Dilip B Jiwrajka v. Union of India & Ors
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 1018; [2023] 16 S.C.R. 562
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice 2016. Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code
- Decided
- 9 Nov 2023
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 1281/2021
- Sections
- 97, 97(5), 99(4), 100, 96, 99, 94, 95, 14, 14(1), 99(2), 1(3)
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 16 S.C.R. 562 : 2023 INSC 1018
CASE DETAILS
DILIP B JIWRAJKA
v.
UNION OF INDIA & ORS
(Writ Petition (Civil) No 1281 of 2021)
NOVEMBER 09, 2023
[DR. DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI, J B PARDIWALA AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: Constitutional validity of ss.95 to 100 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016.
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – ss.95 to 100 – Constitutional validity – Challenge to:
Held: Provisions of ss.95 to 100 are not unconstitutional as they do not violate Articles 14 and 21– No judicial adjudication is involved at the stages envisaged in ss.95 to 99 – The resolution professional appointed u/s.97 serves a facilitative role of collating all the facts relevant to the examination of the application for the commencement of the insolvency resolution process preferred u/ss.94 or 95 – The report to be submitted to the adjudicatory authority is recommendatory in nature on whether to accept or reject the application – Further, the submission that a hearing should be conducted by the adjudicatory authority for the purpose of determining ‘jurisdictional facts’ at the stage when it appoints a resolution professional u/s.97(5), rejected – No such adjudicatory function is contemplated at that stage – The adjudicatory decision-making process of the nature suggested by the petitioners would not be implicated u/s.97(5) – To accept the submission of the petitioners would render the provisions of ss.99 and 100 otiose – The resolution professional may exercise the powers vested u/s.99(4) for the purpose of examining the application for insolvency resolution and to seek information on matters relevant to the application in order to facilitate the submission of the report recommending the acceptance or rejection of the application – There is no violation of natural justice u/ss.95 to 100 – No judicial determination takes place until the adjudicating authority decides u/s.100 whether to accept or reject the application – The report of the resolution professional is only recommendatory in nature and hence, does not bind the adjudicatory authority when it exercises its jurisdiction u/s.100 – The adjudicatory authority must observe the principles of natural justice when it exercises jurisdiction u/s.100 for determining whether to accept or reject the application – The purpose of the interim-moratorium u/s.96 is to protect the debtor from further legal proceedings – Principles of Natural Justice – Constitution of India – Article 14, 21 – Interpretation of Statutes – Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Professionals) Regulations, 2016 – Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules 2019. [Paras 82, 86] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – s.99 – Submission of report by resolution professional – Role ascribed to the resolution professional:
Held: The resolution professional does not possess an adjudicatory function in terms of the provisions of s.99 – In Chapter III of Part III, the legislature has dealt with the resolution of individual or partnership insolvencies and bankruptcies – Therefore, the legislature considered it appropriate to interpose the resolution professional before the adjudicatory function of the adjudicating authority commences u/s.100 – The resolution professional does not have the kind of power which their counterpart has in Part II – The role u/s.99 which is ascribed to the resolution professional is that of a facilitator and is to gather relevant information on the basis of the application submitted u/s.94 or s.95 and after carrying out the process which is referred to in sub-section (2), sub-section (4) and sub-section (6) of s.99, to submit a report recommending the acceptance or rejection of the application – The use of expressions “examine the application”, “ascertain” and “satisfies the requirements” and “recommend” the acceptance or rejection of the application, leaves no manner of doubt that the resolution professional is not intended to perform an adjudicatory function or to arrive at binding conclusions on facts – The role of the resolution professional is purely recommendatory in nature and cannot bind the creditor, the debtor or, the adjudicating authority. [Para 54] DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS 564 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Role of the adjudicating authority in applications under Part II and Part III:
Held: Bearing in mind the clear differences between the CIRP under Part II and insolvency resolution process for individuals and partnership under Part III, the legislature has carefully calibrated the role of the resolution professional; the imposition of the moratorium; and the stage at which the adjudicating authority steps in under Part II, on one hand, and Part III, on the other – This is based on an intelligible differentia between the nature of the insolvency resolution process in the case of a corporate debtor, on one hand, and individuals or partnerships, on the other. [Paras 60, 61] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – s.99 – Process before the resolution professional, if ex parte:
Held: No – The provisions of s.99 leave no manner of doubt that the process which takes place before the resolution professional is not an ex parte process in the absence of a debtor against whom the insolvency resolution process is sought to be initiated – Though, the ultimate report of the resolution professional has only a recommendatory value, the legislature has ensured that the recommendation is made after taking into account the information or, as the case may be, the explanation that is furnished by the debtor – Thus, it cannot be said that there is any element of bias in a report submitted by an RP who is nominated by the creditor. [Para 67] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Professionals) Regulations, 2016 r/w para 21 of the First Schedule – Plea of the petitioners that the resolution professional is empowered to direct the personal guarantor and others to disclose sensitive personal information without a prior hearing and this demand for information, lacking an opportunity for the personal guarantor to be heard, raises concerns about violating the right to privacy:
Held: The resolution professional is only entitled to seek information strictly relevant to the examination of the application for IRP – Further, regulation 7(2)(h) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (Insolvency Professionals) Regulations, 2016 r/w para 21 of the First Schedule, casts an obligation on the resolution professional to ensure confidentiality of all information relating to the insolvency process – The BLRC also acknowledges the information imbalance between debtors and creditors, necessitating the resolution professional’s investigative role in individual insolvency – Therefore, s.99 empowers the resolution professional to seek information – The right to privacy is subject to reasonable restraints – In the context of s.99(4), the legitimate aims of establishing a comprehensive framework for individual insolvency and aiding the adjudicating authority justify seeking personal financial information, balancing privacy rights with the objective. [Para 70] Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – Role of the Adjudicating Authority – Plea of the petitioners that the adjudicating authority must be required to determine jurisdictional question like whether a debt exists or whether the relationship of debtor and creditor subsists, at the threshold:
Held: The adjudicating authority conducts an independent assessment, not solely relying on the resolution professional’s report, to decide the fate of applications u/ss.94 or 95 – The true adjudicatory function of the authority commences u/s.100 after the submission of the report – What is described as a jurisdictional question by the petitioners may not be a simple matter to be decided as a question of law – The jurisdictional questions of the nature suggested by the petitioners, namely, on whether there is a subsisting debt or whether the relationship of debtor and creditor subsists, would involve a decision on mixed questions of law and fact – The entire scheme of ss.99 and 100 implicates time lines laid down by Parliament – The entire process of implementing these time lines would be rendered nugatory if an adjudicatory role were to be read into the provisions of s.97(5) – The provisions of s.99 do not as such implicate any adverse civil consequences particularly if those provisions are read in the manner in which we now propose to elucidate. [Para 73, 74] Interpretation of Statutes – Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 – s.100 – Requirement of hearing for a debtor to be read into s.100: Held: Although s.100 does not explicitly mention a hearing for a debtor, the requirement of a hearing has to be read into s.100 – When a statute is silent on a specific aspect, like a hearing, and there is no explicit DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS 566 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
prohibition, the courts may imply or read in such a requirement – The key point is that the lack of explicit mention of a hearing in a provision does not automatically make it unconstitutional because such a requirement can be read into the statute. [Para 80] Words and Phrases – “in respect of any debt”, in clause (b)(i) and clause (b)(ii) of sub-section(1) of s.96, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016:
Held: These words indicate that the interim-moratorium which is intended to operate by the legislature is primarily in respect of a debt as opposed to a debtor. Clause (b) of sub-section (1) indicates that the purpose of the interim-moratorium is to restrain the initiation or the continuation of legal action or proceedings against the debt – This must be contra-distinguished from the provisions for moratorium which are contained in s.14 in relation to the CIRP under Part II – s.14(1)(a) provides that on the insolvency commencement date, the institution of suits or continuation of pending suits or proceedings against the corporate debtor, including proceedings in execution shall stand prohibited by an order of the adjudicating authority. [Paras 57, 58]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
State Bank of India v Rajesh Agarwal (2023) SCC OnLine SC 342 – distinguished.
