Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax
- Citation
- 2024 INSC 781; [2024] 10 S.C.R. 860
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Pankaj Mithal
- Decided
- 16 Oct 2024
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3291/2009
- Sections
- 28, 18, 19, 20, 21, 263, 14, 36(1), 37, 56, 57, 24(2)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:24 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 860 : 2024 INSC 781 Bank of Rajasthan Ltd.
v.
Commissioner of Income Tax (Civil Appeal Nos. 3291-3294 of 2009)
16 October 2024 [Abhay S. Oka* and Pankaj Mithal, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards the treatment to be given to broken period interest, whether a deduction of the broken period interest can be claimed by the Bank, purchaser of the government Securities. Headnotes† Income Tax Act, 1961 – s.28 – Interest on securities – Interest on Held to Maturity (HTM) government securities – Interest for the broken period, if allowed as a deduction:
Held: As the securities were treated as stock-in-trade, the interest on the broken period cannot be considered as capital expenditure and will have to be treated as revenue expenditure, which can be allowed as a deduction – Whether the Bank holds the HTM security as investment or stock-in-trade will depend on the facts of each case – If it is found that HTM Security is held as an investment, the benefit of broken period interest will not be available and if it is held as a trading asset, deduction for broken period interest can be claimed – If deduction on account of broken period interest is not allowed, the broken period interest as capital expense will have to be added to the acquisition cost of the securities, which will then be deducted from the sale proceeds when such securities are sold in the subsequent years – Profit earned from the sale would be reduced by the amount of broken period interest. [Paras 20, 21, 24-30] Case Law Cited Vijaya Bank Ltd. v. Additional Commissioner of IncomeTax, Bangalore (1991) Supp 2 SCC 147; American Express International Banking Corporation v. Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr (2002) 258 ITR 601 (Bombay) : 2002 SCC OnLine Bom 944; Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay v. Citi Bank NA Civil Appeal * Author [2024] 10 S.C.R. 861Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax No. 1549 of 2006; Commissioner of Income Tax, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad v. The Cocanada Radhaswami Bank Ltd., Kakinada (1965) 57 ITR 306 : 1965 SCC OnLine SC 186; United Commercial Bank Ltd., Calcutta v. Commissioner of Income Tax, West Bengal (1957) 32 ITR 688 : 1957 SCC OnLine SC 74; Commissioner of Income Tax, Jalandhar v. Nawanshahar Central Cooperative Bank Ltd (2007) 289 ITR 6 : (2007) 15 SCC 611; Bihar State Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax (1960) 39 ITR 114 : 1960 SCC OnLine SC 193; M/s. Radhasoami Satsang, Saomi Bagh, Agra v. Commissioner of Income Tax [1991] Supp. 2 SCR 312 : (1992) 193 ITR 321: (1992) 1 SCC 659; Commissioner of Income Tax (Central), Calcutta v. Associated Industrial Development Company (P) Ltd., Calcutta (1972) 4 SCC 447; HDFC Bank Ltd. v. CIT (2014) 366 ITR 505 – referred to.
List of Acts Banking Regulation Act, 1949; Income Tax Act, 1961; Finance Act, 1988.
List of Keywords Broken period interest; Deduction of broken period interest; Purchaser of the government securities; Interest on securities; Interest on Held to Maturity (HTM) government securities; Stock-in-trade; Capital expenditure; Revenue expenditure; HTM Security; Investment.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 3291-3294 of 2009 From the Judgment and Order dated 24.03.2008 of the High Court of Rajasthan at Jodhpur in ITA Nos. 12, 117, 119 and 120 of 2005 With Civil Appeal Nos. 11200-11201, 11202, 11203, 11204, 11205, 11196, 11197, 11198 and 11199 of 2024 And Civil Appeal No. 4755 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Balbir Singh, A.S.G., Sanjay Jhanwar, Jehangir Mistri, Sr. Advs., Ms. Kavita Jha, Anant Mann, Aditya Rathore, Naman Tandon, Samarvir Singh, Shyam Gopal, Raj Bahadur Yadav, H R Rao, 862 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Prahlad Singh, Manoj Mishra, Ms. Kritgya Kait, Rupesh Kumar, Zoheb Hussain, Satya Prakash Gautam, Sridhar Potaraju, Aayush, Rajat Srivastava, Ms. Zeba Zoariah, Sanjay Kapur, Surya Prakash, Ms. Divya Singh Pundir, Tarun Gupta, Rajat Sharma, Aryan Singh Chaudhary, Gaurav Asati, Sanjiv M. Shah, Pranab Kumar Mullick, Mrs. Soma Mullick, Ms. Banani Sikdar, Sebat Kumar Deuria, Anil Rana, Advs. for the appearing parties.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Abhay S. Oka, J.
