed that
(ka) order may be passed for delivery of khas of land measuring 1 katha 5 lechas described in the schedule (ka) of the plaint to the plaintiff after partition of the land;
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1919Abdul Rejak Laskar v. Mafizur Rahman & Ors. (kha) A commissioner may be appointed at the time of partition for effecting partition;
(ga) Issue precept to the revenue authorities for correcting the records and issue of separate patta in favour of plaintiff;
(gha) full cost of the suit may be decreed in favour of the plaintiff;
(unga) any other relief/reliefs which are entitled by the plaintiff under law and equity.”
m. The defendants filed their written statements inter alia taking the stance that the civil court had no jurisdiction, and it is only the revenue authority which has the jurisdiction to partition the land.
n. The Trial Court having regard to the pleadings of the parties framed the following issues for its consideration:
“1) Whether there is any cause of action for the suit? 2) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form?
3) Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties?
4) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for partition of suit land as per provisions of ALRR 1886?
5) Whether the TS 67/79 was decreed in favour of the plaintiff?
6) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree as prayed for?
7) To what other relief/reliefs the parties are entitled?”
o. The Civil Judge (Jr. Div.) No. 1 Nagaon, Assam vide its judgment and order dated 16.07.2011 dismissed the Title Suit No. 83/2004 instituted by the plaintiff on the ground that the plaintiff was not entitled to seek imperfect partition in view of the bar encoded in Section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation, 1886.
1920 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports p. The Trial Court while answering the issues nos. 5, 6 and 7 respectively observed as under:
“Issue No 5:
26.This issue was framed to decide whether TS 67/79 was decreed in favour of the plaintiff. This is a matter of records and there is nothing to prove or disprove this fact. The Ld. Counsel of the parties have not made any submissions in this regard. It appears from the record that initially TS 67/79 was decreed in favour of the plaintiff. Then it went to the first appellate court. The case was again remanded back by the appellate court. In the subsequent occasion the suit was dismissed on the ground that the suit is bad for non-joinder of parties and that no proper identification of the land could be established by the plaintiff and hence no effective decree could be passed.
This issue is decided negatively.
Issue No 6 & 7:
27. This suit is basically for partition of the suit land and for issuance of precept. From the discussions made in issue No 4 it transpires that the plaintiff has failed to prove his entitlement for partition. As such these two issues are decided against the plaintiff.”
q. In such circumstances referred to above, the plaintiff preferred Title Appeal No. 30 of 2011 before the Civil Judge, Nagaon which came to be allowed vide judgment and order dated 16.05.2014, holding that as in the first round of litigation declaration of joint possession had already been issued (vide order dated 20.04.1993 referred to above), plaintiff was entitled to recovery of exclusive Khas possession of his share of 01 kathas and 05 lechas by partition thereof. Furthermore, a direction was issued to the Trial Court to issue precept to the revenue authority to effect the partition. The operative part of the order passed by the First Appellate Court reads thus:- “Appeal is allowed on contest. No cost. Judgment and decree passed by the learned Munsif No.2, [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1921Abdul Rejak Laskar v. Mafizur Rahman & Ors. Nagaon in TS 83/04 dated 16-07-2011 is set aside.
Suit of the plaintiff is decreed. Plaintiff is entitled for partition of his share of 1 Katha 5 lechas of land in suit patta and recovery of possession of his share of purchased 1 katha 5 lechas of land and precept is to be issued to the revenue authority (collector) to cause the partition. Trial Court shall issue precept.
Prepare decree accordingly.”
r. The defendants being dissatisfied with the above filed Regular Second Appeal No. 243 of 2014 before the High Court seeking to challenge the judgment and order dated 16.05.2014 passed in TA No.30 of 2011 referred to above.
s. The High Court formulated two substantial questions of law for its consideration:
“A. Whether the plaintiff/respondent is entitled to get partition of the land being under Section 97 of Assam Land Revenue Regulation?
