Abhishek Singh v. Huhtamaki Ppl Ltd. & Anr.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 308; [2023] 4 S.C.R. 596
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Bhushan Ramkrishna Gavai, Justice Vikram Nath Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, Justice Even Where Such Application Was Filed Before the Constitution of Coc
- Decided
- 28 Mar 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2241/2023
- Sections
- 12A, 9, 14, 66, 12, 7, 10, 240, 30A, 62
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 596 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.[2023] 4 S.C.R. 596
ABHISHEK SINGH
v.
HUHTAMAKI PPL LTD. & ANR.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 2241 of 2023)
MARCH 28, 2023
[B. R. GAVAI AND VIKRAM NATH, JJ.] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016: ss.9 and 12A – Interpretation of s. 12A and Regn 30A – Withdrawal of application of Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process-CIRP before the constitution of Committee of Creditors-CoC – Validity of – Held: s.12A permits withdrawal of applications admitted u/ss. 7, 9 and 10 – s. 12A does not debar entertaining applications for withdrawal even before constitution of CoC – Application u/s. 12A cannot be said to be kept pending for constitution of CoC, even where such application was filed before the constitution of CoC – Furthermore, Regn 30A clearly provided for withdrawal applications being entertained before constitution of CoC – It does not in anyway conflicts or is in violation of s.12A – There is no inconsistency in the two provisions – It only furthers the cause introduced vide s.12A – On facts, petition u/s.9 filed by Operational Creditor-OC before NCLT for its outstanding amount against the Corporate Debtor- CD – Petition admitted and CIRP initiated – Within two days of admission order, OCs and CD entered into a settlement for payment of the amount even before constitution of CoC – After receipt of the settlement amount, OC filed application u/s.12A and Interim Resolution Professional filed an application u/Regn 30A seeking withdrawal of CIRP against the CD – However, the NCLT rejected the withdrawal application – Said order cannot be sustained – NCLT erred in taking a contrary view – At the time when the application for withdrawal of the proceedings was filed the CoC was not constituted as such there could not have been any other concerned parties except the OC, CD and IRP – It was only because of the delay caused by the NCLT in disposing of the applications u/s. 12A and Regn 30A that large number of creditors filed their claims – Inherent powers are to be invoked in order to meet the ends of justice which the NCLT failed to invoke – Thus, application filed u/ Regn 30A allowed and application u/s. 9 filed by the OCs stands A B C D E F G H withdrawn – Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 2018 – Regn. 30 A.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1.1 Plea of alternative remedy is a self-imposed restriction by the superior Courts and is never an absolute bar unless barred by the statute. Further, in the present case, this Court had entertained the SLP in 2021 itself and had granted an order of status quo on 20.04.2021. Substantial time has passed since then. As such this Court is not inclined to entertain the said objection relating to availability of alternative remedy of filing the appeal before the NCLT. IBC provides a statutory timeframe for disposal of matters. Further, such matters being commercial in nature keeping these matters pending for long, frustrates the very object of IBC. [Para 25][609-E-G] 1.2 The intervenors have vehemently contended that after 01.03.2021, once the NCLT has admitted the petition and had issued restraint order, section 14 of IBC had come into play; the transactions made in the accounts of the CD would be unlawful and illegal as such payment of the settlement amount from the funds of the CD transferred to the account of the suspended Director after 01.03.2021 ought to be rejected and no discretion should be exercised permitting withdrawal of the proceedings. Even the NCLT was not satisfied with the submission of the IRP and has not approved the same. Secondly, even if there was any transaction from the account of the CD, the same may at best be held to be a wrongful transaction and in any other proceedings where CIRP is initiated the amount so transferred could be recovered under section 66 of IBC by the IRP or the RP subject to establishing that the said transactions would be hit by the said provision. [Para 26][609-G-H; 610-A-C] 1.3 Other creditors would have their own right to avail such legal remedies as may be available to them under law with respect to their claims. The rights of the creditors for their respective claims do not get whittled down or adversely affected if the settlement with the OC in the instant case is accepted and the proceedings allowed to be withdrawn. [Para 27][610-D] ABHISHEK SINGH v. HUHTAMAKI PPL LTD. & ANR.
