Shivshankara & Anr v. H.P. Vedavyasa Char
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 318; [2023] 6 S.C.R. 359
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai
- Decided
- 29 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 10215/2011
- Sections
- 52, 6, 151, 8, 9
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:25 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H
SHIVSHANKARA & ANR.
v.
H.P. VEDAVYASA CHAR
(Civil Appeal No. 10215 of 2011)
MARCH 29, 2023
[B. R. GAVAI AND C. T. RAVIKUMAR, JJ.] Abatement: Abatement of suit – Non-joinder of necessary parties – Non-impleadment of all other legal heirs of deceased defendant – Effect of – Held: In the event of death of one of the defendants, when the estate/interest was being fully and substantially represented in the suit jointly by the other defendants along with deceased defendant and when they are also his legal representatives, by reason of non-impleadment of all other legal heirs consequential to the death of the said defendant, the suit would not abate – Such suit not bad for non-joinder of necessary parties of all his legal heirs/representatives.
Amendment: Amendment of pleadings at appellate stage – Permissibility of – Held: While dealing with such prayers, the Courts should avoid hyper technical approach – Circumstances attending to the particular case are to be taken into account to allow or not to allow such prayer – It is allowable only in rarest of rare circumstances – It cannot be granted on the mere request, especially at the appellate stage – On facts, trial court allowed the amendment of the plaint, and the defendants were given multiple opportunities to file an additional written statement, which they did not avail and the suit was decreed – Subsequent developments culminated in the impugned judgment wherein the High Court declined permission to amend the written statement to the defendants – High Court observed that grant of amendment of written statement, if at that stage would have necessitated framing of fresh issues and de novo trial – Thus, no perversity or illegality with the rejection of the prayer for amendment of the written statement.
Suit: Suit for possession, based on possessory title – Facts disclosing no title in either party at the relevant time – Prior possession – Relevance of – Held: In such circumstances, when the facts disclose no title in either party, at the relevant time, prior [2023] 6 S.C.R. 359 A B C D E F G H 360 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
possession alone decides the right to possession of land in the assumed character of owner against all the world except against the rightful owner.
Suit: Suit for injunction and for recovery of possession by respondent against the appellants – Maintainability of – Held: On a careful consideration of the available pleadings of the appellants, the High Court held that they did not disclose their defence in their written statement and at the same time did not even contend that they are in possession of the suit property – Thus, the High Court correct in holding the question of maintainability of the suit in the affirmative and in favour of the respondent – Trial court after carefully considering the evidence on record held that the respondent is entitled to get back the possession of suit schedule property from which he was dispossessed – After careful consideration of the additional evidence recorded and transmitted to the High Court by the trial court and considering all contentions and aspects, the High Court only confirmed the judgment and decree of the trial court – Thus, when the concurrent findings of the courts below are the outcome of the rightful consideration and appreciation of materials on record, they do not call for any interference.
Transfer of Property Act, 1882: s. 52 – Transfer of property pending suit relating thereto – Doctrine of Lis pendens – Held: Import of s. 52 is that if there is any transfer of right in immovable property during the pendency of a suit such transfer will be non est in the eye of law if it will adversely affect the interest of the other party to the suit in the property concerned – Wherever TP Act is not applicable, such principle in the said provision of the Act, based on justice, equity and good conscience is applicable in a given similar circumstance, like Court sale etc – On facts, the suit from which the appeal arises was one based on possessory title, the legality of sale deed need not be gone into in this appeal and rightly has not been gone into by the High Court – High Court declined to act upon the same, in the light of the doctrine of lis pendens.
Pleadings: Proof offered without pleadings – Relevance of – On facts, claim for possession/ownership over the suit property by the defendants – Original defendants failed to raise sufficient and appropriate pleadings in the written statement that they have better right for possession of the suit properties – No amount of proof A B C D E F G H offered without appropriate pleadings would have any relevance – Finding of the High Court that any volume of evidence sans appropriate pleadings would be of no avail is correct.
