Ankita Thakur & Ors. v. The H.P. Staff Selection Commission & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 992; [2023] 16 S.C.R. 813
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Hrishikesh Roy, Justice Department Office Assistant (Information Technology), Justice Class-Iii, Justice (Non-Gazetted), Justice Ministerial Services, Justice Common Recruitment and Promotion Rules, Justice 2014, Justice If Yes, Justice Whether The
- Decided
- 9 Nov 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7602/2023
- Sections
- 2, 3, 12, 13, 15, 31
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 16 S.C.R. 813 : 2023 INSC 992
CASE DETAILS
ANKITA THAKUR & ORS.
v.
THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 7602 of 2023)
NOVEMBER 09, 2023
[HRISHIKESH ROY AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: (i) Whether relaxation in the essential eligibility qualifications could be made post the last date fixed for receipt of applications; (ii) Essential eligibility qualifications specified in the Himachal Pradesh, Department of Personnel, Junior Office Assistant (Information Technology), Class-III, (Non-Gazetted), Ministerial Services, Common Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2014, if ambiguous to warrant clarification/relaxation; (iii) If there was a statutory regime in place to accord recognition to an Institution, if yes, whether the clarificatory letter/ relaxation order is in ignorance of such statutory regime and therefore, invalid; (iv) In absence of prior consultation with the Commission, the relaxation/clarificatory order if was in conformity with the 2014 Rules; (v) Whether in view of requirement for a written and computer typing test prior to selection, possession of one year diploma in Computer Science/Computer Application/IT from a recognised University/Institution was not an essential eligibility qualification; (vi) Candidates holding qualifications other than the one prescribed by the 2014 Rules or the advertisement, though allegedly higher, if could be considered eligible; (vii) Employer if could be forced to fill all vacancies advertised; and whether it could be restrained from carrying it forward for filling it as per the amended/new Rules.
Himachal Pradesh, Department of Personnel, Junior Office Assistant (Information Technology), Class-III, (Non-Gazetted), Ministerial Services, Common Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 2014 – Recruitment of Junior Office Assistants– Essential eligibility qualifications under the Rules – Relaxation in, after the last date for 814 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
receipt of the applications – Change in eligibility criteria midway – Legality:
Held: If the extant Rules provide for the power to relax the eligibility criteria, the same could be exercised only if such power is reserved in the advertisement – And when this power is exercised, there must be wide publicity of its exercise so that persons who are likely to benefit by exercise of such power may get opportunity to apply and compete – In the present case, it is not shown that the advertisement reserved the power to relax the essential eligibility qualifications specified in the advertisement at any later stage– It is not demonstrated that after the decision to relax the eligibility criteria was taken, the same was widely publicised – Further, the clarificatory/relaxation order providing equivalence to certain courses was not founded on empirical data – If there existed a statutory procedure for granting recognition, an Institution cannot be considered recognized dehors that procedure – Power to relax the eligibility criteria, even if it existed, was not exercised in consonance with the settled legal principles and it violated the constitutional mandate enshrined in Articles 14, 16 – Relaxation/clarificatory order approved by the State cabinet after the last date fixed by the advertisements (for Post Code 447 and 556) for receipt of applications from candidates, is not legally sustainable qua those posts, when no opportunity was afforded to similarly placed persons who might have been left out to apply and compete with those candidates who, though not eligible as per the terms of the advertisement, had applied thereunder – Argument that requirement to hold one year diploma in the specified courses was not an essential qualification, rejected – Furthermore, there existed no provision in the extant Rules or the advertisement to treat any other qualification as higher or equivalent to the one specified, claim of candidates who could not demonstrate that they held the prescribed essential qualifications, rejected – An employer cannot be forced to fill all the existing vacancies under the old Rules – Directions contained in paragraphs 33 and 34 of the impugned judgment of the High Court, set aside – Further directions issued – Appointments already made under the first advertisement (for Post Code 447) not to be disturbed – Constitution of India – Articles 14, 16 – Service Law – Appointment/Recruitment/ Selection. [Paras 26, 27, 30, 35, 38, 39, 45]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Rakesh Kumar Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi) & Ors. (2013) 11 SCC 58; Bedanga Talukdar v. Saifudaullah Khan [2011] 11 SCR 635 : (2011) 12 SCC 85 – relied on.
