Pawan Kumar v. Union of India & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 1041; [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1253
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 18 Dec 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 14689/2024
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 12 S.C.R. 1253 : 2024 INSC 1041 Pawan Kumar v.
Union of India & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 14689 of 2024)
18 December 2024 [J.B. Pardiwala and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Pursuant to an advertisement published by the Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited (“BPCL”), the appellant made an online application for being appointed/ allotted a regular and rural retail outlet. The appellant was selected on draw on lots and he offered a suitable piece of land for purchase/lease belonging to third parties - Shri Lila Dhar and Shri Dinesh Kumar, whose consent letters were made available along with the application. At the time of application, there was some dispute between Mr. Lila Dhar and Mr. Dinesh Kumar as regards the land which was offered by the appellant. But the same ultimately came to be settled to the satisfaction of the Corporation before they issued the Letter of Intent. An unsuccessful contender in the application process filed a writ petition challenging the allotment to the appellant on ground of ‘False information’. The High Court allowed the writ petition. The appellant is before the Hon’ble Supreme Court against that order.
The issue before the Hon’ble Supreme Court was as to when a Constitutional Court can interfere with the decision of the Public Sector Undertaking (PSU) allotting retail outlets.
Headnotes† Judicial review – When can a Constitutional Court interfere with the decision of the allotment of retail outlets made by Public Sector Undertaking:
Held: The Court shall interfere with the decision of allotment of dealership when the Corporation (PSU) shows outright favor to the appellant – Once the PSU was convinced with the entire procedure undertaken by the appellant, the Constitutional Courts have no business interfering with the allotment – Power of judicial 1254 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports review would be called for if the approach of the PSU is arbitrary or mala fide or procedure adopted is meant to favor one of the applicants – The decision-making process should clearly show that the said maladies are kept at bay. [Paras 22-23, 25] Tenders – When should a Constitutional Court exercise Judicial Restraint with regard to the decision of PSU Corporations granting it:
Held: The PSU that authors the tender documents is the best person to understand and appreciate its requirements and interpret its documents and therefore, the constitutional courts must defer to this understanding and appreciation of the tender documents, unless there is mala fide or perversity in the understanding or appreciation or in the application of the terms of the tender conditions – For the mere reason that the PSU has given an interpretation to the tender documents that is not acceptable to the constitutional courts it cannot be a reason to interfere with the interpretation – Where a decision is taken that is manifestly in consonance with the language of the tender document or subserves the purpose for which the tender is floated, the court should follow the principle of restraint and technical evaluation or comparison by the court would be impermissible – The principle that is applied to scan and understand an ordinary instrument relatable to contract in other spheres has to be treated differently than interpreting and appreciating tender documents relating to technical works and projects requiring special skills – The owner should be allowed to carry out the purpose and there has to be allowance of free play in the joints. [Para 25] List of Acts Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Retail outlet dealership; Allotment of dealership; False information; Judicial review; Judicial restraint Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 14689 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 06.07.2023 of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh at Shimla in CWP No. 835 of 2020 [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1255Pawan Kumar v. Union of India & Ors. Appearances for Parties Jayant Bhushan, Sr. Adv., Shyam S Sharma, Sanjeev Kumar Baliyan, Rishabh Singhle, Amartya Bhushan, Yojit Mehra, Tushar Bhushan, Yash Yadav, Ms. Jyoti Garg, Sujoy Chatterjee, Advs. for the Appellant.
S.D. Sanjay, A.S.G., V. Giri, Sr. Adv., Vikrant Narayan Vasudeva, Rohit Lochav, Shlok Chandra, Suyash Pandey, Shaurya Rai, Sunita Gautam, Madhav Sinhal, Dr. N. Visakamurthy, Parijat Sinha, Divyam Dhyani, Ms. Reshmi Rea Sinha, Rahul Narang, Shyamal Kumar, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment/Order of the Supreme Court Order
1. Application seeking deletion of proforma Respondent No.1 from the array of parties is allowed at the risk of the appellant.
2. Cause title be amended accordingly.
3. Leave granted.
4. This appeal arises from the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Himachal Pradesh at Shimla dated 6-7-2023 in CWP No.835/2020, by which the Writ Petition filed by the Respondent No.5 - herein (original petitioner before the High Court) came to be allowed and thereby the allotment of dealership by Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited to run a petrol pump in favour of the appellant herein came to be cancelled.
5. The facts in brief necessary for the disposal of this appeal may be set out thus:-
6. The Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited (for short, the “BPCL”) issued an advertisement dated 25-11-2018 for appointment/allotment of retail outlet dealerships for petrol pumps in the State of Maharashtra.
7. It is not in dispute that the appellant - herein made an online application showing his willingness for being appointed/ allotted retail outlet dealership.
8. The appellant - herein claims to be falling within the OBC category and accordingly he applied against the OBC category on 24-12-2018. 1256 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
9. The appellant was included in Group II as mentioned in clause 4(v) of the brochure for selection of dealers for regular and rural retail outlet, i.e., the appellant had affirmed offer for suitable piece of land for purchase/lease belonging to a third party.
10. It appears from the materials on record that the appellant offered a piece of land owned by Shri Lila Dhar and Shri Dinesh Kumar bearing KK No. 4/5, Khasra No. 167/70 measuring 7-6 Bighas situated at Mauza Patta.
11. It also appears that there was some dispute between Mr. Lila Dhar and Mr. Dinesh Kumar as regards the land which was offered by the appellant herein. However, the same ultimately came to be settled to the satisfaction of the Corporation.
