Ravi Mandal v. State of Uttarakhand
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 552; [2023] 7 S.C.R. 1
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Hrishikesh Roy, Justice Manoj Misra Penal Code, Justice 1860 – Ss. 302, Justice 34 and 201 – Arms Act
- Decided
- 18 May 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 511/2011
- Sections
- 302, 34, 201, 161, 313, 25, 4, 60, 82
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 1[2023] 7 S.C.R. 1
RAVI MANDAL
v.
STATE OF UTTARAKHAND
(Criminal Appeal No. 511 of 2011)
MAY 18, 2023
[HRISHIKESH ROY AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.] Penal Code, 1860 – ss. 302, 34 and 201 – Arms Act, 1959 – ss. 4 and 25 – Acquittal under – FIR lodged by PW-1 (father of deceased) after founding dead body of his son at 0730 hours on 01.11.2001 in a forest, alleging that deceased was with ‘R’ and ‘G’ on 31.10.2001 at about 2100 hours – Later, he replaced ‘G’ with ‘S’ in written information – Both accused (R and S) were convicted by the Trial Court u/s.302 r/w. s.34, s.201 of IPC and ss. 4/25 of the Arms Act – Trial Court relied on testimonies of PW-2 and PW-5 to conclude that deceased was last seen alive in the company of the accused persons – Trial Court also noticed that as per FSL report the empty cartridge recovered from the spot was fired from the same pistol which was recovered from ‘S’ – High Court confirmed the conviction – On appeal, held: According to the testimony of police witnesses, it was the informant who gave information to the police about his son’s dead body – Whereas, according to PW-1 the police informed him that his son’s dead body has been found in the forest – In FIR there is no disclosure as to how the body was found in the forest – FIR did not name any witness who had seen the deceased with accused persons – Further, ‘S’ was not named as accused in FIR at the first instance and was only arrayed at later stage – Explanation offered by PW-2 is delayed disclosure – Similarly, explanation offered by PW-5 for his presence at the spot at the odd hours appears false – There is contradiction in PW-5’s statement made u/s. 161 and in his deposition before the Court as to presence of ‘G’ with deceased – Therefore, the testimony of PW-2 and PW-5 does not inspire confidence – Forensic report/ballistic report were not even put to ‘S’, while recording his statement u/s. 313 Cr.P.C. – In the case at hand, the evidence was not confidence inspiring as to uphold the conviction of the accused-appellants – Thus, impugned judgments and orders of the Trial Court set aside.
A B C D E F G H 2 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 7 S.C.R.
Witnesses – Chance witness – Reliability of – Held: The law is settled, which is, evidence of a chance witness requires a very cautious and close scrutiny and a chance witness must adequately explain his presence at the place of occurrence – Deposition of chance witness whose presence at the place of incident remains doubtful should be discarded.
Allowing the appeals, the Court HELD: 1. The striking feature of the case is that the FIR of the case was lodged at 0730 Hours on 01.11.2001 after the dead body of informant’s son was found in a forest. According to the testimony of police witnesses, it was the informant who gave information to the police about his son’s dead body being found in the forest and thereafter, on the basis of the FIR, investigation commenced. Whereas, according to PW-1 the police informed him that his son’s dead body has been found in the forest and thereafter, he went to the spot, brought the body to the police station and then lodged the report. This cleavage in the testimony of prosecution witnesses is important because it would throw a question as to whether the prosecution case is based on informant’s own knowledge and information or on suggestions/ guess work, may be at the instance of the police. [Para 19][18-H; 19-A-C]
2. Prosecution case is primarily based on the evidence of the deceased being last seen alive with the two accused near the place of occurrence on or about the probable time of occurrence. Such evidence is forthcoming from two witnesses, namely, PW-2 and PW-5. Insofar as PW-2 is concerned, admittedly, he is not listed as a witness in the police report/charge sheet. He gave his statement to the police on an affidavit for the first time on 18.02.2002, that is, the date when the police report was prepared. This implies that he remained silent for as long as three and a half months. Hence, this Court is to examine whether there was a cogent explanation offered by PW-2. In the instant case, the only explanation offered by PW-2 for his three and a half month’s silence is that he felt