State of Gujarat & Ors. Etc. v. Dr. P. A. Bhatt & Ors. Etc.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 434; [2023] 5 S.C.R. 301
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice V. Ramasubramanian
- Decided
- 26 Apr 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 8553/2014
- Sections
- 174, 176
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 301[2023] 5 S.C.R. 301
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS. ETC.
v.
DR. P. A. BHATT & ORS. ETC.
(Civil Appeal Nos. 8553-8557 of 2014)
APRIL 26, 2023
[V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN AND PANKAJ MITHAL, JJ.] Service Law : Equal Pay – Allopathy doctors and doctors of indigenous medicine-, if can be said to be performing “equal work” so as to be entitled to “equal pay Non-MBBS medical officers seeked extension of the benefit of higher scales of pay on parity with the allopathic doctors on the basis of the recommendations of Tikku Pay Commission – – Held: Classification based upon educational qualification for the grant of higher pay scale, is a valid classification – Both categories of doctors are certainly not performing equal work to be entitled to equal pay.
Pay scales – Appointment of officers to the same post in a cadre – Fixation of different scales of pay on the basis of educational qualifications possessed by them – Held: Classification based upon educational qualification for the grant of higher pay scale, is a valid classification – Thus, the classification based upon educational qualification is not violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. Allowing the appeals, the Court HELD: 1.1 The classification based upon educational qualification is not violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. Hence, the answer to Issue No.1 that Whether different scales of pay can be fixed for officers appointed to the same cadre, on the basis of the educational qualifications possessed by them would be in favour of the State and against the respondents. [Para 37][314-D-E] 1.2 Allopathy doctors are required to perform emergency duties and to provide trauma care. By the very nature of the science that they practice and with the advancement of science and modern medical technology, 23 the emergency duty that Allopathy doctors are capable of performing and the trauma care A B C D E F G H 302 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
that they are capable of providing, cannot be performed by Ayurved doctors. [Para 43][316-D-E] 1.3 It is also not possible for Ayurved doctors to assist surgeons performing complicated surgeries, while MBBS doctors can assist. This Court shall not be understood to mean as though one system of medicine is superior to the other. It is not the mandate nor within competence of this Court to assess the relative merits of these two systems of medical sciences. As a matter of fact, this Court is conscious that the history of Ayurveda dates back to several centuries. The Encyclopaedia Britannica states that the golden age of Indian medicine from 800 B.C., till 1000 A.D., was marked by the production of two medical treatises known as “caraka-samhita” and “susruta-samhita”. [Para 44][316- E-G] 1.4 Every alternative system of medicine may have its pride of place in history. But today, the practitioners of indigenous systems of medicine do not perform complicated surgical operations. A study of Ayurved does not authorise them to perform these surgeries. [Para 49][319-B-C] 1.5 A post-mortem or autopsy is not carried out by/in the presence of Ayurved doctors. Section 174 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 19738 deals with the procedure for the police to inquire and report on suicide, etc. Sub-section (3) of Section 174 mandates that the police officer shall, subject to such rules as the State Government may prescribe, forward the dead body, with a view to its being examined, to the nearest Civil Surgeon, or other qualified medical man appointed in this behalf by the State Government, in certain types of cases such as, (i) suicide by a woman within seven years of marriage; (ii) death of a woman within seven years of marriage in certain circumstances; and (iii) cases where there are any doubts regarding the cause of death. Section 176 of Cr.P.C deals with inquiry by Magistrates into cause of death. Sub-section (5) of Section 176 uses similar words namely “Civil Surgeon or other qualified medical man”. The AYUSH doctors are normally not notified as competent to perform postmortem. [Paras 50, 51][319-C-F] 1.6 It is common knowledge that during out-patient days (OPD) in general hospitals in cities/towns, MBBS doctors are A B C D E F G H made to attend to hundreds of patients, which is not the case with Ayurveda doctors. In the comparative chart extracted, the State of Gujarat have claimed that IV injections and ART injections cannot be administered by Ayurved doctors. [Paras 52-53][319- F-H] 1.7 Even while recognizing the importance of Ayurved doctors and the need to promote alternative/indigenous systems of medicine, this Court cannot be oblivious of the fact that both categories of doctors are certainly not performing equal work to be entitled to equal pay. Hence, issue No.2 is answered in favour of the appellant-State and against the respondents. [Para 54][320- A-B] 1.8 The impugned order of the High Court is liable to be set aside. As a sequitur, the benefits derived by the respondents by virtue of the interim order passed by this Court on 08.09.2014, are liable to be recovered from the respondents. In the normal course, this Court would not have desired to allow the State to effect recovery but for the fact that a few doctors have received and a few have not. Among the Ayurved doctors, a classification cannot be amde between those who have already received some benefits by virtue of the interim order of this Court dated 08.09.2014 and those who have not received such benefits. Moreover, the fundamental principle cannot be overlooked that a benefit derived by an individual by virtue of an interim order passed by a Court cannot be allowed to be retained, if the ultimate outcome of the case went against such a person. [Para 55][320- B-E] North Delhi Municipal Corporation vs. Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma 2021 (9) SCALE 47; The State of Mysore vs.
