Ramesh Chandra Sharma & Ors. v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 144; [2023] 2 S.C.R. 422
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Krishna Murari, Justice S. Ravindra Bhat Land Acquisition Act
- Decided
- 20 Feb 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 8819/2022
- Sections
- 23, 3, 6(1), 17, 6, 18, 12, 26, 377, 65(2), 4
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:26 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 422 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.[2023] 2 S.C.R. 422
RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA & ORS.
v.
STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH & ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 8819 of 2022)
FEBRUARY 20, 2023
[KRISHNA MURARI AND S. RAVINDRA BHAT, JJ.] Land Acquisition Act, 1894– U.P. Land Acquisition (determination of compensation and declaration of award by agreement) Rules, 1997 – Payment of compensation – Classification of landholders as Pushtaini or Gair-Pushtaini – Impermissibility of – Held: Classification made by the GNOIDA authority for the purposes of awarding differential compensation is bad in law – Land Acquisition Act does not distinguish between classes of owners, and uniformly provides compensation to all class of landowners – Classification made between Pushtaini landowners and Gair-pushtaini landowners is violative of the law laid down in the Nagpur Trust case and Article 14 – Said classification made by the executive actions is bad in law, and is liable to be set aside – However, since the mischief lies only within the classification, it can be severed, and the remaining part of the executive actions that set out to grant compensation for the purpose of rehabilitation remains valid in law – Impugned judgment passed by the Full Bench of the High Court set aside – Appellants entitled to the reliefs claimed in the Writ Petition filed before the High Court – Constitution of India – Art.14. Constitution of India – Art.14 – Reasonable Classification Test, Wednesbury Principle and Proportionality Test – Discussed – Administrative Law.
Allowing the appeals, the Court HELD: 1. Whether the Appellants are bound by the compensation as per the agreement under the Land Acquisition rules, and have waived off their right to seek enhanced compensation?
The Respondent Authority argued that since the agreement was consented to, no challenge could exist in the Court. This argument in the facts of the case, has been raised only to be A B C D E F G H rejected. The issue involved in adjudication is not in respect of an agreement entered into by the appellants. Similar agreements were also entered into with the Authority by such identically situated landholders who have been granted additional compensation subsequent to the agreement by carving out a distinction on the basis of period of residence/occupation of the land which was acquired by creating an artificial classification of ‘Pushtaini’ and ‘Gair-Pushtaini’ landholders. Furthermore, since the issue of additional compensation by making an artificial classification of ‘pushtaini’ and ‘Gair-pushtani’ was not in existence at the time of the agreement, there was no occasion to challenge the same. Further, specifically in the context of the grant of exgratia payment, it is to be noted that the said payment granted to Pushtaini landowners through a separate notification, was assessed, and given, after the agreement was signed by both, Pushtaini and Gair-pushtaini Landowners. The Appellants herein, under those circumstances, could not have challenged the agreement vis a vis the exgratia payment on grounds of violation of Article 14, when no such violation existed at the time of the agreement. No man can be expected to predict a future violation of their rights and file a pre-emptive appeal.The Appellants, because of their signing of the agreement, have not forfeited their right to seek revised compensation, because ,the cause of action accrued to them much after entering into the agreement. The issue no. 1 is answered accordingly in the negative and in favour of the Appellants.[Paras 27-30][448-D-H; 449-A-B,D] 2.1 Whether the classification made by and executive fiat between Pushtaini Landowners and Gair-pushtaini Landowners for payment of compensation at different rates is liable to be struck down as violative of Article 14 of the Constitution?
REASONABLE CLASSIFICATION TEST
For any classification to survive the test of Article 14, the classification must be based on intelligible differentia, and it must have a rational nexus to the object sought to be achieved by the law. The object sought to be achieved must also be lawful, and if the object of the law itself is found to be discriminatory, then such discrimination must be struck down. [Para 33][451-C-D] RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR
PRADESH
A B C D E F G H 424 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
2.2 While prima facie, the classification and the object sought to be achieved through the said classification seems reasonable, however, the devil lies in the details. The justification given by the GNOIDA Authority, and the Full-bench of the High Court assumes that only Pushtaini landowners permanently reside in the subject land or that the subject land is the primary source of income only for Pushtaini landowners, and this assumption has been backed by no empirical data produced by the authority. While the classification made by Greater Noida has been based on the object of giving fair compensation, however, such a laudable object of the classification would stand breached by the effects of such a classification, creating a dissonance between the object and its effect. Many Gair-pushtaini landholders, whose main area of residence or their main source of income is also the subject land, would be subject to great discrimination and injustice, if the same compensation that has been granted to the pushtaini landholders is not extended to them. [Paras 38, 39][455-F-H; 456-A-B]
2.3 WEDNESBURY PRINCIPLE
The classification made by GNOIDA does not find its footing in the Land Acquisition Act, or the UP-Land Acquisition Rules, and hence is contrary to law. The said classification also suffers from not taking into account relevant considerations. The Authority, without taking into account any empirical data, or calculating any possibility of Gair-pushtaini landowners being rendered landless or without a primary source of income, made the impugned classification. These relevant factors, by not being taken into account, can and would cause great injustice to Gairpushtaini landowners. Further, GNOIDA, by arbitrarily classifying the landowners as Pushtaini and Gair-pushtaini on the basis of a cut-off date, have taken into account an irrelevant factor. The cut-off date by itself, without any context of the landowners on ground, is not indicative of who the most adversely affected landowners are. By not complying with these three factors while making the classification, this Court must strike down such a classification. [Paras 44, 45][457-F-G; 458-A-B]
2.4 PROPORTIONALITY TEST