K.S. Puttaswamy (9 Judge Bench) v Union of India (2017) 10 SCC 1 – followed.
Lalit Kumar Jain v Union of India [2021] 3 SCR 1075:(2021) 9 SCC 321; Ravi Ajit Kulkarni v. State Bank of India (2021) SCC OnLine NCLAT 641; Ujjam Bai v State of Uttar Pradesh AIR [1963] SCR 778: (1962) SC 1621; Swiss Ribbons Private Limited v Union of India (2019) 4 SCC 17; Essar Steel India Limited v Satish Kumar Gupta (2020) 8 SCC 531 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION : Writ Petition (Civil) No.1281 of 2021.
(Under Article 32 Of The Constitution of India)
With
W.P.(C) NOS.149, 307, 308, 525, 472, 528, 519, 544, 546, 599,
600, 597, 590, 611, 615, 622, 596, 703, 705, 753, 826, 984, 812, 809, 818, 825, 910, 925, 1062, 1004, 929, 937, 1027, 1113 Of 2022, W.P.(C) NOS.89, 133, 216 of 2023, W.P.(C) NOS.403, 385, 388, 395, 394, 424, 443, 428, 709, 418, 416, 417, 491 of 2022, W.P.(C) Diary No.18674 of
2022, W.P.(C) NOS.485, 486, 467, 471, 478, 530, 541, 559, 551, 567,
578, 755, 570, 616, 560, 583, 582, 654, 652, 638, 635, 601, 634, 649, 647, 668, 657, 684, 655, 674, 692, 510, 714, 729, 663, 726, 666, 670, 776, 760, 696, 707, 736, 887, 885, 766, 683, 791, 794, 700, 716, 717, 733, 720, 724, 773, 816, 752, 789, 759, 754, 781, 785, 803, 784, 807, 800, 834, 821, 832, 858, 835, 837, 863, 894, 1084, 839, 830, 886, 854, 868, 842, 862, 884, 870, 873, 909, 849, 831, 843, 901, 907, 917, 916, 845, 889, 922, 924, 921, 935, 893, 895, 914, 900, 920, 923, 938, 934, 949, 1121, 822,1061, 1042, 1041, 1040 Of 2022, W.P.(C) Diary No.29889 Of 2022, W.P.(C) NOS.941, 1072, 945, 1043, 947, 1044, 976, 952, 972, 905, 939, 997 Of 2022, W.P. (C) NO.8 Of 2023, W.P.(C) NOS.957, 992, 996, 1099, 1048 Of 2022, W.P.(C) NO.5 of 2023, W.P.(C) Diary No.36132 of 2022, W.P.(C) NOS.1003, 1008, 1006, 1007, 1033, 1032, 1083 Of 2022, W.P.(C) NO.11 Of 2023, W.P.(C) NO.1114 Of 2022, W.P.(C) NO.17 of 2023, W.P.(C) NOS.1117, 1118, 1147, 1139, 1149 Of 2022, W.P.(C) NOS. 94, 13, 81, 127, 73, 46, 92, 91, 61, 72, 70, 111, 120, 109, 96, 110, 114, 117, 134, 145 of 2023, W.P.(C) Diary No(s).36130, 40974, 42246 of 2022, W.P.(C) NOS.118, 77, 173, 233, 166 of 2023, W.P.(C) Diary No(s).4241, 4379 of 2023, W.P.(C) NOS.161, 181, 183, 286, 298, 182, 194, 285, 189, 180, 609, 245, 203, 215, 200, 265, 249, 295, 217, 237, 236, 234, 361, 326, 329, 347, 332, 324, 338, 403, 383, 417, 588, 363, 424, 402, 422, 476, 433, 413, 426, 458, 459, 465, 454, 448, 521, 584, 546, 694, 693, 566, 528, 541, 557, 542, 553, 602, 596, 657, 620, 634, 652, 643, 647, 649, 1192 ,212, 480, 683, 797, 798, 885, 811 of 2023, W.P.(C) Diary No.20508 of 2023, W.P.(C) NOS.601, 663, 617, 641, 690, 639, 729, 728, 743, 711, 667, 668, 684, 778, 786, 709, 734, 770, 735, 774, 740, 731, 751, 818, 861, 883, 903, 779, 845, 791, 839, 787, 871, 810, 805, 803, 795, 842, 924, 919, 926, 920, 997, 886, DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS 568 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
915, 936, 954, 1021, 1052, 1004, 973, 1023, 1016, 1026, 1041, 1090, 1116, 1094, 1145, 1101, 1065, 1071, 1095, 1111, 1068, 1110, 1040, 1132, 1107, 1171, 1221, 1233, 1217, 1194, 1242 of 2023 Appearances:
Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Ritin Rai, Prateek Sekseria, Siddhath Bhatnagar, Rajiv Dutta, Rakesh Dwivedi, Nakul Dewan, Sr. Advs., Ms. Pallavi Pratap, Ms. Prachi Pratap, Dr. Prashant Pratap, Avishkar Singhvi, Ms. Ritika Sinha, Ms. Gunjan Mathur, Mridul Yadav, Ms. Shreya Munoth, Lzafeer Ahmad B. F., Ms. Gunjan Mathur, Vaibhav Choudhary, Ms. Ayesha Zaidi, Rajdeep Saraf, Sidharth Kaushik, Rajat Sehgal, Mrs. Vandana Anand, Samyak Jain, Sumesh Dhawan, Ankur Saigal, Mahesh Agarwal, Rohan Dakshni, Vatsala Kak, Ms. Geetika Sharma, Ankur Saigal, Pranjit Bhattacharya, Vishesh Malviya, Ms. Pracheta Kar, Ms. Kamakshi Sehgal, Divyanshu Srivastava, Ms. Pooja Vasandani, Shivam Shukla, Shaurya Shyam, Nishant Chothani, Yash Cheda, Archit Jain, Shashwat Singh, Aditya Sidhra, Ms. Kamakshi Saigal, E. C. Agrawala, Nadeem Afroz, Shravan Kumar Yammanur, Arvind Kumar Gupta, Ms.
