Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 856; [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1647
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 7 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice Sanjiv Khanna, Justice Surya Kant, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Manoj Misra, Justice Satish Chandra Sharma
- Decided
- 8 Nov 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2286/2006
- Sections
- 23, 6, 8, 9, 23(1), 4, 28(3), 40, 2, 5(2), 3, 10
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1647 : 2024 INSC 856 Aligarh Muslim University v.
Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 2286 of 2006)
08 November 2024 [Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud,* CJI, Sanjiv Khanna, Surya Kant,* J.B. Pardiwala, Dipankar Datta,* Manoj Misra and Satish Chandra Sharma,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The issues were: 1) ingredients, indicia or criteria for an educational institution to be considered a minority educational institution under Article 30 of the Constitution; 2) whether Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) is a minority educational institution; 3) whether the Constitution Bench decision in Azeez Basha was incorrect, and 4) Whether two-Judge Bench of Supreme Court in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya erred in referring the correctness of the decision rendered in Azeez Basha directly to a Bench of seven Judges.
Headnotes† A1. Educational Institution – No distinction between educational institutions established before and after commencement of the Constitution for purposes of Art. 30(1) – Right guaranteed by Article 30(1) is applicable to universities established before commencement of the Constitution – Constitution of India – Art.30.
A2. Educational Institution – Minority institution – Indicia for ‘establishment’ of a minority educational institution – Meaning of word ‘establish’ as used in Art.30(1) – Effect of incorporation on minority character of an institution – Distinction between ‘incorporation’ and ‘establishment’ – Constitution of India – Art.30.
* Author Ed. Note: There are four judgments in the matter. One judgment was pronounced by Hon’ble Dr Justice Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, Chief Justice of India, on behalf of himself, Hon’ble Mr Justice Sanjiv Khanna, Hon’ble Mr Justice J B Pardiwala and Hon’ble Mr Justice Manoj Misra. Hon’ble Mr Justice Surya Kant, Hon’ble Mr Justice Dipankar Datta and Hon’ble Mr Justice Satish Chandra Sharma pronounced their separate judgments.
1648 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports A3. Educational Institution – Minority institution – Declaration of an institution as one of national importance does not amount to change in minority character of the institution. A4. Educational Institution – Minority educational institution – Whether Aligarh Muslim University (AMU) is a minority educational institution.
A5. Constitution of India – Art.30 – Scope of – Purpose of Art.30(1) – Special protection guaranteed by Art.30(1). A6. Constitution of India – Art.30 – Article 30(1) can be classified as both an anti-discrimination provision and a special rights provision.
A7. Words and Phrases – ‘establishment’ and ‘incorporation’ of educational institutions – The words ‘incorporation’ and ‘establishment’ cannot be used interchangeably.
Held [per Dr D Y Chandrachud, CJI (for himself, Sanjiv Khanna, J.B. Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, JJ.)]:
1.1. A distinction between educational institutions established before and after the commencement of the Constitution cannot be made for the purposes of Article 30(1) – Article 30 will stand diluted and weakened if it is to only apply prospectively to institutions established after the commencement of the Constitution – The adoption of the Constitution reflects a break from the system of sovereign and potentate government under the colonial regime and the dawn of governance based on the rule of law – It secures to the minority educational institutions, rights under the Constitution from the date of its commencement. [Para 83]
1.2. Upon the commencement of the Constitution, citizens received the protective cover of Part III – Article 372 read with Article 13(1) stipulates that laws which pre-date the Constitution are unconstitutional if they contravene the fundamental rights – The provisions do not stipulate that laws which pre-date the Constitution cannot receive the additional protection which the fundamental rights offer – The right to administration in Article 30(1) is one such protection. [Para 84]
2.1. ‘Incorporation’ signifies the legal existence of the institution. In contrast, ‘establishment’ signifies the founding or bringing into [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1649Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. existence of the institution – The possibility of distinguishing the establishment and incorporation of universities arose with the advent of teaching Universities – Two kinds of institutions were incorporated as teaching universities – They consisted of institutions which were established and incorporated at the same time, and institutions in which the establishment of the institution predated its incorporation – Universities in the latter category, however, were teaching colleges converted into teaching universities – The instance of conversion of teaching collages to teaching universities elucidates the distinction between the ‘establishment’ and ‘incorporation’ of educational institutions. [Para 94]
2.2. The word ‘establish’ as used in Article 30(1) cannot and should not be understood in a narrow and legalistic sense – The words used in clause (1) of Article 30 have to be interpreted in view of the object and purpose of the article, and the guarantee and protection it confers – The guarantee and protection are not dependent on the basis or the manner in which the legal requirements were/are complied with, rather it concerns the persons who have founded and created the establishment – The incorporation by a statute or the procedure and requirements in law are not determinative factors – The persons behind it, that is, the promoters and founder(s) are important – They should belong to a linguistic or a religious minority – There will always be individuals and groups instrumental in catalysing and setting up the institution – Thus, giving a legal character to an educational institution through state or sovereign action, it does not ipso facto follow that the university so established deprives the group of persons/individuals the guarantee under clause (1) of Article 30 of the Constitution – Universities are as much educational institutions as schools and colleges – The interpretation in Azeez Basha confers a legalistic meaning to the word ‘established’, sans the context of clause (1) of Article 30 – No distinction exists between universities and other educational institutions such as schools and colleges for the purpose of Article 30(1). [Para 95]
2.3. It cannot be argued that a university was established by Parliament merely because the long title and preamble of the statute incorporating the university states that it is an Act to establish and incorporate – If such a formalistic 1650 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports interpretation is adopted, fundamental rights would be made subservient to legislative language – The courts must identify the circumstances surrounding the incorporation of the University (including through a reading of the statute) to identify who established the university – Formalism must give way to actuality and to what is real. [Para 112]
2.4. The argument that the test of whether an educational institution is a minority institution must be examined based on whether the community or the group which had established the institution was a minority at the time of its establishment in pre-independent India, is rejected – The purpose of the provision is to ensure that the minorities are able to preserve and promote their linguistic and religious culture – For this purpose, the status of the group/community, that had established the institution, on the date of commencement of the Constitution should be considered – The test of establishment will apply to future situations on the day when new educational institutions are established – The protection under clause (1) of Article 30 cannot be denied to institutions established before the commencement of the Constitution for the reason that at the time of establishment in pre-independent India, the founders were not aware that they would receive protection of Article 30(1). [Para 122]
2.5. ‘establishment’ or formation of an institution can be at any point of time and even before the commencement of the Constitution – If an institution was established before the commencement of the Constitution, the enquiry on the question of ‘establishment’ must relate back to the date when the institution was established or formed to ascertain whether it would qualify as a minority institution upon the commencement of the Constitution. [Para 134]
3.1. To determine who established the institution, the Courts must consider the genesis of the educational institution – For this analysis, the Courts must trace the origin of the idea for the establishment of the institution – The Court must identify who was the brain behind the establishment of the educational institution – Letters, correspondence with other members of the community or with government/State officials and resolutions issued could be valid proof for establishing ideation or the impetus to found and establish – The proof [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1651Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. of ideation must point towards one member of the minority or a group from the community. [Para 135]
3.2. The second indicia is the purpose for which the educational institution was established – Though it is not necessary that the educational institution must have been established only for the benefit of a religious or linguistic minority community, it must predominantly be for its benefit – It is not necessary that education must be provided in the language spoken by the minority or on the religion of the minority – For example, it is not necessary that an educational institution established for the Tamils in Uttar Pradesh must necessarily prescribe Tamil as the language of instruction – However, it must be proved that the institution was established for the benefit of the tamil-speaking community – This indicia could be proved by a reference to private communication or speeches about the necessity of establishing an educational institution for the community and a recognition of the educational difficulties faced by the community. [Para 136]
3.3. The third test is tracing the steps taken towards the implementation of the idea – Information on who contributed the funds for its creation, who was responsible for obtaining the land, and whether the land was donated by a member of the minority community or purchased from funds raised by the minority community for this purpose or donated by a person from some other community specifically for the establishment of a minority educational institution are elements that must be considered – Similar questions must be asked of its other assets – Other important questions are: who took the steps necessary for establishing the institution (such as obtaining the relevant permissions, constructing the buildings, and arranging other infrastructure). It is also important to note that the state may grant some land or other monetary aid during or after the establishment of the educational institution – If the land or monies were granted after the establishment, the grant would not have the effect of changing the minority character of the institution – Minority institutions are not barred from receiving aid save at the cost of their minority status – If the land or monies are granted at the time of establishment, the circumstances surrounding the establishment must be considered as a whole to determine who established the institution – The presence of a grant must 1652 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports not be automatically interpreted as leading to the erasure of a claim to minority status. [Para 137]
3.4. An educational institution is a minority educational institution if it is established by a religious or linguistic minority – It is not necessary to prove that administration vests with the minority to prove that it is a minority educational institution because the very purpose of Article 30(1) is to grant special rights on administration as a consequence of establishment – To do otherwise, would amount to converting the consequence to a pre-condition – The right to administer is guaranteed to minority educational institutions to enable them to possess sufficient autonomy to model the educational institution according to the educational values that the community wishes to emphasise – It is not necessary that the purpose can only be implemented if persons belonging to the community helm the administrative affairs – This is so particularly because a minority institution may wish to emphasise secular education. [Para 138]
3.5. The test to be adopted by the Court is whether the administrative set up of the educational institution affirms the minority character of the institution – If the administrative structure of the educational institution does not reflect its minority character or when it does not elucidate that the educational institution was established to protect and promote the interests of the minority, it may be reasonably inferred that the purpose was not to establish an educational institution for the benefit of the minority community – [Para 139]
3.6. The test of administration should be evaluated in praesenti, that is, on the date of the commencement of the Constitution – An institution to be a minority institution must satisfy the criteria of being ‘administered’ as a minority institution on the date of commencement of the Constitution, and being a minority institution on the date of formation – Even if an educational institution was established by the minority for the purposes of the community, one must assess the impact of any subsequent events that altered the character of the institution before the commencement of the Constitution – The statutory incorporation of the institution does not ipso facto amount to a surrender of the minority character of the institution – The Court must pierce the veil to identify if the [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1653Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. University was established by a minority for the purpose of promoting the interest of the community – The Court may on a holistic reading of the statutory provisions relating to the administrative set-up of the educational institution deduce if the minority character or the purpose of establishment was relinquished upon incorporation – The question is whether the regulatory measures wrest the administrative control from the founders of the institution – This is a question of fact which must be determined on the facts of each case – The Court must make that determination upon a comprehensive analysis of the administrative framework which includes host of factors such as the representation of the interests of the community in the administrative set-up. [Para 140]
3.7. Taken together, these are the main indicia which assist the Court in determining who established an educational institution under Article 30 – However, the complex nature of establishing an educational institution is not lost on us – Undoubtedly, there can be no straitjacket formula which may be applied – The above indicia of establishment must be considered as a whole, along with any relevant facts which are available to the Court – The matter must be considered in totality and competing factors must be weighed against each other depending on the facts and circumstances of each institution. [Para 141]
3.8. The above indicia must be proved through the submission of cogent material – Reliance must be placed on primary sources such as office documents, letters and resolutions or memorandums issued to implement the resolutions – Secondary sources must only be used to corroborate the primary sources – The onus to prove that the educational institution was established by a minority is on the claimants. [Para 142]
4. The declaration of an institution as one of national importance does not amount to a change in the minority character of the institution – This is for multiple reasons – First, Entries in the Lists in the Seventh Schedule delineate the legislative competence of Parliament and of the legislatures of the States – The State may regulate various aspects of education and educational institutions – The field of legislative competence over universities does not amount 1654 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to a surrender of minority character – The distribution of legislative competence between Parliament and the State legislatures does not bear upon the minority character of the institution – Second, as a matter of principle, nothing prevents a minority educational institution from being an institution of national importance – The qualities denoted by the terms ‘national’ and ‘minority’ are not at odds with each other nor are they mutually exclusive – The former indicates that the institution has a pan-India or national character, as opposed to relatively more local or regional institutions – It is indicative of the importance of the institution on the national stage – The latter is evidence of the religious or linguistic background of the founders and the constitutional rights which vest in them – Each term indicates distinct attributes which are not antithetical to one another – A university may well be both national and ergo, of national importance, as well as minority in character – There is no reason why a minority educational institution cannot also be an institution of national importance – Third, Entries 63 and 64 provide Parliament with the power to declare an institution to be of national importance – An interpretation that an institution of national importance cannot be a minority institution would amount to rendering the fundamental right guaranteed by Article 30(1) subservient to the legislative power of Parliament – Parliament can in terms of Entries 63 and 64 declare any institution to be of national importance. [Para 148]
5. Article 30(1) can be classified as both an anti-discrimination provision and a special rights provision – A legislation or an executive action which discriminates against religious or linguistic minorities in establishing or administering educational institutions is ultra vires Article 30(1) – This is the anti-discrimination reading of the provision – Additionally, a linguistic or religious minority which has established an educational institution receives the guarantee of greater autonomy in administration – This is the ‘special rights’ reading of the provision. [Para 160(b)]
6. Religious or linguistic minorities must prove that they established the educational institution for the community to be a minority educational institution for the purposes of Article 30(1). [Para 160(c)] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1655Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
7. The right guaranteed by Article 30(1) is applicable to universities established before the commencement of the Constitution. [Para 160(d)]
8. The right under Article 30(1) is guaranteed to minorities as defined upon the commencement of the Constitution – A different right-bearing group cannot be identified for institutions established before the adoption of the Constitution. [Para 160(e)]
9. The incorporation of the University would not ipso facto lead to surrendering of the minority character of the institution – The circumstances surrounding the conversion of a teaching college to a teaching university must be viewed to identify if the minority character of the institution was surrendered upon the conversion – The Court may on a holistic reading of the statutory provisions relating to the administrative set-up of the educational institution deduce if the minority character or the purpose of establishment was relinquished upon incorporation. [Para 160(f)]
10. The following are the factors which must be used to determine if a minority ‘established’ an educational institution: i. The indicia of ideation, purpose and implementation must be satisfied – First, the idea for establishing an educational institution must have stemmed from a person or group belonging to the minority community;
second, the educational institution must be established predominantly for the benefit of the minority community; and third, steps for the implementation of the idea must have been taken by the member(s) of the minority community; and ii. The administrative-set up of the educational institution must elucidate and affirm (I) the minority character of the educational institution; and (II) that it was established to protect and promote the interests of the minority community. [Para 160(g)]
11. The question of whether AMU is a minority educational institution must be decided based on the principles laid down in this judgment – The papers of this batch of cases shall be 1656 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports placed before the regular bench for deciding whether AMU is a minority educational institution. [Para 161] Held [per Surya Kant, J.]:
1. The minority institutions established in the pre-Constitution era are also entitled to the protection conferred by Article
30. [Para 192(g)]
2. Educational institutions, with reference to Article 30 include universities as well. [Para 192(h)]
3. In order to seek protection under Article 30 of our Constitution, the minority institution must satisfy the conjunctive test, namely that it was established by a minority community and has been/ is being administered by such a community. [Para 192(i)]
4. The true import and meaning of the expressions ‘establish’ and ‘administer’, which comprise the very core of Article 30, are to be construed and understood strictly in accordance with the indicia in paragraphs 141 and 181. [Para 192(j)]
5. The question pertaining to whether AMU satisfies the abovementioned test of ‘establish’ and ‘administer’ so as to seek protection of Article 30 of the Constitution, and which will concomitantly entail a mixed question of facts and law, will be determined by a Regular Bench. [Para 192(k)] Held [per Dipankar Datta, J.]:
1. While the majority opinion seems to have identified establishment as the sole indicium, Hon’ble Surya Kant and Hon’ble Satish Chandra Sharma, JJ – have laid equal stress on administration apart from establishment as the indicia – Inasmuch as the broad criteria which can be used to assess the status of an educational institution is concerned, I express my agreement with the indicia laid out by Their Lordships. [Para 54]
2. Certain broad indicia, which are universally applicable, may be applied prospectively to facilitate identification of minority institutions – However, any indicium or the indicia, as identified or formulated, for treating an institution as a minority institution may not be exhaustive so as to cater to all situations – Previous decisions of this Court have also determined the minority [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1657Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. character of educational institutions vis-à-vis Article 30, as per indicia tailored to the specific factual matrices – It could be well-nigh difficult, if not impossible, to fix indicia without regard to a whole lot of relevant facts and circumstances, which might have escaped notice or may not have been visualized – A flexible framework rather than a rigid one-size-fits-all model is always desirable and essential for accurately assessing minority institution status – Having regard to special features that each minority institution is most likely to have, a nuanced approach would be required to identify minority institutions by balancing the general guidelines with unique institutional circumstances – The indicia, which have been proposed, could partly inform classification of minority institutions but a tailored evaluation is all the more necessary to account for distinct characteristics which each such institution is associated with; more so, when AMU is unique in itself and its status is under consideration as a standalone institution. [Para 57]
3. It is no longer res integra that even institutions established prior to the Constitution would be eligible to seek the protection of Article 30(1), as was expressed by this Court in Re: The Kerala Education Bill, 1957. [Para 67]
4. The claim of the appellants cannot stand – AMU was neither established by any religious community, nor is it administered by a religious community which is regarded as a minority community; hence, AMU does not qualify as a minority institution – Protection under Article 30(1) of the Constitution is, thus, not available – This submission of the appellants has no historic, legal, factual, or logical basis. [Para 149]
5. In terms of clause (5) of Article 145 of the Constitution, not only do the references not require an answer, it is also declared that AMU is not a minority educational institution and that the appeals seeking minority status for it should fail. [Para 150] Held [per Satish Chandra Sharma, J.]:
1. The ‘establishment’ of an institution by the minority is necessary for the said minority to claim right of administration under Article 30 – The words ‘establish’ and ‘administer’ are used conjunctively in Article 30 of the Constitution. [Para 266]
2. The term ‘establish’ in Article 30 means ‘to bring into existence or to create’ and cannot be conflated with generic phrases 1658 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports such as ‘genesis of the institution’ or the ‘founding moment of the institution’. [Para 266]
3. The real positive indicia for determining the question of establishment of an institution would have to be developed on a case to case basis with the following broad parameters in mind:
Firstly, to claim ‘establishment’, the minority community must actually and tangibly bring the entirety of the institution into existence – The role played by the minority community must be predominant, in fact almost complete to the point of exclusion of all other forces – The indicia which may be illustrative and exhaustive in this regard may be the nature of the institution, the legal/statutory basis required for establishing the institution, whether the establishment required any ‘negotiation’ with outside forces, the role in acquiring lands, obtaining funds, constructing buildings, and other related matters must have been held completely by the minority community – Similarly, while teachers, curriculum, medium of instruction, etc. can be on secular lines, however, the decision-making authority regarding hiring teachers, curriculum decisions, medium of instruction, admission criteria, and similar matters must be the minority community – The choice of having secular education in the institution must be made expressly by the minority community, demonstrating the link between institution and the persons claiming to establish it.
Secondly, the purpose of the institution must have been to predominantly serve the interests of the minority community or the sole betterment of the minority community, irrespective of the form of education provided and the mode of admission adopted – Therefore, as per the choice of the minority community, an institution may have secular education, but such secular education and the resultant institution, must be predominantly meant for the overall betterment of the minority community.
Thirdly, the institution must be predominantly administered as a minority institution with the actual functional, executive and policy administration vested with the minority – The minority community should determine the selection, removal criteria, and procedures for hiring teaching, administrative staff, and [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1659Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. other personnel – The authority to hire and fire staff must be from the minority community – Further, even if teaching or administrative staff may include non-minority persons, the final authority exercising functional, directional, and policy control over these authorities must be from the minority community – This ensures that the thoughts, beliefs, and ideas of the minority community regarding administration are implemented in reality – This represents the real decisionmaking authority of the institution being of the minority community – In ascertaining the above, it would be open for the Court to look at the true purpose behind each of the above factors and to pierce the veil. [Para 266]
4. The minority community may conceptualize the idea of an institution and may advocate for the same, however, if during exchange or negotiation, the actual institution which was established had primacy of governmental efforts and control, then such institution cannot be held to be predominantly established by the efforts and actions of the minority community. [Para 266]
5. In the pre-independence and pre-UGC era, in the absence of a provision like Section 23 of the UGC Act, 1956, it was open for any institutions to adopt the titles such as ‘university’ or in some cases ‘vidyapeeth’ or ‘jamia’ asserting their capability to grant degrees – The absence of a legislative embargo from private establishment of Universities prior to 1956 would be critical for the scope of enquiry. [Para 266]
6. The use of the phrase ‘establish and incorporate’ by the Legislature may be relevant in the larger enquiry but cannot be said to be conclusively determinative of the factum of establishment or not by the minority community – If the intention of the Legislature is to establish or incorporate or recognise a minority University, the Legislatures have incorporated suitable provisions to colour the University with a minority identity. [Para 266]
7. There were no rights, fundamental or otherwise, prior to the Constitution coming into force and therefore, there is no question of surrendering any right – The British Indian Government was a supreme Imperial power in the country, and the question of surrender is illusionary and does not arise in the present case – The coming into force of the Constitution 1660 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports and fundamental right after 1950, cannot alter the events that occurred during the decade of 1910-1920 which led to the establishment of the AMU. [Para 266]
8. There is no legal requirement for the AMU ‘Court’ to be manned by the people from the minority community ever since 1951 and therefore, merely because de facto the persons from the minority community may have manned the posts in the institution, would not be relevant to adjudicate the question. [Para 266]
9. The assertion that ‘neutral’ institutions or non-minority institutions would in the natural course of things be ‘majoritarian’ or that Article 30 contemplates constitutionally protecting certain educational spaces from such ‘majoritarianism-bydefault’ tendencies, is wholly erroneous – The purpose of Article 30 is not to create ‘minority only’ ghettos rather provide positive rights to the minorities to establish educational institutions of their choice and kind. [Para 266]
10. Article 30, as a feature of the Constitution, provides important rights which function within the larger penumbra of fundamental rights – There is substantial interplay, intermixing and balancing of rights inter se within the fundamental rights and Article 30 is not absolute and certainly do not exist in a silo. [Para 266]
11. The crux of Article 30(1) lies in its mandate to ensure parity between non-minority [or ‘neutral’] institutions and minority institutions – Its fundamental aim is to prevent any form of discrimination or preferential treatment to non-minority communities, thereby advocating for equal treatment under the law for one and all – This provision underscores that no specific category or type of institution should be disadvantaged or unduly favoured over another within the legal framework. [Para 266]
12. To assume that the minorities of the country require some ‘safe haven’ for attaining education and knowledge is wholly incorrect – The minorities of the country have not just joined the mainstream but comprise an important facet of the mainstream itself. The institutions of national character of the country always serve the interests of the minorities and are diverse centers of learning. [Para 266] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1661Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. B. Educational Institution – Minority educational institution – Status of AMU vis-à-vis minority rights – Whether the Constitution Bench decision in Azeez Basha was incorrect.
Held [per Dr D Y Chandrachud, CJI (for himself, Sanjiv Khanna, J.B. Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, JJ.)]: The view taken in Azeez Basha that an educational institution is not established by a minority if it derives its legal character through a statute, is overruled. [Para 161] Held [per Surya Kant, J.]: The Constitution Bench in Azeez Basha, when it holds that since Section 6 of the AMU Act, 1920 stipulates that degrees conferred by AMU would be recognised by the Government, it could not have been ‘brought into existence by a private individual or body’, is seemingly incorrect – There is no conflict between the seven-judge bench opinion in Kerala Education Bill and the five-judge Constitution Bench in Azeez Basha on the other – The six-judge Constitution Bench in Sidhajbhai Sabhai, laying down that the right under Article 30 is absolute and unconditional, is not the correct principle of law; the judgement is no more binding in nature and stands effectively overruled in TMA Pai, to that extent – Consequently, Azeez Basha does not suffer from any legal infirmity on the premise that it did not cite or follow Sidhajbhai Sabhai. [Para 192(a), (b) and (f)] Held [per Dipankar Datta, J.]: Not only is Azeez Basha a judicial verdict more than half a century old on the status of AMU vis-àvis minority rights, but it has a strong foundational basis and is anchored in robust legal reasoning – The view taken therein, in the given facts and circumstances, is indeed a plausible view which demands due deference rather than the view being overruled at this distance of time. [Para 14] Held [per Satish Chandra Sharma, J.]: The notion that Azeez Basha categorically prohibits minorities from establishing universities due to statutory requirements is unfounded – The bench in Azeez Basha and present bench are faced with a unique situation and needs to adopt a suitably modulated approach – The judgment in Azeez Basha does not preclude minorities from establishing universities but rather highlights the importance of legislative intent and statutory provisions in determining an institution’s character – The UGC Act or the judgment in Yashpal, in no manner, comes to the aid of the parties challenging the correctness of the judgment 1662 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports in Azeez Basha – The amendment in the NCMEI Act 2004 does not come to the aid of the parties questioning the correctness of the decision in Azeez Basha.
C. Judicial discipline – Preliminary objection to reference – Whether two-Judge Bench of Supreme Court in Anjumane-Rahmaniya could not have referred the correctness of the decision rendered by the Constitution Bench in Azeez Basha directly to a Bench of seven Judges.
Held [per Dr D Y Chandrachud, CJI (for himself, Sanjiv Khanna, J.B. Pardiwala and Manoj Misra, JJ.)]:
1. In Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community, a Constitution Bench discussed the legal precepts which apply to orders of reference and reiterated the position of law as below:a. Decisions of this Court rendered by a Bench of larger strength are binding on Benches of a less or equal strength;
b. If a Bench of lower strength is doubtful about the correctness of a judgment delivered by a Bench of larger strength, it cannot disagree or dissent from the view taken by the larger Bench – In case of doubt, it can invite the attention of the Chief Justice of India to its opinion and request the Chief Justice to list the matter before a Bench, the strength of which is greater than that which delivered the judgment which has been doubted;
c. The correctness of the view taken by any Bench can only be doubted by a Bench of equal strength – The matter will then be placed for hearing before a Bench of greater strength;
d. There are two exceptions to the rules: i. The discretion of the Chief Justice is not bound by the rules – As the master of the roster, the Chief Justice may list any case before any Bench of any strength; ii. Despite the rules, if a particular case has come up for hearing before a Bench of larger strength and that Bench is of the opinion that the judgment of the Bench of lower strength requires reconsideration or correction, or is otherwise doubtful of its correctness, it may dispense with the need for a [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1663Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. reference in the terms described above or an order of the Chief Justice and hear the matter for reasons given by it. [Para 37]
2. The position of law laid down in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community is correct – Decisions of a larger Bench are binding precedent, and judicial discipline and propriety dictate that Benches of lower strength must adhere to such decisions – This will also avoid inconsistencies in the development of law – Questions concerning the correctness of judgments must ordinarily be referred only by a Bench which is equal in strength to the Bench whose judgment is doubted – We also agree with the two exceptions to this rule, as detailed by this Court in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community – They must remain exceptions and not transmogrify into the rule itself. [Para 38]
3. The three issues which required an authoritative pronouncement in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya, were not directly a point of contention in Azeez Basha – However, the decision would have a bearing on them – Doubting the correctness of the opinion in Azeez Basha, without disagreeing with it, the two-Judge Bench requested that the matter may be placed before the Chief Justice of India for being heard by a Bench of seven Judges – This falls within the permissible limits laid down in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community – Further, the Solicitor General has also stated that he is not pressing the Union’s preliminary objection – The order of reference dated 12 February 2019 (wherein a three-Judge Bench of this Court observed that the correctness of the question arising from the decision in Azeez Basha was unanswered, and then referred the matter to a seven-Judge Bench), too, noted that although a three-Judge Bench could not ordinarily refer a case directly to a seven-Judge Bench, it was doing so in this case because the question was already referred to a Bench of seven Judges but was not answered. [Para 39]
4. The reference in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya of the correctness of the decision in Azeez Basha was valid – The reference was within the parameters laid down in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community. [Para 160(a)] 1664 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held [per Surya Kant, J.]:
1.1. The two-judge bench in Anjuman, after expressing doubt about the correctness of Azeez Basha and its principles, referred the matter for reconsideration to a larger bench – Additionally, the bench in Anjuman specifically stated that the larger bench reviewing Azeez Basha — A decision by a five-judge bench—Should consist of seven judges – The decision further directed that the matter be placed before the Hon’ble Chief Justice for appropriate directions – Such a reference is not consistent with the established norms of judicial propriety. [Paras 90, 91]
1.2. The principles enunciated in Dawoodi Bohra re-enforce the provisions of the Supreme Court Rules referred to earlier, and also reiterate the well-established principles based upon doctrines of predictability, consistency, finality and the principle of stare decisis – The two-judge bench in Anjuman, ought to have understood and applied the law, consistent with these principles – The two-judge bench in Anjuman being of lesser strength than the five-judge bench in Azeez Basha, lacked the authority to explicitly question the correctness of Azeez Basha and refer the matter to a seven-judge bench. [Para 93]
1.3. In Anjuman, the bench not only referred the matter but also specified the numerical strength of the bench to which it should be referred, with a further direction that the matter be placed before the Chief Justice for the limited purpose of notifying the composition of the seven-judge bench – This effectively impaired the Chief Justice’s authority as the master of the roster – Allowing such a practice would enable benches of lesser strength, such as a two-judge bench, to undermine the decisions of larger benches, potentially even an eleven-judge bench – This would also place the Chief Justice in an untenable position, who would be bound by a judicial order while acting in an administrative role, leading to procedural complications and embarrassment. [Para 94]
2. There is no substantial difference between ‘doubting’ or ‘disagreeing’ with a judgement – That being so, the reference by a two-judge bench in Anjuman doubting the correctness of the five-judge bench in Azeez Basha and referring it to a [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1665Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. seven-judge bench suffers from multiple illegalities, including judicial impropriety. [Para 192(c)]
3. In view of the dictum of the Constitution Bench in Dawoodi Bohra, a two-judge bench has no authority whatsoever to doubt or disagree with a judgement of the larger bench, and directly refer the matter to a bench having a numerically greater strength than the matter so doubted – The reference by the two judge bench in Anjuman is nothing but a challenge to the authority of the Chief Justice of India being the master of the roster and in derogation of the special powers enjoyed upon under Article 145 of the Constitution read with Order VII Rule 2 of the Supreme Court Rules, 1966 (as was applicable) – Consequently, the said reference is not maintainable – However, the subsequent reference dated 12.02.2019, in which the then Hon’ble Chief Justice of India was the presiding judge, is maintainable. [Para 192(d)]
4. The reference in Anjuman to a seven-judge bench for the reconsideration of the five-judge decision in Azeez Basha is bad in law and ought to be set aside. [Para 192(e)] Held [per Dipankar Datta, J.]:
1.1. It has been considered uniformly to be an act of breach of judicial propriety and discipline if a bench of lesser strength [of 2 (two) Judges] casts doubt in respect of a decision rendered by a bench of greater strength [of 5 (five Judges] and a request is made to the Chief Justice of India to constitute a still larger Bench [of 7 (seven Judges] – This concept was extensively ratiocinated in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community vs. State of Maharashtra. [Para 24]
1.2. If “doubting the correctness of the opinion in Azeez Basha, without disagreeing with it” could permit the bench in Anjumane-Rahmania to request the Chief Justice of India to place the matter for being heard by a bench of 7 (seven) Judges and such a course of action were held to be permissible and within the limits of Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community, as proposed in the majority opinion - I am afraid, tomorrow, a bench of 2 (two) Judges, referring to opinions of jurists [as in Anjuman-e-Rahmania] could well doubt the ‘basic structure’ doctrine and request the Chief Justice of India to constitute a bench of 15 (fifteen) Judges – The 1666 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports reasoning in the majority opinion, with due respect, appears to be based on an incomplete reading of paragraph 12(2) of Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community – Though the second sentence of the said paragraph is a bit ambiguous, but the same read harmoniously with the other sentences would lead to the inevitable conclusion that even in case of a doubt being expressed by a bench of 2 (two) Judges in respect of the ratio laid down by a bench of 5 (five) Judges, the case on a reference being made (with sufficient reasons) ought to be first placed before a bench of 3 (three) Judges, and not to a bench of either 5 (five) or 7 (seven) Judges – If, indeed, the proposed view in the majority opinion were accepted, all the precedents referred to above would stand overruled and a legal principle, which hitherto no bench of this Court did, would be laid down and, in the process, the floodgates for unmeritorious references opened – That would be an incorrect and improper approach – Hence, the order of reference in Anjuman-e-Rahmania must be regarded as completely flawed and non-est. [Para 28]
2. The essence of the law laid down in State of Kerala vs. Very Rev. Mother Provincial, which is a decision of the Constitution Bench of 6 (six) Judges of this Court rendered more than half a century back, and has never been doubted by any subsequent bench, is that the minority institution should have been established for the benefit of a minority community by a member of that community – Attention of the bench of 2 (two) Judges in Anjuman-e-Rahmania was not invited to this and one is left to wonder whether the reference would have at all been made if Very Rev. Mother Provincial was cited – There being no reference in Anjuman-e-Rahmania of Very Rev. Mother Provincial, a binding decision, certainly the said decision of the Constitution Bench had not been placed before the bench of 2 (two) Judges by the set of counsel appearing before it who agreed with the bench on the question of (in)correctness of Azeez Basha – Also, there cannot be any comparison of chalk and cheese – The case dealt with by Azeez Basha and the one arising for decision in Anjuman-e-Rahmania were fundamentally different and in stark contrast with each other – Therefore, even on merits, there was no good reason to make a reference for being placed before a bench of 7 (seven) Judges which Anjumane-Rahmania ordered. [Para 42] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1667Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Held [per Satish Chandra Sharma, J.]: The bench of two judges in Anjuman-e-Rehmania & Ors v. Distt. Inspector of School & Ors. could not have referred the matter to a bench of seven Hon’ble Judges directly, without the Hon’ble Chief Justice of India, being a part of the bench. [Para 266] Case Law Cited In the judgment of Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, CJI:
S Azeez Basha v. Union of India [1968] 1 SCR 833 : AIR 1968 SC 662 – overruled.
Prof. Yashpal v. State of Chhattisgarh [2005] 2 SCR 23 : (2005) 5 SCC 420 – held inapplicable.
Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community v. State of Maharashtra [2004] Supp. 6 SCR 1054 : (2005) 2 SCC 673; TMA Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka [2002] Supp. 3 SCR 587 : (2002) 8 SCC 481; Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai v. State of Bombay [1962] 3 SCR 837; In re Kerala Education Bill [1958] 1 SCR 995 – relied on. Dalco Engg. (P) Ltd. v. Satish Prabhakar Padhye [2010] 4 SCR 15 : (2010) 4 SCC 378 – distinguished.
Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya v. District Inspector of Schools [Supreme Court decision in W.P.(C) No. 54-57 of 1981] – affirmed. Indira Sawhney (II) v. Union of India & Ors., AIR 2000 SC 498; A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras, AIR 1950 SC 27; Rustom Cavasjee Cooper v. Union of India [1970] 3 SCR 530 : (1970) 1 SCC 248; Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India [1978] 2 SCR 621 : (1978) 1 SCC 248; Ahmedabad St. Xaviers College Society and Anr. v. State of Gujarat and Anr. [1975] 1 SCR 173 : AIR 1974 SC 1389; Rev. Father W. Proost and Ors. v. State of Bihar and Ors. [1969] 2 SCR 73; PA Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 603 : (2005) 6 SCC 537; State of Kerala v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial [1971] 1 SCR 734 : (1970) 2 SCC 417; Manager, St. Thomas UP School v. Commr. & Secy, to general Education Dept. (2002) 2 SCC 497; DAV College trust & Management Society v. State of Maharashtra [2013] 4 SCR 821 : (2013) 4 SCC 14; SP Mittal v. Union of India [1983] 1 SCR 729 : (1983) 1 SCC 51; The Durgah Committee, Ajmer v. Syed Hussain Ali [1962] 1 SCR 383 : (1962) 1 S.C.P 383; Rev. Bishop SK Patro v. State of Bihar [1970] 1 SCR 172 : (1969) 1 SCC 863; In re Special Courts Bill [1979] 2 SCR 476 : (1979) 1 SCC 380; SEBI v. Rajpur Nagpal [2022] 15 1668 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports SCR 1 : (2023) 8 SCC 274; Keshavan Madhava Menon v. State of Bombay [1951] 1 SCR 228 : AIR 1951 SC 128; Sukhdev Singh v. Bhagatram Sardar Singh Raghuvanshi [1975] 3 SCR 619 : (1975) 1 SCC 421; Vaish Degree College v. Lakshmi Narain [1976] 2 SCR 1006 : (1976) 2 SCC 58; S.S. Dhanoa v. MCD [1981] 3 SCR 864 : (1981) 3 SCC 431 – referred to.
Dr. Naresh Agarwal v. Union of India , 2005 SCC OnLine All 1705 – referred to.
Aligarh Muslim University v. Malay Shukla Judgment in Special Appeal No 1321 of 2005 and connected matters, High Court of Allahabad – referred to.
St. David’s College, Lampeter v. Ministry of Education, 1951 All ER 559 – referred to.
In the judgment of Surya Kant, J.:
S. Azeez Basha v. Union of India [1968] 1 SCR 833 – modified and clarified to an extent.
Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai v. State of Bombay [1963] 3 SCR 837 – held overruled.
Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community and another v. State of Maharashtra and another (2005) 2 SCC 673; Right Rev. Bishop S.K. Patro v. State of Bihar [1970] 1 SCR 172 : (1969) 1 SCC 863; A.P. Christian Medical Educational Society v. Govt. of A.P. [1986] 2 SCR 749 : (1986) 2 SCC 667; T. Varghese George v. Kora K. George [2011] 12 SCR 1070 : (2012) 1 SCC 369; Dayanand Anglo Vedic (DAV) College Trust and Management Society v. State of Maharashtra [2013] 4 SCR 821 : (2013) 4 SCC 14; St. Stephen’s College v. University of Delhi [1991] Supp. 3 SCR 121 : (1992) 1 SCC 558; State of Kerala v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial [1971] 1 SCR 734 : (1970) 2 SCC 417; Dalco Engg. (P) Ltd. v. Satish Prabhakar Padhye [2010] 4 SCR 15 : (2010) 4 SCC 378; Executive Committee of Vaish Degree College v. Lakshmi Narain [1976] 2 SCR 1006 : (1976) 2 SCC 58; – relied on.
Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal [2009] 2 SCR 907 : (2020) 13 SCC 737; TMA Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka [2002] Supp. 3 SCR 587 : (2002) 8 SCC 481; Prof. Yashpal v. State of Chhattisgarh [2005] 2 SCR 23 : (2005) 5 SCC 420; P.A. Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 603 : (2005) 6 SCC 537; Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1669Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. [2003] Supp. 2 SCR 474 : (2003) 6 SCC 697; Secy., Malankara Syrian Catholic College v. T. Jose [2006] Supp. 9 SCR 644 : (2007) 1 SCC 386; In re the Kerala Education Bill,1957 [1959] 1 SCR 995; Krishen Kumar v. Union of India [1990] 3 SCR 352 : (1990) 4 SCC 234; State of Uttar Pradesh v. Ajay Kumar Sharma [2015] 12 SCR 627 : (2016) 15 SCC 292; Shanker Raju v. Union of India [2011] 2 SCR 1 : (2011) 2 SCC 132; SEBI v. Rajkumar Nagpal [2022] 15 SCR 1 : (2023) 8 SCC 274; Ashoka Kumar Thakur v. Union of India (2008) 4 SCR 1 : (2008) 6 SCC 1; S.P. Mittal v. Union of India (1983) 1 SCC 51; Rev. Father W. Proost and Ors. v. State of Bihar and Ors. [1969] 2 SCR 73; Ahmedabad St. Xaviers College Society and Anr. v. State of Gujarat and Anr. [1975] 1 SCR 173 : AIR 1974 SC 1389; Gandhi Faiz-e-am-College v. University of Agra and Anr. [1975] 3 SCR 810 : (1975) 2 SCC 283; Kolawana Gram Vikas Kendra v. State of Gujarat and Anr. [2009] 15 SCR 272 : (2010) 1 SCC 133; All Saints High School v. Govt. of A.P. and Ors. [1980] 2 SCR 924:(1980) 2 SCC 478 Christian Medical College Vellore Assn. v. Union of India [2020] 5 SCR 516 : (2020) 8 SCC 705; Modern School v. Union of India and Ors. [2004] Supp. 1 SCR 668 : (2004) 5 SCC 583; Father Thomas Shingare and Ors. v. State of Maharashtra and Ors. [2001] Supp. 5 SCR 636 : (2002) 1 SCC 758; Andhra Kesari College of Education v. State of A.P. [2019] 12 SCR 669 : (2019) 9 SCC 457; Society for Unaided Private Schools of Rajasthan v. Union of India [2012] 2 SCR 715 : (2012) 6 SCC 1; Icon Education Society v. State of M.P. and Ors. [2023] 2 SCR 728 : 2023 SCC OnLine SC 289; Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka and Ors. [2003] Supp. 2 SCR 474 : 2003 6 SCC 697; Cochin University of Science & Technology and Anr. v. Thomas P. John and Ors. [2008] 7 SCR 887 : (2008) 8 SCC 82; Board of Secondary Education and Teachers Training v. Jt. Director of Public Instructions (1998) 8 SCC 555; Ivy C.Da. Conceicao v. State of Goa and Ors. [2017] 1 SCR 445 : (2017) 3 SCC 619; The Manager, Corporate Educational Agency v. James Mathew and Ors. [2017] 6 SCR 498 : (2017) 15 SCC 595; R. Sulochana Devi v. D.M. Sujatha & Ors. [2004] Supp. 5 SCR 1 : (2005) 9 SCC 335; Lilly Kurian v. Sr. Lewina and Ors. [1979] 1 SCR 820 : AIR 1979 SC 52; State of Karnataka and Anr. v. Associated Management of English Medium Primary & Secondary Schools and Ors. [2014] 5 SCR 1104 : (2014) 9 SCC 485; Society for Unaided Private Schools of Rajasthan v. Union of India and Anr. [2012] 2 SCR 715 : (2012) 6 SCC 1; Pramati Educational & Cultural Trust and Ors. v. Union of India and Ors. 1670 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports [2014] 11 SCR 712 : (2014) 8 SCC 1; G. Vallikumari v. Andhra Education Society (2010) 2 SCC 497; Frank Anthony Public School Employees’ Assn. v. Union of India and Ors. [1987] 1 SCR 238 : (1986) 4 SCC 707; State of Karnataka and Anr. v. Associated Management of English Medium Primary & Secondary Schools and Ors. [2014] 5 SCR 1104 : (2014) 9 SCC 485 – referred to. Sehajdhari Sikh Federation v. Union of India and others, 2011 SCC Online P&H 17374; Manager, Rajershi Memorial Basic Training School v. State of Kerala, 1972 SCC OnLine Ker 111; Rt. Rev. Dr. Aldo Maria Patroni v. Assistant Educational Officer, 1973 SCC OnLine Ker 60; A. Raju and Ors. v. Manager, Nallor Narayana L.P. Basic School & Ors., 2019 SCC OnLine Ker 16483; Dipendra Nath Sarkar v. State of Bihar & Ors., 1960 SCC OnLine Pat 205; Rt. Rev. Dr. Aldo Maria Patroni v. Assistant Educational Officer, 1973 SCC OnLine Ker 60, para 7; A. Raju and Ors. v. Manager, Nallor Narayana L.P. Basic School & Ors., 2019 SCC OnLine Ker 16483 and Dipendra Nath Sarkar v. State of Bihar & Ors., 1960 SCC OnLine Pat 205 – referred to.
Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya v. District Inspector of Schools. [Supreme Court decision in W.P.(C) No. 54-57 of 1981] – bad in law. In the judgment of Dipankar Datta, J.:
Supertech Ltd. v. Emerald Court Owner Residents Association [2021] 10 SCR 569 : (2023) 10 SCC 817; Maganlal Chhaganlal (P) Ltd. v. Municipal Corpn. of Greater Bombay [1975] 1 SCR 1 : (1974) 2 SCC 402; Re: Kerala Education Bill [1959] 1 SCR 995; Lala Shri Bhagwan v. Shri Ram Chand [1965] 3 SCR 218; Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community v. State of Maharashtra [2004] Supp. 6 SCR 1054 : (2005) 2 SCC 673; Union of India v. Hansoli Devi & Ors. [2002] Suppl. 2 SCR 324 : (2002) 7 SCC 273; Pradip Chandra Parija v. Pramod Chandra Patnaik [2001] Supp. 5 SCR 460 : (2002) 1 SCC 1; Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms v. Union of India [2017] 12 SCR 331 : (2018) 1 SCC 196 – relied on.
Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel [1985] Supp. 2 SCR 131 : (1985) 3 SCC 398; S. Azeez Basha and Anr. v. Union of India [1968] 1 SCR 833; Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal and Ors. [2020] 4 SCR 706 : (2020) 13 SCC 737; M. P. Sharma v. Satish Chandra [1954] 1 SCR 1077 : (1954) 1 SCC 385; T.M.A. Pai [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1671Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Foundation and ors. v. State of Karnataka and Ors. [2002] Supp. 3 SCR 587 : (2002) 8 SCC 481; Shahal H. Musaliar and Anr. v. Union of India and Ors., Writ Petition (C) No. 331 of 2005; Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka [2003] Supp. 2 SCR 474 : (2003) 6 SCC 697; P.A. Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra [2005] 2 Supp. SCR 603 : (2005) 6 SCC 537; Prof. Yashpal v. State of Chhattisgarh [2005] 2 SCR 23:(2005) 5 SCC 420; State of Kerala v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial [1971] 1 SCR 734 : (1970) 2 SCC 417; St. Stephen’s College v. University of Delhi [1991] Supp. 3 SCR 121:(1992) 1 SCC 558; A.P. Christian Medical Educational Society v. Govt. of A.P. [1986] 2 SCR 749 : (1986) 2 SCC 667; Ahmedabad St. Xavier’s College Society v. State of Gujarat [1975] 1 SCR 173:(1974) 1 SCC 717; Dayanand Anglo Vedic (DAV) College Trust and Management Society v. State of Maharashtra [2013] 4 SCR 821 : (2013) 4 SCC 14 – referred to. Anjuman-e-Rahmania and Ors. v. Distt. Inspector of School and Ors. [Supreme Court decision in Writ Petition (Civil) Nos. 54-57 of 1981] – non-est in law.
In the judgment of Satish Chandra Sharma, J.:
S. Azeez Basha v. Union of India [1968] 1 SCR 833 – clarified. Prof. Yashpal v. State of Chhattisgarh [2005] 2 SCR 23 : (2005) 5 SCC 420 – held inapplicable.
T.M.A. Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka [2002] Supp. 3 SCR 587 : (2002) 8 SCC 481; In Re Kerala Education Bill, 1957 [1959] 1 SCR 995; Ahmedabad St. Xavier’s College Society v. State of Gujarat [1975] 1 SCR 173 : (1974) 1 SCC 717 – relied on. Dalco Engineering Pvt. Ltd. v. Satish Prabhakar Padhye [2010] 4 SCR 15 : (2010) 4 SCC 378 – distinguished.
P.A. Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 603 : (2005) 6 SCC 537; St. Stephen’s College v. University of Delhi [1991] Supp. 3 SCR 121 : (1992) 1 SCC 558 [5-Judge Bench]; Rev. Father W Proost v. State of Bihar [1969] 2 SCR 73 [5-Judge Bench]; Right Rev. Bishop SK Patro v. State of Bihar [1970] 1 SCR 172 : (1969) 1 SCC 863 [5-Judge Bench]; Sidhajbhai Sabhai v. State of Bombay [1963] 3 SCR 837; A.P. Christians Medical Educational Society v. Government of Andhra Pradesh [1986] 2 SCR 749 : (1986) 2 SCC 667; Dir. of Endowments Gov. 1672 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of Hyderabad v. Syed Akram Ali, AIR 1956 SC 60; State of Kerala v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial [1971] 1 SCR 734 : (1970) 2 SCC 417; Bal Patil v. Union of India [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 459 : (2005) 6 SCC 690; Hyderabad Asbestos Cement Products v. Union of India [1999] Supp. 5 SCR 155 : (2000) 1 SCC 426; M. Siddiq (Ram Janambhumi Temple Reference-5J) v. Mahant Suresh Das [2019] 18 SCR 1 : (2020) 1 SCC 1; Indira Sawhney v. Union of India & Anr. [1999] Supp. 5 SCR 229 : (2000) 1 SCC 168; Mullaperiyar Environmental Protection Forum v. Union Of India & Ors. [2006] 2 SCR 740 : (2006) 3 SCC 643; Sukhdev Singh v. Bhagatram Sardar Singh Raghuvanshi [1975] 3 SCR 619:(1975) 1 SCC 421; Sardar Syedna Taher Saifuddin Saheb v. State of Bombay [1962] 2 Supp. SCR 496; Bharat Petroleum Corpn. Ltd. v. Mumbai Shramik Sangha [2001] 3 SCR 208 : (2001) 4 SCC 448; Pradip Chandra Parija v. Pramod Chandra Patnaik [2001] Supp. 5 SCR 460 : (2002) 1 SCC 1; Chandra Prakash v. State of U.P. [2002] 2 SCR 913 : (2002) 4 SCC 234; Vishweshwaraiah Iron & Steel Ltd. v. Abdul Gani (2002) 10 SCC 437; Arya Samaj Education Trust v. Director of Education (2004) 8 SCC 30; Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community and Anr. v. State of Maharashtra and Anr. [2004] Supp. 6 SCR 1054 : (2005) 2 SCC 673; Govt. of A.P. v. B. Satyanarayana Rao (2000) 4 SCC 262; Shrimanth Balasaheb Patil v. Speaker, Karnataka Legislative Assembly [2019] 16 SCR 886 : (2020) 2 SCC 595; Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, Surat v. Saheli Leasing & Industries Ltd. [2010] 6 SCR 747 : (2010) 6 SCC 384; Kantaru Rajeevaru (Right to Religion, In re-9 J.) (2) v. Indian Young Lawyers Association [2019] 17 SCR 599 : (2020) 9 SCC 121; S.P. Mittal v. Union of India [1983] 1 SCR 729 : (1983) 1 SCC 51; Dayanand Anglo Vedic (DAV) College Trust and Management Society v. State of Maharashtra [2013] 4 SCR 821 : (2013) 4 SCC 14; Sakshi v. Union of India [2004] Supp. 2 SCR 723 : (2004) 5 SCC 518; Milkfood Ltd. v. GMC Ice Cream Private Ltd. (2004) 7 SCC 288; Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab [2014] 4 SCR 1012 : (2014) 6 SCC 466; Shah Faesal v. Union of India [2020] 3 SCR 1115 : (2020) 4 SCC 1; D.A.V. College v. State of Punjab (1971) 2 SCC 269; Gandhi Faiz-e-am-College v. University of Agra [1975] 3 SCR 810 : (1975) 2 SCC 283; Rt. Rev. Msgr. Mark Netto v. State of Kerala [1979] 1 SCR 609 : (1979) 1 SCC 23; Lily Kurian v. Lewina [1979] 1 SCR 820 : (1979) 2 SCC 124; Christian Medical College Hospital Employees’ Union v. Christian Medical College Vellore Association [1988] 1 SCR 546 : (1987) [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1673Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. 4 SCC 691; Al-Karim Educational Trust v. State of Bihar (1996) 8 SCC 330; Yunus Ali Sha v. Mohamed Abdul Kalam (1999) 3 SCC 676; Society of St. Joseph’s College v. Union of India (2002) 1 SCC 273; Secy., Malankara Syrian Catholic College v. T. Jose [2006] Supp. 9 SCR 644 : (2007) 1 SCC 386; Satimbla Sharma v. St Paul’s Senior Secondary School [2011] 10 SCR 203 : (2011) 13 SCC 760; Durgah Committee, Ajmer v. Syed Hussain Ali [1962] 1 SCR 383; P.S. Sathappan v. Andhra Bank Ltd. & Ors. [2004] Supp. 5 SCR 188 : (2004) 11 SCC 672; Executive Committee of Vaish Degree College v. Lakshmi Narain [1976] 2 SCR 1006 : (1976) 2 SCC 58; S.S. Dhanoa v. MCD [1981] 3 SCR 864 : (1981) 3 SCC 431; CIT v. Canara Bank [2018] 7 SCR 866 : (2018) 9 SCC 322; Sri Jagadguru Kari Basava Rajendraswami of Govimutt v. Commr. of Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments [1964] 8 SCR 252 : [1964] 8 SCR 252; Rabindranath Bose v. Union of India (1970) 1 SCC 84; Guru Datta Sharma v. State of Bihar [1962] 2 SCR 292]; KS Puttaswamy (Privacy-9 J.) v. Union of India [2018] 8 SCR 1 : (2017) 10 SCC 1; Keshavan Madhava Menon v. State of Bombay [1951] 1 SCR 228 : [1951] SCR 228 and Pannalal Binjraj v. Union of India [1957] 1 SCR 233 – referred to.
Hotel and Catering Industry Training Board v. Automobile Propriety Ltd (1968) 1 WLR 1526 – referred to.
Anjuman-e-Rahmania and Others v. District Inspector of Schools and Others [Supreme Court decision in W.P. (C) 54-57 of 1981] – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited In the judgment of Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, CJI:
Ronald Dworkin, “The Moral Reading of the Constitution” (March 21, 1996) – referred to.
In the judgment of Surya Kant, J.:
Jennifer Jackson Preece, “Minority rights in Europe: from Westphalia to Helsinki” Review of International Studies (1997), Vol. 23, pp. 75– 92; Joseph B. Kelly, “National Minorities in International Law”, Denv. J. Int’l L. & Pol’y, (1973) Vol. 3, pp. 253; Liebich, Andre. “Minority as Inferiority: Minority Rights in Historical Perspective” Review of International Studies, (2008) Vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 243–63; Greece 1674 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Liberated– London Protocol, (United Kingdom, France & Russia) (adopted on 03 February, 1830); Mazohl, Brigitte, ‘‘Equality among the Nationalities’ and the Peoples (Volksstämme) of the Habsburg Empire”, Constitutionalism, Legitimacy, and Power: Nineteenth- Century Experiences Chapter 9, Oxford University Press (2014); Holloway, Jonathan Scott,“Civilization, race, and the politics of uplift”, African American History: A Very Short Introduction, Chapter 4, (Oxford University Press) (2023); Treaty of Peace with Poland [Polish Minorities Treaty], (adopted on 28 June 1919); 11 Rights of Minorities in Upper Silesia (Germ. v. Pol.), 1928 P.C.I.J. (ser. A) No. 15 (Apr. 26) (Permanent Court of International Justice); Minority Schools in Albania, Advisory Opinion, PCIJ Series A/B no 64, ICGJ 314 (Permanent Court of International Justice, 1935); Greco-Bulgarian “Communities”, Advisory Opinion, PCIJ Series B. No 17 (Permanent Court of International Justice, 1928); Dosabhoy Framjee, “History of the Parsis: including their manners, customs, religion and present position” Volume 2, Discovery Publishing House, (1986); Justice R. A. Jahagirdar (Retd.), “Secularism: the Road Behind and the Road Ahead,” Secularism: Collected Works, Rationalist Foundation, pp. 9; Rochana Bajpai,“Debating Difference: Group Rights and Liberal Democracy in India, Oxford University Press, (2011); Sumit Mukherjee, “Conceptualisation and Classification of Caste and Tribe by the Census of India,” Journal of the Anthropological Survey of India, (2013), Vol. 62 no. 2 pp.807; Tariq Rahman, “Punjabi Language during British Rule,” International Journal of Punjab Studies (2007); Meetika Srivastava, “Evolution of the System of Public Administration in India from the Period 1858- 1950: A Detailed Study Highlighting the Major Landmarks in Administrative History Made During this Period” (2009), available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=1482528. Dick Kooiman, “Communalism and Indian Princely States: A Comparison with British India” Economic and Political Weekly (1995) Vol. 30 No. 34 pp. 2123-2133; Francesca R. Jensenius, “Mired in Reservations: The Path-Dependent History of Electoral Quotas in India” The Journal of Asian Studies (2015) Vol. 74 No. 1; McMillan, Alistair, “Standing at the Margins: Representation and Electoral Reservations in India ” Oxford University Press (2005); Owen, Hugh “Negotiating the Lucknow Pact”, Journal of Asian Studies, (1972) Vol. 31 No. 3 pp. 561–87; Proceedings of the Indian Round Table Conference (12th November, 1930–19th January, 1931); Krishna, K.B., The Problem of Minorities in India or Communal Representation in India, G. Allen and Unwin, (1939); [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1675Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Rochana Bajpai, “Constituent Assembly Debates and Minority Right ” Economic and Political Weekly, (2000) Vol. 35 No. 21- 22; Navin Pal Singh, Dr. Balvinder Singh Slathia, “Intricacies of Educational and Cultural Rights of Minorities in India: Efficacy of Constitutional Safeguards” UGC Care Journal (2020) Vol. 43, no.4; Kamlesh Kumar Wadhwa, Minority Safeguards in India, Thomas Press (India) Limited, (1975); “Partition of 1947 Continues to Haunt India, Pakistan ” Stanford Report (2019) available at https://news.stanford.edu/stories/2019/03/partition- 1947-continues-haunt-india-pakistan-stanford-scholar-says; B Shiva Rao (ed), The Framing of India’s Constitution, Vol. I-V, Indian Institute of Public Administration, (1967); Christina George, “Begum Aizaz Rasul: The only Muslim Woman to oppose minority reservations in the Constituent Assembly” The Indian Express, (14 February, 2018), available at https://indianexpress.com/article/ gender/begum-aizaz-rasul-the-only-muslim-woman-to-opposeminority-reservations-in-the-constituent-assembly-5057096/; Constituent Assembly Debate, Speech by Mohammad Ismail Khan, (26 May 1949); Ministry of Human Resource Development, No. F.7-5/2005-MC(P) (Notified on 18 January, 2005) available at https://www.education.gov.in/sites/upload_files/mhrd/files/ Notification18012005.pdf; Ministry of Minority Affairs, S.O. 267(E) (Notified on 27 January, 2014) available at https://ncm.nic.in/ legislations/Gazette_JainInclusion_27Jan2014.pdf; Theodore Beck, “The Principal’s Annual Report for 1898—99” (‘Principal’s Report), (1898—99), Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College Magazine (Aligarh) (MAOCM), and Aligarh Institute Gazette (Aligarh) (AIG), New Series VII, No. 11 (15 July 1899) (At this time the two journals were temporarily merged); Shamim Akhtar, “Aligarh: From College to University” Proceedings of the Indian History Congress (2018-19) Vol. 79, pp. 623; Rafiuddin Ahmad, ‘The Proposed Muslim University in India’, The Nineteenth Century, XLIV (1898), 915-21; Sushila Rao, “The Doctrine of Eclipse in Constitutional Law: A Critical Reappraisal of its Contemporary Scope and Relevance” National Law School of India Review, (2006) Vol. 18 No. 1 pp. 49; Lukas Meyer et. Al. (ed.), Rights, Culture, and the Law, Oxford University Press (2003) pp. 181; Justice GP Singh, Principles of Statutory Interpretation, Lexis Nexis (2016), 14th edn.’ Henry Sharp, “The Development of Indian Universities” Journal of the Royal Society of Arts, (1925), Vol. 73, No. 3778 pp. 523; Indian Statutory Commission, Interim Report- Review of Growth of Education in British India, Calcutta, 1676 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Government of India, Central Publication Branch (1929) pp. 123, available at https://archive.org/details/dli.csl.1000/page/ n157/mode/2up?view=theaterDr. Vishwanath Pandey (editor), Founder of Banaras Hindu University: Pandit Madan Mohan Malviya, Publication Cell, Banaras Hindu University (2006), pp. 19, available at https://web.archive.org/web/20120412191310/ http://www.bhu.ac.in/MMMMM.pdf – referred to.
In the judgment of Dipankar Datta, J.:
Constituent Assembly Debates, Volume 9, 30th August 1949 (9.127.209); Lok Sabha Debates, Twelfth Session, Third Series Vol. XLIV – No. 9, 27th August 1965; Lok Sabha Debates, Twelfth Session, Third Series Vol. XLV- No. 13, 2nd September 1965; History of the Aligarh Muslim University, Khaliq Ahmad Nizami, p. 110, Idarah-i-Adbiyat-i-Delli, Delhi, 1995 and Black’s Law Dictionary 9th Edition – referred to, In the judgment of Satish Chandra Sharma, J.:
Oxford Centre for Hindu Studies (OCHS), Oxford Centre for Islamic Studies, and Delhi University’s Centre for Hindu Studies – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India; Aligarh Muslim University Act, 1920; Aligarh Muslim University (Amendment) Act, 1951; Aligarh Muslim University (Amendment) Act, 1965; Entry 63 of List I of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution; National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions Act, 2004.
List of Keywords Educational institution; Minority institution; Indicia for ‘establishment’ of a minority educational institution; Aligarh Muslim University (AMU); Azeez Basha case; Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya case; Scope and purpose of Art.30(1); Special protection guaranteed by Art.30(1); Anti-discrimination provision; Special rights provision; Right guaranteed to minorities; Educational institutions established before and after commencement of the Constitution; Distinction between ‘incorporation’ and ‘establishment’; Effect of incorporation on minority character of an institution; Declaration as institution of national importance.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1677Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE/ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2286 of 2006 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.01.2006 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in SA No. 1324 of 2006 With Civil Appeal Nos. 2321, 2320 and 2318 of 2006, Special Leave Petition (C) No. 32490 of 2015, Writ Petition (C) No. 272 of 2016, Civil Appeal Nos. 2861, 2316, 2319 and 2317 of 2006 and T.C. (C) No. 46 of 2023 Appearances for Parties By Courts Motion.
R Venkataramani, Attorney General for India, Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, K M Nataraj, Vikramjit Banerjee, A.S.Gs., Dr. Rajeev Dhavan, Nikhil Nayyar, Kapil Sibal, Rakesh Dwivedi, Neeraj Kishan Kaul, Guru Krishna Kumar, Vinay Navare, Sridhar Potaraju, Ms. Archana P. Dave, Salman Khurshid, Sr. Advs., T. V. S. Raghavendra Sreyas, N Sai Vinod, Naveen Hegde, Siddharth Vasudev, Ms. Gayatri Gulati, Gurmeet Singh Makker, V. Mohna, Ms. Sonali Jain, Kartikay Aggarwal, Abhishek Kumar Pandey, Raman Yadav, Chitvan Singhal, Gaurang Bhushan, Madhav Sinhal, Padmesh Mishra, Kanu Agrawal, Ankur Talwar, Rohit Khare, Apoorv Kurup, R Bala, Siddhartha Sinha, Prashant Rawat, Abhishek Singh, Ms. Sushma Suri, Prashant Bhushan, Debadutta Kanungo, Govind Jee, Omanakuttan K K, Ramesh Kumar Mishra, Aftab Ali Khan, Bahar. U. Barqui, Nizam Pasha, Ms. Aparajita Jamwal, Ali Safeer Farooqi, Ms. Ruppali Samuels, Ms. Sumedha Ray Sarkar, Rishabh Parikh, Mohd. Taiyub Khan, Shahid Hussain Rizvi, Mansoor Ali, Z. K. Faizan, Mohd. Yunus, Shadan Farasat, Gautam Bhatia, Aman Naqvi, Harshit Anand, Ms. Hrishika Jain, Ms. Natasha Maheshwari, Ms. Mreganka Kukreja, Abhishek Babbar, Ajesh K. Chawla, Ms. Shivangi Singh, Ms. Saket Gautam, Ms. Mahesh Sharma, Nachiketa Joshi, Vikas Chandra Shukla, Ms. Aditi Tripathi, Eklavya Dwivedi, Ms. Sanskriti Pathak, Merusagar Samanatray, Aditya Shekhar, Pashupati Razdan, Akash Vajpai, Bhakti Vardhan Singh, Vvv Pattabhiram, Atulesh Kumar, Alabhya Dhamija, T. Bhaskar Gautham, Anirudh Sharma, Aditya Kashyap, Shubhendu Anand, Amit Sharma, 1678 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Pranaya Kumar Mohapatra, Baijnath Patel, Ms. Sneh Lata Mishra, Ms. Himadri Haksar, Narayan Dev Parashar, Santosh Kumar, Praneet Pranav, Rahul G. Tanwani, Aman Jha, Sudipto Sircar, Ms. Sindoora V.N.L, Mohit Pandey, Ms. Ankita Sharma, Yashraj Bundela, Dhruv Sharma, Ms. Shriya Gilhotra, Rishi Tutu, Raghav Agarwal, Piyush Beriwal, Sanyat Lodha, Sandeep Singh, Toshiv Goyal, R. C. Kohli, Avnish Dave, Vaibhav Dwivedi, Shuchi Singh, Gautam Singh, Aditya Sharma, Ms. Ankita Choudhary, Kumar Prashant, Ms. Rashmi Singhania, Varun Chugh, Rajan Chaurasia, Adarsh Kumar Pandey, Ayush Anand, Baij Nath Patel, Ms. Alpana Sharma, Pravartak Pathak, Ranjeet Mishra, Ms. Bharti Tyagi, Pramod Kumar Vishnoi, Akshat, Ramesh Thakur, Shaswat Nath, Shespal Sai, Gopal Jha, Sayooj Mohandas, Govind Kumar, Nisarg Choudhary, Gobind Kumar, Hrishikesh Haridas, Aishvary Vikram, Raghav Agrawal, Prakash Gautam, Anjuman Tripathi, Pankaj Singh, Ms. Ranjana Singh, Sanjay Kumar Dubey, Krishna Kant Dubey, Ujjwal Kumar Dubey, Vivek Kumar Pandey, Rakesh Kumar Tewari, Devendra Kumar Shukla, Rajeev Ranjan, Pratyush Prakash, Jitendra Kumar Tripathi, Ms. Isha Singh, Ms. Snehil Sonam, Mukesh Kumar, Arun Kanwa, Vignesh Singh, Aniruth Sharma, P. V. Yogeswaran, Ashish Kumar Upadhyay, Y. Lokesh, V. Kandha Prabhu, Ms. Maitri Goal, Sachin Kumar Verma, Neeleshwar Pavani, Prem Prakash, Ms. M. Vidhya, Dr. Vivek Sharma, Mrs. Naghma Imtiaz, Ms. Azra Rehman, Ms. Sommya Chaturvedi, Ms. Sonika Choudhary, Ms. Satakshi Mathur, Zargham Ahmed, Saif Naseem, Md Irshad Ahmed, Syed Imtiyaz Ali, Tanveer Khan, Mrs. Seema Khan, Mrs. Rubina Javed, Sheikh Imran, Ms. Sanchita Ain, (for M/S. Equity Lex Associates), M.R. Shamshad, Arijit Sarkar, Ms. Nabeela Jamil, Zaki Ahmad Khan, Sarwar Raza, Attarup Bannerjee, Sunado Raha, Pulkit Agarwal, Abu Sohel, Ms. Sampriti Baksi, Kunal Malik, Nishant Kumar Singh, Ankur Parihar, Pratyush Prasanna, Ishan Jain, Sushmit Phatale, Sudhanshu Kaushesh, Palav Agarwal, Prashant Kumar Yadav, Raghav Sehgal, Avnish Chaturvedi, Md Tasnimul Hassan, Martin G George, Gholam Mohiuddin, Anindo Mukherjee, Rameshwar Prasad Goyal, Ejaz Maqbool, Saif Zia, Gaurav Sharma, Dhawal Mohan, Prateek Bhatia, Paranjay Tripathi, Rajesh Raj, Ms. Ankita Dogra, Syed Mehdi Imam, Mohd Parvez Dabas, Uzmi Jamil Husain, Tabrez Ahmad, Mohammad Noorullah, Atif Shuhrawardy, Aqib Baig, Saheb, Abdul Nasir Khan, Amir Dabas, Anisul Haque, Advs. for the appearing parties.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1679Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dr Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, CJI* Table of Contents** A. Background ....................................................................... 5 B. The reference and related events .................................... 10 C. Submissions .................................................................... 19 D. Issues ............................................................................... 33 E. Analysis ............................................................................ 36 i. The preliminary objection by the Union of India.... 36 ii. The scope of Article 30 ........................................... 39 a. The purpose of Article 30(1) ................................ 44 b. The ‘special protection’ guaranteed by Article 30(1) ........................................................ 49 iii. Indicia for a Minority Educational Institution ......... 55 iv. Applicability of Article 30 to a ‘University’ established before the commencement of the Constitution ............................................................. 64 a. Article 30(1) applies to educational institutions established before the commencement of the Constitution ........................................................ 65 b. There is no difference between ‘Universities’ and ‘colleges’ established before the commencement of the Constitution .............................................. 69 c. The minority character of the institution is not ipso facto surrendered upon the incorporation of the University .................................................. 77 d. ‘Minority’ as on the commencement of the Constitution ......................................................... 88 v. Indicia for the ‘establishment’ of a minority educational institution ............................................. 91 * For himself, Sanjiv Khanna, J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Mishra, JJ. ** Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
1680 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports vi. Impact of Entry 63 of List I on the minority status of educational institutions ..................................... 103 vii. The decision of this Court in Prof. Yashpal ........... 107 viii. The amendment of the NCMEI Act in 2010 ............. 112 ix. Registration under the Societies Registration Act ............................................................................ 114 F. Conclusion ........................................................................ 115
1. Article 30 of the Constitution of India guarantees to religious and linguistic minorities, the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. The issues which arise for adjudication in this reference pertain to the criteria to be fulfilled to qualify as a minority educational institution for the purpose of Article 30(1) of the Indian Constitution.
A. Background
2. In 1977, the Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College was established in Aligarh. The college was a teaching institution affiliated to the Calcutta University at first and subsequently to the Allahabad University. The imperial legislature passed the Aligarh Muslim University Act 1920.1 The enactment, as the preamble indicates, “established and incorporated” Aligarh Muslim University.2 The AMU Act was amended by the Aligarh Muslim University (Amendment) Act 19513 and Aligarh Muslim University (Amendment) Act 1965.4 The amendments related to the religious instructions of Muslim students5 1 “AMU Act”
2 “AMU”
3 “1951 Amendment Act”
4 “1965 Amendment Act”
5 Section 8 was amended to stipulate that it would be unlawful for the University to adopt or impose any test of religious belief for admission or recruitment except where the religious test was made a condition for benefaction. The amended proviso to the provision stipulated that nothing in the Section shall be deemed to prevent the provision of religious instruction to those who consent to it. Section 9 which empowered the Court to mandate religious instruction for Muslim students was deleted by the amendment. Section 23(1), which provided that all members of the Court would be Muslims, was also deleted.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1681Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. and the administrative set-up of the university.6 Proceedings under Article 32 of the Constitution were instituted before this Court for challenging the constitutional validity of the 1951 Amendment Act and the 1965 Amendment Act. A Constitution Bench in the decision in S Azeez Basha v. Union of India7 upheld the constitutional validity of the Amendments. The petitioners made a three-fold argument:
(a) AMU was established by Muslims, who are a religious minority for the purposes of Article 30(1); (b) Article 30(1) guarantees Muslims the right to administer the University established by them; and
(c) the 1951 and 1965 Amendments are violative of Article 30(1) to the extent that it infringed the right of the Muslim community to administer the institution. Article 30 is extracted below: “30. Right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions.—(1) All minorities, whether based on religion or language, shall have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. (1A) In making any law providing for the compulsory acquisition of any property of an educational institution established and administered by a minority, referred to in clause (1), the State shall ensure that the amount fixed by or determined under such law for the acquisition of such property is such as would not restrict or abrogate the right guaranteed under that clause.
(2) The State shall not, in granting aid to educational institutions, discriminate against any educational institution on the ground that it is under the management of a minority, whether based on religion or language.”
The amendments were also impugned on the ground that they violated Articles 14, 19, 25, 26, 29 and 31 of the Constitution. 6 Section 23 of the AMU Act was amended to delete clauses (2) and (3). By this amendment, the powers of the Court were significantly reduced. The Court which was the supreme governing body of the University now only had the power to advise the Visitor or any other authority of the University on matters which may be referred to it for advice and exercise powers assigned to it by the Visitor. The powers of the Court were instead placed in the hands of the Executive Council. The composition of the Court (which was an all-Muslim body) was also amended. The process of constituting the Court and the Executive Council was also amended.
7 (1968) 1 SCR 833 : AIR 1968 SC 662
1682 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
3. The Union of India opposed the petitions, arguing that the Muslim minority did not have the right to administer AMU since they had not established the institution. It was submitted that AMU was established by Parliament. That being the case, it was contended that the amendments were not violative of Article 30(1).
4. A Constitution Bench dismissed the writ petitions in Azeez Basha (supra). The challenge on the ground of violation of Article 30(1) was rejected on the following grounds:
a. The phrase “establish and administer” in Article 30(1) must be read conjunctively. Religious minorities have the right to administer those educational institutions which they established. Religious minorities do not have the right to administer educational institutions which were not established by them, even if they were administering them for some reason before the commencement of the Constitution;
b. The word “establish” in Article 30(1) means “to bring into existence”;
c. AMU was not established by the Muslim minority for the following reasons:
i. AMU was brought into existence by the AMU Act, which was enacted by Parliament in 1920. Section 6 of the AMU Act provides that the degrees conferred to persons by the University would be recognised by the government.
This provision indicates that AMU was established by the Government of India because the Muslim minority could not have insisted that the degrees conferred by a university established by it ought to be recognized by the Government. The AMU Act may have been passed as a result of the efforts of the Muslim community but that does not mean that AMU was established by them;
ii. The conversion of the College to the University was not by the Muslim minority but by virtue of the 1920 Act; and iii. Section 4 of the AMU Act by which the MAO College and the Muslim University Association were dissolved, and the properties, rights and liabilities in the societies were vested in AMU shows that the previous bodies legally ceased to exist;
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1683Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. d. Since the Muslim community did not establish AMU, it cannot claim a right to administer it under Article 30(1). Thus, any amendment to the AMU Act would not be ultra vires Article 30 of the Constitution;
e. The argument that the administration of the University vested in the Muslim community though it was not established by them was rejected. The administration of AMU did not vest in the Muslim minority under the AMU Act for the following reasons: i. Although all the members of the Court (which was the supreme governing body in terms of Section 23 of the AMU Act) were required to be Muslims, the electorate (which elected the members of the Court) did not comprise exclusively of Muslims;
ii. Other authorities of AMU such as the Executive Council and the Academic Council were tasked with the administration of the University and were given significant powers. The members of these bodies were not required to be Muslims; iii. The Governor General (who was the Lord Rector) was also entrusted with certain “overriding” powers concerning the administration of the University. The Governor General was not required to be a Muslim. In terms of Section 28(3), the Governor General had overriding powers to amend or repeal the Statutes. The Governor General possessed similar powers with respect to amending or repealing Ordinances. In terms of Section 40, the Governor General had the power to remove any difficulty in the establishment of the University; and iv. The Visiting Board which consisted of the Governor of the United Provinces, the members of the Executive Council and Ministers were not necessarily required to be Muslims; f. The term “establish and maintain” in Article 26 must be read conjunctively, like the phrase “establish and administer” in Article
30. Assuming that educational institutions fall within the ambit of Article 26, the Muslim community does not have the right to maintain AMU because it did not establish it; and g. The impugned amendments do not violate Articles 14, 19, 25, 29 and 31.
1684 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports B. The reference and related events
5. In 1981, a two-Judge Bench of this Court in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya v. District Inspector of Schools8 was faced with a question of whether V.M.H.S Rehmania Inter College is a minority educational institution. By an order dated 26 November 1981, the Bench questioned the correctness of Azeez Basha (supra) and referred the matter to a Bench of seven Judges, in the following terms:
“After hearing counsel for the Parties, we are clearly of the opinion that this case involves two substantial questions regarding the interpretation of Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India. The present institution was founded in the year 1938 and registered under the Societies Registration Act in the year 1940. The documents relating to the time when the institution was founded clearly shows that while the institution was established mainly by the Muslim community but there were members from the non-Muslim community also who participated in the establishment process. The point that arises is as to whether Art. 30(1) of the Constitution envisages an institution which is established by minorities alone without the participation for the factum of establishment from any other community. On this point, there is no clear decision of this court. There are some observations in S. Azeez Basha & ors. Vs. Union of India 1968(1)
SCR 333, but these observations can be explained away.
Another point that arises is whether soon after the establishment of the institution if it is registered as a Society under the Society Registration Act, its status as a minority institution changes in view of the broad principles laid down in S. Azeez Basha’s case. Even as it is several jurists including Mr. Seervai have expressed about the correctness of the decision of this court in S. Azeez Basha’s case. Since the point has arisen in this case we think that this is a proper occasion when a larger bench can consider the entire aspect fully. We, therefore, direct that this case may be placed before 8 W.P.(C) No. 54-57 of 1981 [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1685Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Hon. The Chief Justice for being heard by a bench of at least 7 judges so that S. Azeez Basha’s case may also be considered and the points that arise in this case directly as to the essential conditions or ingredients of the minority institution may also be decided once for all. A large number of jurists including Mr. Seervai, learned counsel for the petitioners Mr. Garg and learned counsel for respondents and interveners Mr. Dikshit and Kaskar have stated that this case requires reconsideration. In view of the urgency it is necessary that the matter should be decided as early as possible we give liberty to the counsel for parties to mention the matter before Chief Justice.” (emphasis supplied)
The above extract indicates that the following three questions were of concern to this Court: (i) the essential conditions or ingredients of a minority educational institution; (ii) whether the expression ‘establish’ in Article 30 means that the institution should be established only by a minority without any association by other communities; and
(iii) whether the registration under the Societies Registration Act 1860 after the establishment of the institution alters its character.
6. About a month after the order referring the matter to a Bench of seven Judges, the AMU Act was amended. On 31 December 1981, the Aligarh Muslim University (Amendment) Act 19819 received the assent of the President. Various provisions of the AMU Act were amended, including the long title and preamble from which the words “establish and” were omitted.10 Section 2(l) which defined the term ‘University’ was also amended.11 After the amendment, ‘University’ was defined to mean “the educational institution of their choice established by the Muslims of India, which originated as the Mohammedan Anglo-Oriental College, Aligarh, and which was subsequently incorporated as the Aligarh Muslim University.” The amendment included Section 5(2)(c) by which the University was required to promote “the educational and cultural advancement of the Muslims of India”.12 9 AMU (Amendment) Act 1981 10 AMU (Amendment) Act 1981, Section 2 11 AMU (Amendment) Act 1981, Section 3 12 AMU (Amendment) Act 1981, Section 4 1686 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
7. In 2002, an eleven-Judge Bench of this Court in TMA Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka13 heard a batch of tagged matters which included Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra). This Court formulated a question which reflected the reference made in Anjuman-e- Rahmaniya (supra). The question was as follows: what is the indicia for an educational institution to be a minority education institution to which the rights in Article 30 would apply:
“3(a) What are the indicia for treating an educational institution as a minority educational institution? Would an institution be regarded as a minority educational institution because it was established by a person(s) belonging to a religious or linguistic minority or its being administered by a person(s) belonging to a religious or linguistic minority?”
8. Despite framing the question arising from the reference, this Court did not answer it in TMA Pai (supra). The decision stated that a regular Bench would adjudicate the question. However, the regular Bench disposed of the matters before it on 11 March 2003 without answering the question.
9. Separately, AMU proposed a policy for admission into its postgraduate medical course by which 50% of the seats were reserved for Muslim candidates. The proposal was accepted by the Union of India. Proceedings were initiated under Article 226 for challenging the constitutional validity of the reservation policy.
10. The petitioners argued that the reservation policy by which 50% of the seats were earmarked for Muslims was unconstitutional because AMU was not a minority educational institution in view of the judgment of this Court in Azeez Basha (supra). They averred that the amendments to Sections 2(l) and 5(2)(c) of the AMU Act by the AMU (Amendment) Act 1981 attempted to overrule the judgment in Azeez Basha (supra) without altering the basis of the decision in that case. In response, AMU contended that the AMU (Amendment) Act 1981 had the effect of changing the basis of Azeez Basha (supra) and that AMU was a minority institution after the amendment, and thus was entitled to reserve seats for candidates from the Muslim community.
13 (2002) 8 SCC 481
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1687Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
11. A Single Judge of the Allahabad High Court in the decision in Dr. Naresh Agarwal v. Union of India declared the reservation policy unconstitutional on the following grounds:14 a. The basis for the decision in Azeez Basha (supra) was Sections 3, 4, and 6. These provisions were not amended by the AMU (Amendment) Act 1981. The deletion of the word ‘establish’ from the long title and the preamble, and the amendment to the definition of the term ‘University’ in Section 2(l) are not sufficient to hold that AMU is a minority institution under Article 30; b. The Muslim community willingly surrendered the right to administer the University to statutory bodies;
c. The amendment to Section 2(l) is a legislative action which encroaches on judicial power and is akin to Parliament functioning as an appellate court or tribunal. To prevent Section 2(l) from being struck down for overruling Azeez Basha (supra), it is necessary to read down the term “established” in the amended AMU Act as referring to MAO College; and d. AMU, not being a minority institution, is not entitled to the protection of Article 30 and shall not provide for reservation on the basis of religion as this would amount to a violation of Article 29(2).
12. The Court declared AMU’s reservation policy unconstitutional and directed the cancellation of the admissions made under this policy. It directed the University to conduct a fresh entrance examination without reservation on the basis of religion.
13. The judgement in appeal by a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court was reported as Aligarh Muslim University v. Malay Shukla.15 The Division Bench affirmed the judgment of the Single Judge, with some modifications. AN Ray, C.J. speaking for the Division Bench held that:
a. When the minority status is not assumed or admitted, the factor of administration and control by non-minority groups becomes important. The indicia for the determination of whether an 14 2005 SCC OnLine All 1705 15 Judgment in Special Appeal No 1321 of 2005 and connected matters, High Court of Allahabad 1688 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports educational institution is a minority educational institution is (i) who established it; (ii) who is responsible for administration; and (iii) the purpose of the establishment;
b. By amending Section 2(l), Parliament attempted to overrule the decision in Azeez Basha (supra). This amendment does not change the basis of that decision because the incorporation of the University was not the sole factor which influenced the decision;
c. Section 5(2)(c) is discriminatory. Further, it does not change the basis of the decision in Azeez Basha (supra);
d. The removal of the words “establish and” from the long title and preamble of the AMU Act is impermissible because Azeez Basha (supra) held that incorporation and establishment are intimately connected. Permitting the omission of the word “establish” may give rise to doubts as to whether incorporation alone is sufficient for the surrender of the minority character of the institution;
e. AMU is not merely a university but a field of legislative power in Entry 63 of List I of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution. Section 2(l) modified the definition of a word in an entry in the Seventh Schedule. The definition of a word in the Constitution cannot be altered except through a constitutional amendment. The AMU (Amendment) Act 1981 therefore suffers from lack of legislative competence; and f. Parliament lacks the authority to create a minority institution. Only a minority can do so and courts may declare whether a minority has succeeded in establishing an institution under Article 30.
14. Ashok Bhushan, J. concurred with AN Ray, C.J. in a separate judgment. The learned Judge observed that the institution must have been both established and administered by a minority to seek the protection of Article 30(1). The 1981 Amendment, in his view, has dealt with the establishment component of the judgment but has left the administration component untouched. Further, the learned Judge agreeing with Chief Justice Ray observed that the requirements for a minority to establish an institution cannot be secured by merely altering the definition of the institution and the long title and the preamble of [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1689Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. the Act. In view of the findings detailed above, the Court declared that AMU was not a minority institution within the meaning of Article 30 and struck down Sections 2(l) and 5(2)(c) as amended by the AMU (Amendment) Act 1981. The High Court held that the removal of the words “establish and” from the long title and preamble was invalid and restored them. It affirmed the conclusion of the Single Judge that the reservation policy was unconstitutional. However, it overruled the direction issued by the Single Judge to AMU to cancel the admission of students who had already been accommodated in the University on the basis of the reservation policy.
15. On 12 February 2019, while hearing the appeal against the judgment of the Division Bench, a three-Judge Bench of this Court presided over by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi noticed that the High Court relied on the decision in Azeez Basha (supra). It also noticed that the reference in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra) on the correctness of Azeez Basha (supra) was yet to be determined. The observations in Azeez Basha (supra) that the words “establish” and “administer” in Article 30(1) must be read conjunctively were referred to. Having noticed all of the above, the three-Judge Bench observed that the correctness of the question arising from the decision in Azeez Basha (supra) is unanswered:
“1. This Court in S. Azeez Basha and Anr. Vs. Union of India, inter alia, has observed as follows:
“It is to our mind quite clear that Art. 30(1)
postulates that the religious community will have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice meaning thereby that where a religious minority established an educational institution, it will have the right to administer that. An argument has been raised to the effect that even though the religious minority may not have established the educational institution, it will have the right to administer it, if by some process it had been administering the same before the Constitution came into force.
We are not prepared to accept this argument.
The Article in our opinion clearly shows that the minority will have the right to administer 1690 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports educational institutions of their choice provided they have established them, but not otherwise.
