Office of the Odisha Lokayukta v. Dr. Pradeep Kumar Panigrahi and Others
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 154; [2023] 2 S.C.R. 560
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Ajay Rastogi, Justice Bela M. Trivedi Odisha Lokayukta Act, Justice 2014 – S.20(1), Justice 28 – Order Passed By the Appellant, Justice In Exercise of Power Conferred U/S.20(1), Justice Is in Violation of the Principles of Natural Justice – Even On Merits, Justice High Court Completely Overlooked S.20(1) That Empowers the Lokayukta, Justice On Receipt of A Complaint
- Decided
- 23 Feb 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1384/2023
- Sections
- 20(1), 25, 28, 20(2), 20(8), 20(3), 2, 14, 16, 46, 32, 173
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 560 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.[2023] 2 S.C.R. 560
OFFICE OF THE ODISHA LOKAYUKTA
v.
DR. PRADEEP KUMAR PANIGRAHI AND OTHERS
(Civil Appeal No(s).1384-85 of 2023)
FEBRUARY 23, 2023
[AJAY RASTOGI AND BELA M. TRIVEDI, JJ.] Odisha Lokayukta Act, 2014 – s.20(1), 25, 28 – Order passed by the appellant, in exercise of power conferred u/s.20(1), directing to conduct preliminary inquiry against respondent no.1 – Set aside by High Court –Held: High Court passed the impugned order setting aside the order of the appellantwithout affording it an opportunity of hearing and thus, is in violation of the principles of natural justice – Even on merits, High Court completely overlooked s.20(1) that empowers the Lokayukta, on receipt of a complaint, in its discretion if intended to proceed and to hold any inquiry, can conduct preliminary inquiry against a public servant by its wing or any other agency – So far as the term ‘any agency’ is concerned, it clearly manifests from s.25 which entrusts the power of superintendence to the Lokayukta to exercise in such a manner so as to require any agency, including the State Vigilance and Crime Branch – Also, u/ s.28 for the purpose of conducting any preliminary inquiry or investigation, it is open for the Lokayukta to utilize the services of any officer or organization or investigation agency of the Government – Thus, in the present case, if the appellant conducted a preliminary inquiry through an agency of the Government of which reference has been made u/s.28 through the Directorate of Vigilance, Cuttack, there is no legal infirmity committed by the appellant – Decision-making process in conducting the preliminary inquiry was within the scope and ambit of s.20(1)–Judgment of High Court and the review order are set aside.
Administrative Law– Rule against Bias – Held: Rule against bias ensures a fair procedure by excluding decision makers who are tainted by bias – Under the rule, actual bias is disqualifying even though it is prohibitively difficult to establish – Justice must not only be done but must also appear to be done – In the present case, the Officer who submitted the complaint was simply an A B C D E F G H informant and not the person interested, at the same time, preliminary enquiry was conducted by a different officer not connected with author of the complaint – Thus, the plea of bias is ill-founded – Odisha Lokayukta Act, 2014.
Allowing the appeals, the Court HELD: 1.1 The aim to the rule of natural justice is to secure justice or to put it negatively, these rules can operate only in areas not covered by any law validly made. Before any action could have been taken by the Directorate of Vigilance in conducting a preliminary enquiry, a writ petition was filed by respondent no.1 before the High Court and on the first motion stage, the High Court, without affording an opportunity of hearing to the appellant, set aside the order dated 11th December, 2020 passed by the appellant for conducting a preliminary inquiry. The Division Bench of the High Court has committed a manifest error in passing of the order impugned while setting aside the order of the appellant dated 11th December, 2020 to conduct a preliminary inquiry against respondent no.1 in exercise of powers under Section 20(1) of the Act, 2014 which is in violation of the principles of natural justice. [Paras 25, 26, 27][572-F-H; 573-B-C] 1.2 Even on merits, the Division Bench has completely overlooked Section 20(1) of the Act, 2014 that empowers the Lokayukta, on receipt of a complaint, obviously after recording satisfaction, in its discretion if intended to proceed and to hold any inquiry, can conduct either a preliminary inquiry against a public servant by its inquiry wing or any other agency to ascertain whether there exists a prima facie case for proceeding in the matter or hold investigation by any agency or authority empowered under any law to investigate whether there exists a prima facie case. So far as the term ‘any agency’ is concerned, it clearly manifests from Section 25 of Chapter VIII which entrusts the power of superintendence to the Lokayukta to exercise in such a manner so as to require any agency, including the State Vigilance and Crime Branch. [Paras 28, 29][573-D-E] 1.3 At the same time, under Section 28, for the purpose of conducting any preliminary inquiry or investigation, it is open for OFFICE OF THE ODISHA LOKAYUKTA v. DR. PRADEEP