The interfering law, i.e. the impugned notification that creates the classification, does not have a rational nexus to the A B C D E F G H object sought to be achieved, and thus, violates the first two prongs of the proportionality test. Coming to the third and fourth prong of the proportionality test, i.e whether the classification created by the Authority was a necessity to achieve the state aim of compensating those landowners that are either direct residents 46 of the land or the land exists as their primary source of income and whether such measure was proportional to the object sought to be achieved. For this, it is pertinent to refer to Section 23 of the Act, which provides for matters to be taken into account while determining the compensation. A bare perusal of Section 23 would show that, the grounds for classification as purported by the GNOIDA authority, have already been covered by Section 23 of the Act. The fifth point of the said Section squarely covers the requirement of compensating for rehabilitation of the affected landowners. In the presence of an already existing provision in the act, the classification created by the GNOIDA authority, must exist in furtherance of the said Section, and not in contrast of. [Paras 52-54][465-B-D; 466-C-D] 2.5 The classification if allowed to exist, can lead to several Gair-pushtaini landowners who may also need to be rehabilitated, cannot rehabilitate themselves without compensation for the same. This circumstance alone besides being discriminatroy pits the said classification against Section 23 of the Act, causing an insubordination to the 1894 Act. Such a mischief, if allowed to exist, would not only nullify the purpose of the Act, but also violate the third and fourth principle of the proportionality test, and hence is liable to be struck down. Further, it is also important to note that the classification, even if allowed to exist, does not come with any safeguards against its potential abuse. As mentioned above, the said notification by way of its classification creates disastrous mischief, and the notification does nothing to remedy such potential abuse. No guidelines for the said classification exist, nor are there any bars placed. If such classification is left unchecked, it may lead to bad precedence, and disastrous ramifications in the future. This lack of substantive guidelines also violates the fifth prong of the proportionality test. The impugned classification is liable to be struck down as violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. [Paras 55-57][466-D-H] RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR
PRADESH
A B C D E F G H 426 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
State Of West Bengal Vs. Anwar Ali Sarkar (1952) AIR 75 : [1952] SCR 284; Rustom Cavasjee Cooper (Banks Nationalisation) v. Union of India (1970) 1 SCC 248 :
[1970] 3 SCR 530; Navtej Singh Johar & Ors. Vs.
Union of India Thr. Secretary, Ministry of Law and Justice (2018) 10 SCC 1 : [2018] 7 SCR 379; K. S.
Puttaswamy & Anr. Vs. Union of India & Ors (2017) 10 SCC 1 : [2017] 10 SCR 569 – followed.
Gujarat Mazdoor Sabha & Anr. Vs. State of Gujarat (2020) 10 SCC 459 – relied on.
Associated Provincial Picture Houses Limited v.
Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223 – referred to.
3. Whether the classification made by the Full-Bench of the High Court between Pushtaini landowners and Gair-pushtaini landowners is in contravention to the law laid down by this Hon’ble Court in the case of Nagpur Improvement Trust and another vs. Vithal Rao and others (1973) 1 SCC 500?
The classification made by the GNOIDA authority for the purposes of awarding differential compensation is bad in law, and it is precisely this kind of classification that has been barred. When the purpose of the acquisition of the land is for the benefit of the public at large, then the nature of the owner of the said land is inconsequential to the purpose. If such a classification on the basis of the nature of owner is allowed, then on the same grounds, there might be a possibility of future classifications where powerholding members of the society may get away with a larger compensation, and the marginalized may get lesser compensation. This is precisely what this Court in the abovementioned judgment predicted, and to preempt such arbitrary classification, clarified the position in law. The Land Acquisition Act does not distinguish between classes of owners, and uniformly provides compensation to all class of landowners. The classification made between Pushtaini landowners and Gair-pushtaini landowners, on the basis of the reasoning mentioned above, is violative of the law laid down in the Nagpur Trust case and Article 14 of the Constitution. [Para 59, 60][468-B-F] A B C D E F G H Nagpur Improvement Trust and Another Vs. Vithal Rao and Ors. (1973) 1 SCC 500 : [1973] 3 SCR 39 – relied on.
4.1 The classification made by both the executive actions is bad in law, and is liable to be set aside. The Land Acquisition Act does not envisage any differential compensation on the basis of such classification, and hence, this Court must infer the compensation to be provided by the executive actions within the confines of Section 23 of the Act. Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act states out the grounds for granting compensation in cases of acquisition of land under the Act. One such reason for the grant of compensation is rehabilitation, and it is this need for granting compensation for rehabilitation under the Act that is echoed by the impugned notification. A bare reading of both the executive actions in consonance with the Act would show that the need for giving compensation for rehabilitation is valid in law and is backed by the parent statute. The mischief then, is only limited to the arbitrary classification made by such actions. In such a case, since the mischief lies only within the classification, it can be severed, and the remaining part of the executive actions that sets out to grant compensation for the purpose of rehabilitation remains valid in law. Once the classification is removed, and the executive actions are read in consonance with the parent act, it would be seen that since the Act, and now even the executive actions do not discriminate in terms of compensation, the ex gratia payment and the increased base amount, as enunciated by the executive actions, must be given to all landowners in the subject area. [Paras 62, 63][468-H; 469- A-C] 4.2 Further, in cases of administrative action, even if the classification has a rational nexus to the objective of the notification, the classification must also be legitimized by the parent statute. If the parent statute does not allow for a classification, then, even if the classification vis-à-vis the notification is able to pass the tests of Article 14, it would still be liable to struck down if the parent statute does not allow for the same. The impugned judgment passed by the Full Bench of the High Court is not liable to be sustained and stands set aside. As RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR
PRADESH
A B C D E F G H 428 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
a consequence, the Writ Petition filed by the appellants before the High Court stands allowed and the appellants are held entitled to the reliefs claimed in the said Writ Petition. [Paras 65, 67][469- F-H; 470-A-B] Om Kumar & Ors. Vs. Union Of India (2001) 2 SCC 386 : [2000] 4 Suppl. SCR 693; Smt. Madhuri Srivasatava Vs. State of U.P. & Ors. (2016) 6 SCC OnLine AII 2832; Gajraj Vs. State of U.P (2011) SCC OnLine AII 1711; Radheyshyam (Dead) through L.Rs & Ors. Vs. State Of UP & Ors. (2011) 5 SCC 553 :
[2011] 8 SCR 359; Greater Noida Industrial Development Authority Vs. Devendra Kumar & Ors.
