Ramachandran & Ors. v. Vijayan & Ors.
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 885; [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1013
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice C.T. Ravikumar, Justice Sanjay Karol
- Decided
- 22 Nov 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2161/2012
- Sections
- 2(3), 631, 3, 77, 38, 38(2), 6, 39, 22(1)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1013 : 2024 INSC 885 Ramachandran & Ors.
v.
Vijayan & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 2161 of 2012)
22 November 2024 [C.T. Ravikumar and Sanjay Karol,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose with respect to the devolution of property by way of Marumakkathayam law. Nature and character of the scheduled properties. Whether the property obtained by a female and her children after partition would be considered their separate property or would it belong to her tharwad; whether, in the present facts, ‘PA’ had the legal right to transfer the entire property of her son to her daughter-in-law and grandchildren by way of a mortgage deed or was her right only limited to one-sixth of the property as contended by the original defendants.
Headnotes† Madras Marumakkattayam Act, 1932 – ss.3(j)(i), 38 – ‘thavazhi’ – The Travancore Nayar Regulation, II of 1100 – s.2(3) – Cochin Nayar Act, XXIX of 1113 – Parties governed by the Marumakkathayam law – Right of marumakkathayee female on partition – Whether the property obtained by a female and her children after partition would be considered their separate property or would it belong to her tharwad (a Marumakkathayam joint family comprising of a female ancestor, her children, her daughter’s children, her daughter’s daughter’s children and all such other descendants, however remote, in the female line):
Held: The minority opinion of the Full Bench of Kerala High Court in Mary Cheriyan case correctly holds that if at the time of partition the female is single, she continues to hold the property as her own, even if she has children in the future – Partition alters the nature of the property from, at one point being jointly held property or tharwad to a property held solely by her – In order for a thavazhi (branches of tharwad) to be formed, there has to be at least one female and her successive generation, either male or female, in *Author 1014 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the generation immediately succeeding and thereafter progeny of the female line – The majority view in Mary Cheriyan falters for in their understanding one single female is sufficient to form a thavazhi – ‘PA’ and her descendants formed a thavazhi and had received the scheduled properties under item No.1 collectively (two sets of scheduled properties being item No.1 and item No.2) – Further, the divergence of opinion between the minority and majority was in respect of single female(s) receiving property in partition which is not the case here – All five Judges were ad idem when it comes to property being received at partition by females and members of her thavazhi – Since the properties were received by the thavazhi and not by a woman who is single, the property is unquestionably tharwad property – The fact that branch 5 (‘PA’ and her children) held the property jointly is supported by the fact that the compromise deed, which granted them the said property, was never challenged – The appointment of one of the sons of ‘PA’ as karanavan also manifests the intention that the parties wished to jointly hold the property as tharwad – The original defendants’ reliance on the minority view is thus, misplaced as the difference of opinion was only with respect to inheritance by single females and not thavazhis – Though on the point of law, the minority view of the Full Bench of the Kerala High Court in Mary Cheriyan case is upheld, on facts, the finding about which all five judges were ad idem applies – The pronouncement of law in this judgment to apply prospectively – Preliminary decree passed by the Trial Court and upheld by the High Court affirmed. [Paras 32, 43, 45-47, 58] Marumakkathayam law – Devolution of property – Whether, in the present facts, ‘PA’ had the legal right to transfer the entire property of her son to her daughter-in-law and grandchildren by way of a mortgage deed or was her right only limited to one-sixth of the property as contended by the original defendants: Held: ‘PA’, after the death of her son ‘P’, received the property in her own right – Apart from a few transactions, no other evidence was placed on record to prove that property was Putravakasha and not Marumakkathayam - ‘PA’ executed the mortgage deed in favour of her daughter-in-law and her minor children – The possession was given to the mortgagee and it was never redeemed – Trial Court held that as per the evidence on record the plaint schedule second item property also belonged to the tavazhy of ‘PA’ – Findings with respect to schedule properties in item No.2 concurred by High Court – Concurrent findings of fact not disturbed. [Paras 49, 53, 57] [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1015Ramachandran & Ors. v. Vijayan & Ors. Constitution of India – Article 136 – Exercise of power under, interference with concurrent findings of fact – When – Discussed.