Sanjay K. Dixit v. State of U.P (2019) 17 SCC 373; Mukul Kumar Tyagi v. State of U.P [2019] 16 SCR 1145 : (2020) 4 SCC 86; Krishna Rai v. Banaras Hindu University (2022) 8 SCC 713; Union of India v. Somasundaram Viswanath & Ors. (1989) 1 SCC 175; P.D. Aggarwal & Ors. v. State of U.P. & Ors. [1987] 3 SCR 427 : (1987) 3 SCC 622; Dhananjay Malik v. State of Uttaranchal [2008] 3 SCR 1035 : (2008) 4 SCC 171; State of Gujarat v. Arvindkumar T. Tiwari [2012] 7 SCR 1072 : (2012) 9 SCC 545; Maharashtra Public Service Commission v. Sandeep Sudhakarrao Lavhekar [2019] 7 SCR 94 : (2019) 6 SCC 362; State of M.P. v. Raghuveer Singh Yadav (1994) 6 SCC 151; Zahoor Ahmad Rather & Ors. v. Sheikh Imtiyaz Ahmad & Ors. [2018] 14 SCR 1082 : (2019) 2 SCC 404; Mohammad Shujat Ali & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors. [1975] 1 SCR 449 : (1975) 3 SCC 76; Bank of India v. Aarya K. Babu [2019] 11 SCR 627 : (2019) 8 SCC 587; Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India (1991) 3 SCC 47 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 7602 of 2023. From the Judgment and Order dated 31.12.2021 of the High Court of Himachal Pradesh at Shimla in LPA No. 43 of 2021.
With Civil Appeal Nos.7603, 7604, 7605 and 7606 of 2023.
Appearances:
Ms. Kaveeta Wadia, Ms. Astha Sharma, Srisatya Mohanty, Ms. Anju Thomas, Sanjeev Kaushik, Ms. Mantika Haryani, Shreyas Awasthi, Himanshu Chakravarty, Ms. Ripul Swati Kumari, Ms. Sruthi Venugopal, Bhanu Mishra, Devvrat Singh, Ms. Muskan Surana, Ms. Vandana Sehgal, Ms. Nidhi Mohan Parashar, Vikrant Kumar, Ms. Shruti Venugopal, Advs. for the Appellants.
ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION
COMMISSION & ORS.
816 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
Abhinav Mukerji, A.A.G., Anup Kumar Rattan, Advocate General, J.S. Attri, Sr. Adv., Abhinav Mukerji, Puneet Rajta, Akshay C. Shrivastava, Mrs. Bihu Sharma, Ms. Pratishtha Vij, Vinod Sharma, Vivek Narayan Sharma, Mrs. Mahima Bhardwaj, Ms. Laksha Bhavnani, Shubham Awasthi, Sudhanshu Khandelwal, Rajeev Kumar Jha, Rohit Sharma, Ram Kumar, Rameshwar Prasad Goyal, Vikas Kumar Singh, Tarun Gupta, Anmol Mishra, Atul Kumar, Abhishek Sharma, Yatinder Chaudhary, Davinder Singh Khurana, Manoj Rajpoot, Vikrant, Ms. Rajani Ohri Lal, Himinder Lal, Yaduinder Lal, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
MANOJ MISRA, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. All these appeals are directed against a common judgment and order1 of the High Court2 disposing of a batch of writ petitions as well as intra-court appeals concerning recruitment on the post of Junior Office Assistant3, a Class III (Non-gazetted) post, under the Government of Himachal Pradesh4. There being a commonality of law and facts concerning these appeals, they are being decided by a common judgment.
Factual Matrix
3. As these appeals arise from multiple proceedings, a disclosure of relevant facts in a chronological order would be apposite. These facts are set out below:
(A) On 24.12.2014, Himachal Pradesh, Department of Personnel, Junior Office Assistant (Information Technology), Class-III, (Non-Gazetted), Ministerial Services, Common Recruitment and Promotion Rules, 20145, framed under the proviso to Article 309 of 1 Order dated 31.12.2021 2 High Court of Himachal Pradesh
3 JOA
4 Govt.
5 2014 Rules the Constitution of India6, were notified with a view to have common recruitment and promotion rules for the post of JOA in various departments of the Government. Relevant provisions of the 2014 Rules are detailed below:
(1) Rule 7 prescribed qualifications for the post of JOA as follows:
“(a) Essential Qualification:
(i) 10 + 2 from a recognized Board of School Education/University,
(ii) One year diploma in Computer Science/ Computer Application/ Information Technology from a recognized University/Institution and
(iii) Computer typing speed of 30 words per minute in English or 25 words per minute in Hindi OR
(i) 10 + 2 from a recognized Board or School Education/University.
(ii) ‘O’ or ‘A’ level Diploma from National Institute of Electronics & Information Technology (NIELIT)
(iii) Computer typing speed of 30 words per minute in English or 25 words per minute in Hindi OR
(i) 10 + 2 from a recognized Board or School Education/University.
(ii) Diploma in Information Technology (IT) from a recognized ITI/Institution.
(iii) Computer typing speed of 30 words per minute in English or 25 words per minute in Hindi 6 Constitution ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS. [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 818 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
(b) Desirable Qualification(s):
Knowledge of customs, manners and dialects of Himachal Pradesh and suitability for appointment in the peculiar conditions prevailing in the Pradesh.”
(2) Rule 15 prescribed the mode of selection for appointment to the post by direct recruitment as follows:
“Rule 15. Selection for appointment to the post by direct recruitment – Selection for appointment to the post in the case of direct recruitment shall be made on the basis of viva-voce test, if Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission or other recruiting authority, as the case may be, so consider necessary or expedient by a written test or practical test, the standard/ syllabus, etc. of which will be determined by the Commission or other recruiting authority, as the case may be.”