P. Narasinga Rao AIR 1968 SC 349 : [1968] SCR 407;
Dr. C. Girijambal vs. Government of Andhra Pradesh (1981) 2 SCC 155 : [1981] 2 SCR 782; Mewa Ram Kanojia vs. All India Institute of Medical Sciences (1989) 2 SCC 235 : [1989] 1 SCR 957; Shyam Babu Verma vs. Union of India (1994) 2 SCC 521 : [1994] 1 SCR 700; State of Haryana vs. Ram Chander (1997) 5 SCC 253 : [1997] 1 Suppl. SCR 309; Director of Elementary Education, Odisha vs. Pramod Kumar Sahoo (2019) 10 SCC 674 – referred to.
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS. ETC. v. DR. P. A. BHATT & ORS.
ETC.
A B C D E F G H 304 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
Britannica records in page 776 of Volume-23 (15th Edition); “Man and Medicine - A History” authored by Farokh Erach Udwadia – referred to.
Case Law Reference [1968] SCR 407 referred to Para 27 [1981] 2 SCR 782 referred to Para 28 [1989] 1 SCR 957 referred to Para 31 [1994] 1 SCR 700 referred to Para 33 [1997] 1 Suppl. SCR 309 referred to Para 34 (2019) 10 SCC 674 referred to Para 36 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 8553- 8557 of 2014.
From the Judgment and Order dated 17.01.2014 of the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in SCA Nos.3718, 6017, 6959, 11706 of 2008, 11363 of 2009 and LPA Nos. 295, 610, 642, 964, 965 of 2013. With Contempt Petition (C) Nos.701, 674 and 916 of 2017.
Nirav Majumdar, Priank Adhyaru, Rameshwar Prasad Goyal, Kusum Chaudhary, Ms. Archana Pathak Dave, Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Ms. Devyani Bhatt, Advs. for the appearing parties.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN, J.
1. These civil appeals arise out of a common order passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad confirming the order of the learned Single Judge, holding that the respondents possessing a degree of BAMS (Bachelor of Ayurved in Medicine and Surgery) should be treated at par with the doctors holding MBBS degrees and that they are entitled to the benefits of the recommendations of the Tikku Pay Commission.
2. We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties.
3. On the basis of a Memorandum of Settlement dated 21.08.1989 A B C D E F G H entered into by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare with the Joint Action Council of Service Doctors Organisation, a High-Power Committee was constituted on 03.05.1990 with Shri R.K. Tikku as its Chairman, for the purpose of improving the service conditions and prospects of the doctors in Government service.
4. This Committee held 30 meetings during the period from June- 1990 to October-1990 and submitted its recommendations under a Report dated 31.10.1990. The recommendations contained in this Report was confined only to service doctors holding MBBS degrees and post-graduate medical degrees and degrees in super-specialities and those on the teaching and non-teaching sides.
5. By a separate order dated 19.11.1990, the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare constituted another High-Power Committee under the chairmanship of the very same person, namely, Shri R.K. Tikku, for the purpose of considering the career improvement and cadre restructuring of the practitioners of Indian Systems of Medicine and Homeopathy. This Committee submitted a separate Report on 26.02.1991 and it was confined to practitioners of alternative Systems of Medicine, holding degrees in Ayurved/Unani/Siddha/Homeopathy.
6. The Government of India accepted the recommendations of the Tikku Committee dated 31.10.1990, in respect of allopathic doctors by Office Memorandum dated 14.11.1991. The State of Gujarat also accepted the recommendations of the Tikku Committee for allopathic doctors and issued an order in Resolution No.GHS/1094/2842/T dated 17.10.1994. It was stated in the said order dated 17.10.1994 that adequate number of allopathic doctors was not available in the State and that therefore, it was necessary to attract talent.
7. After the implementation of the recommendations of the Tikku Committee dated 31.10.1990 in respect of allopathic doctors, in the State of Gujarat by the Government Resolution dated 17.10.1994, the Local Fund Audit, Ahmedabad sought clarifications, vide letters dated 04.03.1998 and 21.04.1998, as to whether the same benefits are available to non- MBBS medical officers holding qualifications such as G.A.F.M/LMP.
8. In response, the Health and Family Welfare Department of the Government of Gujarat issued a Government Resolution bearing No.KRV/ 1098/726/CH dated 01.01.1999, holding that non-MBBS medical officers are also entitled to the benefit. Incidentally this letter stated that the STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS. ETC. v. DR. P. A. BHATT & ORS.