B. Whether the suit is barred under Section 154 of the Assam Land Revenue Regulation?”
t. The High Court allowed the Second Appeal filed by the defendants and thereby quashed and set aside the Judgment and Decree passed by the First Appellate Court. The High Court held that the Section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation, 1886 bars the civil court from exercising its jurisdiction and further that the revenue court had rightly rejected the prayer of partition under Section 97 as whoever seeks partition of the land must be in possession of the land. The High Court while allowing the Second Appeal observed in Paras 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16 respectively as under:- “12. There is no doubt that a civil court is empowered to decide the right of a person in respect of a property but section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation of 1886 states that no civil court shall exercise jurisdiction in case of claims of persons to imperfect partition, except in cases in which a perfect partition could not be claimed from, and being refused by the revenue authorities on the ground that the result of such partition would 1922 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports be to form a separate estate liable for an annual amount of revenue less than 5 rupees.
13. It is an admitted fact that the revenue authorities refused the prayer of partition made by Abdul Rejak Laskar. It was rejected on the ground that he did not have possession over the said 1.5 kathas of land.
Under Section 97 of Regulation of 1886, whoever seeks partition of a land, he must be in possession of that land. It is also an admitted fact that Abdul Rejak Laskar is not in possession of that land and, therefore, the revenue authorities rightly rejected his prayer for partition.
14. Under the aforesaid premised reasons, the substantial questions of law are answered accordingly.
15. Now, this court is of the opinion that the learned civil judge erroneously reversed the judgment of the Civil Judge (Jr. Division No. 1), Nagaon. Therefore, judgment and decree dated 16.05.2014 passed by the Civil Judge, Nagaon, in Title Appeal No.30/2011 arising out of the judgment and decree dated 16.07.2011 passed by the Munsif No. 2, Nagaon in Title Suit No. 83/2004 is set aside and quashed.
16. Further, the judgment and decree dated 16.07.2011 passed by the Munsif No.2, Nagaon in Title Suit No.83/2004 is affirmed.”
5. Being dissatisfied with the Judgment and order passed by the High Court, referred to above, the plaintiff is here before this Court with the present appeal.
B. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT /
PLAINTIFF
6. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant would submit that Section 97 of the Regulation, 1886 provides that a suit for imperfect partition would be maintainable, inter alia, on two conditions stipulated therein being satisfied:
a. The person seeking partition is in actual possession of the property in respect of which he seeks partition, and;
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1923Abdul Rejak Laskar v. Mafizur Rahman & Ors. b. Consent of the recorded co-sharers of land, holding in aggregate more than one-half of the estate.
7. He submitted that since both these conditions were absent in the case of the appellant herein, the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Nagaon held that the imperfect partition suit was not maintainable before the Revenue Authority. That being the position, the civil court would have jurisdiction to entertain the appellant’s partition suit. He submitted that the jurisdiction of the civil court under Section 154(1)(e) will be barred only if an imperfect partition suit is otherwise maintainable under Section 97. In the facts of the present case, where the ingredients for invoking the remedy of imperfect partition under Section 97 are admittedly absent, the bar contained in Section 154(1)(e) would not apply. He submitted that any other interpretation of the said Regulation would render the appellant remediless in seeking partition, even after having a decree of right, title and possession in his favour.
8. The learned counsel further submitted that the Revenue Authorities are competent to carry out perfect/imperfect partition of an estate only if all the co-sharers give their consent for such amicable partition. However, if there is any dispute with regard to the title or possession raised by any of the co-sharers, the matter will be decided by the competent civil court having jurisdiction over the matter. C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS /
DEFENDANTS
9. On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the respondents submitted that no error not to speak of any error of law could be said to have been committed by the High Court in passing the impugned judgment and order. He submitted that the claim of the appellant herein for imperfect partition is barred under Section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation, 1886 which categorically prohibits the civil courts from entertaining the claims for imperfect partition of revenue paying estates except in those cases where a perfect partition is refused by the revenue authorities under specific conditions.
10. He further submitted that the civil court have been conferred jurisdiction only on the fulfilment of the following conditions, namely: a. Where a perfect partition could not be claimed from the revenue authorities;
1924 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports b. The claim for perfect partition has been refused by the revenue authorities;
c. The bar to the claim or the refusal of the revenue authorities is on the ground that the result of the partition would be to form a separate estate liable for an annual amount of revenue less than five rupees.