1. Leave granted in the Special Leave Petitions.
FACTUAL ASPECTS
2. The main issue in this group of appeals is about the treatment to be given to broken period interest. The question is whether a deduction of the broken period interest can be claimed. We must provide a brief background of how the issue arises.
3. A Scheduled Bank is governed by the provisions of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (for short, “the 1949 Act”). The 1949 Act, read with the guidelines of the Reserve Bank of India (for short, ‘RBI’), requires Banks to purchase government securities to maintain the Statutory Liquidity Ratio (for short, ‘SLR’). The guidelines dated 16 th October 2000 issued by the RBI categorise the government securities into the following three categories: (a) Held to Maturity (HTM);
(b) Available for Sale (AFS); and (c) Held for Trading (HFT).
4. The interest on the securities is paid by the Government or the authorities issuing securities on specific fixed dates called coupon dates, say after an interval of six months. When a Bank purchases a security on a date which falls between the dates on which the interest is payable on the security, the purchaser Bank, in addition to the price of the security, has to pay an amount equivalent to the interest accrued for the period from the last interest payment till the date of purchase. This interest is termed as the interest for the broken period. When the interest becomes due after the purchase of the security by the Bank, interest for the entire period is paid to the purchaser Bank, including the broken period interest. Therefore, in effect, the purchaser of securities gets interest from a date anterior [2024] 10 S.C.R. 863Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax to the date of acquisition till the date on which interest is first due after the date of purchase.
5. Under the Income Tax Act, 1961 (for short, ‘the IT Act’), Section 18, which was repealed by the Finance Act, 1988, dealt with tax leviable on the interest on securities. Section 19 provided for the deduction of (i) expenses in realising the interest and (ii) the interest payable on the money borrowed for investment. Section 20 dealt with the deduction of (i) expenses in realising the interest and (ii) the interest payable on money borrowed for investment in the case of a Banking company. Section 21 provided that the interest payable outside India was not admissible for deduction. Sections 18 to 21 were repealed by the Finance Act, 1988, effective from 1st April 1989. We are dealing with cases involving the period post the deletion of the four Sections.
6. In Civil Appeal Nos.3291-3294 of 2009, which is the lead case, the appellant-assessee is a Scheduled Bank. The appellant was engaged in the purchase and sale of government securities. The securities were treated as stock-in-trade in the hands of the appellant. The amount received by the appellant on the sale of the securities was considered for computing its business income. The appellant consistently followed the method of setting off and netting the amount of interest paid by it on the purchase of securities (i.e., interest for the broken period) against the interest recovered by it on the sale of securities and offering the net interest income to tax. The result is that if the entire purchase price of the security, including the interest for the broken period is allowed as a deduction, then the entire sale price of the security is taken into consideration for computing the appellant’s income. According to the appellant’s case, the assessing officer allowed this settled practice while passing regular assessment orders for the assessment years 1990-91 to 1992-93. However, the Commissioner of Income Tax (for short, ‘CIT’) exercised jurisdiction under Section 263 of the IT Act and interfered with the assessment orders. The CIT held that the appellant was not entitled to the deduction of the interest paid by it for the broken period. The Commissioner relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd. v. Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, Bangalore.1 This Court held that under the head “interest on securities”, the interest for a broken period was not an allowable 1 (1991) Supp (2) SCC 147 864 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports deduction. Being aggrieved by the orders of the CIT, the appellant preferred an appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (for short, ‘Appellate Tribunal’). The Tribunal allowed the appeal by holding that the decision of this Court in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd. 1 was rendered after considering Sections 18 to 21 of the IT Act, which have been repealed. Therefore, the Tribunal held that as the appellant was holding the securities as stock-in-trade, the entire amount paid by the appellant for the purchase of such securities, which included interest for the broken period, was deductible. The respondent Department preferred an appeal before the High Court against the decision of the Appellate Tribunal. By the impugned judgment, the High Court interfered and, relying upon the decision of this Court in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd.,1 allowed the appeal. This order was impugned in Civil Appeal Nos. 3291-3294 of 2009.