Dismissing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1.1 There can be no doubt with respect to the settled position that the Court to which the case is remanded has to comply with the order of remand and acting contrary to the order of remand is contrary to law. In other words, an order of remand has to be followed in its true spirit. [Para 7][372-H; 373- A]
1.2. In dealing with prayers for amendment of the pleadings the Courts should avoid hyper technical approach. But at the same time, the Court should keep reminded of the position that the same cannot be granted on the mere request through an application for amendment of the written statement, especially at the appellate stage where what is called in question is the judgment and decree passed by the trial court and in other words, after the adverse decree and without a genuine, sustainable reason. The circumstances attending to the particular case are to be taken into account to consider whether such a prayer is allowable or not and no doubt, it is allowable only in rarest of rare circumstances. In the case on hand, prayer to amend the plaint was allowed by the trial court. Accordingly, the amendment was carried out by the plaintiff. Indisputably, thereafter, during the span of one year or thereabouts more than eight opportunities were given to the defendants therein to file additional written statement, if any. Indubitably, the materials on record would reveal that the opportunities were not availed and no additional written statement was filed. Thereafter, based on the pleadings, issues were framed. Obviously, the defendants did not adduce any evidence for the reasons best known to them. The suit came to be decreed thereafter. All the subsequent developments which ultimately culminated in the impugned judgment is discussed. Evidently the High Court observed that if the amendment of written statement was allowed at that stage, it would have necessitated framing of fresh issues and parties were to agitate their rights as if in a de novo trial. In the circumstances thus SHIVSHANKARA & ANR. v. H.P. VEDAVYASA CHAR A B C D E F G H 362 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
revealed from the materials on record and when such aspects and evidence were taken into account by the High Court to decline permission to amend the written statement, there is no reason or justification to interfere with it. [Para 14 & 15][377-A-E; 378- D-E; 379-B-E]
1.3. In the wake of the admission by DW-1, the attempt to bring in new plea by amending the written statement that the second defendant (the deceased second appellant) had purchased the suit schedule property as per the sale deed dated 05.10.2000 has to be seen. Since admittedly and indisputably the suit from which the appeal arises was one based on possessory title, the legality of the sale deed need not be gone into in this appeal and rightly has not been gone into by the High Court. Evidently, the High Court declined to act upon the same, in the light of the doctrine of lis pendens. Even if it is taken for granted that the provisions under Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act are not applicable as such in the case on hand it cannot be disputed that the principle contained in the provision is applicable in the case on hand. It is a well-nigh settled position that wherever TP Act is not applicable, such principle in the said provision, which is based on justice, equity and good conscience is applicable in a given similar circumstance, like Court sale etc. Transfer of possession pendente lite will also be transfer of property within the meaning of Section 52 and, therefore, the import of Section 52 is that if there is any transfer of right in immovable property during the pendency of a suit such transfer will be non est in the eye of law if it will adversely affect the interest of the other party to the suit in the property concerned. The effect of Section 52 is that the right of the successful party in the litigation in regard to that property would not be affected by the alienation, but it does not mean that as against the transferor the transaction is invalid”. [Para 16][379-D-H; 380-A]
1.4. The prohibition by application of the principles of the doctrine of lis pendens would take its effect with the institution of the suit. There is no hesitation to hold that the High Court was perfectly justified in the circumstances, to come to the conclusion, while considering the application for amendment of the written statement filed at the appellate stage, that granting the same would have, in effect, necessitated framing of fresh issues and A B C D E F G H constrained the parties to agitate their rights as if in a de novo trial. The aspects is referred solely to drive home the point that since the subject suit is based only on possessory title viz., on the basis of prior possession the finding and consequential rejection of the prayer for amendment of written statement to bring in the plea of purchase of the property pending the suit by the deceased second appellant cannot be said to be ground resulting in grave injustice. [Para 16][380-B-D]
