Shah Newaz Khan & Ors. v. State of Nagaland & Ors
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 176; [2023] 3 S.C.R. 985
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Hrishikesh Roy, Justice Dipankar Datta Code of Civil Procedure, Justice 1908 – Ss.24, Justice 25 – Constitution of India – Arts. 214, Justice Dimapur, Justice Nagaland to the Court of the District Judge At Gauhati, Justice Issue Was: Is the Supreme Court the Sole Repository of Power
- Decided
- 28 Feb 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1497/2023
- Sections
- 24, 25, 3, 24(1), 25(1), 23(1), 23(2), 22, 23, 229, 13, 18
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 985[2023] 3 S.C.R. 985
SHAH NEWAZ KHAN & ORS.
v.
STATE OF NAGALAND & ORS.
(Civil appeal no. 1497 of 2023)
FEBRUARY 28, 2023
[HRISHIKESH ROY AND DIPANKAR DATTA, JJ.] Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – ss.24, 25 – Constitution of India – Arts. 214, 231 – Suit – Transfer of – Appellant-plaintiff moved an application u/s. 24 of CPC before the Gauhati High Court (Common High Court for the states of Assam, Nagaland and two other states) for an order to transfer of a suit filed by appellant in the court of the District Judge, Dimapur, Nagaland to the court of the District Judge at Gauhati, Assam – High Court rejected the transfer application – In appeal before the Supreme Court, issue was: Is the Supreme Court the sole repository of power in terms of s. 25 of the CPC to direct transfer of a suit, appeal or other proceeding from a Civil Court in one State to a Civil Court in another State? Or, is it open for a High Court, if it is the common High Court for two or more States, to entertain an application for transfer u/s. 24 of the CPC and transfer a suit, appeal or other proceeding from a Civil Court to another Civil Court, both of which are subordinate to such High Court but situate in different States in relation to which it exercises jurisdiction, for consideration and decision – Held: A true and proper interpretation of s.25 of the CPC leads to conclusion that same applies to inter-State transfer of a suit, appeal or other proceeding where both States have a High Court in terms of Art.214 of the Constitution and not to a transfer where both States have a common High Court under Art. 231 – Power u/s. 24 of the CPC can be exercised by the High Court even for inter-State transfer of a suit, appeal or other proceeding, if it is the common High Court for two or more States under Art. 231 of the Constitution and both the Civil Courts (transferor and transferee) are subordinate to it – Judgment of High Court set aside – Gauhati High Court to now decide the application u/s. 24 of CPC afresh. Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 – ss.24, 25 – Interpretation of – Held: A narrow interpretation of s.25 imposing a bar for A B C D E F G H 986 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
entertainment of an application u/s. 24 for transfer of a suit, appeal or other proceeding by a common High Court like the Gauhati High Court inter-se the four States in relation to which it exercises jurisdiction could place a heavy burden and might pose an insurmountable obstacle for litigants of the far-flung areas of the North-East, if they were made to approach Supreme Court for such transfer on the specious ground that the Civil Court to which the same is proposed to be transferred is in a State other than the State in which the suit has been instituted.