7. All other appeals that are the subject matter of this group are preferred by the Revenue. These are the cases where the deduction of interest for the broken period was allowed.
8. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant in Civil Appeal Nos. 3291-3294 of 2009 and learned counsel representing the respondents/ Banks in other appeals have made extensive submissions. The submissions made by the learned counsel appearing for the assessees can be summarised as follows:
a. Reliance was placed on a decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of American Express International Banking Corporation v. Commissioner of Income Tax & Anr. 2 Learned counsel pointed out that in the said decision, the Bombay High Court distinguished the decision in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd.1 by holding that in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd.,1 the claim for deduction of interest on broken period was made under Sections 19 and 20 of the IT Act. This was done on the footing that the Department had brought to tax the interest accrued on the securities up to the date of purchase as “interest on securities” under Section 18. It was held that the decision in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd.1 will not apply to the cases postrepeal of Sections 18 to 21 of the IT Act. In the said case, the amount of interest was brought into tax under Section 28. 2 (2002) 258 ITR 601 (Bombay) : 2002 SCC OnLine Bom 944 [2024] 10 S.C.R. 865Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax b. The learned counsel appearing for the assessees pointed out that the view taken by the Bombay High Court in the case of American Express International Banking Corporation2 has been approved by the order dated 12 th August 2008 of this Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay v. Citi Bank NA.3 The learned counsel pointed out that this Court affirmed the decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of Citi Bank NA, 3 which in turn relied upon its earlier decision in the case of American Express International Banking Corporation.2 c. Our attention was also invited to a decision by this Court in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad v. The Cocanada Radhaswami Bank Ltd., Kakinada.4 Inviting our attention to the said decision, it is pointed out that this Court accepted that the securities held by Banking companies are held as stock-in-trade. He pointed out that this Court, in the case of United Commercial Bank Ltd.; Calcutta v. Commissioner of Income Tax, West Bengal,5 held that government securities are held as stock-in-trade by Banking companies. He submitted that the assessee pays interest for the broken period to which he is not entitled as after the purchase, when the interest becomes due, the assessee gets income for the entire period even covering the interest payable before the date on which the assessee makes the acquisition. It is submitted that there cannot be any dispute that such securities held by Banking companies constitute stock-in-trade. He submitted that in the case of Commissioner of Income Tax, Jalandhar v. Nawanshahar Central Cooperative Bank Ltd.,6 it was held that investments are a part of the Banking business, particularly when statutorily mandated. It was submitted that Banking companies buy government securities to comply with SLR requirements. d. It is well-settled that in the Banking business, securities purchased by Banks, per se, constitute stock-in-trade of the Bank 3 Civil Appeal No. 1549 of 2006 4 (1965) 57 ITR 306 : 1965 SCC OnLine SC 186 5 (1957) 32 ITR 688 : 1957 SCC OnLine SC 74
6 (2007) 289 ITR 6 : (2007) 15 SCC 611
866 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports as normal and ordinary Banking business is to deal in money credit. The money is parked in readily marketable securities so that it is available to meet the demand of depositors. This argument is supported by a decision of this Court in the case of Bihar State Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax.7 e. It was contended that when the interest income of securities is uniformly assessed under the head “profits and gains from business or profession”, the decision of this Court in the case of Citi Bank NA 3 will squarely apply. It was submitted that in the case of many Banks, for several assessment years, the assessment officer allowed the deduction of interest for the broken period. Reliance was placed on a decision of this Court in the case of M/s. Radhasoami Satsang, Saomi Bagh, Agra v. Commissioner of Income Tax.8 f. It was submitted that IndusInd Bank Ltd. is following a practice that interest accrued on a security but not due on the date of purchase of security is debited to the profit and loss account as expenditure and is claimed as such in return of income. The balance amount remaining after reducing the broken period interest is capitalised to the balance sheet covering the acquisition cost of such securities. It is submitted that the department has accepted the said methodology for several years. It was submitted that the exercise undertaken by Revenue in disallowing broken period interest on the footing that it is a capital expenditure is revenue neutral. It was pointed out that if the deduction of broken period interest as a capital expense is disallowed, it will