Henna George, Vijay K Singh, Himanshu Dubey, Kumar Shashwat Singh Sawno, Prem Prakash, Ms. Eshna Kumar, Masoom Shah, Pulkit Deora, Nipun Gautam, Udit Gupta, Anup Jain, Ms. Prachi Gupta, Vyom Chaturvedi, Ms. Divya Hirawat, Ms. Nishtha Goel, Akshat Maheshwari, M/s. Udit Kishan and Associates, Ms. Pooja M Saigal, Snehasish Mukherjee, Nikhil Sabri, Ishank Jha, Nipun Gupta, Abhimanyu Bhandari, Arjun Syal, Shreyan Das, Ms. Anindita Mitra, Ms. Nattasha Garg, Thakur Ankit Singh, Ms. Rooh-e-hina Dua, Mrs. Nina R. Nariman, Piyush Singh, Aditya Parolia, Alankrit Bhatnagar, Ms. Kashish Sareen, Vivek Kumar, Ms. Sumbul Ismail, Jayant Upadhyay, Rajesh Kumar, Gaurav Goel, Mohit Chaudhary, Mrs. Puja Sharma, Kunal Sachdeva, Ms. Madhuri Jain, Prakhar Mithal, Ms. Arushi Jain, Ms. Srishti Bajpai, Aashish Arya, Ms. Sagrika Arya, Anubhav Singhal, M/s. Kings and Alliance Llp, Ms. Purti Gupta, Arvind Kumar Gupta, Ms. Henna George, Subhankar Nag, Partha Sil, Tavish Bhushan Prasad, Ms. Sayani Bhattacharya, Abhiraj Choudhary, Ms. Tahira Karanjawala, Arjun Sharma, Shreyas Maheshwari, Ms. Sukanya Das, M/s. Karanjawala & Co., Mathews J. Nedumpara, Ms. Usha Nandini V., Ms. Maria Nedumpara, Ms. Hemali Kurne, Ms. Rohini Amin, Shameem Fayiz, Bhupinder Singh Munday, Pai Amit, Ms. Ranu Purohit, Abhyudaya Vats, Yashas Rk, Mrs. Taruna Singh Gohil, S S Ray, Ms. Praveena Gautam, Pawan Shukla, Ms. Akanksha Tyagi, Kunal Vajani, Kunal Mimani, Kartikey Bhatt, Shubhang Tandon, Gaurav Khatri, Pranav Sarthi, Nitish Chodhary, Siddharth Mittal, Pai Amit, Ms. Komal Mundhra, Abhiyudaya Vats, Diwakar R. Singh, Ms. Honey Satpal, Manaswi Agrawal, Mrs. Naresh Bakshi, Ms. Pankhuri Bhardwaj, Saurabh Agrawal, Ms. Vanshika Dubey, Mahesh Dube, Tathagata Dutta, Ms. Salomi Kalwade, Kushal Dube, P. Ashok, Siddhartha Chowdhury, Ms. Ritwika Nanda, Gaichangpou Gangmei, Ms. Lothungbeni T. Lotha, Yimyanger Longkumer for M/s. Trust Legal, Ashutosh Thakur, Dhruva Vig, Chandra Pratap, Ms. Shruti Goyal, Gaurav, M/s. Mitter & Mitter Co., S.K. Gandhi, Raman Tomar, Ms. Nidhi Jaswal, Nakul Mohta, Ms. Misha Rohatgi, Ms. Alina Merin Mathew, Aviral Kumar Mishra, Ms. Bhavana Duhoon, Abhirup Dasgupta, Mohit D. Ram, Ishaan Duggal, Ms. Mukta Halbe, Anubhav Sharma, M/s. Pratap And Co., Narender Naik, Rahul Kumar, Debmalya Ganguli, Bebmalya Ganguli, Gopal Singh, Abhishek Agarwal, D. Abhinav Rao, Devadipta Das, Rahul Jajoo, Ms. Prerna Robin, C.S. Gupta, Vijay Kumar, Shekhar Kumar, Gaurav Nair, Mriganga Dutta, Ishwar Ahuja, Rahul Saxena, Ms. Bhairavi Sn, Ms. Anne Mathew, Anurag Ojha, Vipul, D N Chaturvedi, Keshri Kumar Tiwari, Ms. Krutika Raghavan, Ms. Gayatri Gulati, Bhairav Kuttaih, Bhairav Kuttaiah, Ms. Sameeksha Patil, T. V. S. Raghavendra Sreyas, Siddharth Vasudev, Ashu Kansal, Anando Mukherjee, Manish Raghav, Rohit Gour, Jugnu Bhati, Aakarshan Aditya, Anshuman Sharma, Ms. Pallavi Langar, Ms. Gauri Rishi, Ms. Srishti Juneja, Ms. Garima Sehgal, Aman Varma, Vishesh Kalra, Ms. Riya Wasade, Prashant Katara, Dr. (Mrs.) Vipin Gupta, Rakesh Kumar, Saurabh Mishra, Varun Pandit, Ms. Preeti Kashyap, Shrimay Mishra, Rishi K Awasthi, Piyush Vatsa, Ms. Ritu Arora, Amit Awasthi, Ms. Yukti Anand, Usman Khan, Avinash Ankit, Rahul Kumar Gupta, Shubham Saxena, Punit Vinay, Ms. Tatini Basu, Malak Manish Bhatt, Ms. Neeha Nagpal, Kaustav Talukdar, Ishan Das, Mrityunjai Singh, Rajesh J, Ms. Anshula Vijay Kumar Grover, Ms. Nitika Grover, Mayan Prasad, Vishesh Kalra, Ms. Mithu Jain, Sunil Fernandes, Abhishek Anand, Ms. Diksha Dadu, Karan Kohli, Maulk Chokshi, Tarun Arora, Ms. Priyansha Sharma, Sajal Jain, Supriyo Banerjee, Sanchit Garga, Sikhar Tiwari, Kunal Rana, Kashish Rehan, Lubhanshi Rai, Rasveen Kaur Kapoor, Pulkit Tare, Sahil Tagotra, Ms. Abhivyakti Banerjee, Rakesh Talukdar, DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS 570 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
Abhishek Pandey, Pulkit Srivastava, D.K. Garg, Abhishek Garg, Dhananjay Garg, Ishaan Tiwari, Varun Satiya, Karma Dorjee, Vaibhav Agarwal, Parvez Bashista, Sunil Ahaya, Prashant Katara, Harsh Varna, Surendra Ramgopal Agarwal, Md. Sadath Hussain, Mohammad Usman Siddiqui, Vijay Kumar, Mrs. Aisha Siddiqui, Dr. Ram Kishore Chaudhary, Syed Kashan Ali, Ms. Sakeena Quidwai, Mrs. Shikha Bhargava, Chand Qureshi, Rajiv K Virmani, Gaurav Jain, Atul Malhotra, Abhinav Agrawal, Ms. Swati Bhardwaj, Kartik Sharma, Soumik Ghosal, Sandeep S. Ladda, Gaurav Singh, Adnan A. Ansari, Ms. Niharika Ahluwalia, Arpit Sharma, Pranjit Bhattacharya, Vaibhav Niti, Ms. Raj Sarit Khare, Ms. Madhavi Agrawal, Divyanshu Agrawal, B. Srinivas, Madhur Mahajan, Ms. Anindita Pujari, Anant Prakash, Anand Dilip Landge, Apoorv Shukla, Manan Verma, Rajat Mittal, Hemant Chaudhri, Parminder Singh Bhullar, Arjun Mahajan, Davesh Bhatia, Raghvendra N Budholiya, Piyush Gautam, Sumit R. Sharma, Anish R. Shah, Anuj Tiwari, Nikhil Anand, Aditya Bharat Manubarwala, Saurabh K Mishra, Ms. Tuhina Mishra, Shubham Rajhans, Ms. Prakhar Shukla, Hitesh Kumar Sharma, Bharat Thakorlal Manubarwala, Sandeep Hirvadekar, K.