1.5. There was considerable delay in seeking amendment of the written statement or filing additional written statement and no sustainable reason was assigned as to why such prayers were not sought in the trial court while the original proceedings were pending before it. It is also relevant to note that such prayers were also not made before the High Court when the High Court initially disposed of RFA and also before this Court in the Civil Appeal against the said judgment. The impact and effect of the order of remand passed by this Court assumes great relevance. If the judgment of the High Court was not modified by this Court as per judgment in the Civil Appeal, it would have had the effect of reviving the suit in full and in such eventuality, the suit should have been deemed to be pending. [Para 20, 21][382-A-D]
1.6. In view of the subsequent judgment of this Court in the said Civil Appeal directed against the order of remand in RFA, the judgment of the High Court got merged in it. As per the same, the scope of proceedings before the trial court was confined only to record the additional evidence of defendants and to transmit the same to the High Court so as to enable the High Court to dispose of the RFA afresh. The trial court could not have expanded the scope of the proceedings before it contrary to the order of remand and hence, the trial court was perfectly correct in rejecting the application for amending the written statement [Para 22][383-A-C]
1.7. In the totality of the circumstances, taking into account the relevant reasons assigned by the High Court for disallowing the prayer for amendment of the written statement and taking note of the delay and the failure to offer any reason therefor and SHIVSHANKARA & ANR. v. H.P. VEDAVYASA CHAR A B C D E F G H 364 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
the reasons mentioned there is no perversity or illegality with the rejection of the prayer for amendment of the written statement. On the questions as to maintainability of the suit, whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties as also whether the suit ought to have been held as abated against all the defendants for non-substitution of all the legal heirs on the death of the original third defendant, the courts below returned concurrent findings against the appellants. [Para 23, 24][383-F- H; 384-A] 1.8 It cannot be understood as to how the plea regarding the maintainability of the suit arise for consideration. The contention of the appellants is that it was filed under section 6 of the Specific Relief Act and while disposing of the Civil Appeal, this Court held against the respondent/ the plaintiff that the suit is not one under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act. Ergo, according to the appellants, the relief claimed for possession by the plaintiff/the respondent was not entertainable as he being a person claiming only possessory title and the original defendant No. 2/ the deceased appellant No. 2 being the lawful owner of the suit schedule property. Though the contentions appear to be attractive and acceptable at the first blush the fact is that they are absolutely untenable and rightly held against them, in view of the materials on record. It is true that the respondent/ the plaintiff had a case that O.S. No. 6456 of 1993 filed under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act and even after, the judgment in the Civil Appeal he seems to have attempted to resurrect the said question. But this Court is entirely in agreement with the High Court that the question whether the suit is one under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act is not now available for consideration as it was held otherwise by this Court in the judgment in the Civil Appeal and as such it had attained finality. On the face of judgment in the Civil Appeal the conclusion that O.S. No. 6456 of 1993 is not one under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act is not revisitable. Evidently, even-after holding thus and upon modifying the judgment of the High Court, this Court directed only for fresh disposal of the RFA and in that regard the trial court was directed to record the additional evidence of the defendants and to transmit the same to the High Court along with a report. [Para 25, 26][384- B-G] A B C D E F G H 1.9 It is evident that on a careful consideration of the available pleadings of the defendants, the High Court held that they did not disclose their defence in their written statement and at the same time did not even contend therein that they are in possession of the suit property. In such circumstances, when the facts disclose no title in either party, at the relevant time, prior possession alone decides the right to possession of land in the assumed character of owner against all the world except against the rightful owner. In that context, it is worthy to refer to the maxim “Possessio contra omnes valetpraeter eur cui ius sit possessionis’ (he that hath possession hath right against all but him that hath the very right)”. The High Court is correct in holding the question of maintainability of the suit in the affirmative and in favour of the respondent herein. [Para 30 & 31][386-C-E, F] 1.10 As regards the abatement the question whether the suit ought to have been held as abated against all the defendants as contended by the appellants for non-substitution and owing to the failure to implead all the legal representatives on the death of the original third defendant. The contention that the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties is also raised based on the same reason. Hence, these questions are to be considered jointly. Obviously, the courts below declined to uphold the said contentions of the defendants. It is to be noted that the appellants have also raised a contention that SMS which is an organization and SVR ought to have been impleaded as parties to the suit and in view of their non impleadment, the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties. When that be the position and when the subject suit is one based on prior possession the appellants are not justified in contending that the suit is bad for non-joinder of SM Sangha and SVR. [Para 32][386-F-H; 387-A, D] 1.11 The appellants have also contended that the suit ought to have been held as abated against all the defendants owing to non-substitution of all the legal representatives of the deceased defendant No. 3 upon his death. This contention is bereft of any basis and merits and was rightly repelled by the courts below. In that regard it is to be noted that the first appellant and deceased SHIVSHANKARA & ANR. v. H.P. VEDAVYASA CHAR A B C D E F G H 366 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
second appellant as also their father were all arrayed in the suit as defendants and they were jointly defending the suit. Upon the death of original third defendant, the original defendants No.1 and 2, who are sons of the original defendant No.3 fully and substantially representing the joint interest contested the suit and, thereafter, after suffering an adverse judgment and decree in the suit diligently preferred the appeal before the High Court which ultimately culminated in the impugned judgment and decree. Even thereafter, obviously they are diligently prosecuting the joint interest, even if the contention of joint interest is taken as correct, by filing the captioned appeal. [Para 33][387-E-H] 1.12 The same analogy is applicable in a case where even in the event of death of one of the defendants, when the estate/ interest was being fully and substantially represented in the suit jointly by the other defendants along with deceased defendant and when they are also his legal representatives. In such cases, by reason of non-impleadment of all other legal heirs consequential to the death of the said defendant, the defendants could not be heard to contend that the suit should stand abated on account of non-substitution of all the other legal representatives of the deceased defendant. In this case, it is to be noted that along with the deceased 3rd defendant the original defendant Nos. 1 and 2 were jointly defending their joint interest. Taking into account the fact that the appellants/ the original defendants No. 1 and 2 despite the death of original defendant No.3 defended the suit and preferred and prosecuted the first appeal. Upon the death of the second appellant the joint interest is being fully and substantially taken forward in this proceeding as well by the first appellant along with the substituted legal representatives of the deceased second appellant, there is no reason to disagree with the conclusions and findings of the courts below for rejecting the contention that suit ought to have held abated owing to the non-substitution of all the legal heirs of deceased third defendant against all defendants. For the same reason, the submission that the suit was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties of all his legal heirs/representatives also fails. [Para 36][389-A-E] A B C D E F G H 1.13 There is yet another reason why the contention that suit was bad for non-joinder of necessary parties due to failure to bring on record the legal representatives of the deceased third defendant should fail. Relying on Exhibit D-1 it is contended that pursuant to the agreement for sale of the suit schedule property executed in favour of the first appellant/ the first defendant jointly by SMS and SVR its possession was handed over to the first appellant. Its rejection by the High Court is upheld. However, what is being taken out of the said contention is that based on the same the appellants cannot raise a ground of non-joinder of necessary parties, as the first appellant was arrayed as a party in the very suit itself and he being the person in favour of whom the same was allegedly executed. The contention raised based on Exhibit D-2 