Interpretation of Statutes – An interpretation of the law that seeks to address the mischief, that is consistent with the Constitution and promotes constitutional objectives and that which responds to the needs of the nation must be adopted.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD : 1. Section 24 of the CPC is a general power of ‘transfer and withdrawal’ capable of being invoked by the High Courts at any stage either suo motu without notice or on the application of any of the parties after notice, whereas section 25 confers exclusive power on the Supreme Court, on the application of either of the parties and after notice, to transfer suits, etc. from the Courts stated therein. While section 24 is part of the general law, section 25 is the special law. Law is well-settled, and referring to the decision in Amarendra Pratap Singh vs. Tej Bahadur Prajapati, that a general law cannot defeat the provisions of a special law to the extent to which they are in conflict; else, an effort has to be made at reconciling the two provisions by homogenous reading. What, therefore, needs to be seen and appreciated is whether there is any conflict or inconsistency between the general law (section 24) and the special law (section 25) for the former to yield to the latter, and ascertain whether the High Court still has the jurisdiction under the general law to order an inter-State transfer notwithstanding the special law vesting the Supreme Court with such power of transfer. There has to be an inconsistency between the two so as to apply the maxim generalia specialibus non derogant. The jurisdiction conferred on the Supreme Court pursuant to the amendment of section 25 of the CPC in 1976 though special, invocation of the jurisdiction of the High Court under section 24 may not come in conflict and A B C D E F G H defeat section 25, if jurisdiction is still found available to be exercised in a given case under the former without doing violence to the latter. [Para 37][1006-H; 1007-A, D-G]
2. A High Court ~ howsoever big or small, old or new ~ is as much a Constitutional Court as this Court is and enjoys wide ranging powers vested in it by law. No doubt, the power under section 25 is a special power, but the common High Courts of the country ought not to read section 24 of the CPC in a manner as if the power of the Supreme Court under section 25 to order an inter-State transfer is available to be exclusively exercised by it in all cases of inter-State transfer, thereby denuding the common High Courts of the country of their jurisdiction by mere reference to involvement of an inter-State transfer and without anything more being looked at. [Para 42][1009-G-H; 1010-A-B]
3. In opinion of this Court, an approach to construe section 25 of the CPC has to be fair, pragmatic, reasonable and realistic. Any construction of section 25 which would impede “access to justice”, considered to be a Fundamental Right, has to be eschewed. A narrow interpretation of section 25 imposing a bar for entertainment of an application under section 24 for transfer of a suit, appeal or other proceeding by a common High Court like the Gauhati High Court inter-se the four States in relation to which it exercises jurisdiction could place a heavy burden and might pose an insurmountable obstacle for litigants of the farflung areas of the North-East, if they were made to approach this Court for such transfer on the specious ground that the Civil Court to which the same is proposed to be transferred is in a State other than the State in which the suit has been instituted. An interpretation of the law that seeks to address the mischief, that is consistent with the Constitution and promotes constitutional objectives and that which responds to the needs of the nation must be adopted. If “access to justice” has to be real, it becomes the moral responsibility of the Supreme Court, the supreme guardians/protectors of the rights of people guaranteed by the Constitution and the laws, not to construe the substantive part in section 25 of the Code in a pedantic manner to bring about a situation that would thwart the initiative of making “access to justice” real. [Para 46][1012-C-F] SHAH NEWAZ KHAN v. STATE OF NAGALAND A B C D E F G H 988 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
4. In view of the aforesaid discussions, the issue is answered by concluding that:
(i) a true and proper interpretation of section 25 of the CPC lead to the conclusion that the same applies to inter-State transfer of a suit, appeal or other proceeding where both States have a High Court in terms of Article 214 of the Constitution and not to a transfer where both States have a common High Court under Article 231 thereof; and
(ii) the power under section 24 of the CPC can be exercised by the High Court even for inter-State transfer of a suit, appeal or other proceeding, if it is the common High Court for two or more States under Article 231 of the Constitution and both the Civil Courts (transferor and transferee) are subordinate to it. [Para 48][1013-A-D] Durgesh Sharma vs. Jayshree (2008) 9 SCC 648 :
[2008] 13 SCR 1056- distinguished.
D. Saibaba v Bar Council of India & Anr. (2003) 6 SCC 186 : [2003] 3 SCR 1209; Amarendra Pratap Singh vs. Tej Bahadur Prajapati (2004) 10 SCC 65 :
[2003] 6 Suppl. SCR 42 – referred to.
Pomi Sengupta vs. Biswajit Sengupta (2015) 6 GLR 396; Megha Jain vs. Kartik Jain (2019) 6 GLR 379;
Chalasani Deepthi vs. Chalasani Krishna Chaitanya 2015 SCC OnLine Hyd 978; Irene Blanch Khera vs.
Glenn John Vijay 2018 (6) Mh. L.J. 199 – referred to.
12th Edition of ‘Principles of Statutory Interpretation’ at page 131 (Para 6 (e))
Case Law Reference [2008] 13 SCR 1056 distinguished Para 4 [2003] 3 SCR 1209 referred to Para 6 (g)
[2003] 6 Suppl. SCR 42 referred to Para 37 CIVIL APPELLATE/ORIGINAL JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.1497 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 10.12.2015 of the High Court of Gauhati in TR No.68 of 2015.
A B C D E F G H With Transfer Petition (c) No.307 of 2016.
Parthiv K. Goswami, Sr. Adv., Ms. Ragini Pandey, Ms. Atiga Singh, Ms. Diksha Rai, Advs. for the Appellants.
