Shanti Bhushan (D) Thr. Lr. & Ors v. State of U.P. and Ors
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 425; [2023] 6 S.C.R. 513
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Rajesh Bindal Stamp Act, Justice 1899 – Ss.31, Justice 700/- – the Assistant Stamp Collector, Justice 000/Per Sq. Meter – Thus, Justice On the Date of the Sale Deed, Justice The Market Value of the Sale Deed
- Decided
- 25 Apr 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 8388/2017
- Sections
- 31, 47, 2, 2(10), 17, 2(12), 3, 52, 29, 23, 4A, 47A
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H
SHANTI BHUSHAN (D) THR. LR. & ORS.
v.
STATE OF U.P. AND ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 8388 of 2017)
APRIL 25, 2023
[ABHAY S. OKA AND RAJESH BINDAL, JJ.] Stamp Act,1899 – ss.31,32, 47-A and Art. 23 of the Schedule IB – Market Value of property – Determination of – A property was purchased by the appellants under a registered sale deed from the vendor – Appellants were already in possession land as tenants – The appellants calculated Rs.6,67,200/-as the market value of the property and paid the stamp duty quantified at Rs. 46,700/- – The Assistant Stamp Collector, held that the market value of the land will have to be calculated at the rate of Rs. 24,000/per sq. meter – Thus, on the date of the sale deed, the market value of the sale deed property was Rs.19,23,08,305/- on which stamp duty of Rs.1,34,61,630/- was payable – Appellants were directed to pay a deficit stamp duty along with penalty and the interest – The appellants preferred an appeal against the order of Assistant collector, which was dismissed by the Appellate Authority – The above orders were challenged before the High Court – The High Court affirmed the market value fixed by the authorities but set aside the demand for penalty – On appeal, held: Stamp duty on a conveyance will be payable as per the market value prevailing on the date of conveyance unless consideration shown therein is more than the prevailing market value – The market value fixed by appellants was fixed by adopting method used for levy of property tax under the Municipal laws, such a value cannot be taken as basis for determining the market value for the purpose of Art. 23 – Further, a property in possession of a tenant will fetch lesser value in the open market than the market value of a similar property exclusively in possession of the vendor as the buyer will not get actual possession of the portion of the property in possession of the tenant – The market value can be determined by the comparison method even in case of a property in possession of tenants – If no comparable instances are found, the market value can be fixed of the property in possession of tenants by making an appropriate deduction from the market [2023] 6 S.C.R. 513 A B C D E F G H 514 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
value of a comparable property in which there are no tenants – Even if the guidance value of Rs. 24,000/- per sq. meter is to be taken as the market value of the sale deed land, necessary deductions will have to be made from the market value as the appellants were already in possession of the sale deed land as tenants – The extent to which deduction can be made will depend upon the nature of the tenancy and other material factors – Case sent back to the Assistant Stamp Collector for determination of the market value of the sale deed land.
Stamp Act, 1899 – Interpretation of – In interpreting a taxing statute, equitable considerations cannot be applied – The rule of literal construction must be applied while interpreting a taxing statute – It must be interpreted in terms of the natural construction of the words used – There is no scope to imply anything which is not expressly provided.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD:1. The Stamp Act is a taxing statute. In interpreting such a statute, equitable considerations cannot be applied. A taxing statute has to be interpreted in accordance with what is clearly expressed therein. While interpreting such a statute and determining the liability to pay tax, the provisions are required to be construed strictly. In other words, the rule of literal construction must be applied while interpreting a taxing statute. It must be interpreted in terms of the natural construction of the words used. There is no scope to imply anything which is not expressly provided. [Para 18][524-D-E]
2. In view of Article 23 of Schedule I of the Stamp Act, the stamp duty payable on a conveyance will be in accordance with the market value of the subject property on the date of the conveyance unless the consideration shown therein is more than the prevailing market value. When a sale deed is presented for registration, the registering authority must ascertain the correct market value of the property subject matter of the document on the date of execution of the document. The stamp duty is payable on the basis of such market value and not on the consideration mentioned in the document. If the consideration mentioned is A B C D E F G H more than the market value, the stamp duty will be payable on the consideration shown. Moreover, the market value mentioned in the agreement for sale or the market value prevailing on the date of the agreement or the market value prevailing on the date on which the bargain was struck is of no relevance for deciding the stamp duty. The relevant market value is the one which prevails on the date of execution of the conveyance. Therefore, this Court had no manner of doubt that the appellants were under an obligation to pay stamp duty calculated on the market value of the sale deed property on the date of execution of the sale deed. [Paras 19, 20][524-F; 525-H; 526-A-C]