Marumakkathayam Customary Law – Concepts of – Discussed. Words and Phrases – ‘Partition’ – Discussed – Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
Case Law Cited Mary Cheriyan & Anr. v. Bhargavi Pillai Bhasura Devi & Anr, 1967 SCC OnLine Ker 68 – minority view held correct.
Achuthan Nair v. Chinnamu Amma [1966] 1 SCR 454 : 1965 SCC OnLine SC 303; Srinivas Ram Kumar v. Mahabir Prasad and Ors. [1951] 1 SCR 277 : 1951 SCC 136; Sree Sree Iswar Gopal Jieu Thakur v. Pratapmal Bagaria [1951] 1 SCR 332 : AIR 1951 SCC 214; Addagada Raghavamma And Anr v. Addagada Chenchamma [1964] 2 SCR 933 : 1964 AIR SC 136; Variety Emporium v. V.R.M. Mohd. Ibrahim Naina [1985] 2 SCR 102 : (1985) 1 SCC 251; Indira Kaur v. Sheo Lal Kapoor (1988) 2 SCC 488; Mithilesh Kumari & Anr vs Prem Behari Khare [1989] 1 SCR 621 : (1989) 2 SCC 95; Sardar Jogendra Singh v. State of U.P. (2008) 17 SCC 133; Guljar Singh v. Dy. Director (Consolidation) [2009] 5 SCR 1080 : (2009) 12 SCC 590; Ghisalal v. Dhapubai [2011] 1 SCR 651 : (2011) 2 SCC 298; Sukhbiri Devi & ors v. Union of India & Ors. [2022] 13 SCR 523 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1322 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited K. Sreedhara Variar Marumakkathayam and Allied Systems of law in the Kerala State, First Edition, 1969; Advanced Law Lexicon, Third Edition; Travancore Nayar Regulation.
List of Websites https://www.merriam-webster.com/; https://www.collinsdictionary. com/ List of Acts Madras Marumakkattayam Act, 1932; The Travancore Nayar Regulation, II of 1100; Cochin Nayar Act, XXIX of 1113; Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
1016 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports List of Keywords Marumakkathayam law; ‘tharwad’; ‘thavazhi’; ‘thavazhy’; ‘karanavan’; Scheduled properties; Devolution of property; Partition; Separate property; Mortgage deed; Marumakkathayee female; Minority opinion; Majority opinion; ad idem; Jointly held property; Single females; Inheritance by single females; Putravakasha; tavazhy; Divergence of opinion; Hindu Law; Mitakshara school of law; Descendants; Ancestral joint family property; Coparcenary property; Prospectively.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2161 of 2012 From the Judgment and Order dated 27.08.2009 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in AS No.563 of 1999 Appearances for Parties CS Vaidyanathan, Chitambaresh, Sr. Advs., A. Raghunath, Babu Malayil, Advs. for the Appellants.
Ms Vishnu Shankar, Atul Shankar Vinod, Dileep Pillai, Kannan Gopal Vinod, M. P. Vinod, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Sanjay Karol, J.
1. The instant appeal, preferred by the original defendants, assails the judgment dated 27.08.2009 passed by the High Court of Kerala in A.S. No. 563 of 1999 whereby the appeal was dismissed and the preliminary decree passed by the Trial Court in O.S.631/1999 was affirmed.
MARUMAKKATHAYAM CUSTOMARY LAW - AN INTRODUCTION
2. The present appeal concerns the devolution of property by way of traditional Marumakkathayam law. Prior to delving into the legal niceties, an understanding of certain foundation concepts is necessary.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1017Ramachandran & Ors. v. Vijayan & Ors.