K N Balgopal, Sr. Adv., Ms. K. Enatoli Sema, Ms. Limayinla Jamir, Amit Kumar Singh, Ms. Chubalemla Chang, Prang Newmai, Vivek Narayan Sharma, Ms. Mahima Bhardwaj, Ms. Laksha Bhavnani, Pranshu Kausha, Shubham Awasthi, Rajeev Kumar Jha, Ram Kumar, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
DIPANKAR DATTA, J.
1. Leave granted.
THE ISSUE
2. An issue, pristinely legal and novel, emerges for decision. It is novel in the sense that although three different High Courts of the country have taken views which are entirely consistent, except the view taken in the judgment and order under challenge of the Gauhati High Court which impliedly stands overruled by a larger Bench of the same High Court, this Court hitherto might not have had the occasion to deal with such an issue and decide either way.
3. Shortly put, the issue is:
Is the Supreme Court the sole repository of power in terms of section 25 of the Code of Civil Procedure (for brevity ‘the CPC’) to direct transfer of a suit, appeal or other proceeding from a Civil Court in one State to a Civil Court in another State? Or, is it open for a High Court, if it is the common High Court for two or more States, to entertain an application for transfer under section 24 of the CPC and transfer a suit, appeal or other proceeding from a Civil Court to another Civil Court, both of which are subordinate to such High Court but situate in different States in relation to which it exercises jurisdiction, for consideration and decision?
FACTS AND THE ORDER UNDER CHALLENGE
4. The facts leading to presentation of this appeal reveal that the appellants having instituted a suit for declaration of right, title and interest SHAH NEWAZ KHAN v. STATE OF NAGALAND A B C D E F G H 990 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
as well as for perpetual injunction and damages in the court of the District Judge at Dimapur, Nagaland sometime in 2007, failed to prosecute it in the right earnest allegedly due to hostile circumstances created by the private defendants in the suit resulting in dismissal and restoration thereof on three occasions. Pleading why it is impossible for them to continue with prosecution of the suit at Dimapur, the appellants moved an application under section 24 of the CPC before the Gauhati High Court for an order to transfer the suit to the court of the District Judge at Guwahati, Assam. A learned Judge of the Gauhati High Court, which presently happens to be the common High Court for the States of Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh, presiding over the Bench at the principal seat at Guwahati, rejected the application for transfer by a judgment and order dated 10th December, 2015. While so rejecting, the learned Judge followed His Lordship’s previous decision in Pomi Sengupta vs. Biswajit Sengupta1 which, in turn, had entirely relied on the decision of this Court in Durgesh Sharma vs. Jayshree2. The judgment and order of rejection of the application under section 24 of the CPC is under challenge in this appeal.
5. The appellants, by way of abundant caution, have also applied before this Court under section 25 of the CPC seeking the same relief that was disallowed by the learned Judge.
APPELLANTS’ CONTENTIONS
6. Appearing in support of the appeal, Mr. Goswami, learned senior counsel contended that:
a. Article 214 of the Constitution of India ordains that there shall be a High-Court for each State. Article 231 of the Constitution of India provides for the establishment of a common High Court for two or more States.
b. The relevant provisions of the CPC for the purpose of a decision on the present dispute are sections 22 to 25 read with section 3 thereof dealing with subordination of courts.
c. The power of the High Court and the District Courts to direct transfer of proceedings is provided in section 24 of the CPC. d. The facts of the instant case clearly satisfy all the ingredients of section 24 CPC, more particularly, sub-clause (ii) of clause (b) of sub-section (1) thereof. A bare perusal of such provision 24 would indicate
1 (2015) 6 GLR 396
2 (2008) 9 SCC 648
A B C D E F G H that the High Court may, at any stage, direct transfer of proceedings pending before it to any court subordinate to it, or transfer proceedings pending in any court subordinate to it to itself or to any other court subordinate to it. Thus, the emphasis under the said provision is on the expression “court subordinate to it”. Section 3 of the CPC, inter alia, defines the courts subordinate to the High Court. Thus, on a plain reading of section 24 of the CPC, it is evident that the common High Court, i.e., the Gauhati High Court, has the power and jurisdiction to direct inter- State transfer of proceedings, provided both the transferor and transferee courts are subordinate to it, and fall within its territorial jurisdiction, which is the case here.