(2011) 12 SCC 375; Savitri Devi Vs. State of U.P. & Ors. (2015) 7 SCC 21 : [2015] 7 SCR 512 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [1973] 3 SCR 39 referred to Para 4 [2011] 8 SCR 359 referred to Para 10 [2015] 7 SCR 512 referred to Para 10 [1952] SCR 284 followed Para 34 [1970] 3 SCR 530 followed Para 35 [2018] 7 SCR 379 followed Para 36 [2000] 4 Suppl. SCR 693 referred to Para 43 [2017] 10 SCR 569 followed Para 48 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No.8819 of 2022.
From the Judgment and Order dated 30.03.2018 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad in WC No.49326 of 2009.
With Civil Appeal Nos. 8820 And 8821 of 2022.
Salman Khurshid, S.G. Hasnain, Pradeep Kant, Ravindra Kumar Raizada, Ravindra Kumar, Sr. Advs., Prashant Kanha, Gaurav Srivastava, Aftab Ali Khan, Syed Mohd. Fazal, M.Z. Chaudhary, Ms. Azra Rehman, Ms. Aadya Mishra, Ms. Saba Baby Khan, Rohit Kumar Singh, Simranjeet A B C D E F G H Singh Rekhi, Harsh Jain, Anuvrat Sharma, Arun Kumar Singh, Ms. Alka Sinha, Binay Kumar Das, Ms. Priyanka Das, Ms. Neha Das, Ajai Kumar, Ms. Kamini Jaiswal, Omanakuttan K. K., Advs. for the appearing parties. The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
KRISHNA MURARI, J.
1. These appeals are directed against the judgment and order dated 30.03.2018 passed by a Full Bench of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad (hereinafter referred to as ‘the High Court’), The reference to Full Bench came to be made under the following circumstances: - 1.1 Writ Petition No. 61449 of 2009, Smt. Madhuri Srivasatava Vs. State of U.P. & Ors.1 along with other connected petitions were filed by certain landholders whose land was acquired by NOIDA challenging the decision of the Board of Directors of NOIDA dated 07.01.1998 as also the approval granted to the said resolution by the State Government dated 02.03.2009 whereby a distinction was carved out in the matter of payment of compensation by creating a classification between “Pushtaini” and “Gair-pushtaini” landholders. The ‘Pushtaini’ landholders whose lands were acquired, were given additional compensation @ Rs.3 per sq. yard along with 15% as rehabilitation bonus on the compensation already awarded, as also the 10% area of the acquired land, whereas those who were declared as ‘Gair-pusht xcaini’ were denied this additional benefit. A Division Bench of the High Court vide Judgment and order dated 10.05.2016 dismissed the Writ Petition holding the classification to be reasonable having direct nexus with the object sought to be achieved i.e., rehabilitation of the original residents who are likely to become landless due to the acquisition of their land.
2. Another bunch of Writ Petitions were filed by the present appellants challenging a similar classification made by the Greater Noida Authority (hereinafter referred to as ‘G Noida’) in payment of compensation on the basis of the landholder being ‘Pushtaini’ and ‘Gair- Pushtaini’.
3. While considering the Writ Petitions, another Division Bench disagreed with the views expressed in the case of Smt. Madhuri (Supra) and vide order dated 07.07.2017 referred the matter to be decided by a larger Bench.
1 (2016) 6 SCC OnLine AII 2832 RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR
PRADESH
A B C D E F G H 430 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
4. The Full Bench constituted in pursuance to the reference framed the following questions for adjudication :-
(i) Whether the law laid down by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Smt. Madhuri Srivastava reported in (2016) 6 ADJ 1 is in conflict to the law laid down by the Supreme Court in the case of Nagpur Improvement Trust and Another Vs. Vithal Rao and Ors.2 and also with the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894?
(ii) Whether the classification made under the U.P. Land Acquisition (determination of compensation and declaration of award by agreement) Rules, 1997, the distinction made among ‘Pushtaini’ and ‘Gair-Pushtaini’ farmers, is a classification having reasonable nexus with the object sought to be achieved?
5. Vide impugned judgment and order dated 30.03.2018, the Full Bench answered question No. 1 in negative and question No. 2 in affirmative and upheld the view taken by the Division Bench in the case of Smt. Madhuri Srivastava (Supra). As a consequence of the answers to the questions framed, the Full Bench held that nothing remains to be decided in the Writ Petitions filed by the present appellants and the same were dismissed.