3. The Hindu community being a vast and diverse community is governed by different schools of personal laws. Apart from the dominant Mitakshara school of law, some communities among Hindus have their own system of personal law like the Marumakkathayam law, the Nambudiri law or the Aliyasantana law. In the issue at hand, parties are admittedly governed by the Marumakkathayam law. With respect to Marumakkathayam law, this Court has stated in Achuthan Nair v. Chinnamu Amma1:
“6. …The said law [Marumakathayam law] governs a large section of people inhabiting the West-Coast of South India. “Marumakkathayam” literally means descent through sisters’ children. There is a fundamental difference between Hindu law and Marumakkathayam law in that, the former is founded on agnatic relationship while the latter is based on matriarchate. The relevant principles of Marumakkathayam law are well settled and, therefore, no citation is called for...”
4. Under this law, tharwad, thavazhi, karanavan are dominant concepts with respect to joint family. A tharwad is a Marumakkathayam joint family comprising of a female ancestor, her children, her daughter’s children, her daughter’s daughter’s children and all such other descendants, however remote, in the female line. By necessary exclusion, only the immediate male heir is part of the tharwad while his progeny are not. A person belongs to tharwad of his or her mother only.2 Membership of a tharwad is acquired by virtue of birth alone and on death, his interest devolves upon the other members of the tharwad. Members of a tharwad do not have a fixed interest but a fluctuating one, subject to change as per the number of members of the tharwad. Unlike coparcenary in Mitakshara law which extends to three generations succeeding the last male holder of the property, the Marumakkathayam system gives equal rights to all persons, however remote.
1 [1966] 1 SCR 454 : 1965 SCC OnLine SC 303 2 K. Sreedhara Variar Marumakkathayam and Allied Systems of law in the Kerala State, First Edition, 1969 1018 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
5. A tharwad is a larger body which holds within itself many branches. These branches are known as thavazhi which is a group of descendants in the female line of a female common ancestor. A thavazhi can own properties, separate and distinct from tharwad properties. In other words, a marumakkathayee woman alongwith her children and further descendants, how low-soever, in a female line constitute thavazhi.
The concepts discussed above would be best explained by way of illustrations as under:
ILLUSTRATION :
A AH AD1 AD2 C C1 C2 B AS AS1 A is married to AH. They have three children- two daughters, AD1 and AD2, and a son, AS. All members shown above with the exception of AS1 form the tharwad of A. This is in line with the matrilineal succession or in other words, the female being the ‘stock of descent’. AD2 with her children C, the daughter and B, the son and grandchildren C1 and C2 forms a thavazhi.
6. A karanavan is a manager of a joint family property. It is the oldest male member of the family. However, this customary position does not exclude a woman from managing the affairs of the tharwad or thavazhi if no male member is capable of taking up the required duties. Under Madras Marumakkattayam Act, 1932, it is defined as under: [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1019Ramachandran & Ors. v. Vijayan & Ors. “ Section 3(c) ‘karanavan’ means the oldest male member of a tarwad or tavazhi, as the case may be, in whom the right to management of its properties vests or, in the absence of a male member, the oldest female member or where by custom or family usage the right to such management vests in the oldest female member, such female member;”
7. This Court explained the position of karanavan in Achuthan Nair v. Chinnamu Amma (supra)3:
“7. ..The management of a tarwad or tavazhi ordinarily vests in the eldest male member of the tarwad or tavazhi, as the case may be. But there are instances where the eldest female member of a tarwad or a tavazhi is the manager thereof. The male manager is called the karnavan and the female one, karnavati. A karnavati or karnavan is a representative of the tarwad or tavazhi and is the protector of the members thereof. He or she stands in a fiduciary relationship with the members thereof. … But it is settled law that if a property is acquired in the name of the karnavan, there is a strong presumption that it is a tarwad property and that the presumption must hold good unless and until it is rebutted by acceptable evidence.” (Emphasis supplied)
It is to be noted that, the position does not grant any special rights in the property and these rights standard part with any other member of the joint family.
BRIEF FACTS
8. The facts which are necessary to dispose of the appeal are presented hereinbelow. For ease of understanding, a chart representing the genealogy is produced:
3 [1966] 1 SCR 454 : 1965 SCC OnLine SC 303 1020 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1021Ramachandran & Ors. v. Vijayan & Ors.