threatened. With regard to his threat perception, PW-2 stated that in the night of the incident when he witnessed ‘R’ and ‘S’ emerging from the forest, soon after the incident, he noticed their hands and clothes blood stained. On A B C D E F G H 3RAVI MANDAL v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND spotting PW-2, those two accused threatened him by saying that if he tells to anyone about what he has seen, he would meet the same fate. PW-2 stated that with the arrest of the two accused his fear vanished, therefore, he is now appearing as a witness. If this was the reason for him not to make the disclosure earlier, there should have been a prompt disclosure by him once the accused were arrested. Notably, the two accused were arrested on 24.11.2001, yet, till 18.2.2002 no disclosure was made by him. Therefore, the explanation offered by him for the delay in making disclosure is not confidence inspiring. [Paras 22-24[[20-E, G; 21- G-H; 22-A-B]
3. Further, the presence of PW-2 at the spot does not appear natural, particularly, at that odd hour of the night. To explain his presence at the scene of crime, PW-2 stated that his parents stay at another place, and therefore, to meet them he visited them that fateful night and on way return he could witness the incident. During cross examination, PW-2 stated that he usually takes dinner at 2100 Hours with his family; and that he used to visit his parents at least once a week. According to PW2, that fateful night he left his house to visit his parents after having dinner in his own house and on way return, at 0030 Hours he witnessed the incident. This explanation is not confidence inspiring, particularly, because his parents have not been interrogated or examined to corroborate PW-2’s visit to their house at that odd hour of the night. In view of this Court, PW-2 is a mere chance witness, whose presence at the spot, at that hour, is not satisfactorily explained therefore, bearing in mind that he kept silent for unusually long i.e., for more than three and a half months, his testimony is not worthy of any credit. In view of this Court, the courts below erred by placing reliance on his testimony. [Para 25][22-B-E]
4. As regards the testimony of PW-5, he too, is a chance witness. As to when testimony of a chance witness could be relied, the law is settled, which is, that the evidence of a chance witness requires a very cautious and close scrutiny and a chance witness must adequately explain his presence at the place of occurrence. Deposition of a chance witness whose presence at the place of incident remains doubtful should be discarded. The explanation offered by PW-5 for his presence at the spot at that odd hour A B C D E F G H 4 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 7 S.C.R.
appears false. According to PW-5, he was having an upset stomach, therefore, while watching a night show of a movie, to attend to nature’s call, he came out of the cinema hall and, while he was easing himself, he got the chance to witness the incident. It be noted that the investigating officer (PW-10) and PW-7, a gram vendor in that cinema hall, have deposed that there are toilets in the cinema hall where no money is charged for their use. This falsifies the explanation of PW-5 that he went out of the cinema hall to ease himself because cinema hall charged money for use of the toilet. Otherwise also, PW-10 in his deposition had stated that he was not shown the place where PW-5 squatted to ease himself. [Paras 26-27][22-F-H; 23-A-C]
5. Besides that, PW-5 is not consistent because, in his statement under section 161 Cr.P.C., with which he was confronted during the course of his deposition, he had indicted ‘G’ along with two accused persons by stating that all three were present with the deceased but, during his deposition in Court, he stated that ‘G’ was not present. He is also not consistent with regard to the place where his statement was recorded. At one place he states that it was recorded at the police station and at another place he states that it was recorded at his shop. [Para 28][23-C-D]
6. Another important feature of the case is that, according to PW-10, PW-5’s statement was recorded by him on 01.11.2001 at PW5’s house. What was the reason for the police to go to the residence of PW-5 to record his statement is not disclosed by the prosecution. This Court finds it inexplicable as to why police would go to PW-5’s residence to record his statement when the FIR makes no disclosure about PW-5’s presence at the scene of crime or with regard to his knowledge about the incident. All these circumstances give rise to a lingering doubt as to whether, on discovery of the dead body in the forest, the accused were implicated at the instance of the police on suspicion rather than on information received from persons conversant with the facts. [Para 29][23-D-F]