Parameshwar, Ms. Arti Gupta, Ms. Kanti, Chinmay Kalgaonkar, Shikhar Garg, Akshat Srivastava, Kumar Dushyant Singh, Rohit Sharma, Nikhil Purohit, Jatin Lalwani, Vaibhav Sahni, Ms. Tina Garg, Shivam Shukla, Anshuman Srivastava, Shantanu Sagar, Mrs. Divya Mishra, Prashant Chaudhary, Ms. Tanu Priya Gupta, Ms. Bhabna Das, Kuriakose Varghese, Ms. Uttara Babbar, V. Shyamohan, Ms. Aishwarya Hariharan, Ms. Anshika Bajpai, M/s. Kmnp Law, Saksham Maheshwari, V.C. Shukla, Vikash Chandra Shukla, Aishvary Vikram, Ajay Awasthi, Nitesh Ranjan, Suyash Pande, Tarun Gulia, Piyush Singh, Jaydip Pati, Anantha Narayana M.G., Sushant Bajaj, Sidhartha Relan, Siddhartha Relan, Akshya Kumar Panda, Pushpraj Singh Parihar, Prabhsimar Singh, Abhinav Gupta, Neetej Kumar, Nishanth Patil, Ms. Puja Sharma, Simarpal Singh Sawhney, Aditya Singh, M/s. Vedya Partners, Vardhman Kaushik, Sujoy Datta, NPS Chawla, Surekh Kant Baxy, Ms. Mahima Shekhawat, Mrs. Mahima Shekhawat, Gautam Singhal, Om Pal, Rajat Chaudhary, Sudhir Naagar, Ms. Mehaak Jaggi, Ms. Barnali Chowdhury, Dechen W. Lachungpa, Abhishek Roy, Mrs. Pragya Baghel, Ajay Vikram Singh, Anup Jain, Abhay Anand Jena, Arup Banerjee, D. Bharat Kumar, Kaoliangpou Kamei, Utkarsh Pratap, Aman Shukla, Lavkesh Bhambhani, Abhinay Reddy M., Ms. Marbiang Khongwir, Harshwardhan Thakur, Ms. Achala Siri Doddala, Raghav Kumar, Ms. Shreya Devaki, Ms. Praneetha Sreeramula, Manasvi Reddy J, M. Chandrakanth Reddy, Nring Chamwibo Zeliang, Ms. Anu Priya Nisha Minz, Siddhartha Sinha, Chritarth Palli, Ankur Bansal, Sidhant Dhingra, Sadre Alam, Krishna Dev Jagarlamudi, M Gireesh Kumar, Ankur S. Kulkarni, Ms. Priya Bhalerao, Varun Kanwal, Kaushik Laik, S. Ram Babu, Angad Mehta, Ashay Kaushik, Shashank Tiwari, Aditya Soni, Jose Abraham, Ms. Vismai Rao, Harsh, Sameer Abhyankar, Rahul Kumar, Naman Jain, Aman Malik, Anish Maheswari, Vijay Kumar Maurya, Ms. Naazish Khan, Debesh Panda, Kaushik Poddar, Saurabh Jain, Ankur Sood, Soayib Qureshi, Nitin Mishra, Aayush Agarwala, Anuj P. Agarwala, Nishit Dhruva, Ms. Khushbu Chajjed, Yash Dhruva, Auritro Mukherjee, M/s. Pba Legal, Raj Kamal, Shikhar Sarin, Aseem Atwal, Kartavya Batra, Ms. Nupur Kaushik, Ms. Stuti, Ms. Aprajita Tyagi, Ms. Muskan Sidana, Sumit Sinha, Mandeep Kalra, Ms. Supriya Juneja, Ms. Hetu Arora Sethi, Ms. Lalit Mohini Bhat, Ms. Saumya Preeti Tandon, Rahul Jain, Anirudh Bhat, Ninad Dogra, Balaji Srinivasan, G. Vidya Sagar, A. Venayagam Balan, Ms. Soujanya, C.M. Sundaram, Kiritkumar Govindlal Sheth, Gaurav Pal, Puneet Thakur, Ashray Behura, Ms. Sujata Kurdukar, Abhirup Das Gupta, Rahul Gupta, Ms. Prachi Johri, Ishan Duggal, Ms. Mukta, Himanshu Dhawan, Shubham Jain, Ms. Aakashi Lodha, Ms.
Vipasha Singh, D. Bharat Kumar, Utkarsh Pratap, Aman Shukla, Raghav Kumar, Abhinay Reddy M., Ms. Achala Siri Doddala, Ms. Shreya Devaki, Lavkesh Bhambhani, Harshwardhan Thakur, Ms. Praneetha Sreeramula, Ms. Manasvi Reddy J, M. Chandrakanth Reddy, Gopal Jha, Alok Dhir, Ms. Varsha Banerjee, Karan Batura, GP Madaan, Aditya Madaan, Salvador Santosh Rebello, Raghav Sharma, Ms. Shivangi Singhal, Archit Upadhayay, Sravan Kumar Karanam, Ms. Shireesh Tyagi, Akshay Mann, Sarthak Ghonkrokta, Kanu Agrawal, Rajan Kumar Chourasia, Shailesh Madiyal, Apoorva Kurup, Sourav Roy, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Amrish Kumar, Ms. Megha Karnwal, Surya Prakash, Devesh Dubey, Arjun Bhatia, Ms. Divya Singh Pundir, Ms. Mahima Kapur, Ms. Isha Virmani, Mrs. Shubhra Kapur, Sanjay Kapur, Ms. Anannya Ghosh, Adarsh Ramanujan, Dushyant Manocha, Neil Chatterjee, Ms. Sirka, Ms. Doel Bose, Ms. Chitra Vats, Ms. Skanda, Ms. Priyanka Vora, Ativ Patel, Siddhant Buxy, Ms. Viloma Shah, Krishna Sumanth, Arijeet Shukla, DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS 572 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
Darshit Dave, Harshad Vyas, Neil Chatterjee, Amar Dave, Ms. Ayshwarya Chander, Mayank Mishra, Ms. Sushmita Gandhi, Amit Jajoo, Ms.
