Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 1044; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1482
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bela M. Trivedi, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma
- Decided
- 19 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5273/2008
- Sections
- 13(6), 12(1), 2(1), 21A, 12, 2, 21, 35A, 56, 10, 2(46), 74
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1482 : 2024 INSC 1044 Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd.
v.
Awaz & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 5273 of 2008)
20 December 2024 [Bela M. Trivedi and Satish Chandra Sharma,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration
(i) Whether the Respondent organization had the locus to approach the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC);
(ii) Whether the NCDRC had the jurisdiction to interfere with banking operations, which is the exclusive statutory domain of the Reserve Bank of India; (iii) Whether the NCDRC had the jurisdiction to fix a maximum ceiling rate of interest to be charged by banks from their credit card holders for their failure to make full payment on the due date, at the behest of the Reserve Bank of India & unilaterally direct banks/non-banking financial institutions to charge rates of interest not beyond the 30% p.a., in absence of an instruction/ directive of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI); (iv) Whether the Impugned Judgment interferes with the contract executed between the parties; (v) Whether charging rate of interests by banks in the manner as advised by RBI vide its master circulars and notifications being independent of a standard ceiling rate prescribed by the RBI, constitute an unfair trade practice.
Headnotes† Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – ss.12(1), 13(6), 2(1)(d) – “consumer” – Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 – Respondent nos. 1 and 2-Trusts claiming themselves to be a voluntary consumer association fighting for consumer rights, if had the locus to approach the National Commission – The original complaint, if met the threshold of ss.12(1) and 13:
Held: No – The original Complaint before the Commission which was filed in a representative capacity, by the Trust, representing all consumers purportedly aggrieved owing to the exorbitant rates of interest charged by the banks, was filed without complying with * Author [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1483Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors. the mandate of Or. I, r.8, CPC prescribed u/s.13(6) – No order was passed by the National Commission permitting the Respondent nos.1 and 2 to represent the interest or act on behalf of any consumer – Complainants filed the application u/s.13(6) seeking permission to act “on behalf of consumers” only at the stage of conclusion of arguments, and judgment being reserved – Since, the requirement of Or. I r.8, prescribed in s.13(6) is to be read into s.12(1), the requirement of obtaining prior permission from the Commission, for any consumer to act in a representative capacity, cannot be dispensed with – Further, a trust is not a “person” as defined u/s.2(1)(m) of the 1986 Act and therefore not a consumer and thus, cannot file a consumer dispute under the 1986 Act – Also, the consumer complaint did not disclose any deficiency in service or violation and was in fact a public interest litigation in guise of a purported consumer dispute – Respondents approached the National Commission at the behest of the Respondent no.3, a credit card holder with Citibank, purportedly claiming an amount of Rs. 90,000/- against excess interest charged by the bank, which is barred by the pecuniary jurisdiction of the Commission – Furthermore, the administrative policy decisions of banks do not constitute provisions/facilities of banking, which may come under the umbrella of ‘service’, defined u/s.2(1)(o) of the 1986 Act – A policy decision pertaining to the rate of interest, and trade practices carried out by the banks across the country is a regulatory function within the specific statutory domain of the RBI and cannot come under the purview of judicial scrutiny by the National Commission – National Commission erred in holding that any complaint under the 1986 Act to curb unfair trade practice(s) adopted by the banks is maintainable – National Commission had no jurisdiction to entertain a complaint having vague, ambiguous allegations and no cause of action – Order of the National Commission set aside. [Paras 42-47, 57] Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 – Banking Regulation Act, 1949 – s.21A – Whether the NCDRC has the jurisdiction to interfere with banking operations which is the exclusive statutory domain of the RBI – Whether the NCDRC had the jurisdiction to fix a maximum ceiling rate of interest to be charged by banks from their credit card holders for their failure to make full payment on the due date, at the behest of the RBI and unilaterally direct banks/non-banking financial 1484 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports institutions to charge rates of interest not beyond the 30% p.a., in absence of an instruction/directive of the RBI: Held: RBI is the prime banking institution of the country and a statutory authority entrusted with the supervisory role over banking and conferred with the authority of issuing binding directions having statutory force – NCDRC assumed jurisdiction and expertise over the RBI observing that a ceiling on the rates of interest is the purported solution to the alleged exploitation of credit card holders – It made observations contrary to the legislative intent of s.21A of the 1949 Act that provides for a statutory bar on any court/tribunal to re-open transactions, that the rate of interest charged by the banking company in respect of such transaction is excessive – The decision of the National Commission unilaterally holding that any interest above 30% p.a. is usurious is contrary to the legislative intent of s.21A and is an encroachment upon the domain of the RBI – The challenge by the complainants that the guidelines issued by the RBI are arbitrary and not in public interest is without any basis – RBI is the prime regulator and the decision-making authority for the economic/financial decisions of the Indian economy, any endeavor by the National Commission or any other Court/Tribunal to decide at the behest of the RBI cannot be termed to be just, fair and equitable – An endeavour to cap the rate of interest charged by banks and dictating the need for a Benchmark Prime Lending Rate, drawing parallels with other economies across the world, whilst failing to trust the prudence of the RBI which is entrusted with the fundamental responsibility of regulation of the monetary system and banking business is unwarranted – A direction cannot be issued to the RBI, to enact a particular legislation. [Paras 48, 50, 51, 56, 58-60] Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – s.2(1)(m) – “person” – Trust, if a “person” and whether can file a consumer dispute under the 1986 Act:
Held: A trust, whether registered under the Indian Trust Act or the State Trust Registration Act is not a “person” as defined u/s.2(1)
(m) of the 1986 Act – The issue whether a Trust would come within the purview of consumer has been referred to a larger bench in Administrator Smt. Tata Bai Desai Charitable Opthalmic Trust Hospital, Jodhpur case, however, the ratio in Pratibha Pratisthan case holding that a trust is not a person and therefore not a [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1485Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors. consumer and consequently cannot invoke provisions or file a consumer dispute under the provisions of this Act, is the position of law in force – Indian Trust Act, 1882 – State Trust Registration Act. [Para 44] Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 – Notifications, circulars, direction/guideline issued by RBI – Nature:
Held: Any direction or guideline issued by a statutory authority is an extension of the statute itself – Rules made under a statute must be treated, for all purposes of construction or obligations, exactly as if they were in that Act – The notifications, circulars and directions of the RBI are nothing but the legislative expression of the ‘statement of object & reasons’ encapsulated in the preamble of the 1934 Act – Hence, the statutory presumption that the legislature while formulating laws has inserted every part thereunder for a purpose and that legislative intention, which should be given effect to, would be applicable to the present guidelines as well – National Commission had no jurisdiction to assume the jurisdiction of the RBI, or act/decide or regulate on its behest, any monetary decision or policy. [Paras 56, 57] Contract – Terms of the contract, if can be re-written – Whether the Impugned Judgment of the National Commission interferes with the contract executed between the parties:
Held: Yes – The credit card holders in the present case were well-informed and educated and agreed to be bound by the express stipulation by the terms issued by the respective banks – The banks in the most important terms and conditions provided all necessary information with regard to fees, and charges applicable to credit cards, credit and cash withdrawal limits – Once the terms of the credit card operations were known to the complainants and disclosed by the banking institutions before the issuance of the credit cards, the National Commission could not have scrutinized the terms or conditions, including the rate of interest – National Commission had no jurisdiction to re-write the said terms of the contract entered between the banks and the credit cardholders, which the parties mutually agreed to be bound by. [Paras 63, 65] Economic legislation/notification – Validity – To be tested on the touchstone of reasonableness:
1486 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: In deciding the validity of any economic legislation or notification having a public objective sought to be attained, it is imperative to test it on the touchstone of reasonableness – In the absence of any patent arbitrariness, the directions cannot be condemned as being violative of Part III of the Constitution of India – In the present case, it is not the case of the Complainants that the directions or decisions taken by the statutory authority entrusted to manage the economy, do not pass the test of Wednesbury principle of reasonableness, or are not free from arbitrariness nor affected by bias or actuated by mala fide. [Para 61] Unfair trade practice – What is not – Whether charging rate of interests by banks in the manner as advised by RBI vide its master circulars & notifications being independent of a standard ceiling rate prescribed by the RBI, constitute an unfair trade practice:
Held: No – Any trade practice adopted for promoting the sale, use, or supply of any goods, or for the provision of any service, by adopting any unfair method or unfair or deceptive practice, has to be treated as ‘unfair trade practice’ – Thus, whether an act can be condemned as an unfair trade practice, or not, the key is to examine the ‘modus operandi’ i.e. whether there is any false statement/misrepresentation or deception – In the present case, the pre-conditions of ‘deceptive practice’ and unfair method’ are manifestly absent – The Banks in no manner made any misrepresentation to deceive the credit card holders – RBI held that none of the bank acted contrary to the policy directives issued by the RBI – Even otherwise, there is no averment to establish how the charging of rates of interest upon the default by credit card holders, without a standardized rate, is usurious and constitutes an unfair trade practice – Mere inflation in the rates of interest cannot be construed as a practice, intended to cause loss or injury. [Paras 68, 69] Case Law Cited Keshav Lal Khemchang & Sons Pvt. Ltd & Ors. v. Union of India (2015) 4 SCC 770; Central Bank of India v. Ravindran (2002) 1 SCC 367; Union of India v. Prakash P. Hinduja (2003) 6 SCC 195; Pratibha Pratisthan v. Canara Bank (2017) 3 SCC 712; Godfrey Phillips India Ltd. v. Ajay Kumar [2008] 5 SCR 937 : (2008) 4 SCC 504 : 2008 SCC OnLine SC 603; Pioneer Urban Land [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1487Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors. and Infrastructure v. Geetu Gidwani Verma & Anr. (2019) 5 SCC 725; Ireo Grace v. Abhishek Khanna [2021] 2 SCR 1 : (2021) 3 SCC 241; Experion Developers Pvt Ltd v. Sushma Ashok Shiroor [2022] 5 SCR 590 : (2022) 12 SCC 286; Texco Marketing Pvt. Ltd. v. TATA AIG GIC [2022] 9 SCR 1031 : [2023] 1 SCC 428; L.Chandra Kumar v. Union of India & Ors. [1997] 2 SCR 1186 : [1997] 3 SCC 261; Rameshwar Prasad Shrivastava & Ors. v. Dwarkadhis Projects Private Limited & Ors [2018] 14 SCR 1118 : (2019) 2 SCC 417; Administrator Smt. Tata Bai Desai Charitable Opthalmic Trust Hospital, Jodhpur v. Managing Director, Supreme Elevators India Pvt. Ltd. & Ors., SLP(Civil) No. 18636/2019; Shri Sitaram Sugar Company Ltd. v. Union of India [1990] 1 SCR 909 : (1990) 3 SCC 223; Small Industries Development Bank of India v. SIBCO Investment (P) Ltd. [2022] 1 SCR 913 : (2022) 3 SCC 56; Supreme Court Employees Welfare Association v. Union of India [1989] 3 SCR 488 : (1989) 4 SCC 187; Peerless General Finance & Investment Co. Ltd. & Anr. v. Reserve Bank of India [1992] 1 SCR 406 : (1992) 2 SCC 343; Rajasthan State Industrial Development & Investment Corporation v. Diamond & Gem Development Corporation Ltd. [2013] 4 SCR 331; Bharathi Knittting Company v. Worldwide Express Courier Division of Airfrieght Ltd. [1996] Supp. 2 SCR 653 : (1996) 4 SCC 704; Colgate Palmolive (India) Ltd. v. MRTP Commission [2002] Supp. 4 SCR 219 : (2003) 1 SCC 129; Directorate of Education v. Educomp Datamatics Ltd. [2004] 2 SCR 1010 : (2004) 4 SCC 19 – referred to.