6. Before we enter into the factual matrix of the case, we find it expedient to first trace out the etymology of the words “Pushtaini” and “Gair Pushtaini” used in the impugned classification, for language, once adopted inside the realm of law, materializes itself a much more powerful being, one which must be understood in the right historical context.
7. The word ‘Pushtaini’ is a Persian word and finds its origin from the word ‘Pusht’, which means ‘back’. The said word has been historically used in the context of ancestry. Any possession, tale or legend, that has roots to a particular ancestry, to denote it’s significance to the said ancestry, the word ‘Pushtaini’ is used. As is obvious, since the word ‘Gair’ which finds its origin in Urdu language means ‘other than’, thus, ‘Gair-Pushtaini’ would mean one which is not ‘Pushtaini’.
8. What we find most interesting however, is that ancestry as a concept, especially before times of modern private property ownership,
2 (1973) 1 SCC 500
A B C D E F G H had remained to be a tool for inclusivity and not exclusion. In such a context, the use of the word “Pushtaini” by the Authority, to exclude compensation might be a historically inaccurate interpretation. While this is not consequential to the merits of the case, it is in our opinion a worthwhile observation, for law has to power to legitimize the meaning of words and can change the context in which a word used, and in turn can change the course of history itself.
Background Facts
9. Since the early 1970s, Liberalization took over India by storm, and it brought with it the promise of massive economic growth. A huge amount of money was infused in the Indian Economy with the purpose of developing Indian cities into massive global hubs of capital and business. In line with this, Delhi began its journey of becoming a global city. This influx of capital into the city also brought with it massive employment opportunities, and people from all over the country started migrating to Delhi. To contain such influx of migrants and ensure dignified living for all who came to the city with the hopes of improving their lives, the government of India planned to develop residential and industrial areas around the capital. For this, Gurgaon was developed across the border of Haryana, and New Okhla Industrial Development Authority (NOIDA) was developed by the Uttar Pradesh Government in the adjoining district of Gautam Budh Nagar. In this period, the city enjoyed massive growth, both in terms of influx of capital and migration. This growth was so unprecedented, that it even exceeded the planning estimates as envisaged by the authorities. As a measure to accommodate such growth, the Uttar Pradesh Government, exercising its powers under Section 3 of the U.P. Industrial Area Development Act, 1976, by notification dated 28.01.1991 created the township of Greater Noida, in an area of 38000 hectare, comprising of 124 villages of Gautam Budh Nagar.
10. For its planned development, the Respondent- G. Noida started acquisition of land within its territorial area of operation under the provisions of Land Acquisition Act (hereinafter referred to as ‘1894 Act’). In the same connection, notifications dated 03.10.2005 and 05.01.2006 were issued under Sections 4(1) and Section 6(1) of 1894 Act for acquisition of total area of 580.1734 hectares of the land for plan development situate in different villages falling within the jurisdiction of G. Noida. The said notifications, which also included the land of the RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [KRISHNA MURARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 432 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
present appellants, were subject matter of challenge before the High Court in a bunch of Writ Petitions challenging the acquisition proceedings mainly on the ground of arbitrarily invoking urgency clause under Sections 17(1) read with Section 17 (4) of the 1894 Act. The bunch of the said Writ Petitions came to be decided by the another Full Bench of the High Court titled as Gajraj Vs. State of U.P3. The High Court concluded that the urgency clause was wrongly invoked, but saved the acquisition for the reason that much development had already taken place over the said land and the nature of land stands completely changed. The Full Bench further in order to compensate the landholders directed an additional compensation to be paid to the landholders at the rate of 64.70% of the already paid compensation and a further direction was issued to allot developed Abadi land to the extent of 10% of their acquired land, subject to a cap of Rs.2,500/- square meter. The Full Bench never made any distinction between ‘Pushtaini’ and ‘Gair-Pushtaini’ farmers for payment of the additional compensation or allotment of land. The Full Bench also relying upon the decisions rendered in the case of Radheyshyam (Dead) through L.Rs & Ors. Vs. State Of UP & Ors.4, Greater Noida Industrial Development Authority Vs. Devendra Kumar & Ors.5, further held that merely because the farmers had received compensation under an agreement, it cannot be said that they have waived off the right to challenge the same. The Full Bench judgment in Gajraj (Supra) came to be affirmed by this Court in Savitri Devi Vs. State of U.P. & Ors.6
11. The present appellants had also filed a Writ Petition being Writ Petition No. 62056 of 2011 challenged the notification issued under Sections 4 and 6 read with Section 17 of the Act. The said Writ Petition came to be disposed of in terms of the directions issued by the Full Bench in the case of Gajraj (Supra) vide judgment and order dated 01.11.2011.
12. It is also pertinent to mention at this stage that even before the land acquisition proceedings were initiated and notification under Sections 4 and 6 of the 1894 Act, were issued, the Respondent-Greater Noida in its 26th Board meeting dated 28.10.1997 decided to classify the landholders for the purposes of payment of compensation for acquisition 3 (2011) SCC OnLine AII 1711
4 (2011) 5 SCC 553
5 (2011) 12 SCC 375
6 (2015) 7 SCC 21
A B C D E F G H of their land as ‘Pushtaini’, namely, those landholders who had purchased the land prior to the date of establishment of authority i.e., 28.01.1991 or thereafter got the land by partition or family settlement and ‘Gair- Pushtaini’ being those persons who purchased the land after its establishment. Thus, two classes of landholders were carved out for payment of compensation and those who were classified as ‘Pushtaini’ landholders, a higher amount of compensation was decided to be awarded to them in the name of their rehabilitation.