The Article cannot be read to mean that even if the educational institution has been established by somebody else, any religious minority would have the right to administer it because, for some reason or other, it might have been administering it before the Constitution came into force. The words “establish and administer” in the Article must be read conjunctively and so read it gives the right to the minority to administer an educational institution provided it has been established by it. ……….We are of the opinion that nothing in that case justifies the contention raised on behalf of the petitioners that the minorities would have the right to administer an educational institution even though the institution may not have been established by them. The two words in Art. 30(1) must be read together and so read the Article gives the right to the minority to administer institutions established by it. If the educational institution has not been established by a minority it cannot claim the right to administer it under Art. 30(1).”
[…]
8. The said facts would show that the correctness of the question arising from the decision of this Court in S. Azeez Basha (supra) has remained undetermined.
9. That apart, the decision of this Court in Prof. Yashpal and another vs. State of Chhattisgarh and others and the amendment of the National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions Act, 2004 made in the year 2010 would also require an authoritative pronouncement on the aforesaid question formulated, as set out above, besides the correctness of the view expressed in the judgment of this Court in S. Azeez Basha (supra) which has been extracted above.”
(emphasis supplied)
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1691Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
16. The three-Judge Bench then referred the matter to a seven-Judge Bench.
17. When this matter was taken up for hearing, the Union of India sought to withdraw its appeal against the decision of the Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court.16 This Court is competent to hear the present case even if the Union of India was permitted to withdraw its appeal because the other appellants continue to press their case. C. Submissions
18. The petitioners broadly contend that the decision in Azeez Basha (supra) is not correct, and that AMU is a minority institution. The submissions of the learned counsel on behalf of the petitioners and the intervenors are summarized below.
19. Dr. Rajeev Dhawan, learned senior counsel made the following submissions:
a. The Union of India’s recent attempt to withdraw its appeal against the minority status of AMU contradicts its consistent position since 1981;
b. Azeez Basha (supra) is no longer good law because:
i. It failed to recognize that the words ‘establish’ and ‘administer’ are not preconditions to define a minority but the consequential rights that flow from such a recognition; ii. The assumption that universities lose their minority status when recognized by a statute conflicts with the right of minorities to establish educational institutions;
iii. It recognized the role of the Muslim community in the establishment of AMU but held that its origins and administration were rooted in legislation. This interpretation could restrict the recognition of minority institutions under Article 30;
iv. Its restrictive interpretation of the word ‘establish’ in Article 30(1) is contrary to the expansive view adopted by subsequent judgments; and 16 Civil Appeal No. 2318 of 2006, Supreme Court of India 1692 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports v. This decision has been superseded by subsequent decisions like TMA Pai (supra), which emphasized that the religious character of an institution cannot be stripped down by government interventions.
c. Upholding Azeez Basha (supra) could jeopardize the minority status of several educational institutions, including recognized minority institutions like St. Stephen’s College and Christian Medical College;
d. Minority rights were acknowledged by the State before the adoption of the Constitution through various legislative enactments like the Indian Councils Act of 1909, and the Government of India Acts of 1919 and 1935, which provided reservations to Muslims, Sikhs, and Christians in the legislature; e. The formation of AMU was characterized as a “movement” rather than a “surrender” by the Mohammedan Anglo-Oriental College. Provisions in the AMU Act, including the transfer of assets, liabilities, and special provisions for Muslim students, underscore the continuation of minority rights with the establishment of AMU; f. Entry 63 in the Union List of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution deals with the competence of the Union to make laws regarding AMU and BHU but does not determine who established or administers the universities. Article 30, which guarantees minority rights, cannot be negated merely because the institution is of national importance in terms of Entry 63; g. The evolution of the AMU Act can be broken down into four phases: pre-1951 with Muslim administration, the 1951 Amendment aligning with the Constitution, the 1965 Amendment diluting minority status, and attempts to restore minority status in 1972 and 1981;
h. While the 1951 amendment aligned the Act with the Constitution by removing compulsory religious education, the 1965 amendment diluted minority administration by reducing “the Court” to an advisory role, shifting the supreme governing authority to the “Visitor” and the President of India; and i. Amendments in 1972 and 1981 aimed to restore AMU to minorities. The 1981 amendment explicitly stated that AMU was “established by the Muslims of India” and aimed to [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1693Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. promote Muslim educational and cultural advancement. The 1981 amendment accommodated a democratic setup, focusing on the institution’s original purpose rather than numerical representation.
20. Mr Kapil Sibal, learned senior counsel made the following submissions:
a. The enactment of the Act of 1920 marked the formal recognition of the MAO “College” as the Aligarh Muslim University, reflecting a crucial legislative step in its evolution into a full-fledged University;
b. Compliance with regulatory requirements, constitutionally grounded in Article 19(6), is crucial for university status. However, adherence to these regulations does not diminish the right guaranteed by Article 30 to minorities to establish institutions of their choice;
c. Article 30 grants religious and linguistic minorities the autonomy to establish and administer institutions of their “choice”. Institutions covered by Article 30 have the flexibility to choose their administrative set-up, even if it includes individuals outside the minority community. This choice is solely vested in the institution;
d. Assessing the numerical composition within the administration is inadequate to determine its minority status. Minority institutions have the prerogative to include non-minorities in their administration while maintaining their minority status. St. Stephen’s College, Delhi, despite having a Christian representation of less than 5 per cent, maintains its classification as a minority institution;
e. The crucial factor for recognizing an educational institution as a Minority educational institution lies in its genesis, focusing on three key aspects:
i. the purpose for which it was founded (educational advancement of the minority community);
ii. the identity of the founders and major fund providers (being substantially from the concerned minority); and iii. the concept’s initiation by a member of the minority, 1694 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports f. Provisions within the AMU Act focus on governance structures, academic standards, and prevention of maladministration. These statutory measures primarily relate to the administration of the University and do not alter the constitutional fact of its establishment by a minority;
g. “Establish” under Article 30 must be interpreted to mean ‘found’. The word does not cover the conversion process from a college to a university through the AMU Act;
h. AMU was established with the objective of providing quality education specifically to Muslims. The exclusivity of such institutions in offering education tailored to the needs of minorities was not adequately considered by Azeez Basha (supra);
i. The denial of reservation to institutions like AMU results in fewer degrees and job opportunities, exacerbating socio-economic disparities within minority groups;
j. The founders of AMU satisfactorily fulfilled the five-step criteria laid down in TMA Pai (supra) to ascertain the right to administer. The criteria related to admission policies, fee structures, governance, faculty appointments and disciplinary action; k. The objective of establishing AMU was to obtain the status of an independent university and not demonstrate allegiance to colonial authorities;
l. A minority institution can accede to some regulations to maintain a particular standard of education. With that, the institution also retains the right to challenge any invasive restrictions imposed on it; and m. The imperial government never interfered with the administration of the University after it was incorporated. MAO College was also supervised by the British government even when it was not a university. MAO College was acknowledged as a minority institution under Azeez Basha (supra).
21. Mr Salman Khurshid, learned senior counsel made the following submissions:
a. Adopting a ‘political, moral reading’ of Article 30 would facilitate a broader interpretation of the term ‘established’. Ronald Dworkin’s definition of a ‘political moral reading’ involves invoking moral [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1695Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. principles about political decency and justice for interpreting constitutional provisions;17 b. Aligarh Tehzeeb represents a distinctive cultural ethos cultivated by the AMU. This unique cultural identity encompasses traditions, values and practices that have evolved within the university; c. The concept of takeover in the context of educational institutions can be categorized into non-consensual and consensual takeovers. In the case of AMU, there was a consensual takeover, where changes and amendments were made to its structure and character through a process that involved the University’s participation and consent; and d. AMU was founded by members of the community. The societies formed for this purpose had a crucial role in the establishment and evolution of the University, contributing resources, support and a collective vision that shaped the identity and character of AMU.
22. Mr. Shadan Farasat, learned counsel submitted that: a. The purpose of Article 30 rests primarily on two grounds: i. The ability to retain the minority identity;
ii. The ability to fully participate in the national mainstream; Azeez Basha (supra) adopts an approach by which the institution could either retain the minority status or integrate into the national mainstream and lose it;
b. The Indian secularism model allows state involvement in religious activities without compromising their character;
c. In advocating for a broader interpretation of ‘establish’ in Article 30, there is a need to distinguish between ‘establish’ and ‘incorporate’ to better preserve constitutional protection for minority educational institutions. The AMU Act of 1920 only “incorporated” AMU. This is fundamentally different from the establishment of the institution;
d. Stripping away the minority character of AMU would diminish its significant place in history since the institution has led to: 17 Reliance was placed on Ronald Dworkin, “The Moral Reading of the Constitution” (March 21, 1996). 1696 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports i. The creation of a Muslim-educated middle class; and ii. The education of women.
e. The validity of the 1981 amendment should not be considered in this case. The Parliament enacted it to reinstate AMU’s minority status, which is now being contested by the current Union government. Considering the Union’s arguments requires reassessing Parliament’s reasoning behind the law.
23. Mr MR Shamshad, learned counsel submitted that an inclusive definition of ‘minority educational institutions’ includes universities established and administered by minorities.
24. The respondents broadly submitted that Azeez Basha (supra) is good law, and that AMU is not a minority institution. They argued that AMU was established by Parliament. The submissions of the learned counsel on behalf of the respondents and the intervenors are summarized below.
25. Mr R Venkataramani, Attorney General for India appearing for the Union of India, made the following submissions:
a. The right guaranteed by Article 30 can only be exercised if there is legislation in place to enable the establishment and administration of minority institutions. This legislation should empower minorities to form institutions under constitutional provisions; and b. While Article 30 guarantees minorities certain rights, they are not exempt from other constitutional requirements, particularly regarding reservation.
26. Mr Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General of India appearing for the Union of India, made the following submissions:
a. Azeez Basha (supra) correctly recognized the choices available to AMU in 1920. It had the choice of either affiliating with another university or surrendering its minority status to the imperial government;
b. Under the AMU Act, AMU voluntarily surrendered its minority institution status to the imperial government. This is shown by the historical context of the Aligarh Split, where the institution’s leaders chose cooperation with the British government over retaining its Muslim character;
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1697Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. c. The British government exerted control over AMU, as evidenced by provisions in the 1920 Act. The Lord Rector had significant authority in the administration of the institution. The Act dissolved the previous governing body and transferred property and decision-making authority to secular government authorities; d. The 1920 Act was a substantive statute which dealt with the specifics of the administration of the institution. The administration of the institution predominantly vested with the non-minority; e. The British government mandated that AMU should not be a religious institution and should be controlled by secular authorities;
f. Amendments in 1951 made the 1920 Act consistent with constitutional provisions. This affirmed that AMU was established by statute, not by the minority community;
g. Justice M.C. Chagla in the course of legislative debates in 1965 stated that AMU was neither established nor administered by minorities. Azeez Basha (supra) correctly held that AMU surrendered its minority status to the British Government; h. The validity of the 1981 amendment is questionable, as it is contrary to previous judicial decisions;
i. The 1981 reference sought clarity on the definition of a minority educational institution. The reference did not include the question of whether AMU is a minority educational institution. Legal challenges in 2005 regarding reservations for Muslims in postgraduate programs led to the current reference. This reference also focused on a specific legal question without reopening factual controversies;
j. The term “establish” under Article 30 should be interpreted to mean tangible and manifest establishment. The indicia to decide the minority character of an institution contemplated under Article 30(1) of the Constitution, must include the following:
i. The institution/university must necessarily be established and administered by the minority community; and ii. The institution/university should be established by the minority, for the minority and as a minority institution. 1698 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports k. There are concerns about the potential misuse of minority status without a strict standard of actual establishment. The drafting history of fundamental rights under Articles 29 and 30 consistently uses “establish” and “administer” conjunctively and further expresses apprehensions about an over-expansive interpretation of these Articles;
l. The genesis of an institution does not determine its minority status. Legislative enactments are the final authority on the establishment, as seen in legislations where the minority status is explicitly recognised;
m. The reliance on St. Stephen’s (supra) is self-defeating since this Court applied the standard of administrative control as an indicia in that case. The involvement of the Government in AMU’s establishment, clear intent and specific provisions indicate the national and non-minority character of the institution; n. The Nation Commission for Minority Educational Institution Act 200418 and its Amendment in 2010 provide that an institution needs to be established and administered by minorities to be a minority educational institution. The said definition is not under challenge; and o. The consequence of recognising AMU as a minority educational institution is that seats cannot be reserved for the other categories of the Scheduled Castes/Scheduled Tribes/Socially and Educationally Backward Classes.
27. Mr Rakesh Dwivedi, learned senior counsel submitted that: a. For a community to be considered a “minority,” it must fulfil three criteria:
i. It must be numerically lesser than the majority;
ii. It cannot be the ruling group even if it is numerically smaller; and iii. The group itself should identify as a minority.
b. Muslims were not recognized as a minority during British rule, as Hindus and Muslims were considered equals. Syed Ahmed 18 “NCMEI Act”
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1699Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Khan, the founder of Mohammedan Anglo-Oriental College, claimed in a letter that the Muslim community never considered itself as a minority and instead as rulers prior to the British government;
c. Judgments of this Court have held that Article 30(1) applies to institutions that were established before the commencement of the Constitution. However, these decisions dealt with colleges and schools and not a University. Article 30(1) does not apply to a University that was established before the commencement of the Constitution because a University before the enactment of the University Grants Commission 1956 could only have been established by the Government and not a person; and d. Azeez Basha (supra) was a standalone and statute-specific judgment. Overruling it would disrupt the Union’s control over AMU, constituting “public mischief”. The precedent set by the case should only be overturned if there is a substantial risk to public interest, which is not the case here.
28. Mr. Neeraj Kishan Kaul, learned senior counsel submitted that: a. The correctness or validity of Azeez Basha (supra) was not within the purview of the reference order, which solely aimed to clarify the meaning of “established and administered” under Article 30; b. Parliament cannot deny a fact by creating legal fiction in a subsequent legislation. The 1981 amendment only attempted to change who “established” the University but made no change in the provision related to the administration of the University. It attempted to rewrite history by altering the recognition of the University’s establishment;
c. AMU’s inclusion as an institution of national importance under Entry 63 of the Union list gives the Union government sole authority over it. Altering AMU’s status would require a constitutional amendment rather than a legislative amendment; and d. Over the past decades, there has been no demand for minority status for AMU, as evidenced by legislative actions in 1951 and 1965. The demand for minority rights now would conflict with existing reservation rights for Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and Socially and Economically Backward Classes. 1700 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
29. Mr Guru Krishnakumar, learned senior counsel made the following submissions:
a. The “new sovereign,” presumably referring to contemporary legislative and executive authorities, holds the discretion to determine the approach towards minority rights. This implies that decisions regarding minority rights are subject to the interpretation and judgment of current governing bodies; b. H.V. Kamath in the Constituent Assembly advocated for parliamentary legislation on universities to demonstrate their impartial and non-communal nature. Similarly, Naziruddin Ahmed, a member of the Muslim League in the Constituent Assembly, asserted that universities were rightly under the Union’s jurisdiction; and c. A fact established by legislation cannot override a fact recognised by the Court.19
30. Mr Vijay Navare, learned senior counsel submitted that granting minority status to AMU would undermine Parliament’s authority and interfere with powers vested under Entry 63.
31. Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, learned senior counsel submitted that AMU was created ‘by the Statute’ (Act 21 of 1920) and not ‘under the Statute’.
32. Mr. Nachiketa Joshi, learned counsel submitted that the Rajya Sabha debates related to the amendments of 1981 reveal a misconception that this Court in Azeez Basha (supra) neglected AMU’s history before 1920. The amendment failed to alter the foundational aspect of Azeez Basha (supra), which is centred on the Muslim community’s concessions to the terms of the British Government.
D. Issues
33. The petitioner and the respondents disagree on whether this Bench must determine if AMU is a minority educational institution. In Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra), the two-Judge Bench referred the question of the essential ingredients of a minority education institution. This was the core issue which was referred to the Constitution 19 Reliance was placed on Indira Sawhney (II) v. Union of India & Ors, AIR 2000 SC 498. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1701Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Bench. The other two questions which were formulated, that is, the meaning of the phrase “establish” and the impact of registration under the Societies Registration Act 1860 after the establishment of the institution are in essence, subsets of the core issue. The question of the indicia for recognising an educational institution as a minority educational institution was reflected in question 3(a) framed in TMA Pai (supra). Thus, neither was Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra) nor TMA Pai (supra) concerned with the factual situation in Azeez Basha: that is, whether AMU is a minority education institution.
34. The 2019 reference order also limits the reference to the legal aspects arising from the decision in Azeez Basha (supra) and not the factual aspects of the decision relating to AMU. This is clear from the passages from the 2019 reference order extracted above, particularly paragraphs 8 and 9. Paragraph 8 states that the correctness of the “question arising from” Azeez Basha (supra) has “remained undetermined”. The paragraph indicates that the 2019 reference order must be read along with the previous references in both Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra) and TMA Pai Foundation (supra). Paragraph 9 mentions that the correctness of the view in Azeez Basha (supra) “which has been extracted above” requires an authoritative pronouncement. The paragraph from Azeez Basha (supra) extracted in the 2019 reference order deals with the question of indicia to be considered a minority educational institution. It is evident upon a reading of the reference orders that only the question of the criteria to be fulfilled to qualify as a minority educational institution is referred to this Bench.
35. From the order in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra) referring the judgment in Azeez Basha (supra) to a larger Bench, the question formulated in TMA Pai (supra) and the 2019 Reference order, the question that must be decided by this Bench is what are the ingredients, indicia or criteria for an educational institution to be considered a minority educational institution under Article 30. The following issues must be answered for this purpose:
a. Whether an educational institution must be both established and administered by a linguistic or religious minority to secure the guarantee under Article 30;
b. What are the criteria to be satisfied for the ‘establishment’ of a minority institution? Whether Article 30(1) envisages an 1702 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports institution which is established by a minority with participation from members of other communities;
c. Whether a minority educational institution which is registered as a society under the Societies Registration Act 186020 soon after its establishment loses its status as a minority educational institution by virtue of such registration; and d. Whether the decision of this Court in Prof. Yashpal v. State of Chhattisgarh21 and the amendment of National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions Act 200522 in 2010 have a bearing on the question formulated above and if so, in what manner.
E. Analysis i. The preliminary objection by the Union of India
36. The Union of India advanced a preliminary objection to the reference. It argued that the order dated 26 November 1981 in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra) by which the matter was referred to a Bench of seven Judges is “wholly bad in law.” It relies on the decision of a Constitution Bench in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community v. State of Maharashtra23 to argue that the two- Judge Bench of this Court in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra) could not have referred the correctness of the decision rendered by the Constitution Bench in Azeez Basha (supra) directly to a Bench of seven Judges. It was suggested that the two-Judge Bench ought to have referred the matter to a Bench of equal strength to the decision the correctness of which is doubted, that is, a Bench of five Judges. The Union of India argued that only a Bench of five Judges could have referred the matter to a Bench of seven Judges.
37. In Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community (supra), a Constitution Bench discussed the legal precepts which apply to orders of reference and reiterated the position of law as below:24 20 “Societies Registration Act”
21 [2005] 2 SCR 23 : (2005) 5 SCC 420 22 “NCMEI Act”
23 (2005) 2 SCC 673
24 Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community (supra) [12] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1703Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. a. Decisions of this Court rendered by a Bench of larger strength are binding on Benches of a less or equal strength;
b. If a Bench of lower strength is doubtful about the correctness of a judgment delivered by a Bench of larger strength, it cannot disagree or dissent from the view taken by the larger Bench. In case of doubt, it can invite the attention of the Chief Justice of India to its opinion and request the Chief Justice to list the matter before a Bench, the strength of which is greater than that which delivered the judgment which has been doubted; c. The correctness of the view taken by any Bench can only be doubted by a Bench of equal strength. The matter will then be placed for hearing before a Bench of greater strength;
d. There are two exceptions to the rules discussed above: i. The discretion of the Chief Justice is not bound by the rules. As the master of the roster, the Chief Justice may list any case before any Bench of any strength;
ii. Despite the rules discussed above, if a particular case has come up for hearing before a Bench of larger strength and that Bench is of the opinion that the judgment of the Bench of lower strength requires reconsideration or correction, or is otherwise doubtful of its correctness, it may dispense with the need for a reference in the terms described above or an order of the Chief Justice and hear the matter for reasons given by it.
38. The position of law laid down in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community (supra) is correct. Decisions of a larger Bench are binding precedent, and judicial discipline and propriety dictate that Benches of lower strength must adhere to such decisions. This will also avoid inconsistencies in the development of law. Questions concerning the correctness of judgments must ordinarily be referred only by a Bench which is equal in strength to the Bench whose judgment is doubted. We also agree with the two exceptions to this rule, as detailed by this Court in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community (supra). They must remain exceptions and not transmogrify into the rule itself.
39. The three issues which required an authoritative pronouncement in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra), were not directly a point of contention in Azeez Basha (supra). However, the decision would 1704 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports have a bearing on them. Doubting the correctness of the opinion in Azeez Basha (supra), without disagreeing with it, the two-Judge Bench requested that the matter may be placed before the Chief Justice of India for being heard by a Bench of seven Judges. This falls within the permissible limits laid down in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community (supra) as explained in point (b) of paragraph 37. Further, the Solicitor General has also stated that he is not pressing the Union’s preliminary objection. The order of reference dated 12 February 2019, too, noted that although a three-Judge Bench could not ordinarily refer a case directly to a seven-Judge Bench, it was doing so in this case because the question was already referred to a Bench of seven Judges but was not answered. The reference order notes:
“10. Ordinarily and in the normal course the judicial discipline would require the Bench to seek a reference of this matter by a Five Judges Bench. However, having regard to the background, as stated above, when the precise question was already referred to a Seven Judges Bench and was, however, not answered, we are of the view that the present question, set out above, should be referred to a Bench of Hon’ble Seven Judges.
11. Consequently and in the light of the above, place these matters before the Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India on the administrative side for appropriate orders.”
40. This Court will hear the questions referred to a seven-Judge Bench for these reasons.
ii. The scope of Article 30
41. The fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution do not operate in silos. In A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras,25 the majority judgment of this Court held that fundamental rights operate to the mutual exclusion of one another. In other words, each fundamental right was understood as being distinct and unrelated to the others. This view of Part III of the Constitution was later rejected in Rustom Cavasjee
25 AIR 1950 SC 27
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1705Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Cooper v. Union of India,26 which held that Part III “weaves a pattern of guarantees on the texture of basic human rights. The guarantees delimit the protection of those rights in their allotted fields: they do not attempt to enunciate distinct rights.”27 Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India28 affirmed that Rustom Cavasjee Cooper (supra) overruled the majority judgment in A.K. Gopalan (supra). Thus, the scope of the right of “minorities to establish and administer educational institutions” must be identified in the background of the other cultural and religious rights guaranteed by the Constitution.
42. Articles 25 to 28 are placed under the heading ‘Right to freedom of religion’. Article 25(1) stipulates that all persons are equally entitled to freedom of conscience, the right to freely profess, practice or propagate religion. This is subject, however, to public order, morality, health and other provisions of Part III of the Constitution. Clause (2) of Article 25 provides that nothing in Clause (1) would affect the operation of any existing law or prevent the State from enacting a law regulating or restricting any economic, financial, political or secular activity, which may be associated with religious practice, and legislation providing for social welfare reform or opening Hindu religious institutions of public character to all classes and sections of Hindus. Article 26 guarantees religious denominations or a section of them, the right to establish and maintain institutions for religious and charitable purposes, manage their own affairs in the matter of religion, to own and acquire movable and immovable property, and administer such property in accordance with law. The rights are subject to public order, morality and health. Article 27 mandates that no one shall be compelled to pay any taxes, the proceeds of which are to be specifically appropriated in payment of expenses for the promotion and maintenance of any particular religion or religious denomination.
43. Article 28, deals with the rights of individuals and secures to them vide clause (3), the right not to take part in any religious instructions that may be imparted in any educational institution recognised by the State or receiving aid of the State funds. The provision stipulates that a person need not attend religious worship conducted in such institution
26 (1970) 1 SCC 248
27 (1970) 1 SCC 248 [52]
28 (1978) 1 SCC 248
1706 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports or any premises attached thereto unless he wishes to do so, and if such person is a minor, upon the consent of his guardian. Clause (1) of Article 28 restricts educational institutions wholly maintained out of the State funds29 from imparting ‘religious instructions’. However, clause (2) to Article 28 stipulates that clause (1) will not apply to an educational institution which is administered by the State but was established under an endowment or trust which required religious instruction to be imparted in such institution. The clause recognises the distinction between ‘establishment’ and ‘administration’ of an institution.
44. Articles 29 and 30 under the heading ‘Cultural and Educational Rights’, are two provisions which specifically confer rights on a section of citizens residing in the territory of India or a part thereof, having a distinct language, script, or culture. Some would say that these are in nature of special privileges, yet in substance, they are in the nature of guarantees and protections given by the Constitution not to any specific denomination by identity, but to any section of the citizens which can be distinguished on the basis of language, script or culture. Clause (1) of Article 29 gives them the right to conserve, secure and extol their language, script or culture. The clause underscores the right to conserve and nurture the language, script or culture. Clause (2) of Article 29 is a negative right which stipulates that no citizen shall be denied admission on the grounds of religion, race, caste, language, or any of them in any educational institution maintained by the State or receiving aid out of the State funds.
45. Though the heading of Article 29 states that it is a provision for the protection of the interest of minorities, the substantive portion stipulates that the right is available to “any section of citizens” residing in India and having a distinct language, script or culture of their own. Thus, Article 29 applies to non-minorities as much as it applies to minorities, provided that the sections have a distinct language, script and culture of their own.30 Similarly, Articles 25 29 The expression ‘wholly maintained out of the State funds’ has been interpreted in DAV College v. State of Punjab (II), (1971) 2 SCC 269, to mean an institution which receives grants for its expenditure that may be wholly maintained out of the State funds even though it receives a fee for affiliation or holding examination as quid pro quo.
30 See Ahmedabad St. Xavier’s College Society v. State of Gujarat (1974) 1 SCC 717, (9J) [Chief Justice Ray writing for himself and Justice Palekar [5,6], Justice Khanna [73], Justice Mathew writing for himself and Justice YV Chandrachud [125, 126]; Rev. Father W Proost v. State of Bihar [5J] [1969] 2 SCR 73 [8,9] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1707Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. to 28 also do not make a distinction between majority and minority religious sections. The provisions guarantee the right to freedom of religion to both minorities and non-minorities. Article 25 recognises the right of all persons to freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practice and propagate religion. Article 26 recognises the right of every religious denomination or any section thereof to manage its religious affairs. The provisions of Article 28 also do not distinguish between a minority and a non-minority educational institution. The provisions apply equally to educational institutions established by religious and linguistic minorities and non-minorities.31
46. The provisions noted above, whether they refer to individual rights or denomination rights are manifestations that India is a pluralistic society with different religions, practices, cultures and languages. These provisions which are in the nature of rights and guarantees, also prescribe the ambit of State interference.
47. Article 30 consists of three clauses. Clause (1) states that all minorities whether based on religion or language, shall have a right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. Clause (1)(a) deals with the provision for compulsory acquisition of any property for an educational institution established and administered by a minority. We are not concerned per se with the said clause. Clause (2) of Article 30 provides that the State shall not, in granting aid to educational institutions, discriminate against any educational institution on the ground that it is under the management of a minority whether based on religion or language.
48. The two crucial expressions which arise for consideration and interpretation in this decision are the words ‘establish’ and ‘administer’ used in clause (1) of Article 30. These two words and expressions have to be interpreted in the context of clause (1) to Article 30 which confers a guarantee and protection to minority communities based on religion or language.
31 See TMA Pai (supra) [88-90;144]; “144 […] As in the case of a majority-run institution, the moment a minority institution obtains a grant of aid, Article 28 of the Constitution comes into play. When an educational institution is maintained out of State funds, no religious instruction can be provided therein. Article 28(1) does not state that it applies only to educational institutions that are not established or maintained by religious or linguistic minorities. Furthermore, upon the receipt of aid, the provisions of Article 28(3) would apply to all educational institutions whether run by the minorities or the nonminorities. […] Just as Articles 28(1) and (3) become applicable the moment any educational institution takes aid, likewise, Article 29(2) would also be attracted and become applicable to an educational institution maintained by the State or receiving aid out of State funds.” 1708 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a. The purpose of Article 30(1)
49. A brief reference to the drafting history of the provision will help us discern the purpose of the provision. On 19 April 1947, the Minorities Sub-Committee (which was appointed to examine and propose changes to the draft clauses of the fundamental rights Committee) submitted the interim report to the Chairperson of the Advisory Committee on Minorities and Fundamental Rights.32 The Minorities Sub-Committee recommended, inter alia, the inclusion of a constitutional provision that stipulated that all minorities, whether based on religion, community or language shall be free to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice.33 However, when the first Draft of the Constitution was submitted by the Drafting Committee to the President of the Constituent Assembly, the provision guaranteed a right to establish and administer educational institutions.34 This change in the language of the provision is crucial to understanding the scope of the provision. The provision guaranteed a purely negative group right to religious and linguistic minorities against the State with the use of the words “shall be free”, that is, the right to ensure that the State does not discriminate against minorities who wish to establish and administer educational institutions. However, upon the use of the phrase ‘right’, the possibility of interpreting the provision as a guarantee of a positive right arose.
50. It cannot be disputed that Article 30(1) guarantees the minority educational institutions, the right to not be discriminated. In fact, Article 30(2) is a facet of the principle of non-discrimination of minorities. The Article provides that the State shall not discriminate in granting aid to educational institutions or discriminate on the ground that it is under the management of a religious or linguistic minority. The question is whether the use of ‘right’ in Article 30(1) also guarantees a ‘special right’ in addition to the right to non-discrimination.
51. While there is no doubt that Article 30 protects the rights of minorities, this Court has in numerous judgments conceptualised varied reasons for the constitutional guarantee. In Ahmedabad St. Xavier’s College 32 B. Shiva Rao, The Framing of India’s Constitution: Select Documents [Vol II, The Indian Institute of Public Administration] 207 33 Ibid[ 273] 34 Draft Constitution of India 1948, Article 23(a)
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1709Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Society v. State of Gujarat,35 a nine-Judge Bench discussed the objective of the provision in detail. Chief Justice Ray writing for himself and Justice Palekar observed that Article 30 ensures equality between the majority and the minority, which would be denied in the absence of a special provision.36 Justice HR Khanna cast the purpose of the provision in terms of substantive equality and observed that Article 30 guarantees ‘special rights’ to give minorities a ‘sense of security’. The learned Judge observed that the real effect of the provision was to “ensure the preservation of the minority institutions by guaranteeing the minorities autonomy […] in administration.”37 Justice Mathew, writing for himself and Justice YV Chandrachud, also traced the purpose to the guarantee to substantive equality for minorities. The learned Judge observed that it will be impossible to protect the group identity of minorities and prevent the assimilation of identities in the absence of a provision guaranteeing substantive equality.38
52. Justice Mathew referred to the Advisory opinion of the Permanent Court of International Justice on Minority Schools in Albania to draw on the purpose of providing additional guarantees for minorities.39 In this judgment, a crucial principle regarding equality and differential treatment for minority groups was articulated. The Permanent Court of International Justice observed that true equality might necessitate differential treatment to establish equilibrium between different situations:
“Whereas equality in fact may involve the necessity of differential treatment in order to attain a result which establishes an equilibrium between different situations. It is easy to imagine cases in which equality of treatment of the majority and of the minority whose situation and requirements are different, would result in inequality. The
35 (1974) 1 SCC 717
36 Ibid [8,9] 37 Ibid [77] 38 Ibid [131-133]; “132.The problem of the minorities is not really a problem of the establishment of equality because if taken literally, such equality would mean absolute identical treatment of both the minorities and the major ities. This would result only in equality in law but inequality in fact. The distinction need not be elaborated for it is obvious that “equality in law precludes discrimination of any kind; whereas equality in fact may involve the necessity of differential treatment in order to attain a result which establishes an equilibrium between different situations.”
39 Minority Schools in Albania, Advisory Opinion, PCIJ Series A/B no 64, ICGJ 314 (PCIJ 1935), 6th April 1935, League of Nations; Permanent Court of International Justice. 1710 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports equality between the members of the majority and of the minority must be effective, genuine equality…”
53. This perspective underscores the imperative to enable minorities to maintain their distinctive characteristics and fulfil their specific needs. The case in question involved the abolition of all private schools, a measure challenged primarily by the minority. The Court emphasized that the rationale for the protection of minorities aimed at preserving their unique attributes. To achieve this objective, it deemed two aspects crucial. Firstly, it stressed the importance of ensuring that members of minority groups enjoy complete equality with other nationals of the state. Secondly, it emphasized the necessity of providing minority groups with appropriate means for preserving their racial peculiarities, traditions and national characteristics.
54. Distinct and diverse languages and religions have inherent value. It is also indisputable that cultures are often entangled with language and religion. The Constitution recognises that people who practise such religions or speak such languages who find themselves in the minority must not be at a disadvantage because of their numbers.
55. That being said, the purpose of Article 30 is not solely to enable religious minorities to impart religious instruction. Article 30 extends to secular education as well. That minorities may wish to impart secular and religious instruction side by side may be one aspect of the matter. Another equally relevant aspect is that minorities may wish to impart secular education in a manner that is conducive to the practice of their religion or harmonious with it, even if religious instruction does not form part of the curriculum. In this way, the right of linguistic and religious minorities to equality is protected.
56. The nine-Judge Bench in St. Xavier’s (supra) held that Article 30(1) is in pursuance of the anti-discrimination and substantive equality facets of the equality doctrine.40 In TMA Pai (supra), Chief Justice Kirpal writing for the majority of the eleven-Judge Bench observed that a law that discriminates based on whether the institution is established by a minority or a majority is unconstitutional for violation of Article 30. The Chief Justice observed that, however, the provision 40 St. Xavier’s (supra) Chief Justice Ray for himself and Justice Palekar [9]; Justice HR Khanna [77]; Justice Mathew for himself and Justice YV Chandrachud [131-133] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1711Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. should not lead to reverse discrimination.41 This observation on a cursory view seems to indicate that the Court has taken a volteface by shifting from a special rights/substantive equality approach of the provision to an anti-discrimination/formal equality reading of the provision. However, a closer examination reveals that the observations of the majority in TMA Pai (supra) were in line with the precedents that viewed the provision as a guarantee of a ‘special right’. This is evident from the interpretation of the interrelationship between Article 29(2) and Article 30. One of the issues in that case was whether Article 29(2) which provides that no person shall be denied admission in State aided educational institution only on the grounds of religion, race, caste, language or any of them is applicable to minority education institutions. The opinion of the majority held that the denial of admission to non-minorities in minority institutions to a “reasonable extent” is not violative of Article 29(2) since it “preserves the minority character of the institution”.42 Thus, Article 30, beyond preventing the State from discriminating against religious and linguistic minorities who wish to establish educational institutions also guarantees a ‘special protection’.
b. The ‘special protection’ guaranteed by Article 30(1)
57. This purpose of Article 30 was further expanded in PA Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra,43 where a seven-Judge Bench observed that the provision is better understood as a ‘protection’ and/ or a ‘privilege’ 41 “138. As we look at it, Article 30(1) is a sort of guarantee or assurance to the linguistic and religious minority institutions of their right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. Secularism and equality being two of the basic features of the Constitution, Article 30(1) ensures protection to the linguistic and religious minorities, thereby preserving the secularism of the country. Furthermore, the principles of equality must necessarily apply to the enjoyment of such rights. No law can be framed that will discriminate against such minorities with regard to the establishment and administration of educational institutions vis-à-vis other educational institutions. Any law or rule or regulation that would put the educational institutions run by the minorities at a disadvantage when compared to the institutions run by the others will have to be struck down. At the same time, there also cannot be any reverse discrimination. It was observed in St. Xavier’s College case [(1974) 1 SCC 717 : (1975) 1 SCR 173] at SCR p. 192 that : (SCC p. 743, para 9)
“The whole object of conferring the right on minorities under Article 30 is to ensure that there will be equality between the majority and the minority. If the minorities do not have such special protection they will be denied equality.”
In other words, the essence of Article 30(1) is to ensure equal treatment between the majority and the minority institutions. No one type or category of institution should be disfavoured or, for that matter, receive more favourable treatment than another. Laws of the land, including rules and regulations, must apply equally to the majority institutions as well as to the minority institutions. The minority institutions must be allowed to do what the non-minority institutions are permitted to do.” 42 TMA Pai (supra) [133]
43 (2005) 6 SCC 537
1712 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of the minority rather than an abstract right.44 What is the special guarantee that Article 30 provides educational institutions established by religious and linguistic minorities which is not otherwise available to non-minorities?
58. Until the judgment of the eleven-Judge Bench in TMA Pai (supra), the right to establish and administer educational institutions was interpreted as a right that was exclusively available to religious and linguistic minorities by virtue of Article 30. In TMA Pai (supra), the right of every citizen to establish and administer educational institutions was traced to Article 19(1)(g),45 which guarantees the freedom to practise any profession, or to carry on any occupation, trade or business. The eleven-Judge Bench also traced the right of ‘every’ religious denomination (of both the majority and the minority) to establish and administer educational institutions to Article 26(a) which guarantees the right to establish and maintain institutions for religious and ‘charitable’ purposes. Charitable purposes was interpreted to include education.46
59. The rights guaranteed by Articles 19(1)(g) and 26(a) can be reasonably restricted on the grounds in Articles 19(6) and 26 respectively. An educational institution established and administered by any citizen can be regulated on the grounds stipulated in Article 19(6) which includes the ground of professional or technical qualifications necessary for practising any profession or carrying on any occupation, trade, business.47 An educational institution established by a religious 44 PA Inamdar (supra) [100]; Also see St. Stephen’s (supra) [28,30(1), 59] 45 TMA Pai (supra) [Chief Justice Kirpal 19-20]; Chief Justice Kirpal authoring the majority opinion observed that Article 19(1)(g) covers activities of citizens in respect of which income or profit is generated. The learned Judge observed that “the establishment and running of an educational institution where a large number of persons are employed as teachers or administrative staff, and an activity is carried on that results in the imparting of knowledge to the students, must necessarily be regarded as an occupation.” [para 25] 46 TMA Pai (supra) [Chief Justice Kirpal 26]; “26.The right to establish and maintain educational institutions may also be sourced to Article 26(a), which grants, in positive terms, the right to every religious denomination or any section thereof to establish and maintain institutions for religious and charitable purposes, subject to public order, morality and health. Education is a recognized head of charity. Therefore, religious denominations or sections thereof, which do not fall within the special categories carved out in Articles 29(1) and 30(1), have the right to establish and maintain religious and educational institutions. This would allow members belonging to any religious denomination, including the majority religious community, to set up an educational institution.” 47 The right of citizens of establish and administer educational institutions does not prevent the State from making any law relating to: (a) professional or technical qualifications necessary for practising any profession or carrying on any occupation, trade, business; (b) carrying on by the State or by a corporation owned or controlled by the State, of any trade, business, industry or service, whether to the exclusion, complete or partial of citizens or otherwise. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1713Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. denomination (without any element of profit48) can be regulated on grounds of public order, morality and health. As opposed to these two provisions, Article 30 does not circumscribe the right on any grounds. This Court has, however, consistently emphasised that the right guaranteed by Article 30 is not absolute.
60. In Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai v. State of Bombay,49 a Constitution Bench observed that Article 30 is absolute and cannot be restricted on any grounds such as in Article 19. However, in the very next sentence this Court observed that the right can be restricted on the grounds of efficiency of instruction, discipline, health, sanitation, morality and public order.50 It must be noticed that these grounds resemble the grounds for restraint prescribed in Articles 19(6) and 26.
61. The inconsistency of the observations in Rev. Sidhajbahi (supra) was set right in State of Kerala v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial.51 The six-Judge Bench differentiated between restrictions on the autonomy of a minority institution and the standard of education.52 The former is impermissible in view of the protection under Article 30(1). The latter was traced to the regulation of the profession which is covered by Article 19(6). Thus, regulation of a minority educational institution is permissible on the grounds in Article 19(6). However, the regulation must not infringe the minority character of the educational institution. Article 30(1) is absolute in that sense. Justice Khanna’s concurring opinion in St. Xavier’s (supra) also highlighted this point. The learned Judge observed that reasonable restrictions can be imposed to ensure that a minority educational institution is an institution of excellence. The examples given by the Judge included ensuring regular payment of salaries and audit of accounts.53 The distinction between regulation which affects the minority character and a regulation in pursuance of ‘national interest’ was also drawn by the opinion of the majority in TMA Pai (supra).54 National interest was interpreted to include public safety, national 48 PA Inamdar [6] 49 [1962] 3 SCR 837 50 [1962] 3 SCR 837 [849]
51 (1970) 2 SCC 417
52 Ibid [9, 10] 53 St. Xavier’s [91] 54 TMA Pai (supra) [107] 1714 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports security and national integrity, preventing the exploitation of students or the teaching community, and application of general laws such as laws on taxation, sanitation and social welfare.55 The principle that can be inferred from the above precedents is that regulations that may be justified on the grounds stipulated in Articles 19(6) and 26 may fall foul of Article 30 if they infringe the ‘minority character’ of the institution.56 This is the ‘special right’ or ‘protection’ which the Constitution guarantees minority education institutions.
62. The right to administer was considered in some depth in St. Xavier’s (supra) by Chief Justice AN Ray and Justice HR Khanna. Justice Khanna emphasised that the right to administer an institution is to effectively manage and conduct the affairs of the institution. The learned Judge held that it means shaping the institution in congruence with their vision and ideas for best serving the interests of both the community and the institution. Chief Justice AN Ray, on the other hand, observed that the right to administer has four components:
(a) the right to choose its managing or governing body; (b) the right to choose the teachers; (c) the right not to be compelled to refuse admission to students; and (d) the right to use its properties and assets for the benefit of its own institutions. The right to administer as guaranteed under Article 30(1) ensures autonomy in administration and the right of choice which may not otherwise be available to a non-minority institution. The right to administration, however, does not grant a carte blanche to flout or disregard the regulations and controls established by statute, which are essential for protecting the larger public interest and maintaining educational standards. Thus, the right to administer is not impaired by factors such as rules and regulations prescribing the proper utilization of State funds, qualifications of the teachers, their remuneration and benefits, eligibility criteria for admission of students, attendance requirements and the threshold to pass the exams conducted by the board/university to which the college or school is affiliated. What is barred is the interference in the internal management and overall control of the institution. At the same time, we must clarify that a minority institution can employ non-minority employees. Non-minority individuals can be teachers or even hold the position of the academic or institution head. To 55 PA Inamdar (supra) [119]; TMA PAI [136] 56 See PA Inamdar (supra)[92,122] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1715Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. hold otherwise, would amount to interference with the choice, as envisaged by Article 30(1).