List of Acts Consumer Protection Act, 1986; Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934; Banking Regulation Act, 1949; Indian Trust Act, 1882; Consumer Protection Act, 2019; Indian Contract Act, 1872; Code of Civil Procedure, 1908; Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Credit card holders; Maximum ceiling rate of interest; Reserve Bank of India; Domain of the RBI; Borrowers/debtors; Banking operations; Banks/non-banking financial institutions; Unfair trade practice; Misrepresentation; Trust; Consumer; “Person”; Voluntary consumer association; Representative capacity; Locus to approach the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC); Exorbitant rates of interest; “On behalf of consumers”; 1488 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports No deficiency in service; Re-write the terms of the contract; Guidelines issued by RBI; Cap the rate of interest charged by banks; Economic legislation/notification; Test of Wednesbury principle of reasonableness.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 5273 of 2008 From the Judgment and Order dated 07.07.2008 of the National Consumers Disputes Redressal Commission, New Delhi in OP No. 51 of 2007 and 1913 of 2004 With Civil Appeal No(s). 5294, 5627, 5278 and 6679 of 2008 Appearances for Parties Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Manish Singhvi, Dhruv Mehta, Jaideep Gupta, Sr. Advs., Dr. Kishan Rawat, Ms. Mallika Joshi, Rajan Narain, Chanchal Kumar Ganguli, Mrs. Suruchi Suri, Ms. Nupur, Mayur Shah, Apurv Singhvi, Ms. Shalini Haldar, Shankar Divate, Sanjay Gupta, Ateev Mathur, Ajay Monga, Ms. Varsha Kripalani, Ms. Jagriti Ahuja, Ananta Prasad Mishra, Gagan Gupta, Amand Raj Gandhi, Partha Sarthy Bose, Lukshay Kumar, Keith Varghese, Ms. Bindi Girish Dave, Mrs. Shiel Sethi, Ms. Nina Gupta, Dr. Lalit Bhasin, Ms. Radhika Gupta, Vijay Gupta, Shiv Vinayak Gupta, Mrs. Bina Gupta, Shantanu Tyagi, Ms. Neha Goel, Shashvat Chandra, S. S. Shroff, Manish K. Bishnoi, H. S. Parihar, Kuldeep S. Parihar, Ms. Ikshita Parihar, Kunal Chatterjee, Satish Singh, Riddi Bose, Ms. Sampriti Baksi, Siddarth Banerjee, Mahesh Kumar, Advs. for the appearing parties.
Judgment/Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Satish Chandra Sharma, J.
1. The captioned set of appeals arise out of the common Judgment & Order dated 07.07.2008 passed by the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Delhi (hereinafter “National Commission/ NCDRC”) in Complaint Case No. 51/2007 and Revision Petition [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1489Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors. No. 1913/2004. No appeal has been preferred from either of the parties, in the Revision Petition No. 1913/2004.
2. The National Commission proceeded with the prima-facie view that the charging of interest at rates ranging from 36% to 49% p.a. is exorbitant and amounts to the exploitation of the borrowers/debtors and is usurious, had framed the following issues:
i. Whether the Reserve Bank of India (hereinafter referred to as RBI) is required to issue any circular or guidelines prohibiting the Banks/Non-Banking Financial Institutions/ money lenders from charging interest above a specific rate? ii. (a) Whether banks can charge the credit card users interest at rates from 36% to 49% per annum if there is any delay or default in payment within the time specified?
(b) Whether interest at the above-stated rates amounts to charging usurious rates of interest?
3. The Appellants, Hong Kong Shanghai Corporation, Citibank, American Express Banking Corporation, Standard Chartered Bank, vide C.A. no. 5273/2008, C.A. No. 5294/2008, C.A. No. 5627/2008 and C.A. 5278/2008 respectively along with the Intervenor, Housing Development Finance Corporation (I.A. No. 6/2017) [hereinafter “Banks”] have challenged the correctness of the Impugned Order dated 07.07.2008, whereby the National Commission has held that the charging of interest at rates beyond 30% by the banks/non-banking financial institutions, from credit card holders, upon delay or default in payment, constitutes an unfair trade practice and that penal interest could be charged only once for one period of default and the same shall not be capitalized. The conclusive observation under challenge, passed by the National Commission is as under:
(i) Charging of interest rates in excess of 30% p.a. from the credit card holders by banks for the former’s failure to make full payment on the due date or paying the minimum amount due, is an unfair trade practice.
(ii) Penal interest can be charged only once for one period of default and shall not be capitalized.