(3) Rule 18 conferred power on the State Govt. to relax any of the provisions of the Rules in following terms:
“Rule 18. Power to Relax – Where the State Govt. is of the opinion that it is necessary or expedient to do so, it may, by order for reasons to be recorded in writing and in consultation with the Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission, relax any of the provision (s) of these rules with respect to any class or category of person (s) or post(s).”
(B) On 13.02.2015, Himachal Pradesh Subordinate Services Selection Board7 vide Advertisement No. 30 of 2015 invited applications for selection / appointment on 1421 post (s) of JOA (Post Code 447) prescribing same qualifications as in Rule 7 of the 2014 Rules. The last date for submission of application was 18.03.2015. However, for residents of certain districts, it was 02.04.2015. But the date(s) were 7 Selection Board extended up to 31.10.2015. Clause 4 of the general conditions in the advertisement specifically provided that, “the candidate must fulfil / possess all the required essential educational and other qualifications mentioned against each code on or before the last date fixed for the receipt of application forms, otherwise the candidature will be rejected at the time of Personal Interview.”
(C) As large number of applicants had done their computer course from Private Institutes, the Principal Secretary (Education) to the Govt. was requested to inform:
(i) whether a candidate could be considered eligible if he has certificate / diploma from any registered Institute, whether operating within or outside the State;
(ii) the name(s) / list of registered / recognized institutes whose diplomas / certificates could be considered valid for determining eligibility for the post.
(D) In response to the above, on December 2, 2015, the Additional Chief Secretary (Personnel) to the Govt. wrote a letter to the Selection Board stating:
“It is informed that the provisions of the Rules regarding essential qualifications are crystal clear which provides that Diploma in Computer Science, Computer Application, Information Technology from a recognized University/ Institution/ITI OR “O” Or “A” level diploma from National Institute of Electronics and Information Technology (NIELIT) only are required and the question of registered/ unregistered institution does not arise. As regard the information on point-II, the clarification can be obtained by you from the Education Department or IT Department.”
(E) The above stand was reiterated in letter dated February 25, 2016. However, as list of registered / recognized institutes, whose diplomas / certificates were valid / recognized for determining eligibility to the post, was not available, the Commission wrote a letter to the Director of Higher Education, Himachal Pradesh, marking its copies to Additional Chief Secretary (Education), Govt., Director IT, Govt. and Secretary, ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS. [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 820 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
H.P. Board of School Education, Dharamshala, for a list of recognized institutions / institutes.
(F) Pursuant to the correspondences above, the Directorate of Higher Education, Himachal Pradesh, Shimla, vide letter dated 27.05.2017, provided a list of institutions recognized by Himachal Pradesh Takniki Shiksha Board8, Dharamshala, District Kangra, Himachal Pradesh.
(G) In between, candidature of several candidates was rejected for not possessing essential qualifications as prescribed by the 2014 Rules. Aggrieved by rejection of their candidature, some of these candidates preferred Original Applications9 (for short O.A.) before the Tribunal10, wherein an interim order was passed on 30.06.2017. The operative portion of which is extracted below:
“All the applicants are 10+2. However, the nomenclatures of the one-year diploma held by them in Computer is not in consonance with the nomenclature of the diploma mentioned in the aforesaid education qualifications.
However, prima facie, it is made out that they are holding one year diploma in computer. In such circumstances, there shall be a direction in the interim to the Respondent Commission to permit the applicants, who admittedly have already appeared in the written/Typing Test, to appear in the interview, provisionally. However, their result shall not be declared and instead kept in a sealed cover till the matter with regard to equivalence of the diploma held by them with the diploma required as per the aforesaid educational qualifications is considered and decided by the newly added Respondent No.2- State, which shall be done as expeditiously as possible but within the reasonable time frame.”
8 Takniki Board 9 O.A. Nos.2830, 2989, 2994, 2998, 3009 and 3026 of 2017 10 Himachal Pradesh State Administrative Tribunal (H) In deference to the above order, the Commission sought directions / clarifications / guidance from the Govt., inter alia, on the following issues:
(1) Whether the diplomas possessed by those applicants equivalent to the diploma required by the Rules.
(2) Whether diploma / certificate obtained from private Institutes, regarding which there was no information about their recognition, could be considered as one from a recognized University / Institute.
(I) Pursuant to that, the Commission was informed about the Govt.’s decision dated 21.08.2017, which was in the following terms: “(1) All such candidates having one year Diploma in Computer or higher qualification in Computer Science/ Application/IT from any private Institution like from Society under Societies Act, Rashtriya Saksharta Mission IT programme/Skill Development Programme etc. be considered for final selection subject to having successfully passed their skill test i.e. Typing Test on Computer and after having obtained their undertaking/ declaration certifying that they had attended the classes/ diploma course by attending the classes regularly.