63. This proposition was clearly elucidated by the seven-Judge Bench in PA Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra57 which was formed to cull out the ratio decidendi of the eleven - Judge Bench in TMA Pai (supra). The degree of interference of the State in the administration of an educational institution differs based on whether the institution receives aid or recognition from the Government or whether the institution was established by a minority. In PA Inamdar (supra), this Court discussed the extent of State interference in an (i) unaided and unrecognised/unaffiliated minority institution; (ii) unaided minority institution seeking recognition; and (iii) aided minority institution. In the case of the first class, the seven-Judge Bench held that the minority ‘can exercise the right to heart’s content’. Institutions that fall within the first class could even fill all the seats with students from their community.58 With respect to the second class, this Court held that the State cannot interfere in the day to day administration, including the essential ingredients of management, admission of students, recruiting staff and charging of fees.59 This Court held that the regulation must be reasonable and for the purpose of ensuring that the institution is effective for the minority and others who resort to it.60 For institutions that fall within the third class, the State can only regulate the proper utilisation of the grant without diluting the minority status of the educational institution.61
64. Thus, the position that emerges is that: (i) the regulations must be relevant to the purpose of granting recognition (in the case of a Staterecognised institutions) and aid (in the case of Government aided institutions); and (ii) the effect of the regulation must not infringe the minority character of the institution.
65. From the discussion above, the following principles emerge : a. The purpose of Article 30(1) is to ensure that the State does not discriminate against religious and linguistic minorities which
57 (2005) 6 SCC 537
58 PA Inamdar (supra) [120]; TMA Pai (supra) [145] 59 Ibid [121] 60 ibid [122] 61 PA Inamdar [123]; TMA Pai [143] 1716 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports seek to establish and administer educational institutions (“the non-discrimination” purpose); and b. The purpose of Article 30(1) is also to guarantee a ‘special right’ to religious and linguistic minorities that have established educational institutions. This special right is the guarantee of limited State regulation in the administration of the institution. The State must grant the minority institution sufficient autonomy to enable it to protect the essentials of its minority character. The regulation of the State must be relevant to the purpose of granting recognition or aid, as the case may be. This special or additional protection is guaranteed to ensure the protection of the cultural fabric of religious and linguistic minorities. iii. Indicia for a Minority Educational Institution
66. To recall, the petitioners while challenging the 1951 and 1965 amendments to the AMU Act in Azeez Basha (supra) argued that the amendments were violative of the right to administration guaranteed by Article 30(1). The Union of India responded to the argument with the submission that the Muslim minority cannot claim the right to administration since it did not ‘establish’ the institution. Opposing this argument, the petitioners in Azeez Basha (supra) submitted that Article 30(1) guarantees the ‘right to administer’ an educational institution to minorities even if it was not established by them, if by “some process, it had been administering the same before the Constitution came into force.” The argument of the petitioners was rejected. This Court held that the words “establish” and “administer” must be read conjunctively, that is, the guarantee of the right to administration is contingent on the establishment of the institution by religious or linguistic minorities. In this context, the following observations were made:
“It is to our mind quite clear that Art. 30(1) postulates that the religious community will have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice meaning thereby that where a religious minority establishes an educational institution, it will have the right to administer that. An argument has been raised to the effect that even though the religious minority may not have established the educational institution, it will have the right to administer it, if [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1717Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. by some process it had been administering the same before the Constitution came into force. We are not pre-pared to accept this argument. The Article in our opinion clearly shows that the minority will have the right to administer educational institutions of their choice provided they have established them, but not otherwise. The Article cannot be read to mean that even if the educational institution has been established by somebody else, any religious minority would have the right to administer it because, for some reason or other, it might have been administering it before the Constitution came into force. The words “establish and administer” in the Article must be read conjunctively and so read it gives the right to the minority to administer an educational institution provided it has been established by it.
… We are of opinion that nothing in that case justifies the contention raised on behalf of the petitioners that the minorities would have the right to administer an educational institution even though the institution may not have been established by them. The two words in Art. 30(1) must be read together and so read the Article gives the right to the minority to administer institutions established by it.” (emphasis supplied)
The Constitution Bench in St. Stephen’s (supra) reiterated this interpretation of the phrases ‘establish’ and ‘administer’ in Article 30(1).62
67. Let us refer to Article 19(1)(a) to understand what it means to conjunctively read two words in a provision. Article 19 guarantees the fundamental right to free speech and expression. The guarantee of the freedom of expression is, however, not dependent on the freedom of speech. They are two separate rights. However, the situation 62 St Stephen’s [28] “It should be borne in mind that the words “establish” and “administer” used in Article 30(1) are to be read conjunctively. The right claimed by a minority community to administer the educational institution depends upon the proof of establishment of the institution. The proof of establishment of the institution, is thus a condition precedent for claiming the right to administer the institute.” 1718 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports differs with regard to the rights to establish and administer outlined in Article 30. It is settled that the rights to establish and administer must be read conjunctively and not disjunctively. This Court has not doubted this interpretation in any of the judgments subsequent to Azeez Basha (supra).63
68. The question is whether the conjunctive reading of the words “establish” and “administer” would also mean that for an educational institution to be a minority institution, it should have been both established and administered by a minority. In Azeez Basha (supra), the Constitution Bench held that the institution must be both established and administered by the minority. The Constitution Bench framed the following three questions to determine if AMU was a minority educational institution:
a. Whether on the reading of the AMU Act, the University was established by the Muslim minority;
b. Whether the right to administer the University ever vested in the minority; and c. If (b) is affirmative, whether the right to administer the University was surrendered when AMU was established.
69. The issue before this Bench is the indicia for an educational institution to be a minority educational institution. Should it be proved that the institution was established by the minority, or it was administered by the minority, or both? The petitioners and the respondents agree that the words ‘establish’ and ‘administer’ must be read conjunctively. They argue that administration is a sequitur to establishment. However, they disagree on the test to be applied to identify a minority education institution. The petitioners argue that the only indicia for a minority educational institution is that it must be established by a minority, while the respondents argue that the dual test of establishment and administration must be satisfied.
70. Before proceeding further, it is relevant to note the provisions of the NCMEI Act. The NCMEI Act was enacted in 2004 to constitute a National Commission for minority educational institutions and 63 Manager, St. Thomas UP School v. Commr. & Secy, to general Education Dept. (2002) 2 SCC 497; St. Stephen’s (supra); DAV College trust & Management Society v. State of Maharashtra (2013) 4 SCC 14; SP Mittal v. Union of India (1983) 1 SCC 51 [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1719Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. to provide for matters connected or incidental to it. Section 10 of the NCMEI Act was amended in 2006. The amended provision prescribed a procedure for the establishment of a minority educational institution.64 Thus, there can be no ambiguity about the minority status of educational institutions established after the enactment of NCMEI (Amendment) Act 2006. However, that is not the case for institutions which were established before the 2006 Amendment. How do we identify if an educational institution established before 2006 is a minority educational institution?
71. Article 30 does not prescribe conditions which must be fulfilled for an educational institution to be considered a minority educational institution. Article 30 confers two group rights on all linguistic and religious minorities: the right to establish an educational institution and the right to administer an educational institution. This right can be exercised by an individual belonging to a group or a collection of persons.65 As observed above, the provision guarantees both a positive and negative right. Thus, the provision, in addition to ensuring that the State does not discriminate against the minority community also guarantees the minority educational institution certain guarantees. The institution is guaranteed the right of lesser State regulation and greater autonomy in the administration of the educational institution. The right to establish an educational institution guaranteed to the minority is not a special right. That, as held in TMA Pai (supra) (as explained in the preceding section), is a right which is available to 64 “10. Right to establish a Minority Educational Institution.- (1) Any person who desires to establish a Minority Educational Institution may apply to the Competent authority for the grant of the no objection certificate for the said purpose.
(2) The Competent authority shall, -
(a) on perusal of documents, affidavits or other evidence, if any;
(b) after gving an opportunity of being heard to the applicant, decide every application filed under subsection (1) as expeditiously as possible and grant or reject the application, as the case may be: Provided that where an application is rejected, the Competent authority shall communicate the same to the applicant.
(3) Where within a period of ninety days from the receipt of the application under sub-section (1) for the grant of no objection certificate,-
(a) the Competent authority does not grant such certificates; or
(b) where an application has been rejected and the same has not been communicated to the person who has applied for the grant of such certificate, It shall be deemed that the Competent authority has granted a no objection certificate to the applicant.
(4) The applicant shall, on the grant of a no objection certificate or where the Competent authority has deemed to have granted the no objection certificate, be entitled to commence and proceed with the establishment of a Minority Educational Institution in accordance with the rules and regulaitons, as the case may be, laid down by or under any law for the time being in force. 65 Mother Provincial (supra)
1720 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports every citizen under Article 19(1)(g) and to minority and non-minority religious denominations under Article 26. The special right that the provision guarantees to religious and linguistic minorities relates to the administration of educational institutions “of their choice”. The expression “of their choice” is of an expansive nature indicating that the choice extends to the full range of educational institutions.
72. Article 30(1) cannot extend to a situation where the minority community which establishes an educational institution has no intention to administer it. A religious or linguistic community may establish an educational institution and yet not administer it. This is evident from Article 28(2) of the Constitution which states that Article 28(1) will not apply to an educational institution which is administered by the State but was established under an endowment or a trust which require religious instruction to be imparted. It is quite possible that a member or a group belonging to the minority community wishes to establish an institution but intends to accept greater State regulation and lesser autonomy for the community. In that case, putting a ‘minority’ tag on such an educational institution merely because it has been established by a person or a group belonging to a religious or linguistic minority would not be permissible under Article 30(1). An educational institution established by a minority, whether linguistic or religious, can give up their right to claim the benefit under clause (1) of Article 30. The right can be given up consciously by waiver. This may occur where administration has been consciously and willingly entrusted to the State. Therefore, to determine whether an educational institution is a minority educational institution, a formalistic test such as to whether it was established by a person or group belonging to a religious or linguistic minority is not sufficient. The tests adopted must elucidate the purpose and intent of establishing an educational institution for the minority. Both the establishment and the administration by the minority must be fulfilled cumulatively for that.66
73. In Azeez Basha (supra), the Constitution Bench referred to the judgment in The Durgah Committee, Ajmer v. Syed Hussain Ali,67 for the proposition that even if a minority established an educational 66 See Section E(v) of this judgment for an expansive elucidation of the indicia. 67 (1962) 1 S.C.P 383 [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1721Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. institution, it may lose the concomitant right of administration in certain circumstances. The relevant observations are extracted below: “We should also like to refer to the observations in The Durgah Committee, Ajmer v. Syed Hussain Ali. In that case this Court observed while dealing with Art. 26(a) and
(d) of the Constitution that even if it be assumed that a certain religious institution was established by a minority community it may lose the right to administer it in certain circumstances. We may in this connection refer to the following observations at p. 414 for they apply equally to Art. 30(1):
“If the right to administer the properties never vested in the denomination or had been validly surrendered by it or had otherwise been effectively and irretrievably lost to it, Art. 26 cannot be successfully invoked.”
74. In Azeez Basha (supra), in addition to determining if AMU was established by a Muslim minority, this Court also determined whether it was ever administered by them or if the administration was validly surrendered by them, on the basis of the above observations.
75. The context of the above observations in Durgah Committee (supra) and its application to the interpretation of Article 30(1) needs to be clarified. In that case, the constitutional validity of the Durgah Khwaja Saheb Act 195568 was challenged by the Khadims of the tomb for violation of Article 26(c) and Article 26(d) of the Constitution. To offer a brief background, Khwaja Saheb was a saint who came to India at the end of the 12th Century AD and settled in Ajmer. A tomb in the form of a kutcha structure was built immediately after his death. However, there were no endowments at this time. Akbar, the Mughal emperor, took interest in the tomb and rebuilt it. Documents also indicate that eighteen villages were endowed to the Durgah. During this period, a descendant of the Saint functioned as the Sajhadanashin and Mutawalli. During the rule of Shahjahan, the office of Sajhadanashin and Mutawalli were separated. The Mutawalli was solely made responsible for the management of the properties 68 “Durgah Act”
1722 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of the Durgah and was appointed by the Ruler. Over the years, this model was not altered. The Mutawalli was always appointed by the Government in power.
76. Section 4(1) of the Durgah Act dealt with the appointment of a Committee in which the administration, control and management of the Durgah Endowment would vest. The members of the Committee would be appointed by the Central Government. These two provisions were challenged on the ground they were ultra vires Article 26(c) and Article 26(d). In this context, the Constitution Bench observed that the denomination will not have a right to administer the property if it never had the right to administer it; if it had been surrendered; or if it had been irretrievably lost:
“37. […] In other words, if the denomination never had the right to manage the properties endowed in favour of a denominational institution as for instance by reason of the terms on which the endowment was created, it cannot be heard to say that it has acquired the said rights as a result of Article 26(c) and (d)…If the right to administer the properties never vested in the denomination or had been validly surrendered by it or has otherwise been effectively and irretrievably lost to it Article 26 cannot be successfully invoked. […]”
77. On the facts of the case, the Constitution Bench observed that the endowments were made on such terms that did not confer the right to manage the properties to the denomination. This Court held that the right to administer the property could not be claimed if the terms of the endowment did not confer administration to the denomination.
78. Azeez Basha (supra) relied on the decision of the Constitution Bench in Durgah Committee (supra) which dealt with clauses (c) and (d) of Article 26 which guarantee the right of any religious denomination to own property and administer such property. They were not made in the context of Article 26(a) by which the right to establish and maintain institutions is conferred on religious denominations.
79. A parallel could have been drawn between the right guaranteed by Article 26(a) and Article 30(1), which is what this Court in Azeez Basha (supra) attempted to do. However, a parallel cannot be drawn between clauses (c) and (d) of Article 26, and Article 30(1). [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1723Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. The rights differ in nature and scope. Article 26(d) guarantees the right to administer property in ‘accordance with law’. The provision does not confer any special right to administration as in the case of minority educational institutions.
iv. Applicability of Article 30 to a ‘University’ established before the commencement of the Constitution
80. Mr Rakesh Dwivedi, senior counsel appearing for the respondents made two submissions on the application of Article 30 to educational institutions which were established before the commencement of the Constitution. First, he urged that the claimant must prove that they were a linguistic or religious minority when the institution was established and not when the Constitution commenced; and second, before the Constitution was adopted, Universities (unlike schools and colleges which could be established by persons) could only be established by the Imperial Government. Thus, Universities which could not have been established by persons before the Constitution was adopted cannot, according to the submission, claim a right under Article 30. The observations in re Kerala Education Bill,69 Rev. Bishop SK Patro v. State of Bihar70 and St. Stephen’s (supra) that Article 30(1) applies to educational institutions which were established before the Constitution was adopted were distinguished on the ground that those cases dealt with colleges and schools, and not Universities. The learned Attorney General also made a similar argument. He submitted that in the absence of a legal competence to establish a given class of institutions (that is, universities), the question of availing of all attendant rights and claims in relation to Article 30 cannot arise. In the subsequent sections, we will answer the following two questions:
a. Whether ‘universities’ established before the commencement of the Constitution are excluded from the purview of Article 30(1); and b. Whether those who established an educational institution have to prove that they were a minority at the time of establishment. 69 [1958] SCR 995
70 (1969) 1 SCC 863
1724 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a. Article 30(1) applies to educational institutions established before the commencement of the Constitution
81. In re the Kerala Education Bill 1957 (supra), a seven-Judge Bench of this Court held that Article 30 applies to educational institutions which predate the Constitution. This Court held that the right to administer guaranteed by Article 30(1) is wide enough to cover educational institutions established both before and after the Constitution was adopted:
“22. … There is no reason why the benefit of Article 30(1) should be limited only to educational institutions established after the commencement of the Constitution. The language employed in Article 30(1) is wide enough to cover both pre-Constitution and post-Constitution institutions. It must not be overlooked that Article 30(1) gives the minorities two rights, namely, (a) to establish, and (b) to administer, educational institutions of their choice. The second right clearly covers pre-Constitution schools just as Article 26 covers the right to maintain pre-Constitution religious institutions. …”
82. Although the opinion in that case was rendered in exercise of the advisory jurisdiction of this Court under Article 143, it has immense persuasive value.71 The judgment in Inre Kerala Education Bill (supra) has held the field for many decades. Subsequent decisions of this Court have also relied on it. The decision in Azeez Basha (supra) observed that Article 30 would be “robbed of much of its content” if it were held to apply only to educational institutions established after the commencement of the Constitution.72 The Constitution Bench in SK Patro (supra) also held the same. In that case, an educational institution which was established in 1854 received the protection of the rights guaranteed by Article 30(1).73 In St. Stephen’s (supra), a Constitution Bench held that St. Stephen’s College which was established in 1881 is a minority educational institution for the purposes of Article 30(1).
71 In re Special Courts Bill, (1979) 1 SCC 380 72 Azeez Basha [19] 73 SK Patro [17] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1725Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
83. A distinction between educational institutions established before and after the commencement of the Constitution cannot be made for the purposes of Article 30(1). Article 30 will stand diluted and weakened if it is to only apply prospectively to institutions established after the commencement of the Constitution. The protection and guarantee, if made applicable to only institutions established after the commencement of the Constitution, would debase and defile the object and purpose of the provision. The adoption of the Constitution reflects a break from the system of sovereign and potentate government under the colonial regime and the dawn of governance based on the rule of law. It secures to the minority educational institutions, rights under the Constitution from the date of its commencement.
84. The Constitution annihilates the vestiges of colonial rule as reflected in Article 395. Article 395 repeals the two enactments that established the system of governance in pre-independent India: the Indian Independence Act 1947 and the Government of India Act 1935. Article 395 repudiates the chain of colonial continuity and symbolises constitutional autochthony by repealing the Indian Independence Act 1947. At the same time, Article 372 represents the thread of continuity even when a new system of governance is put in place. Article 372 stipulates that all laws which were in force in the territory of India before the commencement of the Constitution will continue in force. However, the only caveat was that the laws must not be inconsistent with the provisions of the Constitution. Laws that are violative of the provisions of Part III would be void to the extent of the inconsistency.74 It is crucial to note that Article 13(1) renders the laws to the extent of contravention void and not void ab initio. Thus, the Constitution does not fully overhaul the system of governance and administration. Rather, it only ensures that the governance is in accordance with the rules prescribed in the Constitution. To put it in legal terms, Article 13(1) has a retroactive effect and not a retrospective effect. A provision is retrospective if it alters the position of law before its enactment/commencement. It is retroactive if it imposes new results for previous actions.75 Upon the commencement of the Constitution, citizens received the protective cover of Part III. 74 Constitution of India, Article 13(1)
75 SEBI v. Rajpur Nagpal (2023) 8 SCC 274 [99-102] 1726 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Article 372 read with Article 13(1) stipulates that laws which predate the Constitution are unconstitutional if they contravene the fundamental rights.76 The provisions do not stipulate that laws which pre-date the Constitution cannot receive the additional protection which the fundamental rights offer. The right to administration in Article 30(1) is one such protection.
85. What is the scope of Article 30 when read in the context of Article 372 read with Article 13? Any law enacted by the Imperial Legislature which discriminates against linguistic and religious minorities in the establishment and administration of educational institution would be void. This is the scope of the provision vis-à-vis Articles 372 and 13 when Article 30 is purely read as a negative right. But, this Court has also interpreted the Article as a ‘special rights’ provision guaranteeing additional protection to educational institutions established by minorities. Thus, educational institutions established by religious and linguistic minorities before the commencement of the Constitution will also receive the special protection guaranteed by Article 30(1): the right to administration without the infringement of their minority character.
86. If the argument as propounded is accepted, we will have two sets of minority educational institutions, one established before the commencement of the Constitution which is deprived of the guarantee given under Article 30(1), and those established after the commencement of the Constitution which are entitled to the benefit and guarantee given under Article 30(1). We do not think the Constitution envisages such incongruous and unpalatable differences in rights guaranteed under Article 30(1).
b. There is no difference between ‘Universities’ and ‘colleges’ established before the commencement of the Constitution
87. The next argument which needs to be addressed is whether ‘universities’ established before the commencement of the Constitution could receive the protection of Article 30(1). To recall, the petitioners argued that prior to the commencement of the Constitution, the law did not confer the power to establish a university on a person. It was argued that the power only vested in the Imperial Legislature and thus, no person could have “established” a university.
76 See Keshavan Madhava Menon v. State of Bombay, AIR 1951 SC 128 [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1727Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
88. The educational policy in pre-independent India must be referred to provide a brief context on the distinction between universities and colleges. One of the distinctions between a college and a university is the ability of the latter to confer degrees to students as evidence of their proficiency in subjects which they have studied and for which they are assessed. On 19 July 1854, the Court of Directors of the East India Company submitted a despatch77 to the Governor-General of India in Council on the subject of General Education in India. The despatch recommended the incorporation of Universities by Acts of the Legislative Council of India. The first University established in India was the University of Calcutta. It was established by Act No. II of 1857, passed by the Legislative Council of India. The preamble to the enactment provides that the University at Calcutta was to be established for the purpose of awarding academic degrees to persons who have acquired proficiency in subjects. Subsequently, the Legislative Council of India enacted Act No. XXII of 1857 to establish and incorporate the University at Bombay for the same purpose. In 1857, the University at Madras was established.78 In 1860, an Act was passed to give the Universities of Calcutta, Madras and Bombay, the power of conferring degrees in addition to those degrees provided for in the earlier enactments. The Legislative Council of India passed sixteen other enactments79 for the establishment of universities before the commencement of the Constitution.
89. The University Grants Commission Act 195680 was enacted a few years after the commencement of the Constitution. The UGC Act provides the power to confer degrees even to institutions which are not established by an enactment. Section 2(f) defines a University as educational institutions established or incorporated by or under a Central Act, a Provincial Act or a State Act, and includes any such institution as may, in consultation with the University concerned, be 77 “Woods Despatch”
78 Act No. XXVII of 1987 79 The Punjab University Act 1992, the Allahabad University Act 1887, The Mysore University Regulation 1916, The Patna University Act 1917, The Firman of Osmania University 1918, The Lucknow University Act 1920, The Delhi University Act 1922, The Nagpur University Act 1923, The Agra University Act 1926, The Annamalai University Act 1926, University of Tranvancore Promulgation Act 1937, The Utkal University Act 1943, The Gauhati University Act 1947, The Maharaja Sayajirao University of Baroda Act 1949, The Gujarat University Act 1949; The Visva-Bharati Act 1951; The Jadavpur University Act 1955.
80 “UGC Act”
1728 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports recognized by the Commission in accordance with the regulations made in that behalf under the Act. Section 3 states that the Central Government may, on the advice of the UGC, declare by notification that any institution for higher education shall be deemed to be a University for the purposes of the Act. All the provisions of the UGC Act would apply to deemed-to-be-Universities just as they apply to universities.81 Under the UGC Act, an institution (which is not a university or deemed-to-be university) can be specially empowered by an Act of Parliament to confer degrees.82
90. Two facets emerge from the above discussion. First, only Universities can confer degrees;83 and second, before the enactment of the UGC Act, the University had to necessarily be incorporated by a legislation for the degrees conferred by them to be recognised. Thus, the argument of the petitioners narrows down to one aspect. According to the submission, a member or community belonging to a minority despite making efforts through representation, mobilisation and participation to establish a University cannot be regarded to have ‘established’ a Minority educational institution for the purpose of Article 30(1) only because the University was incorporated through a legislation. A brief analysis of the nature of Universities is necessary to unravel this paradox.
91. The Wood despatch noted that the purpose of universities upon their establishment was to confer academic degrees on students as evidence of attainment of proficiency in the branch of study.84 Universities were instituted, “not so much to be in themselves places of instruction, as to test the value of the education obtained elsewhere”.85 Affiliated colleges and other institutions educated students and sent them to universities where their proficiency was to be tested.86 This limited role of Indian Universities upon their establishment was recognised in the statutory enactments which incorporated the first three Universities in India. The preamble to Act No. II of 1857 which established and incorporated the University at 81 UGC Act, Section 3 82 UGC Act, Section 22 83 Also see St. David’s College, Lampeter v. Ministry of Education, 1951 All ER 559 84 Charles Wood, The despatch of 1854 on General education in India. [25]; 85 Report of the Indian Universities Commission 1902 [ 7] 86 Willium Hunter, Report of the Indian Education Commission 1882 [25-26] “ Hunter Commission” [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1729Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Calcutta, Act XXII of 1857 which established and incorporated the University at Bombay, and Act XXVII of 1857 which established and incorporated the University at Madras stipulated that the Universities were established to ascertain (through an examination) those persons who had acquired proficiency in different branches. This was the only power conferred upon Universities.87 The enactments also provided that only candidates who were authorised through a certificate from one of the institutions authorized by them shall be a candidate for the degree.88 However, the University at Punjab incorporated in 1882 had greater scope. In 1869, an institution styled the Lahore University College (and the Punjab University College later) was established in pursuance of the wishes of the Chiefs, Nobles and influential classes of Punjab. Act XIX of 1882 incorporated the University at Punjab by which the college was converted into a University to confer degrees. The University at Punjab was, thus, the first teaching University in India.
92. On 12 January 1902, the Government of India issued a resolution to appoint a commission to “inquire into the condition and prospects of the Universities established in British India; to consider and report upon any proposals […] for improving their constitution and working […]”. The Report of the Commission discussed the necessity of establishing teaching Universities, where better provision for advanced courses of study could be made.89 In 1904, Act No. VIII of 1904 was enacted to amend the law relating to the Universities at Bombay, Calcutta, Madras and Allahabad. Section 3 of the Act provided that the University shall have the power to make provision for, inter alia, the instruction of students and the power to appoint University professors and Lecturers. Universities that were incorporated subsequent to Act No. VIII of 1904 had the power to instruct students in addition to conducting examinations to confer degrees.90 However, teaching universities also had to be incorporated 87 See Section XIII and XIV of the enactments; Also see Section 14 of Act No. XVIII of 1887 that established the University at Allahabad 88 Section XII of the enactments.
89 Report of the Indian Universities Commission 1902 [24, 25] 90 See Section 4 of Osmania University Act, preamble and Section 4(1) of the Lucknow University Act 1920; preamble to the Delhi University Act 1922 which states that it established and incorporates a teaching and affiliating University; Section 4(1) of the Delhi University Act 1922; Section 4(1) of the Nagpur University Act 1923 1730 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports through a legislative enactment because they would have the power to confer degrees recognised by the Government.
93. It is in this background that we should decide if Universities established before the enactment of the UGC Act could be covered by Article 30(1). It is true that the intervention of the imperial legislature was necessary to incorporate a university before the commencement of the Constitution. The intervention of the State legislature was necessary after the commencement of the Constitution until the enactment of the UGC Act.91 The intervention of the legislative body was required to ‘incorporate’ universities because the degrees conferred by them would be recognised by the Government. This was required even for the incorporation of teaching universities. However, could it be argued that no person had the power to ‘establish’ a university merely because the intervention of the legislative body was required for the incorporation of the institution? Could it be argued that a university was ‘established’ by the legislature merely because it enacted a legislation incorporating it?
94. The words ‘incorporation’ and ‘establishment’ cannot be used interchangeably. They connote different meanings. ‘Incorporation’ signifies the legal existence of the institution.92 In contrast, ‘establishment’ signifies the founding or bringing into existence of the institution.93 The possibility of distinguishing the establishment and incorporation of universities arose with the advent of teaching Universities. Two kinds of institutions were incorporated as teaching universities. They consisted of institutions which were established and incorporated at the same time, and institutions in which the establishment of the institution predated its incorporation. Universities in the latter category, however, were teaching colleges converted into teaching universities. The University at Punjab is one such example. The Annamalai University would also fall in this category. In the case of Annamalai University, the Hon’ble Diwan Bahadur Sir S.R.M Annamalai Chettiyar had established and was maintaining colleges around Chidambaram in Tamil Nadu. The college was converted to a University through the enactment of Annamalai 91 See Entry 11 of List II to the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution prior to Constitution(Forty-second Amendment) Act 1976 92 Oxford Dictionary defines the word ‘incorporated’ as formed into business company with legal status 93 Oxford Dictionary defines establish as ‘to start or create an organization, a system.’ [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1731Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. University Act 1928.94 The ‘establishment’ and ‘incorporation’ of these universities was distinct. The incorporation of the University was necessary to confer degrees recognised by the Government. However, there was an institution that pre-dated the incorporation of the University that continued to exist even after the incorporation. Thus, the instance of conversion of teaching collages to teaching universities elucidates the distinction between the “establishment” and “incorporation” of educational institutions.
95. The word ‘establish’ as used in Article 30(1) cannot and should not be understood in a narrow and legalistic sense. The words used in clause (1) of Article 30 have to be interpreted in view of the object and purpose of the article, and the guarantee and protection it confers. The guarantee and protection are not dependent on the basis or the manner in which the legal requirements were/are complied with, rather it concerns the persons who have founded and created the establishment. The incorporation by a statute or the procedure and requirements in law are not determinative factors. The persons behind it, that is, the promoters and founder(s) are important. They should belong to a linguistic or a religious minority. There will always be individuals and groups instrumental in catalysing and setting up the institution. Thus, giving a legal character to an educational institution through state or sovereign action, it does not ipso facto follow that the university so established deprives the group of persons/individuals the guarantee under clause (1) of Article 30 of the Constitution. Universities are as much educational institutions as schools and colleges. The interpretation in Azeez Basha (supra) confers a legalistic meaning to the word ‘established’, sans the context of clause (1) of Article 30. No distinction exists between universities and other educational institutions such as schools and colleges for the purpose of Article 30(1).
96. The following conclusions emerge from the discussion above: a. The teaching universities and colleges serve the common function of educating students. No distinction between the two can be drawn for the purposes of Article 30(1) which guarantees minorities the right of greater autonomy in the administration of educational institutions to curate a model of education which best serves the interests of the community; and 94 See the preamble of the Annamalai University Act 1928 1732 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports b. The submission that a person did not have the power to ‘establish’ a university before the enactment of the UGC Act is rejected. The words establishment and incorporation cannot be interchangeably used. They connote different meanings. The former refers to founding an institution, which in the case of teaching colleges that were converted to universities would refer to any person or community who undertook the efforts the establish the teaching college.
c. The minority character of the institution is not ipso facto surrendered upon the incorporation of the University
97. The Solicitor General argued that Azeez Basha (supra) — correctly understood — holds that the Muslim minority surrendered its rights as a denominational institution before the Constitution was adopted by approaching the imperial legislature to recognise the degrees. He argued that the decision tacitly recognised the fact that two broad groups existed during the freedom struggle. The first of these groups was determined to conduct their affairs without assistance from or reference to the imperial legislature. It set up institutions which granted degrees which were not recognised by the imperial government. They did not seek recognition of the degrees granted by their institutions at that time. Instead, such institutions (and the degrees granted by them) were recognised post-independence. Examples of such universities include Shantiniketan; the predecessor of IIT Roorkee. In contrast, the second group chose to collaborate with the imperial government and sought recognition of the degrees awarded by its universities. Having approached the imperial government for such recognition, the second group surrendered their denominational status (comparable to minority status under Article 30). It was submitted that the founders of AMU formed a part of the second group. While MAO College may have been of a denominational character, it has been urged that the incorporation of the institute as AMU resulted in the surrender of rights. Since we are only dealing with the principles of law, we will address this argument without referring to the factual aspects submitted by the learned Solicitor General. In short, the argument is that the minority character of an educational institution is surrendered upon the incorporation of the institution.
98. The minority character of institutions cannot be rejected if they were conferred a legal character by a statute enacted prior to 1950. The [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1733Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. enactment was necessary to award degrees recognized by the British government, allowing graduates to gain degree recognition and secure employment. The enactment of the statute is a ministerial and a legislative act, which confers juristic personality as well as legal rights in terms of the law in force. The statute grants the power to the educational institution to confer the degrees. The incorporation by way of statute is a legal requirement. That being the case, we will not accept the argument that compliance with legal requirement would tantamount to the ‘establishment’ of an institution by the Legislature, and thereby the linguistic and religious minority forgo the guarantees and protection under clause (1) of Article 30 of the Constitution.
99. In the same vein, the state may also provide for the mode by which educational institutions may be set up or established. For instance, it may require that a society registered under the Societies Registration Act or a public trust constituted in accordance with law is a prerequisite to establishing a school.95 The state may also issue a certificate of recognition to the school (or other educational institution) meeting the relevant criteria. It may also require schools to register with the authorities.96 Certain steps as mandated by law may be a sine qua non for setting up educational institutions.
100. In the absence of these prerequisites (such as registration with the competent authorities), the educational institution will have no 95 See, for instance, Section 20A of the Andhra Pradesh Education Act 1982 read with Rule 14(4) of the Andhra Pradesh Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Rules 2010. Section 20A: “20-A. Prohibition of individual to establish institutions.—On and from the commencement of the Andhra Pradesh Education (Amendment) Act, 1987 no individual shall establish a private institution: Provided that this section shall not have any effect on any private institution established by an individual and recognized by the competent authority prior to such commencement].” Rule 14(4): “(4) The District Educational Officer, on being satisfied that the school fulfils the norms and standards prescribed under section 19 and section 25 of the Act, shall issue the recognition certificate in Form-2 as shown in the appendix. The certificate shall be for a period of three years and shall be issued within 30 days from the date of making application for recognition. The certificate of recognition shall be issued subject to following conditions: (a) The school is run by a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 (21 of 1860), or a public trust constituted under any law for the time being in force; …”
96 See, for instance, Section 30 of the Karnataka Education Act 1983: “30. Educational institutions to be registered.- (1) Save as otherwise provided in this Act, every local authority institution and every private educational institution established on or before the date of commencement of this Act or intended to be established thereafter, shall notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, be registered in accordance with this Act and the rules made thereunder. (2) No person or local authority shall establish or as the case may be, run or maintain an educational institution requiring registration under this section, unless such institution is so registered.” 1734 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports existence in the eyes of the law. It is only upon compliance with these requirements that the institution assumes the legal form mandated by the regulatory provisions of the law.
101. It is true that many persons or groups founded universities which awarded degrees which were not recognised by the imperial government. The existence of this option and the fact that others chose this path in colonial times cannot shape the contours of the right under Article 30 in independent India. This is because the recognition of degrees was and is essential not only to the success of the university but more importantly, to the success of its graduates. Recognition of the degrees or qualifications held by persons who have completed courses from universities is essential to professional development. It is impossible to avail of employment opportunities if the degree that one holds is not recognised.
102. This interpretation has also found support in numerous judgments of this Court. Judgments of this Court have previously expounded on the importance of recognition or affiliation of a College. It is only with the affiliation of the college with the University that a student could be awarded a degree upon the completion of the course of study. The degree, beyond being a testament of a personal achievement, is necessary for their professional growth. In in re the Kerala Education Bill 1957 (supra), this Court expounded on the importance of recognition and observed as follows:
“32. […] Without recognition, therefore, the educational institutions established or to be established by the minority communities cannot fulfil the real objects of their choice and the rights under Article 30(1) cannot be effectively exercised. The right to establish educational institutions of their choice must, therefore, mean the right to establish real institutions which will effectively serve the needs of their community and the scholars who resort to their educational institutions. There is, no doubt, no such thing as fundamental right to recognition by the State but to deny recognition to the educational institutions except upon terms tantamount to the surrender of their constitutional right of administration of the educational institutions of their choice is in truth and in effect to deprive them of their rights under Article 30(1). We repeat that the legislative power [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1735Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. is subject to the fundamental rights and the legislature cannot indirectly take away or abridge the fundamental rights which it could not do directly and yet that will be the result if the said Bill containing any offending clause becomes law.”
103. In Rev. Sidhajbhai (supra), this Court reiterated that regulations which may impose conditions for the recognition of the educational institution must be directed towards making the institution effective, while retaining its character as a minority institution. The dual test laid down in this case to assess the validity of such regulations is that the regulations must be reasonable and regulate the educational character of the institution while being conducive to making it an effective vehicle of education. An educational institution does not lose its minority character merely because it subjects itself to regulatory measures essential to avail the benefit of recognition/affiliation, or grant in aid, provided these controls are designed to maintain the standards of education and larger public interest.
104. The decision of the seven Judge Bench in In re the Kerala Education Bill (supra)was followed by a six Judge Bench in Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai (supra). This aspect was overlooked in Azeez Basha (supra) which was decided by a bench of five judges. The importance of recognition and affiliation cannot be understated. The position of law even at the time of the decision in Azeez Basha (supra), as held in re the Kerala Education Bill 1957 (supra), was that recognition on terms tantamount to the surrender of the right to administer the institution was a violation of Article 30(1). For Azeez Basha (supra) to hold that the minority character of the institution is surrendered upon enactment by central imperial legislation is to hold that the recognition of its degrees would result in the denial of the right under Article 30, reducing the choice available to a religious or linguistic minority. This would be in the teeth of settled law on the subject as well as Article 30(1). Azeez Basha (supra) failed to notice this aspect of the decision in In re the Kerala Education Bill 1957 (supra) discussed above and the decision in Rev. Sidhajbhai (supra).
105. Further, the decisions of this Court subsequent to Azeez Basha (supra) have not disturbed the relevant part of the precedents in In 1736 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports re the Kerala Education Bill 1957 (supra) and Rev. Sidhajbhai (supra). Azeez Basha (supra) is the lone case which stands apart in the long line of cases on this subject. In St. Xavier’s (supra), the majority of the nine-Judge Bench held that an unconstitutional condition of surrendering the minority character in exchange for affiliation or recognition cannot be imposed.
106. Presently, the decision of eleven Judges in TMA Pai (supra) holds the field on the subject and is binding on this Court. It, too, unequivocally affirms the proposition of law discussed above. One of the many relevant paragraphs in this regard is extracted below:
“70. … The object of establishing an institution has thus been to provide technical or professional education to the deserving candidates, and is not necessarily a commercial venture. In order that this intention is meaningful, the institution must be recognized. At the school level, the recognition or affiliation has to be sought from the educational authority or the body that conducts the school-leaving examination. … A college or a professional educational institution has to get recognition from the university concerned, which normally requires certain conditions to be fulfilled before recognition. It has been held that conditions of affiliation or recognition, which pertain to the academic and educational character of the institution and ensure uniformity, efficiency and excellence in educational courses are valid, and that they do not violate even the provisions of Article 30 of the Constitution; but conditions that are laid down for granting recognition should not be such as may lead to governmental control of the administration of the private educational institutions.”
(emphasis supplied)
107. Compliance with the legal requirement to secure a benefit provided by the State cannot be on terms that require the relinquishment of fundamental rights. An interpretation that leans towards this consequence must not be adopted. Thus, the minority character of an educational institution could not have been denied merely because it was converted to a University through a legislative enactment. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1737Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
108. In Azeez Basha (supra), this Court recognised the efforts of the Muslim community towards the establishment of AMU’s predecessor, the MAO College, as well as towards the enactment of the AMU Act but held that the central imperial legislature established AMU, and not the Muslim community. In effect, it held that the enactment of the AMU Act rendered any previous action undertaken by the Muslim community towards the establishment of AMU irrelevant.
109. The reasoning of the Court hinged on the fact that the Muslim minority could have established a university and awarded degrees but could not have insisted upon governmental recognition of its degrees. The Court held that the fact that AMU was brought into existence by a statute which mandated the recognition of its degrees meant that the central imperial legislature established it. Since the correctness of the reasoning of the Court is being considered in these proceedings, it is extracted below:
“22. There was nothing in 1920 to prevent the Muslim minority, if it so chose, to establish a university; but if it did so the degrees of such a university were not bound to be recognised by Government. … The Aligarh University was also in the same way established by legislation and it provided under Section 6 of the 1920 Act that “the degrees, diplomas and other academic distinctions granted or conferred to or on persons by the University shall be recognised by the Government as are the corresponding degrees, diplomas and other academic distinctions granted by any other university incorporated under any enactment”. It is clear therefore that even though the Muslim minority could have established at Aligarh in 1920 a university, it could not insist that degrees granted by such a university should be recognised by Government. Therefore when the Aligarh University was established in 1920 and by Section 6 its degrees were recognised by Government, an institution was brought into existence which could not be brought into existence by any private individual or body for such individual or body could not insist upon the recognition of the degrees conferred by any university established by it. The enactment of Section 6 in the 1920 Act is a very important circumstance which shows that the Aligarh University when it came to be established in 1920 1738 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports was not established by the Muslim minority, for the minority could not insist on the recognition by Government of the degrees conferred by any university established by it.
23. … There was no Aligarh University existing till the 1920 Act was passed. It was brought into being by the 1920 Act and must therefore be held to have been established by the Central Legislature which by passing the 1920 Act incorporated it. The fact that it was based on the M.A.O. College, would make no difference to the question as to who established the Aligarh University.
The answer to our mind as to who established the Aligarh University is clear and that is that it was the Central Legislature by enacting the 1920 Act that established the said University. As we have said already, the Muslim minority could not establish a university whose degrees were bound to be recognised by Government as provided by Section 6 of 1920 Act : that one circumstance along with the fact that without the 1920 Act the University in the form that it had, could not come into existence shows clearly that the Aligarh University when it came into existence in 1920 was established by the Central Legislature by the 1920 Act. It may be that the 1920 Act was passed as a result of the efforts of the Muslim minority. But that does not mean that the Aligarh University when it came into being under the 1920 Act was established by the Muslim minority.”
110. In Azeez Basha (supra), this Court observed that the term ‘establish’ means ‘to bring into existence’ and not any of the other dictionary meanings that is, to ratify, confirm, settle, found, or create. Adopting a formalistic interpretation, the Bench held that AMU was not established by the Muslim minority since it was brought ‘into existence’ by the Central Legislature. In Mother Provincial (supra), another Constitution Bench which was decided before Azeez Basha (supra) interpreted the word ‘establish’ to mean to found an institution, which offers a broader interpretation.97 In our view, it is inconsequential 97 8. […] Establishment here means the bringing of an institution and it must be by a minority community. It matters not if a single philanthropic individual with his own means, founds the institution or the community at large contributes the funds.” (emphasis supplied) [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1739Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. whether the word means ‘to bring into existence’ or ‘to found’. We have held above that the enactment of a legislation to incorporate a university would not repudiate the minority character. The Court must pierce the veil of the statute to identify if the institution intended to retain its minority character even upon incorporation.
111. The respondents further submitted that the long title and the preamble of the enactment must be used to determine if the minority established the institution. A comparison was drawn between the preamble of the AMU Act and statutes by which other universities were incorporated. For example, the preamble of the Annamalai University Act 1928 stipulates that the founder of the college, Shri Annamalai Chettiyar, handed over the college with the property and a fund of twenty thousand rupees to the local Government for the establishment of a University. The preamble also recognises that he and his heirs would be entitled to certain powers and privileges in the University. However, in contrast, the preamble of the AMU Act 1920 stated that it is an enactment to ‘establish’ and ‘incorporate’ a University.