(iii) Charging of interest with monthly rests is also an unfair trade practice 1490 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4. The Appellants have contended that determining the reasonability and ‘fixing of the maximum or the minimum rates of interest’, is the exclusive function of the Respondent no.6, the Reserve Bank of India, a statutory authority responsible for the regulation of the Indian Banking system. The Appellants have assailed the observations of the National Commission, in light of the statutory bar under section 21A & 35A of the Banking Regulation Act, which expressly bars courts/tribunals to re-open transactions between banks, on the question that the rates of interest are excessive and empowers the Reserve Bank of India, to formulate directions, as befitting the public interest, proper management and banking policies of the country. The Appellants have urged that the encroachment of this statutory domain of the Reserve Bank of India, by the National Commission, is against the mandate of the Constitution and the legislative intent of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934. The Appellants have further contended that the original complaint by the Respondent nos. 1-3 not only fails to meet the criterion of a Complaint u/s 12 r/w 13 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, but is a public interest litigation, guised as a consumer dispute which could not have been entertained by the National Commission, being beyond its inherent jurisdiction.
5. The Respondents nos. 1 to 3, the original Complainants [hereinafter “Complainants”] before the National Commission, have also preferred a cross-Appeal bearing CA. 6679/2008, against the Impugned Judgment dt. 07.07.2008 contending that the National Commission has only partly allowed their complaint, and ought to have adjudicated upon a benchmark restriction for the rates of interest charged by banks from credit card holders. It is contended that the rates of interest charged by the banks from its credit cardholders is usurious and exploitative in nature, and in contravention of the circulars issued by the Reserve Bank of India. The Complainants claim that they represent the public at large, as a voluntary consumer association voicing against the usurious rate of interest charged by the banks, which is a deficiency in service in banking and constitutes an unfair trade practice, in terms of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. It is argued on behalf of the Complainants that there ought to have been a Notification passed by the Reserve Bank of India, fixing a maximum ceiling rate of interest for all banks, and in pursuance thereto had approached the National Commission by filing the [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1491Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors. Consumer Complaint no. 51 of 2007. It was prayed that the Appellant along with Respondent nos. 5, 6 & 7 be permanently restrained from charging excessive interest and service charges, de-hors the Prime Lending Rate, and the directions issued by the Reserve Bank of India. It was further prayed that all banks who have issued credit cards to Respondent no. 3 and members of the Respondent no.1 be directed to refund the amount of interest, claiming the same to be more than Rs. 5 crores.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF BANKS
6. The Appellant, along with the Respondent nos. 5, 6 and 7 are foreign banks carrying on the business of banking in India under the provisions of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 and are scheduled commercial Banks as notified by the Reserve Bank of India.
7. The Appellants submit that the allegations raised by the Complainant that the rate of interest, charged by banks from its credit card holders, constitutes an unfair trade practice, is erroneous. It is stated that the modus of adopting any unfair methods, or deceptive means to promote the sale, use or supply of any goods or for providing any service, is manifestly absent. The Banks assert that they have neither indulged in any unfair trade practice nor have done anything which would bring them within the mischief of Section 2(r)(l)(i) to 2(r)(l)(x).
8. Further, there are also no specific allegations raised by the Complainants or any materials on record, to elicit any unfair trade practices adopted by the Banks. The Counsel for the Appellant submits that the National Commission has barely acted on the assumption that banks are indulging in unfair trade practices. It is stated that there are no facts to suggest that any of the scheduled banks under the purview of the Reserve Bank of India, are indulging in unfair trade practices, including charging exorbitant rates of interest. The National Commission has made the observation that rates of interest charged by banks is an unfair trade practice, without even discussing the scope of the definition under section 2(1)(r) of the Act. The only reason given with respect to the practice of charging excessive interest being unfair trade practice is that “if the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 requires that the RBI shall discharge certain functions in the public interest and the RBI does not discharge such 1492 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports functions, it would amount to unfair trade practice, but, that question is not required to be dealt with finally in this matter.”