e. On a harmonious construction of section 24 and section 25 of the CPC, it is clear that the latter will apply only to inter-State transfer of proceedings between two States where the two States in question have different High Courts, whereas, in a case involving inter-State transfer of proceedings within the territorial jurisdiction of a common High Court, the common High Court would have the power and jurisdiction to direct inter-State transfer of proceedings of the nature stated above, in exercise of its power under section 24 of the CPC.
f.It is a settled proposition of law that in construing a provision, the consequences that befall on a particular interpretation of a provision is a relevant consideration. Justice G.P. Singh in his treatise3 has observed thus:
4. REGARD TO CONSEQUENCES
If the language used is capable of hearing more than one construction, in selecting the true meaning, regard. Must be had to the consequences resulting from adopting the alternative constructions. A construction that results in hardship, serious inconvenience, injustice, absurdity, or anomaly or which leads to inconsistency or uncertainty and friction in the system which the statute purports to regulate has to be rejected and preference should be given to that construction which avoids such results.
g. This observation was quoted with approval by the Supreme Court in paragraph 17 of its decision in D. Saibaba v Bar Council of India & Anr.4.
3 12th Edition of ‘Principles of Statutory Interpretation’ at page 131
4 (2003) 6 SCC 186
SHAH NEWAZ KHAN v. STATE OF NAGALAND [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] A B C D E F G H 992 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
h. Therefore, the aforementioned observation would also lend support to the submission of the appellants in as much as it would be more convenient for litigants within the territory of the common High Court to approach the Gauhati High Court for seeking transfer.
7. Mr. Goswami also cited three other decisions. The first is a decision of the larger bench of the Gauhati High Court in Megha Jain vs. Kartik Jain5. This decision has overruled Pomi Sengupta (supra), on which the impugned judgment and order is premised. The second is a decision of the (undivided) Andhra Pradesh High Court in Chalasani Deepthi vs. Chalasani Krishna Chaitanya6 and the last a decision of the Bombay High Court in Irene Blanch Khera vs. Glenn John Vijay7.
8. Based on his aforesaid submissions, Mr. Goswami urged us to set aside the order under challenge and to remit the matter to the Gauhati High Court for fresh consideration of the application of the appellants under section 24 of the CPC. In the alternative, he submitted that the application under section 25 may be considered by us on its own merits.
CONTENTIONS OF THE RESPONDENTS 1 TO 3
9. Opposing the appeal, Mr. Balgopal, learned senior counsel for the State of Nagaland and its officers, contended as follows: a. A brief issue with regard to the scope and ambit of section 24 vis-à-vis section 25 of the CPC has arisen before this Court in the instant case in view of the peculiar circumstances wherein two States share a common High Court as provided under Article 231 of the Constitution of India.
b. Section 24(1)(b), CPC gives power to the High Court to withdraw any suit, appeal or other proceeding pending in any court subordinate to it and to transfer the same for trial or disposal to any Court subordinate to it which is competent to try or dispose of the same. As the State of Nagaland does not have a separate High Court, consequently all courts functioning in the State of Nagaland are subordinate to the Gauhati High Court, being the common High Court for the States of Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh. c. However, in order to appreciate whether the common High Court has the power to withdraw any suit, appeal or other proceeding
5 (2019) 6 GLR 379
6 2015 SCC OnLine Hyd 978 7 2018 (6) Mh. L.J. 199 A B C D E F G H pending before any Court subordinate to it from one State and to transfer the same to any Court subordinate to it, in another State, the provisions of both sections 24 and 25 of the Code will have to be examined as it involves an inter-State transfer and not an intra-State transfer simplicitor. d. To appreciate the true import and meaning of the provisions of section 25(1), the said provision will have to be read in two parts as it contains two-fold power to direct any suit, appeal or other proceeding to be transferred:
i. From one High Court to another High Court; or ii. From one Civil Court in one State to another Civil Court in any other State.
This interpretation is substantiated by the observation made by this Court in Durgesh Sharma (supra).
e. Section 25 is the only provision in the CPC, which refers to transfer of a case from a Civil Court in one State to a Civil Court in another State. Incidentally, the appellants themselves are asking for this relief.
f. Report of the Joint Committee, Lok Sabha of the Code of Civil Procedure (Amendment) Bill 1974 which was passed on 1st April, 1976 shows that this issue was raised by one of the North-Eastern States, i.e., State of Meghalaya with regard to conflict between sections 24 and 25 insofar as the North-East area is concerned and reading of the minutes suggests that the Committee assured to look into the issue. g. In view of the specific provision in section 25(1) of the CPC, it is only the Supreme Court and no other court which has the power to direct transfer of the suit instituted by the appellants from the Civil Court in Dimapur, Nagaland to the Civil Court in Guwahati, Assam, if at all any ground is set up therefor.