112. We do not agree with this submission. It cannot be argued that a university was established by Parliament merely because the long title and preamble of the statute incorporating the university states that it is an Act to establish and incorporate. If such a formalistic interpretation is adopted, fundamental rights would be made subservient to legislative language. The preamble of the Annamalai University Act certainly provides context to the incorporation of the University and brings out the distinction between incorporation and establishment. However, the courts in the absence of such an elaborate preamble must not be ready to conclude that Parliament established the University. The courts must identify the circumstances surrounding the incorporation of the University (including through a reading of the statute) to identify who established the university. Formalism must give way to actuality and to what is real.
113. The written submissions filed on behalf of the Union of India place reliance on Dalco Engg. (P) Ltd. v. Satish Prabhakar Padhye98 to argue that the term ‘establish’ means “coming into existence by virtue of a statutory enactment”. It suggests that the institution owes
98 (2010) 4 SCC 378
1740 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports its existence to the legislature if the long title to an enactment states that it is an act to “establish and incorporate”.
114. In Dalco (supra), the question before this Court was whether companies incorporated in terms of the Companies Act 1956 were bound by the norm contained in Section 47 of the same enactment. Section 47 stipulated that an ‘establishment’ shall not dispense with or reduce in rank an employee who acquires a disability during their service.99 Section 2(k) of the same statute defined ‘establishment’ in the following terms:
“2. Definitions.—In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,— …
(k) ‘establishment’ means a corporation established by or under a Central, Provincial or State Act, or an authority or a body owned or controlled or aided by the Government or a local authority or a government company as defined in Section 617 of the Companies Act, 1956 (1 of 1956) and includes Departments of a Government;”
(emphasis supplied)
115. After analysing the precedents, this Court held that Section 2(k) referred to companies which owe their existence to a statute. It held that without such a statute, the company would not exist. It held that the term “established by or under” in Section 2(k) referred to companies which are created by statutes and not ones which are merely governed by statutes after coming into existence. This court, therefore, held that companies incorporated and registered under the Companies Act 1956 are not necessarily established by it. 99 Section 47, Companies Act 1956: “47. Non-discrimination in government employment.—(1) No establishment shall dispense with, or reduce in rank, an employee who acquires a disability during his service:
Provided that, if an employee, after acquiring disability is not suitable for the post he was holding, could be shifted to some other post with the same pay scale and service benefits: Provided further that if it is not possible to adjust the employee against any post, he may be kept on a supernumerary post until a suitable post is available or he attains the age of superannuation, whichever is earlier.
(2) No promotion shall be denied to a person merely on the ground of his disability: Provided that the appropriate Government may, having regard to the type of work carried on in any establishment, by notification and subject to such conditions, if any, as may be specified in such notification, exempt any establishment from the provisions of this section.” [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1741Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
116. Dalco (supra) does not have a bearing on the interpretation of the term “establish” in Article 30 because it was concerned with the interpretation of the term “established by or under a Central, Provincial or State Act” as it occurs in a parliamentary statute. The words “establish and incorporate” in the long title of enactments must be read together holistically to understand the import of the expression. The other cases100 relied on by the Union of India in this respect are not applicable to the question before us for similar reasons.
d. ‘Minority’ as on the commencement of the Constitution
117. Mr Dwivedi submitted that an educational institution to be a minority educational institution must have been established by a linguistic or religious minority at the time of establishment. He proposed that the following tests must be satisfied to determine if the community was a minority:
a. The numerical test:101 Which community ruled the country when the university was established? Is the community which seeks to claim the right under Article 30 a minority compared to the former?
b. The qualitative test of non-dominance:102 Even if the community which seeks to claim the right under Article 30 was in a numerical minority, was it in a non-dominant position in the state at the point of time at which the institution was established? c. The test of self-assessment: Did the specific persons who established the educational institute consider themselves to be a minority?
118. A preliminary question must be answered before addressing the feasibility and legality of adopting the above tests. What should be the relevant point to determine if the educational institution that was founded before the commencement of the Constitution was 100 Sukhdev Singh v. Bhagatram Sardar Singh Raghuvanshi (1975) 1 SCC 421; Vaish Degree College v. Lakshmi Narain (1976) 2 SCC 58; S.S. Dhanoa v. MCD (1981) 3 SCC 431 101 See opinion of Justice Ruma Pal in TMA Pai (supra)
102 See opinion of Justice Quadri in TMA Pai (supra)
1742 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports established by a minority? Should it be determined based on the time of establishment, the time of the commencement of the Constitution, or the time when the right was claimed.
119. Before the commencement of the Constitution, there was no concept of minority institutions, both linguistic and religious. The guarantee and the protection given by the Constitution are applicable on the date when the Constitution was adopted. It is on this date that it must be determined if the right under Article 30 accrues. However, when the question of whether the educational institution was established by a linguistic or a religious minority arises, we will have to relate back to the point in time when the institution was established. It would be immaterial that back then the educational institution was not granted the status and treated as a linguistic or a religious minority institution. Thus, the details of the persons who had established the institution, though earlier in point of time, is relevant and determines the character of the institution. Such interpretation would do justice to Article 30(1) and not deny and rob minority educational institutions of constitutional guarantees.
120. The question of whether they qualify as a ‘minority’ has to be answered with reference to the date of enforcement of the Constitution. The Constitution upon its adoption guaranteed fundamental rights to specific groups such as ‘persons’, ‘citizens’, ‘religious and linguistic minorities’, ‘women’, ‘the Scheduled Castes’ and ‘Scheduled Tribes’. These groups consist of such members as conceived by the Constitution. For example, Part II of the Constitution and provisions of the Citizenship Act 1955 enacted in pursuance of the power provided under Article 11 stipulate conditions for acquiring citizenship. Only those persons who satisfy the conditions prescribed can enforce the rights guaranteed to citizens as a class. Similarly, the President in exercise of the power under Article 341 may notify castes, tribes or groups that would be Scheduled Castes for the purposes of the Constitution.
121. The only criteria that is prescribed for right-bearers under Article 30 is that they should be linguistic or a religious minorities. The courts have, however, specified what constitutes a minority. Chief Justice Kirpal, writing for the majority of the eleven-Judge Bench in TMA Pai (supra) observed that the minority must be determined [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1743Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. based on the test of numerical minority within the State.103 If a group or community is required to prove that it was a religious or linguistic minority at the time of establishment of the institution (where the institution was established before the commencement of the Constitution), it would lead to a situation where the fundamental right is conferred upon a group other than the one intended by the Constitution. The demography of the Dominion of India underwent a drastic change upon partition. The Constitution, through Article 30(1), confers a right on those communities that were disadvantaged upon the commencement of the Constitution and not the group that was disadvantaged in pre-independent India.
122. We reject the argument that the test of whether an educational institution is a minority institution must be examined based on whether the community or the group which had established the institution was a minority at the time of its establishment in pre-independent India. The purpose of the provision as highlighted in the preceding sections is to ensure that the minorities are able to preserve and promote their linguistic and religious culture. For this purpose, the status of the group/community, that had established the institution, on the date of commencement of the Constitution should be considered. The test of establishment will apply to future situations on the day when new educational institutions are established. The protection under clause (1) of Article 30 cannot be denied to institutions established before the commencement of the Constitution for the reason that at the time of establishment in pre-independent India, the founders were not aware that they would receive protection of Article 30(1).
123. Having addressed the preliminary arguments on the applicability of Article 30, we will now proceed to formulate the indicia for the establishment of an educational institution.
v. Indicia for the ‘establishment’ of a minority educational institution
124. In this section of the judgment, we will answer two questions: (i) the indicia for ‘establishment’ of a minority educational institution; and
(ii) the burden and degree of proof required to prove ‘establishment’ of a minority educational institution.
103 TMA Pai (supra) [81] 1744 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
125. In SK Patro (supra), the question before the Constitution Bench was whether Church Missionary Society Higher Secondary School was a minority educational institution. It was contended that the school was established by the Church Missionary Society, London and not the local residents of Bhagalpur. The Bench relied on the following evidence to conclude that the School was established by the local Christians:
a. The correspondence and resolutions indicated that a permanent home for the Boys School was set up on property acquired by local Christians and in buildings erected from funds collected by them104 b. The institution and the land on which it was built and the balance in the local fund were handed over to the Church Missionary Society;105 and c. Though substantial assistance was obtained from the Church Missionary Society London, it could not be said that the school was not established by local residents only because of that.106
126. In Mother Provincial (supra), this Court observed that the intention to found an institution for the benefit of the minority community must be present. In St. Stephen’s (supra), a Constitution Bench determined whether St. Stephen’s College is a minority educational institution. St Stephen’s College is a constituent college of Delhi University. The Bench held that the college was established by the Indian Christian community based on the following material:
a. The purpose of establishing the educational institution emerged from the Report of 1878 to the Cambridge Brotherhood. The purpose of founding the college was to ensure that graduates from St. Stephen’s Mission School could be given the benefit of Christian teachings in college;107 b. The buildings depicted the Christian orientation of the college108 104 SK Patro (supra) [15] 105 ibid [15] 106 ibid [16] 107 St Stephen’s (supra) [30] 108 Ibid [31-32] Foundation stone has the inscription :”to the glory of god, and the advancement of sound, learning and religious education”; a cross was placed in the new building. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1745Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. c. The motto of the college is “Ad Dei Gloriam”, that is the glory of god;109 d. There is a chapel in the college campus, where religious instruction is imparted;110 e. The Constitution of the college reflects its Christian character. It states that the object of the college is, inter alia, to offer instruction on doctrines of Christianity,111 the original members of the society were mostly Christians,112 and the composition of the society reflects its Christian character where a large number of Christian members of the Church of North India are a part of it;113 and f. The Governing Body has a distinct christian character. The Supreme Council comprises of members of the Church of North India. Their role is to look after the religious and moral instruction to students.114 The administration vests with the Governing Body which predominantly consists of Christians. Though three of the thirteen members of the Governing Body may be non-Christians, that does not dilute the Christian character of the institution.
127. The decisions in Mother Provincial (supra), SK Patro (supra) and St. Stephen’s (supra) emphasise that the indicia for establishment must elucidate the minority character of the educational institution. What is the meaning of the phrase ‘minority character’? Are special rights guaranteed by Article 30(1) only if educational institutions are established ‘for’ the minorities, towards the purpose of protecting minority interests? If yes, when can the courts be certain that the above two conditions are satisfied? That is, what are the ‘core essentials’ of minority character? We will answer this by referring to judicial decisions on four questions. Clarity over the essentials of the minority character will help us ascertain the indicia for ‘establishment’ of a minority educational institution.
109 ibid [33] 110 ibid [34] 111 Memorandum of the Society and Rules, Clause 2 112 Memorandum of the Society and Rules, Clause 4 113 ibid [35] 114 ibid [36] 1746 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
128. The first question that arose in earlier cases was whether a minority educational institution must be established towards the conservation of the distinct language, script or culture of linguistic and religious minorities protected by Article 29(1). In Rev. Father W. Proost v. The State of Bihar,115 a Constitution Bench answered the question in the negative. The Bench held that Article 30(1) covers a minority educational institution which is established to conserve culture and language. However, that need not be the only purpose for the establishment of the institution. This Court held that the scope of Article 30(1) cannot be restricted by Article 29(1).116 In St. Xavier (supra), the majority of the nine-Judge Bench approved this interpretation.117
129. The second question that arose in earlier decisions was whether an educational institution would retain its minority character even if non-minorities are admitted in it. Would a Muslim minority education institution retain its minority character when it admits students from other faiths in the institution? In re the Kerala Education Bill 1957 (supra), a seven-Judge Bench held that a minority educational institution would not lose its minority character by merely admitting students belonging to non-minorities and that the provision contemplates an institution with a ‘sprinkling of outsiders’.118 This position was further fortified in TMA Pai (supra). In TMA Pai (supra), Article 29(2) and Article 30(1) were read harmoniously to hold that Article 29(2) would apply to a limited extent to minority educational institutions as well.119 Thus, an aided minority educational institution 115 [1969] 2 SCR 73 116 Rev. Father W Proost v. State of Bihar [5J] [1969] 2 SCR 73 117 See footnote 30 of this judgment.
118 “By admitting a non-member into it the minority institution does not shed its character and cease to be a minority institution. Indeed the object of conservation of the distinct language, script and culture of a minority may be better served by propagating the same amongst non-members of the particular minority community.”
119 “149. […] As observed quite aptly in St. Stephen’s case [(1992) 1 SCC 558] (at SCC p. 608, para 85) “the fact that Article 29(2) applies to minorities as well as non-minorities does not mean that it was intended to nullify the special right guaranteed to minorities in Article 30(1)”. The word “only” used in Article 29(2) is of considerable significance and has been used for some avowed purpose. Denying admission to non-minorities for the purpose of accommodating minority students to a reasonable extent will not be only on grounds of religion etc., but is primarily meant to preserve the minority character of the institution and to effectuate the guarantee under Article 30(1). The best possible way is to hold that as long as the minority educational institution permits admission of citizens belonging to the non-minority class to a reasonable extent based upon merit, it will not be an infraction of Article 29(2), even though the institution admits students of the minority group of its own choice for whom the institution was meant. What would be a reasonable extent would depend upon variable factors, and it may not be advisable to fix any specific percentage. The situation would vary according to [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1747Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. is mandated to admit students from other faiths and that in itself does not erode the minority character of the institution.
130. The third question was whether a minority education institution would lose its minority character when secular education is taught. In In re Kerala Education Bill (supra) and St. Xavier’s (supra), this Court held that the word ‘choice’ in Article 30(1) expands the scope of the provision to include not only religious but also secular education.120
131. The fourth question was whether it is essential that religious instruction must be provided in a minority educational institution. In TMA Pai (supra), this Court held that Article 28 equally applies to minority educational institutions.121 Thus, if the minority institution has received aid from the State wholly or in part, no student can be forced to participate in religious instruction. Similarly, a minority educational institution which is fully maintained out of State funds cannot provide religious instruction. Even here, a harmonious construction of Article 28 and Article 30(1) was adopted. the type of institution and the nature of education that is being imparted in the institution. Usually, at the school level, although it may be possible to fill up all the seats with students of the minority group, at the higher level, either in colleges or in technical institutions, it may not be possible to fill up all the seats with the students of the minority group. However, even if it is possible to fill up all the seats with students of the minority group, the moment the institution is granted aid, the institution will have to admit students of the non-minority group to a reasonable extent, whereby the character of the institution is not annihilated, and at the same time, the rights of the citizen engrafted under Article 29(2) are not subverted. It is for this reason that a variable percentage of admission of minority students depending on the type of institution and education is desirable, and indeed, necessary, to promote the constitutional guarantees enshrined in both Article 29(2) and Article 30. [emphasis supplied] 120 In re Kerala Education Bill(supra) [23] “23. […] the right conferred on such minorities is to establish educational institutions of their choice. It does not say that minorities based on religion should establish educational institutions for teaching religion only, or that linguistic minorities should have the right to establish educational institutions for teaching their language only. What the article says and means is that the religious and the linguistic minorities should have the right to establish educational institutions of their choice. There is no limitation placed on the subjects to be taught in such educational institutions. As such minorities will ordinarily desire that their children should be brought up properly and efficiently and be eligible for higher university education and go out in the world fully equipped with such intellectual attainments as will make them fit for entering the public services, educational institutions of their choice will necessarily include institutions imparting general secular education also.”; St. Xavier’s (supra) [Chief Justice Ray for himself and Justice Palekar, 8]; [Justice HR Khanna, 96]; [Justice Beg, 197]; [Justice Dwivedi, 236];
121 See TMA Pai (supra) [88-90;144]; “144 […] As in the case of a majority-run institution, the moment a minority institution obtains a grant of aid, Article 28 of the Constitution comes into play. When an educational institution is maintained out of State funds, no religious instruction can be provided therein. Article 28(1) does not state that it applies only to educational institutions that are not established or maintained by religious or linguistic minorities. Furthermore, upon the receipt of aid, the provisions of Article 28(3) would apply to all educational institutions whether run by the minorities or the nonminorities. […] Just as Articles 28(1) and (3) become applicable the moment any educational institution takes aid, likewise, Article 29(2) would also be attracted and become applicable to an educational institution maintained by the State or receiving aid out of State funds.” 1748 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
132. The discussion above elucidates that the ‘minority character’ of the institution is not a rigid concept. The provision does not contemplate institutions which are exclusively for the benefit of members from the minority community. A minority institution established by a religious or linguistic minority need not be solely for their students or only for the purpose of teaching the tenets of their religion or language. The issue of whether an institution is a minority institution should not be determined purely on the basis of the number of their students or the teaching staff. Such an interpretation is contrary to precedent.
133. A holistic and realistic view should be taken keeping in mind the objective and purpose of the provision. Based on the above principles laid down by Benches of co-equal strength and larger Benches of this Court on the components of the ‘minority character’, the following inferences can be drawn:
a. The existence of a religious place for prayer and worship is not a necessary indicator of the minority character because institutions wholly maintained out of State funds are constitutionally barred from providing religious instructions; and b. The existence of religious symbols in the precincts of the educational institution are not necessary to prove the minority character because educational institutions could be established for minorities to provide secular education without imparting any lessons on religion.
134. As discussed above, ‘establishment’ or formation of an institution can be at any point of time and even before the commencement of the Constitution. If an institution was established before the commencement of the Constitution, the enquiry on the question of ‘establishment’ must relate back to the date when the institution was established or formed to ascertain whether it would qualify as a minority institution upon the commencement of the Constitution.
135. To determine who established the institution, the Courts must consider the genesis of the educational institution. For this analysis, the Courts must trace the origin of the idea for the establishment of the institution. The Court must identify who was the brain behind the establishment of the educational institution. Letters, correspondence with other members of the community or with government/State officials and resolutions issued could be valid proof for establishing [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1749Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. ideation or the impetus to found and establish. The proof of ideation must point towards one member of the minority or a group from the community.122
136. The second indicia is the purpose for which the educational institution was established. Though it is not necessary that the educational institution must have been established only for the benefit of a religious or linguistic minority community, it must predominantly be for its benefit. It is not necessary that education must be provided in the language spoken by the minority or on the religion of the minority. For example, it is not necessary that an educational institution established for the Tamils in Uttar Pradesh must necessarily prescribe Tamil as the language of instruction. However, it must be proved that the institution was established for the benefit of the tamil-speaking community. This indicia could be proved by a reference to private communication or speeches about the necessity of establishing an educational institution for the community and a recognition of the educational difficulties faced by the community.
137. The third test is tracing the steps taken towards the implementation of the idea. Information on who contributed the funds for its creation, who was responsible for obtaining the land, and whether the land was donated by a member of the minority community or purchased from funds raised by the minority community for this purpose or donated by a person from some other community specifically for the establishment of a minority educational institution are elements that must be considered. Similar questions must be asked of its other assets. Other important questions are: who took the steps necessary for establishing the institution (such as obtaining the relevant permissions, constructing the buildings, and arranging other infrastructure)? It is also important to note that the state may grant some land or other monetary aid during or after the establishment of the educational institution. If the land or monies were granted after the establishment, the grant would not have the effect of changing the minority character of the institution. Minority institutions are not barred from receiving aid save at the cost of their minority status.123 If the land or monies are granted at the time of establishment, the 122 Mother Provincial (supra)
123 TMA Pai (supra) [141] 1750 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports circumstances surrounding the establishment must be considered as a whole to determine who established the institution. The presence of a grant must not be automatically interpreted as leading to the erasure of a claim to minority status.
138. The next question is whether the administrative structure of the educational institution is an indicia for the establishment of a minority educational institution. We have already held above that an educational institution is a minority educational institution if it is established by a religious or linguistic minority. We have clarified that it is not necessary to prove that administration vests with the minority to prove that it is a minority educational institution because the very purpose of Article 30(1) is to grant special rights on administration as a consequence of establishment. To do otherwise, would amount to converting the consequence to a pre-condition. The right to administer is guaranteed to minority educational institutions to enable them to possess sufficient autonomy to model the educational institution according to the educational values that the community wishes to emphasise. It is not necessary that the purpose can only be implemented if persons belonging to the community helm the administrative affairs. This is so particularly because a minority institution may wish to emphasise secular education. The founders or the minority community may choose to populate the managing board (or a comparable authority) responsible for the day-to-day administration of the institution with persons belonging to the same community. However, they are not compelled to do so. They may wish to appoint persons who do not belong to their community but who they deem fit for the proper administration of the institution. This may be the case for professional colleges which offer specialised courses such as law, medicine, or architecture, where the founders may not possess the knowledge, experience, or insight necessary to manage or administer the institution personally.
139. The test to be adopted by the Court is whether the administrative set up of the educational institution affirms the minority character of the institution. If the administrative structure of the educational institution does not reflect its minority character or when it does not elucidate that the educational institution was established to protect and promote the interests of the minority, it may be reasonably inferred that the purpose was not to establish an educational institution for the benefit of the minority community.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1751Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
140. We may specifically deal with a scenario of an educational institution established before the commencement of the Constitution. The test of administration should be evaluated in praesenti, that is, on the date of the commencement of the Constitution. An institution to be a minority institution must satisfy the criteria of being ‘administered’ as a minority institution on the date of commencement of the Constitution, and being a minority institution on the date of formation. Even if an educational institution was established by the minority for the purposes of the community, we must assess the impact of any subsequent events that altered the character of the institution before the commencement of the Constitution. We have in section E(iv)(c) held that the statutory incorporation of the institution does not ipso facto amount to a surrender of the minority character of the institution. We have held that the Court must pierce the veil to identify if the University was established by a minority for the purpose of promoting the interest of the community. The Court may on a holistic reading of the statutory provisions relating to the administrative set-up of the educational institution deduce if the minority character or the purpose of establishment was relinquished upon incorporation. The question is whether the regulatory measures wrest the administrative control from the founders of the institution. This is a question of fact which must be determined on the facts of each case. The Court must make that determination upon a comprehensive analysis of the administrative framework which includes host of factors such as the representation of the interests of the community in the administrative set-up.
141. Taken together, these are the main indicia which assist the Court in determining who established an educational institution under Article
30. However, the complex nature of establishing an educational institution is not lost on us. Undoubtedly, there can be no straitjacket formula which may be applied. The above indicia of establishment must be considered as a whole, along with any relevant facts which are available to the Court. The matter must be considered in totality and competing factors must be weighed against each other depending on the facts and circumstances of each institution.
142. The above indicia must be proved through the submission of cogent material. Reliance must be placed on primary sources such as office documents, letters and resolutions or memorandums issued to implement the resolutions. Secondary sources must only be 1752 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports used to corroborate the primary sources. The onus to prove that the educational institution was established by a minority is on the claimants.
143. One of the questions referred to this Bench was whether Article 30(1) envisages an institution which is established by minorities alone without participation from any other community? This question was based on the facts as observed by this Court in Anjuman-e- Rahmaniya (supra) where some persons from communities other than the Muslim community had contributed to the establishment of the educational institution. That case has been finally adjudicated and the issues which arose in it do not survive. Nothing in Article 30 prevents some persons from other communities in contributing to the establishment of an institution by a minority. There may be persons hailing from different communities who are concerned about the need for minority educational institutions and lend their assistance in some form – be it by contributing monies or otherwise. Their participation and involvement would not preclude Article 30 from being applicable to such institutions provided that the minority community continues to shoulder the core of the responsibility of establishing an educational institution.
vi. Impact of Entry 63 of List I on the minority status of educational institutions
144. Entry 63 of the Union List to the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution deals with the institutions known at the commencement of the Constitution as Benares Hindu University, Aligarh Muslim University and Delhi University. Notably, the entry also indicates that Parliament may enact laws which pertain to any other institutions which are declared by law to be institutions of national importance.124
145. Entry 63 of List I had its genesis in Entry 13 of List I to the Seventh Schedule to the Government of India Act 1935. Entry 13 read as “Benares Hindu University and the Aligarh Muslim University”. Entry 17 of List II read as “Educations including Universities other than those specified in paragraph 13 of List I”. The Federal Legislature 124 Entry 63: “The institutions known at the commencement of this Constitution as the Benares Hindu University, the Aligarh Muslim University and the Delhi University, and any other institution declared by Parliament by law to be an institution of national importance.” [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1753Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. had the power to enact laws with respect to BHU and AMU while the Provincial Legislatures had the power to enact laws to establish new Universities and amend the legislation through which Universities were established and/or incorporated, except for the laws relating to AMU and BHU.125
146. The Constitution of India adopted a similar model of division of legislative power as regards the subject at hand. The State Legislature had the power to enact laws with respect to education, including Universities by virtue of Entry 11 of List II of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution. This power was subject to Entries 63,64 and 65 of List I and Entry 25 of List III. By the Constitution (Thirty-second Amendment) Act 1973, Entry 63 was amended to include the University established in pursuance of Article 371-E.126,127 Subsequently, by the Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act 1976, Entry 11 of List II was deleted and a similar subject was placed in Entry 25 of List III.128 Both Entry 11 of List II (prior to its omission) and Entry 25 of List III (as it currently stands) were made subject to the provisions of Entries 63, 64 and 65 of List I. The effect of this was that Parliament retained the exclusive power to legislate upon AMU, BHU and Delhi University in Entry 63 of List I and the subjects which fall within the scope of Entries 64 and 65 notwithstanding the broader or more general entries in the Seventh Schedule which include Universities.
147. In the Government of India Act 1935, the Federal Legislature only had the power to legislate upon AMU and BHU. However, the scope of Parliament’s legislative domain over education and Universities was enlarged in the Constitution of India. In addition to Entry 63, Parliament also has the power to legislate upon educational institutions which fall within the ambit of Entries 64 and 65. Entry 64 deals with institutions of scientific or technical education financed by the Government of 125 The Government of India Act 1935, Section 100 126 Article 371-A Establishment of Central University in Andhra Pradesh.- Parliament may by law provide for the establishment of a University in the State of Andhra Pradesh. 127 Entry 63 subsequent to the enactment of the Constitution (Thirty-second Amendment) Act 1973: “The institutions known at the commencement of this Constitution as the Benares Hindu University, the Aligarh Muslim University and the Delhi University; the University established in pursuance of Article 371-E any other institution declared by Parliament by law to be an institution of national importance.” 128 Entry 25: “Education, including technical education, medical education and universities, subject to the provisions of Entries 63, 64, 65 and 66 of List I; vocational and technical training of labour.” 1754 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports India wholly or in part and declared by Parliament by law to be institutions of national importance. Entry 65 deals with Union agencies and institutions for (i) professional, vocational or technical training, including the training of police officers; (ii) the promotion of special studies or research; and (iii) scientific or technical assistance in the investigation or detection of crime. Thus, Entries 64 and 65 deal with institutions which provide education in specific fields. Another crucial point is that by virtue of Entries 63 and 64, Parliament has the power to legislate upon institutions which are declared by law to be institutions of national importance. While Entry 64 provides broad criteria for declaring an institution to be of national importance, Article 63 does not contain similar indicia.
148. The question is whether the inclusion of a University as an institution of ‘national’ importance amounts to an abrogation of its minority character. The declaration of an institution as one of national importance does not amount to a change in the minority character of the institution. This is for multiple reasons. First, Entries in the Lists in the Seventh Schedule delineate the legislative competence of Parliament and of the legislatures of the States. As discussed in the preceding sections of this judgment, the State may regulate various aspects of education and educational institutions. The field of legislative competence over universities does not amount to a surrender of minority character. The distribution of legislative competence between Parliament and the State legislatures does not bear upon the minority character of the institution. Second, as a matter of principle, nothing prevents a minority educational institution from being an institution of national importance. The qualities denoted by the terms “national” and “minority” are not at odds with each other nor are they mutually exclusive. The former indicates that the institution has a pan-India or national character, as opposed to relatively more local or regional institutions. It is indicative of the importance of the institution on the national stage. The latter is evidence of the religious or linguistic background of the founders and the constitutional rights which vest in them. Each term indicates distinct attributes which are not antithetical to one another. A university may well be both national and ergo, of national importance, as well as minority in character. There is no reason why a minority educational institution cannot also be an institution of national importance. Third, Entries 63 and 64 provide Parliament with the power to declare an institution to be of [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1755Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. national importance. An interpretation that an institution of national importance cannot be a minority institution would amount to rendering the fundamental right guaranteed by Article 30(1) subservient to the legislative power of Parliament. Parliament can in terms of Entries 63 and 64 declare any institution to be of national importance.129 If the submission of the respondents is accepted, such a declaration would automatically exclude the institution(s) from the scope of Article 30(1). vii. The decision of this Court in Prof. Yashpal
149. Question (d) formulated in these proceedings requires the Court to assess whether the decision in Prof. Yashpal (supra) has a bearing on the other questions and if so, in what manner. It is therefore necessary to advert to the facts and decision in that case. Various writ petitions challenged certain provisions of the Chhattisgarh Niji Kshetra Vishwavidyalaya (Sthapana Aur Viniyaman) Adhiniyam 2002.130 Section 5 of this statute empowered the state government to incorporate and establish a university by issuing a notification in the Gazette. Section 6 permitted such a university to affiliate any college or other institution or to set up more than one campus with the prior approval of the state government. The state government established more than a hundred universities under the Chhattisgarh Act.
150. The petitioners in that case submitted that:
a. The universities established under the Chhattisgarh Act had no buildings or campuses and were running from tenements consisting of a single room or a single floor in a building. Basic infrastructure (such as classrooms, libraries, and laboratories) was absent. Despite this, the universities were empowered to award degrees;
b. The state government did not exercise any supervision over these universities and was establishing them in a mechanical manner, without assessing the infrastructure, teachers, or other resources of each of them;
129 See The Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education and Research, Puducherry Act 2008; The Institutes of Technology Act 1961; The Indian Institutes of Management Act 2017; National Institutes of Technology, Science, Education and Research Act 2007; The Indian Institutes of Information Technology Act 2014; See https://www.education.gov.in/institutions-national-importance 130 “Chhattisgarh Act”
1756 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports c. The UGC was unable to exercise any control over these universities due to the scheme of the Chhattisgarh Act and was made a redundant body;
d. These universities were offering courses and degrees which were not a part of the Schedule to the UGC Act. This was in violation of Section 22 of the UGC Act as well as the Schedule; e. These universities were offering professional courses without obtaining permission or approval from regulatory bodies such as the All India Council of Technical Education, Medical Council of India and Dental Council of India; and f. These universities conferred degrees without obtaining the requisite permission from statutory bodies. These degrees would not be recognised by professional organisations or other employers. The students who were awarded such degrees would therefore not only suffer financially but would also have lost the time spent completing these courses.
151. In response, the State of Chhattisgarh submitted that it was competent to enact the statute under challenge in view of Entry 32 of List II of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution.131 It argued that the universities were established on the basis of the representations made by the sponsoring body as set out in the project reports. However, it admitted that some of these universities did not meet the minimum standards expected of educational institutions, giving rise to serious concerns about the academic interest of the students. It stated that it therefore amended the Chhattisgarh Act in 2004. After the amendments, a large number of universities were de-notified because they failed to comply with the amended statute. Finally, it argued that the writ petitions ought to be dismissed because the concerns raised in them no longer subsisted after the amendments in 2004 and the consequent denotification of many universities.
152. This Court analysed the relevant entries in the Lists of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution as well as the UGC Act and held that Sections 5 and 6 of Chhattisgarh Act were ultra vires the Constitution and liable to be struck down for the following reasons: 131 “32. Incorporation, regulation and winding up of corporations, other than those specified in List I, and universities; unincorporated trading, literary, scientific, religious and other societies and associations; co-operative societies.”
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1757Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. a. The term “university” occurring in the three Lists of the Seventh Schedule must mean an institution with adequate facilities and resources for advanced learning and research. The standard of teaching and education must be such as would befit a university. The power conferred on state legislatures with respect to the incorporation of universities must be exercised only with respect to institutions which would in substance amount to universities. The Chhattisgarh Act did not provide for the establishment of universities in the true sense. Rather, it conferred the legal status of a university to mere institutions or project reports and permitted them to issue degrees. In doing so, it clothed an institute which is not a university and cannot amount to a university (because of a lack of infrastructure and resources) with the juristic personality of a university. This is not contemplated either by Entry 32 of List II or Entry 25 of List III. Sections 5 and 6 of the Chhattisgarh Act were a fraud on the Constitution; b. Although Entry 32 of List II and Entry 25 of List III empower the state legislatures to enact laws concerning the incorporation of universities, the whole gamut of the university including teaching, quality of education, curriculum and examinations, would not come within the purview of the state legislature because of Entry 66 of List I. Entry 66 of List I concerns the coordination and determination of standards in institutions for higher education or research and scientific and technical institutions. Parliament alone is competent to enact legislation which pertains to Entry 66 of List I. The UGC Act was enacted in pursuance of this entry; c. A statute enacted by the state legislature which stultifies or has the effect of nullifying a statute validly enacted by Parliament would be ultra vires. The Chhattisgarh Act made it impossible for the UGC to perform its duties and to ensure the coordination and determination of standards in terms of the UGC Act; and d. The expression “established or incorporated” in Sections 2(f), 22 and 23 of the UGC Act must be read as “established and incorporated” insofar as private universities are concerned. This is necessary in order to give effect to the purpose of the UGC Act.
153. The decision of this Court in Prof. Yashpal (supra) will not have a bearing on this case for the following reasons:
a. The interpretation of a statutory provision cannot influence the interpretation of a provision of the Constitution. The Constitution 1758 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports is the basic or fundamental law of the country. It controls all other laws;
b. The decision in Prof.Yashpal (supra) was rendered in the context of institutions which were given the status of universities by the operation of law but which existed only on paper, without any facilities, and offered some courses which were not approved by the relevant authorities. The purpose of this Court reading “established or incorporated” as “established and incorporated” was to prevent such institutions from being given the status of universities in the absence of essential features of universities. It was to ensure that institutions which were accorded the status of universities existed in actuality; and c. The distinction between the meaning of the term ‘establish’ and that of the term ‘incorporate’ was not effaced by this interpretation. Article 30 uses the word ‘establish.’ The indicia for determining whether an institution is a minority educational institution for the purposes of Article 30 would depend only upon whether the minority community in question established the educational institution.
viii. The amendment of the NCMEI Act in 2010
154. The NCMEI Act was enacted in 2004 to constitute a National Commission for minority educational institutions and to provide for matters connected or incidental to it. Section 3 mandates the constitution of the National Commission For Minority Educational Institutions.132 Section 11 details the functions of the Commission which include advising the Central or State governments on questions related to the education of minorities which may be referred to it; suo motu enquiries or enquiries based on petitions instituted by minority educational institutions; and intervening in proceedings before courts (with the leave of the court) which concern the deprivation or violation of the educational rights of minorities. Section 12 empowers the Commission to adjudicate disputes between a minority educational institution and university regarding affiliation and confers upon it the power of a civil court trying a suit in certain matters. Section 12B empowers the Commission to hear appeals against orders of authorities established by the Central or State governments, which reject applications for the grant of minority status filed by educational 132 “Commission”
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1759Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. institutions. The Commission also has other powers.133 Section 10 prescribes the procedure to establish a minority educational institution. In terms of the provision, any person who desires to establish a minority educational institution has to apply to the competent authority for the grant of a no objection certificate for the purpose. The competent authority would upon the perusal of documents, affidavits or other evidence and after giving the applicant an opportunity to be heard either allow or reject the application.
155. The NCMEI Act was amended in 2010.134
156. Section 2(g) defined a ‘minority educational institution’ as reproduced below:
“(g) “Minority educational institution” means a college or institution (other than a University) established or maintained by a person or group of persons from amongst the minorities;”
In 2010, Section 2(g) was amended to read as follows:
“(g) “Minority educational institution” means a college or an educational institution established and administered by a minority or minorities;”
157. Two material changes were made to Section 2(g) in 2010. The first was the removal of the words “other than a University” from the definition. The NCMEI Act did not extend to universities prior to 2010. The amendment in that year widened the ambit of the Act and made its provisions applicable to minority universities as well. The second change was the replacement of the term “established or maintained” with “established and administered.” The amendment in 2010 to the definition of a minority educational institution in Section 2(g) cannot impact the interpretation of Article 30(1). In the preceding sections, we have held that establishment by a minority is the only indicia for a minority educational institution. Section 10 of the NCMEI Act recognises this by prescribing the procedure to ‘establish’ a minority educational institution. The amendment to the definition of a minority educational education in Section 2(f) only recognises the right guaranteed by Article 30(1). It recognises that a minority educational institution once established is also administered by them.
133 Sections 12D and 12E, NCMEI Act.
134 See the National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions (Amendment) Act 2010. 1760 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports ix. Registration under the Societies Registration Act
158. The question is whether a minority educational institution which is registered as a society under the Societies Registration Act soon after its establishment loses its status as a minority educational institution by virtue of such registration.
159. As discussed in Section B of this judgment, this question was referred to a larger Bench by this Court in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra). This question was referred because the institution in that case was founded in 1938 and was registered under the Societies Registration Act in 1940. The judgment in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra) has been rendered and the case has been disposed of. This judgment will therefore not have a bearing on that case. Moreover, the parties in the present proceedings have not addressed this Court as to question (c) nor does the question have a bearing on the other questions referred. In these circumstances, we are of the opinion that this question is not required to be answered.
F. Conclusion
160. In view of the above discussion, the following are our conclusions: a. The reference in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya (supra) of the correctness of the decision in Azeez Basha (supra) was valid. The reference was within the parameters laid down in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community (supra);
b. Article 30(1) can be classified as both an anti-discrimination provision and a special rights provision. A legislation or an executive action which discriminates against religious or linguistic minorities in establishing or administering educational institutions is ultra vires Article 30(1).This is the anti-discrimination reading of the provision. Additionally, a linguistic or religious minority which has established an educational institution receives the guarantee of greater autonomy in administration. This is the ‘special rights’ reading of the provision;
c. Religious or linguistic minorities must prove that they established the educational institution for the community to be a minority educational institution for the purposes of Article 30(1); d. The right guaranteed by Article 30(1) is applicable to universities established before the commencement of the Constitution; e. The right under Article 30(1) is guaranteed to minorities as defined upon the commencement of the Constitution. A [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1761Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. different right-bearing group cannot be identified for institutions established before the adoption of the Constitution;
f. The incorporation of the University would not ipso facto lead to surrendering of the minority character of the institution. The circumstances surrounding the conversion of a teaching college to a teaching university must be viewed to identify if the minority character of the institution was surrendered upon the conversion. The Court may on a holistic reading of the statutory provisions relating to the administrative set-up of the educational institution deduce if the minority character or the purpose of establishment was relinquished upon incorporation; and g. The following are the factors which must be used to determine if a minority ‘established’ an educational institution: i. The indicia of ideation, purpose and implementation must be satisfied. First, the idea for establishing an educational institution must have stemmed from a person or group belonging to the minority community; second, the educational institution must be established predominantly for the benefit of the minority community; and third, steps for the implementation of the idea must have been taken by the member(s) of the minority community; and ii. The administrative-set up of the educational institution must elucidate and affirm (I) the minority character of the educational institution; and (II) that it was established to protect and promote the interests of the minority community.
161. The view taken in Azeez Basha (supra) that an educational institution is not established by a minority if it derives its legal character through a statute, is overruled. The questions referred are answered in the above terms. The question of whether AMU is a minority educational institution must be decided based on the principles laid down in this judgment. The papers of this batch of cases shall be placed before the regular bench for deciding whether AMU is a minority educational institution and for the adjudication of the appeal from the decision of the Allahabad High Court in Malay Shukla (supra) after receiving instructions from the Chief Justice of India on the administrative side.
162. The reference is disposed of in the above terms.
163. Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
1762 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Surya Kant, J.
Table of Contents** I. Background ........................................................................ 4 A. History of minority rights ............................................. 4 B. The Constitutional scheme ......................................... 14 C. Brief history of AMU .................................................... 19 D. Challenge to the constitutionality of the 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts ......................................................... 29 E. History of discordance with Azeez Basha ................... 37 II. Contentions of the parties ................................................. 41 III. Issues for determination .................................................... 45 IV. Analysis .............................................................................. 47 F. Issue I: What are the requisite parameters of reference to a larger bench? ....................................................... 47 G. Issue II: Whether the Appellant has the locus standi to bring the present challenge? .................................. 55 H. Issue III: What are the tests to seek protection under Article 30? ................................................................... 62 I. Issue IV: What is the meaning of ‘establish’ in Art. 30? .......................................................................... 66 J. Issue V: What is the meaning of ‘administer’ in Article 30? ............................................................................... 84 K. Issue VI: Whether the Union of India is obligated to defend the AMU Amendment Act, 1981? .................... 90 V. Areas of divergence .............................................................. 91 VI. Conclusion ........................................................................... 100
1. A three-judge bench presided over by the then Chief Justice of India vide order dated 12.02.2019, passed in Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal,1 (2019 Reference Order) made this reference to a Bench of Seven Judges, with a view to:
** Ed. Note: Pagination as per the original Judgment.
1 Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal (2020) 13 SCC 737. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1763Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. i. To determine the correctness of the question arising from the decision of this Court in S. Azeez Basha v. Union of India,2 which had ruled against the minority status sought to be accorded to the Aligarh Muslim University (AMU).
ii. To determine question 3(a) formulated in TMA Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka,3 which postulates that:
“Q. 3. (a) What are the indicia for treating an educational institution as a minority educational institution? Would an institution be regarded as a minority educational institution because it was established by a person(s) belonging to a religious or linguistic minority or its being administered by a person(s) belonging to a religious or linguistic minority? This question need not be answered by this Bench, it will be dealt with by a regular Bench.”; and iii. Whether the decision of this Court in Prof. Yashpal v. State of Chhattisgarh,4 and the amendment in 2010 to the National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions Act, 2004 (NCMEI Act) have any bearing on the aforesaid questions formulated?
2. The fulcrum of this reference revolves around the interpretation of Article 30 of the Constitution of India, which deals with the right of minorities to set up educational institutions. We have had the benefit of perusing the erudite opinion authored by Hon’ble the Chief Justice Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud. While the said opinion comprehensively addresses each issue with depth and clarity, we have expressed a differing view on the interpretation of certain aspects, given the significant constitutional implications involved. Recognizing the weight of these issues, we have chosen to offer our own perspective, though we acknowledge the thoroughness and diligence with which Hon’ble the Chief Justice has approached this complex matter.
3. Before we lay down the indicia under Article 30 to determine whether an institution has a minority character and ought to be afforded protection, we deemed it appropriate to embark on a substantive 2 S. Azeez Basha v. Union of India [1968] 1 SCR 833 3 TMA Pai Foundation v. State of Karnataka (2002) 8 SCC 481, para 18. 4 Prof. Yashpal and Anr. v. State of Chhattisgarh and Ors. (2005) 5 SCC 420 1764 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports analysis of the issues involved, and will begin by undertaking a comprehensive examination of the multifaceted nature of minority rights, both in India and internationally.