KUMAR PANIGRAHI
A B C D E F G H 562 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
the Lokayukta to utilize the services of any officer or organization or investigation agency of the Government and, in the circumstances, if the appellant in its judicious discretion and on the facts and circumstances of the case, conduct a preliminary inquiry through an agency of the Government of which reference has been made under Section 28 through the Directorate of Vigilance, Cuttack, there appears no legal infirmity being committed by the appellant in the decision-making process in conducting a preliminary inquiry whichwas within the scope and ambit of Section 20(1) of the Act, 2014 and a manifest error was committed by the Division Bench of the High Court while setting aside the order of the appellant dated 11th December, 2020 to conduct an inquiry against respondent no.1. [Para 30][573-F-H; 574-A] 1.4 Although this Court may not appreciate the action of the appellant in taking further steps when there was stay of the order impugned passed by this Court, but at the same time, an opportunity was granted to the respondents as well to justify if the action taken by the appellant is not in conformity with the mandate of the Act, 2014, but from the written submissions placed before this Court, no valid objection was found to have been raised by the respondents which may call upon this Court to interfere in furtherance of the action being taken by the appellant after the preliminary inquiry report was submitted pursuant to order dated 11th December, 2020.[Para 33][574-D-F] 1.5 The rule against bias is an essential component of modern administrative law. The rule against bias ensures a fair procedure by excluding decision-makers who are tainted by bias. Under the rule, actual bias is disqualifying even though it is prohibitively difficult to establish. The basic principle underlying the time-tested rule is that justice must not only be done but must also appears to be done. In the instant case, the complaint was made by the Deputy Superintendent of Police of the Directorate of Vigilance, who is, directly or indirectly, not concerned with the complaint, he can be said to be an informant to the office of the appellant and that apart, a preliminary inquiry was conducted independently by a senior officer of the Directorate of Vigilance, Additional Superintendent of Police who submitted A B C D E F G H his report of the preliminary inquiry. The question of bias in the instant facts and circumstances does not arise at all. Further, if the order of the appellant directing the Directorate of Vigilance to conduct the preliminary inquiry in exercise of power under Section 20(1) of the Act, 2014 has been set aside by the High Court, obviously,the appellant is a person aggrieved and can certainly question the legality/validity of the judgment of the High Court impugned by invoking jurisdiction of this Court under Article 136 of the Constitution.The judgment of the High Court and the review order are set aside.[Paras 35, 37, 42 and 43][575- C; 578-D-F; 581-B-D] Ashok Kumar Yadav and others vs. State of Haryana and others 1985 (4) SCC 417 : [1985] 1 Suppl. SCR 657; Mukesh Singh vs. State (Narcotic Branch of Delhi)
2020 (10) SCC 120 : [2020] 9 SCR 245– followed.
National Commission for Women vs. State of Delhi and another 2010 (12) SCC 599 : [2010] 10 SCR 905; M.S.
Kazi vs. Muslim Education Society and others 2016 (9)
SCC 263 : [2016] 4 SCR 80 – held inapplicable.
A.K. Kraipak and others vs. Union of India and others 1969 (2) SCC 262 : [1970] 1 SCR 457 – relied on.
Case Law Reference [1970] 1 SCR 457 relied on Para 35 [1985] 1 Suppl. SCR 657 followed Para 36 [2020] 9 SCR 245 followed Para 37 [2010] 10 SCR 905 held inapplicable Para 38 [2016] 4 SCR 80 held inapplicable Para 38 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal Nos.1384- 1385 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 03.02.2021 of the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in WP (C) No.3488 of 2021 and dated 05.04.2021 in RVWPET No.45 of 2021.
Ravindra Shrivastav, Sr. Adv., Arjun Garg, Aakash Nandolia, Ms. Sagun Srivastava, Ms. Sanya Shukla, Devangna Singh, Advs. for the Appellant.