have to be added to the acquisition cost of the securities, which will then be deducted from the sale proceeds when such securities are sold in the subsequent years. It was submitted that, consequently, the related interest received would have to be excluded from the income and truncated from the purchase cost, or alternatively, both the broken interest period and interest received thereof will be netted and added/subtracted from the cost of acquisition. Therefore, the exercise done by 7 (1960) 39 ITR 114 : 1960 SCC OnLine SC 193 8 [1991] Supp. 2 SCR 312 : (1992) 193 ITR 321 : (1992) 1 SCC 659 [2024] 10 S.C.R. 867Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax the Department is academic. It was submitted that the decision of this Court in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd.1 is per incuriam as it was rendered in ignorance of the decisions of this Court in the case of Cocanada Radhaswami Bank Ltd.4 Reliance was also placed on the Central Board of Direct Taxes (for short, “the CBDT”) Circular No. 665 of 1993.
g. It was also pointed out that though Banks are required to maintain SLR by investing amounts in specified securities, as long as Banks maintain a specified percentage of reserve, they are permitted to buy and sell such securities, irrespective of their categorisation. There is no embargo on the Bank to hold security in SLR up to the maturity date of the security. It was submitted that Banks always treat interest income from all securities as profit or loss, irrespective of the categorisation of investments. The interest on securities held by Banks is always taxed under the head “income from business or profession”. This contention is raised by HDFC Bank. It was submitted that in accordance with the well-settled and accepted method of accounting, the amount of broken period of interest which is debited in the profit and loss account of the Bank is claimed as a deduction while computing the income from business under the head “income from business and profession” as the entire interest income is offered to tax under the said head.
h. Reliance was placed on the RBI Circular dated 1 st July 2009, which permits the debit of broken period interest to the profit and loss account. Reliance was also placed on a Circular dated 2 nd November 2015 issued by the CBDT. The Circular provides that the investments made by a Banking company are a part of the business of the Bank. Therefore, income from such investments is attributable to the business of Banking falling under the head “profit and gain of business and profession”. i. It was submitted that assuming that as per the mandate of the 1949 Act, the securities are treated as investments in the books of accounts, it cannot be held that even for the purposes of the IT Act, securities would continue to be investments and not stock-in-trade. It was submitted that this Court has repeatedly held that the entries in the books of accounts are not relevant for determining the taxability under the provisions 868 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of the IT Act. Reliance is placed on the RBI Circular dated 1st July 2009, which provides that broken period interest is not to be capitalised as part of the cost and is required to be debited to the profit and loss account.
j. It is submitted that as required by the Banking Regulation Act, all three categories of securities are treated in the same manner, and there is no distinction between the securities which are HTM and the other two categories of securities. It was submitted that Banks can always shift the securities falling in the category of HTM to the other two categories.
k. It was further urged on behalf of the assessee that the plea based on distinguishing the nature of the treatment of SLR securities viz-a-viz non-SLR securities has been raised for the first time by the Revenue before this Court.
l. Considering the fact that securities are held as stock-in-trade, interest paid on them constitutes an expense which is liable to be claimed as a deduction.
9. The submission of learned ASG is that the broken period interest on security held to maturity constitutes an investment and, therefore, should be treated as capital expenditure. It was submitted that since HTM securities are held up to maturity for maintaining the SLR ratio and as the same are treated as investment in the books of accounts of Banks, the same should be treated as investment and not stock-in-trade. Another submission of ASG is that Circular No. 18 of 2015 applies only to non-SLR securities. Another submission of learned ASG is that the decision of Vijaya Bank Ltd. 1 would squarely apply as while omitting Sections 18 to 21, corresponding amendments have been made in Sections 28, 56(2)(d) and 57(3) of the IT Act, and the securities are now taxable under the head of “Income from other Sources”. Therefore, the principles laid down in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd. 1 will squarely apply. He argued that the increase in capital by the acquisition of securities results in the expansion of the Bank’s capital base, which helps in profit making. Therefore, the expenditure in the nature of broken period interest was capital expenditure. Learned ASG, thus, submitted that the assessees in these cases will not be entitled to a deduction of broken period interest.