3. Stamp duty was paid by the appellants by taking the market value of the sale deed property at Rs.6,67,200/- . This market value was fixed by adopting method used for levy of property tax under the Municipal laws. Such a value cannot be taken as the basis for determining the market value for the purposes of Article 23. [Para 21][526-D]
4. The test for determination of the market value is very simple. The market value is the one which a bona fide and willing buyer will offer. It is apparent that if the property subject matter of the sale is in possession of the vendor himself, the bona fide purchaser will offer more price for the property than the price which he may offer for a similar property which is in possession of a tenant. There is no doubt that a property in possession of a tenant or tenants will fetch lesser value in the open market than the market value of a similar property exclusively in possession of the vendor. The reason is that the buyer will not get actual possession of the portion of the property in possession of the tenant. [Para 24][529-G-H; 530-A-B]
5. The market value can be determined by the comparison method even in case of a property in possession of tenants. For example, if there is a sale transaction of a property in possession of a tenant which is comparable to the property sought to be valued and if the said sale transaction is held to be a genuine transaction, market value can be fixed on the basis of the sale transaction. If no comparable instances are found, the market SHANTI BHUSHAN (D) THR. LR. & ORS. v. STATE OF U.P.
AND ORS.
A B C D E F G H 516 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
value can be fixed of the property in possession of tenants by making an appropriate deduction from the market value of a comparable property in which there are no tenants. [Para 25][530- C]
6. The Assistant Collector, the Appellate Authority, and the High Court have not decided the issue in terms of what this Court have held above. Even if the guidance value of Rs. 24,000/- per sq. meter is to be taken as the market value of the sale deed land, necessary deductions will have to be made from the market value as the appellants were already in possession of the sale deed land as tenants. The extent to which deduction can be made will depend upon the nature of the tenancy and other material factors. Some tenancies may be protected under the relevant rent control legislation, whereas some may not be protected. That is all a matter of evidence. [Para 27][530-F-G]
7. The issue regarding the market value of the sale deed land on the date of execution of the sale deed is required to be decided by permitting the parties to adduce oral and documentary evidence. The Assistant Collector will have to ascertain whether a comparable sale instance of a property in possession of tenants is available. If it is not available, the Assistant Collector will have to ascertain the market value of the sale deed property on the relevant date again by comparison method by taking market value of a comparable property which does not have encumbrance of tenancy. Thereafter, he will have to determine the percentage of the deduction which should be made from the market value in the facts of this case. These questions are to be decided by the Assistant Collector on the basis of the evidence on record. Therefore, subject to what this Court have held in the judgment, this Court proposed to send back the case to the Assistant Stamp Collector for determination of the market value of the sale deed land on the date of execution of the sale deed. [Para 28][530-G- H; 531-A-B] Special Land Acquisition & Rehabilitation Officer, Sagar v. M.S. Seshagiri Rao & Another [1968] 2 SCR 892; Mangat Ram and Others v. State of Haryana and Others (1996) 8 SCC 664 : [1996] 1 Suppl. SCR 634;
A B C D E F G H State of Rajasthan and Others v. Khandaka Jain Jewellers (2007) 14 SCC 339 : [2007] 12 SCR 105 – referred to.
O. N. Talwar v. The Collector of Stamps (1971) 7 DLT 319; The Commissioner of Wealth Tax Mysore, Bangalore v. V. C. Ramachandran (1966) 60 ITR 103 – referred to Case Law Reference [1968] 2 SCR 892 referred to para 10 [1996] 1 Suppl. SCR 634 referred to para 10 [2007] 12 SCR 105 referred to para 19 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 8388 of 2017.
From the Judgment and Order dated 23.01.2013 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in CMWP No. 55473 of 2012.
Rohit Kumar Singh, Pavan Bhushan, Amartya Bhushan, Tushar Bhushan, Harsh Jain, Advs. for the Appellants.
R. K. Raizada, Sr. Adv., Bhakti Vardhan Singh, Ankit, Advs. for the Respondents.
Jayant Bhushan, in Person/Sr. Adv.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
ABHAY S. OKA, J.