7. Upon evaluation of the testimony of PW-2 and PW-5 carefully and with due caution, as is required in the facts of the case, their testimony does not inspire our confidence as to sustain A B C D E F G H 5RAVI MANDAL v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND the conviction. Unfortunately, the courts below accepted the same as gospel truth, without testing it on the anvil of settled legal principles, thereby resulting in grave miscarriage of justice. This Court, therefore, conclude that the prosecution has failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the deceased was last seen alive in the company of the accused near the spot at the relevant time. [Para 30][23-G-H; 24-A]
8. In so far as recovery of the country made pistol and knife from the person of the accused at the time of their arrest is concerned, the same does not inspire our confidence for the following reasons – According to PW-10, while he was looking out for the suspects/accused, received an information from an informer that the accused were to come to a specified place at 1600 Hours. But, there is no record of receipt of the said information even though it is stated to have been received few hours before the action. Assuming that such information was received, there appears no effort to rope in a public witness even though a locality, as per statement of PW-10, was just 200 meters away from that spot. Lastly, what is most interesting is that the investigating officer, who investigated the case relating to the offence punishable under the Arms Act, prepared the site plan of the place of arrest/recovery on 06.12.2001 even though arrest was allegedly affected on 24.11.2001, which, in the facts of the case, would suggest that it was an exercise to complete the formality. Moreover, the site plan does not disclose the place where the Jeep was hidden in the forest to ambush the accused. Having regard to the circumstances noted above, including the fact that ‘S’ was not named as a suspect in the FIR and his name cropped up later in the statement of PW-5, whose statement was recorded on the same day at his residence, even though, he was not cited as a witness in the FIR, bearing in mind the statement of PW-1 that the police made him to submit the second report indicting ‘S’, this Court is of the view that the police had shown extraordinary interest in implicating ‘S’ and therefore, for all the reasons above, the alleged recovery of gun and knife shown from the appellants does not inspire our confidence. In considered view of this Court, it would be unsafe to rely on such recovery to sustain the conviction. Insofar as forensic report/ballistic report A B C D E F G H 6 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 7 S.C.R.
is concerned, the same has not even been put to ‘S’, from whom the country made pistol was seized, while recording his statement under section 313 of Cr.P.C., therefore, in any event, it would have to be eschewed from consideration. [Paras 31-32][24-B-G]
9. On putting the prosecution evidence to strict scrutiny and testing the same on the anvil of settled legal principles as discussed above, this Court finds the evidence not confidence inspiring as to uphold the conviction of the accused appellants. The courts below have failed to properly evaluate and test the evidence by applying the correct legal principles. In such circumstances, the judgments of the courts below are liable to be set aside. The appellants are acquitted of all the charges for which they have been tried and convicted. [Para 33][25-A-C] Kali Ram v. State of Himachal Pradesh (1973) 2 SCC 808 : [1974] 1 SCR 722; Rajesh Yadav & Another v.
State of Uttar Pradesh (2022) 12 SCC 200; Jarnail Singh & Others v. State of Punjab (2009) 9 SCC 719 :
[2009] 13 SCR 774 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [1974] 1 SCR 722 referred to para 23 (2022) 12 SCC 200 referred to para 26 [2009] 13 SCR 774 referred to para 26 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.511 of 2011.
From the Judgment and Order dated 07.04.2010 of the High Court of Uttaranchal at Nainital in CRLA No.54 of 2004.
With Criminal Appeal No.2345 of 2011.
Gopal Jha, Adv. (Amicus Curiae), Ms. Ankita Gautam, Dr. A.K. Gautam, Ravi Mehrotra, Nitin Juyal, Ashok Mathur, Sanket, Ms. Babita Sant, Advs. for the Appellant.
Jatinder Kumar Bhatia, Krishnam Mishra, Param Kumar Mishra, Rajeev Kumar Dubey, Ashiwan Mishra, Kamlendra Mishra, Advs. for the Respondent.
A B C D E F G H 7RAVI MANDAL v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
MANOJ MISRA, J.