11. In the instant case, the claim for imperfect partition by the plaintiff was refused by the revenue authorities on 12.07.2004 on the ground of non-possession. Neither the claim was for perfect partition, nor the grounds for refusal were as mentioned in Sections 154(1) and 154(2) respectively of the Regulation, 1886.
12. In support of his aforesaid submissions, he relied on the judgment rendered by the Single Judge of the High Court in Moimunnessa v. Faizur Rahman & Ors. reported in (1987) 2 GLR 28 paras 4, 5 and 6 which unequivocally held that the partition of revenue-paying estates must be conducted by the Revenue Authorities under Section 54 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as “CPC”).
13. The learned counsel also placed reliance on Section 4 of the CPC which provides that in the absence of any specific provision to the contrary, nothing in this Code shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect any special or local law now in force or any special jurisdiction or power conferred, or any special form of procedure prescribed, by or under any law for the time being in force.
14. He submitted that Section 54 of the CPC mandates that the partition of an undivided estate assessed to revenue shall be conducted by the Collector or a designated revenue officer. The appellant in the present case had bypassed the established procedures by directly approaching the civil court instead of appealing the Additional District Commissioner’s Order before the proper forum, i.e., the Assam Board of Revenue. This procedural violation is in direct conflict with the law already established in Moimunnessa (supra).
15. He submitted that instead of appealing to the Assam Board of Revenue or the Revenue Tribunal, the appellant filed yet another title suit knowing fully well that no effective decree of partition could have been passed because no proper identification of the land could be established by the appellant.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1925Abdul Rejak Laskar v. Mafizur Rahman & Ors.
16. He submitted that the proper authority which can demarcate any land is the Revenue Authorities and not the civil court.
17. According to the learned counsel the judgment and decree dated 16.07.2011 passed by the Munsif No.2, Nagaon in Title Suit No. 83/2004 had rightly returned a finding upon examination of evidence that actual possession is a precondition to succeed in a claim for a partition and that the refusal by the revenue authority was for imperfect partition on the ground of non-possession and not for a claim of perfect partition or for the grounds mentioned in Section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation, 1886. Hence, there was no question of lifting the bar on the jurisdiction of civil courts.
18. He also submitted that the suit land is an estate within the meaning of Section 54 of CPC and the procedure prescribed therein is applicable in the present case.
19. As per Section 97 of the Regulation, 1886, certain pre-conditions are required to be fulfilled for a person claiming partition. From the lower Court records as recorded in the order dated 16.07.2011 in TS 83/2004 as well as the Final Judgment and Order dated 22.08.2022 in RSA No. 243 of 2014, it is evident the appellant did not meet these requirements, thereby rendering the claim for partition untenable.
D. ANALYSIS
20. The short point that falls for our consideration is whether the High Court committed any error in taking view that the suit filed by the appellant herein was barred under Section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation, 1886 referred to above.
21. Section 97 of the Regulation, 1886 reads thus:
“97. Persons entitled to partition.-(1) Every recorded of a permanently settled estate and every recorded landholder of a temporarily-settled estate may, if he is in actual possession of the interest, in respect of which he desires partition, claim perfect or imperfect partition of the estate : Provided that-
(a) no person shall be entitled to apply for perfect partition if the result of such partition would be to form a separate estate, liable for an annual amount of revenue less than five rupees;
1926 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(b) no person shall be entitled to apply for imperfect partition of an estate unless with the consent of recorded co-sharers holding in the aggregate more than one half of the estate;
(c) a person may claim partition only in so far as the partition can be effected in accordance with the provisions of this chapter.
(2) When two or more proprietors land-holders would be entitled under sub-Section (1) to partition in respect of their respective interests in the estate, they may jointly claim partition in respect of the aggregate of their interests.”
22. Section 154(1)(e) of the Regulation, 1886 reads thus: “154. Matters exempted from cognizance of Civil Court.-(1) Except when otherwise expressly provided in this Regulation, or in rules issued under this Regulation, no Civil Court shall exercise jurisdiction in any of the followingxxx xxx xxx
(e) claims of persons to imperfect partition, except in cases in which a perfect partition could not be claimed from, and been refused by, the revenue authorities on the ground that the result of such partition would be to form a separate estate liable for an annual amount of revenue less than five rupees.”
i. What is Partition?