ETC. [V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN, J.] A B C D E F G H 306 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
recommendations of the Tikku Committee were extended even to doctors working under the Employees State Insurance Scheme, vide Government Resolution dated 01.07.1997.
9. The respondents herein who were originally appointed on adhoc basis, under the ‘Community Health Volunteer Medical Officers Scheme’ floated by the Government of India and who were later absorbed by the State of Gujarat in May- 1999, filed 4 writ petitions on the file of the High Court of Gujarat seeking extension of the benefit of higher scales of pay on the basis of the recommendations of Tikku Pay Commission. A separate writ petition was filed by the Medical Officers (Ayurved) Association, comprising of persons initially appointed as Medical Officers Class-III. The relief sought by this Association was similar to the one sought in the batch of four writ petitions.
10. By a common order dated 26.07.2012, a learned Judge of the High Court allowed all the writ petitions, holding that doctors having degrees in alternative Systems of Medicine are entitled to be treated at par with doctors holding MBBS degree.
11. The State of Gujarat preferred intra-court appeals. After filing appeals, the State also issued a Government Resolution dated 31.07.2013 withdrawing the Resolution dated 01.01.1999 by which the benefit was extended to non-MBBS degree holders. This was because the learned Single Judge held that discrimination between non-MBBS degree holders working in the ESI Scheme and non-MBBS degree holders working in other areas was not permissible.
12. But the Division Bench of the High Court dismissed all the intra-court appeals holding, (i) that both MBBS and non-MBBS doctors form part of the same cadre and hence no discrimination is permissible within the cadre on the basis of educational qualifications; and (ii) that the non-MBBS doctors were also discharging the same duties and functions discharged by MBBS doctors and were even manning primary health centres independently and that therefore they were entitled to equal pay.
13. Aggrieved by the said order of the Division Bench of the High Court, the State has come up with the above appeals. On 08.09.2014, this Court granted leave in the special leave petitions and passed an interim order to the following effect.
A B C D E F G H “Leave granted.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties, it is directed that the State of Gujarat shall comply with the order of the High Court up to 50% within two months. Needless to say, it case the appeal is dismissed, the respondents shall be entitled to the balance 50% with interest, which shall be determined at the time of final adjudication of the appeal.
Hearing expedited.”
14. Claiming that the above interim direction issued on 08.09.2014 was not complied, a batch of contempt petitions was filed in the year 2016. Those contempt petitions were disposed of on the basis of a statement made to the effect that the State will comply with the order by the end of October, 2016.
15. However, a fresh set of three contempt petitions were filed in the year 2017, complaining of wilful disobedience of the order dated 08.09.2014. These contempt petitions were directed to be listed alongwith the main appeals and this is why we have five civil appeals and three contempt petitions on hand.
Preliminary contention
16. The learned counsel for the respondents raised a preliminary issue that the question raised in these appeals is squarely covered by a recent judgment of this Court in North Delhi Municipal Corporation vs. Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma1 and that therefore the impugned order of the High Court does not need a deeper scrutiny. Therefore, it is necessary to address this preliminary issue before we proceed to consider the rival contentions on merits.
17. In Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma (supra), the only question that arose was as to whether the benefit of enhancement of age of retirement from 60 years to 65 years, granted in favour of Allopathy doctors, was available even for Ayurved doctors or not. It was held in the said decision as follows:
“22. The common contention of the appellants before us is that classification of AYUSH doctors and doctors under CHS in different categories is reasonable and permissible in law. This however does not appeal to us and we are inclined to agree with
1 2021 (9) SCALE 47
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS. ETC. v. DR. P. A. BHATT & ORS.
ETC. [V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN, J.] A B C D E F G H 308 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
the findings of the Tribunal and the Delhi High Court that the classification is discriminatory and unreasonable since doctors under both segments are performing the same function of treating and healing their patients. The only difference is that AYUSH doctors are using indigenous systems of medicine like Ayurveda, Unani, etc. and CHS doctors are using Allopathy for tending to their patients. In our understanding, the mode of treatment by itself under the prevalent scheme of things, does not qualify as an intelligible differentia. Therefore, such unreasonable classification and discrimination based on it would surely be inconsistent with Article 14 of the Constitution. The order of AYUSH Ministry dated 24.11.2017 extending the age of superannuation to 65 Years also endorses such a view. This extension is in tune with the notification of Ministry of Health and Family Welfare dated 31.05.2016.
23. The doctors, both under AYUSH and CHS, render service to patients and on this core aspect, there is nothing to distinguish them. Therefore, no rational justification is seen for having different dates for bestowing the benefit of extended age of superannuation to these two categories of doctors. Hence, the order of AYUSH Ministry (F.No.D14019/4/2016-E-I(AYUSH)) dated 24.11.2017 must be retrospectively applied from 31.05.2016 to all concerned respondent-doctors, in the present appeals. All consequences must follow from this conclusion.”