1. These two appeals are against the judgment and order of the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital (for short “the High Court”), dated 07.04.2010, dismissing Criminal Appeals Nos.54 and 59 of 2004 filed against the judgment and order of Additional Sessions Judge/Fast Track Court Haldwani, Nainital (for short “the Trial Court”) dated 28.01.2004, and, thereby, affirming the conviction and sentence awarded to the appellants detailed below: (i) life imprisonment under section 302 read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short “IPC”) along with one year R.I. under section 201 IPC in Sessions Trial (S.T.) No.93/2002 (State vs. Shabbir Ahmad and Another); (ii) one year R.I. with fine of Rs.500/- under section 25 Arms Act to appellant Shabbir in S.T. No.104 of 2002 (State vs. Shabbir Ahmed); and (iii) one year R.I. with fine of Rs.500/- under section 4/25 of Arms Act to appellant Ravi Mandal in connected S.T. No.105 of 2002 (State vs. Ravi Mandal). Introductory Facts:
2. On 01.11.2001, Man Singh (PW-1), father of Chhotu @ Surjeet (the deceased), on finding his son’s dead body in a forest, 150 meters west of Government Inter College, lodged a first information report (FIR) at P.S. Lalkuan, Haldwani, district Nainital at about 7.30 hrs, alleging therein that, — on 31.10.2001, at about 2100 Hours, the deceased was with his friends Govind and Ravi Bangali (later identified as Ravi Mandal); Govind, a criminal, had been influencing his son to choose a wrong path; therefore, he suspects that these persons have killed his son and concealed his body in the forest. Thereafter, on 10.11.2001, PW-1 gave a written information to the police stating that it was not Govind but Shabbir who along with Ravi and one Mazhar Khan were with the deceased on that fateful night. In this written information, it was alleged that Babloo (PW- 7) had misled him to take the name of Govind.
3. During the course of investigation, the police effected arrest of the two accused, namely, the appellants herein, and disclosed recovery of a 12 bore country made pistol with one live cartridge from Shabbir and a knife from Ravi Mandal, giving rise to two separate cases against each of the two accused under the Arms Act.
4. On completion of investigation three charge sheets were laid giving rise to three sessions trials which were connected with each other A B C D E F G H 8 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 7 S.C.R.
and decided by a common judgment, which has been affirmed by the High Court.
Prosecution Evidence:
5. To appreciate the arguments advanced in this case, it would be apposite to notice the testimony of the prosecution witnesses in brief. The prosecution examined 10 witnesses, the gist of their testimony is as under:
(i) PW-1 – Man Singh - Informant (father of the deceased) He is not an eyewitness of the murder. He, however, proved lodging of the FIR on 01.11.2001 and stated that, — on 31.10.2001 in the evening Babloo (PW-7) came to his residence, told him that the deceased, Ravi Bangali and Govind were asking for food and have sent him to fetch food for them; on that request, PW-1’s wife (Urmila Devi- PW-3) cooked food, packed it and gave it to Babloo, who left with the food; next day, he came to know that dead body of his son was lying in the forest; he then visited the place, brought the dead body to Lalkuan Police Station and lodged the report; later, when he came to know that Govind was not with his son, rather it was Shabbir along with others who were there, he gave the second report (Ex. Ka-2) to the police on 10.11.2001. During cross examination, PW-1 admitted that there were three or four criminal cases against his son (the deceased) wherein, he was on bail.
With regard to the sequence of events on the date of lodging the FIR, PW-1 stated that, — a constable with two men came in the morning to inform him that dead body of his son is lying in the forest; on getting the information he went to that place and brought the body to the police station to lodge the FIR whereafter, the body was sealed and sent to Haldwani Hospital for autopsy. He also stated that papers relating to recovery of tiffin box; collection of blood-stained earth etc. were prepared at the police station and he signed those papers at the police station itself. PW-1 also clarified that the second report (i.e. Ex. Ka-2) was dictated by the Sub-Inspector at the police station and he wrote whatever was told to him.
A B C D E F G H 9RAVI MANDAL v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND [MANOJ MISRA, J.] At the fag end of his cross-examination, PW-1 stated that he had informed the Sub-Inspector regarding financial transactions with Govind and also about Govind not refunding the money, which gave rise to enmity.
(ii) PW-2 - Chandan Singh He deposed that, — (a) he knew Shabbir Ahmad and Ravi Mandal; (b) they had come to his shop with the deceased at about 1900 Hours on 31.10.2001 and from there they proceeded towards the cinema hall; (c) later, in the night of 31.10.2001/ 01.11.2001, at about 0030 Hours, he saw the accused-appellants emerging from the forest and walking fast; (d) at that time, hands of Shabbir were bloodstained and Ravi’s clothes were also having blood stains,
(e) seeing PW-2, they got nervous, Shabbir threatened PW- 2 by saying that if PW-2 discloses what he has seen to any one, he would meet the same fate as Chhotu (the deceased); (f) next day morning, PW-2 learnt that dead body of Chhotu has been found in that forest.