sale deed was also repelled by the High Court and is upheld. The note is taken of the same again solely to stress upon the position that the case built upon the same can in no way be the basis for raising a contention of non-joinder of necessary party/ parties. This is because the deceased second appellant who was shown as the vendee thereunder was the original second defendant in the suit. For the reasons the contention of nonjoinder of necessary parties fails. [Para 37][389-E-H; 390-A-B] 1.14 The courts below are correct in holding that the defendants did not have a case of ownership over the suit schedule property and such a case sought to bring out based on Exhibit D- 2 was repelled by the High Court and the same is upheld. They have also failed to establish any better claim for possession. The finding of the High Court that any volume of evidence sans appropriate pleadings would be no avail is the correct exposition of law. [Para 38][389-B-D] 1.15 In such circumstances, there is absolutely no hesitation to hold that the original defendants failed to raise sufficient and appropriate pleadings in the written statement that they have better right for possession of the suit properties. No amount of proof offered without appropriate pleadings would have any relevance. The courts below have rightly relied on the evidence of PW-5 to hold forceful dispossession of the defendants from ‘B’ schedule property. Nothing is on record to uphold the SHIVSHANKARA & ANR. v. H.P. VEDAVYASA CHAR A B C D E F G H 368 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
said finding. As regard the issue whether the impugned judgment is inflicted with perversity or any patent illegality warranting interference in invocation of the power under Article 136 of the Constitution of India. The sound reasons given by the courts below persuade to answer it in the negative. After carefully considering the evidence on record the trial court arrived at the conclusion that the respondent/ the plaintiff is entitled to get back the possession of suit schedule property from which he was dispossessed and even after careful consideration of the additional evidence recorded and transmitted to the High Court by the trial court and considering all contentions and aspects the High Court only confirmed the judgment and decree of the trial court. When the concurrent findings of the courts below are the outcome of the rightful consideration and appreciation of materials on record they do not call for any interference. Taking into account the fact that the suit was indisputably filed based on prior permission and illegal dispossession there is no reason to place sale deed executed (even if by the owners) in favour of the deceased second appellant to displace the concurrent findings of the courts below on the entitlement of the respondent/the plaintiff for a decree as granted by the trial court and confirmed by the High Court. [Para 39, 40, 41][390-G; 391-A-F] Thomson Press (India) Ltd. v. Nanak Builders and Investors Private Limited (2013) 5 SCC 397 : [2013] 2 SCR 74; Gayathri Women’s Welfare Association v.
Gowramma And Anr. (2011) 2 SCC 330 : [2011] 2 SCR 47; Pandit Ishwardas v. State of Madhya Pradesh And Ors. (1979) 4 SCC 163 : [1979] 2 SCR 424; United Bank of India, Calcutta v. Abhijit Tea Co. (P) Ltd. & Ors. (2000) 7 SCC 357 : [2000] 3 Suppl. SCR 153;
Rukhmanand v. Deenbandh 1971 JLJ SN 159; Krishna Ram Mahale (Dead), By LRs v. Mrs. Shobha Venkat Rao (1989) 4 SCC 131; Nair Service Society Ltd v. Rev.
Father K. C. Alexander & Ors. AIR 1968 SC 1165 :
[1968] SCR 163; Mustapha Saheb v. Santha Pillai (1900) ILR 23 Mad 179; Bhurey Khan v. Yaseen Khan (Dead) By LRs. And Ors. (1995) 3 Supp. SCC 331; State A B C D E F G H of Andhra Pradesh through Principal Secretary and Ors. v. Pratap Karan and Ors. (2016) 2 SCC 82 : [2015] 12 SCR 702; Duggi Veera Venkata Gopala Satyanarayana v. Sakala Veera Raghavaiah and Anr.
(1987) 1 SCC 254 : [1987] 1 SCR 674; Hasmat Rai & Anr. v. Raghunath Prasad (1981) 3 SCC 103 : [1981] 3 SCR 605; Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin and Anr.
(2012) 8 SCC 148 : [2012] 8 SCR 35 – referred to.
R.F.V. Heuston, Salmond on the Law of Torts 4 (17th Edn., 1977) – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2013] 2 SCR 74 referred to Para 16 [2011] 2 SCR 47 referred to Para 18, 19 [1979] 2 SCR 424 referred to Para 18 [2000] 3 Suppl. SCR 153 referred to Para 21 (1989) 4 SCC 131 referred to Para 27 [1968] SCR 163 referred to Para 27, 28 (1900) ILR 23 Mad 179 referred to Para 28 (1995) 3 Supp. SCC 331 referred to Para 34 [2015] 12 SCR 702 referred to Para 35 [1987] 1 SCR 674 referred to Para 38 [1981] 3 SCR 605 referred to Para 38 [2012] 8 SCR 35 referred to Para 38 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 10215 of 2011.
From the Judgment and Order dated 09.09.2010 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bangalore in RFA No. 1966 of 2007.
Ms. Kiran Suri, Sr. Adv., T. S. Shanthi, Narendra Kumar, Sanjeev Kumar, Advs. for the Appellants.
