State of Punjab v. Principal Secretary to the Governor of Punjab and Another
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 1017; [2023] 15 S.C.R. 777
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice As An Unelected Head of the State, Justice Is Entrusted With Certain
- Decided
- 10 Nov 2023
- Case number
- WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) No. 1224/2023
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:27 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 15 S.C.R. 777 : 2023 INSC 1017
CASE DETAILS
STATE OF PUNJAB
v.
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNOR OF PUNJAB
AND ANOTHER
(Writ Petition (Civil) No 1224 of 2023)
NOVEMBER 10, 2023
[DR DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI, J. B. PARDIWALA AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issue for consideration: (i) Whether the Governor can withhold action on Bills which have been passed by the State Legislature; (ii) Whether it is permissible in law for the Speaker to reconvene a sitting of a Vidhan Sabha session which has been adjourned but has not been prorogued.
Constitution of India – Art. 200 – The Governor is a symbolic head and cannot withhold action on Bills passed by the State Legislature: Held: The Governor, as an unelected Head of the State, is entrusted with certain constitutional powers – However, this power cannot be used to thwart the normal course of lawmaking by the State Legislatures – Consequently, if the Governor decides to withhold assent under the substantive part of Art. 200, the logical course of action is to pursue the course indicated in the first proviso of remitting the Bill to the state legislature for reconsideration – In other words, the power to withhold assent under the substantive part of Art. 200 must be read together with the consequential course of action to be adopted by the Governor under the first proviso – If the first proviso is not read in juxtaposition to the power to withhold assent conferred by the substantive part of Art. 200, the Governor as the unelected Head of State would be in a position to virtually veto the functioning of the legislative domain by a duly elected legislature by simply declaring that assent is withheld without any further recourse – Such a course of action would be contrary to fundamental principles of a constitutional democracy SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.778 based on a Parliamentary pattern of governance – Therefore, when the Governor decides to withhold assent under the substantive part of Art. 200, the course of action which is to be followed is that which is indicated in the first proviso – The Governor is u/Art. 168 a part of the legislature and is bound by the constitutional regime – In the instant case, the Governor of Punjab was not empowered to withhold action on the Bills passed by the State Legislature and must act “as soon as possible” – In any event, it was legally permissible for the Speaker to reconvene the Vidhan Sabha because
(a) there is a distinction between adjournment and prorogation; and (b) the Speaker has exclusive jurisdiction over regulating the procedure of the House. [Paras 25, 28] Constitution of India – Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Punjab Vidhan Sabha (Punjab Legislative Assembly) – r.16 – Reconvening a sitting of the Vidhan Sabha which has not been prorogued is permissible in law and is within the exclusive domain of the Speaker:
Held: Rule 16 indicates that the Vidhan Sabha may be adjourned by its own order from time to time – This is however subject to the provisions of the Constitution and the Rules – In terms of the first proviso, a motion for adjournment either to a day or sine die requires consultation with the Speaker – Significantly, in terms of the second proviso, the Speaker is empowered in public interest to call a meeting of the Vidhan Sabha earlier than the date to which it has been adjourned or at any time after it has been adjourned sine die – So, it is clear that the Rules of Procedure expressly recognize a situation where the Speaker reconvenes a sitting of the Vidhan Sabha which has been adjourned sine die but not prorogued – The provision empowering the Speaker to reconvene a sitting of the Vidhan Sabha on any date after it has been adjourned sine die is not unique to the Rules of Procedure of the Punjab Vidhan Sabha – A review of the Rules of Procedure of State Legislatures for various states indicates that almost all of them contain an identical or similar provision – Therefore, it was legally permissible for the Speaker to reconvene the sitting of the Vidhan Sabha after it was adjourned sine die without prorogation – Further, the Speaker was empowered as the sole custodian of the proceedings of the House to adjourn and reconvene the House. [Paras 34, 35, 41] Constitution of India – Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Punjab Vidhan Sabha (Punjab Legislative Assembly) – The dispute in the present case essentially bears upon the Governor having detained four Bills which were passed by the Vidhan Sabha on 20.06.2023:
Held: There is no valid constitutional basis to cast doubt on the validity of the session of the Vidhan Sabha which was held on 19.06.2023, 20.06.2023 and 20.10.2023 – Any attempt to cast doubt on the session of the legislature would be replete with grave perils to democracy – The Speaker who has been recognized to be a guardian of the privileges of the House and the constitutionally recognized authority who represents the House, was acting well within his jurisdiction in adjourning the House sine die – The re-convening of the House was within the ambit of Rule 16 of the Rules of Procedure – Casting doubt on the validity of the session of the House is not a constitutional option open to the Governor – The Legislative Assembly comprises of duly elected Members of the Legislature – During the tenure of the Assembly, the House is governed by the decisions which are taken by the Speaker in matters of adjournment and prorogation – Therefore, this Court is of the considered view that the Governor of Punjab must now proceed to take a decision on the Bills which have been submitted for assent on the basis that the sitting of the House which was conducted on 19.06.2023, 20.06.2023 and 20.10.2023 was constitutionally valid. [Para 44]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
Ramdas Athawale v. Union of India and Others [2010] 3 SCR 1059 : (2010) 4 SCC 1; SR Bommai v. Union of India [1994] 2 SCR 644 : (1994) 3 SCC 1 – followed.