OFFICE OF THE ODISHA LOKAYUKTA v. DR. PRADEEP
KUMAR PANIGRAHI
A B C D E F G H 564 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
Pitamber Acharya, Sr. Adv., Apoorve Karol, Lakshay Sharma, Mithu Jain, Shibashish Misra, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
RASTOGI, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. The instant appeals are directed against the judgment dated 3rd February, 2021 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack setting aside Order dated 11th December, 2020 passed by the Odisha Lokayukta initiating to conduct a preliminary inquiry in exercise of power conferred under Section 20(1) of the Odisha Lokayukta Act, 2014 (hereinafter being referred to as the “Act 2014”) on a complaint dated 9th December, 2020 received from Mr. Ranjan Kumar Das, Deputy Superintendent of Police, Vigilance Cell Unit, Bhubaneswar indicating the alleged corruption against respondent no. 1 who is the elected Member of the Legislative Assembly of Gopalpur Constituency directing the Directorate of Vigilance, Cuttack to conduct a preliminary inquiry and submit a report to the Lokayukta.
3. The review petition filed at the instance of the appellant on the premise that Odisha Lokayukta was never heard and no opportunity of hearing has been afforded before passing of the impugned Order dated 3rd February, 2021 and it was in violation of the principles of natural justice, came to be dismissed by passing a non-speaking Order dated 5th April, 2021.
4. Respondent no. 1 is an elected Member of the Legislative Assembly. Mr. Ranjan Kumar Das, the then Deputy Superintendent of Police, Vigilance Cell Unit, Bhubaneswar, made a complaint dated 9th December, 2020 indicating serious allegations of alleged corruption against Member of the Odisha Legislative Assembly of Gopalpur Constituency. Along with the complaint, supporting documents were also annexed. The Odisha Lokayukta, after taking into consideration the contents of the complaint and the supporting documents annexed thereto, in exercise of power conferred under Section 20(1) of the Act, 2014 directed the Directorate of Vigilance, Odisha, Cuttack to conduct a preliminary inquiry against respondent no. 1 and submit a report within two months with a further direction that the Directorate of Vigilance must ensure that during preliminary inquiry, the mandate of Section 20(2) has to be complied A B C D E F G H with and further directed the Office of Lokayukta to make available all the relevant record to the Directorate of Vigilance for compliance.
5. Immediately on a reference made by the Odisha Lokayukta by its Order dated 11th December, 2020 directing the Directorate of Vigilance to conduct a preliminary inquiry against respondent no. 1 and calling upon the report, came to be challenged by respondent no. 1 by filing writ petition before the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution. Although the Office of Lokayukta was impleaded as one of respondent before the High Court but as informed to this Court, no notice was issued to them and on the first date of hearing, without even affording opportunity of hearing to the appellant to submit their written response, the Division Bench of the High Court under Order dated 3rd February, 2021 proceeded on the premise that entrusting Directorate of Vigilance to conduct preliminary inquiry is not in terms of the mandate of Section 20(1) and set aside the Order dated 11th December, 2020 with a liberty to the Lokayukta to conduct preliminary inquiry, if so advised, against respondent no. 1 by the inquiry wing of the Lokayukta with a further liberty to proceed in conformity with the requirements of Sections 20(2) and 20(3) after the preliminary report being furnished by the inquiry wing of the Lokayukta.
6. A review filed by the Lokayukta against the Order impugned dated 3rd February, 2021 came to be dismissed by a non-speaking order dated 5th April, 2021 which is a subject matter of challenge in the appeals before us.
7. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the order impugned dated 3rd February, 2021 is in violation of the principles of nature justice and the finding has been recorded without affording an opportunity of hearing to the appellant and that apart, it is not in conformity with the mandate of Section 20(1) of the Act 2014.
8. Learned counsel further submits that Section 20(1) provides an option to the Lokayukta, who, on receipt of a complaint, if order to hold a preliminary inquiry against any public servant, may conduct either by its enquiry wing or by any agency to ascertain as to whether there exists any prima facie case for proceeding in the matter any further. If the relevant provisions of the Act are being looked into, particularly Chapter VIII of the Act 2014, any agency as referred to under Section 25 includes the State Vigilance and Crime Branch for the purpose of conducting OFFICE OF THE ODISHA LOKAYUKTA v. DR. PRADEEP KUMAR PANIGRAHI [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 566 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
preliminary inquiry or investigation, as the case may be, and that is further strengthened by the procedure for conducting a preliminary inquiry or investigation envisaged under Section 28 wherein it is open for the Lokayukta to conduct preliminary inquiry or investigation through the agency of the Government. In the given facts and circumstances, the finding which has been recorded by the Division Bench of the High Court that entrusting to conduct preliminary inquiry by the Directorate of Vigilance under Order dated 11th December, 2020 is not in conformity with the Act 2014, needs to be interfered with by this Court.
