Bohatie Devi (Dead) Through Lr v. The State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 465; [2023] 5 S.C.R. 644
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice M.R. Shah, Justice C.T. Ravikumar Code of Criminal Procedure, Justice 1973 – Ss.158, Justice 173(3) – Reinvestigation By Another Agency – Order Passed By Secretary (Home), Justice State of U.P., Justice The Secretary (Home) Passed
- Decided
- 28 Apr 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1294/2023
- Sections
- 173(3), 158, 173, 173(8), 482
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 644 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
BOHATIE DEVI (DEAD) THROUGH LR
v.
THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS
(Criminal Appeal No. 1294 of 2023)
APRIL 28, 2023
[M. R. SHAH AND C. T. RAVIKUMAR, JJ.] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – ss.158, 173(3) – Reinvestigation by another agency – Order passed by Secretary (Home), State of U.P., Lucknow for reinvestigation by CBCID – Legality of – Held: s.173(3) r/w s.158 does not permit the Secretary (Home) to order for further investigation/reinvestigation by another agency, other than the officer in charge of the concerned Police Station and/or his superior officer – For reinvestigation, the prior permission/approval of the Magistrate is required – In the present case, the Secretary (Home) passed an order for reinvestigation by CBCID and thereafter, the CBCID sent the intimation to the Magistrate – Thus, no prior approval/permission was accorded by the Magistrate – Order passed by the Secretary (Home) ordering reinvestigation by another agency and that too, on the basis of the application/complaint submitted by mother of the accused is unknown to law – Impugned judgment passed by the High Court is quashed and set aside – Order passed by the Secretary (Home) and consequently, further investigation/reinvestigation by the CBCID is also quashed and set aside – Penal code – ss.302, 120B.
Disposing of the appeals, the Court HELD: 1.1 Respondent Nos. 8 and 11 as such have been chargesheeted for the offence under Sections 302 and 120B of the IPC of which the cognizance has been taken by the Magistrate on 21.12.2016. That thereafter, respondent No. 8 as such moved the quashing petition before the High Court for quashing the entire criminal proceedings including the chargesheet/ supplementary chargesheet. The High Court dismissed the quashing petition. Therefore, the accused must have taken all the defences which might have been available to him while considering quashing petition including the ground on which now further investigation/reinvestigation is ordered by another [2023] 5 S.C.R. 644 A B C D E F G H agency, namely, CBCID. Thereafter, respondent No. 8 approached this Court and the Special Leave Petition came to be dismissed by this Court and the interim protection in favour of respondent No. 8 came to be vacated. That thereafter, nonbailable warrant was issued against respondent No. 8 and only thereafter, mother of respondent No. 8 – accused moved an application before the Secretary (Home) for further investigation and he transferred the investigation to CBCID, inter-alia, on the ground that the so-called eye witnesses of the murder were not the eye witnesses. The request of the mother of accused has been accepted by the Secretary (Home) and the investigation was transferred to another agency, namely, CBCID despite the fact that after the first chargesheet, the investigation was handed over to the District Crime Branch to further investigate the case and they filed the supplementary chargesheet in which respondent Nos. 8 and 11 were even chargesheeted. Therefore, as such it is not a case of further investigation, but is a case of reinvestigation by another agency. The order passed by the Secretary (Home) transferring the investigation/ordering further investigation by another agency and that too, on the basis of the application/ complaint submitted by mother of the accused is unknown to law. [Para 7][651-F-H; 652-A-B] 1.2 There cannot be any dispute that even after the chargesheet is filed, it is the right of the investigating officer to further investigate in respect of offence even after a report