Samsher Singh v. State of Punjab [1975] 1 SCR 814 :(1974) 2 SCC 831; State (NCT of Delhi) v. Union of India [2018] 7 SCR 1 : (2018) 8 SCC 501 – relied on.
State of Punjab v. Principal Secretary to the Governor of Punjab Writ Petition (Civil) No 302 of 2023; State of Telangana v. Secretary to Her Excellency the Hon’ble Governor for the State of Telangana & Anr WP(C) No. 333 of 2023 – referred to.
STATE OF PUNJAB v. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNOR
OF PUNJAB AND ANOTHER
SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.780
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION: Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1224 of 2023.
(Under Article 32 of The Constitution of India)
Appearances:
Shadan Farasat, AAG, Gurminder Singh, AG/Sr. Adv., Dr. Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Sr. Adv., Ms. Nupur Kumar, Amit Bhandari, Ms. Natasha Maheshwari, Ms. Muskan Nagpal, Advs. for the Petitioner.
Tushar Mehta, SG, Satya Pal Jain, Sr. Adv., Abhinav Mukerji, Mrs. Bihu Sharma, Advs. for the Respondents.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
DR DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI
Table of Contents* I. Factual background ............................................................... 3 II. Submissions ............................................................................ 7 III. Analysis .............................................................................. 9 A. The Governor is a symbolic head and cannot withhold action on Bills passed by the State Legislature ............................................................ 9 B. Reconvening a sitting of the Vidhan Sabha which has not been prorogued is permissible in law and is within the exclusive domain of the Speaker .............. 18 *Ed. Note: The pagination as per the original Judgment.
1. Distinction between adjournment and prorogation .. 18
2. Exclusive domain of the Speaker to regulate the procedure of the House ................................................. 23 IV. Conclusion ............................................................................ 26
1. The jurisdiction of this Court under Article 32 of the Constitution has been invoked by the State of Punjab. The Government of Punjab is aggrieved on the ground that the Governor did not (i) assent to four Bills which were passed by the Vidhan Sabha nor have they been returned; and
(ii) furnish a recommendation for the introduction of certain Money Bills in the Vidhan Sabha.
I. Factual background
2. On 22 February 2023, the Council of Ministers of the Government of Punjab forwarded a recommendation to the Governor of Punjab seeking the summoning of the Punjab Vidhan Sabha for its Budget Session commencing on 3 March 2023. The Governor’s refusal to do so, on the ground that he was seeking legal advice, led to the institution of a petition before this Court on 25 February 2023. On 28 February 2023, this Court delivered its judgment in the State of Punjab v. Principal Secretary to the Governor of Punjab1. This Court observed that:
“There was no occasion to seek legal advice on whether or not the Budget Session of the Legislative Assembly should be convened. The Governor was plainly bound by the advice tendered to him by the Council of Ministers.”
3. While concluding its judgment, this Court had the following observations on the broader aspects of mature political governance in a democracy:
“Political differences in a democratic polity have to be worked upon and sorted out with a sense of sobriety and maturity. The dialogue between constitutional functionaries cannot degenerate into a race 1 Writ Petition (Civil) No 302 of 2023 STATE OF PUNJAB v. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNOR OF PUNJAB AND ANOTHER [DR DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.782 to the bottom. Unless these principles were to be borne in mind, the realization of constitutional values may be placed in jeopardy. Such a situation emerged before this Court, leading to the institution of a petition under Article 32 of the Constitution for a direction to the Governor to summon the Legislative Assembly. It is inconceivable that the Budget Session of the Legislative Assembly would not be convened. We can only hope that mature constitutional statesmanship will ensure that such instances do not occur in the future as much as we reiterate our expectation that constitutional functionaries must be cognizant of the public trust in the offices which they occupy. The public trust which is entrusted to them is intended to sub-serve the cause of our citizens and to ensure that the affairs of the nation are conducted with a sense of equanimity so as to accomplish the objects of the Preamble to the Constitution.”