10. In view of the aforesaid contentions, it was submitted by Mr. Balgopal that the impugned judgement needs no interference and deserves to be upheld.
ARGUMENTS OF THE RESPONDENTS 4 AND 5
11. Mr. Sharma, learned counsel appearing for the respondents 4 and 5, advanced the following arguments:
SHAH NEWAZ KHAN v. STATE OF NAGALAND [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] A B C D E F G H 994 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
a. Power to effect inter-State transfer of any suit, appeal or other proceeding is not available to be exercised by a High Court in terms of section 24 of the CPC since such power is expressly and exclusively provided in section 25 thereof, to be exercised only by the Supreme Court.
b. Reliance placed by the learned senior counsel for the appellants on Durgesh Sharma (supra) is misplaced since that case is distinguishable. The observations in paragraph 47 were made by this Court to decide the issue captured in paragraph 3 and this Court had no occasion to examine the issue in the light as it has occurred in the present case. It is trite to submit that such an observation could at best be treated as obiter dicta (defined as an incidental remark of a Judge’s expression of opinion uttered in court or in a written judgment, but not essential to the decision and therefore not legally binding as a precedent). c. Be that as it may, what has been held by this Court in paragraph 57 of Durgesh Sharma (supra) nullifies the point sought to be urged on the behalf of the appellants.
d. In Megha Jain (supra), the Division Bench of the Gauhati High Court has held that it has jurisdiction to exercise powers under section 24 of the CPC read with section 23(1) and/or section 23(2) thereof to transfer a suit, appeal or any other proceeding from one of the four States under its jurisdiction to any other State under its jurisdiction for trial. In paragraph 9 of Megha Jain (supra), reference has been made to section 24 (1) (a) of the CPC to arrive at the conclusion that the High Court or the District Court may, at any stage, transfer any suit etc. pending before it to any court subordinate to it and that a transfer petition seeking transfer from one State to any of the four States shall be maintainable thereunder. The abovesaid conclusion is not the correct exposition of law. Sections 22 to 24 of the CPC and section 25 thereof are two different codes within the CPC and there is no overlapping in relation to the domain where these two sets of codes operate. e. A plain reading of section 22 of the CPC would show that the words “several Courts” occurring in its last has been continued in section 23, while no such co-relation exists either between sections 22 and 25 or sections 23 and 25. Therefore, application of section 23 together with section 25 appears completely faulty. Also, in relation to the exercise of power under section 24, the said power has been made available to even A B C D E F G H a District Court, which makes it amply clear that the power under section 24 is a continuation of sections 22 and 23 only.
f. Further, the power of transfer of suits under section 22 can be exercised, “(W)here a suit may be instituted in any one of two or more courts and is instituted in one of such courts”. And this power under section 22 is explained in section 23 for the purposes as to which court an application for transfer may lie. Further, after the application is made, under section 24, such power is explained as to how the same can be exercised. Therefore, section 22 provides which of the suits, section 23 provides which of the courts and section 24 provides how such transfers can be effected.
g. In contrast to the above, the power under section 25 has been clearly defined and the same does not have any mention in sections 22 to 24 in the same manner as it occurs in section 25, categoric and precise. Therefore, the legislative intent is clear that only under section 25 of the CPC a direction that any suit, appeal or other proceeding may be transferred from a Civil Court in one State to a Civil Court in any other State and that can only be made by this Court.
12. Resting on the aforesaid arguments, Mr. Sharma too urged that no case for interference had been made out by the appellants and the appeal deserves dismissal.