(2) That the Computer Science is not limited to the specific nomenclature of Diploma prescribed in the R&P Rules, as such, the Diploma in Computer and other Higher Qualifications belonging to Computer Science/ application irrespective of their nomenclature be also considered for final selection subject to having successfully passed their skill test i.e. Typing Test on Computer and after having their undertaking/declaration certifying that they had attended the classes/diploma course by attending the classes regularly. There may be instance where certificates are issued instead of diploma, in such cases, the Commission is to ascertain and ensure that subjects studied are at par with one year Diploma course in Computer Science/ Application/lT.
ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS. [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 822 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
(3) The date of personal interview of the candidate concerned in the instant case be treated as valid date for evaluation/ consideration/ acceptance of his/ her diploma/ essential qualification.
(4) With regard to educational qualification, as informed during the meeting, the Commission has sought clarification of equivalence in some cases from the concerned authorities, therefore, the Commission need to proceed further in accordance with the clarification/ decision obtained from the State Level Board of Equivalence Committee / H.P.
Board of School Education by accepting the qualification of such candidate(s) for his job if that is found equivalent to 10+2 and valid for pursuing higher studies.”
(J) As a result of the above decision, many candidates who, as per the 2014 Rules, were not eligible, came within the zone of consideration and as such included in the select list, resulting in ouster of such candidates who, though lower on merit, were otherwise eligible as per the 2014 Rules. Therefore, some of those ousted candidates laid a challenge to the merit list before the Tribunal through O.A. No. 5543 of 2017 which, consequent to abolition of the Tribunal, came to be transferred to the High Court and was registered as Writ Petition No. 34 of 2019. Notably, though O.A. No. 5543 of 2017 was filed after declaration of the final select list, only three or four selected candidates were initially impleaded as opposite parties.
(K) While the recruitment / selection exercise under the Advertisement dated 13.02.2015 was ongoing, a fresh Advertisement No. 32-3/2016, dated 18.10.2016, was issued by the Commission inviting applications for another set of 1156 posts of JOA (IT) (Post Code 556) with the same qualifications as prescribed in the 2014 Rules.
(L) At this stage, it would be relevant to point out that, broadly, two sets of cases cropped up from the recruitment exercise for Post Code 447, namely,
(i) O.A. Nos. 2830; 2989; 2994; 2998; 3009; and 3026 of 2017, which came to be renumbered as Writ Petition Nos. 2253; 2289; 2290; 2388; 2394; and 7681 of 2020 before the High Court after abolition of the Tribunal. These cases were at the instance of candidates whose candidature was rejected for not possessing qualifications as prescribed by the 2014 Rules.
(ii) O.A. No. 5543 of 2017, filed on 13.10.2017, which, upon transfer to the High Court, came to be registered as Writ Petition No. 34 of 2019 before the High Court. This was by those candidates who were not placed in the select list. Their claim was that the relaxation order dated 21.08.2017 resulted in inclusion of ineligible candidates and, therefore, they were ousted from the merit list. In this O.A. No. 5543 of 2017), the relief(s) sought were:
(i) That clarification dated 21.08.2017 and Office Order dated 18.09.2017 be quashed and set aside; and
(ii) That Commission be directed to prepare a merit list from amongst those candidates who possess essential and minimum qualification as mentioned in Advertisement No.
30 of 2015, dated 13.02.2015, and make recommendation accordingly.
(M) As in between, another Advertisement (i.e., for Post Code 556) was issued, the State Government vide letter dated 19.03.2018 directed the Commission to apply the clarification issued on 21.08.2017 for Post Code 556 as well. The relevant portion of the letter dated 19.03.2018 is extracted below:
“l am directed to refer to your letters No. HPSSC-C(2)-970/16 dated 01-01-2018 & 16-02-2018 on the subject cited above and to say that since the posts of Junior Office Assistant (IT), Class-III (Non-Gazetted) have been advertised under different post codes i.e., Post Code 447 and 556 but are to be filled up under one set of common Recruitment & Promotion Rules for the post and as such carry one or similar cadre, it has been decided that the clarification dated 21-08-2017, issued by this department on the directions of Hon’ble Himachal Pradesh Administrative Tribunal in respect of ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS. [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 824 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
Post Code 447, be also implemented in the on-going process under Post Code 556, being recruitment for the same post with similar provisions of rules. However, the clarification/ instructions dated 21-08-2017 are under challenge before the Hon’ble Court, as such, its implementation will be subject to final outcome of Hon’ble Court orders so passed in case of post code 447 in the pending matters.”
(N) The above decision of the State Government gave rise to another set of litigation (i.e., Writ Petition No. 7585 of 2019) filed by candidates desirous of selection strictly as per the 2014 Rules. Whereas candidates who sought benefit of the relaxation directed vide letter dated 19.03.2018 filed another set of petitions. This latter bunch of petitions were allowed by a Single Judge Bench of the High Court. Against which, the Commission preferred an intra-court appeal before a Division Bench of the High Court.