4. Following the decision of this Court, the Sixteenth Punjab Vidhan Sabha was summoned on 3 March 2023. The Speaker adjourned the session sine die on 22 March 2023. On 12 June 2023, acting in pursuance of the powers conferred by the second proviso to Rule 16 of the Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in the Punjab Vidhan Sabha (Punjab Legislative Assembly)2, the Speaker reconvened the sitting of the session of the Vidhan Sabha on 19 and 20 June 2023. During the course of the session, the Vidhan Sabha passed four Bills, namely:
(i) The Sikh Gurdwaras (Amendment) Bill 2023;
(ii) Punjab Affiliated Colleges (Security of Service) (Amendment) Bill 2023;
(iii) Punjab Universities Law (Amendment) Bill 2023; and
(iv) Punjab Police (Amendment) Bill 2023 No action was taken by the Governor on these Bills.
5. Thereafter, the session of the Vidhan Sabha was sought to be reconvened on 19 October 2023 since the following three Money Bills were to be introduced :
2 “Rules of Procedure”
(i) The Punjab Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (Amendment) Bill, 2023;
(ii) The Punjab Goods and Services Tax (Amendment) Bill 2023; and
(iii) The Indian Stamp (Punjab Amendment) Bill 2023 The recommendation of the Governor was required in terms of the provisions of Article 207(1) of the Constitution for the introduction of the Bill in the Vidhan Sabha.
6. Correspondence was exchanged between the Chief Minister and the Governor. On 15 July 2023, the Chief Minister addressed a communication to the Governor noting that though the Sikh Gurudwaras (Amendment) Bill 2023 was submitted for assent on 26 June 2023, it had not been assented to till then. In his response dated 17 July 2023, the Governor stated that: “I have proceeded to receive legal advice which gives me to believe that your calling of Vidhan Sabha session on 19-6-2023 and 20-6-2023 when these four Bills were passed was in breach of law and procedure” The Governor thereby cast doubt on the legitimacy and legality of those Bills. The Governor stated that “in the background of the legal advice received” he was actively considering whether to obtain the legal opinion of the Attorney General for India “or as per the Constitution, to reserve these Bills for the consideration and consent of the President of India”. The Governor stated that he would take action according to law after the legality of the Vidhan Sabha session which was held on 19 and 20 June 2023 is first examined.
7. The Governor addressed another letter on 24 July 2023 to the Chief Minister annexing a “crux of legal opinion” obtained from a “constitutional expert”, according to which “the House so summoned was patiently (sic) illegal”. After the three Money Bills were forwarded to the Governor for consideration in the special session of the Fourth Budget Session of the Sixteenth Punjab Vidhan Sabha, proposed to be held from 20 October 2023, the Governor addressed a communication to the Chief Minister on 19 October 2023. He reiterated that in his previous communications dated 24 July 2023 and 12 October 2023, he had indicated that the calling of the session was “patently illegal, against the accepted procedures and practice STATE OF PUNJAB v. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNOR OF PUNJAB AND ANOTHER [DR DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.784 of the legislature, and against the provisions of the Constitution”. The Governor stated:
“As the Budget Session stood concluded, any such extended session is bound to be illegal, and any business conducted during such sessions is likely to be unlawful, and ab-initio void. Inspite of these communications, disregarding the possibility of taking an unconstitutional step, it appears that a decision has been taken to call the session. For these reasons I withhold my approval to the above mentioned Bills.”
8. Notably, the Governor did not ‘declare’ in any public notification that he is withholding his assent to the Bills. The Governor advised the Chief Minister to call for a fresh Monsoon/Winter Session and to forward an agenda setting out the specific business to be conducted so as to enable him to grant permission for the summoning of the House to transact the business.
9. Aggrieved by the inaction of the Governor, the State of Punjab invoked the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 32 of the Constitution. The State of Punjab seeks:
(a) A declaration that the Sessions held on 19 June 2023, 20 June 2023 and 20 October 2023 of the Punjab Vidhan Sabha are legal and that the business transacted by the House is valid; and
(b) A mandamus to the effect that the seven Bills which have been kept pending by the Governor including the three Money Bills be processed in accordance with law.