I. B ackground A. History of minority rights
4. The basis of defining the term ‘minorities’ and bestowing associated rights on them have varied significantly across different eras and regions. Indicators such as religion, nationality, ethnicity, and race frequently emerge as markers of minority status across the world. In contrast, the Indian perspective on minorities is broadly categorized as religious and linguistic minorities.
A.1. Global history of minority rights
5. The idea of minority rights can generally be traced back to the ‘Peace of Westphalia’, a set of treaties concluded in the mid-17th century, which sought to give rights to certain religious minorities in newly ceded territories post-war.5 Hence, globally, the concept of minority rights broadly emerged along the fault lines of religion.
6. However, the focus on religion changed subsequently with the rise of nationalism in Europe. Since national identities emerged as the primary means of distinguishing insiders from outsiders, the concept of minorities in different instruments—such as the 1815 Final Act of Congress of Vienna—was defined in terms of national groups.6
7. As national identities began to take shape, the notion of minority rights became increasingly intertwined with the quest for international legitimacy. By the time of the 1878 Congress of Berlin, the question of minorities had become a crucial factor in the emergence of new nation-states beyond Western Europe. These States, requiring international recognition, were accordingly required to demonstrate a willingness to comply with a ‘standard of 5 Jennifer Jackson Preece, “Minority rights in Europe: from Westphalia to Helsinki” Review of International Studies (1997), Vol. 23, pp. 75–92; Joseph B. Kelly, “National Minorities in International Law”, Denv. J. Int’l L. &Pol’y, (1973) Vol. 3, pp. 253; Liebich, Andre. “Minority as Inferiority: Minority Rights in Historical Perspective” Review of International Studies, (2008) Vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 243–63. 6 Ibid.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1765Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. civilization’, which included the protection of minority rights.7 This was not merely a moral obligation but a strategic tool for gaining acceptance within the global community. Nations such as Greece, for example, were compelled by powers like France, Great Britain, and Russia to uphold minority rights as a condition for their recognition and support.8
8. This momentum of bestowing rights to minorities continued to gain further traction across Europe. For instance, Hungary’s Parliament first proclaimed minority rights in July 1849,9 followed by their formal codification into Austrian law in 1867. Similarly, Belgium joined the movement in 1898. Although this era did not achieve universal respect for minority rights, it marked a pivotal shift, with these categories of rights increasingly taking centre stage in international negotiations and settlements, particularly in the aftermath of conflicts.
9. The mid-19th century also witnessed the gradual upliftment of historically-oppressed groups, such as the African-Americans, who constituted the largest minority in the United States. The American Civil War of the 1860s culminated in the issuance of the Emancipation Proclamation by Abraham Lincoln in 1863. This landmark decree effectively abolished slavery and guaranteed freedom to all African- Americans. This progress was further bolstered by the 14th Amendment of 1868, which granted various civil rights to all citizens.10
10. This trajectory of liberation extended into the early 20th century, with the League of Nations making the establishment of a minority state system one of its key priorities. The new Nation-States that emerged in East-Central Europe post-1919 were so ethnographically diverse that recognising minority rights became essential. The victorious powers understood that ethnic dissatisfaction with the territorial status quo could potentially escalate into domestic and even international violence. Thus,the rights of minorities became a prerequisite for 7 G. Gong, “The Standard of Civilization in International Society” Oxford University Press, (1984). 8 Greece Liberated– London Protocol, (United Kingdom, France & Russia) (adopted on 03 February, 1830). 9 Mazohl, Brigitte, ‘‘Equality among the Nationalities’ and the Peoples (Volksstämme) of the Habsburg Empire”, Constitutionalism, Legitimacy, and Power: Nineteenth-Century Experiences Chapter 9, Oxford University Press (2014).
10 Holloway, Jonathan Scott, “Civilization, race, and the politics of uplift”, African American History: A Very Short Introduction, Chapter 4, (Oxford University Press) (2023). 1766 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports independence, as well as a condition for war reparations or admission into the League of Nations. A notable example is the Polish Minority Treaties of 1918, which granted special and presumably temporary rights in areas such as education, allowing minorities to read and learn their preferred languages.11
11. The growing significance of minority rights during this period is further exemplified by several cases before the Permanent Court of International Justice (PCIJ). In a 1923 case of the Rights of Minorities in Upper Silesia, the PCIJ affirmed that individuals should have the autonomy to decide their minority affiliation.12 Similarly, in the 1930 Greco-Bulgarian communities case, the PCIJ emphasized the rights of minorities to uphold and preserve their traditions, clarifying that a ‘community’ under the subject-Convention referred to a group united by race, religion, language, and traditions, and that such a community could possess property distinct from any individual comprising it.13 Further, in Minority Schools in Albania, decided in 1935, the PCIJ explored the interrelation between minority status and cultural identity while addressing the religious and educational autonomy enjoyed by the Greek communities of Albania.14 The PCIJ concluded that the essence of minority treaties was to ensure de facto equality for minorities, thus enabling them to maintain their cultural distinctiveness through a specialized minority regime.
12. In this manner, the historical development of minority rights from the 16th to 20th centuries illustrates a progressively advancing standard of rights accorded to these groups. Initially, minority status was primarily defined by religious affiliation; however, over time, nationality and linguistic identity became key criteria. This evolution reflects a broader international understanding of minority groups. There have been instances where the dominant majority has also actively sought to empower these minorities, highlighting the complex interplay between oppression and advocacy throughout history.
11 Treaty of Peace with Poland [Polish Minorities Treaty], (adopted on 28 June 1919). 12 Rights of Minorities in Upper Silesia (Germ. v. Pol.), 1928 P.C.I.J. (ser. A) No. 15 (Apr. 26) (Permanent Court of International Justice).
13 Greco-Bulgarian “Communities”, Advisory Opinion, PCIJ Series B. No 17 (Permanent Court of International Justice, 1928).
14 Minority Schools in Albania, Advisory Opinion, PCIJ Series A/B no 64, ICGJ 314 (Permanent Court of International Justice, 1935).
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1767Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. A.2. Minority rights in India
13. The trailing analysis put forth hereinabove sets the context to hereafter understand the Indian experience with minority rights. However, any discussion of minority rights in India must begin with appreciating its unique and vibrant nature,characterized by its rich mosaic of cultures, religions, and languages.
14. As a melting pot of cultures, India is home to a diverse array of different communities. One such example is the Parsis, who came to India from Persia—escaping persecution by the then Arab conquerors—and have since established themselves as one of the most prosperous communities in India.15 Another important minority is the Sikhs, who follow Sikhism, which “is believed to be a deep synthesis of divine virtues, ceaseless, remembrance, relentless service of mankind, equality of mind, and ephemeral nature of the world besides the defiance of tyranny and fighting for righteousness”.16 These instances, among others, provide ample historical evidence supporting India’s tradition of tolerance, as embodied in the notion of ‘Vasudeva Kutumbakam’,17 where all communities have flourished and seamlessly integrated into Indian culture.
15. It was only with the advent of British rule in India that longstanding religious, caste, linguistic and regional ethnic tribal entities that had existed in India for centuries began to receive renewed scrutiny.18 The late 19th century, particularly after the Revolt of 1857, saw an increasing incorporation of Indians into the colonial government. This increasing inclusion of Indians in British institutions forced imperialists to address how Indians were to be represented, leading to the concept of group-based representation.19 They were initially defined by religious terms—evident in the first Indian Census of 1872, which classified Indians by religion—the representation later expanded to include caste and racial categories. Subsequent censuses further 15 Dosabhoy Framjee, “History of the Parsis: including their manners, customs, religion and present position” Volume 2, Discovery Publishing House, (1986). 16 Sehajdhari Sikh Federation v. Union of India and others, 2011 SCC Online P&H 17374. 17 Justice R. A. Jahagirdar (Retd.), “Secularism: the Road Behind and the Road Ahead,” Secularism: Collected Works, Rationalist Foundation, pp. 9.
18 Rochana Bajpai, “Debating Difference: Group Rights and Liberal Democracy in India, Oxford University Press, (2011).
19 Ibid.
1768 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports sought to amalgamate oppressed castes of India into a single all-India category of ‘Depressed Classes’.20 A.2.1. The concept of linguistic minorities
16. History indicates that during the British Rule, Hindi was sought to be projected as the language of the majority community.21 In this vein, the British decided to introduce the permissive use of the Devanagari script in the Courts of the North-Western Provinces and Oudh, with a view to undermine the influence of the Mughal elites.22 From the late 19th century onwards, there seemed to be murmurs against the perceived imposition of Hindi language, in regions where other languages were spoken. These concerns were endeavoured to be redressed by reorganising and carving out new States, predominantly on linguistic considerations, such as, for instance, the division of the States of Bihar and Odisha.23
17. The reorganization of the States based on linguistic differences gained momentum with the appointment of the Indian Statutory Commission, and subsequently,in April 1938, when a resolution was passed by the Madras Legislative Assembly, unsuccessfully recommending the establishment of four new Provinces from the former Madras Presidency. Ultimately, the States Reorganisation Act, 1956 enabled the division of States on a linguistic basis, aligning administrative boundaries with the linguistic identities of the population.
A.2.2. The concept of religious minorities
18. In addition to linguistic minorities, the question of rights and privileges for religious minorities also gained prominence. The genesis of this category of minority rights in India can be traced back to the 1909 Morley-Minto Constitutional Reforms, which introduced separate electorates and reserved quotas to protect the interests of one of 20 Sumit Mukherjee, “Conceptualisation and Classification of Caste and Tribe by the Census of India,” Journal of the Anthropological Survey of India, (2013), Vol. 62 no. 2 pp.807. 21 Tariq Rahman, “Punjabi Language during British Rule,” International Journal of Punjab Studies (2007). 22 Amit Ranjan, “How Hindi came to dominate India” The Diplomat, (06 May, 2017) available at https:// thediplomat.com/2017/05/how-hindi-came-to-dominate-india/. 23 Fazal Ali, Report of the States Reorganisation Committee (1955), available at https://www.mha.gov.in/ sites/default/files/State%20Reorganisation%20Commisison%20Report%20of%201955_270614.pdf. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1769Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. the minority communities within the evolving political framework.24 Following this development, the British government extended similar provisions to other communities, as well as the Depressed Classes, thereby institutionalizing measures for their representation and protection.25
19. Subsequently, political organisations seeking to leverage the 1919 Montagu-Chelmsford reforms played a crucial role in consolidating minority identities.26 The principle that eventually emerged for Indian representation in colonial institutions was that minority groups should be represented in proportion to their population size.27 The primary demand of these groups was to secure safeguards against potential dominance by the Congress or the majority community in Indian politics.
20. The 1928 Simon Commission further solidified the foundation of minority rights by recommending the continuation of separate electorates.28 At the same time, the 1928 Nehru Report, which influenced the framing of a Constitution for India, laid great emphasis on the safeguards of minorities.29 However, in a significant departure from the 1916 Lucknow Pact,30 the Committee rejected the Muslim League’s demands for separate electorates, noting that communal protection was no longer necessary for Hindus and Muslims.31
21. Historical events reveal that after the failure of Round Table Conference of 1930 and 1932, the Colonial Government firstly proposed the Communal Award followed by the Government of India Act, 1935, which was the last major colonial constitutional exercise prior to Independence. This Act reserved seats in Provincial Legislatures for 24 Meetika Srivastava, “Evolution of the System of Public Administration in India from the Period 1858- 1950: A Detailed Study Highlighting the Major Landmarks in Administrative History Made During this Period” (2009), available at https://ssrn.com/abstract=1482528. 25 Dick Kooiman, “Communalism and Indian Princely States: A Comparison with British India” Economic and Political Weekly (1995) Vol. 30 No. 34 pp. 2123-2133. 26 Ibid.
27 Francesca R. Jensenius, “Mired in Reservations: The Path-Dependent History of Electoral Quotas in India” The Journal of Asian Studies (2015) Vol. 74 No. 1. 28 McMillan, Alistair, “Standing at the Margins: Representation and Electoral Reservations in India” Oxford University Press (2005).
29 Ibid.
30 Owen, Hugh “Negotiating the Lucknow Pact”, Journal of Asian Studies, (1972) Vol. 31 No. 3 pp. 561–87. 31 Proceedings of the Indian Round Table Conference (12th November, 1930–19th January, 1931). 1770 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a total of thirteen communal and socio-economic categories.32 The 1940s then witnessed intense political debates centred on the ‘minority question,’with various parties negotiating the extent of concessions to be granted to minority communities.33 A.2.3. Deliberations by the Constituent Assembly of India
22. The developments of the last few decades of British rule in India vis-à-vis minority rights directly contributed to the discussions in the Constituent Assembly Debates and the formalisation of safeguards for minorities within the Indian Constitution.34 In fact, it strengthened the belief of the makers of the Indian Constitution that the Indian State must be formally committed to protecting the distinct cultural, linguistic and religious practices of various communities.35
23. Thus, to streamline the complex task of drafting the Indian Constitution, the Constituent Assembly decided to work through specialized committees. Among these, the Advisory Committee on Fundamental Rights, Minorities, etc., was formed under the leadership of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, having proportional representation from all major minority groups.36 Given the broad mandate of this Committee, it was further divided into five Sub-Committees, one of which was the Minorities Sub-Committee, chaired by Dr. H.C. Mookherjee, a prominent Christian leader.37
24. Soon after, the Advisory Committee prepared the ‘Report on Minority Rights’, which recommended that elections to all legislatures be conducted on the basis of joint electorates, with reservations for specified minorities.38 Additionally, the Report also proposed reservation in recruitment for minorities. The Report further incorporated suggestions for establishing Constitutional and Administrative mechanisms to address the challenges faced by minorities in India. 32 Rochana Bajpai, supra note 18.
33 Krishna, K.B., The Problem of Minorities in India or Communal Representation in India, G. Allen and Unwin, (1939).
34 Rochana Bajpai, “Constituent Assembly Debates and Minority Right” Economic and Political Weekly, (2000) Vol. 35 No. 21-22.
35 Ibid.
36 Navin Pal Singh, Dr. Balvinder Singh Slathia, “Intricacies of Educational and Cultural Rights of Minorities in India: Efficacy of Constitutional Safeguards” UGC Care Journal (2020) Vol. 43, no.4. 37 Ibid.
38 Rochana Bajpai, supra note 18.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1771Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
25. The discussions on the Draft Constitution, initiated by Dr. Ambedkar on 21.02.1948,intended to give special attention to minority rights.39 This then led to the insertion of ‘Special Provisions Relating to Minorities’ (Part XIV – Articles 292 to 301) into the Draft Constitution. This was in addition to the protections granted to all citizens under the Chapter of Fundamental Rights.40 The proposed Part XIV instead intended to provide political reservations for Muslims, Indian-Christians, Anglo-Indians, Scheduled Castes, and Scheduled Tribes. Additionally, it envisioned special protection for Anglo-Indians with respect to educational institutions and also addressed minority claims in the realm of public recruitment.41 Finally, it sought to include administrative checks to ensure the effective implementation and functioning of these constitutional safeguards.
26. However, these provisions sought to be incorporated under Part XIV were short-lived. The harsh realities of the communal violence following the partition of the Indian subcontinent into India and Pakistan greatly impacted one and all. The conflicts, violence, exploitation, general public disorder and lawlessness during the migration exercise resulted in the deaths of almost one million people, with an estimated displacement of approximately ten to twenty million people.42
27. Naturally, the aftermath of these events sent shock waves throughout the country. It profoundly affected the Constituent Assembly and the Drafting Committee, particularly in regard to the recognition of communal minority rights.43 Prior to the Partition, the Assembly had granted religious reservations in legislative bodies. However, these reservations were done away with post-Partition.44 The prevailing sentiment was that such measures could foster separatist tendencies and were inconsistent with the principles of a Secular Democratic State. This view was also supported by various Muslim members of the 39 Rochana Bajpai, supra note 34.
40 Kamlesh Kumar Wadhwa, Minority Safeguards in India, Thomas Press (India) Limited, (1975). 41 Ibid.
42 “Partition of 1947 Continues to Haunt India, Pakistan” Stanford Report(2019) available at https://news. stanford.edu/stories/2019/03/partition-1947-continues-haunt-india-pakistan-stanford-scholar-says. 43 B Shiva Rao (ed), The Framing of India’s Constitution, Vol. I-V, Indian Institute of Public Administration, (1967).
44 Ibid.
1772 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Constituent Assembly.45 For instance, Mohammad Ismail Khan stated:46 “[…] Because this reservation of seats would only keep alive Communalism and would be ineffectual as a safeguard for the Muslim minorities or for the matter of that for any other minorities. I congratulate the majority community, that they have not taken advantage of their superiority in numbers, by utilising this device for their own purposes. The Muslims have been thinking for some time that this reservation was wholly incompatible with responsible Government and I may say that when Provincial autonomy was introduced in the provinces for the first time the Muslims soon began to realize the separate representation was not going to be an effective safeguard for the protection of their interests […]”
[Emphasis supplied]
28. Similarly, Tajamul Hussain also emphatically voiced:47 “Mr. President, Sir, reservation of seats in any shape or form and for any community or group of people is, in my opinion, absolutely wrong in principle. Therefore I am strongly of opinion that there should be no reservation of seats for anyone and I, as a Muslim, speak for the Muslims. There should be no reservation of seats for the Muslim community. (Hear, Hear). I would like to tell you that in no civilised country where there is parliamentary system on democratic lines, there is any reservation of seats. […]”
[Emphasis supplied]
29. Eventually, the Constituent Assembly dropped the proposals to grant varied rights to linguistic and religious minorities, and retained only 45 Christina George, “Begum Aizaz Rasul: The only Muslim Woman to oppose minority reservations in the Constituent Assembly” The Indian Express, (14 February, 2018), available at https://indianexpress. com/article/gender/begum-aizaz-rasul-the-only-muslim-woman-to-oppose-minority-reservations-in-theconstituent-assembly-5057096/.
46 Constituent Assembly Debate, Speech by Mohammad Ismail Khan, (26 May 1949). 47 Constituent Assembly Debate, Speech by Tajamul Hussain, (26 May 1949). [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1773Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Articles 29 and 30 to assuage their concerns. These two Fundamental Rights under Part III nonetheless represent a watershed moment in the jurisprudence of minority rights worldwide.
B. The Constitutional scheme
30. The majority of minority rights within the Indian Constitution are encapsulated in Part III under the sub-section on ‘Cultural and Educational Rights’. This section includes: (i) the right of any section of citizens with a distinct language, script, or culture to conserve the same under Article 29; and (ii) the right of linguistic and religious minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice under Article 30.
31. This focus on cultural and educational rights does not diminish the broader protections offered by the Constitution, which includes positive discrimination and affirmative action. Notable amongst these are Articles 15 and 16, which provide reservations to ensure equality of opportunity, and Articles 25 to 28, for the safeguard of religious freedoms. In addition, Articles 350A and 350B were incorporated shortly after independence in 1956 to further protect linguistic minorities. These provisions established administrative shields to support language rights and ensure their preservation within the broader framework of the Indian State.
32. Given this context, Article 29 protects linguistic minorities and their right to conserve their languages,and Article 30 bestows positive rights to religious and linguistic minorities,allowing them to establish and administer educational institutions. These provisions read as follows:
“29. Protection of interests of minorities.—
(1) Any section of the citizens residing in the territory of India or any part thereof having a distinct language, script or culture of its own shall have the right to conserve the same.
(2) No citizen shall be denied admission into any educational institution maintained by the State or receiving aid out of State funds on grounds only of religion, race, caste, language or any of them.”
1774 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “30. Right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions.—
(1) All minorities, whether based on religion or language, shall have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice.
(1A) In making any law providing for the compulsory acquisition of any property of any educational institution established and administered by a minority, referred to in clause (1), the State shall ensure that the amount fixed by or determined under such law for the acquisition of such property is such as would not restrict or abrogate the right guaranteed under that clause.
(2) The State shall not, in granting aid to educational institutions, discriminate against any educational institution on the ground that it is under the management of a minority, whether based on religion or language.”
33. Other provisions in the Constitution of India,such as Article 19, for instance, also provide a similar freedom to establish educational institutions. However, the distinguishing and unique nature of Article 30 lies in its broader protection against State intervention. The interplay of these Articles has been thoroughly examined by an eleven-judge bench of this Court in TMA Pai (supra):
“18. With regard to the establishment of educational institutions, three articles of the Constitution come into play. Article 19(1)(g) gives the right to all the citizens to practise any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business; this right is subject to restrictions that may be placed under Article 19(6). Article 26 gives the right to every religious denomination to establish and maintain an institution for religious purposes, which would include an educational institution. Article 19(1)(g) and Article 26, therefore, confer rights on all citizens and religious denominations to establish and maintain educational institutions. There was no serious dispute that the majority community as well as linguistic and religious minorities would have a right under Articles 19(1)(g) and 26 to establish educational institutions. In addition, Article 30(1), [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1775Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. in no uncertain terms, gives the right to the religious and linguistic minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice.”
34. The distinction between broader rights such as Article 19 and Article 30, is thus clearly visible. Though Article 19 grants all citizens the right to establish institutions, it does not indemnify these institutions from State intervention in their administration and allows reasonable restrictions in the interests of the public. In contrast, Article 30 provides a specific right for religious minorities to establish and administer educational institutions without significant State interference. Additionally, whereas Articles 25 to 28 grant general rights to religious denominations, Article 30 specifically protects the rights of religious minorities.
B.1. Relevant case laws on the interpretation of Article 30
35. While the judicial interpretation of the scope and nuances of Article 30 will be discussed later in relevant parts of the judgement, a brief note of the landmark edicts that have been enumerated on this provision can be laid out. Over the course of several decades, through multiple judicial pronouncements and interpretations, the Supreme Court has held that the right provided under Article 30 is not absolute. An eleven-judge bench in TMA Pai (supra) and a seven-judge bench in P.A. Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra,48 have held that while the minority community possesses the right to administer the educational institutions, the State may impose reasonable regulations for the benefit of these institutions. Similarly, five-judge benches in Islamic Academy of Education v. State of Karnataka49 and St. Stephen’s College v. University of Delhi50 have held that the State can prescribe general rules regarding merit in admissions. This view was seconded in Secy., Malankara Syrian Catholic College v. T. Jose,51 which held that general regulations regarding service conditions of employees could also be imposed.
48 P.A. Inamdar v. State of Maharashtra (2005) 6 SCC 537. 49 Islamic Academy of Education and Anr. v. State of Karnataka and Ors. (2003) 6 SCC 697. 50 St. Stephen’s College v. University of Delhi (1992) 1 SCC 558. 51 Secy., Malankara Syrian Catholic College v. T. Jose & Ors. (2007) 1 SCC 386. 1776 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
36. In that sense, several judicial pronouncements have sought to explain the scope of Article 30 and clarify the extent of the protection granted.
B.2. Statutory Scheme
37. Apart from constitutional guarantees and rights, the Indian Parliament has also adopted several legislations to protect the rights of minorities. The National Commission for Minorities was established as a statutory body under the aegis of the National Commission for Minorities Act, 1992. Section 9(1) of the Act mandates the Commission to perform various functions, including, but not limited to, monitoring the implementation of safeguards for minorities, as provided in the Constitution, and laws enacted by Parliament and State Legislatures. The Commission is also responsible for making recommendations to the Central and State Governments for the effective implementation of these safeguards to protect minority interests. Additionally, it is tasked with addressing specific complaints regarding the deprivation of minority rights and safeguards and addressing such matters with the appropriate authorities.
38. A significant development which flows from Article 30 is also the enactment of the NCMEI Act,which governs minority educational institutions. The NCMEI Act was enacted in 2005 to, inter alia, engender the rights of a minority educational institution to seek recognition as an affiliated college to a Scheduled University and to provide a forum for dispute resolution. In this manner, the NCMEI Act gave greater credence to Article 30 and aided its efficient implementation.
39. In 2006, the NCMEI Act was amended, and the scope of the Commission was expanded further. In addition to protecting the rights of minority educational institutions, the Commission was now endowed with the power to determine and declare whether an institution is a minority institution. Under Section 2(f), minorities have been defined in the NCMEI Act as: “a community notified as such by the Central Government.” Employing this definition, the Central Government has so far notified Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, Buddhists, Parsis and Jains as minority communities.52 52 Ministry of Human Resource Development, No. F.7-5/2005-MC(P) (Notified on 18 January, 2005) [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1777Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
40. Having examined the development of minority rights, as well as the Constitutional and Statutory scheme, it is pertinent at this juncture, to briefly touch upon the history of AMU and analyze the events leading to the instant matter.
C. Brief history of AMU
41. The history of AMU begins after the founding of the Muhammaden Anglo-Oriental (MAO) College at Aligarh in 1875 by Sir Syed Ahmad Khan. It seems that by the year 1895, MAO College had begun to experience considerable decline. It faced governmental pressure to increase student fees and make examinations more difficult, leading to a decrease in student enrolment and endowments.53 The death of Sir Syed in 1898 further intensified the situation, creating a sense of distrust among the benefactors of the college and a power vacuum.54
42. History further suggests that in 1898, the Sir Syed Memorial Fund was created with the goal of raising funds to pay off the debts of the College and to create an endowment to establish a university. The then Lieutenant Governor of the North-Western Provinces is said to have promised aid and support in the management of the College, provided that there was a stable governing body for the same directly under government supervision. The record further indicates that, by 1903, the fund collection drive had raised enough money to meet the College’s needs and restore its stability.55
43. At the ‘All India Muhammadan Educational Conference’ in Calcutta, the idea of establishing a university in Aligarh sparked significant deliberations and gained momentum. Some proposed a pan-India, affiliating university,56 while others advocated for a available at https://www.education.gov.in/sites/upload_files/mhrd/files/Notification18012005.pdf; Ministry of Minority Affairs, S.O. 267(E) (Notified on 27 January, 2014) available at https://ncm.nic.in/legislations/ Gazette_JainInclusion_27Jan2014.pdf.
53 Theodore Beck, “The Principal’s Annual Report for 1898—99” (‘Principal’s Report), (1898—99), Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College Magazine (Aligarh) (MAOCM), and Aligarh Institute Gazette (Aligarh) (AIG), New Series VII, No. 11 (15 July 1899) (At this time the two journals were temporarily merged).
54 Shamim Akhtar, “Aligarh: From College to University” Proceedings of the Indian History Congress (2018-19) Vol. 79, pp. 623.
55 Muhammadan Anglo-Oriental College Magazine (Aligarh) MAOCM, VII, (January 1899), pp. 15-21. 56 Rafiuddin Ahmad, ‘The Proposed Muslim University in India’, The Nineteenth Century, XLIV (1898), 915-21.
1778 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports university completely in line with Muslim ideals, with mandatory religious instruction and administration in consonance with Islamic principles.57
44. However, nothing tangible happened on the ground level for multifarious reasons. In early 1910, efforts to establish a university at Aligarh resurfaced. Once the requisite funds had been collected, a committee was established to draft the constitution for the proposed university, designating the Viceroy as the chancellor and placing governance in the hands of a Muslim Court of Trustees. The matter of affiliation was cursorily mentioned only in the context of the powers of approval by various authorities. Finally, after long drawn-out negotiations between relevant stakeholders, in September 1920, the Aligarh Muslim University Act, 1920 (AMU Act, 1920) was passed by the Central Legislature of British India.
C.1. Features of the AMU Act, 1920
45. The AMU Act, 1920 which came into force with effect from 29.07.1920, comprising 40 sections and 23 statutes, was a comprehensive piece of legislation that meticulously regulated various aspects of AMU. The Statement of Objects and Reasons accompanying the Act clearly articulated its purpose: “to incorporate this University, to indicate its functions, to create its governing bodies and to define their functions.” In essence, the AMU Act, 1920 was focused on establishing the University and making it operational by setting up its Governing Bodies and outlining their respective functions.
46. Broadly, there were four important Governing Bodies, i.e., the Executive Council, the Academic Council, the Court, and other Officers such as the Lord Rector, Vice Chancellor, Pro-Vice Chancellor, etc
47. Without expressing any opinion on the interpretation of its provisions or the legislative policy of the AMU Act, 1920,we deem it fit to encapsulate some relevant provisions.
48. In this light, the role and authority of the Lord Rector was delineated in Section 13, which states as follows:
57 Theodore Beck, supra note 53; MAOCM and AIG, supra note 53. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1779Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. “13. (1) The Governor General shall be the Lord Rector of the University.
(2) The Lord Rector shall have the right to cause an inspection to be made by such person or persons as he may direct, of the University, its buildings, laboratories, and equipment, and of any institution maintained by the University, and also of the examinations, teaching and other work conducted or done by the University, and to cause an inquiry to be made in like manner in respect of any matter connected with the University. The Lord Rector shall, in every case, give notice to the University of his intention to cause an inspection or inquiry to be made and the University shall be made entitled to be represented thereat.
(3) The Lord Rector may address the Vice-Chancellor with reference to the result of such inspection and inquiry, and the Vice-Chancellor shall communicate to the Court the views of the Lord Rector with such advice as the Lord Rector may be pleased to offer upon the action to be taken thereon.
(4) The Court shall communicate through the Vice- Chancellor to the Lord Rector such action, if any, as it is proposed to take or has been taken upon the result of such inspection or inquiry.
(5) Where the Court does not, within reasonable time, take action to the satisfaction of the Lord Rector, the Lord Rector may, after considering any explanation furnished or representation made by the Court issue such directions as he may think fit, and the Court shall comply with such directions.”
49. Similarly, the authority and responsibility of the AMU Court was stated under Section 23:
“23. (1) The Court shall consist of the Chancellor, the Pro-Chancellor and the Vice Chancellor for the, time being, and such other persons as may be specified in the Statutes:
Provided that no person other than a Muslim shall be a member thereof.
1780 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(2) The Court shall be the supreme governing body of the University and shall have the power to review the acts of the Executive and the Academic Councils (save where such Councils have acted in accordance with powers conferred on them under this Act, the Statutes or the Ordinances) and shall exercise all the powers of the University not otherwise provided for by this Act, the Statutes and the Ordinances and the Regulations.
(3) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the Court shall exercise the following powers and perform the following duties, namely:—
(a) of making Statutes and of amending or repealing the same;
(b) of considering Ordinances;
(c) of considering and passing resolutions on the annual report, the annual accounts and the financial estimates;
(d) of electing such persons to serve on the authorities of the University and of appointing such officers as may be prescribed by this Act or the Statutes; and
(e) of exercising such other powers and perform such other duties as may be conferred or imposed upon it by this Act or the Statutes.”
50. The Executive Council, under Section 24, was touted to be the executive body of the University. With its constitution, term of office of members and powers and duties prescribed by the AMU Statutes. Similarly, the Academic Council, being the academic body of AMU, would have the control and general regulation and be responsible for the maintenance of standards of instruction and for the education, examination, discipline and health of students, apart from the conferment of degrees.
51. The power to make the AMU Statutes was set out in the following manner under Section 27:
“27. Subject to the provisions of this Act, the Statutes may provide for all or any of the following matters, namely: - [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1781Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
(a) The conferment of honorary degrees and the appointment of Patrons, Vice-patrons and Rectors;
(b) The institution of Fellowships, Scholarships, Exhibitions, Medals and Prizes;
(c) The terms of office, and the method and conditions of appointment of the officers of the University;
(d) The designations and powers of officers of the University;
(e) The constitution, powers and duties of the authorities of the University;
(f) The classification and mode of appointment of teachers of the University;
(g) The institution and maintenance of Halls;
(h) The constitution of Provident and Pension Funds for the benefit of the officers, teachers and servants of the University;
(i) The maintenance of a register of registered graduates;
(j) The instruction of Muslim students in the Muslim religion and theology;
(k) The establishment of Intermediate colleges and schools; and
(l) All matters which by this Act are to be or may be prescribed by Statutes.”
52. In similar parlance, the power to make Ordinances was incorporated within Section 29:
“29. Subject to the provisions of this Act and the Statutes, the Ordinances may provide for all or any of the following matters namely: -
(a) The courses of study to be laid down for all degrees, diplomas and certificates of the University;
(b) The conditions of the award of fellowships, scholarships, studentships, exhibitions, medals and prizes;
1782 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(c) The conditions under which students may be admitted to the degree or diploma courses and to the examinations of the University and shall be eligible for degrees and diplomas;
(d) The admission of students to the University;
(e) The terms of office and terms and management of appointment and duties of Examining Bodies, Examiners, and Moderators and the conduct of examinations;
(f) The conditions of residence of students of the University, and the levying of fees for residence in Halls;
(g) The conditions under which women may be exempted from attendance at lectures and tutorial classes;
(h) The fees to be charged for courses of study in the University and for admission to the examinations, degrees, and diplomas of the University;
(i) The maintenance of discipline among the students of the University;
(j) The regulation and management of any Intermediate colleges and schools maintained under Section 12; and
(k) All matters which by this Act or the Statutes are to be or may be provided for by the Ordinances.”
C.2. Features of the 1951 Amendment Act
53. With the dawn of independence, the AMU Act was amended in 1951 through Act No. LXII of 1951 (1951 Amendment Act). A significant change was the replacement of the Lord Rector, previously held by the Governor General, with the position of ‘Visitor’.At that time,the term ‘Governor General’ had pertinently been substituted by ‘President of India’ vide the Adaptation of Laws Order, 1950. Section 13 delineated the authority of the Visitor, and was thus amended as follows: “13. (1) The President of India shall be the Visitor of the University.
(2) The Visitor shall have the right to cause an inspection to be made by such person or persons as he may direct, [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1783Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. of the University, its buildings, laboratories, and equipment, and of any institution maintained by the University, and also of the examinations, teaching and other work conducted or done by the University, and to cause an inquiry to be made in like manner in respect of any matter connected with the University.
(2A) The Visitor shall in every case give notice to University of his intention to cause an inspection or inquiry to be made, and the University be entitled to appoint representative who shall have the right to be present and be heard at such inspection or inquiry.; and
(3) The Visitor may address the Vice-Chancellor with reference to the result of such inspection and inquiry, and the Vice-Chancellor shall communicate to the Executive Council the views of the Visitor with such advice as the Visitor may be pleased to offer upon the action to be taken thereon.
(4) The Executive Council shall communicate through the Vice-Chancellor to the Visitors such action, if any, as it is proposed to take or has been taken upon the result of such inspection or inquiry.
(5) Where the Executive Council does not, within reasonable time, take action to the satisfaction of the Visitor, the Visitor may, after considering any explanation furnished or representation made by the Executive Council issue such directions as he may think fit, and the Executive Council shall comply with such directions.
(6) Without prejudice to the foregoing provisions section, the Visitor may, by order in writing, annul any proceeding of the University which is not in conformity with this Act, the Statutes or the Ordinances: Provided that before making any such order, shall call upon the University to show cause why such an order should not be made, and, if any cause is shown within a reasonable time, shall consider the same.”
54. The AMU Court under Section 23 embodied the following: “23. (1) The Court shall consist of the Chancellor, the Pro-Chancellor and the Vice Chancellor and the Pro-Vice 1784 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Chancellor (if any) for the, time being, and such other persons as may be specified in the Statutes.
(2) The Court shall be the supreme governing body of the University and shall have the power to review the acts of the Executive and the Academic Councils (save where such Councils have acted in accordance with powers conferred on them under this Act, the Statutes or the Ordinances) and shall exercise all the powers of the University not otherwise provided for by this Act, the Statutes and the Ordinances and the Regulations.
(3) Subject to the provisions of this Act, the Court shall exercise the following powers and perform the following duties, namely:—
(a) of making Statutes and of amending or repealing the same;
(b) of considering Ordinances;
(c) of considering and passing resolutions on the annual report, the annual accounts and the financial estimates;
(d) of electing such persons to serve on the authorities of the University and of appointing such officers as may be prescribed by this Act or the Statutes; and
(e) of exercising such other powers and perform such other duties as may be conferred or imposed upon it by this Act or the Statutes.”
55. It would be relevant to also note the amendment made to Statute making power under Section 27:
“27. Subject to the provisions of this Act, the Statutes may provide for all or any of the following matters, namely:
(a) the constitution, powers and duties of the authorities of the University;
(b) the election and continuance in office of the members of the said authorities, including the continuance in office the filling of vacancies of members, and all other matters relative to those authorities for which it may be necessary or desirable to provide;
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1785Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
(c) the appointment, powers, and duties of the officers of the University;
(d) the constitution of a pension or provident fund and the establishment of an insurance scheme for the benefit of the officers, teachers and other employees of the University;
(e) the conferment of honorary degrees;
(f) the institution of fellowships, scholarships, studentships exhibitions, medals and prizes;
(g) the withdrawal of degrees, diplomas, certificates and other academic distinctions;
(h) the establishment and abolition of Faculties, Departments, Halls, Colleges and other institutions;
(i) the conditions under which Colleges and institutions. may be admitted to privileges of the University and for the withdrawal of such privileges;
(j) the establishment of High Schools and other institutions in accordance with the provisions of section 12; and all other matters which by this Act are to be or may be provided by the Statutes.”
56. Similar amendment was carried out to the Ordinance making power under Section 29, which was to the following effect:
“29. (1) Subject to the provisions of this Act and the Statutes, the Ordinances may provide for all or any of the following matters, namely:
(a) the admission of students to the University and their enrolment as such;
(b) the courses of study to be laid down for all degrees, diplomas and certificates of the University:
(c) the award of degrees, diplomas, certificates and other academic distinctions, the qualifications for the same and the means to be taken relating to the granting and obtaining of the same;
(d) the fees to be charged for courses of study in the University and for admission to the examinations, degrees, diplomas of the University; and 1786 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(e) the conditions of the award of fellowships, scholarships, studentships, exhibitions, medals and prizes;
(f) the conduct of examinations, including the terms of office and manner of appointment and the duties of examining bodies. examiners and moderators:
(g) the maintenance of discipline among the students of the University:
(h) the conditions of residence of the students of the University;
(i) the special arrangements, if any, which may be made for the residence, discipline and teaching of women students and the prescribing for them of special courses of studies;
(j) the giving of religious instruction;
(k) the emoluments and the terms and conditions of service of teachers of the University;
(l) the maintenance of High Schools and other institutions in accordance with the provisions of section 12;
(m) the supervision and inspection of Colleges and other institutions admitted to the privileges of the University under section 12A; and
(n) all other matters which by this Act or the Statutes, are to be or may be provided for by the Ordinances.
(2) The Ordinances in force immediately before the commencement. of the Aligarh Muslim University (Amendment) Act, 1951, may be amended, repealed or added to at any time by the Executive Council provided that-
(i) No ordinance shall be made affecting the conditions of residence or discipline of students except after consultation with the Academic Council;
(ii) No ordinance shall be made- (a)affecting the admission or enrolment of students or prescribing examinations to be recognised as equivalent to the University examinations, or [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1787Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. (b)affecting the conditions, mode of appointment or duties of examiners or the conduct or standard of examinations or any course of study, unless a draft of such Ordinance has been proposed by the Academic Council.
(3) The Executive Council shall not have the power to amend any draft proposed by the Academic Council under the provisions of sub section (2) but may reject the proposal or return the draft to the Academic Council for reconsideration, either in whole or in part together with any amendments which the Executive Council may suggest.
(4) Where the Executive Council has rejected the draft of Ordinance proposed by the Academic Council, the Academic Council may appeal to the Central Government and the Central Government may, by order, direct that the proposed Ordinance shall be laid before the next meeting of the Court for its approval and that pending such approval it shall have effect from such date as may be specified in the order:
Provided that if the Ordinance is not approved by the Court at such meeting, it shall cease to have effect.
(5) All Ordinances made by the Executive Council shall be submitted as soon as may be, to the Visitor and the court, and shall be considered by the Court at its next meeting and the Court shall have power, by a resolution passed by a majority of not less than two-thirds of the members voting, to cancel any Ordinance made by the Executive Council, and such Ordinance shall, from the date of such resolution. cease to have effect,
(6) The Visitor may, by order, direct that the operation of any Ordinance shall be suspended until he has had an opportunity of exercising his powers of disallowance, and any order of suspension under this sub-section shall cease to have effect on the expiration of one month from the date of such order or on the expiration of fifteen. days 1788 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports from the date of consideration of the Ordinance by the Court, whichever period expires later.
(7) The Visitor may, at any time after an Ordinance has been considered by the Court, signify to the Executive Council his dis-allowance of such Ordinance, and from the date of receipt by the Executive Council of intimation of such disallowance, such Ordinance shall cease to have effect.”
C.3. Features of the 1965 Amendment Act
57. The Act was further amended by the Act No. 19 of 1965 (1965 Amendment Act). Most significantly, it revised the powers of the Court. Section 23 was accordingly amended as follows:
“23. (1) The Court shall consist of the Chancellor, the Pro- Chancellor and such other persons as may be specified in the Statutes:
(2) The functions of the Court shall be-
(a) to advise the Visitor in respect of any matter which may be referred to the Court for advise;
(b) to advise any other authority of the University in respect of any matter;
(c) to perform other such duties and exercise such other powers as may be assigned to it by the Visitor or under this Act.”
58. Further, Section 28 was amended in terms of a shift in Statute making power:
“286. (1) The first Statutes are those set out in the Schedule.
(2) The Executive Council may make new or additional Statutes or may amend or repeal the Statutes; but every new Statute or addition to the Statutes or any amendment or repeal of a Statute shall require the previous approval of the Visitor who may sanction or disallow it or return it to the Executive Council for further consideration.”
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1789Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
59. Having now outlined the legal history of the AMU Act, 1920 as amended till 1965 and the sequence of relevant events, we now turn to the verdict rendered by the five-judge Constitution Bench in Azeez Basha (supra), which constitutes the sine qua non of the present reference.
D. Challenge to the constitutionality of the 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts
60. Shortly after the amendment in 1965, the constitutionality of the 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts was challenged before this Court, which led to the decision in Azeez Basha (supra). The constitutionality of these statutory enactments was primarily examined on the anvil of Article 30 of the Constitution of India, to determine whether AMU could fulfil the litmus test of being a minority educational institution. D.1. Contentions proffered by the parties therein D.1.1. Contentions of the Petitioners
61. Briefly, the Petitioners in Azeez Basha (supra) contended that: a. AMU was established by the Muslim minority and therefore, the Muslims had the right to administer it. Insofar as the 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts take away or abridge any part of that right, they are ultra vires Article 30(1).
b. Article 26 would not apply to educational institutions for there is a specific provision in Article 30(1) with respect to educational institutions and therefore, institutions for charitable purposes in Article 26 (a) refer to institutions other than educational ones. c. Article 14 of the Constitution was violated because the terms of the Act establishing Benares Hindu University (BHU) were not the same as the terms of the AMU Act, 1920. Further, other universities, such as Delhi, Agra, Allahabad, Patna, and Benares, have a certain elective element, unlike AMU.
d. Article 19 of the Constitution was violated because the 1965 Amendment Act deprived Muslims of their right to manage AMU and of the right to hold the property vested in AMU by the AMU Act, 1920.