(O) At this stage, it be clarified that despite request to apply the relaxation accorded for Post Code 447 on Post Code 556 as well, the select list for Post Code 556 was prepared strictly in accordance with the 2014 Rules, because in O.A. No. 2644 of 2018, which later came to be registered as Writ Petition No. 7585 of 2019, the Tribunal, vide order dated 16.08.2018, had allowed declaration of results in the following terms:
“In the facts and circumstances, materials on record and interest of justice, subject to keeping fifteen posts of Junior Office Assistant vacant for the applicants and final outcome of the original application, respondent no. 3-Commission shall be free to declare the result of the process for recruitment to the post of Junior Office Assistants.”
The above order was assailed before the High Court through Writ Petition No. 1964 of 2018, which was disposed of vide order dated 28.08.2018 in the following terms:
“In this background we clarify that the appointments to the posts of Junior Office Assistant (Code 556) shall be strictly in accordance with the Common Recruitment & Promotion Rules for the posts of Junior Office Assistant (Information Technology), Class-Ill (Non-gazetted) in various Departments of Himachal Pradesh Government, as also Advertisement No. 32-3/2016 and not in terms of communication, dated 19th March 2018.”
A review of the order dated 28.08.2018 was sought, which was decided on 05.11.2018 in the following terms:
“Be that as it may, as the matter is sub judice before the learned Tribunal and the Committee which has submitted its report on 21.08.2017, has been so constituted by the learned Tribunal, its recommendations, can be looked into by the learned Tribunal uninfluenced by any observation made by this Court in the perspective of the Common Recruitment & Promotion Rules, in the backdrop of the controversy involved in the application before it.”
(P) In between, another O. A. No. 7397 of 2018 was filed before the Tribunal praying that persons holding qualifications other than the one prescribed be not considered for selection. On this application, an order dated 21.12.2018 was passed requiring the Commission to make selections against Post Code 556 strictly as per 2014 Rules. (Q) The order of the Tribunal dated 21.12.2018 was challenged before the High Court in Writ Petition No. 161 of 2019. Therein, on 11.01.2019, an interim order was passed in the following terms: “Meanwhile the operation of the impugned order dated 21.12.2018 (Annexure P-7) passed by Himachal Pradesh Administrative Tribunal in O.A. No. 7397 of 2018 shall remain stayed. However, the Staff Selection Commission shall only allow the eligible candidates to participate in the process.”
(R) In the light of various interim orders, after carrying out the selection process, the Commission declared result of Post Code 556 on 23.02.2019 thereby recommending 596 candidates only. While doing so, candidature of several candidates, who were found ineligible under the 2014 Rules, was rejected.
ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS. [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 826 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
(S) The candidates who were rejected as ineligible approached the Tribunal. On 26.02.2019, the Tribunal, in O.A. No. 677 of 2019 (later registered as Writ Petition No. 20 of 2019), directed status quo with regard to appointments pursuant to the declared result for Post Code 556.
(T) Aggrieved by the order of the Tribunal dated 26.02.2019, a group of selected candidates filed Writ Petition No. 629 of 2019 before the High Court. On 29.08.2019, Writ Petition Nos. 161 of 2019 and 629 of 2019 were finally decided, whereby Writ Petition No. 161 of 2019, filed by candidates claiming to possess qualifications higher than prescribed, was dismissed; and Writ Petition No. 629 of 2019 filed against the interim order dated 26.02.2019 was allowed.
(U) The order dated 29.08.2019 passed in Writ Petition Nos. 161 of 2019 and 629 of 2019 was subjected to a Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 45 of 2021, which was dismissed by this Court vide order dated 15.11.2021. In these circumstances, selection / recruitment for Post Code 556, under the Advertisement dated 18.10.2016, was carried out strictly in accordance with the 2014 Rules. And 531 posts advertised for Post Code 556 remained unfilled.
(V) There was another petition, namely, writ Petition No.2246 of 2019, filed by candidates who were excluded from consideration though they held equivalent qualifications for Post Code 556. Here, an interim order was passed directing that any appointment against Post Code 556 shall be subject to the orders passed in that petition.
(W) On 06.12.2019, the State Government directed the Commission to treat the recruitment process for Post Code 556 concluded. It also requested the Commission to re-advertise the unfilled posts and carry out recruitment as per new Common Recruitment & Promotion Rules of the year 2020, which prescribed the essential qualifications as follows:
“(a) ESSENTIAL QUALIFICATION(S):
(i) Should have passed 10+2 from a recognized Board of School Education /University.
OR Matriculation from recognized Board of School Education with one/two year’s Diploma/Certificate from an Industrial Training Institute (ITI) in Information Technology Enabled Sectors (ITES) as notified by Director General of Employment & Training (Govt. of India) from time to time or three years Diploma in Computer Engineering / Computer Science/ IT from Polytechnic as approved by All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE).”