To show the reason for his presence there, at that odd hour of the night, PW-2 stated that, — his parents have a separate house at Khatta, where he goes at least once a week; that night, after having dinner, while returning from his parents’ house and proceeding towards his own house/ shop, at about 0030 Hours, he witnessed the incident.
During cross examination, PW-2 stated that, — his shop is run from a room in his house; it remains open from 0500 Hours till 2300 Hours; his house comprises of 3 rooms where he resides with his wife and five sons; the usual time of his dinner is 2100 Hours.
A suggestion was put to PW-2 that mother of Ravi (one of the appellants) is PW-2’s neighbour on whose land PW- 2 had constructed his shop. This suggestion was denied by PW-2.
With regard to the delay in giving information to the police, PW-2 stated that he was petrified by the incident and when the accused were arrested, he could muster courage to make his statement. During cross-examination, A B C D E F G H 10 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 7 S.C.R.
PW-2 admitted that he had been arrested under section 60 of the Excise Act and is on bail. He feigned ignorance to a suggestion that his bail bonds were arranged by parents of Chhotu.
(iii) PW-3 – Urmila Devi-Mother of the deceased She proved that on 31.10.2001, Babloo (PW-7), who use to work at the cinema hall, came to her house to fetch food for the deceased, consequently, food was cooked and supplied by her.
During cross examination, she denied being a surety for the bail of Chandan (PW-2). However, she admitted that Chandan used to visit her house.
(iv) PW-4 – Smt. Mithilesh (Wife of Govind)
PW-4 did not depose anything specific about the incident except that Shabbir had enmity with her husband and 8 to 10 days before the murder of Chhotu, Ravi Bangali and Shabbir had called her husband; in consequence, her husband left, but did not return thereafter; later, she received information from the police that her husband has been killed and the culprits caught.
During cross examination, she admitted that the police had come to her house 2-3 days after the murder of Chhotu but, at that time, she had not informed the police that Govind and Chhotu had gone with the accused persons. She also admitted that the police made no enquiry from her and she did not lodge any complaint in respect of her husband’s murder.
(v) PW-5 – Mahendra Khurana He stated that, — on 31.10.2001, while he was watching a night show at the cinema hall, he had to rush out to attend to nature’s call, then he saw Chhotu (the deceased), Ravi Bangali and Shabbir going towards the forest; 2-3 minutes later, he heard sound of a gunshot and 5-7 minutes later, Ravi Bangali and Shabbir minus Chhotu were noticed running and talking to each other that they have settled their account with Chhotu as he had become a nuisance for them A B C D E F G H 11RAVI MANDAL v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND [MANOJ MISRA, J.] on account of his persistent demand for money. PW-5 stated that he did not disclose this fact to anyone in the night but in the morning, he came to know that Chhotu has been murdered.
During cross examination, he admitted that though toilet facility is available in the cinema hall but, on charge; therefore, he went out to ease himself. He stated that his statement was recorded in the morning, following the night of the incident; and for that purpose, he was called by the constable. On being confronted with his previous statement that he saw Govind, Chhotu, Ravi Bangali and Shabbir going towards the forest, PW-5 stated that he had disclosed the name of all, except Govind. He, however, admitted that he did not disclose to the police the place where he sat that night to ease himself.
(vi) PW-6 – Hanuman Prasad He stated that, — on 31.10.2001 at about mid- night while he was returning from depot no.6, opposite to the cinema hall, he saw three persons, namely, Chhotu, Ravi Bangali and Shabbir talking to each other and going towards the forest; next day in the morning, he came to know that Chhotu has been murdered. He denied having seen Shabbir firing at the deceased. At this stage, the prosecution declared him hostile and sought his cross examination.
During cross examination by the prosecution, he denied that he gave a statement before the police about Shabbir shooting his companion and Ravi holding his leg.
During cross examination by the defence, he stated that he had not seen the incident and he had also informed the police that he had not seen the incident.