9. It is argued that the exercise of jurisdiction by the National Commission is ostensible and non-est in law. The administrative policy decisions of the determination of interest on credit cards and the regulation of the banks across the country, are within the specific statutory domain of the Reserve Bank of India. The Parliament of India, under List I of the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution of India had conferred upon the Reserve Bank of India, the powers of subordinate legislation to formulate directives, circulars, and administrative policies, having statutory force and being binding on all Banks from time to time 1 Our attention is also drawn to the Preamble of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 which enlists the endeavour of the RBI to “ secure monetary stability in India, having a modern monetary policy framework to meet the challenge of an increasingly complex economy, while maintaining price stability is the endeavour of the Reserve Bank of India.
10. The observations by the National Commission that the rate of interest, in excess of 30% per annum is an unfair trade practice, is per se illegal and is an interference with the clear, unambiguous delegation of powers in favour of the Reserve Bank of India and runs contrary to the legislative intent of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949.
11. It is submitted that the National Commission has ostensibly exercised jurisdiction by supplanting itself as the regulator of the banking systems instead and in the place of Reserve Bank of India, notwithstanding the bar under section 21A of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949. It is contended that Section 21A and 35A of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 are enabling provisions for the Reserve Bank of India to give directions/guidelines to banks/banking companies, in the public interest. Section 21A in specific, creates an embargo upon courts/tribunals to re-open and adjudicate upon transactions on the ground that the rate of interest is excessive. The said provisions are reproduced as under:
“21A: Rates of interest charged by banking companies not to be subject to scrutiny by courts:
1 Keshav Lal Khemchang & Sons Pvt. Ltd & Ors. Vs Union of India (2015) 4 SCC 770 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1493Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors. Notwithstanding anything contained in the Usurious Loans Act, 1918 (10 of 2018), or any other law relating to indebtedness in force in any State, a transaction between a banking company and its debtor shall not be reopened by any court on the ground that the rate of interest charged by the banking company in respect of such transaction is excessive.”
35A: Power of the Reserve Bank to give directions:
(1) Where the Reserve Bank is satisfied that:
(a) In the public interest; or
(aa) in the interest of banking policy; or [inserted by Act 58 in the [public interest]; or
(b) to prevent the affairs of any banking company being conducted in a manner detrimental to the interests of the depositors or in a manner prejudicial to the interests of the banking company; or
(c) to secure the proper management of any banking company generally, it is necessary to issue directions to banking companies generally or to any banking company in particular, it may, from time to time, issue such directions as it deems fit, and the banking companies or the banking company, as the case may be, shall be bound to comply with such directions.
(1)The Reserve Bank may, on representation made to it or on its own motion, modify or cancel any direction issued under sub-section (1), and in so modifying or cancelling any direction may impose such conditions as it thinks fit, subject to which the modification or cancellation shall have effect.”
12. The scope of the statutory bar under section 21-A of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 has been comprehensively dealt with by this Hon’ble Court in the Central Bank of India Vs Ravindran2 wherein it has been observed that “With effect from 15.2.1984, Section 21A 2 Central Bank of India Vs Ravindran (2002) 1 SCC 367 1494 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports has been inserted in the Act, which takes away power of the court to reopen a transaction between a banking company and its debtor on the ground that the rate of interest charged is excessive. The provision has been given an overriding effect over the Usurious Loans Act, 1918 and any other provincial law in force relating to indebtedness.” It was also observed by this Hon’ble Court, that for all transactions, which may not be squarely governed by such circulars, the RBI directives may be treated as standards for the purpose of deciding whether the interest charged is excessive, usurious or opposed to public policy. Thus, in view of this statutory bar, the Complaint of the Respondent nos.1 to 3, which is only based on the higher rates of interest, could not have been entertained by the National Commission and deserved to be dismissed at the very threshold.
13. Further, in exercise of powers conferred under Section 35A read with Section 56 of the Banking Regulation Act, 1959 & being satisfied that it is necessary and expedient in the public interest so to do, it is also well within the exclusive jurisdiction of the Reserve Bank of India to take corrective and/or penal steps, suo-moto or on receipt of any representation or inquiry thereof, qua any such act in deference to its policy or circular.