13. Subsequently, on 15.07.2006, an agreement was entered into between Greater Noida and the appellants and other landholders under Rule 4(2) of the Land Acquisition Rules, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as ‘1997 Rules’) and in accordance with the resolution passed by Greater Noida in its 26th Meeting, the ‘Pushtaini’ landholders were paid compensation @ Rs. 322 per sq. yard and the ‘Gair-Pushtaini’ landholders including the appellants herein were paid a lesser amount of compensation @ Rs.280 per sq. yard.
14. The landholders continued with their agitation making demand of further compensation at the enhanced rate which resulted in constituting a Committee to consider the demand of enhanced rate of compensation in the form of bonus/ex-gratia compensation. The Committee submitted its report after making a recommendation for payment of the amount @ Rs.310 per square metre on account of Exgratia to the Ancestral Agriculturists of the land situate in 8 Villages.
15. The report of the Committee dated 25.10.2008 is being reproduced hereunder for a ready reference :- “ ANNEXURE P-4 25.10.2008 Recommendation of the Committee constituted in connection with making consideration on the demands of bonus/ex- gratia/ compensation enhancement at the enhanced rate in connection with the land of Village Ghodi Bachheda and other Villages as per Order No.4/4/1/2008 -C.X. (1) Lucknow dated 4.09.2008 of the Government of Uttar Pradesh Following Committee has been constituted in connection with making consideration on these types of demands and bonus / ex-gratia /compensation enhancement at the enhanced rate in connection with the land of Village Ghodi Bachheda and RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [KRISHNA MURARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 434 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
other Villages vide Order No.4/4/1/2008 C.X. (1) Lucknow dated 4.09.2008 of the Government of Uttar Pradesh:-
1. Shri Thakur Jaibir Singh, Hon’ble Minister, Rural Engineering Service, Agricultural Foreign Trade and Agriculture Export Chairman
2. Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida - Member
3. District Magistrate, Gautam Buddh Nagar - Member Coordinator Examined and perused the records made available in evidence of the Memos submitted by the representatives of agriculture is organizations / Agriculturists and perused the background of the and its different aspects by the Committee and while convening Committee Meeting of the Committee of Villages / their representatives, even consideration was made in respect of the above matter, particulars of which is given below:-
1. Background- this decision was taken in the 26th meeting dated 28.10.1997 of the Greater Noida Authority Board that the rate of compensation be assessed on the basis of agreement by the Authority for each financial year and those Agriculturists, who are agreed for executing the consent at the rates of the questioned Financial Years, they while executing the agreement/consent, may receive compensation under contract/consent regulation and those Agriculturists, who are not agreed with the prescribed rate, the compensation will be payable to them at the rate prescribed by the learned District Magistrate under provisions of Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act 1994. On the basis of above sequence, for the year of 1997-98, the rate of compensation was assessed @ Rs.110 per square and in future, it will be enhanced in accordance with cost inflation index in each financial year. Vide Order No.902/778 3-0 7-1 43 N/04. of the Government of Uttar Pradesh, a High Level Committee under Chairmanship of the Commissioner, Meerut Division, Meerut was constituted. Committee has recommended its compensation value @ Rs.800-850 per square metre, in sequence thereto, in the meeting of Greater Noida Authority Board held on 5.01.2008, while assessing the compensation @ Rs.850 per A B C D E F G H square metre, decision was taken to enforce this rate with effect from 1.04.2007.
Even the particulars of these types of Memos are also mentioned in the recommendation dated 4.01.2008 of the Committee constituted under chairmanship of the Commissioner, Meerut Division, Meerut vide Order dated 31.12.2007 of the Government issued previously, whereby it is clear that at that time also, The Villagers of the above Villages were making demand for enhancement in compensation. The certain Memos of the Villagers were forwarded to the Government for appropriate guidelines/ directions while enclosing them as per Authority letter No.931 / land-record / L.P./2008 dated 7.03.2008/ 903/ land-record / LP/2008 dated 10.03.2008, Land Record/1 a/2008 dated 13.03.20081038/land-record/L.A./2008 dated 29.04.2008, 1055/ land-record/ LA / 2008 dated 5.05.2008/ 1069/landrecord/ LA/2008 dated 9.05.2008, 1113, 1115/land-record/L A/2008 dated 06.06.08. Thereafter, by Order dated 10.05.2008 of the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida, for examination of the demand of compensation enhancement raised by the Agriculturists, a Committee of District Magistrate, Gautam Buddha Nagar, Chief Executive Officer, Deputy Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida was constituted and in its report dated 21.07.2008, recommendation was made to make consideration for additional amount @ Rs. 175 -200 square metre to the Agriculturists of the land acquired in the Financial Years 2006-2007 of the Village Ghodi Bachheda including other Villages. Such directions were given while making perusal of the Recommendation of the Committee in the 72nd Meeting dated 11.08.2008 of the Authority Board, that while making calculation of the situation of its financial source and its management, the case be referred to the Government. Vide Order No.4/4/1/2008 -C.X. (1) Lucknow dated 4.09.2008 of the Government of Uttar Pradesh, the above Committee was constituted for giving recommendation in connection with making consideration on the demands of bonus / ex-gratia/ enhancement of compensation and etc. at the enhanced rate in connection with the Village Ghodi Bachheda and other RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [KRISHNA MURARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 436 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
Villages.