A B C D E F G H 598 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
1.4 Any amount spent by the IRP legally admissible to him could always be recovered in the same proceedings and the NCLT or the Adjudicating Authority would be well within its power to get the same cleared under Clause 7 of Regulation 30A of IBBI Regulations. [Para 28] 1.5 The NCLT committed an error in holding that the Regulation 30A would have no binding effect. This would amount to defeating the very purpose of substituting Regulation 30A in IBBI Regulations on 25.07.2019 after the judgment of Swiss Ribbons’s case which was dated 25.01.2019. Section 12A of IBC permits the withdrawal of applications admitted under sections 7, 9, and 10 of IBC. The withdrawal of such an application is with the approval of 90 percent voting of the CoC. Section 12A did not provide particularly for a situation wherein the CoC has not been constituted but, the Court held that Section 12A does not debar entertaining applications for withdrawal of CIRP even prior to the Constitution of CoC. Therefore, the application u/s 12 A for withdrawal cannot be said to be kept pending for the constitution of the CoC, even where such an application was filed before the constitution of the CoC. The substituted Regulation 30A of IBC as it stands today clearly provided for withdrawal applications being entertained before the constitution of CoC. It does not in any way conflicts or is in violation of section 12A of IBC. There is no inconsistency in the two provisions. It only furthers the cause introduced vide section 12A of IBC. NCLT fell in error in taking a contrary view. [Paras 34 and 35][612-F-G; 613-A-C] 1.6 From a perusal of the order of the NCLT it appears that it was annoyed with the conduct of CD and its counsel. NCLT has recorded its displeasure and annoyance at a couple of places referring to the conduct of the CD and its counsel before the NCLAT, and maybe for this reason, the NCLT passed the impugned order ignoring the observation in the NCLAT order dated 26.03.2021 which had specifically expressed that the Adjudicating Authority (NCLT) would pass orders on the withdrawal application without standing on technicalities. [Para 39][614-E-F] A B C D E F G H 1.7 At the time when the application for withdrawal of the proceedings was filed the CoC was not constituted as such there could not have been any other concerned parties except the OC, CD and IRP. It was only because of the delay caused by the NCLT in disposing of the applications under section 12A of IBC and Regulation 30A that large number of creditors filed their claims. The inherent powers are to be invoked in order to meet the ends of justice which, in our opinion, the NCLT failed to invoke. Regulation 30A of IBBI Regulations provide a complete mechanism for dealing with the applications filed under such provision. The issue raised by the IRP regarding its claim for expenses is well taken care of under the said provision. Various safeguards have been provided in Regulation 30A of IBBI Regulations to be fulfilled by the OC which apparently have been fulfilled as there is no complaint in that regard either by the IRP nor it is apparent from the impugned order of the NCLT. Thus, the objection raised by the IRP does not merit any consideration in this appeal. [Para 40, 41][614-G-H; 615-A-C] 1.8 The impugned order of NCLT cannot be sustained and is set aside. The application for withdrawal u/s 12A is allowed along with the application under Regulation 30A of IBBI Regulations. The Application u/s 9 of IBC filed by the OCs shall stand withdrawn. [Para 43][615-D] Swiss Ribbons (P) Ltd. v. Union of India (2019) 4 SCC 17 : [2019] 3 SCR 535; Kamal K.Singh v. Dinesh Gupta & Anr., dated 25.08.2021 in Civil Appeal No. 4993 of 2021 – relied on.
Ashok G. Rajani v. Beacon Trusteeship Ltd.& Ors. (2022)
SCC Online SC 1275; P. Mohanraj v. Shah Bros. ISPAT (P) Ltd. (2021) 6 SCC 258; Dena Bank (Now Bank of Baroda) v. Shivakumar Reddy & Anr. (2021) 10 SCC 330; MSTC Limited v. Adhunik Metalliks Ltd. and others (2019) SCC Online NCLAT 146; Indian Overseas Bank v. Mr. Dinkar T. Venkatsubramaniam, Resolution Professional for Amtek Auto Limited (2017) SCC Online NCLAT 584; Manoj K. Daga v. ISGEC Heavy Engineering Limited and others (2020) SCC Online NCLAT 869; Narayanamma and anr. v. Govindappa ABHISHEK SINGH v. HUHTAMAKI PPL LTD. & ANR.