THE RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF LAW
13. Sections 24 and 25 of the CPC being at the heart of the debate, the same need to read carefully. To the extent relevant, the said provisions read as follows:
“24. General power of transfer and withdrawal.— (1) On the application of any of the parties and after notice to the parties and after hearing such of them as desire to be heard, or of its own motion, without such notice, the High Court or the District Court may, at any stage—
(a) transfer any suit, appeal or other proceeding pending before it for trial or disposal to any court subordinate to it and competent to try or dispose of the same, or
(b) withdraw any suit, appeal or other proceeding pending in any court subordinate to it, and SHAH NEWAZ KHAN v. STATE OF NAGALAND [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] A B C D E F G H 996 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
(i) try or dispose of the same; or
(ii) transfer the same for trial or disposal to any court subordinate to it and competent to try or dispose of the same; or
(iii) retransfer the same for trial or disposal to the court from which it was withdrawn.
(2) Where any suit or proceeding has been transferred or withdrawn under sub-section (1), the court which thereafter tries such suit may, subject to any special directions in the case of an order of transfer, either retry it or proceed from the point at which it was transferred or withdrawn.
***”
“25. Power of Supreme Court to transfer suits, etc.—
(1) On the application of a party, and after notice to the parties, and after hearing such of them as desire to be heard, the Supreme Court may, at any stage, if satisfied that an order under this section is expedient for the ends of justice, direct that any suit, appeal or other proceeding be transferred from a High Court or other Civil Court in one State to a High Court or other Civil Court in any other State.
***”
14. Prior to its amendment in 1976, section 25 of the Code read as follows:
“25. Power of State Government to transfer suits.—(1) Where any party to a suit, appeal or other proceeding pending in a High Court presided over by a Single Judge objects to its being heard by him and the Judge is satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for the objection, he shall make a report to the State Government, which may, by notification in the Official Gazette, transfer such suit, appeal or proceeding to any other High Court.
Provided that no suit, appeal or proceeding shall be transferred to a High Court without the consent of the State Government of the State in which that High Court has its principal seat.”
15. Since acceptance of the arguments of Mr. Balgopal and Mr. Sharma would result in denuding a common High Court of the jurisdiction A B C D E F G H to even entertain an application under section 24 of the CPC for transfer of a suit from a Civil Court in one State to a Civil Court of another State, notwithstanding that exercise of jurisdiction by such High Court extends to both such States, it is absolutely necessary to consider Chapter V of the Constitution of India titled “(T)he High Courts in the States” and more particularly the terms of Articles 214, 231, 227, 235 and 228 which, to our mind, are of utmost relevance for deciding the legal issue. At the same time, having regard to the terms of pre-amended section 25 of the CPC, a peep into the pages of history as to how the Gauhati High Court became the common High Court for the State of Assam and the other States seems to be imperative.
16. Article 214 is clear that there shall be a High Court for each State. Article 231, inserted in the Constitution by the Constitution (Seventh Amendment) Act, 1956, is an ordainment that notwithstanding anything contained in the preceding provisions of Chapter V, Parliament may by law establish a common High Court for two or more States or for two or more States and a Union territory. Article 227 is the recognition of the power of superintendence of every High Court over all courts and tribunals throughout the territories in relation to which it exercises jurisdiction. The control over all District Courts and courts subordinate thereto, in terms of Article 235, vests in the High Court. One other important provision is Article 228. Article 228 empowers the High Court, subject to its satisfaction that a case pending in a court subordinate to it involves a substantial question of law as to the interpretation of the Constitution and the determination of which is necessary for the disposal of the case, to withdraw the case and (a) either dispose of the case itself, or (b) determine the said question of law and return the case to the court from which the case has been so withdrawn together with a copy of its judgment on such question, whereupon the said court shall proceed to dispose of the case in conformity with such judgment.
ORIGIN AND EVOLUTION OF THE COMMON HIGH
COURT
17. We now move on to note the origin and evolution of the common High Court, i.e., the Gauhati High Court and the trajectory that it has been ordained to follow in relation to the territories over which it exercises jurisdiction.
18. The precursor of the Gauhati High Court was the High Court of Assam, which was established on 5th April, 1948 in terms of the Assam SHAH NEWAZ KHAN v. STATE OF NAGALAND [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] A B C D E F G H 998 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
High Court Order, 1948 (for brevity ‘the 1948 Order’) made by the Governor General in exercise of power conferred by section 229 of the Government of India Act, 1935 and as adopted by the India Provincial Constitution (Amendment) Order, 1948. In terms of paragraph 4 thereof, the High Court of Assam was conferred, in respect of the territories for the time being included in the province of Assam, all such original, appellate and other jurisdiction as, under the law in force immediately before the prescribed day, was exercisable in respect of the said territories or any part thereof, by the High Court in Calcutta or by the Governor of Assam exercising the functions of a high court.