(X) Pursuant thereto, on 21.09.2020, a fresh advertisement No. 36- 2/2020 was issued by the Commission inviting applications for the post of Junior Office Assistant-JOA (IT) (Post Code 817).
(Y) On issuance of fresh advertisement, in Writ Petition No. 2246 of 2019, following interim order was passed:
“Pursuant to Advertisement No. 36-2/2020 dated 21.09.2020, issued by respondent-HPSSC for the post of Junior Office Assistant-JOA (IT), the respondent-Himachal Pradesh Staff Selection Commission, Hamirpur is permitted to proceed with the recruitment process, however, the final result shall not be announced without permission of this Court. Applications stand disposed of.”
Summary of the Litigation before the High Court
4. A conspectus of the narration above would indicate that litigation emanated from three successive advertisements issued by the Selection Board/ Commission inviting applications for the post of JOA (IT). The first advertisement is dated 13.02.2015 for 1421 posts (i.e., Post Code 447). The second is dated 18.10.2016 for 1156 posts (i.e., Post Code 556); and the third is dated 21.09.2020 for 1869 posts (i.e., Post Code 817).
5. Under the first advertisement for Post Code 447, the advertised posts were filled with the aid of the order dated 21.08.2017, which relaxed the advertised eligibility conditions. The litigation therein was initiated by two sets of candidates. One set comprised of those whose candidature got rejected because they failed to meet the eligibility criteria prescribed in the advertisement and the 2014 Rules. The other set comprised of those candidates who were aggrieved by relaxation of the eligibility criteria as it expanded the ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS. [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 828 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
zone of consideration and thereby reduced their chance of selection. They, therefore, questioned the validity of the order of relaxation dated 21.08.2017 as also the selection made thereunder. The challenge laid by them was to the effect that once the 2014 Rules prescribed the essential qualifications, and the advertisement prescribed the same essential qualifications without reserving any power to relax the same at any later stage, how could there be a relaxation of these prescribed essential qualifications. Their prayer, therefore, was that the select list must comprise of only such candidates who hold the prescribed minimum eligibility qualifications by the last date for receipt of the application under the advertisement. Such a challenge was laid through Writ Petition No. 34 of 2019, which was originally filed before the Tribunal as O.A. No. 5543 of 2017.
6. In respect of recruitment against the second advertisement for Post Code 556, challenge was laid by those who either held qualifications at variance from the one prescribed, or had certificate(s) / diploma(s) from such institutes that were not considered recognized. Their challenge was premised on the relaxation granted earlier in connection with the exercise under the first advertisement for Post Code 447. Their case was that once relaxation to the eligibility conditions prescribed in the 2014 Rules was allowed qua the first advertisement, the recruitment to the same post, advertised as Post Code 556, under the same set of Rules, must be subject to same relaxation. These candidates, therefore, challenged rejection of their candidature and prayed that the merit-list be re-drawn by treating their candidature as valid.
7. In respect of the third advertisement dated 21.09.2020, the challenge was confined to 531 posts that were carried forward as unfilled vacancies notified under the second advertisement for Post Code 556. In this category of cases, the claim was that vacant posts of JOA, advertised as Post Code 556, should not have been left unfilled as eligible candidates were available had the benefit of the relaxation been provided. They, therefore, claimed that those carry forward posts, now advertised as Post Code 817, be segregated and filled as part of the second advertisement by taking into consideration those candidates who would be eligible by virtue of the relaxation.
Findings / Observations of the High Court in the impugned judgment
8. The High Court found / held / observed:
(i) The essential qualifications prescribed in the 2014 Rules as “one year diploma in Computer Science / Computer Application / Information Technology from a recognized University / Institution” is ambiguous and creates confusion, firstly, because expression “recognized University / Institution” is not defined, and, secondly, diploma qualification may be held under different nomenclatures. The High Court held that though there could be no dispute regarding a recognized University but as regards the authority competent to recognize an institution to award a diploma, there is no clarity. Therefore, the decision to relax the essential qualifications dated 21.08.2017 was within the powers of the State Government conferred by Rule 18 of the 2014 Rules. Hence, it was rightly applied on the recruitment exercise carried out under the first advertisement dated 13.02.2015.
(ii) Computer Science / Information Technology are subjects of wide amplitude and are admissible to differing nomenclatures and cannot be restricted to the one found in the 2014 Rules / Advertisement. Thus, in absence of any clarity as to the kind of curricula required to obtain the required diploma / certificate to become eligible, the decision of the State Government dated 21.08.2017 cannot be faulted, particularly, when there is no clarity as to the authority competent to accord recognition. While holding so, the High Court took note of the essential qualifications prescribed in the 2020 Rules for the post of JOA (IT), which were more specific as regards the authority competent to recognize.