[2024] 10 S.C.R. 869Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax
CONSIDERATION OF LEGAL POSITION
10. We deal with the legal position at the outset. As noted, Sections 18 to 21 were deleted from 1 st April 1989. In this group of appeals, we are not concerned with cases before the financial year 1988-89. Section 14 of the IT Act reads thus:
“14. Heads of income.— Save as otherwise provided by this Act, all income shall, for the purposes of charge of income-tax and computation of total income, be classified under the following heads of income:— A. —Salaries.
B. * * * * * C. —Income from house property.
D. —Profits and gains of business or profession.
E. —Capital gains.
F. —Income from other sources.”
Clause B was of “interest on securities”. It was deleted with effect from 1st April 1989 along with Sections 18 to 21, which dealt with interest on securities. Head ‘D’ is of income from “profits and gains of business or profession” covered by Section 28 of the IT Act. Profits and gains from any business or profession that the assessee carried out at any time during the previous year are chargeable to income tax. Under Section 36(1)(iii), the assessee is entitled to a deduction of the amount of interest paid in respect of capital borrowed for the purposes of the business or profession. Section 37 provides that any expenditure which is not covered by Sections 30 to 36 and not being in the nature of capital expenditure, laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the business or profession shall be allowed for computing the income chargeable under the head “profits and gains of business or profession”. Section 56 of the IT Act provides that income of every kind which is not to be excluded from the total income under the IT Act shall be chargeable to income tax under the head “income from other sources” if it is not chargeable to income tax under any of the five heads provided in Section 14. Therefore, interest on investments may be covered by Section 56. Section 57 provides for the deduction of expenditure not being in the nature of capital expenditure expended wholly and exclusively for the 870 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports purposes of making or earning such income. In the case of interest on securities, any reasonable sum paid for the purposes of realising interest is also entitled to deduction under Section 57 of the IT Act.
DECISIONS STARTING FROM THE CASE OF VIJAYA BANK LTD.1
11. The first decision which needs consideration is in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd.1 Regarding the facts of the said case, it must be noted that the income of the Bank was not assessed under Section 28 of the IT Act but under Section 18 under the Head “interest on securities”. In the context of the applicability of Section 18 of the IT Act, the Bank claimed that the broken period’s interest was deductible under Sections 19 and 20. In light of these facts, this Court held that the outlay on the purchase of income-bearing assets was a capital outlay. Therefore, no part of the capital outlay can be set off as expenditure against income from the asset in question.
12. A Division Bench of the Bombay High Court, in the case of American Express International Banking Corporation,2 dealt with the decision in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd.1 We are extensively referring to the decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of American Express International Banking Corporation2 for the reason that this Court in Citi Bank NA 3 has expressly approved the view of the Bombay High Court in the said decision. We may note that the Bombay High Court dealt with assessment years 1974-75 to 1977-78. This was a case where the assessee made adjustments for broken period interest. The assessing officer had disallowed the deduction for the payment made by the assessee for broken period interest. The assessing officer followed the decision in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd.1 The Bombay High Court distinguished the decision in the case of Vijaya Bank Ltd.1 and held thus:
“18. The assessee-Bank, like several other Banks, were consistently following the practice of valuing the securities/interest held by it at the end of each year and offer for taxation, the appreciation in their value by way of profit/interest earned due to efflux of time. The Bank also claimed deduction for broken period interest payments. However, the department did not accept the assessee’s method in the assessment year in question in view of the judgment of the Karnataka High Court in the case of (Commissioner of Income-tax, [2024] 10 S.C.R. 871Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax Mysore v. Vijaya Bank),5 reported in 1976 Tax Law Reporter page 524. This judgment has been subsequently upheld by the Supreme Court in 187 I.T.R. page 541. In view of the judgment of the Karnataka High Court, the department took the view that broken period interest payment cannot be allowed as a deduction because it came within the ambit of interest on securities under section 18 of the Income-tax Act. It is the