Narendra Hooda, Sr. Adv., Aljo K. Joseph, Shaurya Lamba, Ms. Shelna K., Ritesh Kumar Chowdhary, Advs. for the Respondent. SHIVSHANKARA & ANR. v. H.P. VEDAVYASA CHAR A B C D E F G H 370 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
C. T. RAVIKUMAR, J.
1. The defendant Nos. 1 and 2 in O.S. No.6456 of 1993 on the file of the Court of XIV Additional City Civil Judge, Bangalore, filed this appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution of India, calling in question the judgment and decree dated 09.09.2010 passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in RFA No.1966 of 2007. They are the sons of the third defendant in the said suit, who died during its pendency. They filed the stated first appeal on being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and decree dated 04.07.2007 in O.S. No.6456 of 1993. During the pendency of the captioned appeal, the second appellant died and consequently his legal heirs were impleaded as additional appellants 2.1 to 2.4. Ergo, in this appeal, hereafter the original first appellant and the impleaded legal heirs of the deceased second appellant are collectively described as ‘appellants’, unless otherwise specifically mentioned. The respondent herein was the plaintiff in the said suit which was filed originally praying thus: - “to grant a judgment for decree of permanent injunction restraining the first and second defendants either by themselves or through anyone on their behalf from interfering in the plaintiffs right, title and interest over and in the suit schedule property including creating documents alienating the property to others and award cost and grant such other relief (s) as deemed fit and proper under the circumstances to the interest of justice and equity.”
2. The appellants herein filed written statement contending, inter alia, that the subject suit is not maintainable, that there is no prayer for possession, that the suit was not valued correctly and that the real owners of the suit property was not arraigned as parties. Subsequently, the plaintiff /respondent herein got amended the plaint by adding paragraph 9 (a), schedules A, B and ‘C’ and also prayers qua them viz., prayer ‘b’. Compositely, the suit property, which is a house bearing No. B-91, has been described as ‘A schedule’ and out of which a portion measuring 35’ x 40’, within the boundaries mentioned, has been described as ‘B schedule’. ‘C schedule’ is the portion of the premises bearing No. B-91 as described therein. To be precise, the prayers in the amended plaint read as under: - A B C D E F G H “(a) a judgment and decree of perpetual injunction against the defendants 1 to 3 directing the defendants to restore the possession of the schedule premises to the plaintiff and not to interfere in the plaintiffs’ lawful possession and enjoyment of the schedule property in any manner whatsoever.
(b) A judgment and decree against the defendants for mandatory injunction directing the defendants to restore the possession of the ‘B’ schedule property, which is marked ‘ABCD’ in the annexed sketch, and there may be decree for permanent injunction against the defendants for ‘CDEF’ portion which is marked as ‘C’ schedule to the plaint and there may be a decree for the enquiry into the mesne profits with Order XVIII Rule 12 of CPC, and also there may be a decree for the cost of the suit, with such other relief or reliefs as this Hon’ble Court deems fit in the circumstances of the case.:
3. Obviously, the defendants did not challenge the order allowing the amendment of the plaint and also did not file additional written statement after the amendment.
4. The Trial Court framed the following issues based on the pleadings on both sides:
1) Whether the suit is bad for mis-joinder or non-joinder of necessary parties?
2) Whether the Court fee paid on the plaint is insufficient? 3) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for possession of the suit schedule premises?
5. Though the plaintiff/respondent herein adduced oral and documentary evidence in support of his claims, the defendant therein did not lead any evidence, at all. The Trial Court, after considering the evidence and the provisions of law applicable partly decreed the suit as per judgment dated 04.07.2007, holding that the plaintiff/respondent herein, is entitled to recover possession of suit ‘B’ schedule property from the defendants and consequently directed the defendants to vacate and deliver suit ‘B’ schedule property to the plaintiff (the respondent herein) within two months from that day. Further, it was also decreed that the plaintiff would be entitled to recover possession of ‘B’ schedule property from the SHIVSHANKARA & ANR. v. H.P. VEDAVYASA CHAR [C. T. RAVIKUMAR, J.] A B C D E F G H 372 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
defendants by due process of law in case of failure on the part of the defendants to vacate and deliver the suit ‘B’ schedule property within the period stipulated. Furthermore, the defendants were restrained by perpetual injunction from interfering with the peaceful possession and enjoyment of ‘C’ schedule property by the plaintiff.