12. The Respondent No.5 - herein preferred a Civil Writ Petition No.835/2020 in the High Court and prayed for the following reliefs:- "i) Issue a writ of certiorari to quash the letter of intent issued to the respondent No. 5 on the basis of draw lots held on 17.06.2019 for running of RO Dealership at village Patta, Tehsil Arki, District Solan, H.P. ii) Issue a writ of mandamus directing the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 to process the case of the petitioner for allotment of RO Dealership being most eligible applicant forthwith.
iii) Issue writ of mandamus directing the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4 to action who initiate appropriate has connived with respondent No. 5 in violating of RO Dealership Guidelines.
iv) Call for the records pertaining to the case at hand. v) Direct the Respondent authorities to pay the cost of the petitions.”
13. The Writ Petition came to be allowed vide the impugned order passed by the High Court.
14. The High Court while allowing the Writ Petition filed by the Respondent No.5 observed in paras 32 to 44 as under:- [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1257Pawan Kumar v. Union of India & Ors. “32) None of these facts had been disclosed by respondent no.5 in his application.
33) Admittedly, Annexure P-3 Brochure issued by the Corporation for selection of dealer for retail outlets, contains Clause 22 which states as under:- “22 FALSE INFORMATION If any statement made in the application or in the documents enclosed therewith or subsequently submitted in pursuance of the application by the candidate at any stage is found to have been suppressed/misrepresented/incorrect or false, then the application is liable to be rejected without assigning any reason and in case the applicant has been appointed as a dealer, the dealership is liable to be terminated.
In such cases the candidate/dealer shall have no claim whatsoever against the respective Company.”
34) Thus, if any statement made in the application submitted by an applicant like respondent no.5 was at any stage found to have been false, incorrect or certain facts are found to have been suppressed or misrepresented, then the application was liable to be rejected by the Corporation without assigning any reason and in case, an applicant had been appointed as a dealer, the dealership was liable to be terminated.
35) Strangely, notwithstanding such a Clause having been incorporated in the Brochure issued by the Corporation, and notwithstanding the fact that the petitioner had informed about the false information furnished by respondent no.5 to respondents no.2 to 4 on 25.06.2019 (including the factum of pendency of a Civil Suit between Leeladhar and his brother Dinesh Kumar), respondents no.2 to 4 went ahead and issued the Letter of Intent on 21.09.2019 to respondent No.5 in gross violation of Clause-22, referred to above.
1258 [2024] 12 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 36) In our considered opinion, it was not open to respondents no.2 to 4/Corporation to grant the retail outlet dealership to respondent no.5 in the face of Clause-22 of the Brochure, merely on the ground that there was a subsequent Out of Court Settlement between Leeladhar and his brother Dinesh Kumar and Dinesh Kumar later gave an affidavit stating that he has no objection for grant of retail outlet dealership to respondent no.5.
37) This is because in the application filed by respondent no.5 at Sr. no.13 where land details are to be furnished, respondent no.5 could have mentioned that Leeladhar and others were co-owners of the land, but instead, he mentioned only Leeladhar and did not mention either about the other co-owners or about the pendency of the civil suit between Leeladhar and his brother Dinesh Kumar.
38) In view of the undertaking given in the said application as well as declaration signed by respondent no.5 that wrong information/misrepresentation/ suppression of facts would make him ineligible the retail outlet dealership, which would bind the 5th respondent, not only respondents no.2 to 4 cannot grant him the retail outlet dealership but cannot also they cannot defending their action in giving him the Letter of Intent by calling the petitioner as a medlesome interloper.
39) We fail to see how the petitioner can be considered as a medlesome interloper in the facts and circumstances of the case, when he was also a contender for the allotment of the retail outlet alongwith the respondent no.5. 40) As held in the decision of Ramana Dayaram Shetty versus The International Airport Authority of India & Others, (1979) 3 SCC 489 if an executive agency lays down certain standards which it professes its actions to be judged, it must scrupulously observe those standards. In the said case, the Supreme Court held that today the Government in a welfare State is the regulator and dispenser of special services and provider of a large [2024] 12 S.C.R. 1259Pawan Kumar v. Union of India & Ors. number of benefits, including jobs, contracts, licenses, quotas etc.; the valuables dispensed by Government take many forms; many individuals and many more businesses enjoy largess in the form of Government contract, and the discretion of the Government or its agency is not unlimited, in that, it cannot give or withhold largess in its arbitrary discretion or its sweet will.
41) This was reiterated in B.S. Minhas versus Indian Statistical Institute & Others (1983) 4 SCC 582, where the Supreme Court held that it is obligatory on the part of the respondent to follow its bye-laws since they have been framed for the conduct of its affairs to avoid arbitrariness and the respondent cannot escape liability for not following the procedure prescribed in the bye-laws.
42) Recently, this was reiterated in M.P. Power Management Company Limited versus Sky Power Southeast Solar India Private Limited & Others (2023) 2 SCC 703 and it was held that if an agency of the State had laid down astandard or a norm of eligibility and if a person submitting a tender did not satisfy this condition of eligibility, his tender would not be eligible for consideration. It held that this Principle had an independent existence apart from Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
43) Having regard to the settled legal position, we are of the opinion that the award of the retail outlet dealership by respondents No.2 to 4-BPCL to respondent no.5, cannot be sustained since respondent no.5 had misrepresented in his application that Leeladhar was the sole owner of the land offered for setting up the said outlet, but the truth was otherwise, and the land was co-owned by Dinesh Kumar and there was also a civil litigation pending before the Civil Court, which was not disclosed by respondent no.5.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.