contention of the department that the assessee-Bank received interest on Dated Government Securities from R.B.I. on half-yearly basis. That, the assessee Bank also traded in such securities. That the assessee Bank bought Dated Government Securities during the intervening period between two due dates. That, on purchase of the dated Government Security, the assessee became the holder of the security and accordingly, the assessee received half-yearly interest on the due dates from R.B.I. on purchase. Therefore, according to the department, the income which the assessee-Bank received came under section 18 of the Income-tax Act interest on securities. Under the circumstances, it was not open to the assessee Bank to claim deduction for broken period interest payment made to the selling/transferor Bank. That, it was not open to the assessee to claim deduction as revenue expenditure for broken period interest payment as no such deduction was permissible under sections 19 and 20 of the Income-tax Act. That, it was not a sum expended by the assessee for realizing interest under section 19 and, therefore, the assessee was not entitled to claim deduction for broken period interest payment as a revenue expenditure under section 28 of the Income-tax Act. In this connection, the department followed the judgment of the Karnataka High Court in Vijaya Bank’s case. Therefore, the point which we are required to consider in this case is: Whether the judgment of the Karnataka High Court in Vijaya Bank’s case was applicable to the facts of the present case.
19. Before going further we may mention at the very outset that the security in this case was of the face value of Rs. 5, 872 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports lakhs. It was bought for a lesser amount of Rs. 4,92,000.00. The difference was of Rs. 8,000.00. The assessee has revalued the security. The assessee offered the notional profit for taxation, as explained herein above, on accrual basis in the appropriate assessment year during which the assessee held the security. This difference could have been treated by the department as interest on securities under section 18. However, in the instant case, the department has assessed the said difference under, section 28 under the head “Business” and not under the head “interest on securities”. Having treated the difference under the head “Business”, the A.O. disallowed the broken period interest payment, which gave rise to the dispute. It was open to the department to assess the above difference under the head “interest on securities” under section 18. However, they chose to assess the interest under the head “business” and, while doing so, the department taxed broken period interest received, but disallowed broken period interest payment. It is in this light that one has to read the judgment of the Karnataka High Court and the Supreme Court in Vijaya Bank’s case. In that case, the facts were as follows. During the Assessment Year under consideration, Vijaya Bank entered into an agreement with Jayalakshmi Bank Limited, whereby Vijaya Bank took over the liabilities of Jayalakshmi Bank. They also took over assets belonging to Jayalakshmi Bank. These assets consisted of two items viz. Rs. 58,568.00 and Rs. 11,630.00. The said amount of Rs. 58,568.00 represented interest, which accrued on securities taken over by Vijaya Bank from Jayalakshmi Bank and Rs. 11,630.00 was the interest which accrued upto the date of purchase of securities by the assessee-Bank from the open market. These too amounts were brought to tax by the A.O. under section 18 of the Income-tax Act. The assessee Bank claimed that these amounts were deductible under sections 19 and 20. This was on the footing that the department had brought to tax, the aforestated two amounts as interest on securities under section 18. It is in the light of these facts that one has; to read the judgment in Vijaya Bank’s case. In the light of the above facts, it was held that outlay on purchase of income [2024] 10 S.C.R. 873Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax bearing asset was in the nature of capital outlay and no part of the capital outlay can be set off as expenditure against income accruing from the asset in question. In our case, the amount which the assessee received has been brought to tax under the head “business”
under section 28. The amount is not brought to tax under section 18 of the Income-tax Act. After bringing the amount to tax under the head “business”, the department taxed the broken period interest received on sale, but at the same time, disallowed broken period interest payment at the time of purchase and this led to the dispute. Having assessed the amount received by the assessee under section 28, the only limited dispute was whether the impugned adjustments in the method of accounting adopted by the assessee Bank should be discarded. Therefore, the judgment in Vijaya Bank’s case has no application to the facts of the present case. If the department had brought to tax, the amounts received by the assessee Bank under section 18, then Vijaya Bank’s case was applicable.