Anamika, Ms. Nasrin, Ms. Tushita Ghosh, Rohit Anil Rathi, Radhey Agrawal, Yashas Rk, M/s. Cyril Amarchand Mangaldas, R. Gopalakrishnan, R Sudhinder, Ms. Ekta Basin, Sanidhya Sonthalia, Rajesh Kumar Gautam, Anant Gautam, Ms. Shivani Sagar, Dinesh Sharma, Shamik Shirishbhai Sanjanwala, Shantanu Parmar, Ateev Mathur, Gagan Gupta, Amol Sharma, Ms. Megha Karnwal, Arun Aggarwal, Ms. Anshika Agarwal, Shivam Saini, Varun Bhatnagar, Ms. Madhu Yadav, Ms. Dipti Jain, Sidharth Sethi, Ms. Pragya Chauhan, Avinash Das, Kuna Saini, Pankaj Kumar Mishra, Vijay Kumar, Ms. Rekha Anand, Kanchan Kumar Jha, Pankaj Kumar Mishra, Badri Prasad Singh, Palash Singhai, Brijesh Kumar Tamber, Ritwik Parikh, Tushar Garg, Gaurav Garg, Gaurav Kumar, Sanjeev Sagar, Shekhar Raj Sharma, Ms. Akshaya Jebakumar, Jinendra Jain, Yash Artha Gupta, Ms. Nishi Chaudhary, Ms. Manjeet Kirpal, Tushar Singh, Kunal Tandon, Ms. Richa Sandilya, Shubhankar Singh, Ronnie S. Barara, Ms. Bhavna Vijay, Rishi, Ms. Akshra Arshi, Aman Raj Gandhi, Krishan Kumar, Kuber Dewan, Ms. Neeharika Aggarwal, Kaustubh Srivastava, Ms. B. Vijayalakshmi Menon, Mrs. Lalita Kaushik, Rohan Batra, Prasouk Jain, Ms. Rabiya Thakur, Karan Sinha, Anurag Sharma, Divyanshu Rai, Shantanu Krishna, Chandra Bhushan Prasad, Ashok Kumar Jain, Amit Kasera, Mrs. Meenakshi Jain, Bijoy Kumar Jain, Ms. Ekta Choudhary, Miss Aanchal Jain, P. S. Sudheer, Rishi Maheshwari, Bharat Sood, Ms. Miranda Solaman, Ms. Padmaja Kaul, Yugank Goel, Kushagra Sah, Ritesh Patnaik, Sanjeev Kaushik, Ms. Mantika Haryani, Ms. Astha Sharma, Ajay Bhargava, Mrs. Vanita Bhargava, Ms. Wamika Trehan, Siddhant Kumar, M/S. Khaitan & Co., Mithilesh Kumar Pandey, Aviral Kashyap, Aditya Mishra, Ms. Pallavi Daisy, Ashutosh Kumar, Palav Agarwal, Sudhanshu Kaushesh, Pulkit Agarwal, Nishant Awana, Azmat Hayat Amanullah, Ms. Rini Badoni, Tirupati Gaurav Shahi, Ms. Nitya Sharma, Hardik Choudhary, Uddyam Mukherjee, Swapnil Pattanayak, Mahfooz Ahsan Nazki, Polanki Gowtham, Ms. Rajeswari Mukherjee, Meeran Maqbool, Ms. Ruchi Guasain, Harsh, Ms. Anushree Kulkarni, Aakash Thakur, Sameer Abhyankar, Rahul Kumar, Sunil Kumar Sharma, Ms. Preeti Goel, O. P. Gaggar, Sachindra Karn, Samar Vijay Singh, Azeem A Dost, Keshav Mittal, Prashant Sharma, Ms. Sabarni Som, Birendra Kumar Mishra, Ms. Poonam Atey, Prabhat Ranjan Singh, Hemendra, Ms. Shagufa Salim, Ms. Monalisa Kosaria, B. Shravanth Shanker, Venancio Dcosta, Ms. Astha Ojha, Ms. Gauri Goel, Faisal Sherwani, Vikas Mehta, Vinayak Sharma, Shakti Kanta Pattanaik, Santosh Kumar, Shantanu Sagar, Ms. Charu Mathur, Yogesh Jagia, Advs. for the appearing parties.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD, CJI
Table of Contents* I. Background .........................................................................16 II. Scheme of the IBC ..............................................................17 III. Submissions .........................................................................25 A. Submissions on behalf of the Petitioners .....................25 B. Submissions on behalf of the Respondents ..................29 IV. Analysis ...................................................................................37 A. Comparative Analysis of Part II and Part III of the IBC ...38
1. Stages under Part II and III ..........................................38
2. The Role of the Resolution Professional in Corporate as opposed to Individual Insolvency ................................39
3. The impact of a moratorium under Section 14 of Part II vis-a-vis interim-moratorium under Section 96 of Chapter III of Part III.................................................................46
4. The Role of the Adjudicating Authority ......................47 B. Applicability of the Principles of Natural Justice............48
1. Role of the Resolution Professional as a facilitator is to collate facts ..................................................................49
2. Role of the Adjudicatory Authority .............................54
3. A right of representation has been provided under Section 99(2) .............................................................................55 DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS *Ed. Note : Pagination is as per original judgment.
574 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
C. Challenge to the constitutional validity ............................58 V. Conclusion ...........................................................................61
1. Applications for condonation of delay in refiling the writ petitions are allowed.
I. Background
2. In a batch of three hundred and eighty four petitions under Article 32 of the Constitution, the petitioners challenge the constitutional validity of Sections 95 to 100 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code 20161. The individual facts of each case are not reproduced here as we are deciding the constitutionality of the above provisions of the IBC.
3. The principle aims of the IBC are to promote investment, and resolution of insolvencies of corporate persons, firms, and individuals in a time bound manner. The IBC consolidated and amended a web of laws which had led to an ineffective and inefficient mechanism for resolution of insolvencies marked with significant delays.
4. Part III of the IBC deals with insolvency resolution and bankruptcy for individuals and partnership firms. Chapter III of Part III which is titled “Insolvency Resolution Process” (“IRP”) comprises of Sections 94 to 120. Prior to the introduction of the IBC, insolvency in relation to individuals was governed by the provisions of the Presidency Towns Insolvency Act 1909 and the Provincial Insolvency Act 1920, both of which stand repealed.
5. The provisions of the IBC apply to personal guarantors to corporate debtors.2 In exercise of the power conferred by Section 1(3), a notification was issued on 15 November 2019 by the Union Government in the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. The notification brought into force Section 2(e), Section 78 (except with regard to fresh start process), Section 79, Section 94 to 187, Sections 239(2)(g), (h) and (i), Sections 239(2)(m) to (zc); Section 239(2)
(zn) to (zs) and Section 249. The notification was challenged before this Court. In Lalit Kumar Jain v Union of India3 a two-Judge Bench inter 1 “IBC”
2 Section 2(e), IBC as amended by the Amending Act 8 of 2018
3 (2021) 9 SCC 321
alia, held that the liability of a guarantor is not discharged merely on the discharge of the corporate debtor.
6. By Amending Act 26 of 2018, Parliament introduced amendments inter alia, in Section 60 which provides for the jurisdiction of the adjudicating authority, namely, the National Company Law Tribunal.4 Among other things, the amendments to Section 60 comprehend the jurisdiction of the Tribunal in matters involving the bankruptcy of a corporate guarantor or personal guarantor, as the case may be, of a corporate debtor.