6. As noted earlier, defendant No. 3 died during the pendency of the suit. The surviving defendants viz., the original defendant Nos.1 and 2 challenged the judgment and decree dated 04.07.2007 of the trial Court before the High Court in RFA No.1966 of 2007. In the said first appeal, they filed an application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, the CPC’) seeking permission to produce additional evidence. Virtually, they did not adduce any evidence whatsoever before the trial court. The respondent herein (the plaintiff) objected to the maintainability of the appeal as the original suit viz., O.S. No.6456 of 1993 was filed under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963. The High Court dispelled the said objection and as per judgment dated 29.10.2007 allowed the application for production of additional evidence and remanded the matter to the trial Court for fresh disposal after affording an opportunity to the defendants viz., the first appellant herein and the deceased second appellant to lead additional evidence. The said judgment of the High Court dated 29.10.2007 was challenged by the plaintiff/respondent herein before this Court in SLP (Civil) No.1279 of 2008 essentially, contending that the said suit being one filed under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, the appeal filed before the High Court being RFA No.1966 of 2007 was incompetent. Leave was granted by this Court and the Civil Appeal arising from the SLP viz., Civil Appeal No.5201 of 2009 was dispose of as per judgment dated 03.09.2009 holding that O.S. No.6456 of 1993 was not one under Section 6 of the Specific Relief Act, as the relief sought for did not fall within its scope. While, virtually, remanding the matter thereunder to the High Court for fresh disposal of the appeal the trial Court was directed to record the evidence as directed by the High Court and to submit a report thereon to the High Court to enable it to dispose of the appeal within the time stipulated.
7. Before proceeding with the matter further, we think it appropriate to consider the impact of such an order of remand as it would certainly deconvolute consideration of this appeal. There can be no doubt with respect to the settled position that the Court to which the case is remanded has to comply with the order of remand and acting A B C D E F G H contrary to the order of remand is contrary to law. In other words, an order of remand has to be followed in its true spirit. True that in this case the High Court, originally, as per judgment dated 29.10.2007 remanded the matter to the trial Court for fresh disposal and while doing so, it also directed the trial Court to afford opportunity to the defendants to lead evidence. But then, the same was modified by this Court and as per the judgment in C.A. No.5201 of 2009 the matter was remanded to the High Court for fresh disposal of RFA No.1996 of 2007 and the further direction to the trial Court was only to record the evidence as directed by the High Court and to forward it along with report to enable the High Court to dispose of the appeal taking into account the additionally recorded evidence of the defendants as well. Thus, it is evident that the direction to the trial Court for recording the evidence and submitting it along with report will not efface the evidence already on record or will not be having the effect of setting aside of the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court and indisputably, its purpose was only to enable the High Court to consider RFA No.1996 of 2007 carrying challenge against the judgment and decree of the trial Court in O.S. No.6456 of 1993, not only based on the evidence already considered by the trial Court but also based on the additionally recorded evidence of the defendants based on its judgment dated 29.10.2007.
8. Now, we will proceed with the matter further. In fact, in the meanwhile, pursuant to the order of remand by the High Court the Trial Court took up the matter and posted it for defendants’ evidence. The original defendant Nos. 1 and 2 (the first appellant herein and the deceased second appellant) filed an application for amendment of the written statement before the Trial Court. Besides the same, three more applications were filed before the Trial Court viz., (1) seeking permission to file additional written statement; (2) seeking permission to produce 8 documents; and (3) to recall PW-1. The Trial Court allowed only the applications for permission to produce documents and to recall PW-1, by order dated 13.11.2007. The plaintiff/respondent herein challenged the same before the High Court in WP No. 18328 of 2007 and consequently, the High Court stayed the said order dated 13.11.2007. It was thereafter that Civil Appeal No. 5201 of 2009 was disposed of by this Court in the manner mentioned above. Pursuant to this Court’s order dated 03.08.2009 the Trial Court took up the matter and posted it for the evidence of the defendants. They filed I.A. No. 8 of 2009 seeking permission to amend the written statement which came to be dismissed SHIVSHANKARA & ANR. v. H.P. VEDAVYASA CHAR [C. T. RAVIKUMAR, J.] A B C D E F G H 374 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
by the Trial Court. Thereafter, the second defendant filed affidavit in lieu of chief examination and got marked Exhibits D-1 to D-9 and he was also cross-examined. However, they did not examine any other witnesses. Later, the Trial Court transmitted the recorded evidence to the High Court along with its report.