18. A cursory reading of the portion of the judgment extracted supra, may give an impression as though the question arising for consideration is no longer res integra and that Allopathy doctors and Ayurved doctors should be treated on par insofar as all service conditions are concerned. But a careful reading of the entire judgment shows that the said decision was based upon an order of the Ministry of Ayurveda, Yoga and Naturopathy, Unani, Siddha and Homeopathy (AYUSH) dated 24.11.2017. As seen from paragraph 2 of the said decision, the age of retirement of Allopathy doctors was increased by an order dated 31.05.2016 issued by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. This was followed by consequential amendment of the Fundamental Rules and Supplementary Rules, 1922. Since Ayurved doctors were not covered by the Ministry’s order dated 31.05.2016, Ayurved doctors filed applications before the Administrative Tribunal. The Administrative Tribunal allowed the applications by an order dated 24.08.2017. The North Delhi Municipal Corporation (employer) filed writ petitions before A B C D E F G H the High Court of Delhi challenging the decision of the Tribunal. During the pendency of the writ petitions, the Ministry of AYUSH issued an order dated 24.11.2017 enhancing the age of retirement of AYUSH doctors also to 65 years, but with effect from 27.09.2017. It is in that context that this Court held as aforesaid in Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma. This Court did not go into the question whether AYUSH doctors and Allopathy doctors were performing equal duties and responsibilities so as to be entitled to equal pay.
19. We must remember the fundamental distinction between, (i) the issue of law that equal work entails equal pay; and (ii) the issue of fact as to whether two categories of employees are performing equal work or not? This Court did not go into the factual aspect in Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma as to whether AYUSH doctors were performing equal work as Allopathy doctors. This Court simply relied upon the order of the Ministry of AYUSH itself enhancing the age of retirement of AYUSH doctors on par with Allopathy doctors.
20. In any case, the question of age of retirement stands on a different footing from the service conditions relating to pay and allowances and revision of pay. Therefore, we do not think that the issue raised in these appeals can be said to be covered by the decision in Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma.
Other contentions
21. Assailing the impugned order of the High Court, it is contended on behalf of the State that the recommendations of Tikku Pay Commission for enhancement of the scales of pay were per se applicable only to MBBS doctors; that the revision of scales of pay in favour of Allopathy doctors was warranted by the perennial shortage of Allopathy doctors; that the State Government had to fulfil its Constitutional obligation of providing adequate healthcare infrastructure to the citizens by recruiting qualified MBBS doctors, but the State could not attract sufficient talent, due to the poor pay structure; that in contrast, the State was never running short of AYUSH doctors and hence there was no necessity to lure qualified AYUSH doctors to come to service; that there is no impediment in law for providing different scales of pay to persons employed in the same cadre, based upon the qualifications; and that the High Court miserably failed to appreciate the completely different nature of duties and responsibilities performed by Allopathy doctors and AYUSH doctors and that therefore the impugned order is wrong, both in law and on facts. STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS. ETC. v. DR. P. A. BHATT & ORS.
ETC. [V. RAMASUBRAMANIAN, J.] A B C D E F G H 310 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 5 S.C.R.
22. In response, it is contended by the learned counsel for the respondents that both Allopathy doctors and AYUSH doctors are appointed to the post of Medical Officer falling in Class-II of Gujarat Medical Services; that once persons with different qualifications are appointed to one unified cadre with a common pay scale and governed by one set of rules, then at a later stage, the Government cannot make a classification; that all Medical Officers, irrespective of their qualifications were discharging the same duties and responsibilities; that by the Government Resolution dated 01.01.1999, the recommendations of the Tikku Pay Commission were made applicable to non-MBBS degree holders working in the ESI Scheme; that it was only after the learned Single Judge allowed the writ petitions, that the State issued another Resolution dated 31.07.2013 withdrawing the Resolution dated 01.01.1999; and that the findings of fact recorded by the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court that both categories of doctors are performing equal work, does not call for any interference under Article 136 of the Constitution and that therefore the appeals are liable to be dismissed.
23. We have carefully considered the above submissions.
24. Two questions, in our opinion, arise for consideration in these appeals. They are:
(i) Whether different scales of pay can be fixed for officers appointed to the same cadre, on the basis of educational qualifications possessed by them?
(ii) Whether Allopathy doctors and doctors of indigenous medicine can be said to be performing “equal work” so as to be entitled to “equal pay”?
Question No.1: Whether different scales of pay can be fixed for officers appointed to the same cadre, on the basis of the educational qualifications possessed by them?
25. The first issue arising for consideration is as to whether persons appointed to the same post in a cadre can be given different scales of pay on the basis of educational qualifications?
26. Though the issue is no longer res integra, we shall refer to a few decisions, some of which were cited before the High Court also. A B C D E F G H
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.