7. In order to consider the nature of challenge in these proceedings, it would be appropriate to make a brief reference to the provisions of the IBC. II. Scheme of the IBC
8. Part I of the IBC deals with preliminary matters, such as its application and definitions. Part II deals with insolvency resolution and liquidation for corporate persons. Part III deals with insolvency resolution and bankruptcy for individuals and partnership firms. Part IV provides for the regulation of insolvency professionals, agencies and information utilities. Part V contains miscellaneous provisions.
9. Chapter I of Part III contains preliminary provisions, including, definitions. Section 78 indicates that the Part shall apply to matters relating to “fresh start, insolvency and bankruptcy of individuals and partnership firms where the amount of the default is not less than one thousand rupees”. However, the Central Government is empowered to specify a higher threshold not exceeding one lakh rupees. Section 79(1) indicates that the adjudicating authority for the purpose of Part III “means the Debt Recovery Tribunal constituted under sub-section (1)of section 3 of the Recovery of Debts Due to Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993”. Chapter II, which is yet to be brought into force, contains provisions in relation to the “fresh start process”.
10. Chapter III provides for the insolvency resolution process . Under Chapter III, the insolvency resolution process can be initiated by a debtor or a creditor. Section 94(1)5 enables a debtor who commits a default to apply, 4 “Tribunal”
5 94. Application by debtor to initiate insolvency resolution process.— DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD, CJI 576 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
either personally or through a resolution professional, to the adjudicating authority for initiating the insolvency resolution process.
11. Section 956 enables the creditor to apply for the initiation of
(1) A debtor who commits a default may apply, either personally or through a resolution professional, to the Adjudicating Authority for initiating the insolvency resolution process, by submitting an application.
(2) Where the debtor is a partner of a firm, such debtor shall not apply under this Chapter to the Adjudicating Authority in respect of the firm unless all or a majority of the partners of the firm file the application jointly.
(3) An application under sub-section (1) shall be submitted only in respect of debts which are not excluded debts.
(4) A debtor shall not be entitled to make an application under sub-section (1) if he is—
(a) an undischarged bankrupt;
(b) undergoing a fresh start process;
(c) undergoing an insolvency resolution process; or
(d) undergoing a bankruptcy process.
(5) A debtor shall not be eligible to apply under sub-section (1) if an application under this Chapter has been admitted in respect of the debtor during the period of twelve months preceding the date of submission of the application under this section.
(6) The application referred to in sub-section (1) shall be in such form and manner and accompanied with such fee as may be prescribed.
6 95. Application by creditor to initiate insolvency resolution process.—
(1) A creditor may apply either by himself, or jointly with other creditors, or through a resolution professional to the Adjudicating Authority for initiating an insolvency resolution process under this section by submitting an application.
(2) A creditor may apply under sub-section (1) in relation to any partnership debt owed to him for initiating an insolvency resolution process against—
(a) any one or more partners of the firm; or
(b) the firm.
(3) Where an application has been made against one partner in a firm, any other application against another partner in the same firm shall be presented in or transferred to the Adjudicating Authority in which the first mentioned application is pending for adjudication and such Adjudicating Authority may give such directions for consolidating the proceedings under the applications as it thinks just.
(4) An application under sub-section (1) shall be accompanied with details and documents relating to—
(a) the debts owed by the debtor to the creditor or creditors submitting the application for insolvency resolution process as on the date of application;
(b) the failure by the debtor to pay the debt within a period of fourteen days of the service of the notice of demand; and
(c) relevant evidence of such default or non-repayment of debt.
(5) The creditor shall also provide a copy of the application made under sub-section (1) to the debtor.
(6) The application referred to in sub-section (1) shall be in such form and manner and the insolvency resolution process either by himself, or jointly with other creditors or through a resolution professional. Under sub-section (2), a creditor may apply under sub-section (1) in relation to any partnership debt owed to him for initiating a resolution process against any one or more partners of the firm; or the firm. Section 95(4) stipulates the requirements of an application made by a creditor for the initiation of the insolvency resolution process. The application is governed by the form and manner as prescribed by Rules framed by the Central Government under Section 239. A copy of the application has to be furnished to the debtor. Immediately on the filing of an application under Section 94 or Section 95, an interim moratorium operates by virtue of the statutory provisions of Section 967 and the adjudicating authority is required to appoint a resolution professional.
12. Where the application has been filed through a resolution professional, the adjudicating authority has to direct the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India8 to confirm within seven days that there are no disciplinary proceedings pending against the resolution professional. Thereafter, the Board has to either confirm the appointment of the resolution professional or to reject it and nominate another resolution professional for accompanied by such fee as may be prescribed.
(7) The details and documents required to be submitted under sub-section (4) shall be such as may be specified.
7 “96. Interim moratorium.—(1) When an application is filed under section 94 or section 95—
(a) an interim-moratorium shall commence on the date of the application in relation to all the debts and shall cease to have effect on the date of admission of such application; and
(b) during the interim-moratorium period—
(i) any legal action or proceeding pending in respect of any debt shall be deemed to have been stayed; and
(ii) the creditors of the debtor shall not initiate any legal action or proceedings in respect of any debt.
(2) Where the application has been made in relation to a firm, the interimmoratorium under sub-section (1) shall operate against all the partners of the firm as on the date of the application.
(3) The provisions of sub-section (1) shall not apply to such transactions as may be notified by the Central Government in consultation with any financial sector regulator.”
8 “Board”
DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD, CJI 578 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
conducting the resolution process within seven days. Alternatively, where the application has been filed by the debtor or creditor without a resolution professional, the adjudicating authority has to direct the Board within seven days to nominate a resolution professional to conduct the process. The Board then has a period of ten days to make a nomination. Section 97(5)9 states that “the adjudicating authority shall by order appoint the resolution professional recommended under sub-section (2) or as nominated by the Board under sub-section (4). The resolution professional, upon appointment, is provided a copy of the application for the insolvency resolution process.
13. Section 98 contains provisions for the replacement of the resolution professional. Section 9910 contains provisions for the submission of a report 9 97. Appointment of resolution professional.—
(1) If the application under section 94 or 95 is filed through a resolution professional, the Adjudicating Authority shall direct the Board within seven days of the date of the application to confirm that there are no disciplinary proceedings pending against resolution professional.
(2) The Board shall within seven days of receipt of directions under sub-section (1) communicate to the Adjudicating Authority in writing either—
(a) confirming the appointment of the resolution professional; or
(b) rejecting the appointment of the resolution professional and nominating another resolution professional for the insolvency resolution process.
(3) Where an application under section 94 or 95 is filed by the debtor or the creditor himself, as the case may be, and not through the resolution professional, the Adjudicating Authority shall direct the Board, within seven days of the filing of such application, to nominate a resolution professional for the insolvency resolution process.
(4) The Board shall nominate a resolution professional within ten days of receiving the direction issued by the Adjudicating Authority under sub-section (3).
(5) The Adjudicating Authority shall by order appoint the resolution professional recommended under sub-section (2) or as nominated by the Board under sub-section (4).