2. Meetings of the Committee - That first meeting of the Committee was convened on 15.09.2008 in the conference room of Uttar Pradesh Sadan, New Delhi, in addition to the Chairman of Committee, following officers have taken part-
1. Shri Pankaj Agarwal, Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida
2. Shri Shravan Kumar Sharma, District officer, Gautam Buddha Nagar In addition to above, following officers of the Greater Noida Authority were appeared in the above meeting-
1. Shri Shailendra Chaudhary, Deputy Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida.
2. Shri Shishir, Special Executive Officer, Greater Noida Consideration and consultation was made in connection with the work area, operation and process of the constitution of the Committee in the meeting land this decision was taken that while convening a meeting with the Agriculturists and their representatives affected with the acquisition, their opinions and demands may be known by way of receiving representations from them and discussion may be made from them in this regard.
In sequence of above, the meeting of Committee was convened on 22.09.2008 and 11.10.2008 respectively in the Conference Room of the Greater Noida Authority, wherein, while receiving the memo from the Agriculturists of Village and their representatives, the matter was discussed and consulted in detail, wherein, mainly, following people have taken part-
1. Ramesh Singh Rawal,
2. Yogendra Singh Rawal,
3. Subedar Ramchandra,
4. Omprakash,
5. Mahi Singh Bhati, A B C D E F G H
6. Lokesh Bhati,
7. Maha Singh Bhati,
8. Pratap Singh Bhati,
9. Pratap Singh Sarpanch,
10. Prem Mukhiya,
11. Inder Singh (Advocate),
12. Ajit Singh Nagar,
13. Kamal Bhati,
14. Mange Ram Bharti
15. Bhule Singh,
16. Rakesh
17. Braham Singh,
18. Atmender,
19. Maharaj Singh,
20. Mehndi Hassan,
21. Umesh,
22. Vikram Singh,
23. Satbir Pradhan,
24. Naresh Upadhyay,
25. Ajith Mukhiya,
26. Rampal Havaldar,
27. Nemvir, Pradhan, Garba and etc. etc.
3. Grounds of the demand and memo submitted by the Agriculturist - There records were received in support of detailed Memos and particulars in connection with the demands from the Villages in their meeting by the Committee. The agriculturist of the land acquired in the year of 2006- 2007 of Village Ghodi Bachheda and including other Villages RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [KRISHNA MURARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 438 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
have collectively produced detailed and factual Memos including necessary records before the Committee and even grounds were also raised by the Agriculturists orally in support of their demand, wherein, main grounds are included, which are as under:-
1. The farmers of questioned Villages have given value enhancement Memo on 2.04.2006, whereon, the Greater Noida Development Authority gave Assurance letter in written on 5.01.2007 after 10 days, that, after calling the rates of Tronica City and etc. in the GDA, till the last week of the February 2007, decision will be taken in connection with enhancing the compensation. In support of their statements copy of letter dated 5.01.2007 of the Deputy Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida addressed to Ashok Pradhan, respected member, Lok Sabha and Sri Nawab Singh Nagar, is enclosed.
2. They had also revealed their demand in connection with compensation enhancement in the meeting of committee constituted under chairmanship of the Commissioner, Meerut Division, Meerut, but nothing benefit has been given to the Agriculturists of the acquired land in the financial year 2006- 2007.
3. The Villagers have produced their demand, while disclosing detailed grounds before the Committee constituted under chairmanship of the learned District Magistrate vide Order dated 10.06.2008 of the Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida but, even then, the Committee, without making intensive consideration thereon, has given recommendation for enhancement @ Rs. 175- 200 per square metre, which is not in practical and it is against the principle of natural justice and that this enhancement is insufficient.
4. Analysis - The Notification was issued on 5.01.2006 under Section 6/17 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 in the proposal of acquisition of 580.1730 hectare land of Village Gonda Bachheda and that the possession of the acquired land was handed over to the Greater Noida Authority on 14.05.2006 by the Additional Collector (L A). After approving the value A B C D E F G H of compensation @ Rs.385 per square metre on 28.06.2006 from the Divisional Commissioner, Meerut, the compensation amount was distributed @ Rs.385 per square metre to the Ancestral Agriculturists and @ Rs.334.78 per square metre to the ancestral Agriculturists. That the land of the following Villages were acquired for well-planned development of the Greater Noida in the Financial Years 2006-2007 including Village Gonda, Bachada and other Villages and that the possession of the above land was taken after 01.04.2006 and the Agriculturists of the above land are making demand for enhancement of compensation.
Agriculturist organization, Agriculturists of these Villagers have also given a number of Memos for demanding enhancement of compensation at the time of constitution of the Committee under chairmanship of the Divisional Commissioner, Meerut vide Order dated 31.12.2007 of the Government and even prior to it.
The copy of consent letter dated 5.01.2007 signed by the then Deputy Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida and consideration and consultation made on the Memos submitted on 5.01.2007 in the matter by the Villagers with Member of Parliament Shri Ashok Pradhan and the then MLA Shri Nawab Singh Nagar was also provided to the agriculturists, wherein, it is mentioned that this decision has been taken in connection with enhancing the compensation of the acquired land that after calling the rates of compensation of the land being acquired by the Ghaziabad Development Authority and the land of Tronica City of Housing Development Board, till the last week of February, decision will be taken in connection RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [KRISHNA MURARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 440 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
with enhancing the compensation. It is clear by it that the Agriculturists were raising demand of enhancing the compensation even in the month of February 2007, whereon, the Assurance was given at the Competent Level of Authority. The Committee constituted under chairmanship of the learned District Magistrate has revealed the facts in detail in its report dated 31.07.2008 on the above overall points raised by the Agriculturists. The Committee has perused the recommendation dated 21.07.2008 of the Committee constituted under the chairmanship of the learned District Magistrate, Gautam Buddha Nagar. Such finding has been concluded in its report dated 21.07.2008 that it is not possible to make any change in the rate of compensation in accordance with law, because of receiving the compensation after fulfillment of the agreement under the Agreement Regulation after acquisition of the land by the concerned Agriculturists, but, the Committee has recommended in its report dated 21.07.2008 to award certain amount in the detailed circumstances on account of ex-gratia.