A B C D E F G H 600 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
and Ors. (2019) 19 SCC 42; Ram Saran Das v. CTO Calcutta & Anr. AIR 1962 SC 1362; Titaghur Paper Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Orissa (1983) 2 SCC 433:[1983] 2 SCR 743 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [2019] 3 SCR 535 relied on Para 17 (2021) 6 SCC 258 referred to Para 22 (2021) 10 SCC 330 referred to Para 22 (2019) 19 SCC 42 referred to Para 22 AIR 1962 SC 1362 referred to Para 22 [1983] 2 SCR 743 referred to Para 22 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.2241 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 13.04.2021 of the National Company Law Tribunal in IA No.196 of 2021.
Shyam Divan, Sr. Adv., Abhijit Sinha, Mahesh Agarwal, Nachiket Dave, Himanshu Satija, Ms. Swaroop George, E. C. Agrawala, Pradhuman Gohil, Mrs. Taruna Singh Gohil, Ms. Ranu Purohit, Alapati Sahithya Krishna, Advs. for the Appellant.
Tushar Mehta, S.G., Kanu Agrawal, Saurabh Roy, Ms. Deepabali Dutta, Ms. Ruchi Gour Narula, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Ms. Anannya Ghosh, Kinshuk Chatterjee, Anirudh Sanganeria, Shamik Shirishbhai Sanjanwala, Sameer Abhyankar, Sarthak Ghonkrokta, Sunil Fernandes, Ms. Priyansha Sharma, Divyansh Tiwari, Advs. for the Respondents. The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
VIKRAM NATH, J.
Leave granted.
2. The appellant,a suspended Director of the Corporate Debtor1:Manpasand Beverages Ltd. (respondent 2),has filed this appeal assailing the correctness of the order dated 13.04.2021 passed by the National Company Law Tribunal2, Ahmedabad Bench at Ahmedabad in 1 In short “CD”
2 In short, “NCLT”
A B C D E F G H I.A. No.196 of 2021 arising out of C.P.(I.B.) No.503 of 2019 rejecting the application of the appellant under section 12A of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 20163 for withdrawal of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process4.
3. CD is in the business of manufacturing and distribution of fruit beverages. It has approximately 700 employees and a turnover of Rs.984.96 Crores in the Financial Year 2018-2019. The Operational Creditor5Huhtamaki PPL Ltd.(respondent No.1) used to supply packaging material to the CD.
4. The OCs filed a petition under section 9 of IBC before the NCLT, stating a total outstanding amount of Rs.1,31,00,825/- against the CD. This was registered as CP (IB) No. 503 of 2019.
5. The NCLT by order dated 01.03.2021 passed an order admitting the petition and initiating CIRP. Two days thereafter i.e. 03.03.2021, the OCs and the CD entered into a settlement wherein the CD was required to pay an amount of Rs.95.72 lakhs. The above settlement was arrived at even before the Committee of Creditors6 could be constituted.
6. On 4th March, 2021, the OCs received Rs.50 Lakhs and again on 8th March, 2021, it received the balance amount of Rs.45.72 lakhs. Thus, the total amount to be paid as per the settlement, was paid to the OCs. The Interim Resolution Professional7 on 10th March, 2021 moved an application under Regulation 30A of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Resolution Process for Corporate Persons) Regulations, 20188 seeking withdrawal of CIRP against the CD. Along with it the application of OCs dated 09.03.2021 was also attached which was moved under section 12A of IBC. The application for withdrawal was registered as IA No. 196 of 2021.
7. In the meantime, an appeal was preferred against the admission order dated 01.03.2021 before the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal9 apparently on the ground that section 9 of IBC petition was not maintainable as there was a pre-existing dispute. On 26.03.2021, the 3 In short, “IBC”
4 In short, “CIRP”
5 In short “OC”
6 In short “CoC”
7 In short “IRP”
8 In short “IBBI Regulations”
9 In short “NCLAT”
ABHISHEK SINGH v. HUHTAMAKI PPL LTD. & ANR.