(6) A resolution professional appointed by the Adjudicating Authority under subsection (5) shall be provided a copy of the application for insolvency resolution process.
10 “99. Submission of report by resolution professional.—(1) The resolution professional shall examine the application referred to in section 94 or section 95, as the case may be, within ten days of his appointment, and submit a report to the Adjudicating Authority recommending for approval or rejection of the application.
(2) Where the application has been filed under section 95, the resolution professional may require the debtor to prove repayment of the debt claimed as unpaid by the creditor by furnishing— by the resolution professional to the adjudicating authority.
14. The scheme of Section 99 is that the resolution professional is required to examine the application which has been preferred by the debtor or the creditor within ten days of appointment and to submit a report to the adjudicating authority “recommending for approval or rejection of the application”. In other words, the resolution professional under sub-section
(1) of Section 99 performs a three-fold function:
(i) The duty to examine the application submitted by the debtor or the creditor;
(ii) The submission of a report; and
(iii) The incorporation of recommendations in the report either for the approval or the rejection of the application which has been submitted by the debtor or the creditor.
(a) evidence of electronic transfer of the unpaid amount from the bank account of the debtor;
(b) evidence of encashment of a cheque issued by the debtor; or
(c) a signed acknowledgment by the creditor accepting receipt of dues.
(3) Where the debt for which an application has been filed by a creditor is registered with the information utility, the debtor shall not be entitled to dispute the validity of such debt.
(4) For the purposes of examining an application, the resolution professional may seek such further information or explanation in connection with the application as may be required from the debtor or the creditor or any other person who, in the opinion of the resolution professional, may provide such information.
(5) The person from whom information or explanation is sought under sub-section
(4) shall furnish such information or explanation within seven days of receipt of the request.
(6) The resolution professional shall examine the application and ascertain that—
(a) the application satisfies the requirements set out in section 94 or 95;
(b) the applicant has provided information and given explanation sought by the resolution professional under sub-section (4).
(7) After examination of the application under sub-section (6), he may recommend acceptance or rejection of the application in his report.
(8) Where the resolution professional finds that the debtor is eligible for a fresh start under Chapter II, the resolution professional shall submit a report recommending that the application by the debtor under section 94 be treated as an application under section 81 by the Adjudicating Authority.
(9) The resolution professional shall record the reasons for recommending the acceptance or rejection of the application in the report under sub-section (7).
(10) The resolution professional shall give a copy of the report under sub-section (7) to the debtor or the creditor, as the case may be.”
DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD, CJI 580 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
15. Where an application has been filed by the creditor, the resolution professional, as sub-section (2) indicates, “may require the debtor to prove repayment of the debt claimed as unpaid by the creditor”. The debtor may be required to furnish:
(i) Evidence of the electronic transfer from the bank account of the debtor repaying the unpaid amount;
(ii) Evidence of the encashment of a cheque issued by the debtor; or
(iii) An acknowledgement signed by the creditor accepting receipt of dues.
16. In terms of sub-section (3), the debtor is not entitled to dispute the validity of debts which are registered with the information utility and form the subject matter of the application for the insolvency resolution process. Section 99(4) enables the resolution professional to seek further information or an explanation “in connection with the application”, as may be required from the debtor or the creditor or any other person for the purposes of examining the application. The person from whom such a request is made is under an obligation to supply it within seven days. Sub-section (6) clarifies the limited ambit entrusted to the resolution professional. In terms of the provision, the resolution professional has to examine the application and ascertain that:
(i) The application satisfies the requirement of Section 94 or Section 95; and
(ii) The applicant has provided information and furnished an explanation which has been sought from him under sub-section (4).
17. After carrying out this process, the resolution professional may recommend the acceptance or rejection of the application in a reasoned report. A copy of the report is provided to the debtor or creditor, as the case may be, under sub-section (10). The jurisdiction of the adjudicating authority, upon the submission of the report, is stipulated in Section 100.11 11 “100. Admission or rejection of application.—(1) The Adjudicating Authority shall, within fourteen days from the date of submission of the report under section 99 pass
18. In terms of Section 100, the adjudicating authority has a time line of fourteen days from the submission of the report to either admit or reject the application for insolvency resolution process. In the event that the adjudicating authority admits an application, it is empowered, on the request of the resolution professional to require that negotiations be conducted between the debtor and the creditor for the purpose of arriving at a repayment plan. The adjudicating authority is required to provide a copy of its order together with the report of the resolution professional and the application to the creditors within seven days from the order. If the application is rejected by the adjudicating authority on the ground that it was made with an intent to defraud the creditors or the resolution professional, the order of the adjudicating authority is to record that the creditor is entitled to file for a bankruptcy under Chapter IV.
19. The interim moratorium under Section 96 commences from the application filed under Sections 94 or 95, and ceases to have effect on the date of the admission of the application. Consequently, Section 10112 contains an order either admitting or rejecting the application referred to in section 94 or 95, as the case may be.
(2) Where the Adjudicating Authority admits an application under sub-section (1), it may, on the request of the resolution professional, issue instructions for the purpose of conducting negotiations between the debtor and creditors and for arriving at a repayment plan.
(3) The Adjudicating Authority shall provide a copy of the order passed under subsection (1) along with the report of the resolution professional and the application referred to in section 94 or 95, as the case may be, to the creditors within seven days from the date of the said order.
(4) If the application referred to in section 94 or 95, as the case may be, is rejected by the Adjudicating Authority on the basis of report submitted by the resolution professional that the application was made with the intention to defraud his creditors or the resolution professional, the order under sub-section (1) shall record that the creditor is entitled to file for a bankruptcy order under Chapter IV.” 12 101. Moratorium.—
(1) When the application is admitted under section 100, a moratorium shall commence in relation to all the debts and shall cease to have effect at the end of the period of one hundred and eighty days beginning with the date of admission of the application or on the date the Adjudicating Authority passes an order on the repayment plan under section 114, whichever is earlier.
(2) During the moratorium period—
(a) any pending legal action or proceeding in respect of any debt shall be deemed to have been stayed;
DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD, CJI 582 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
provisions for a statutory moratorium with effect from the admission of an application under Section 100.
20. The moratorium remains in force for a period of 180 days or when an order approving the repayment plan is passed, whichever is earlier. The effect of the statutory moratorium is that the any pending legal action in respect of the debt is stayed; no new action may be initiated by the creditors in respect of the debt; and the debtor shall not transfer or alienate his assets or legal rights or beneficial interest therein.
21. The remaining provisions of Chapter III relate to the issuance of public notices and inviting claims from the creditors, registration of their claims, preparation of the list of creditors, a repayment plan, meetings of creditors, the rights of secured creditors, approval of the repayment plan by creditors and the order of the adjudicating authority on the repayment plan. Consequential provisions have been made in the remaining provisions of Part III, inter alia, for the completion of the repayment plan (Section 117) and a discharge order (Section 119).