1790 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports e. Vide the 1965 Amendment Act, the Muslim minority was deprived of their property, under Article 31(1), as the composition of the Court was changed from the terms of the 1920 Act.
f. The 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts violated Articles 25 and 29 of the Constitution.
D.1.2. Contentions of the Respondents
62. Conversely, the Respondents submitted that:
a. AMU was established in 1920 by the AMU Act, 1920 and this establishment was not by the Muslim minority, but by the Government of India (GoI) by virtue of a Statute. Thus, the Muslim minority could not claim any Fundamental Right to administer AMU under Article 30(1).
b. Since AMU was established by the GoI, the Parliament had the right to amend that Statute as it thought fit. There was no question of taking away the right to administer under the 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts, as the Muslim minority never had the right of administration.
c. Though the Court of AMU was to be composed entirely of Muslims, under the AMU Act, 1920, they were not given the right to administer the university. It was to be administered by the authorities established under the AMU Act, 1920.
D.2. Issues formulated
63. While this Court in Azeez Basha (supra) did not explicitly outline the issues, a plain reading of the decision reveals the following key issues that were broadly addressed:
a. Whether a ‘university’ established prior to the Constitution coming into force could be construed to be an educational institution included within the ambit of Article 30?
b. What is the meaning of the term ‘establish’ in Article 30 and whether AMU was established by the Muslim minority?
c. Whether AMU was administered by Muslims?
d. Whether the 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts were violative of other Articles contained in Part III of the Constitution? [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1791Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. D.3. Key holdings in Azeez Basha (supra)
64. In the decision of Azeez Basha (supra), the Constitution Bench adjudicated that AMU was not a minority institution for the purposes of Article 30(1) of the Indian Constitution. Since the conclusion of this case forms the bedrock of the present challenge, it is essential to discuss the key holdings of this judgment.
65. In this regard, the Court held that to be a minority institution under Article 30, such an institution must have been both established and administered by the minority community. In other words, it noted that the test provided under Article 30 is conjunctive, and an institution cannot enjoy autonomy to such an extent unless it satisfies both the prongs of establishment as well as administration by the minority community. This Court thus opined that:
“19. […] The Article in our opinion clearly shows that the minority will have the right to administer educational institutions of their choice provided they have established them, but not otherwise. The article cannot be read, to mean that even if the educational institution has been established by somebody else, any religious minority would have the right to administer it because, for some reason or other, it might have been administering it before the Constitution came into force. The words “establish and administer” in the article must be read conjunctively and so read it gives the right to the minority to administer an educational institution provided it has been established by it […]”
66. Having held so, this Court then proceeded to analyze each issue separately.
D.3.1 Whether universities established pre-Constitution could be included within the ambit of Article 30?
67. This Court in Azeez Basha (supra) firstly observed that the term ‘educational institution’ in the Constitution had a wide expanse, and that universities, which would be institutions that could confer degrees, would be covered under the wide import of this term. It further observed that though some private universities in pre- Constitution India did not have government recognition, this would 1792 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports not disentitle them from being covered under the category of an ‘educational institution’.
68. Further, relying on the decision in In re the Kerala Education Bill,58 it held that if Article 30 were to be interpreted such that it covered only educational institutions established after the coming into force of the Constitution, it would rob Article 30 of its very meaning. In this vein, it held as follows:
“19. … The words “establish and administer” in the article must be read conjunctively and so read it gives the right to the minority to administer an educational institution provided it has been established by it. In this connection our attention was drawn to In re; The Kerala Education Bill, 1957 where, it is argued, this Court had held that the minority can administer an educational institution even though it might not have established it. In that case an argument was raised that under Article 30(1) protection was given only to educational institutions established after the Constitution came into force. That argument was turned down by this Court for the obvious reason that if that interpretation was given to Article 30(1) it would be robbed of much of its content. … It is true that at p. 1062 the Court spoke of Article 30(1) giving two rights to a minority i.e. (i) to establish and (ii) to administer. But that was said only in the context of meeting [t]he argument that educational institutions established by minorities before the Constitution came into force did not have the protection of Article 30(1). We are of opinion that nothing in that case justifies the contention raised of behalf of the petitioners that the minorities would have the right to administer an educational institution even though the institution may not have been established by them. …”
[Emphasis supplied] D.3.2 What is the meaning of the term ‘establish’ and whether AMU was ‘established’ by the Muslim community?
58 In re the Kerala Education Bill, 1957,1958 SCR 995.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1793Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
69. The Court in Azeez Basha (supra) interpreted the term ‘establish’ in Article 30 to mean ‘to bring into existence.’ To determine whether AMU was established by the Muslim community, the Court examined the legal framework for the establishment of a university. It was found that prior to independence, a private individual could create a university independently, with State intervention only required for the purposes of recognition of the degree conferred. In this context, it observed that though Muslims had the option to establish a university without any state involvement, they opted for State intervention to secure degree recognition. Consequently, this Court concluded that AMU was established vide the AMU Act, 1920, which was enacted by the then Parliament. It therefore held that AMU was established by an act of the Central Legislature and not by the Muslim community: “22. There was nothing in 1920 to prevent the Muslim minority, if it so chose, to establish a university; but if it did so the degrees of such a university were not bound to be recognised by Government. It may be that in the absence of recognition of the degrees granted by a university, it may not have attracted many students, and that is why we find that before the Constitution came into force, most of the universities in India were established by legislation. […] It is clear therefore that even though the Muslim minority could have established at Aligarh in 1920 a university, it could not insist that degrees granted by such a university should be recognised by Government. Therefore, when the Aligarh University was established in 1920 and by Section 6 its degrees were recognised by Government, an institution was brought into existence which could not be brought into existence by any private individual or body for such individual or body could not insist upon the recognition of the degrees conferred by any university established by it. The enactment of Section 6 in the 1920. Act is a very important circumstance which shows that the Aligarh University when it came to be established in 1920 was not established by the Muslim minority, for the minority could not insist on the recognition by Government of the degrees conferred by any university established by it.”
1794 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “26. […] But if the M.A.O. College was to be converted into a university of the kind whose degrees were bound to be recognised by Government, it would not be possible for those who were in-charge of the M.A.O. College to do so. That is why the three institutions to which we have already referred approached the Government to bring into existence a university whose degrees would be recognised by Government. The 1920 Act was then passed by the Central Legislature and the university of the type that was established thereunder, namely, one whose degrees would be recognised by Government, came to be established.
It was clearly brought into existence by the 1920 Act for it could not have been brought into existence otherwise. It was thus the Central Legislature which brought into existence the Aligarh University and must be held to have established it. It would not be possible for the Muslim minority to establish a university of the kind whose degrees were bound to be recognised by Government and therefore it must be held that the Aligarh University was brought into existence by the Central Legislature and the Government of India. If that is so, the Muslim minority cannot claim to administer it, for it was not brought into existence by it. […]”
[Emphasis supplied] D.3.3 Whether AMU was ‘administered’ by the Muslim community?
70. This Court in Azeez Basha (supra) then examined the AMU Act, 1920 in greater detail and determined that the Act did not grant administrative control of the University to the Muslim community. It observed that members of the AMU Court were elected by individuals who made donations exceeding INR 500, a category which included non-Muslims as well. Furthermore, the Lord Rector, who was the Governor-General, held overriding powers concerning administrative matters. Additionally, various bodies, such as the Executive Council and the Academic Council, possessed significant authority over the University’s affairs. Based on this analysis, the Court concluded that AMU did not meet the administrative criteria required by Article 30 and, therefore could not be recognized as a minority institution:
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1795Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. “28. It appears from para 8 of the Schedule that even though the members of the Court had to be Muslims, the electorates were not exclusively Muslims. For example, sixty members of the Court had to be elected by persons who had made or would make donations of five hundred rupees and upwards to or for the purposes of the University. Some of these persons were and could be non-Muslims. Forty persons were to be elected by the Registered Graduates of the University, and some of the Registered Graduates were and could be non-Muslims, for the University was open to all persons of either sex and of whatever race, creed or class. Further fifteen members of the Court were to be elected by the Academic Council, the membership of which was not confined only to Muslims.”
“29. Besides there were other bodies like the Executive Council and the Academic Council which were concerned with the administration of the Aligarh University and there was no provision in the constitution of these bodies which confined their members only to Muslims. It will thus be seen that besides the fact that the members of the Court had to be all Muslims, there was nothing in the Act to suggest that the administration of the Aligarh University was in the Muslim minority as such. Besides the above, we have already referred to Section 13 which showed how the Lord Rector, namely, the Governor- General had overriding powers over all matters relating to the administration of the University. Then there was Section 14 which gave certain over-riding powers to the Visiting Board. The Lord Rector was then the Viceroy and the Visiting Board consisted of the Governor of the United Provinces, the members of his Executive Council, the Ministers, one member nominated by the Governor and one member nominated by the Minister in charge of Education. These people were not necessarily Muslims and they had overriding powers over the administration of the University. Then reference may be made to Section 28(2)(c) which laid down that no new statute or amendment or repeal of an 1796 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports existing statute, made by the University, would have any validity until it had been approved by the Governor-Generalin-Council who had power to sanction, disallow or remit it for further consideration. Same powers existed in the Governor-General-in-Council with respect to ordinances. Lastly reference may be made to Section 40, which gave power to the Governor-General-in-Council to remove any difficulty which might arise in the establishment of the University. These provisions in our opinion clearly show that the administration was also not vested in the Muslim minority; on the other hand it was vested in the statutory bodies created by the 1920 Act, and only in one of them, namely, the Court, there was a bar to the appointment of any one else except a Muslim, though even there some of the electors for some of the members included non-Muslims. We are therefore of opinion that the Aligarh University was neither established nor administered by the Muslim minority and therefore there is no question of any amendment to the 1920 Act being unconstitutional under Article 30(1) for that Article does not apply at all to the Aligarh University.”
[Emphasis supplied] D.3.4 Whether any other Articles of Part III were violated?
71. This Court analysed the 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts in consonance with other Articles enshrined in Part III of the Constitution, and arrived at the following conclusions:
a. Article 26(a) also bestows the right to ‘establish and maintain’. However, since AMU was not established by the minority, the right to maintain does not arise.
b. Article 26(c) and (d) provides the right to acquire and keep assets. However, the assets of AMU vest in the University and not in the Muslim minority, following the passing of the AMU Act, 1920.
c. Articles 25 and 29 are not affected in any manner by either of the Amendment Acts.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1797Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. d. Article 14 of the Constitution is not violated as there exists a difference in the administrative structure of one university when compared with another. This cannot be construed to be discriminative and is a matter of legislative policy.
e. The right to form associations as espoused under Article 19 is not affected by the Amendment Acts.
f. Article 31(1) is also not violated, since the property vested in AMU is not the property of the Muslim minority. It was voluntarily vested in AMU by MAO College and the Muslim University Association. The money of the Muslim University Foundation Committee was also voluntarily surrendered to the Government to facilitate the establishment of AMU through the AMU Act, 1920. Thus, at the time of coming into force of the Constitution, no right of the Muslim minority existed in property vested with AMU, and it cannot be said that the Amendments deprived the Muslim minority of the same.
E. History of discordance with Azeez Basha
72. Having analysed Azeez Basha (supra), it is imperative to also take into account the decisions proffered by this Court in other relevant cases to holistically understand the background of the reference before this Court. Post the decision in Azeez Basha (supra) came the 1972 Amendment Act vide Act No. 34 of 1972 (1972 Amendment Act), introducing several significant changes.
73. Thereupon, the first discordant note was struck by a two-judge bench of this Court in Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya v. District Inspector of Schools.59 That was a case where this Court was considering the minority status of an institution established by a society registered under the Societies Registrations Act, 1860. The question raised therein pertained to whether such registration would be determinative against the minority status of this institution. In this regard, this Court broadly formulated the following two issues for adjudication: i. Whether Article 30(1) of the Constitution envisages an institution which is established by minorities alone without the participation for the factum of establishment from any other community? 59 Anjuman-e-Rahmaniya v. District Inspector of Schools, W.P.(C) No. 54-57 of 1981. 1798 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports ii. Whether soon after the establishment of the institution if it is registered as a society under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, its status as a minority institution changes in view of the broad principles laid down in Azeez Basha (supra)?
74. The Court then doubted the correctness of Azeez Basha (supra) and referred the case to the Chief Justice for placement before a seven-judge bench, as several jurists including Mr. Seervai had expressed their doubts on the correctness of the said decision. The bench considered it appropriate, in a way, to direct constituting of a larger bench to consider the entire aspect fully.
75. The issue pertaining to the correctness of such reference made by the two-judge bench, has been dealt with greater detail in paragraphs 83 to 99 of this judgement. Almost immediately thereafter, came the 1981 Amendment Act, through Act No. 62 of 1981 (1981 Amendment Act), which finalized the current framework of the AMU Act and reversed some of the changes introduced by the 1972 Amendment Act.
76. Almost two decades after the reference in Anjuman (supra), came the magnum opus decision of the eleven-judge bench of this Court in TMA Pai (supra).In this case, the Court was tasked with analysing the different facets of Article 30, including the extent of intervention permissible by the State and the meaning of the term ‘minority’. Notably, the Court framed a question similar to the reference in Anjuman (supra) but held that the question is to be decided by a regular bench:
“Q. 3. (a) What are the indicia for treating an educational institution as a minority educational institution? Would an institution be regarded as a minority educational institution because it was established by a person(s)
belonging to a religious or linguistic minority or its being administered by a person(s) belonging to a religious or linguistic minority?
This question need not be answered by this Bench, it will be dealt with by a regular Bench.”
[Emphasis supplied] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1799Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
77. Soon thereafter, vide an order dated 11.03.2003, a two-judge bench finally disposed of the petitions that remained pending in Anjuman (supra), with the broad directions that:
“These matters are covered by the decision of a Constitution Bench of this Court in Writ Petition No. 317/1993-T.M.A. Pai Foundation & Ors. Etc. Vs. State of Karnataka & Ors. Etc. and connected batch decided on 3·1 11 October, 2002. All statutory enactments, orders, schemes, regulations will have to be brought in conformity with the decision of the Constitution Bench of this court in T.M.A. Pai Foundation’s case decided on 31.10.2002. As and when any problem arises the same can be dealt with by an appropriate Forum in an appropriate proceeding.
The Writ Petitions are disposed of according[ly].”
78. Hence, though Anjuman (supra) was disposed of, the correctness of Azeez Basha (supra) was left to be answered. Ultimately, the question of the minority status of AMU was raised again in the present batch of appeals in the 2019 Reference Order, which arose out of a challenge laid to different judgements rendered by the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad,holding that in view of Azeez Basha (supra) AMU is not a minority institution. A three-judge bench of this Court therefore examined the trajectory of judicial decisions and noted that the correctness of Azeez Basha (supra) remains undecided. This Court also noted that apart from Azeez Basha (supra), two other aspects required an authoritative pronouncement: (i) The decision in Prof. Yashpal (supra), wherein this Court had held that a private university can only be established by a separate Act or by a compendious Act where the legislature specifically provides for the establishment of the said university; and (ii) The 2010 Amendment of the NCMEI Act, prior to which, the definition of minority educational institutions excluded a university. However, the 2010 Amendment thereafter deleted this exclusion. Accordingly, for an authoritative pronouncement of these issues, the case was referred to the present seven-judge bench of this Court. The relevant part of the 2019 Reference Order is extracted below:
“8. The said facts would show that the correctness of the question arising from the decision of this Court in S. Azeez Basha (supra) has remained undetermined.
1800 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
9. That apart, the decision of this Court in Prof. Yashpal and another vs. State of Chhattisgarh and others2 and the amendment of the National Commission for Minority Educational Institutions Act, 2004 made in the year 2010 would also require an authoritative pronouncement on the aforesaid question formulated, as set out above, besides the correctness of the view expressed in the judgment of this Court in S. Azeez Basha (supra) which has been extracted above.
10. Ordinarily and in the normal course the judicial discipline would require the Bench to seek a reference of this matter by a Five Judges Bench. However, having regard to the background, as stated above, when the precise question was already referred to a Seven Judges Bench and was, however, not answered, we are of the view that the present question, set out above, should be referred to a Bench of Hon’ble Seven Judges.
11. Consequently, and in the light of the above, place these matters before the Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India on the administrative side for appropriate orders.”
79. Having understood the background of the challenge and the reference before this seven-judge bench, we shall now turn to the submissions made by the parties in support of their stance on the matter. II. contentIons of the partIes Appellant’s submissions:
80. Dr. Rajeev Dhavan, Mr. Kapil Sibal, Mr. Salman Khurshid, Mr. Nikhil Nayyar, and Mr. Shadan Farasat, Learned Senior Advocates, appeared for AMU. Their contentions are detailed hereinbelow: a. In the context of Article 30,the term ‘minority’ means a community that constitutes less than fifty percent of the population in the State where the educational institution is situated. This standard was laid down in TMA Pai (supra). Per this standard, Muslims are a minority in the State of Uttar Pradesh. Moreover, the status of Muslims as a minority was evident even before the Constitution came into force, as they were already being afforded reservation in legislative organs.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1801Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. b. To claim protection under Article 30, the minority community is only required to prove that it established the institution. The question of administration, on the other hand, is not relevant in determining the minority character of an institution. It is a right that flows once the institution is established as a minority institution, thus making it a consequence and not a pre-requisite. In other words, the test under Article 30 is not conjunctive, and the claimant is not required to necessarily prove that the institution was being administered by the minority community.
c. The word ‘establish’ should be interpreted widely since it is the only protection available to minorities. ‘Establishment’, under Article 30, is the meeting of minds of the community for the purpose of taking forward the idea that ultimately results in the university being set up. Thus, the genesis of the institution must be considered while examining the word ‘established.’ In contrast, the word ‘established’ used in the AMU Act, 1920 refers to recognition for incorporation and is not the same as the term ‘establish’ used in Article 30.
d. The term ‘administration’ does not mean cent percent control over the institution by the minority community. The State can prescribe reasonable regulations for the management of minority institutions. Administration merely requires overall control. The minority community, in this regard, has the choice to ask others to administer on their behalf.
e. Under Article 30, the term ‘establish’ requires the genesis of the institution to be linked to the minority community. AMU meets this criterion since it originated as MAO College, which was established and administered by Muslims. The desire to convert MAO College to AMU came from the Muslim community, having gathered funds from the Muslim community. Further, AMU was established with the desire of the Muslim community to have their own university. Therefore, AMU can be said to have been established by the Muslim community.
f. The establishment of AMU was an exercise completed by the Muslim community, and the AMU Act, 1920 merely conferred statutory recognition to such an establishment. It was not a creation of the Statute but was rather an acknowledgement 1802 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports by a Statute. Merely because a university was incorporated through State action cannot confer or take away from its nature, as every juristic entity is a creation of State action. g. The administration of AMU was also under the control of Muslims. All members of the AMU Court were required to be Muslims, and its powers were further strengthened by the 1981 Amendment Act. The administration, which entails overall control, remains with the Muslim community. Even if it were determined that external members had administrative roles, it would not jeopardize the university’s minority status. This is because the Muslim community retains the right to reclaim administrative control, as Fundamental Rights cannot be waived.
h. Lastly, the Union of India (UOI) cannot be allowed to challenge its own statutory enactment, i.e., 1981 Amendment Act. Such a summersault in its stance cannot be permitted merely because of a change in the political regime. Furthermore, the UOI has not substantiated the reason for such a volte-face. Thus, its approach lacks bona fides,and the UOI, particularly the Attorney General for India, is obligated to defend such an act of Parliament. Hence, it cannot take a stand against the minority status of AMU.
Respondents’ submissions:
81. Mr. R. Venkataramani, Learned Attorney General for India, Mr. Tushar Mehta, Learned Solicitor General of India, Mr. K. M. Nataraj and Mr. Vikramjit Banerjee, Learned Additional Solicitor Generals of India, Mr. Rakesh Dwivedi, Mr. N. K. Kaul, Mr. G. K. Kumar, Mr. Vinay Navare, Mr. Sridhar Potaraju and Ms. Archana P. Dave Learned Senior Advocates, appeared on behalf of the Respondents. Their arguments are detailed hereinbelow:
a. A bench of two judges could not have directly referred the matter to a bench composed of seven judges in Anjuman (supra) and as such, the reference itself ought to be construed as bad in law. Further, the reference only sought clarity on the definition of a minority institution under Article 30 of the Constitution and did not include examination of whether AMU is a minority educational institution.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1803Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. b. Challenging the locus standi of the Appellant, it was argued that Muslims do not constitute a minority community. For a community to be a minority, it should not just be numerically less than the majority but should also be politically non-dominant. Per this test, Muslims were a numerically larger group than the pre-independence dominant class, i.e., Christians. Hence, Muslims do not have the locus to invoke Article 30. In any case, the institutions that were formed prior to the coming of the Constitution cannot claim minority status because there was no such Fundamental Right when such institutions were created. c. To claim protection under Article 30, the minority community must prove that the institution was both established and is being administered by the community. Merely proving that the minority community established the institution is not enough to claim the status of a minority institution.
d. The word ‘establish’ in Article 30 means bringing an institution into existence. For this, the Court must see if the institution in its legally operational form could have existed ‘but for’ the Statute. If the Statute accorded legal operationalization to the institution, the establishment would be attributed to the legislature and not the minority community.
e. The de facto position of the minority’s role in administration is irrelevant to determining administration by a minority. The Court must see various relevant indicia of administrative control, including who controls the decisions regarding admission, levy of fees, governing council, the appointment of staff, disciplinary powers, and ordinances and statutes.
f. The meaning of ‘establish’ in Article 30 is bringing an institution into existence. AMU was brought into existence by the then Central Legislature, through the AMU Act, 1920. The Constituent Assembly Debates also do not expressly identify AMU as a minority institution within the ambit of Article 30. This indicates that the drafters intended to establish the university’s national character. To this day, the UOI contributes over a thousand crores to AMU, which has resulted in a complete metamorphosis of the university. Finally, the Preamble to the AMU Act, 1920 reflects that AMU was brought into existence by the Act and not by the Muslim community.
1804 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports g. The AMU Court only has residuary powers, not administrative powers. There is no majority of Muslims in the AMU Court, as only 32 out of 180 or more members are Muslims. Except for the AMU Court, no other body or authority is required to be Muslim. Moreover, various administrative functions are vested with bodies such as the Executive and Academic Councils and the Visitor, which are characteristically governmental or external. Even if there are a few Muslim members present in any of the bodies, it was simply an initiative by the State to instil confidence in the community and to ensure their participatory role without giving them any significant control. Hence, AMU is not being administered by the Muslim community.
h. The contention that the Attorney General for India must defend the 1981 Amendment Act is flawed, especially when the same does not exist in the eyes of law—the same having been struck down by the Allahabad High Court. Regardless, the present dispute is not limited to inter se the parties, but involves questions of constitutional interpretation and national importance. Hence, the primary duty of the UOI is to assist the Court and not to defend an amendment in the Act, which is per se unconstitutional.
III. Issues for determInatIon
82. Thus, in our considered opinion, the instant reference,based on the question of the tests required to be fulfilled by an institution, for seeking protection under Article 30 of the Constitution of India, can be broken down into the following segmented questions of law and fact:
Prefatory issues I. What are the requisite parameters of reference to a larger bench? What matters were intended to be addressed by the larger bench, in Anjuman (supra);What are the facets required to be considered by a regular bench for making a reference is made to a larger bench; What are the powers entrusted to the Chief Justice of India in such circumstances?
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1805Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. II. Whether Appellant has the locus standi to bring the present challenge?
It is essential to examine whether the Appellant can invoke Article 30 in the first place. In this regard, various sub-issues that may arise are: (a) Can Article 30 be invoked by institutions set up before the Constitution?;(b) Is it necessary for the whole of the minority community to file the claim, or can an individual or group of individuals also bring a claim?; and (c) Would Muslims be considered a ‘minority’?
Questions on constitutional interpretation III. What are the tests to seek protection under Article 30 of the Constitution?
It is necessary to examine the requirements that must be met for claiming protection under Article 30. The relevant question in this regard is whether the expressions ‘establishment’ and ‘administration’ should be read conjunctively or disjunctively? IV. What is the meaning of the term ‘establish’ in Article 30? Article 30 does not define the term ‘establish’. The pertinent questions are: (a) What is the scope and meaning of this term?; (b) Can a university be established without statutory intervention? If not, whether the recognition of a university by a Statute amounts to establishment by the Legislature? and (c) Is there any conflict in the opinions of this Court in Azeez Basha (supra) vis-à-vis Prof. Yashpal (supra) and the provisions of the NCMEI Act?
V. What is the meaning of the term ‘administer’ in Article 30? Akin to the term ‘establish’, the term ‘administer’ is also not defined. It is necessary to understand its meaning, along with its scope. In other words, the question is whether the presence of members of the non-minority community within the management would necessarily mean that the minority community is not administering the institution?
VI. Whether AMU satisfies the test of ‘establish’ and ‘administer’ and is thus entitled to the protection under Article 30? 1806 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports VII. Whether the Union of India is obligated to defend the AMU Amendment Act, 1981?
IV. analysIs Prefatory Issues F. Issue I: What are the requisite parameters of reference to a larger bench?
83. The issue concerning the power of a regular bench to refer a matter to a larger bench must be examined in light of the order passed in Anjuman (supra), which opined that Azeez Basha (supra) required reconsideration by a larger bench and proceeded to refer it to a sevenjudge bench. To this end, the Respondents have vehemently contended that such reference was bad in law and should be declared so.
84. In this vein, we have identified two key aspects of this issue: (i) what were the issues identified in Anjuman (supra) which were intended for the larger bench to address; and (ii) whether the manner of making such a reference was legally sound.
F.1. Issues that were intended to be addressed by the larger bench
85. At the outset, it is crucial to determine whether the bench in Anjuman (supra) intended to restrict the reference in such a way that the seven-judge bench would only analyse the criteria necessary for an institution to qualify as a minority institution under Article 30 of the Constitution. For the sake of clarity and despite the risk of repetition, we find it essential to put forth the relevant extract from the observations made in Anjuman (supra):
“After hearing counsel for the Parties, we are clearly of the opinion that this case involves two substantial questions regarding the interpretation of Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India. The present institution was founded in the year 1938 and registered under the Societies Registration Act in the year 1940. The documents relating to the time when the institution was founded clearly shows that while the institution was established mainly by the Muslim community but there were members 5 [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1807Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. from the non-Muslim community also who participated in the establishment process. The point that arises is as to whether Act. 30(1) of the Constitution envisages an institution which is established by minorities alone without the participation for the factum of establishment from any other community. On this point, there is no clear decision of this court. There are some observations in S. Azeez Basha & ors. Vs. Union of India 1968(1) SCR 333, but these observations can be explained away: Another point that arises is whether soon after the establishment of the institution if it is registered as a Society under the Society Registration Act, its status as a minority institution changes in view of the broad principles laid down in S. Azeez Basha’s case. Even as it is several jurists including Mr. Seervai have expressed about the correctness of the decision of this court in S. Azeez Basha’s case. Since the point has arisen in this case we think that this is a proper occasion when a larger bench can consider the entire aspect fully. We, therefore, direct that this case may be placed before Hon. The Chief Justice for being heard by a bench of at least 7 judges so that S.
Azeez Basha’s case may also be considered and the points that arise in this case directly as to the essential conditions or ingredients of the minority institution may also be decided once for all. A large number of. jurists including Mr. Seervai, learned counsel for the petitioners Mr. Garg and learned counsel for respondents and interveners Mr. Dikshit and Kaskar have stated that this case requires reconsideration. In view of the urgency it is necessary that the matter should be decided as early as possible we give liberty to the counsel for parties to mention the matter before Chief Justice.”
[Emphasis supplied]
86. A plain reading of these observations reveals that the two-judge bench in Anjuman (supra) doubted the correctness of the decision in Azeez Basha (supra) and the principles enunciated therein. The bench while questioning the holding in Azeez Basha (supra), also borrowed strength from the views expressed by some jurists. 1808 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
87. In Azeez Basha (supra), the issue pertained to the constitutional validity of the AMU 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts. While questioning the correctness of the decision in Azeez Basha (supra), it is evident that the reference in Anjuman (supra) also insinuated that potential errors may have occurred in the analysis of the constitutionality of those enactments. The reference seeking to re-open the issues settled in Azeez Basha (supra), thus, necessarily means not only to reexamine the correctness of that decision but also an attempt to revisit the constitutionality of the AMU 1951 and 1965 Amendment Acts.
88. Importantly, the key term used in the reference order in Anjuman (supra) is ‘and’, which is clearly used to state that both ‘Azeez Basha’s case may also be considered’ and ‘the ingredients of a minority institution’ should be examined definitively. Such an analysis would also have to consider the question posed in TMA Pai (supra) under 3(a) regarding the criteria required for an institution to qualify as a ‘minority institution’ under Article 30 of the Constitution, and consequently, as to whether, AMU fulfils such criteria or not.
89. We therefore find it difficult to align ourselves with the opinion expressed by Hon’ble the Chief Justice, according to which the reference before us was limited to determining only the criteria an educational institution must meet under Article 30 of the Constitution. However, given the Hon’ble Chief Justice’s decision to further refer the matter pertaining to AMU to a regular bench, we have confined our views to discerning the relevant indicia under Article 30, so as to avoid binding or influencing the regular bench that will ultimately decide the factual issues.
F.2. Manner of making reference to a larger bench
90. The two-judge bench in Anjuman (supra), after expressing doubt about the correctness of Azeez Basha (supra) and its principles, referred the matter for reconsideration to a larger bench. Additionally, the bench in Anjuman (supra) specifically stated that the larger bench reviewing Azeez Basha (supra)—a decision by a fivejudge bench—should consist of seven judges. The decision further directed that the matter be placed before the Hon’ble Chief Justice for appropriate directions.
91. Such a reference, to our mind, is not consistent with the established norms of judicial propriety. There are several reasons which [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1809Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. substantiate this school of thought. For instance, Order VII Rule 2 of the Supreme Court Rules, 1966 as applicable during the time of the reference stated:
“Where in the course of the hearing of any cause, appeal or other proceeding, the Bench considers that the matter should be dealt with by a larger Bench, it shall refer the matter to the Chief Justice, who shall thereupon constitute such a Bench for the hearing of it.”
[Emphasis supplied]
92. In this regard, it is imperative to refer to the findings of the Constitution Bench in Central Board of Dawoodi Bohra Community and another v. State of Maharashtra and another,60 which while adjudicating the correctness of previous decisions on the Bombay Prevention of Excommunication Act (Act 42 of 1949), also laid down pertinent principles on the procedure for making references. The decision in Dawoodi Bohra (supra) essentially clarified the framework concerning how a reference should be made, particularly when a bench of lesser strength doubts the correctness of a decision by a larger or co-equal bench. It held that:
“12. Having carefully considered the submissions made by the learned senior counsel for the parties and having examined the law laid down by the Constitution Benches in the above said decisions, we would like to sum up the legal position in the following terms :-
(1) The law laid down by this Court in a decision delivered by a Bench of larger strength is binding on any subsequent Bench of lesser or co-equal strength.
(2) A Bench of lesser quorum cannot doubt the correctness of the view of the law taken by a Bench of larger quorum. In case of doubt all that the Bench of lesser quorum can do is to invite the attention of the Chief Justice and request for the matter being placed for hearing before a Bench of larger quorum than the Bench whose decision has come up for consideration.
It will be open only for a Bench of coequal strength to
60 (2005) 2 SCC 673.
1810 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports express an opinion doubting the correctness of the view taken by the earlier Bench of coequal strength, whereupon the matter may be placed for hearing before a Bench consisting of a quorum larger than the one which pronounced the decision laying down the law the correctness of which is doubted.
(3) The above rules are subject to two exceptions:
(i) The above said rules do not bind the discretion of the Chief Justice in whom vests the power of framing the roster and who can direct any particular matter to be placed for hearing before any particular Bench of any strength; and
(ii) In spite of the rules laid down hereinabove, if the matter has already come up for hearing before a Bench of larger quorum and that Bench itself feels that the view of the law taken by a Bench of lesser quorum, which view is in doubt, needs correction or reconsideration then by way of exception (and not as a rule) and for reasons given by it, it may proceed to hear the case and examine the correctness of the previous decision in question dispensing with the need of a specific reference or the order of Chief Justice constituting the Bench and such listing. Such was the situation in Raghubir Singh and Ors. and Hansoli Devi and Ors. (supra)”
[Emphasis supplied]
93. The principles enunciated in Dawoodi Bohra (supra) re-enforce the provisions of the Supreme Court Rules referred to earlier, and also reiterate the well-established principles based upon doctrines of predictability, consistency, finality and the principle of stare decisis. The two-judge bench in Anjuman (supra), ought to have understood and applied the law,consistent with these principles. The two-judge bench in Anjuman (supra) being of lesser strength than the five-judge bench in Azeez Basha (supra), lacked the authority to explicitly question the correctness of Azeez Basha (supra) and refer the matter to a seven-judge bench.
94. In Anjuman (supra), the bench not only referred the matter but also specified the numerical strength of the bench to which it should be referred, with a further direction that the matter be placed before the [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1811Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Chief Justice for the limited purpose of notifying the composition of the seven-judge bench. With utmost respect at our command, we do not appreciate as to how a two-judge bench could dictate its viewpoint to the Chief Justice of India. This, to our mind, effectively impaired the Chief Justice’s authority as the master of the roster. Allowing such a practice would enable benches of lesser strength, such as a two-judge bench, to undermine the decisions of larger benches, potentially even an eleven-judge bench. This would also place the Chief Justice in an untenable position, who would be bound by a judicial order while acting in an administrative role, leading to procedural complications and embarrassment.
95. We reiterate that such actions completely undermine the principle of stare decisis, a well-established doctrine that mandates the consistent application of legal principles once pronounced by authoritative courts. This principle is rooted in the idea that once a court has determined a rule applicable to a specific set of circumstances, it should be followed in all future cases involving substantially similar facts.61 Stare decisis et non quieta movere—which means to stand by things decided and not disturb settled matters. Accordingly, the importance of precedents and stare decisis as fundamental features of our legal system requires that law laid down by higher courts be followed by coordinate or co-equal benches, and most certainly by smaller benches and subordinate courts.
96. The very purpose of these principles is to ensure predictability and stability in judicial decisions, thereby upholding the Rule of Law. It is trite law that when legal precedents are consistently followed, the law remains stable and strengthened, rather than being disrupted at every opportunity.62 Consistency and finality in judicial orders foster greater confidence and trust in the judicial system, which is the need of the hour. The mere fact that another interpretation may be possible does not warrant unsettling well-established law that has long governed the field.63 Deviation from these long-settled principles, leads to a situation marred by uncertainty and instability, vitiating any sense of finality.
61 Krishen Kumar v. Union of India (1990) 4 SCC 234.
62 State of Uttar Pradesh v. Ajay Kumar Sharma (2016) 15 SCC 292 63 Shanker Raju v. Union of India (2011) 2 SCC 132 1812 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
97. In this light, we respectfully disagree with the opinion of Hon’ble the Chief Justice that the reference in Anjuman (supra) passes muster. Such a reading risks opening the floodgates to further complexity and disruption, where smaller benches could disregard established principles and overturn decisions of larger benches. This would erode the concept of well-settled principles and destabilize the legal framework, as each judgment would strive to chart new directions, undermining legal certainty and continuity. Ironically, the reference in Anjuman (supra) strikes through the very core of Dawoodi Bohra (supra) and the law laid therein.
98. We thus have no hesitation in holding that it is the Chief Justice of India alone, who is the custodian of the authority to determine the composition of benches, and, in public or national interest, place a matter before any bench he deems appropriate, even in the absence of any reference. That being so, the 2019 Reference Order issued by a three-judge bench, which included the then Chief Justice of India, cannot be faulted. Consequently, based on that order, we consider it appropriate to proceed with the determination of some of the issues concerning the constitutional challenge.
99. We also respectfully disagree with the opinion of Hon’ble the Chief Justice in paragraph 39 of his draft judgement, according to which, Anjuman (supra) has merely ‘doubted’ and not ‘disagreed’ with Azeez Basha (supra). It seems to us that the terms ‘doubt’ and ‘disagree’ broadly carry similar connotations. It is difficult to doubt a judicial opinion unless we disagree with the correctness of its contents and substance. Similarly, a disagreement would originate only when such opinion is shrouded with doubts on law or on facts. G. Issue II: Whether the Appellant has the locus standi to bring the present challenge?
100. The Respondents have countered the Appellant’s locus standi to invoke Article 30. They have argued that there was no such Fundamental Right available at the time when AMU was established. It is their assertion that since Fundamental Rights are not retrospectively applicable, and considering AMU was established before the Constitution, it cannot claim protection under Article 30. In addition, the Respondents have challenged the Appellant’s locus on the ground that Muslims did not constitute a ‘minority’ in 1920.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1813Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
101. The Appellant has controverted the Respondents’ objections by arguing that even pre-Constitution institutions can invoke the right under Article 30 and that Muslims did indeed constitute a minority in the State of Uttar Pradesh at the relevant time because they were numerically lesser when compared to other communities. Accordingly, the Appellant contended that it has the locus standi to enforce the right granted by Article 30.
102. These contentions thus merit a determination as to whether a claim can be brought under Article 30 in the first place.
G.1. Locus of pre-Constitution institution
103. It is a settled principle of law that Fundamental Rights are not retrospectively applicable.64 The Constitution of India was framed in a social context that marked a significant departure from an exacting colonial regime to a system based on rights and selfgovernance. Hence, the legal milieu in these two regimes inevitably differed, with the Constitution imposing more stringent restrictions on governmental actions. Consequently, if the previous actions of the colonial government were to be tested on the touchstone of the Constitution, nearly all such acts would need to be overturned.
104. Such a wholesale invalidation of past actions would have far-reaching consequences. It could undermine the stability of the legal system, as people’s lives and rights—such as property rights, contractual relationships, etc.—have been shaped by those earlier actions. Hence, the social and economic disruption resulting from such a scenario would be severe. Furthermore, the retrospective application of Fundamental Rights could also lead to a legal quagmire, where Courts would be crippled with cases in which relevant documents and evidence might no longer be available. Moreover, such an unscrambling of the egg might nearly be impossible in some instances, such as cases of criminal convictions from decades ago.
105. The non-retrospective application of Fundamental Rights therefore is a pragmatic principle aimed at ensuring effective governance in society without being hindered by ghosts from the past. 64 Sushila Rao, “The Doctrine of Eclipse in Constitutional Law: A Critical Reappraisal of its Contemporary Scope and Relevance” National Law School of India Review, (2006) Vol. 18 No. 1 pp. 49. 1814 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
106. At this point, it is essential to distinguish between retrospective and retroactive laws. A retrospective law imposes new obligations or rights on transactions that have already been completed. In contrast, retroactive legislation applies to ongoing transactions, affecting obligations that arise after the law’s enactment, even if the transactions began beforehand.65 For example, if a law prohibits houses from having more than two floors and requires existing houses exceeding this limit to be demolished, it is retrospective. If the law only affects houses under construction when it comes into force, it is retroactive.
107. While the retrospectivity of Fundamental Rights is generally restricted, their application on transactions that arose before and continued post-1950 are not. The temporal boundary in the application of Fundamental Rights prevents pre-Constitution violations from being agitated, and it does not proscribe institutions created before the Constitution to plead their rights post its enactment. If we were to hold otherwise, it would lead to an untenable situation where a significant portion of the population or institutions with a long history would be excluded from the protection of Fundamental Rights simply because they existed before 1950.
108. Similarly,practices prevailing before 1950 but prohibited afterwards must be struck down if it does not align with the constitutional ethos. The significance of 26.01.1950 lies in its role as a golden date for eradicating unconstitutional practices and safeguarding the rights guaranteed under Part III of the Constitution. It would then accordingly follow that if an institution was established and administered by minorities as on 26.01.1950, such an institution would be entitled to seek protection under Article 30.
109. We cannot therefore accept the Respondent’s contention that the Appellant’s claim should be disallowed merely because Article 30 did not exist at the time AMU was established. Applying such an interpretation would be absurd and legally unjust. While certain institutions might have been set up during the pre-Constitutional era, the Court cannot turn a blind eye to their rights that are duly protected by the Constitution.
65 SEBI v. Rajkumar Nagpal (2023) 8 SCC 274, para 98-102. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1815Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
110. In this regard and especially in the context of Article 30, we find more than adequate support from a five-judge bench decision of this Court in Right Rev. Bishop S.K. Patro v. State of Bihar,66 which relied on the opinion proffered by the seven-judge bench in Kerala Education Bill (supra) and held:
“7. […] The guarantee of protection under Article 30 is not restricted to educational institutions established after the Constitution: institutions which had been established before the Constitution and continued to be administered by minorities either based on religion or language qualify for the protection of the right of minorities declared by Article 30 of the Constitution.
In Re the Kerala Education Bill, 1957 [(1959) SCR 995] Das, C.J., observed at p. 1051:
“There is no reason why the benefit of Article 30(1)
should be limited only to educational institutions established after the commencement of the Constitution. The language employed in Article 30(1) is wide enough to cover both pre-constitution and post-constitution institutions. It must not be overlooked that Article 30(1) gives the minorities two rights, namely, (a) to establish, and (b) to administer, educational institutions of their choice. The second right clearly covers pre-constitution schools just as Article 26 covers the right to maintain pre-constitution religious institutions.”
[Emphasis supplied]
111. In conclusion, while Fundamental Rights cannot be applied retrospectively to disrupt pre-constitutional practices, the Appellant is not barred from asserting a claim under Article 30 as long as the necessary conditions of this provision are met. Individuals or institutions who qualify to be protected through a Fundamental Right as of 26.01.1950 are entitled to enforce these rights under Article 32. Therefore, the Appellant’s locus standi cannot be dismissed on this basis.
66 Right Rev. Bishop S.K. Patrov. State of Bihar (1969) 1 SCC 863 1816 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
112. In addressing the issue of locus, two more key questions arise:
(i) whether a small group of individuals from a community can bring a claim under Article 30, as opposed to requiring the entire community to assert the claim collectively?; and (ii) whether the Muslim community in the present case were presumed to be a ‘minority’ at the time AMU was established? Each of these points are analysed separately below.
G.2. Locus of individuals from the minority community
113. The Respondents have countered the Appellant’s locus on the ground that they cannot plead the right under Article 30 since they are not the representative of the entire Muslim community. Hence, it is essential to analyse whether Article 30 can be invoked by a few individuals of the minority community.