under sub-section (2) of Section 173 of Cr.PC forwarded to a Magistrate and as observed and held by this Court the prior approval of the Magistrate is not required. However, as per the settled position of law, so far as the reinvestigation is concerned, the prior permission/approval of the Magistrate is required. In the present case, the Secretary (Home) has passed an order for further investigation by CBCID and thereafter, the CBCID has sent the intimation to the Magistrate. No prior approval/permission as observed by the High Court has been accorded by the Magistrate. The High Court in the impugned judgment and order has observed that the further investigation is ordered with the concurrence of the Magistrate, which is factually incorrect. In any case, as it is a case of reinvestigation, the same is not permissible and that too by another agency without the prior permission of the Magistrate BOHATIE DEVI (DEAD) THROUGH LR v. THE STATE OF
UTTAR PRADESH & ORS
A B C D E F G H 646 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
even while exercising the powers under Section 173(8) of the Cr.PC. So far as the investigation is concerned under the scheme of the Cr.PC, the Police Officer of the concerned Police Station, who is the investigating officer, has to investigate/further investigate the case under the supervision of Superintendent of Police. So far as the Secretary (Home) is concerned, he does not come into picture at all. If such powers are given to the Secretary (Home) in that case any accused who is already chargesheeted may approach the Secretary (Home) and may get an order of further investigation or reinvestigation by another agency and obtain the fresh report nullifying the earlier chargesheet and get himself discharged. If the accused is aggrieved by the chargesheet in that case, the remedy available to him would be either to file the quashing petition under Section 482 of Cr.PC and/or to move an appropriate application for discharge before the Magistrate and it is for the High Court and/or the Magistrate as the case may be, to quash criminal proceedings or discharge the accused. The Secretary (Home) and/or any accused who is already chargesheeted cannot be permitted to circumvent such provision. In the present case, respondent No. 8 – accused earlier did file the quashing petition, but failed. [Paras 7.1, 7.2][652-D- H; 653-A-E] 1.3 Section 173(3) read with Section 158 does not permit the Secretary (Home) to order for further investigation/ reinvestigation by another agency, other than the officer in charge of the concerned Police Station and/or his superior officer. [Para 7.3][653-G] State of Andhra Pradesh Vs. A.S. Peter (2008) 2 SCC 383 : [2007] 13 SCR 517; Ram Lal Narang Vs. State (Delhi Administration) (1979) 2 SCC 322 : [1979] 2 SCR 923 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2007] 13 SCR 517 referred to Para 5.1 [1979] 2 SCR 923 referred to Para 5.2 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.1294 of 2023.
With Criminal Appeal No. 1295 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 17.11.2020 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in CRLMWP No.7093 of 2019.
A B C D E F G H Ardhendumauli Kumar Prasad, A.A.G., Ms. Vibha Datta Makhija, S Nagamuthu, Rameshwar Singh Malik, Sr. Advs., Atul Kumar, Abhimanyu Sharma, Ms. Deepali, Pulak Bagchi, Tarun Gupta, Jitesh Malik, R Sudhakaran, Abhaya Nath Das, Satish Kumar, Harikesh Singh, Sandeep Sinhmar, Satish Hooda, Satyendra Kumar, Anand Sanjay M. Nuli, Prashant Chowdhari, K.P. Singh, Kanishk Chowdhari, Sarvesh Singh Baghel, Ms. Deepika Kalia, Sidharth Sengar, Advs. for the appearing parties.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
M. R. SHAH, J.
1. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court of Allahabad in Criminal Misc. Writ Petition No. 7093/2019, by which, the High Court has dismissed the said writ petition preferred by the appellant herein – mother of the deceased – Satyveer alias Kallu, in which, the appellant challenged order dated 13.02.2019 passed by the Secretary (Home), State of UP, Lucknow, whereby he ordered for further investigation by CBCID of Case Crime No. 1069/2014, the original writ petitioner has preferred the present appeal.