22. In exercise of the powers conferred by Section 239, the Central Government has notified the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority for Insolvency Resolution Process for Personal Guarantors to Corporate Debtors) Rules 2019. The rules specify the form in which the applications have to be submitted under Sections 94 and 95. III. Submissions
23. Now, it is in this backdrop that it would become necessary to analyse the submissions made on behalf of the parties.
A. Submissions on behalf of the Petitioners
24. Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, senior counsel has set forth the following propositions for determination by the Court:
(b) the creditors shall not initiate any legal action or legal proceedings in respect of any debt; and
(c) the debtor shall not transfer, alienate, encumber or dispose of any of his assets or his legal rights or beneficial interest therein;
(3) Where an order admitting the application under section 96 has been made in relation to a firm, the moratorium under sub-section (1) shall operate against all the partners of the firm.
(i) The IBC is an invasive in rem proceeding and is highly prejudicial against the respondent;
(ii) Before initiating proceedings for insolvency under the IBC and the appointment of a resolution professional or, at the minimum, before the resolution professional takes any action, there must be a determination by a judicial body of the existence of a debt;
(iii) The following ought not to take place automatically after the filing of an application under Section 95 without judicial adjudication/ intervention, namely:
(a) An automatic interim moratorium;
(b) The automatic appointment of a resolution professional subject to worthiness;
(c) The resolution professional seeking information from the guarantor; and
(d) The resolution professional examining the information received and submitting a report;
(iv) None of the above steps, once performed, is reversible under Section 100 which is the first stage at which two crucial steps take place (a) it is the first time at which a judicial body adjudicates; and (b) it is the first stage at which the guarantor is furnished with a hearing by the adjudicating authority;
(v) The power to seek information not only from a guarantor but also from third parties which is made available to the resolution professional is untrammelled and is being routinely exercised;
(vi) Common law consistently provides natural justice unless explicitly prohibited by statute. Any statutory exclusion is subject to review and may be invalidated, except in cases related to special reasons like national security;
(vii) All that the petitioners seek is natural justice by a judicial body at the stage of Section 97(1) similar to the exercise of the adjudicating authority which discharges its functions under Section 7 or 9 of the IBC; and DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD, CJI 584 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
(viii) The IBC follows the same model as sought by the petitioners under Sections 7 and 9 and neither any reasonable distinction nor any qualification exists for denying the right to adjudicatory hearing to a guarantor in the same statute when confronted with the application under Section 95.
25. Primarily, the submission which has been urged on behalf of the petitioners by Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi postulates that the fundamental aspect as to whether the jurisdiction to entertain an application under Chapter III of Part III exists must be determined at the threshold by giving the debtor or personal guarantor an opportunity to be heard. The submission is that logically the determination of the jurisdictional question has to take place first before the appointment of the resolution professional under Section 97(5). Consequently, it has been submitted that the adjudicating authority must be required to determine at the threshold whether (a) a debt exists; and (b) whether the debt has been effaced.
26. The submission has been sought to be advanced from two perspectives. Firstly, it postulates that a judicial aspect is involved even before the resolution professional begins the task outlined in Section 99, for determining the jurisdictional requirements for the existence and continuity of a debt. Secondly, following the appointment of the resolution professional under Section 97(5), wide-ranging powers are granted by Section 99(4) to demand information not only from the debtor but also from third parties. As a result, the submission emphasizes the need for a judicial determination by the adjudicating authority before the stage outlined in Section 100. Senior counsel argues that without incorporating a requirement for a hearing before the adjudicating authority prior to the appointment of a resolution professional, the provisions of Sections 95 to 100 would be arbitrary and violative of Article 14. Therefore, it is urged that a judicial application of mind by the adjudicating authority is essential even before the appointment of a resolution professional to avoid such consequences.
27. The submission which has been urged by Dr Singhvi has been buttressed further in the course of the submissions urged before this Court by Mr Ritin Rai, senior counsel.
28. Mr Ritin Rai argued that:
(i) A person as an applicant under Section 95 claims to be a creditor to whom a debt is owed. The existence of a debt which is owed is a jurisdictional fact which has to be determined by the adjudicating authority at the very threshold;
(ii) Section 97 (5) postulates that a resolution professional has to be appointed by the adjudicating authority. This being the first interface of the adjudicating authority, it must satisfy itself at that stage of the existence of a creditor-debtor relationship which must be demonstrated to exist. The entire jurisdiction in terms of the entertainment of an application under Part III would depend on the proof of the jurisdictional fact;
(iii) The plain consequence of the appointment of a resolution professional under Section 97(5) is that broad powers are given to them in terms of Section 99(4). The appointment of a resolution professional has serious consequences for the debtor besides which the credit worthiness of the debtor is seriously impinged. In many cases, lending documents trigger a default when an insolvency notice is issued as a consequence of which collateral or independent debts may become invocable by a lending agency. Bearing in mind the broad ranging enquiries which are made by the resolution professional, the debtor is excluded from accessing the remedies of an adjudicatory nature; and
(iv) In view of both the requirement of establishing a jurisdictional fact at the threshold and the impact of the enquiries which are made by the resolution professional, civil consequences would follow upon the conduct of an enquiry under Section 99 by the resolution professional. As a consequence, natural justice involving the adjudicatory body must be read into the provisions, at that stage.
29. We have also heard in support of the petitions other counsel, including, Mr Rajiv Dutta, Mr Prateek Seksaria, senior counsel, Mr Arvind Kumar Gupta, Mr Vijay Kumar Singh, Mr Masoom Shah, Ms Pooja M Saigal, Mr Abhimanyu Bhandari, Ms Nina R Nariman, Mr Mohit Chaudhary, Ms Eeshna Kumar, Ms Purti Gupta, Mr Subhankar Nag, Ms Tahira Karanjawala and Mr Mathews J Nedumpara. We would be dealing DILIP B JIWRAJKA v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD, CJI 586 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 16 S.C.R.
with some of the supplementary submissions which have been urged at a subsequent stage of the judgment.
B. Submissions on behalf of the Respondents
30. Mr Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General appearing on behalf of the Union of India and the State Bank of India, has urged the following submissions:
(i) The time bound resolution of insolvency constitutes the heart and soul of the provisions of the IBC;
(ii) Part II of the IBC which deals with the resolution of corporate insolvency and Part III which deals with the resolution and bankruptcy of individuals and partnership firms contains distinct provisions;
(iii) Under Sections 7 and 9 which deals with an application for initiation of corporate insolvency resolution process13 by a financial creditor and the operational creditor respectively, the admission of the application itself triggers the CIRP. Thereupon, by an operation of the statute, a moratorium comes into operation under the provisions of Section 14. Such a moratorium, inter alia, has a direct impact on the corporate debtor who is prevented from transferring, encumbering, alienating or disposing of any of its assets. Consequently, the admission of an application under Section 7 or Section 9 triggers serious consequences as a result of which the legislature has mandated the involvement of the adjudicating authority at that very stage itself;
(iv) The moratorium under Section 96, unlike Section 14, is for the benefit of the guarantor or, as the case may be, the debtor. At the stage of an application under Section 94 or Section 95, no adjudication takes place. The interim moratorium under Section 96 does not impose an embargo on alienation of assets, legal rights or beneficial interest of the debtor. Hence, the moratorium under Part II under Section 14 is markedly different in its nature 13 “CIRP”
and character from the interim-moratorium under Section 96 in Part III;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.