5. Recommendation - As per the information provided by the Special Executive Officer (L A), Greater Noida, most of the Agriculturist of the acquired land in the financial year 2006 2007 of Village Ghodi Bachheda, including other Villages, as per the Government Order dated 29.09.2001, under the provisions of Uttar Pradesh Land Acquisition (Determination of Compensation and Declaration of Award by Agreement) Rules, 1997, have received Compensation. Therefore, it would not be possible under the rule to make any enhancement/ change in the compensation rates of the award to be declared. Accordingly, it would be appropriated only to give additional amount on account of Ex gratia to be awarded as relief to the Agriculturists of these Villages. In the report dated 21.07.2008 of the Committee constituted under the chairmanship of the learned District Magistrate, recommendation has been given to award additional amount @ Rs.175-200 per square metre. But, in opinion of the Committee, there is justification to make partial enhancement in above amount.
Therefore, in view of the above detailed factual analysis, consultation, discussion, consideration made from the A B C D E F G H Agriculturists and assurance given at the level of Authority, this Committee is hereby made recommendation to make payment of the amount @ Rs.310 per square metre on account of Ex gratia to the ancestral Agriculturists of the questioned land of 8 Villages detailed in Para No.4 possession of which has been received in the financial year 2006-2007 and the Committee is hereby further recommended to submit the recommendation before the Greater Noida Authority Board for necessary proceedings.
Sd/-, Shravan Kumar Sharma, District Magistrate, Gautam Buddha Nagar Sd/- (Pankaj Agarwal), Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida Sd/- (Thakur Jaiveer Singh), Hon’ble Minister Rural Engineering Service Agriculture Foreign Trade and Agriculture Export, Uttar Pradesh”
16. Based on the aforesaid report, a decision was taken in the 74th Board Meeting of Greater Noida for payment of additional compensation/ex-gratia @ Rs.310 per square metre only to the ‘Pushtaini’ farmers of 8 villages.
17. The Minutes of the 74th Board Meeting of the Greater Noida Authority dated 03.11.2008 are being reproduced hereunder :- “ ANNEXURE P-5 S. No.1 - For approval of minutes of 74th Board Meeting of the authority 74th Board meeting of Authority was held on 03.11.2008. RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [KRISHNA MURARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 442 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
Minutes of this meeting (enclosure), has been sent to the members of authority vide semi Government letter No.UMC/ 74th Board Meeting/ 2008 / 265 dated 3.11.2008. Minutes of the above meeting is being submitted herewith for approval of the Authority Board.
S.No. 9- In connection with demand of bonus/ex-gratia/ compensation enhancement of the Agriculturists of the land of Village Ghodi Bachheda and Other Villagers acquired in the Financial Year 2006 2007 by Greater Noida The Agriculturists of the land of following Villagers, whose land was acquired in the financial year 2006 -2007 by the Greater Noida, have submitted a lots of Memos, while making demand of compensation enhancement- Which have been submitted to the Government from time to time for appropriate directions and guidelines. For examination of the demand of compensation and management of Agriculturist, following a Committee of District Magistrate, Gautam Buddha Nagar, Additional Chief Executive Officer, Deputy Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida was constituted vide Order dated 10.06.2008 of the Chairman, Greater Noida, and the above committee has recommended to make consideration on awarding additional amount @ Rs.175- 200 per square metre to the cultivators, whose land was acquired in the financial year 2006, 2007, in Village Ghodi Bachheda including other Villages, in its report dated 21.07.2008. In the 72nd meeting of the Board held on 11.08.2008, while using the Recommendation of the Committee, this direction was given that, while making calculation of the situation of the financial sources and its A B C D E F G H management, the matter may be referred to the Government, as per Government Order No.4/4/1/2008 - C.X. (1) Lucknow dated 4.09.2008 of the Government of Uttar Pradesh, the committee was constituted in connection with making consideration on the demands of the Agriculturists in connection with bonus / Ex gratia / compensation enhancement of the enhanced rates in connection with the land of Village Ghodi Bachheda and other Villages.
1. Sri Thakur Jaiveer Singh Hon’ble Minister, Rural Engineering Service, Agriculture Foreign Trade and Agriculture export -Chairman
2. Chief Executive Officer, Greater Noida member
3. District Magistrate, Gautam Buddha Nagar -Member Coordinator The committee has submitted its recommendation on 25.10.2008, wherein, the recommendation has been made to make payment on account of ex-gratia @ Rs.310 square metre to the ancestral agricultural of the land whose possession has been received in the Financial Year 2006-2007 of 1.04.2006 by the Greater Noida in respect of the land of Village Ghodi Bachheda and recommendation has been made to submit the matter with recommendation of the Committee before the Greater Noida Authority Board for necessary proceedings. The report dated 25.10.2008 of the Committee is enclosed and that it is a part of agenda.