FACTUAL ASPECTS
1. The dispute involved in this appeal is about the determination of the market value of a property at Allahabad purchased by the appellants under a registered sale deed dated 29th November 2010 (the sale deed) from Hari Mohan Das Tandon (the vendor). The property has been described in the Schedule to the sale deed which reads thus: “SCHEDULE OF THE PROPERTY”
Part Portion of Free Hold Site No. 49 Civil Station, Allahabad of which Nagar Nigam No. is 19 Old, 77/29 New, and 19-A Old 79/ 31 New, Lal Bahadur Shastri Marg (Elgin Road), Allahabad SHANTI BHUSHAN (D) THR. LR. & ORS. v. STATE OF U.P.
AND ORS.
A B C D E F G H 518 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
measuring 7818.00 sq.mts. land alongwith construction and super structure standing thereon shown in Red Colour in the annexed map and bounded as under:-
BOUNDARIES
East : Part Portion of Freehold Site No. 49 Civil Station, Allahabad, facing Strachey Road which has been released in the favour of the Sellers- 1st Party as per the compromise.
West : Site No. 50 Civil Station, Allahabad North : Elgin Road (Lal Bahadur Shastri Marg)
South : Site No. 30 Civil Station, Allahabad”
This property is hereinafter referred to as the sale deed property.
2. According to the case of the appellants, Bungalow No.19 and Cottage No.19-A existed on the larger property. According to their case, in the year 1939, Bungalow No.19, together with appurtenant land and outhouse as well as cottage no.19-A, was taken on rent by the first appellant’s father. The appellants claimed to be protected tenants under the United Provinces (Temporary) Control of Rent and Eviction Act, 1947 and subsequently under the U.P. Urban Buildings (Regulation of Letting, Rent and Eviction) Act 1972. According to the case made out by the appellants, by two letters dated 2nd September 1966 and 10th September 1966, the vendor agreed to sell the sale deed property to the first appellant’s father for a total sale consideration of Rs. 1 lakh. A sum of Rs. 5000/- was paid to the vendor as earnest money. The land was a leasehold land. It was converted into a freehold land on 8th June 2000 by virtue of a freehold deed executed in favour of the vendor. The first appellant filed a suit for specific performance in the same year.
3. On 29th September 2010, a compromise was arrived at between the vendor and the appellants under which the appellants agreed to give up approximately 1/3rd of the land which was a part of the original agreement for sale covered by the aforesaid two letters, and agreed to take land measuring 7818 sq. meters along with existing structures for the same consideration which was fixed in the year 1966. An application to record compromise was made in the pending suit on 5th October 2010. On the basis of the said compromise, on 12th October 2010, an agreement for sale was executed by and between the parties. A compromise decree was passed by the Civil Court on 16th November 2010.
A B C D E F G H
4. Prior to the execution of a fresh agreement for sale, on 29th September 2010, the appellants filed an application under Section 31 r/w 32 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 (for short ‘the Stamp Act’) for adjudication of the stamp duty payable on the sale deed by forwarding a copy of the proposed sale deed. However, no adjudication was made. On 29th November 2010, the sale deed was executed by the vendor in favour of the appellants.
5. Two notices were issued to the appellants on 8th February 2011 and 15th April 2011 by the Assistant Stamp Commissioner in the exercise of powers under Section 47-A of the Stamp Act, informing the appellants that the Assistant Stamp Collector was considering the question of payment of appropriate stamp duty on the sale deed.
6. We may note here that by using the rent capitalisation method, the appellants calculated Rs.6,67,200/- as the market value of the sale deed property and paid the stamp duty on the said market value quantified at Rs. 46,700/-. In the notice dated 15th April 2011, it was alleged that the deficiency in the stamp duty was to the extent of Rs.1,33,07,900/-. The appellants contested the notices by filing written submissions. The Assistant Stamp Collector, by order dated 6th January 2012, held that the market value of the land having an area of 7818 sq. meters will have to be calculated at the rate of Rs. 24,000/- per sq. meter. The Assistant Collector noted that four sales had taken place in 2010 in respect of a part of the same property showing the market value at Rs.24,000/- per sq. meter. By calculating the market value of the land at Rs.24,000/- per sq. meter, the Assistant Stamp Collector added the value of the structures as well as mango trees. The Collector came to the conclusion that on the date of the sale deed, the market value of the sale deed property was Rs.19,23,08,305/- on which stamp duty of Rs.1,34,61,630/- was payable. Taking into account the stamp duty of Rs. 46,700/- paid by the appellants, they were directed to pay a deficit stamp duty of Rs.1,34,14,930/-. A penalty of Rs. 27,00,000/- was imposed on the appellants. Moreover, they were directed to pay interest at the rate of 1.5% per month on the deficit stamp duty from the date of the sale deed till the realisation of the amount.