8.1 Pursuant to the receipt of the report and recorded evidence the High Court took up RFA No. 1966 of 2007. The defendants viz., the appellants therein filed three interlocutory applications before the High Court as hereunder:- 1) Misc. Civil Application No. 10400/2010 under Order 41 Rule 2 read with Section 151 CPC to raise additional grounds 16A and l6B in the Appeal.
2) Misc. Civil Application No. 11451/2010 under Order 41 Rule 2 read with Section 151 CPC to raise additional grounds 16C and 16D in the appeal.
3) Misc. Civil Application No.11452/2010 under Order 6 Rule 17 read with 151 CPC for amendment of written statement.
8.2 Misc. Civil Application No. 10400/2010 to raise additional grounds was allowed on consent. However, the other two applications were vehemently opposed. After hearing the parties on the main appeal as also on the other two applications referred above, the Hon’ble High Court formulated the following points for consideration: -
(i) “Whether the application Misc.Civil.No.11452 / 2010 filed by the appellants under Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking amendment of the written statement to incorporate paragraphs 26(b) to 26(e) deserves to be allowed or rejected?”
(ii) Whether the application Misc. Civil No.11451/2010 filed under 41 Rule 2 r/w Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure by the appellants to raise additional grounds in this appeal as ground No. l6C & 16D is to be allowed or dismissed?”
(iii) Whether the suit as brought is maintainable or not?
(iv) Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties?
A B C D E F G H
(v) Whether the judgment and decree passed by the XIV Addl. City Civil Court in O.S. No.6456/1993 dated 4-7-2007 is to be reversed, confirmed or modified?
(vi) What order?”
9. After elaborately considering the contentions, the evidence adduced by both sides with reference to the rival pleadings, the High Court answered the points formulated against the appellants herein and in favour of the respondent herein. Misc. Application Nos. 11451 of 2010 and 11452 of 2010, seeking respectively amendment of the written statement and permission to raise additional grounds viz., ground No.16
(c) and 16(d), were dismissed. Point No.3 in regard to the maintainability of the suit raised by the appellants therein was rejected and suit was held as maintainable. On the question whether the suit is bad for nonjoinder of necessary parties viz. point No.4, it was held in the negative. Based on conclusions and findings on the points formulated it was held that the respondent herein/the plaintiff is entitled to the judgment and decree as decreed by the Trial Court and consequently the appeal was dismissed with cost and the judgement and decree of the Trial Court was confirmed. Hence, this appeal.
10. Heard, Ms. Kiran Suri, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants and Mr. Narender Hooda, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent.
11. The appellants have raised multiple grounds to assail the judgment of the High Court. It is contended inter alia that the plaintiff/ the respondent herein had failed to establish his possession over plaint ‘B’ schedule property. That apart, it is contended that the High Court had failed to consider the contention that the subject suit was actually abated owing to the failure of the respondent herein/the plaintiff to bring on record the legal representatives of Sri Hanumaiah, the third respondent who breathed his last during the pendency of the subject suit. It is their further contention that Sri Rama @ Ramamurthy, the deceased second defendant had purchased the suit property from Sriman Madhwa Sangha which is an organisation and Sri Vittal Rao as per sale deed executed on 05.10.2000 jointly by the latter and the authorised representative of the former organisation and therefore, the High Court ought not to have confirmed the judgment and decree of the trial Court.
12. We have already taken note of the fact that the Misc. Civil Application carrying the prayers for amendment of the written statement SHIVSHANKARA & ANR. v. H.P. VEDAVYASA CHAR [C. T. RAVIKUMAR, J.] A B C D E F G H 376 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 6 S.C.R.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.