But,in the present case, the department brought to tax such amounts under section 28 right from the inception. Therefore, the Tribunal was right in coming to the conclusion that the judgment in Vijaya Bank’s case did not apply to the facts of the present case. However, before us, it was argued on behalf of the revenue that in view of the judgment in Vijaya Bank’s case, even if the securities were treated as part of the trading assets, the income therefrom had to be assessed under section 18 of the Act and not under section 28 of the Act as income from securities can only come within section 18 and not under section 28. We do not find any merit in this argument. Firstly, as stated above, Vijaya Bank’s case has no application to the facts of this case. Secondly, in the present case, the Tribunal has found that the securities were held as trading assets. Thirdly, it has been held by the Supreme Court in the subsequent decision reported in 57 I.T.R. Page 306, in the case of C.I.T. Andhra Pradesh v. Cocanada Radhaswami Bank Limited, that income from securities can also 874 [2024] 10 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports come under section 28 as income from business. This judgment is very important. It analyzes the judgment of the Supreme Court in UCO Bank’s case reported in 53 I.T.R. page 250, which has been followed by the Supreme Court in Vijaya Bank’s case. It is true that once an income falls under section 18, it cannot come under section 28. However, as laid down by the Supreme Court in Cocanada Radhaswami Bank’s case (supra), income from securities treated as trading assets can come under section 28. In the present case, the department has treated income from securities under section 28. Lastly, the facts in the case of UCO Bank reported in 53 I.T.R. page 250, also support our view in the present case. In UCO Bank’s case, the assessee Bank claimed a set off under section 24(2) of the Income-tax Act, 1922 (section 71(1) of the present Act) against its income from interest on securities under section 8 of the 1922 Act (similar to section 28 of the present Act). It was held that UCO Bank was not entitled to such a set off as the income from interest on securities came under section 8 of the 1922 Act.
Therefore, even in UCO Bank’s case, the department had assessed income from interest on securities right from the inception under section 8 of the 1922 Act and, therefore, the set-off was not allowed under, section 24(2) of the Act. Therefore, UCO Bank’s case has also no application to the facts of the present case in which the assessee's income from interest on securities is assessed under section 28 right from inception, in fact, in UCO Bank’s case, the matter was remitted back as it was contended on behalf of UCO Bank that the securities in question were a part of trading assets held by the assessee in the course of its business and the income by way of interest on such securities was assessable under section 10 of the Income-tax Act, 1922 (similar to section 28 of the present Act). It is for this reason that in the subsequent judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Radhaswami Bank Limited (supra), that the Supreme Court has observed, after reading UCO Bank’s case, that where securities [2024] 10 S.C.R. 875Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax were part of trading assets, income by way of interest on such securities could come under section 10 of the Income tax Act 1922.
20. In the light of what we have discussed hereinabove, we find that the assessee's method of accounting does not result in loss of tax/revenue for the department. That, there was no need to interfere with the method of accounting adopted by the assessee-Bank. That, the judgment in the case of Vijaya Bank had no application to the facts of the case. That, having assessed the income under section 28, the department ought to have taxed interest for broken period interest received and the department ought to have allowed deduction for broken period interest paid.” (emphasis added)
13. In the case of Citi Bank NA,3 the question before this Court was whether interest paid for the broken period should not be considered part of the purchase price and whether it should be allowed as revenue expenditure in the year of purchase of securities. In this decision, this Court quoted the above paragraphs from the decision of the Bombay High Court in the case of American Express International Banking Corporation.2 This Court expressly approved the conclusions recorded by the Bombay High Court. This Court held thus:
“The facts in the present case are similar to the facts in American Express (supra).Agreeing with this view and accepting the distinction pointed out by the Bombay High Court, this Court dismissed the two special leave petitions filed by the revenue, one of which was dismissed by a three Judge Bench.
After going through the facts which are similar to the facts in American Express (supra), since the tax effect is neutral, the method of computation adopted by the assessee and accepted by the revenue cannot be interfered with. We agree with the view expressed by the Bombay High Court in American Express (supra) that on the facts of the present case, the judgment in Vijaya Bank Ltd. (supra) would have no application.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.