10. This Court entertained the Petition on 6 November 2023. During the course of the hearing, the Court has been apprised of the fact that after the institution of the Petition, the Governor has recommended that two out of the three Money Bills, namely, the Punjab Goods and Services Tax (Amendment) Bill 2023; and the Indian Stamp (Punjab Amendment) Bill 2023, may be introduced before the Vidhan Sabha.
II. Submissions
11. During the course of the hearing, we have heard submissions on behalf of the petitioners by Dr Abhishek Manu Singhvi, senior counsel who appeared with Mr Gurminder Singh, Advocate General for the State of Punjab. Mr. Satya Pal Jain, senior counsel appeared on behalf of the Principal Secretary to the Governor.
12. The principal submissions which have been urged on behalf of the petitioners are that:
(a) Though the Budget Session of the Legislative Assembly was summoned on 3 March 2023, it was adjourned sine die on 22 March 2023 by the Speaker without prorogation;
(b) The adjournment of the House sine die could not have been treated by the Governor as a prorogation of the House;
(c) The Speaker was acting within the exercise of constitutional jurisdiction, as evinced by the provisions of the Rules of Procedure governing the Vidhan Sabha, in reconvening the sitting of the Assembly on 19 and 20 June 2023 under the second proviso to Rule 16;
(d) Regulating the rules of procedure and the conduct of business in the House lies within the sole discretion of the Speaker;
(e) The Governor as a symbolic head of State did not act within the scope of his constitutional powers in coming to the conclusion that reconvening of the session of the Vidhan Sabha in June 2023 was unconstitutional, thereby rendering the legislative business which was transacted on 20 June 2023 void; and
(f) The consequence of the decision of the Speaker is to virtually nullify the legislations which have been passed by an overwhelming majority of the Members of the Legislative Assembly.
13. On the other hand, it has been urged on behalf of the Secretary to the Governor that:
(i) After the business of the Budget Session had been transacted, the House was required to be prorogued and it was not open to the Speaker to adjourn the proceeding sine die to be reconvened initially on 19 and 20 June 2023 and thereafter on 19 and 20 October 2023; STATE OF PUNJAB v. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNOR OF PUNJAB AND ANOTHER [DR DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.786
(ii) Rule 14A of the Rules of Procedure requires that three sessions should be held in the Vidhan Sabha, namely, the Budget Session, the Monsoon Session and the Winter Session and hence, it was not open to the Speaker to continue the Budget Session in the month of June 2023;
(iii) The Governor has, as a matter of fact, assented to as many as 185 Bills which were presented to him for assent, which would clearly indicate that there has been no delay on the part of the Governor and it is only in view of the objection to the manner in which the House was adjourned sine die that assent to the four Bills was withheld;
(iv) Subsequentl y, the Governor has even granted his recommendation for the introduction of two of the three Money Bills in the Vidhan Sabha;
(v) In the reliefs which have been claimed in the petition under Article 32 of the Constitution, the petitioners themselves seek a declaration that the sessions which were held on 19 and 20 June 2023 and the business which was transacted was legal, which is an indication of the fact that the State of Punjab itself is unsure about the validity of the session; and
(vi) The Governor would have no objection whatsoever to deal with the Bills in respect of which assent has been sought if this Court were to clarify that the Budget Session was lawfully adjourned sine die so as to be reconvened in the month of June 2023.
14. Two issues arise for consideration: first, whether the Governor can withhold action on Bills which have been passed by the State Legislature; and second, whether it is permissible in law for the Speaker to reconvene a sitting of a Vidhan Sabha session which has been adjourned but has not been prorogued.
III. Analysis A. The Governor is a symbolic head and cannot withhold action on Bills passed by the State Legislature
15. In a Parliamentary form of democracy real power vests in the elected representatives of the people. The governments, both in the States and at the Centre consist of members of the State Legislature, and, as the case may be, Parliament. Members of the government in a Cabinet form of government are accountable to and subject to scrutiny by the legislature. The Governor as an appointee of the President is the titular head of State. The fundamental principle of constitutional law which has been consistently followed since the Constitution was adopted is that the Governor acts on the ‘aid and advise’ of the Council of Ministers, save and except in those areas where the Constitution has entrusted the exercise of discretionary power to the Governor. This principle cements the bedrock of the constitutional foundation that the power to take decisions affecting the governance of the State, or as the case may be of the nation essentially lies with the elected arm of the government. The Governor is intended to be a constitutional statesman, guiding the government on matters of constitutional concern.