9. The dispute relates to the property of one Parukutty Amma. Parukutty Amma had four children namely Karunakara Menon, Neelakanta Menon, Narayani Amma and Amukutty Amma. Narayani Amma had four children namely, Kamalakshy, Aravindakshy Amma, Ramachandran and Padmavathi Amma. The husband and children of one of these four, Padmavathi Amma, are the plaintiffs. All other children and grandchildren of Parukutty Amma are the defendants except Padmavathy Amma. The defendants, having concurrently lost before all the courts below, are appellants herein. For ease of reference, the parties shall be referred, as per their position before the Trial Court.
10. A suit for partition and separate possession (O.S. No.631/1993) was filed by Plaintiffs no. 1-8 against Defendants before the Addl. Sub Court, Ernakulam4 for dividing the plaint scheduled properties belonging to Andipillil Tharwad by metes and bounds into 16 shares. Before us, the challenge pertains to two sets of scheduled properties- Item no.1 and Item no.2. Some preliminary understanding is required of how the properties subject matter of dispute came to be divided into two heads.
10.1 Item No.1: The property is situated in Ponnurunni Desom of Poonithura village and was part of the erstwhile Cochin state. It was gifted by one Krishna Menon in favour of 11 members of the same tharwad vide gift deed no.1223/1099. One of the donees, Ayyappa Menon filed a suit for partition5 of the said property against other donees. During the pendency of the suit, parties thereto entered into a compromise, and a partition deed giving effect to such compromise was executed dated 1.11.1950. The property was divided amongst nine donees as two, namely, Ravunni Nair and Madhavi Amma had passed away and it was mutually allotted to five branches as shown below:- 4 hereinafter referred to as ‘Trial Court’ 5 (O.S.77/1125)
1022 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Ayyapa Menon (Branch 1)
Parameswara Menon (Branch 2)
Govinda Meon (Branch 3)
Raghava Menon (Branch 4)
Branch 5 Parukutty Amma and her children namely, Karunakara Menon, Neelakanda Menon, Narayani Amma and Ammukutty Amma 10.2 Item no.2: There was one Sankar Padmanabhan, on his demise, half of his property devolved on his wife, Parukutty Amma and their children; and another half on his mother, Parvathy Amma. His mother subsequently transferred her interest in the said property in favour of Parukutty Amma and her children through a mortgage deed.
TRIAL COURT
11. The Trial Court framed as many as eleven issues. Below is a tabulated representation of the eleven issues and their corresponding findings. Sr.
No.
Issue Finding Decision
1. Whether the suit is time barred?
The plaintiffs can ignore the partition deeds since they are not binding on them, as execution of partition deeds by some of the members will not take away their right.
No
2. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties?
The assignees of a partition of the plaint schedule properties were impleaded as additional defendants after the issues were framed.
No
3. Whether the plaint schedule first item property was the property of Andippillil Taravadu?
The executants of the partition deed formed a natural group of Marumakkathayees, that is, the matrilineal heirs, and this led to the conclusion that the property was tharwad property.
Decided in
FAVOUR
of the Plaintiffs.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1023Ramachandran & Ors. v. Vijayan & Ors.
4. Whether the Plaint Schedule second item property was the property of Andippillil Taravadu?
Property belonged to the thavazhi of Parvathy, as it was allotted to her and her son as per the recitals in the mortgage deed. The plaint schedule second item property thus belonged to the thavazhi of Parukutty Amma (through Parvathy’s son, Padmanabhan), as the property, obtained through a mortgage deed, was in the possession and enjoyment of the children of Parakutty Amma.
Decided in
FAVOUR
of the Plaintiffs.
5. Whether the alienations made by Neelakanta Menon are valid?
In Ammalu Amma and others v.
Lakshmi Amma and other (1966 KLT 32) a Full Bench of the High Court held that the undivided interest of a member of a thavazhi cannot be alienated.
So the alienations made by Neelakanta Menon are void.