Overall Compensation Amount of Rs.5522134695.00 (Rupees Five Arab fifty two crores twenty one lakhs thirty four thousand six hundred ninety five only), calculated @ Rs.385 per square metre. applied at that time against the land measuring 1434.3207 of the above Villages acquired in the financial year 2006-2007, has already been sent to the learned Additional District Magistrate (L.A.). And as per letter No.527/ 8 -VK BHL a dated 23.06.2008 received from the land acquisition officer, the amount of Rs.5,27,56,68,568 (Five Arab Twenty seven crores, fifty six lakhs sixty eight thousand five hundred sixty eight only), which is 95.54%, has already been distributed among the concerned Agriculturists. As per RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [KRISHNA MURARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 444 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
the information received vide letter No.833/Eight- A.D.O. (L A) /08 dated 21.10.2008 of the Additional Collector (L.A. ), out of the questioned acquired land of the above Villages, the area measuring 1392.9586 hectare, is ancestral area. So, in case of making payment at the enhanced rates to the ancestral Agriculturist, that is, on making payment @ Rs.310 per square metre as recommended by the Committee, then, their shall financial burden of Rs.4318171660 (Rupees four Arab twenty one crores eighty one lakhs seventy one thousand six hundred and sixty only).
The report of the Committee is submitted for consideration of the Authority Board.”
18. Vide order dated 15.01.2009, the State Government granted its approval for payment of enhanced compensation/ex-gratia/bonus to the ‘Pushtaini’ landholders.
19. For the sake of convenience, the break-up of compensation granted to both the categories of landowners is being produced hereunder:- A B C D E F G H
ARGUMENTS ADVANCED BY THE APPELLANTS
20. The learned Counsel for the Appellants Contended that:- I. Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act does not allow for a discrimination between Pushtaini and Gair-pushtaini landowners in determination of compensation under the Land Acquisition Act.
I. In light of the law laid down by this Court in the Nagpur Improvement Trust Case (Supra), no distinction between the abovementioned two sets of classes of landowners can be made on the basis of the date of purchase of the land and the date of establishment of G NOIDA. The Ld.
Counsel argued that all the landowners whose land was acquired should stand on the same pedestal.
II. The Land of both the classes of landowners have been acquired under the same procedure, for the same public purpose and having the same market value, and hence, any difference in the rate of compensation provided to any party is highly discriminatory and is violative of Article 14. III. Further, it has also been argued that merely by signing the agreement, the Appellants herein cannot be said to have waived their right to Appeal the compensation, especially since the fact that the ex-gratia payment granted to the Pushtaini landowners was awarded after the agreement was signed.
IV. It has also been contended that the ex-gratia payment as a form of compensation does not exist in the Land Acquisition Act, and can only be interpreted as one of the reasons for payment within Section 23 of the Land Acquisition Act, and in such a scenario, the payment must be universally made to all parties.
ARGUMENTS ADVANCED BY THE RESPONDENTS
21. The Ld. Counsel for the Respondents Contended that: I. The UP Land Acquisition Rules have been formed under the Land Acquisition Act,1894. These rules prescribe for method of compensation between the acquirer and the RAMESH CHANDRA SHARMA v. STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH [KRISHNA MURARI, J.] A B C D E F G H 446 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 2 S.C.R.
acquiree through an agreement. The Appellants, by way of an agreement, voluntarily accepted the compensation being granted to them. Further, while accepting the compensation, the Appellants herein also submitted an Affidavit stating that the compensation is agreed upon and accepted by the parties. It was only three years later that the Appellants decided to file a writ challenging the compensation, after entering into the agreement and explicitly agreeing to the compensation amount.
II. The Appellants had entered into an agreement as per the law of the land and had accepted the compensation granted to them. In such a scenario, there exists no legal remedy of the Appellants to re-open the agreement on grounds of a subsequent increase in compensation to a different party. There is no remedy to re-open the agreement by way of approaching the Court in the statue.
III. The distinction created between the two classes of land owners has been done on the basis of their residence. The base compensation given to both the classes is the same, and only an additional 15% extra amount is given to Pushtaini landowners as rehabilitation bonus, which is not a necessity for the Gair-pushtaini landowners as they do not reside in the concerned land and are not sons of the soil.
IV. As regards to the ex-gratia payment given to the Pushtaini landowners, the same is merely an additional compensation based on the classification between sons of the soils and mere investors in the land. The payment is based on reasonable classification and is not violative of Article 14. Issues
22. In the aftermath of the aforesaid litigations in the High Court, the following three questions arise for adjudication in these Appeals :- I. Whether the Appellants, by signing the agreement,have waived their right to seek for revised compensation?
II. Whether the classification made under the Land Acquisition Act, and the UP Land Acquisition Rules,1997 between A B C D E F G H Pushtaini Landowners and Gair-pushtaini Landowners for the payment of compensation at different rates is liable to be struck down as violative of Article 14 of the Constitution? III. Whether the classification made by the Full-Bench of the High Court between Pushtaini landowners and Gair-pushtaini landowners is in contravention to the law laid down by this Hon’ble Court in the case of Nagpur Improvement Trust and Another vs. Vithal Rao and Others (1973) 1 SCC 500?
23. We have heard, Shri Pradeep Kant, Learned Senior Counsel for the appellants, Shri. Ravindra Kumar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Greater Noida and Shri Ravindra Kumar Raizada, learned counsel for the State of U.P./A.A.G., at great length.
24. At the outset, we would like to clarify that in the present appeals, we are only concerned with the legality and validity of action of G. Noida paying an enhanced compensation to the landholders by carving out an artificial class of ‘Pushtaini’ landholders from among the same class of landholders whose land was acquired by the same notification for the same purpose. There is no challenge to the validity of the acquisition itself as the same stands finally settled by this Court. Analysis Whether the Appellants are bound by the compensation as per the agreement under the Land Acquisition rules, and have waived off their right to seek enhanced compensation?
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.