[VIKRAM NATH, J.] A B C D E F G H 602 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
appeal was withdrawn before the NCLAT with liberty to apply for revival of the appeal in case the settlement failed. The NCLAT while allowing the withdrawal of the appeal granted stay of formation of CoC. The said order dated 26.03.2021 is reproduced below:
“Mr. Vikram Nankani, Advocate appears for the Appellant. He submits that Respondent No.1 – Operational Creditor filed CP (IB) No.503/9/NCLT/AHM/2019 before Adjudicating Authority (NCLT Ahmedabad Bench, Court No.1). The Application was filed under section 9 of Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC in short) against the Respondent No.2 M/s.Manpasand Beverages Ltd. the Corporate Debtor. Appellant is the Director of the Suspended Board of the Corporate Debtor. Respondent No.3 is Interim Resolution Professional.
2. Learned counsel for the Appellant submits that the Application was admitted by the Impugned Order and Appeal is filed. It is stated that thereafter the Appellant has settled the claim of Operational Creditor and the Operational Creditor has filed Application for withdrawal copy of which is at Page 348 and even the IRP has filed Application before the Adjudicating Authority copy of which is at page 368. The Application for withdrawal under section 12A of IBC has been filed through IRP. Mr. Salil Thakore, Advocate agrees with the Learned Counsel for the Appellant that there has been a settlement and accordingly Application under section 12A of IBC has ben filed. The Learned Counsel for IRP however states that the money has been paid violating moratorium which the IRP has reported to the Adjudicating Authority.
3. Mr. Hitesh Buch, PCS also agrees that settlement has taken place.
4. Learned counsel for the Appellant submits that considering these facts, the Appeal may be allowed to be withdrawn with liberty to seek restoration in case the effort with regard tosection 12 A of IBC runs into difficulty. The Learned Counsel for IRP accepts that Committee of Creditors (CoC in short) has not been constituted.
5. The learned counsel for the Appellant submits that he is making request for withdrawal of the Appeal under instructions from the Appellant.
A B C D E F G H
6. Considering the objects of IBC, we have no reason to doubt that the Adjudicating Authority without standing on technicalities would pass appropriate Orders, if settlement has taken place between the Original Operational Creditor and Corporate Debtor and CoC is not yet constituted.
7(A) For reasons stated above, the Appeal is permitted to be withdrawn with liberty to seek restoration of the Appeal in case at any future time the effort to settle in terms of section 12A of IBC runs into difficulty and does not happen.
7(B) Till the Adjudicating Authority decides Application under section 12 A of IBC which is stated to have already been filed, CoC may not be constituted.
The Appeal is disposed with observations and directions as above.”
8. NCLT by the impugned judgment and order dated 13.04.2021 rejected the settlement application and fixed the matter for disposal of the application under Regulation 30A of IBBI Regulations after hearing all creditors.
9. Subsequent to the above order of NCLT dated 13.04.2021, the IRP constituted the CoC on 15.04.2021. The appellant preferred the SLP on 19.04.2021. This Court vide order dated 20.04.2021 while issuing notice, directed the parties to maintain status quo.
10. It would be pertinent to mention here that primary opposition is by the IRP by way of an intervention application. The OC is not opposing the appeal in as much as it had already received the full amount as per the settlement dated 03.03.2021.Further, three other applications for intervention/impleadment have been filed by creditors of the CD, who allegedly had raised their claims before the IRP.
11. Before proceeding any further, the relevant statutory provisions may be noticed.
12. Rule 11 of The National Company Law Tribunal Rules, 201610 confer inherent powers on the NCLT to pass appropriate orders for meeting the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the Tribunal. The said rule is reproduced hereunder:
“11. Inherent powers- Nothing in these rules shall be deemed to limit or otherwise affect the inherent powers of the Tribunal to 10 In short “the NCLT Rules”
ABHISHEK SINGH v. HUHTAMAKI PPL LTD. & ANR.