14. The Appellants therefore urge that the maxima or minima of the interest could not have been decided by the Consumer Forum, as it is the specific statutory domain of the Reserve Bank of India and it is the directives of RBI alone that may be treated as standard for the purpose of deciding whether the interest charged is excessive, usurious or opposed to public policy3 Ld. Counsel for the Banks, also submits that in absence of a statutory direction by the Reserve Bank of India, with respect to a maximum ceiling rate, the Banks could not be held liable for any unfair trade practices. More-so, they are bound by the circulars of the Reserve Bank of India and have formulated policies accordingly.
15. It has been further argued that once an executive authority exercises a legislative power by way of subordinate legislation, pursuant to a delegated authority of a legislature, such executive authority cannot be asked to enact a law, which he has been empowered to do under the delegated legislative authority.4 A direction by the National 3 Keshav Lal Khemchang & Sons Pvt. Ltd & Ors. Vs Union of India [supra] 4 Union of India Vs Prakash P. Hinduja (2003) 6 SCC 195 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1495Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors. Commission to the Reserve Bank of India to issue directions on Benchmark Rates of Interest, is an attempt to usurp the jurisdiction, and can in no manner be considered lawful and tenable.
16. On merits, it is the assertion of the Appellants that the rates of interest formulated by them, are in conformity with the directions of the Reserve Bank of India. As a matter of policy pursuant to the liberalization of the economy and consequent deregulation of interest rates, the RBI vide Circulars dated 21.10.2003 and 02.07.2007 provided that: “Credit card dues are in the nature of non-priority sector personal loans, and as such, banks are free to determine the rate of interest on credit card dues without reference to their BPLR and regardless of the size”
The same circulars also gave comprehensive directions on charging interest rates on advances and the Benchmark Prime Lending Rate (BPLR) as under:
“Benchmark Prime Lending Rate (BPLR) and Spreads:
2.2.1 With effect from October 18, 1994, RBI has deregulated the interest rates on advances above Rs.
2 lakhs and the rates of interest on such advances are determined by the banks themselves subject to BPLR and Spread guidelines. For credit limits up to Rs. 2 lakh banks should charge interest not exceeding their BPLR.
Keeping in view the international practice, and to provide operational flexibility to commercial banks in deciding their lending rates, banks can offer loans at below BPLR to exporters or other creditworthy borrowers, including public enterprises, on the basis of a transparent and objective policy approved by their respective Boards. Banks will continue to declare the maximum spread of interest rates over BPLR.
2.2.3. Banks are free to determine the rates of interest without reference to BPLR and regardless of the size in respect of loans for purchase of consumer durables, loans to individuals against shares and debenture/bonds, other non-priority sector personal loans, etc. as per details given in paragraph 2.4.
1496 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
2.4. Freedom to fix Lending Rates:
2.4.1 Banks are free to determine the rates of interest without reference to BLPR and regardless of the size………………..”
17. The said circulars clarify that credit card dues constitute non-priority sector personal loans and Banks are free to determine the rates of interest, without reference to PLR and regardless of their size. The Reserve Bank of India had given this discretion to the banks to determine rates of interest, as per the market forces, while maintaining transparency with the credit card holders. The Appellants assert that they have duly complied with all the requirements of the Reserve Bank of India, and none of the practices adopted by them, run contrary to the intent or directions of the Reserve Bank of India and its circulars.
18. The rates of interest on credit card dues are neither usurious nor do they constitute a practice that is unfair, arbitrary or unreasonable. The practice of charging any interest on credit-cards dues is such that credit card generally carry an interest rate on an annualised basis (Annual Interest Rate-APR). The interest due is calculated only on unpaid balances. Any customer who pays in the entire amount being the value of the said transaction, within the due date of payment, is not charged any interest. The penalty or cost of such interest is incurred once, there is default, which takes into account costs to the bank of non-performing loans (bad debt), acquisition costs, and are not unreasonable.