2. The facts leading to the present appeal in a nutshell are as under: - 2.1 That son of the appellant – Satyaveer @ Kallu was murdered by un-known persons. An FIR was lodged by the informant Sanjeev son-in-law of the appellant against Smt. Anju and two un-known persons. The investigation was carried out by the Inspector of Police, Baraut, District Baghpat who submitted chargesheet on 01.03.2015 against two persons of which cognizance was taken by the learned Magistrate on 31.03.2015. That thereafter, on the complaint/application by the appellant, the investigation was handed over to the District Crime Branch. A supplementary chargesheet was filed on 02.12.2016 against one Ashwani Kumar – respondent No. 8 herein (son of respondent No. 9 herein) and Smt. Anju - respondent No. 11 herein. The learned Magistrate took cognizance of the same on 21.12.2016. That thereafter, respondent No. 8, namely, Ashwani Kumar filed the quashing petition before the High Court for quashing of the entire criminal proceedings of Case No. 7626/ 2016 originating out of Case Crime No. 1069/2014 as well as for quashing of the chargesheet dated 02.12.2016. The said application came to be BOHATIE DEVI (DEAD) THROUGH LR v. THE STATE OF
UTTAR PRADESH & ORS
A B C D E F G H 648 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
dismissed by the High Court on 05.07.2017. Being aggrieved of order dated 05.07.2017, respondent No. 8 – Ashwani Kumar approached this Court by way of Special Leave Petition (Crl) No. 599/2017 which was dismissed by this Court on 24.08.2018. This Court also vacated the interim protection granted to respondent No. 8 vide order dated 15.09.2017. The learned CJM, Baghpat issued non-bailable warrant against respondent No. 8 vide order dated 08.09.2018. That thereafter and after non-bailable warrant was issued against respondent No. 8 herein, mother of Ashwani Kumar – accused moved an application dated 23.01.2019 to the Secretary (Home), State of Uttar Pradesh for transferring the investigation to CBCID, inter-alia, on the ground that respondent No. 8 has been arraigned as accused on the basis of statements of two witnesses who in fact were in the Jail and therefore, their statements cannot be believed. That by order dated 13.02.2019, Secretary (Home) State of U.P., Lucknow, ordered further investigation by CBCID. The order passed by the Secretary (Home) transferring investigation to CBCID was impugned before the High Court by way of present petition. By the impugned judgment and order the High Court has dismissed the writ petition by observing that further investigation was ordered after intimation to the learned Magistrate and therefore, there is no infirmity in the order passed by the Secretary (Home) directing further investigation. The impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court is the subject matter of present appeal.
3. Ms. Vibha Datta Makhija, learned Senior Advocate has appeared on behalf of the appellant and Shri S. Nagamuthu and Shri Rameshwar Singh Malik, learned Senior Advocates have appeared on behalf of respondent Nos. 8 and 11. Shri Anand Sanjay M. Nuli, learned counsel has appeared on behalf of the intervenor.
4. Ms. Makhija, learned Senior Advocate appearing on behalf of the appellant has vehemently submitted that the order passed by the Secretary (Home) transferring the investigation to CBCID is absolutely illegal and contrary to the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.PC).
4.1 It is submitted that in the present case after thorough investigation by the investigating agency of the State, respondent Nos. 8 and 11 were chargesheeted. It is submitted that once chargesheeted thereafter, at the instance of mother of one of the accused, the Secretary (Home) could not have transferred the investigation.
A B C D E F G H 4.2 It is vehemently submitted that such an order of transfer of investigation by the Secretary (Home) and that too at the instance of mother of one of the accused, is un-known to law and is not permissible at all.
4.3 It is further submitted by Ms. Makhija, learned Senior Advocate that in fact, the grounds on which the investigation was sought to be transferred can be said to be the defences on behalf of the accused which are required to be considered at the time of trial. It is submitted that as such by passing the order of transfer of investigation to CBCID and the subsequent investigation by CBCID virtually acquits the accused who are chargesheeted in the supplementary chargesheet and would tantamount to nullify the chargesheet against respondent Nos. 8 and 11, which as such is not permissible.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.