[VIKRAM NATH, J.] A B C D E F G H 604 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
make such orders as may be necessary for meeting the ends of justice or to prevent abuse of the process of the Tribunal.”
13. Section 12A of IBC which was inserted w.e.f. 06.06.2018 permits withdrawal of applications admitted under sections 7, 9 or 10 of IBC, with the approval of 90 percent voting share of the CoC in such manner as may be specified. The said provision is reproduced below: “12A. Withdrawal of application admitted under section 7,9 or 10 – The Adjudicating Authority may allow the withdrawal of application admitted under section 7 or section 9 or section 10, on an application made by the applicant with the approval of ninety per cent voting share of the committee of creditors, in such manner as may be specified.”
14. Regulation 30A of IBBI Regulations was introduced after insertion of section 12A in IBC. It provided the mechanism of dealing with applications filed for withdrawal. Later on, itwas substituted by notification dated 25.07.2019 in IBBI Regulations. According to the said provision, withdrawal under section 12A of IBC could be moved before Adjudicating Authority by the applicant through IRP before constitution of the CoC and in case the CoC has been constituted, then also by the applicant through IRP or the RP.However, the applicant would be required to justify the withdrawal by giving reasons. It further provides the procedure for dealing with such an application. Regulation 30A of IBBI Regulations,as it stands today, is reproduced hereunder: “30A. Withdrawal of application. (1) An application for withdrawal under section 12A may be made to the Adjudicating Authority –
(a) before the constitution of the committee, by the applicant through the interim resolution professional;
(b) after the constitution of the committee, by the applicant through the interim resolution professional or the resolution professional, as the case may be:
Provided that where the application is made under clause (b) after the issue of invitation for expression of interest under regulation 36A, the applicant shall state the reasons justifying withdrawal after issue of such invitation.
(2) The application under sub-regulation (1) shall be made in Form- FA of the Schedule accompanied by a bank guarantee- A B C D E F G H
(a) towards estimated expenses incurred on or by the interim resolution professional for purposes of regulation 33, till the date of filing of the application under clause (a) of sub-regulation (1); or
(b) towards estimated expenses incurred for purposes of clauses (aa), (ab), (c) and (d) of regulation 31, till the date of filing of the application under clause (b) of sub-regulation (1).
(3) Where an application for withdrawal is under clause (a) of sub-regulation (1), the interim resolution professional shall submit the application to the Adjudicating Authority on behalf of the applicant, within three days of its receipt.
(4) Where an application for withdrawal is under clause (b) of sub-regulation (1), the committee shall consider the application, within seven days of its receipt.
(5) Where the application referred to in sub-regulation (4) is approved by the committee with ninety percent voting share, the resolution professional shall submit such application along with the approval of the committee, to the Adjudicating Authority on behalf of the applicant, within three days of such approval.
(6) The Adjudicating Authority may, by order, approve the application submitted under sub-regulation (3) or (5).
(7) Where the application is approved under sub-regulation (6), the applicant shall deposit an amount, towards the actual expenses incurred for the purposes referred to in clause (a) or clause (b) of sub-regulation (2) till the date of approval by the Adjudicating Authority, as determined by the interim resolution professional or resolution professional, as the case may be, within three days of such approval, in the bank account of the corporate debtor, failing which the bank guarantee received under sub-regulation (2) shall be invoked, without prejudice to any other action permissible against the applicant under the Code. “
15. NCLT, in the impugned order while rejecting I.A.No.196 of 2021 filed by the OCs, recorded the following findings:
i. The facts relating to the settlement and the fulfilment of the terms of the settlement are not disputed;
ABHISHEK SINGH v. HUHTAMAKI PPL LTD. & ANR.
[VIKRAM NATH, J.] A B C D E F G H 606 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 4 S.C.R.
ii. The suspended directors of the CD despite the moratorium having commenced with effect from 01.03.2021 have not only made transactions of deposit but also withdrawal from the account of the CD. They have thus violated the directions contained in the admission order dated 01.03.2021; iii. Although the IRP had made submissions that the suspended director having transferred huge amount from the account of the company to his personal account and from there having made the payment to the OC under the settlement but the same was not conclusively proved;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.