No
6. Whether partition deed No.6143/1981 is binding on the plaintiffs?
Both items 1 and 2 were thavazhi properties the partition deed executed by 3 members alone does not bind the other members of the thavazhi.
No
7. Whether the alienations made by defendants 1 and 2 are binding on the plaintiffs?
The executants of partition deed did not have exclusive title to the properties and that document is not binding on the other members of the thavazhi. Hence, the subsequent transactions are also not binding on the other members.
No
8. Whether the alienation made by the 8th defendant is binding on the plaintiffs?
This transaction is also not binding on the other members of the thavazhi, as the property was a thavazhi property.
No 1024 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
9. What is the share (if any)
to which each of the co-owners is entitled in the plaint schedule properties?
Defendants 1 to 8 and plaintiffs 1 to7 are entitled to 1/15 shares.
1/15 share
10. What is the amount (if any) to which defendants 13 and 15 to 17 are entitled as value of improvements?
There is no evidence to show that they have made improvements to the properties thus, no relief can be granted to them even if there was any entitlement.
None
11. What is the order as to costs?
-- Costs to be borne out of the estate.
12. It was concluded that the properties were tharwad property. A preliminary decree was passed allotting one share each to defendants 1-7 and plaintiffs 2-8 and one share to defendants 9-14 altogether. The relevant extract reads thus:
“In the result, a preliminary decree is passed in the following terms :-
1. The plaint schedule properties will be divided by metes and bounds into 15 shares.
2. Defendants 1 to 7 and plaintiffs 2 to 8 are entitled to one share each. Additional defendants 9 to 14 together are entitled to one share.
3. The plaintiffs will be put in possession of their joint 7/15 share.
4. The fifth defendant will be put in possession of her share.
[2024] 11 S.C.R. 1025Ramachandran & Ors. v. Vijayan & Ors.
5. The plaintiffs and fifth defendant are allowed to realize their share of income out of the shares of the other co-owners who will be liable proportionate to their shares.
6. The quantum of the share of income will be decided in the final decree proceedings
7. The costs shall come out of the estate”
13. For adjudication of the dispute before this Court, the findings returned in issues 3 and 4 are pertinent and the same are discussed in detail in the coming paragraphs.
14. In respect of item No.1, it was held that even though there was no evidence as to the original source of the property gifted by Krishna Menon, but the fact that the partition deed was executed by a natural group of Marumakkatayees led to the conclusion that the property was tharwad property. Parukutty Amma and her children forming part of a thavazhi and therefore being entitled to the property as members of the fifth branch is strengthened by the fact that the fifth branch comprising them was mentioned in the partition deed as a branch of Karunakaran Menon who was the Karnavan of the thavazhy. As such the conclusion drawn was that the property under item No. 1 was the thavazhi property of the fifth branch.
15. Issue no.4 before the Trial Court was in regard to item No.2. While answering in the affirmative, it was held that the said property would be tharwad property. Reasoning therefor was derived from the deed executed by Parvathy Amma in favour of Parukutty Amma and her children. The deed records that the former became the absolute owner of the property once Sankaran Padmanabhan died. Having become the absolute owner, she executed the said mortgage deed. Since Parvathy Amma was the absolute owner, she transferred the said property to her daughter-in-law and her successors.
HIGH COURT
16. The High Court, qua item No.1, has held that the share allotted to a female on partition retains the tharwad characteristic. It further held that since after the passing away of Madhavi Amma and Ravunni Nair, two of the eleven persons upon whom the property originally devolved, it was divided amongst nine surviving co-donees in 1950. 1026 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports It is clear that even at this point in time, the method adopted for succession was in line with the property being thavazhi in nature. It also relied on the testimony of DW-1 who deposed that Parukutty Amma and her children were separated as one thavazhi in the above-mentioned partition of 1950.
17. Qua item No.2, it was observed:
“The document is in favour of Parukutty Amma and her minor children. This mortgage was never redeemed by Parvathy Amma. Under the Prestine Marumakkathayam Law acquisition of a property in the name of mother and children who form a natural group had always been presumed to be on behalf of the tavazhi and even the existence of an original nucleus was not considered essential.