(vii) PW-7 – Babloo He stated that, — on 31.10.2001, he met Chhotu at the gate of cinema hall; Chhotu asked him to get food for him from his residence; at that time, no one was present with Chhotu. PW-7 stated that he came to the residence of Chhotu, took food and brought it in three boxes but when A B C D E F G H 12 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 7 S.C.R.
he reached there with the food, he saw no one, therefore, he kept the food there. Next day morning, he came to know that Chhotu has been killed. At this stage, the prosecution declared him hostile and sought permission for his cross examination.
During cross examination by the prosecution, PW-7 admitted his signature on paper No.3/15 which was marked Ex. Ka-6. He also admitted that he gave a statement to the sub-inspector but denied that he saw Chhotu in the company of Shabbir and Ravi Bangali on 31.10.2001.
During cross examination at the instance of defence, PW-7 stated that he used to sell chana (gram) at the cinema hall; the cinema hall had toilets and no money is charged for use of those toilets. He also stated that during the course of investigation of this case, the police had beaten him and had detained him in the police lock-up for three days.
(viii) PW-8 – Dr. Anil Chandra K Sah (Autopsy surgeon)
He proved the autopsy report and stated that death of the deceased was due to shock and haemorrhage as a result of ante mortem gunshot.
(ix) PW-9 – Sub-Inspector Nanhe Lal (Investigating Officer of the cases under the Arms Act)
He proved the inquest report (Ex. Ka-7A) and autopsy related papers (Ex.K-8 to K-10). He also proved various stages of investigation of case crime No.756/01, under section 25 of Arms Act, and case crime No.757/01, under section 4/25 of Arms Act, as also submission of charge sheet and obtaining of sanction for prosecution under the provisions of the Arms Act.
During cross examination, PW-9 stated that on 06.12.2001 he prepared site plan of the place from where the accused were arrested and weapon was recovered.
He sought to explain the delay in preparation of the site plan by stating that he was busy with other matters.
(x) PW-10 – SI Pramod Kumar Shah (Investigating Officer of the murder case)
A B C D E F G H 13RAVI MANDAL v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND [MANOJ MISRA, J.] He proved — registration of the FIR; visiting the spot with PW-9; inspection of the spot; preparation of site plan (Ex.Ka-15); lifting of: blood stained soil/plain soil, vide seizure memo Ex. Ka-4, and one empty 12 bore cartridge from the spot, vide seizure memo Ex.Ka-5 of which PW-1 is one of the witnesses; conducting inquest; recording statement of — complainant Man Singh (PW-1), Babloo (PW-7) and Mahender Khurana (PW-5); preparation of custody memo of the tiffin; recording statement of — Smt. Urmila Devi (PW-3) on 02.11.2001, Mithilesh (PW-4) on 03.11.2001, Hanuman (PW-6) on 07.11.2001; submission of application by Man Singh on 10.11.2001; and submission of charge sheet (EX.Ka-16). He also produced material exhibits etc. In addition to the above, he stated that accused Shabbir and Ravi Mandal were absconding, therefore, application to draw proceedings under section 82 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (for short “Cr.P.C.”) was moved. Thereafter, on 24.11.2001 at 1530 Hours accused Shabbir and Ravi Mandal were arrested with a 12 bore country made pistol and knife respectively. He proved the arrest memo as Ex. Ka-17.
PW-10 stated that on 15.01.2002 the country made pistol, empty cartridge recovered from the spot and live cartridge seized at the time of arrest were sent to Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL), Agra for examination and its report has been submitted, as per which, EC-1 (empty cartridge found near the dead body) was fired from the pistol which was recovered from Shabbir. During cross examination, at the instance of accused Shabbir, PW-10 stated that, — in the FIR Shabbir was not named; PW-10 reached the place of occurrence at about 0800 Hours; the dead body was lying at the spot; the statement of Man Singh was recorded at the spot on 01.11.2001; Man Singh had informed him that Chhotu (the deceased) had not been coming home since last 10-12 days before the incident, however, no information regarding Chhotu was given earlier; Mahender Khurana (PW-5) had told that in the night he had seen Govind with Ravi, Chhotu and Shabbir going towards the forest; Man Singh on 01.11.2001 had stated that Govind had borrowed A B C D E F G H 14 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 7 S.C.R.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.