19. It is submitted that the charging of interest by the Bank is in accordance with the circulars issued by the RBI and cannot an unfair trade practice as the interest is paid only by those who default in making payments of their credit-card bills, after having enjoyed free credit for periods ranging between 17-55 days, or those who do not make payment of the entirety of their dues on each bill, and then on the balance dues. Most pertinently, the terms and conditions for charging of rates of interest or charges applicable thereto, have been duly informed to all customers by way of the Most Important Terms and Conditions issued by the Banks, which are the standard set of conditions for the issuance and usage of credit cards, thereby defining the responsibilities of the card issuer and the cardholder, and contain information with regard to fee, charges applicable on credit cards, [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1497Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors. finance charges and withdrawal limits, and are also provided at the time of the generation of each monthly bank/billing statement. The customer from day one is aware that in the event of there being a delayed payment, he would be liable to pay the interest.
20. A preliminary objection has also been raised by the Banks, that the Respondent nos. 1 & 2, do not qualify as a ‘consumer’ under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 and have no locus standi to approach the National Commission. The Respondent nos. 1 & 2, are registered trusts, that claim to fight for consumer rights, are not purchasers of any goods, nor have they availed any services. The Complainant trust does not meet the requirements under section 2(b) & 2(d)) read with Section 12(c) and 13(6) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 and cannot be considered a voluntary consumer association. Be that as it may, a trust, whether registered under the Indian Trust Act, or the State Trust Registration Act, is not a person ‘person’ as defined under Section 2(1)(m) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, and & therefore not a consumer and consequently cannot invoke provisions or file a consumer dispute under the provisions of this Act.5
21. It is further submitted by the Appellants that the Respondents had approached the National Commission at the behest of the Respondent no. 3, one Mr. Thakur a credit card holder with Citibank, purportedly claiming an amount of Rs. 90,000/- against excess interest charged by the bank. Ld. Senior Counsel submits that the purported claim is ex-facie barred by section 21(a) of the Consumer Protection Act, which mandates the Commission to entertain claims only above Rs. 1 crore. More-so, the alleged concern “about an excessive exorbitant rate of interest being charged by the Respondent no. 2 and other similarly placed banks. But not getting proper guidance about it, hence could not challenge grievances about excessive rate of interest on credit card facilities” is wholly insufficient to constitute an unfair trade practice. Further, the pleading raised by the said Complainant, is improper and devoid of any material particulars to sustain a complaint. It not only fails to indicate how the concerned Respondent has suffered a deficiency of service; it does not disclose the date of purported default or alleged damage, or any particular date/rate of interest charged from him due to such default. 5 Pratibha Pratisthan Vs Canara Bank (2017) 3 SCC 712 1498 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
22. It has been further submitted that the consumer complaint was purportedly filed in a representative capacity by the Respondents, ought to have complied with the provisions of Order 1 Rule VIII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 as mandated under Section 13(6) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986. 6 In terms of Section 13(6) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, it was necessary for the Complainants to take necessary permission of the National Commission to sustain a complaint in a representative capacity. Our attention is drawn to an application filed by the Complainant, under section 13(6) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, and it has been brough to our notice that:
(a) No application seeking such permission to file a Complaint in a representative capacity was filed up till the point of conclusion of arguments and reservation of judgment 22.05.2008.
(b) Even otherwise, the application (undated) filed by the Complainant was done so subsequently, upon the reservation of the Judgement.
(c) The application was never adjudicated upon by the Commission, and no attempt had been made by the Complainants to file review against the final order in this regard.
23. It is stated that the Complaint could not have been filed in a representative capacity on behalf of all credit card holders across the spectrum, as only a handful of banks were impleaded as a party to the Complaint. Even otherwise, no notice of any kind whatsoever was issued to any other bank by the Hon’ble Commission for adequate representation, so as to further treat the complaint in a representative capacity. The scheduled banks notified by the Reserve Bank of India are engaged in the business of credit card, hence any representation at the behest of other banks, or directions to other banks, could not be done in a piecemeal manner. Most pertinently, all banks come under the regulation and supervision of the Reserve Bank of India, which is the statutory authority empowered to regularize, notify and further direct guidelines for the functioning of these Banks. 6 Godfrey Phillips India Ltd. v. Ajay Kumar (2008) 4 SCC 504 : 2008 SCC OnLine SC 603 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1499Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corp. Ltd. v. Awaz & Ors.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.