…Since the acquirers under Ext.A2 mortgage namely Parukutty Amma and her minor children formed a natural group, the property would enure to all the members of the tavazhi of Parukutty Amma. It is pertinent in this connection to note that in Ext.B3 partition dated 28-10- 1981 as per which Karunakara Menon, Narayani Amma and Ammukutty Amma are alleged to have divided the property to the exclusion of the other tavazhi members including the plaintiffs, the title which is traced to plaint A schedule item No. 2 is ExtA2 mortgage and not ExtB 11 gift deed. This also re-inforces the plaintiffs’ case that this item was acquired by Parukutty Aroma and her children as per ExtA2 mortgage.”
and then concluded that since the acquirers under mortgage deed, namely, Parukutty Amma and her children formed a natural group the property would enure to all the members of the thavazhy of Parukutty Amma.
18. In terms of the above, the decree of the Trial Court stood confirmed by the High Court.
ARGUMENTS OF PARTIES
19. Learned Senior Counsel Mr. C.S. Vaidyanathan for the originaldefendants/appellants submitted that the scheduled properties are [2024] 11 S.C.R. 1027Ramachandran & Ors. v. Vijayan & Ors. not thavazhy property. It is submitted that item No.1 is a co-ownership property and item No.2 is a Putravakasam property. In so far as scheduled properties under item No.1 are concerned, the learned senior counsel submitted that the minority view expressed by the full Bench of the Kerala High Court in Mary Cheriyan & Anr. v. Bhargavi Pillai Bhasura Devi & Anr.6 should, in fact, be held as the correct view having regard to the difficulties of law noted by this Court in Achuthan Nair (supra).
20. For properties mentioned under item No.2, it is submitted that the property originally belonged to Kadangad Sankaran Padmanabhan and his mother could only execute gift deed as well as mortgage deed only to the extent of her own share and not the share of Padmanabhan.
21. Learned Counsel Mr. M.P. Vinod for the original plaintiffs/respondents submitted that a new tharwad is formed when a female member and all her children jointly receive properties by gift from another Marumakathayee. With respect to item No.1, it is submitted that when a share was allotted to the natural thavazhy vide partition deed dated 01.11.1950, then such natural thavazhy will also have the characteristics of a tharwad property. For item No.2, reliance is placed on partition deed 6143/1981 wherein it is specifically stated that Parvathy Amma became the sole owner after the death of her son thus she could validly transfer her share to Parukutty Amma and her children.
ISSUES
22. We have gone through the detailed pleadings of the parties. The bone of contention is the nature and character of the scheduled properties. After carefully going through the pleadings, the following two questions require adjudication :
1. Whether the property obtained by a female and her children after partition would be considered their separate property or would it belong to her tharwad?
2. Whether, in the present facts, Parvathy Amma had the legal right to transfer the entire property of her son to her daughter- 6 1967 SCC OnLine Ker 68 1028 [2024] 11 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in-law and grandchildren by way of a mortgage deed or was her right only limited to one-sixth of the property as contended by the original defendants?
APPRECIATION OF LAW
23. The case of plaintiffs is that scheduled properties being tharwad properties and they being members of the same are entitled to seek partition whereas defendants deny this claim.
Issue 1
24. This issue deals with the right of marumakkathayee female on partition. Partition is a process by which joint ownership is reduced to individual ownership. It puts an end to the joint status, separating members who hold their respective shares, which, on their death, will devolve upon their heirs. Under mitakshara law, if a member continues to be joint with his own male issue then the share allotted to him retains the characteristic of coparcenary property.
25. However, in Marumakkathayam law, as per the original defendants the position of law has been incorrectly settled.
26. The answer to the first question (supra), was answered, favouring the latter by the majority of the Full Bench of Kerala High Court in Mary Cheriyan (supra) but since the original-defendants are placing their reliance on minority opinion, we deem it necessary and appropriate to discuss all opinions expressed therein.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.