(iii) Advent of computerization and wide use of information technology has caused a sense of urgency for appointment(s) on the posts advertised across various departments of the State Government. This is reflected by successive advertisements for the posts. In that scenario, to meet the exigency, if an exercise to constitute an equivalence committee was undertaken pursuant to a judicial order of the Tribunal dated 30.06.2017, which was not ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS. [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 830 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
assailed by any of the writ petitioners, departure, if any, from the 2014 Rules cannot be faulted. Otherwise also, where rules are ambiguous, and it may take time to amend the rules, relaxation and clarifications are permissible as part of administrative exigency.
(iv) There is nothing on record to infer that action of the State Government / HPSSC was actuated by extraneous consideration(s) or lack of bona fide(s).
(v) The petitioners could not substantiate that anyone or more of the selected persons obtained the requisite qualifications after the cut-off date.
Impugned Decision of the High Court
9. In light of the findings / observations noticed above, the High Court dismissed Writ Petition No. 34 of 2019 which questioned the relaxation order; and upheld the process of selection and appointment against Post Code 447. Consequent to the dismissal of Writ Petition No. 34 of 2019, other writ petitions, namely, numbered 2253, 2289, 2290, 2388, 2394 and 7681 of 2020, which were filed for consideration of candidates who benefited from the relaxation order, were dismissed as infructuous.
10. Writ petitions seeking relaxation in the eligibility conditions for the second advertisement (i.e., for Post Code 556) in terms provided for Post Code 447, were disposed of by directing that same relaxation be accorded for Post Code 556 as accorded for Post Code 447. In consequence, the High Court, in paragraphs 33 and 34 of the impugned judgment, directed: “33. Thus, the HPSSC is directed to re-cast the merit list for JOA 556 by including all categories of candidate as was done for JOA 447 on the basis of decision of Government dated 21.8.2017/ 18.9.2017 and further made applicable to JOA 556 vide communication 19.3.2018 except the candidates with higher qualification, who have already been held ineligible vide judgment dated 29.8.2019 of a Division Bench of this Court in CWP 161/2019. These selections for JOA 556 shall be made by taking into account the entire number of vacancies advertised for JOA 556 and the decision of the Government/HPSSC to close the selection procedure for JOA 556 is set aside and quashed.
34. Since the Common R&P Rules stand amended by 2020 Rules and the cause of persistent confusion for the time being appears to have been removed, as a necessary consequence selection for JOA 817 shall take place in accordance with 2020 Rules, however, the selection process shall not include the selection for posts which were left over from advertised posts of JOA 556 as the said posts have already been directed to be filled through selection process of JOA 556.”
11. The resultant effect of the above directions would be that for recruitment against Post Code 556, candidates who, but for the relaxation dated 21.08.2017, were ineligible under the 2014 Rules, were to be treated eligible and the merit list redrawn accordingly. Not only that, 531 posts of Post Code 556, which remained unfilled, and, therefore, carried forward, and re-advertised on 21.09.2020, were to be segregated and filled in terms of the direction above. In consequence, the number of posts advertised under the advertisement dated 21.09.2020 were to get reduced to that extent. However, as per the decision of the High Court, the candidates who professed holding qualifications higher than the one prescribed were not to get any benefit as that issue already stood concluded vide judgment and order of the High Court dated 29.08.2019, passed in Writ Petition No.161 of 2019, against which SLP (C) No.45 of 2021 was dismissed by this Court.
Appeals Before This Court
12. (A) Arising out of SLP (C) No. 730 of 2022:
This appeal questions the direction given in paragraph 33 of the impugned judgment. The appellants herein claim that they hold the requisite eligibility qualifications prescribed by the 2014 Rules as well as the advertisement; they participated in the recruitment exercise for Post Code 556 and were placed in the merit-list; if candidates who were otherwise not eligible, but for the relaxation, are permitted to be considered, as directed in paragraph 33, the merit-list might have to be re-drawn and they may be ousted and replaced by those who, otherwise, were ineligible. These appellants have, therefore, prayed that the direction given by the High Court in paragraph 33 of the impugned judgment be quashed and the earlier merit-list be not disturbed.
ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS. [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 832 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
In this appeal, intervention / impleadment application(s) (i.e., I.A. Nos. 30862 of 2022; 26627 of 2022; and 73507 of 2022) have been filed by such candidates who were to benefit by the direction given in paragraph 33 of the impugned judgment.
Another I.A. No 14524 of 2022 has been filed for impleading parties who had put in appearance through various intervention applications. Yet another I.A. No. 5062 of 2022 has been filed to bring on record:
(a) a copy of letter issued by the Director of Higher Education, Govt. of Himachal Pradesh;
(b) copy of the order of the High Court dated 29.08.2019 passed in Writ Petition Nos. 629 of 2019 and 161 of 2019; and
(c) copy of the order dated 15.11.2021 passed by this Court in SLP (C) No. 45 of 2021 whereby Special Leave Petition preferred against the order of the High Court dated 29.08.2019 was dismissed.
(B) Arising out of SLP (C) No. 729 of 2022:
This appeal is also at the instance of those candidates who were considered and selected under the second advertisement for Post Code
556. They are, therefore, similarly aggrieved as the appellants of appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 730 of 2022.