9. Learned counsel further submits that calling upon the inquiry wing or any agency to conduct a preliminary inquiry is only for a limited purpose to ascertain whether there exists prima facie case to proceed in the matter. The Legislature was conscious of the fact that if it may cause any prejudice to the incumbent against whom the prima facie case has been registered and before any further action is being taken or to make any recommendation to proceed either to conduct investigation or initiate a departmental inquiry, it is incumbent upon the Lokayukta to afford an opportunity of hearing to the public servant as referred to under Sections 20(2) and 20(3) of the Act, 2014. A complete inbuilt procedure has been prescribed under Chapter VII for conducting preliminary inquiry and investigation within the powers of the Lokayukta. Chapter VIII prescribes not only the purpose of conducting preliminary inquiry and investigation but also in reaching to a final conclusion even at the stage of registering of the charge-sheet as referred to under Section 20(8) of the Act, 2014.
10. Learned counsel further submits that no adverse or prejudicial action was taken by the appellant in initiating to conduct a preliminary inquiry under its Order dated 11th December 2020, thus the interference made by the High Court, at this stage, in exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India was neither valid nor justified.
11. Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents, on the other hand, submits that a complaint was made by the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Vigilance Cell, Bhubaneshwar dated 9th December, 2020, who was the Officer of Directorate of Vigilance, Cuttack, Odisha, Cuttack and direction was given to the Directorate of Vigilance, Odisha to conduct a preliminary inquiry by Order dated 11th December, 2020, the decision itself was in violation of the principles of natural justice. Once the complaint was made by the officer of the Directorate of Vigilance, at A B C D E F G H least entrusting the preliminary inquiry to be conducted by another Officer of the Directorate of Vigilance, may be senior in the ladder, was not legally justified. The Officer of the Department has made a complaint on 9th December, 2020 and other officer is called upon to conduct a preliminary inquiry as stated that one cannot be a judge in its own cause and that being the reason, the Division Bench of the High Court has permitted the Lokayukta to conduct an inquiry by the inquiry wing of the Lokayukta and administrative bias can’t be ruled out of the Directorate of Vigilance who is to conduct a preliminary inquiry.
12. Learned counsel further submits that since the respondents were duly represented and the Advocate General of the State appeared along with the State counsel, opportunity of hearing was afforded to the appellant and plea of the principles of natural justice as prayed for by the appellant being violated, in the facts and circumstances, does not hold good. That apart, review petition came to be rightly dismissed as the appellant failed to justify any manifest error being committed by the Division Bench of the High Court under its Order dated 3rd February, 2021 which may call for our interference.
13. It may be noticed that while issuing notice by this Court on 23rd April, 2021, operation of the impugned order was stayed. In furtherance of the stay granted by this Court, it is informed that the appellant has proceeded further and after the preliminary inquiry report being submitted to the Lokayukta by the Officer Shri P.K. Naik on 28th May, 2021 and after affording opportunity of hearing to the appellant, a detailed Order was passed by the Lokayukta under Section 20(3)(a) dated 27th September, 2021 directing the Directorate of Vigilance to carry out investigation. In furtherance thereof, Directorate of Vigilance submitted a detailed report of investigation to the Lokayukta on 7th June, 2022, however, no further action has been initiated and awaiting orders of this Court which is indicated in the order dated 24th June, 2022 placed on record along with IA No. 89629 of 2022.
14. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and with their assistance perused the material available on record.
15. Before we proceed to examine the question raised in the instant appeals, it may be apposite to first take a bird’s eye view of the Scheme of the Act, 2014.
OFFICE OF THE ODISHA LOKAYUKTA v. DR. PRADEEP KUMAR PANIGRAHI [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 568 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
16. The Act, 2014 has been enacted by the legislature of the State of Odisha having been assented to by the President on the 16th January, 2015 with an object to provide for the establishment of the body of Lokayukta for the State of Odisha to inquire into allegations of corruption against public functionaries and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto. The Act is applicable to the public servants of the State of Odisha serving in and outside the State and the public servants under the control of Government of Odisha.