114. Under the Indian Constitution, the framework of rights can be broadly divided into three classes based on who holds the right and who can exercise it:
a. The first category, known as ‘individual rights’, encompasses rights available to all individuals and can be claimed by them. An example of such a right is the right to privacy, which pertains to all individuals and can be asserted by any individual. b. The second category, termed ‘group rights’ in India, consists of rights available to individuals,provided they belong to a specified group. An example of such a right could be the right of reservation provided to individuals belonging to certain classes. In this regard, this Court has held:
“407. Unless the creamy layer is removed, OBCs cannot exercise their group rights. The Union of India and other respondents argued that creamy layer exclusion is wrong because the text of the Ninety-third Amendment bestows a benefit on “classes”, not individuals. While it is a group right, the group must contain only those individuals that belong to the group. I first take the entire lot of creamy and non-creamy layer OBCs. I then remove the creamy layer on an individual basis based on their income, property holdings, occupation, etc. What is left is a group that meets constitutional muster. It is a group right that [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1817Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. must also belong to individuals, if the right is to have any meaning. If one OBC candidate is denied special provisions that he should have received by law, it is not the group’s responsibility to bring a claim. He would be the one to do so. He has a right of action to challenge the ruling that excluded him from the special provisions afforded to OBCs. In this sense, he has an individual right. Group and individual rights need not be mutually exclusive. In this case, it is not one or the other but both that apply to the impugned legislation.” 67 [Emphasis supplied] As elucidated in the extract above, such group rights are possessed by an individual, and such individual can assert their claim to exercise these rights. The individual does not need to demonstrate that the group as a whole is affected and may exercise such rights in their singular capacity.
c. The third category, which we would like to refer to as collective rights, includes rights that belong to groups as a whole and can only be exercised by those groups collectively. An example of such a right could be the right of a country to vote in the UN General Assembly.68 Such rights belong to the entire nation as a community and are not contingent on whether individual citizens of the nation are individually exercising this right. Another example of such a category is the right of a country to be free from intervention by other countries, which also belongs to and is to be exercised by the nation as a whole.69 Unlike the previous two categories, the bearer of these rights is a collective unit and not individual constituents. Accordingly, the right can be claimed by the community at large or by an individual representing the entire community.
115. Based on the foregoing discussion, we believe that the right ensconced under Article 30 belongs to the second category, namely, 67 Ashoka Kumar Thakur v. Union of India (2008) 6 SCC 1, para 407. 68 Charter of United Nations (signed on 26 June, 1945) Art. 27. 69 Lukas Meyer et. Al. (ed.), Rights, Culture, and the Law, Oxford University Press (2003) pp. 181. 1818 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports it is granted to a minority community at large but can be exercised by an individual or a group of individuals. This right does not fit into the first category because Article 30 specifically aims to uplift and protect certain minority communities, making membership in such a community a necessary pre-condition. At the same time, however, it is also distinct from the third category because the protection envisaged in Article 30 is toward individuals belonging to such a community and not the entire community as one single entity. Thus, while the right exists for the benefit of the whole community, it can be exercised qua its individual members rather than requiring collective action by the whole community.70
116. Having said that, it is important to emphasize that the technical issue of who can invoke Article 30 should not be used to oust the claim at the threshold. Procedure, ultimately, is the handmaiden of justice. This is especially true for contentions regarding locus and who can invoke a particular provision, especially when there is public interest at stake. Unless there is a risk of collusion between the parties or the Court believes that the interest of all the stakeholders might not be adequately represented and there might be some ‘invisible victims’, the Court typically refrains from scrutinizing who has invoked the constitutional provision and whether the claimant represents the entire community. Constitutional Courts are envisaged as liberal platforms where vital questions regarding the violation of Fundamental Rights can be analysed without being bogged down by procedural technicalities. In that sense, the substance of the claim usually takes precedence over its form, instead of the form foreclosing the substance at the very outset.
117. The locus standi of the Appellant is thus not undermined on this count as well.
G.3. What is a ‘minority’ community?
118. Since during the course of hearing, or otherwise, the Respondents have not provided any reliable figures or substantial evidence to counter the Appellant’s position, it appears that it is not necessary to determine this issue at this stage, when only legal issues are being resolved.
70 Right Rev. Bishop S.K. Patro,supra note 66.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1819Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
119. Having answered the prefatory issues of locus and maintainability, we now proceed to delve into the contours of Article 30 of the Constitution and make an endeavor to explain the true meaning of the expressions ‘establish’ and ‘administer’.
Questions regarding constitutional interpretation H. Issue III: What are the tests to seek protection under Article 30?
120. When posed with the question of whether the prongs of ‘establishment’ and ‘administration’ ought to be construed conjunctively or disjunctively in determining whether it is a minority institution, the Appellant sought to contend that minority administration of their institution is merely discretionary and that they are not bound to satisfy the twin test. They instead urged that the prong of administration, would not be a prerequisite for determining the minority status of an educational institution.
121. The Respondents, on the other hand, assailed that for an institution to claim the protection proffered under Article 30, the minority community would have to demonstrate the two prongs of ‘establishment’ and ‘administration’ of the institution conjunctively.
122. Having considered the rival submissions tendered by the parties as well the language of the provision itself, it is evident that ‘establishment’ and ‘administration’ are qualitatively distinct: while the former deals with the history of the institution, the latter deals with the control over the institution, at present. Accordingly, ‘establishment’ is temporally fixated, while ‘administration’ requires analysis over a continuous span of time, both during and post-establishment.
123. Of these two aspects, the necessity of the prong of establishment is not in dispute. Both parties agree that an institution must be established by the minority community. This issue is also largely settled by various judicial precedents of this Court, which have held that establishment by minority is a necessary pre-requisite for claiming the right under Article 30.71 The question, however, has been raised 71 Kerala Education Bill, 1957, supra note 58; State of Kerala vs. Very Rev. Mother Provincial, (1970) 2 SCC 417, para 8; S.P. Mittal vs. Union of India, (1983) 1 SCC 51, para 137; Dayanand Anglo Vedic (DAV) College Trust and Management Society v. State of Maharashtra,(2013) 4 SCC 14. 1820 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports in regard to the administration prong. The Respondents have argued it to be a pre-requisite for invoking Article 30, while the Appellant has argued it to be the result of such an invocation.
124. We find that both the Appellant and Respondents are right, but only to the extent that administration is both a pre-requisite and the result. In this respect, it mirrors its counterpart,Article 29,under the section ‘Cultural and Educational Rights’. Article 29 makes the distinctiveness of culture a pre-requisite for invoking its provision, and once invoked, it bestows the right to conserve such distinctiveness. Similarly, Article 30 outlines administration by the minority community as a pre-requisite for invoking the provision, ultimately granting the right to continue such administration free from unreasonable government interference.
125. There are multifarious reasons behind upholding administration as a pre-requisite rather than merely a right or result. First, if Article 30 were contingent only on the establishment by the minority community, it would render the provision susceptible to significant misuse. In a bid to attain special protection under Article 30, majority communities could purchase or takeover institutions established by minorities and then administer such institutions with reduced State interference in perpetuity. This will potentially lead to all communities ultimately enjoying the special right guaranteed by Article 30, denuding the very purpose of this Article.
126. Second, it is clear that Article 30 carves out an exception to the general power of the Government to regulate and intervene in educational institutions. It has also been defined broadly, extending to all religious and linguistic minorities, potentially encompassing a significant portion of India’s population. If not interpreted narrowly,Article 30 would undermine governmental control over educational institutions and compromise the quality of higher education.
127. Therefore,if the institutions not administered by minorities were also brought under the purview of Article 30, it could face misuse by institutions camouflaging as minority institutions when, in reality, they are not. I find support to this view in A.P. Christian Medical Educational Society v. Govt. of A.P.,72 which held:
72 A.P. Christian Medical Educational Society v. Govt. of A.P & Anr. (1986) 2 SCC 667, para 8. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1821Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. “8. […] The government, the University and ultimately the court have the undoubted right to pierce the ‘minority veil’ — with due apologies to the corporate lawyers — and discover whether there is lurking behind it no minority at all and in any case, no minority institution. The object of Article 30(1) is not to allow bogies to be raised by pretenders but to give the minorities ‘a sense of security and a feeling of confidence’ not merely by guaranteeing the right to profess, practise and propagate religion to religious minorities and the right to conserve their language, script and culture to linguistic minorities, but also to enable all minorities, religious or linguistic, to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. These institutions must be educational institutions of the minorities in truth and reality and not mere masked phantoms […] What is Important and what Is imperative is that there must exist some real positive index to enable the institution to be identified as an educational institution of the minorities […].”
[Emphasis supplied]
128. Several other existing case laws support the notion that administration too, ought to be regarded as a pre-requisite. For instance, In St. Stephen’s College (supra), a five-judge bench of this Court analysed the facets regarding both establishment and administration of St. Stephen’s College under the Delhi University Act,to conclude whether it could be characterised as a minority institution. In DAV College (supra) a two-judge bench reiterated the principle that administration has to be exercised by the minority community. This view was also reinforced by another two-judge bench in T. Varghese George v. Kora K. George.73 Similarly, in Manager, Rajershi Memorial Basic Training School v. State of Kerala,74 the Kerala High Court held that an institution merely being founded by a member of a minority community is insufficient, and it has to be administered by the minority community in question.
73 Dr. T. Varghese George v. Kora K. George and Ors.,(2012) 1 SCC 369. 74 Manager, Rajershi Memorial Basic Training School v. The State of Kerala and Anr.,1972 SCC OnLine Ker 111, para 4.
1822 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
129. All of these cases support the legal principle that for an institution to claim protection under Article 30, it should have a ‘real positive indicia’ and must not be a mere sham. It is, therefore, permissible to ‘pierce the veil’ in order to ascertain the real character of the institution,as the minority status cannot be bestowed on illusionary claims.
130. Lastly, it is an established principle of statutory interpretation that a provision has to be read as a whole, and the accompanying text may be employed in interpreting the meaning of another clause.75 This principle is particularly relevant in the present case, as Article 30(1A) specifically defines an institution “referred to in Clause 1” and mentions it to be an institution that is both established ‘and’ administered by a minority:
“(1A) In making any law providing for the compulsory acquisition of any property of an educational institution established and administered by a minority, referred to in clause (1), the State shall ensure that the amount fixed by or determined under such law for the acquisition of such property is such as would not restrict or abrogate the right guaranteed under that clause.”
[Emphasis supplied]
131. Since the term ‘and’ has been consciously employed instead of ‘or’, it is clear that the text of the provision itself envisages the conditions to be read conjunctively. To hold to the contrary would require reading down an original provision of the Constitution, which the Court must refrain from doing.
132. Considering that institutions claiming any benefit under Article 30 must satisfy this two-pronged test, it is trite to say that the terms ‘establishment’ and ‘administration’ under Article 30 are conjunctive.
I. Issue IV: What is the meaning of ‘establish’ in Art. 30?
133. The Appellant has argued that the term ‘establish’ in Article 30 means who ‘founded’ the institution. It is their assertion that if the genesis 75 Justice GP Singh, Principles of Statutory Interpretation, Lexis Nexis (2016), 14th edn. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1823Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. of the institution can be traced back to the minority community, the institution would satisfy the test of being a minority institution.
134. Per contra, the Respondents ascribe a different meaning to the term ‘establish’ and argue that the Court must evaluate as to who created the institution. If the institution owes its existence to the Statute, then it would mean that the institution was established by the Legislature and not by the minority community.
135. In due consideration of these opposing views, the central issue for our determination,therefore would be to ascertain the meaning of the term ‘establish’ in Article 30 and determine what the relevant indicia should be, in order to determine on facts as to whether or not an institution is established by the minority community.
136. Previously, a six-judge bench of this Court had conducted a similar exercise in State of Kerala v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial76 and defined the term establish as the ‘bringing into being of an institution’: “8. Article 30(1) has been construed before by this Court. Without referring to those cases it is sufficient to say that the clause contemplates two rights which are separated in point of time. The first right is the initial right to establish institutions of the minority’s choice. Establishment here means the bringing into being of an institution and it must be by a minority community. It matters not if a single philanthropic individual with his own means, founds the institution or the community at large contributes the funds. The position in law is the same and the intention in either case must be to found an institution for the benefit of a minority community by a member of that community. It is equally irrelevant that in addition to the minority community others from other minority communities or even from the majority community can take advantage of these institutions. Such other communities bring in income and they do not have to be turned away to enjoy the protection”
[Emphasis supplied] 76 Mother Provincial, supra note 71, para 8.
1824 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
137. Hence, as rightly held by this Court, the term ‘establish’ means bringing the institution into existence for the benefit of the minority community. However, we must ask ourselves as to when an institution can be said to have come into existence, and what it means to establish it for the benefit of the community. Each of these prongs have been analysed separately below.
I.1. Bringing into existence—meaning and factors
138. In this regard, the Appellant and Respondents both suggested that an institution comes into existence at a single point in time but disagreed on what that exact point should be. The Appellant suggested looking back into the genesis of the institution to determine when it was ‘founded’ or when the idea was conceived. In contrast, the Respondents argued against going back in time and instead urged that the institution should be considered established the moment it was operationalized. According to them, if the institution was operationalized by virtue of a statute, then it was established at that specific point by the Legislature.
139. To clarify these divergent views, it might be helpful to consider analogous situations. For instance, if the question is about when a photograph taken with an analogue camera comes into existence, one perspective would argue that it is created when the photograph is clicked, while the other would assert that it only exists when the photo is finally printed on paper. Similarly, in the context of a melody, one side might argue that it comes into existence when it is composed, whereas the other side could contend that it only comes into being when it is finally performed. Or in the context of art, one perspective could be that a painting comes into existence when the idea is conceived, and the other side could be that it is only when it is fully completed.
140. We believe that both sides are partly right and partly wrong. They are right in considering both the genesis of the institution and the point of sanction by the statute for operationalizing the institution as relevant factors to determine establishment. However, they are incorrect in asserting that coming into existence is an event frozen at a single point in time. Instead, we believe that coming into existence operates in a continuum, which requires the analysis of the entire gamut of relevant factors that brought the institution into being. The [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1825Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. essence of existence—be it that of an educational institution or a photograph, melody, or an art as instantiated above—is a multifaceted and an ontological question that cannot be answered by artificially fixating it at a specific time with a bright-line test. Since there are several factors that contribute towards the existence of the educational institution, at no point can we say that the institute came into existence as soon as one specific factor was fulfilled. Such an exercise would highlight one factor while discounting the importance of others, which would be arbitrary and irrational. Instead, the correct approach requires an appraisal of the entirety of facts—i.e., the origin, the point of finality, and the whole process in between—to reach an understanding about the establishment.
141. Hence, while the parties are right in pointing out the relevant factors of genesis and the statutory sanction, the analysis of who establishes the educational institution has to go beyond them to cover all aspects holistically. Since these factors would be a question of fact that would differ from case to case, giving a laundry list of all such aspects would be erroneous in law. However, to determine whether the minority community has established the institution or not, a few illustrative factors that the Courts have considered in the past include: a. The genesis of the institution and who conceptualized the idea; b. The gathering of resources and who provided the requisite finances for creating the institution;77 c. Who contributed towards the infrastructure of the institution to provide it with a physical existence;78 d. The framing of charter documents and who imparted the purpose to the institution;79 e. In case government approvals were required, who made the initial efforts in taking those permissions and fulfilling the necessary compliances; and f. Post the approval of the government, who undertook the initial steps in forming the administrative bodies,80 hiring teachers, 77 Right Rev. Bishop S.K. Patro, supra note 66, para 15-16. 78 St. Stephen’s College, supra note 50, para 31.
79 Ibid, para 35.
80 Ibid, para 35-40.
1826 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports admitting students, passing the first statutes and ordinances, ensuring regular compliances, etc., for operationalizing the institution.
I.1.1. Caveat to these factors
142. In regard to these factors and any additional ones that may be relevant based on the specifics of each case, there are two important qualifications to note. First, as was previously stated, none of these factors individually would be determinative of the minority status; the analysis must be holistic, and the factum of existence must be seen in a continuum instead of fixating on one factor and point of time. In several instances, Courts have clarified that the absence of certain factors, such as the institution not being constructed by the minority community81 or receiving external financial assistance,82 does not negate the minority character of the institution. These decisions reiterate that the presence or absence of a single factor should not alter the Court’s overall conclusion.
143. Second, the analysis concerning who fulfils each individual factor should not aim at creating absolutes, i.e., the Court must not mandate that the minority community must be single-handedly responsible for fulfilling the role prescribed by that factor. It could be the case that the community takes aid of external parties for setting up the institution, but still takes the lead role in such establishment. If we were to hold that such aid would take away the minority character of the institution, we would, in effect, be laying down a requirement that the community must work in silos and that no member belonging to any other community should provide any assistance in achieving its purpose. This would squarely contravene the very spirit of our Constitution, which permits—or rather encourages— other communities to work in tandem with minority communities for their upliftment. In a cohesive society like ours, cooperation for mutual development is a shared moral responsibility. Hence, the 81 Rt. Rev. Dr. Aldo Maria Patroni v. Assistant Educational Officer, 1973 SCC OnLine Ker 60, para 7; A. Raju and Ors. v. Manager, Nallor Narayana L.P. Basic School & Ors., 2019 SCC OnLine Ker 16483, para 6-7; T.M.A. Pai,supra note 3, para 11.
82 Right Rev. Bishop S.K. Patro, supra note 69, para 16; Dipendra Nath Sarkar v. State of Bihar & Ors., 1960 SCC OnLine Pat 205, para 14.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1827Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. mere presence of external aid is a factor which would not obviate the minority character of the institution
144. That being said, the converse must also hold true. If the leading role in establishing an institution is played by an external party, mere contributions from a member of the minority community would not be sufficient to attribute the establishment itself to the minority. To hold otherwise would expose the protection given under Article 30 to potential misuse, allowing institutions established by the majority community to claim minority status based on some insignificant contribution from the minority community. The test should therefore rather focus on who takes a leading and decisive role in fulfilling the relevant criteria for establishing an institution.
145. To determine whether the minority community established the institution, the Court should thus examine whether it was indeed that community which brought the institution into existence. This involves assessing who played the leading role from the institution’s inception, through the process of making its creation a reality, and finally, in making it operational.
146. Having understood the meaning of ‘bringing into existence’, we shall now revisit the Respondent’s argument that if an institution is being created by Statute, then it cannot be said to have been brought into existence by the minority community since in that, case it is the Legislature which establishes the university. This particular element requires some detailed analysis, not only because it was vehemently argued by both sides but also because,as confirmed by this Court in Prof Yashpal (supra), a University can only be created by or under a Statute.
147. Having said that, if we were to hold that statutory intervention means that the Parliament ‘establishes’ the university and not the minority community (as was held in Azeez Basha (supra)), it would mean that the minority community would never be able to qualify the ‘establishment’ prong under Article 30. This would concomitantly lead to the conclusion that minorities can never establish a university under this provision. Such a conclusion would run contrary to the amendment to the NCMEI Act, which includes universities also under the ambit of minority educational institutions. Therefore, to render quietus to this issue, we shall discuss whether the Statute does, in fact, bring an institution into existence.
1828 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports I.1.2. Statutory intervention and establishment of an institution
148. In this regard, it is important to note that statutory intervention exists as a sliding scale, which can differ based on the kind of institution. Broadly, there are three such categories of institutions: first, those which are ‘registered in accordance’ with the statute; second, which are ‘recognized’ by the statute; and third, which are ‘created by’ the statute. Each of these are analysed separately below.
I.1.2.1. Registered in accordance with the statute
149. To establish an institution as a juristic entity, it is possible that the minority community uses a form of organization provided under a statutory framework. For instance, to establish an institution as a company, the community might utilize the provisions of the Companies Act, 2013; for a society,it would perhaps be the Cooperative Societies Act, 1912, and so on. In case such a statutory framework is used by the community, the question arises who truly brings the institution into existence—the community or the statute that is used to create the institution?
150. This question is no longer res integra and has been effectively answered in Dalco Engg. (P) Ltd. v. Satish Prabhakar Padhye,83 wherein this Court held:
“20. A “company” is not “established” under the Companies Act. An incorporated company does not “owe” its existence to the Companies Act. An incorporated company is formed by the act of any seven or more persons (or two or more persons for a private company) associated for any lawful purpose subscribing their names to a memorandum of association and by complying with the requirements of the Companies Act in respect of registration. Therefore, a “company” is incorporated and registered under the Companies Act and not established under the Companies Act. Per contra, the Companies Act itself establishes the National Company Law Tribunal and the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, and these two statutory authorities owe their existence to the Companies Act.”
[Emphasis supplied] 83 Dalco Engg. (P) Ltd. v. Satish Prabhakar Padhye and Ors. (2010) 4 SCC 378, para 20. [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1829Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors.
151. Hence, as rightly held in the aforementioned case, using a statutory framework does not necessarily mean that the organization is established by the statute. If that were so, all companies under Companies Act, 2013 would become government companies, leading to an absurd consequence that does not hold water.
152. The Statutes that are used merely as a tool by the minority community to register their institution under the statutory framework do not thus take away the community’s role in bringing the institution into existence. I.1.2.2. Recognized under the Statute
153. The second kind of Statutes are those that provide recognition to already existing institutions. This is usually true for Statutes providing affiliation to colleges with universities. Once the college affiliates itself to a university, it will have to fulfil the statutory requirements prescribed under the relevant statute of the university. Would such a statutory intervention then mean that the institution has been brought into existence by that Statute?
154. This question has also been lucidly answered by this Court in Executive Committee of Vaish Degree College v. Lakshmi Narain,84 where a similar contention was raised that after being affiliated with the university, Vaish Degree College became a statutory body that was created by the statute. Rejecting this view, the Court held that: “Here a distinction must be made between an institution which is not created by or under a statute but is governed by certain statutory provisions for the proper maintenance and administration of the institution. There have been a number of institutions which though not created by or under any statute have adopted certain statutory provisions, but that by itself is not, in our opinion, sufficient to clothe the institution with a statutory character. […] It is, therefore, clear that there is a well-marked distinction between a body which is created by the statute and a body which after having come into existence is governed in accordance with the provisions of the statute. In other words the position seems to be that the institution 84 Executive Committee of Vaish Degree College and Anr. v. Lakshmi Narain and Ors. (1976) 2 SCC 58, para 10.
1830 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports concerned must owe its very existence to a statute which would be the fountainhead of its powers. The question in such cases to be asked is, if there is no statute would the institution have any legal existence. If the answer is in the negative, then undoubtedly it is a statutory body, but if the institution has a separate existence of its own without any reference to the statute concerned but is merely governed by the statutory provisions it cannot be said to be a statutory body[…].” [Emphasis supplied]
155. Hence, if an institution possesses legal existence independent of the statute, then the Statute merely recognizes an existing institution and does not ‘establish’ it. This kind of Statute also does not take away the role of the minority community in bringing the institution into existence. Accordingly, just because a college is affiliated with a university and follows its statutory requirements, it would not deprive the institution of its minority character. This was also stated in St. Stephens (supra), where this Court held:
“41. It was contended that St. Stephen’s College after being affiliated to the Delhi University has lost its minority character. The argument was based on some of the provisions in the Delhi University Act and the Ordinances made thereunder. It was said that the students are admitted to the University and not to the College as such. But we find no substance in the contention. In the first place, it may be stated that the State or any instrumentality of the State cannot deprive the character of the institution, founded by a minority community by compulsory affiliation since Article 30(1) is a special right to minorities to establish educational institutions of their choice […]”
“45. From these and other relevant provisions of the Act and Ordinances, we have not been able to find any indications either in the general scheme or in other specific provisions which would enable us to say that the College is legally precluded from maintaining its minority character. That in matters of admission of students to Degree courses including Honours courses, the candidates [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1831Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. have to apply to the College of their choice and not to the University and it is for the Principal of the College or Dean of Faculties concerned to take decision and make final admission. It is, therefore, wrong to state that there is no admission to the College but only for the University. The procedure for admission to Post Graduate courses is of course, different but we are not concerned with that matter in these cases.”
[Emphasis supplied]
156. It may also be relevant at this stage to examine instances of such universities, which, under law, are mandated to be operationalized by a Statute. We may,in this regard,usefully refer to the University Grants Commission Act, 1956 (UGC Act) which provides as follows: “22. Right to confer degrees—
(1) The right of conferring or granting degrees shall be exercised only by a University established or incorporated by or under a Central Act, a Provincial Act or a State Act or an institution deemed to be a University under Section 3 or an institution specially empowered by an Act of Parliament to confer or grant degrees.
(2) Save as provided in sub-section (1), no person or authority shall confer, or grant, or hold himself or itself out as entitled to confer or grant, any degree.
(3) For the purposes of this section, “degree” means any such degree as may, with the previous approval of the Central Government, be specified in this behalf by the Commission by notification in the Official Gazette.
23. Prohibition of the use of the word “University” in certain cases.— No institution, whether a corporate body or not, other than a University established or incorporated by or under a Central Act, a Provincial Act or a State Act shall be entitled to have the word “University” associated with its name in any manner whatsoever:
Provided that nothing in this section shall, for a period of two years from the commencement of this Act, apply to an 1832 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports institution which, immediately before such commencement, had the word “University” associated with its name.”
[Emphasis supplied]
157. Since the UGC Act mandates that degrees can be conferred only by those universities that are established ‘by or under’ a statute, it is a necessary corollary that the university must be operationalized by a statute itself in order to validly confer the degrees. Given that the legal existence in this context flows directly from the statute, the question thus arises: does this mean that the minority community does not bring such universities into existence, and that they are instead established by the legislature? Indeed, Azeez Basha (supra) says so. Contrarily, the NCMEI Act,as amended from time to time,enables a minority community to establish a university on its own. There being an apparent inconsistency between the two, the question that arises for further consideration is as to which perspective accurately reflects the correct position—Azeez Basha (supra) or the NCMEI Act? Azeez Basha (supra) v. the NCMEI Act: The curious case of bringing universities into existence
158. In this regard, one needs to note the nuance between legal recognition and other facets of existence. As was discussed before, existence covers other aspects apart from legal sanction. Especially for universities, this Court, in the case of Prof. Yashpal (supra), held that the Statute shall not give legal sanction unless it is satisfied that there exist enough infrastructural facilities within the institution: “44. […] When the Constitution has conferred power on the State to legislate on incorporation of university, any Act providing for establishment of the university must make such provisions that only an institution in the sense of university as it is generally understood with all the infrastructural facilities, where teaching and research on a wide range of subjects and of a particular level are actually done, acquires the status of a university. […]”
45. The State Legislature can make an enactment providing for incorporation of universities under Entry 32 of List II and also generally for universities under Entry 25 of List III. The subject “university” as a legislative head must be [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1833Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. interpreted in the same manner as it is generally or commonly understood, namely, with proper facilities for teaching of higher level and continuing research activity. An enactment which simply clothes a proposal submitted by a sponsoring body or the sponsoring body itself with the juristic personality of a university so as to take advantage of Section 22 of the UGC Act and thereby acquires the right of conferring or granting academic degrees but without having any infrastructure or teaching facility for higher studies or facility for research is not contemplated by either of these entries. Sections 5 and 6 of the impugned enactment are, therefore, wholly ultra vires, being a fraud on the Constitution.”
46. […] In the absence of any campus and other infrastructural facilities, UGC cannot take any measures whatsoever to ensure a proper syllabus, level of teaching, standard of examination and evaluation of academic achievement of the students or even to ensure that the students have undergone the course of study for the prescribed period before the degree is awarded to them.” [Emphasis supplied]
159. Similarly, while Regulation 3.1 of the University Grants Commission (Establishment of and Maintenance of Standards in Private Universities) Regulations, 2003 also states that universities have to be established by a statute, the very definition of the term ‘private university’ in Regulation No. 2.1 clarifies that the university is established albeit ‘through’ the legislation, but ‘by’ a private body:
“3.1. Each private university shall be established by a separate State Act and shall conform to the relevant provisions of the UGC Act, 1956, as amended from time to time.”
“2.1. “Private university” means a university duly established through a State / Central Act by a sponsoring body viz. a Society registered under the Societies Registration Act 1860, or any other corresponding law for the time being in force in a State or a Public Trust or 1834 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports a Company registered under Section 25 of the Companies Act, 1956.”
[Emphasis supplied]
160. In addition to these provisions, it is also imperative to take into consideration that the role of sponsoring bodies is explicated in further detail in various state legislations. For instance, the Uttar Pradesh Private Universities Act, 2019, sets out in detail the steps that the sponsoring body must take to receive sanction for establishing a university. The body is required to create an endowment fund, possess certain specified areas of land, construct buildings, install equipment, appoint professors, plan curriculum and other activities, make rules for the functioning of the university, and comply with other norms.85 Subsequently, such a body is then required to apply for the sanction by furnishing the requisite details.86 Only once the government is satisfied with the necessary compliances by the sponsoring body, does it grant the sanction and incorporates it under the statute.87 Therefore, even though the final legal existence is sanctioned through the statute, it is the private body which initiates and fulfils other essential roles.
161. A similar situation existed in India prior to independence. During this pre-independence era, the very nature of universities was in a state of flux. Up until the 1920s, universities primarily functioned as administrative units rather than teaching institutions. Accordingly, they were established by the State as government bodies to exercise control over all the colleges in the respective provinces. This factum is acknowledged by the Saddler Commission of 1917-19, which noted:
“These territorial limits have been deemed necessary in the past, mainly for the following reasons. In the first place, the functions of the older universities in India have demanded them. So long as each of these universities is engaged, subject to Government control, in administrative rather than teaching functions, it necessarily follows that its 85 Uttar Pradesh Private Universities Act, 2019, Section 3. 86 Ibid, Section 4.
87 Ibid, Section 7.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1835Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. boundaries should be as far as possible co-terminous with those of a province […] The self-contained provincial university affords some administrative conveniences.
Because it exercises direct control over Government colleges, gives grants-in-aid to others, and is deeply interested in the secondary school system, Government is necessarily hampered in carrying out these duties if the affiliation and inspection of colleges within its area and the recognition of schools situated within its territorial jurisdiction are in any respect under the authority or in the hands of another Government and university.”88 [Emphasis supplied]
162. However, in order to expand the scope of education and to accommodate growing demand, there was a legitimate need to change the role of the university from mere administrative bodies to institutions of learning. Hence, while there was hitherto monopoly exercised by government universities,89 it permitted private players to approach the government and seek the setting up of a university. As recognized by the Saddler Commission, BHU was the first of its kind.
163. In due parlance, the University Commission Report of 1929 also acknowledged this change, and it was noted that various learning universities had come into being.90 In order to establish a university whose degree would be recognized by the government, they were required to be established through a statute.91 Universities that were established in native states were also created through the sanction of the ruler.92 Even though some native groups did establish universities 88 M.E. Sadler, Calcutta University Commission 1917-1919, Chapter XXIX. 89 Henry Sharp, “The Development of Indian Universities” Journal of the Royal Society of Arts, (1925), Vol. 73, No. 3778 pp. 523.
90 Indian Statutory Commission, Interim Report- Review of Growth of Education in British India, Calcutta, Government of India, central Publication Branch (1929) pp. 123, available at https://archive.org/details/ dli.csl.1000/page/n157/mode/2up?view=theater 91 Dr. Vishwanath Pandey (editor), Founder of Banaras Hindu University: Pandit Madan Mohan Malviya, Publication Cell, Banaras Hindu University (2006), pp. 19, available at https://web.archive.org/ web/20120412191310/http://www.bhu.ac.in/MMMMM.pdf .
92 The Handbook of Indian Universities, published by Inter University Board India (1928), pp. 255, available at https://archive.org/details/handbookofindian029307mbp/page/n269/mode/2up?view=theater; Syed Akbar, “Controversy over Osmania University Centenary as Firman says it was founded in 1918, The Indian Express (23 November, 2017) available at https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ hyderabad/controversy-over-osmania-university-centenary-as-firman-says-it-was-founded-in-1918/ 1836 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports without the statute, their degrees were not recognized, consequently leading to them being less attractive centres of learning.93
164. That means that while universities were still required to seek a government’s sanction for recognition of degrees, the statutes were limited to their legal existence. There are other essential components as well, to determine the status of a university. As was also briefly explicated in Prof. Yashpal (supra),94 a university in essence, is also an organized body that serves as a centre of higher education by linking students and teachers. For it to exist in that form, it is necessary for someone to ideate, plan, gather the resources, take approvals, and functionalize the institution once the sanction is received.95 This materiality was also briefly alluded to by the University Commission of 1948, when it said that:
“The Annamalai University owes its inception to the generosity of the late Annamalai Chettiar of Chettinad. The Banaras and the Aligarh Universities have had large endowments given by princes and commoners. The Calcutta University has had endowments given by such eminent persons as P.C. Ray, Rash Behari Ghose and Tarakanath Palit; while Bombay has had large endowments from the Singhania and Tata Trusts besides endowments from several other philanthropic citizens; the University of Nagpur has had a large endowment under the Laxminarayan Trust, Fund and the Madras University has for the first time been given a generous endowment by Dr. Alagappa Chettiar.
The new university at Saugor owes its existence to a donation of Rs. 2,000,000 from Sir Hari Singh Gaur which is regarded as a first instalment.”
[Emphasis supplied]
165. Hence, even when the legal existence—i.e., the authority to grant degrees—comes from an external body or legislature, it is an important but not the sole facet that constitutes a University. Further, the legislative object and intent of such a Statute would be a determinative articleshow/61762699.cms.
93 Indian Statutory Commission, supra note 90, pp. 121. 94 Prof. Yashpal, supra note 4, para 20-22.
95 Dr. Vishwanath Pandey, supra note 91.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1837Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. factor in ascertaining the nature of the University. If it were solely responsible for the creation of the university, the statute might assume a size larger than the University. Instead, since the concept of a university encompasses numerous other factors beyond legal sanction, these factors also contribute to its existence, and the statute is one of them. Consequently, the presence of this external factor does not render the entire existence attributable to the Legislature.
166. It seems to us that when the UGC Act or colonial laws mandated universities to be created by statutes, those who intended a university, including the minority community, were not absolved from complying with other relevant factors so as to bring the university into being. We therefore do not find any conflict between the amended provisions of the NCMEI Act, UGC Act, and the holding in Prof. Yashpal (supra). Each holds its own independent and distinct field and operates validly within that sphere. The minority community thus can establish a university under Article 30,96 provided it fulfils the norms of the UGC—i.e., gets legal sanction to create the university through a statute. To the extent that Azeez Basha (supra) holds to the contrary, it deserves to be modified and clarified.
167. Having held so,we will now analyse the third category of institutes, which are ‘created by’ the legislature itself.
I.1.2.3. Created by the statute
168. The previous section showed that an institution would not owe its existence to the legislature itself, provided that other facets apart from legal operationalization are fulfilled by another body. However, it may also happen that the Government itself may fulfil the other aspects by perhaps ideating the institution, providing funds and infrastructure for its set-up, making its charter documents, and finally operationalizing it through different bodies. In case the leading role in the different factors instantiated in paragraph 141 of this judgement is played by the Legislature itself or through the Executive Government, then it will be said to have brought the institution into existence and not any private individual or community.
169. The distinction between the second and third categories of institutions (i.e., those recognized by statute versus those created by statute) is thus one of degree and a matter of fact. While both types of 96 Uttar Pradesh Private Universities Act, 2019, Section 2(p). 1838 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports institutions may appear on paper to be established under a statute, only a thorough analysis of their backgrounds can illuminate whether they belong to the second category—i.e., where the statute merely operationalizes the institution or to the third category—where their very existence is attributable to legislative action. Depending on such analysis, the Court can conclude whether the institution meets the establishment prong under Article 30 or not.
170. To sum up the entire discussion on the spectrum of legislative interference pictorially:
I.2. Establishment shall be for the benefit of the community
171. There can hardly be any quarrel that, for fulfilling the establishment prong, it is not sufficient that the institution was brought into existence by the community, but it must be further proved that it was for the benefit of that community. For this purpose, it is essential to analyse the overall functioning of the institution and the primary [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1839Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. objective for which it has been established. For instance, where the institution admits members of other communities; also teaches secular courses;97or if it is working merely as a commercial entity that does not admit students of its own community; or working primarily towards the development of its community, it would be antithetical to the very purpose of Article 30 to grant such an institution minority status.
172. This has been clarified by various judgements of this Court, which held that the purpose of Article 30 is to ensure the upliftment of the minority community by providing them with a congenial atmosphere for education.98If the institution is not aligned with this purpose, it would not be covered under the purview of Article 30 and would not enjoy extra administrative autonomy, even if its existence is owed to a minority community.
173. To conclude the discussion on the meaning of ‘establish’, for an institution to fulfil the establishment prong under Article 30, it is necessary for it to have been brought into existence by the minority community and must be working towards the benefit of that community. J. Issue V: What is the meaning of ‘administer’ in Article 30?
174. The parties are not unanimous on the meaning of the term ‘administer’ as contained in Article 30 of the Constitution. The Appellant sought to assail that the term ‘administer’ essentially refers to who has overall control over the university. The parties argued that the mere fact that the State regulates the institution does not take away the ‘administration’ from the community. The Respondents, on the other hand, proffered that the ‘administer’ prong requires the minority community to control essential factors of the institution, such as admission to the institution, fee structure, appointment of teachers, etc.
175. Before venturing onto understanding what is included in administration, it is necessary to first understand what it does not include. Various judicial precedents, including the decision in TMA Pai (supra), have 97 In Re: The Kerala Education Bill, supra note 58; para 23; Rev. Father W. Proost and Ors. v. State of Bihar and Ors. [1969] 2 SCR 73, para 8; Ahmedabad St. Xaviers College Society and Anr. v. State of Gujarat and Anr., AIR 1974 SC 1389, para 10.
98 In Re: The Kerala Education Bill, supra note 58; Para 32; P.A. Inamdar, supra note 48, para 97. 1840 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports held that the term ‘administration’ does not include maladministration. In other words, while the minority community has the right to administer the institution, the regulatory measures imposed by the State that merely regulate the educational standards are not included within the right of ‘administration’.99
176. To this end, the State has the power to prescribe, inter alia: compliance requirements of the government for granting recognition to the university, if they largely and substantially leave unimpaired the right of administration in regard to internal affairs of the institution;100 general laws of the land applicable to all persons, such as laws relating to taxation, sanitation, social welfare, economic regulation, public order and morality, or general regulations regarding welfare of students and teachers;101 regulations requiring transparency and merit in admission procedure;102 regulations restricting charging of capital fee;103 regulations which mandate that there is a govt. nominee in admission process, that fix merit criteria for minority students, or which mandate that the vacant seats shall go to non-minority students;104 etc.
177. Similarly, this Court has held that in a minority institution, there can be a sprinkling of outsiders in administration, and the mere presence of members of the non-minority community does not take away the minority character of the institution.105
178. However, at the same time, there is a core part of ‘administration’ that should remain in control of the minority community. As has been discussed before during the discussion on the conjunctive and disjunctive nature of the test incorporated within the text of 99 Very Rev. Mother Provincial, supra note 71, para 9-10; Gandhi Faiz-e-am-College v. University of Agra and Anr. (1975) 2 SCC 283, para 40; Kolawana Gram Vikas Kendra v. State of Gujarat and Anr.
(2010) 1 SCC 133.
100 All Saints High School v. Govt. of A.P. and Ors. (1980) 2 SCC 478, para 5. 101 TMA Pai Foundation, supra note 3, para 136 and 161; P.A. Inamdar, supra note 48. Para 94;Secy., Malankara Syrian Catholic College, supra note 51.
102 TMA Pai Foundation, supra note 3, para 161; Christian Medical College Vellore Assn. v. Union of India
(2020) 8 SCC 705.
103 P.A. Inamdar, supra note 48, Para 140; Modern School v. Union of India and Ors. (2004) 5 SCC 583; Father Thomas Shingare and Ors. v. State of Maharashtra and Ors. (2002) 1 SCC 758. 104 Andhra Kesari College of Education v. State of A.P. (2019) 9 SCC 457, para 6.9. 105 In Re: Kerala Education Bill, supra note 58; Society for Unaided Private Schools of Rajasthan v. Union of India (2012) 6 SCC 1, para 57.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1841Aligarh Muslim University v. Naresh Agarwal & Ors. Article 30 (Issue III), this is necessary to prevent the potential misuse of this provision. The question that now arises is when would ‘administration’ be said to have been taken away from the minority community?
179. To this end, the very concept of ‘administration’ is inherently fluid, and a specific definition is likely to be under inclusive. Determining whether a minority community exercises control over an institution is a factual question that varies from case to case. Although there is no definitive test to ascertain whether administration lies with the minority community, various judicial precedents provide indicators that may be considered relevant.
180. Similar to the test to determine ‘establishment’, these indicators alone may not conclusively establish whether the administration rests with the minority community. Instead, a cumulative and holistic analysis of these factors can assist the court in making its determination.
181. To instantiate, illustrative factors which are likely to take away administration of minority community from the institution include, inter alia:
i. Management staff is not answerable to the founders, or an external person has veto over their selection.106 The lack of control over such selection would have significant weight since it is a post of prime importance around which administration revolves, i.e., he/she is the hub on which all spokes of the institution’s wheels are set around.107 ii. There are outside authorities in the governing body of the managing committee108 with wide powers over the other members;109 106 Very Rev. Mother Provincial, supra note 71, para 19. 107 Secy., Malankara Syrian Catholic College, supra note 51, para 22-28; Board of Secondary Education and Teachers Training v. Jt. Director of Public Instructions (1998) 8 SCC 555, para 3; Ivy C.Da. Conceicao v. State of Goa and Ors. (2017) 3 SCC 619, para 16; The Manager, Corporate Educational Agency v. James Mathew and Ors. (2017) 15 SCC 595; R. Sulochana Devi v. D.M. Sujatha & Ors. (2005) 9 SCC 335, para 26.
108 Dr. T. Varghese George, supra note 73, para 37.
109 All Saints High School, supra note 100.
1842 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports iii. Minority community does not have any right over determining the overall fee structure of the institution;110 iv. Minority community does not have the final say over administration, such that over the management committee comprising of members of the minority community, there is an appeal to an outside member;111 v. Minority community does not have any say over the medium of instruction;112 vi. Regulation prescribes reservation for unaided minority institutions;113 vii. Minority community does not have the right to choose the governing body and to choose teachers or admit students;114 viii. Removal of an employee requires the approval of an outside member who has the discretion to withhold such consent;115 ix. The minority community does not have a say in appointment of administrative authorities of the university such as the Vice Chancellor, Pro-Vice Chancellor, Registrar etc.;
x. The minority institution entirely depends on government aid; and xi. The minority community does not have the right to deploy properties and assets for the benefit of the institution.116
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.