23. Partition is either perfect or imperfect. Perfect partition means division of a revenue paying estate into two or more such estates each separately liable for revenue assessed thereon. Imperfect partition means the division of a revenue paying estate into two or more portions jointly liable for the revenue assessed thereon entire estate.
24. Chapter VI of the Regulation, 1886 deals with the procedure for carrying out “perfect partition” and “imperfect partition” of a revenue paying estate on the basis of an application made before the Deputy Commissioner. Section 100 of the Regulation, 1886, however, provides that when there is objection as regards the question of title, the Deputy Commissioner will stay his hand in the matter and such objection would be determined by a civil court of competent jurisdiction. [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1927Abdul Rejak Laskar v. Mafizur Rahman & Ors.
25. Section 100 of the Regulation, 1886 is quoted hereinbelow: “100. Objection on question of title.— (1) If an objection, preferred as required under section 99 raises any question of title which has not been already determined by a Court of competent jurisdiction, the Deputy Commissioner shall stay his proceedings for such time as, in his opinion, is sufficient to admit of a suit being instituted in the civil court to try the objection.
(2) A Deputy Commissioner staying his proceedings under this section shall make on order requiring the objector, or, if for any reasons he deems it more equitable, the applicant, to institute such a suit within the time fixed, and, in the event of such a suit not being instituted within that time, may in his discretion, disallow the objection, or dismiss the application, as the case maybe.
(3) On a suit being instituted to try any objection under this section, the Deputy Commissioner shall with reference to the objection, be guided by the orders passed by the Civil Court in the suit.”
26. Further, instruction No. 29 of the Part-III of the Executive Instructions framed under the provisions of Assam Land Revenue Reassessment Act, 1936 clearly indicates that the partition of ejmali patta can be carried out by the revenue authorities provided all the shareholders agree and give their consent in writing by putting their signatures in the chitha or otherwise. The said provision is quoted hereinbelow: “29. If the shareholders of an ejmali patta wish to partition amicably their land according to possession and point out the new boundaries, the recorder will survey the boundaries as pointed out, provided all of them agree and give their consent in writing by putting their signatures in the chitha or otherwise. If any co-sharer objects, or if there be dispute about possession, the recorder will not effect the partition.”
27. A bare reading of the provisions contained in Chapter VI of the Regulation, 1886 read with the Rules framed and the Executive Instructions issued under the Assam Land Revenue Re-assessment Act, 1936, leaves no manner of doubt that the Revenue authorities would be competent to carry out perfect/imperfect partition of a revenue paying estate if and only if all the co-sharers give their 1928 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports consent for such amicable partition, i.e., when the application for such partition is made on mutual consent of the parties. However, if there is any dispute as regards the title or possession raised by any of the co-sharers, the Deputy Commissioner has to stay his hands on such process of partition and leave the matter to be decided by a competent civil court having jurisdiction over the matter. The said position also becomes amply evident from the language employed in Order XX Rule 18 read with Section 54 of the CPC.
28. When a suit for partition is instituted seeking declaration of share and separate possession by a co-sharer based on contesting claim of title, the Revenue authorities cannot proceed to decide such a question as per the scheme of the Regulation, 1886. However, the High Court under a serious misconception of law appears to have taken a contrary view in the matter by holding that it is the civil court which would have no jurisdiction to try the suit once an application for partition is entertained by the revenue authorities concerning the subject-matter of the suit.
29. Section 9 of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908 provides that whenever a question arises before the civil court whether its jurisdiction is excluded expressly or by necessary implication, the Court naturally feels inclined to consider whether the remedy afforded by an alternative provision prescribed by any special statute is sufficient or adequate. In cases where exclusion of the civil court’s jurisdiction is expressly provided for, the consideration as to the scheme of the statute in question and the adequacy or sufficiency of the remedy provided for by it may be relevant but cannot be decisive. Where exclusion is pleaded as a matter of necessary implication such consideration would be very important and in conceivable circumstances might become even decisive.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.