17. A ‘complaint’ has been defined under Section 2(d), and the term ‘preliminary inquiry’ and ‘public servant’ under Sections 2(l) and 2(n) of the Act 2014 which are stated as follows:- “2. (1) In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,— ……
(d) “complaint” means a complaint, made in such form as may be prescribed, alleging that a public servant has committed an offence punishable under the Prevention of Corruption Act,1988;
……
(l) “preliminary inquiry” means an inquiry conducted under this Act;
……
(n) “public servant” means a person referred to in clauses (a) to
(h) of sub-section (1) of section 14 but does not include a public servant in respect of whom the jurisdiction is exercisable by any court or other authority under the Army Act, 1950, the Air Force Act, 1950, the Navy Act, 1957 and the Coast Guard Act, 1978 or the procedure is applicable to such public servant under those Acts;
…….”.
18. Chapter VII prescribes the procedure in respect of preliminary inquiry and investigation, the relevant part of which is reproduced as under:- “20. (1) The Lokayukta, on receipt of a complaint, if it decides to proceed further, may order— A B C D E F G H
(a) preliminary inquiry against any public servant by its Inquiry Wing or any agency to ascertain whether there exists a prima facie case for proceeding in the matter; or
(b) investigation by any agency or authority empowered under any law to investigate, where there exists a prima facie case: Provided that any investigation under this clause shall be ordered only if in the opinion of the Lokayukta there is substantial material relating to the existence of a prima facie case or any earlier statutory investigation or enquiry regarding the same complaint reveals that a prima facie case exists:
Provided further that before ordering an investigation under this clause, the Lokayukta shall call for the explanation of the public servant and views of the competent authority, so as to determine whether there exists a prima facie case for investigation: Provided also that a decision to order investigation under this clause shall be taken by a bench constituted by the Chairperson under section 16.
(2) During the preliminary inquiry referred to in sub-section (1), the Inquiry Wing or any agency shall conduct a preliminary inquiry and on the basis of material, information and documents collected, seek the comments on the allegations made in the complaint from the public servant and competent authority and after obtaining the comments of the concerned public servant and competent authority, submit, within sixty days from the date of receipt of the reference, a report to the Lokayukta.
(3) A bench consisting of not less than three Members of the Lokayukta shall consider every report received under sub-section
(2) from the Inquiry Wing or any agency and after giving an opportunity of being heard to the public servant, decide as to whether there exists a prima facie case, and make recommendations to proceed with one or more of the following actions, namely:
(a) investigation by any agency (including any special investigation agency);
OFFICE OF THE ODISHA LOKAYUKTA v. DR. PRADEEP KUMAR PANIGRAHI [AJAY RASTOGI, J.] A B C D E F G H 570 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
(b) initiation of the departmental proceedings or any other appropriate action against the concerned public servant by the competent authority;
(c) closure of the proceedings against the public servant and take action to proceed against the complainant under section 46.
(4) The promotion and other service benefits of a public servant mentioned in clauses (e) to (h) of sub-section (1) of section 14 shall not be affected until the public servant is put under suspension on recommendation of the Lokayukta under section 32 or charge sheet is filed after completion of investigation under clause (a) of sub-section (3) or a charge memo is issued against the said public servant in a disciplinary proceeding initiated on the recommendation of the Lokayukta under clause (b) of sub-section (3).
(5) Every preliminary inquiry referred to in sub-section (1) shall ordinarily be completed within a period of ninety days and for reasons to be recorded in writing, within a further period of ninety days from the date of receipt of the complaint.
(6) In case the Lokayukta decides to proceed to investigate into the complaint, it shall, by order in writing, direct any investigating agency (including any special agency) to carry out the investigation as expeditiously as possible and complete the investigation within a period of six months from the date of its order:
Provided that the Lokayukta, for the reasons to be recorded in writing, may extend the said period by a further period not exceeding six months at a time and for the maximum period of two years.
(7) Notwithstanding anything contained in section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, any investigating agency (including any special agency) shall, in respect of cases referred to it by the Lokayukta, submit the investigation report to the Lokayukta.
(8) A bench consisting of not less than three Members of the Lokayukta shall consider every report received by it under sub-section (7) from any investigating agency (including any special agency) and may, decide as to—
(a) filing of charge-sheet or closure report before the Special Court against the public servant;
A B C D E F G H
(b) initiating the departmental proceedings or any other appropriate action against the concerned public servant by the competent authority.
(9) The Lokayukta may, after taking a decision under sub-section
(8) on the filing of the charge sheet, direct its Prosecution Wing to initiate prosecution in a Special Court in respect of cases investigated by any investigating agency (including any special agency).
…..”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.