16. These principles have been well established since the decision in Samsher Singh v. State of Punjab3, where this Court held:
“28. Under the Cabinet system of Government as embodied in our Constitution the Governor is the constitutional or formal head of the State and he exercises all his powers and functions conferred on him by or under the Constitution on the aid and advice of his Council of Ministers save in spheres where the Governor is required by or under the Constitution to exercise his functions in his discretion. …
32. It is a fundamental principle of English Constitutional law that Ministers must accept responsibility for every executive act. In England the Sovereign never acts on his own responsibility. The power of the Sovereign is conditioned by the practical rule that the Crown must find advisers to bear responsibility for his action. Those advisers must have the confidence of the House of Commons. This rule of English Constitutional Law is incorporated in our Constitution. The Indian Constitution envisages a Parliamentary and responsible
3 (1974) 2 SCC 831
STATE OF PUNJAB v. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNOR OF PUNJAB AND ANOTHER [DR DHANANJAYA Y CHANDRACHUD, CJI] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 15 S.C.R.788 form of Government at the Centre and in the States and not a Presidential form of Government. The powers of the Governor as the constitutional head are not different.”
17. In SR Bommai v. Union of India4 a nine judge bench of this Court has held that federalism is a part of the basic structure of the Constitution. The manner in which the role of the Governor as a symbolic Head of State is performed is vital to safeguard this basic feature. The exercise of unbridled discretion in areas not entrusted to the discretion of the Governor risks walking rough shod over the working of a democratically elected government at the State. In a steady line of cases this Court has strengthened the importance of institutions and their vitality to democratic functioning. Federalism and democracy, both parts of the basic structure, are inseparable. When one feature is diluted it puts the other in peril. The tuning fork of democracy and federalism is vital to the realization of the fundamental freedoms and aspirations of our citizens. Whenever one prong of the tuning fork is harmed, it damages the apparatus of constitutional governance.
18. In State (NCT of Delhi) v. Union of India,5 one of us (D Y Chandrachud J) observed:
“287. … These cases involve vital questions about democratic governance and the role of institutions in fulfilling constitutional values. The Constitution guarantees to every individual the freedom to adopt a way of life in which liberty, dignity and autonomy form the core. The Constitution pursues a vision of fulfilling these values through a democratic polity. The disputes which led to these cases tell us how crucial institutions are to the realisation of democracy. It is through them that the aspirations of a democratic way of life, based on the rule of law, are fulfilled. Liberty, dignity and autonomy are constraining influences on the power of the State. Fundamental human freedoms limit the authority of the State. Yet the role of institutions in achieving democracy is as significant. Nations fail when institutions of governance fail. The working of a democratic institution is impacted by the statesmanship (or the lack of it)
4 (1994) 3 SCC 1
5 (2018) 8 SCC 501
shown by those in whom the electorate vests the trust to govern. In a society such as ours, which is marked by a plurality of cultures, a diversity of tradition, an intricate web of social identity and a clatter of ideologies, institutional governance to be robust must accommodate each one of them. Criticism and dissent form the heart of democratic functioning. The responsiveness of institutions is determined in a large measure by their ability to be receptive to differences and perceptive to the need for constant engagement and dialogue. Constitutional skirmishes are not unhealthy. They test the resilience of democracy. How good a system works in practice must depend upon the statesmanship of those who are in decision-making positions within them. Hence, these cases are as much about interpreting the Constitution as they are about the role of institutions in the structure of democratic governance and the frailties of those who must answer the concerns of citizens.”
19. The dispute in the present case essentially bears upon the Governor having detained four Bills which were passed by the Vidhan Sabha on 20 June 2023. Article 2006 of the Constitution postulates that when a Bill has been passed by the Legislative Assembly of a State or, in the case of a bicameral legislature, by both the Houses, it shall be presented to the Governor. The Governor has three options available when a Bill which has 6 When a Bill has been passed by the Legislative Assembly of a State or, in the case of a State having a Legislative Council, has been passed by both Houses of the Legislature of the State, it shall be presented to the Governor and the Governor shall declare either that he assents to the Bill or that he withholds assent therefrom or that he reserves the Bill for the consideration of the President:
Provided that the Governor may, as soon as possible after the presentation to him of the Bill for assent, return the Bill if it is not a Money Bill together with a message requesting that the House or Houses will reconsider the Bill or any specified provisions thereof and, in particular, will consider the desirability of introducing any such amendments as he may recommend in his message and, when a Bill is so returned, the House or Houses shall reconsider the Bill accordingly, and if the Bill is passed again by the House or Houses with or without amendment and presented to the Governor for assent, the Governor shall not withhold assent therefrom:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.