In this appeal, too, an Impleadment Application No. 15047 of 2022 has been filed to bring on record parties who had put in appearance through various intervention applications.
(C) Arising out of SLP (C) No. 4321 of 2022:
This appeal is by the writ petitioners of Writ Petition No. 34 of 2019 before the High Court. They are aggrieved by dismissal of their writ petition which sought:
(a) quashing of the relaxation order dated 21.08.2017; and
(b) a direction upon HPSSC to prepare the merit-list by including only those candidates who possess essential minimum qualifications as specified in advertisement No. 30 of 2015 dated 13.02.2015.
Appellants herein are those candidates who failed to find their name in the select list prepared after the recruitment exercise under the first advertisement for Post Code 447.
In this appeal, I.A. No. 56457 of 2022 has been filed for bringing on record copy of the order dated 29th March 2022 passed by the High Court in Writ Petition No. 113 of 2019 whereby the said writ petition was dismissed by a Single Bench of the High Court.
Another I.A. No. 100627 of 2022 has been filed by a bunch of candidates who claim to have possessed qualifications higher than the one specified in the Advertisement for Post Code 447. According to them, they hold Degree instead of Diploma and Degree being higher than Diploma, they were eligible.
Yet another I.A. No. 188852 of 2022 has been filed to bring on record:
(i) An RTI query report dated 02.07.2022. This is to the effect that the relaxation order dated 21.08.2017 was not published in any Newspaper, E-Gazette or Official website; and
(ii) A chart containing reasons as to why some of the selected candidates were not qualified/ eligible for consideration against Post Code 447. Note: It is not clear whether this chart was ever placed before the High Court.
(D) Arising out of SLP (C) No. 9977 of 2022:
This appeal is by those candidates who participated under the second advertisement and got selected for appointment against Post Code 556. They are aggrieved by the direction contained in paragraph 33 of the impugned judgment. They apprehend that if the merit-list is re-drawn by including those who were otherwise ineligible under the 2014 Rules, they may go out of the merit-list. Their case is thus identical to the appellants in the appeal arising out of SLP (C) No. 730 of 2022.
In this appeal, I.A. No. 77624 of 2022 has been filed to bring on record an application filed by one of the candidates under the advertisement for Post Code 556 to initiate contempt proceeding against the State for noncompliance of the directions contained in the impugned judgment of the High Court.
ANKITA THAKUR & ORS. v. THE H.P. STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION & ORS. [MANOJ MISRA, J.] 834 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
(E) Arising out of SLP (C) No. 17676 of 2022:
This appeal is by those who have applied under the third advertisement dated 21.09.2020 qua Code 817. Their grievance is that if the direction given in paragraphs 33 and 34 of impugned judgment is implemented, the number of posts advertised would get reduced thereby affecting their chances of selection.
Interim Orders passed during pendency of the proceedings:
13. In Special Leave Petition (C) No. 730 of 2022, on 12.01.2022, an interim order was passed putting in abeyance the direction contained in paragraph 33 of the impugned judgment. Likewise, in SLP (C) No. 17676 of 2022, an interim order was passed on 30.09.2022 putting in abeyance the direction contained in paragraph 34 of the impugned judgment.
14. We have heard learned counsel for the appellants; the learned counsel for the respondents / Intervenors and the Advocate General of the State of Himachal Pradesh, who appeared for the State and the Commission. Submissions on behalf of Appellants
15. Ms. Kaveeta Wadia, who led the arguments on behalf of the appellants in appeals arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 730 of 2022, 729 of 2022 and 9977 of 2022, inter alia, submitted:
(i) The first and second advertisements (i.e., dated 13.02.2015 and 18.10.2016) were issued during currency of the 2014 Rules. The 2014 Rules prescribed eligibility qualifications in unequivocal terms and the advertisements specified the same qualifications with a clear stipulation that candidates applying thereunder must hold the requisite qualifications by the last date for receipt of the application. The last date for receipt of application under the first advertisement was 31.10.2015, and under the second advertisement it was 17.11.2016. Both the advertisements did not reserve the power to relax the eligibility criteria at any later stage. In these circumstances, the relaxation accorded on 21.08.2017, after the last date for receipt of the applications, was illegal.
(ii) The High Court erred in observing that relaxation was necessitated because, (a) there could be confusion as to the true import of the expression “recognized University / Institution” and (b) there could be institutions conducting the same course under a different nomenclature. These observations of the High Court were in ignorance of the statutory regime in place since 1986 vide Himachal Pradesh Takniki Shiksha Board Act, 198611 and the Regulations framed thereunder, set out below:
Section 2 of the 1986 Act provides:
“In this Act, unless the context otherwise requires,-
(a) “affiliated institution” means an institution affiliated to the Board in respect of any course or courses of study in accordance with the provisions of the Act or regulations made thereunder;
(b) “Board” means the Himachal Pradesh Takniki Shiksha Board established under section 3…………….;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.