19. In 1962, by an Act of Parliament titled the State of Nagaland Act, 1962 (for brevity ‘the 1962 Act’), the State of Nagaland was formed. While sub-section (1) of section 13 of the 1962 Act ordained that there shall be a common high court called the High Court of Assam and Nagaland, sub-section (3) thereof provided that expenditure in respect of the salaries and allowances of the Judges of the common High Court shall be allocated between the States of Assam and Nagaland in such proportion as the President may by order determine.
20. The 1962 Act was followed by the North-Eastern Areas (Reorganisation) Act, 1971 (for brevity ‘the 1971 Act’). This enactment contained provisions for the establishment of the States of Manipur and Tripura and for the formation of the State of Meghalaya, and the Union territories of Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh, by reorganizing the existing State of Assam. Part IV of the 1971 Act titled “High Court” contained sections 28 to 43. Sections 28 and 29, being relevant are quoted below: “28. Common High Court for Assam, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur and Tripura.— (1) On and from the appointed day,—
(a) the High Court of Assam and Nagaland shall cease to function and is hereby abolished;
(b) there shall be a common High Court for the States of Assam, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur and Tripura to be called the Gauhati High Court (the High Court of Assam, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur and Tripura);
(c) the Judges of the High Court of Assam and Nagaland holding office immediately before that day shall, unless they have elected otherwise, become on that day the Judges of the common High Court:
A B C D E F G H
(2) Nothing in clause (a) of sub-section (1) shall prejudice or affect the continued operation of any notice served, injunction issued, direction given or proceedings taken before the appointed day by the High Court of Assam and Nagaland under the powers then conferred upon that Court.”
“29. Jurisdiction of the common High Court.—On and from the appointed day, the common High Court shall have, in respect of the territories comprised in the States of Assam, Manipur, Meghalaya, Nagaland and Tripura, all such jurisdiction, powers and authority as under the law in force immediately before the appointed day, are exercisable in respect of those territories by the High Court of Assam and Nagaland or the Court of the Judicial Commissioner for Manipur, or the Court of the Judicial Commissioner for Tripura, as the case may be.”
21. With the enactment of the State of Arunachal Pradesh Act, 1986 and the State of Mizoram Act, 1986, two new States were born. Section 18 of the former and section 15 of the latter legislation, more or less commonly worded, when read together would evince that a common High Court for the States of Assam, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur, Tripura, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh to be called the Gauhati High Court (the High Court of Assam, Nagaland, Meghalaya, Manipur, Tripura, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh) came into existence. The common thread that runs through the developments of 1962, 1971 and 1986, noted above, is that as and when the jurisdiction of the High Court of Assam and thereafter the Gauhati High Court came to be enlarged and extended to States other than Assam, all seven sister States in the North- Eastern part of the country agreed to bear the expenditure in respect of the salaries and allowances of the Judges of the common High Court as shall be allocated amongst the States in such proportion by an order of the President.
22. In view of the provisions of the 1971 Act, till little over a decade back, the Gauhati High Court was the common High Court for the seven sister states. The jurisdiction of the said High Court extended throughout the territories of Assam, Nagaland, Tripura, Manipur, Meghalaya, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh.
23. However, the 1971 Act came to be amended by the North- Eastern Areas (Re-organisation) and Other Related Laws (Amendment) SHAH NEWAZ KHAN v. STATE OF NAGALAND [DIPANKAR DATTA, J.] A B C D E F G H 1000 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 3 S.C.R.
Act, 2012 (for brevity ‘the Amendment Act’). It established separate High Courts for the States of Meghalaya, Manipur and Tripura. Accordingly, the definition of “common High Court” in section 2(d) of the 1971 Act was amended. Apart from insertion of sections 28A to 28K between sections 28 and 29, the Amendment Act, inter alia, also introduced a proviso in sub-section (1) of section 28, reading as follows: “Provided that on and from the commencement of the North- Eastern Areas (Reorganisation) and Other Related Laws (Amendment) Act, 2012, the common High Court shall be the High Court for the States of Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, Mizoram and Nagaland and shall cease to have its jurisdiction, powers and authority for the States of Meghalaya, Manipur and Tripura.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.