7. According to the case of the appellants, on 1st February 2012, they paid a stamp duty of Rs.70 lakhs by demand draft as coercive action was likely to be taken against them. The appellants preferred an appeal against the order dated 6th January 2012, which was dismissed SHANTI BHUSHAN (D) THR. LR. & ORS. v. STATE OF U.P.
AND ORS. [ABHAY S. OKA, J.] A B C D E F G H 520 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
by the Appellate Authority. The appellants deposited an additional amount of Rs. 30 lakhs towards the stamp duty on 9th November 2012. The orders of the Assistant Collector and the Appellate Authority were subjected to a challenge by the appellants before the Allahabad High Court by invoking writ jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution. While affirming the market value fixed by the authorities, the High Court granted limited relief to the appellants vide judgment dated 23rd January 2013. The limited relief was of setting aside the demand of the penalty of Rs.27,00,000/-. The present appeal is directed against the judgment and order of the High Court.
SUBMISSIONS
8. Shri Jayant Bhushan, the learned senior counsel who is appellant no.3, appeared in person and made submissions on his behalf as well as on behalf of the other appellants. He has taken us through the facts leading to the filing of the writ petition. Learned senior counsel submitted that though the appellants were entitled to purchase total land measuring 11428 sq. meters as per the agreement for sale, they agreed to give up an area of 3614 sq. meters by agreeing to purchase a lesser area of 7814 sq. meters. However, the agreed monetary consideration was not reduced.
9. The learned senior counsel submitted that the first appellant’s father was already inducted in the sale deed property as a tenant. He submitted that when a property is in possession of a tenant, the market value considerably diminishes. He stated that when a willing purchaser acquires a property in possession of a tenant, he is aware that he will have to follow a long process of law to evict the tenant. Therefore, the value fetched by such property is less than the market value of a comparable property which is in possession of the owners. He urged that the sale, in this case, was of an encumbered property which was on “as is where is” basis.
10. The learned senior counsel submitted that the market value of a property is ascertained by applying the test of what a willing buyer would pay. He submitted that while determining the market value of a property in possession of a tenant, when the property is sold to the tenant, the market value has to be apportioned as per the principles laid down in several decisions of this Court in connection with fixation of the market value of the acquired land under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. He A B C D E F G H relied upon decisions of this Court in the case of Special Land Acquisition & Rehabilitation Officer, Sagar v. M.S. Seshagiri Rao & Another1and Mangat Ram and Others v. State of Haryana and others2. He submitted that the market value is liable to be reduced if there are encumbrances on the property. The market value will be the real market value minus the value of encumbrances or liabilities. He relied upon a decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of O.N. Talwar v. The Collector of Stamps3.
11. He submitted that the market value of the property further diminishes due to the fact that there was already an agreement of sale in favour of the appellants under which the vendor had agreed to sell the property for a price of Rs. 1 lakh.
12. He submitted that though an application for adjudication of the stamp duty payable on the proposed sale deed was submitted, there was no response to the said application, and on that ground, the order of penalty imposed by the Assistant Collector has been set aside by the High Court.
13. He submitted that as per the compromise between the vendor and the appellants, the consideration agreed to be paid by the appellants was of Rs.1 lakh plus the release of 1/3rd of the property. He submitted that the actual conveyed property to the appellants was 2/3rd of the land in respect of which they were tenants. Therefore, the value of 2/3rd land would be 2/3rd x (1/3rd of the value of the entire land plus Rs.1 lakh). He submitted that the market value will have to be calculated accordingly.
14. The learned senior counsel also pointed out that even the direction to pay interest @ 1.5% per month under Section 47-A (4A) of the Stamp Act was not justified as even before the execution of the sale deed, the appellants had voluntarily sought adjudication of the amount payable by way of stamp duty on the draft sale deed. Moreover, he pointed out that by interim order dated 23rd September 2013, the High Court had stayed the recovery proceedings. Lastly, he pointed out that a total amount of Rs.1 crore has already been deposited by the appellants.
15. Shri R. K. Raizada, learned senior counsel, submitted on behalf of the State that stamp duty payable by the appellants is to be calculated
1 (1968) 2 SCR 892
2 (1996) 8 SCC 664
3 (1971) 7 DLT 319
SHANTI BHUSHAN (D) THR. LR. & ORS. v. STATE OF U.P.
AND ORS. [ABHAY S. OKA, J.] A B C D E F G H 522 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.