Union of India and Others v. Dilip Paul
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 975; [2023] 13 S.C.R. 473
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justice J.B. Pardiwala
- Decided
- 6 Nov 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 6190/2023
- Sections
- 165, 2, 99, 465, 327
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2023] 13 S.C.R. 473 : 2023 INSC 975
CASE DETAILS
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS
V.
DILIP PAUL
(Civil Appeal No. 6190 of 2023)
NOVEMBER 06, 2023
[DR. DHANANJAYA Y. CHANDRACHUD, CJI, J. B. PARDIWALA AND MANOJ MISRA, JJ.]
HEADNOTES
Issues for consideration:
In an appeal directed against the judgment passed by the High Court by which it allowed the writ petition filed by respondent and thereby set aside the order of penalty of withholding of 50% of his pension for all times to come, imposed upon the respondent in connection with disciplinary proceedings initiated against him on allegations of a lady employee of sexual harassment at workplace, the following questions arose for consideration:- I. Whether the Central Complaints Committee constituted by the Competent authority to inquire into the first complaint dated 30.08.2011 committed error in looking into the second complaint dated 18.09.2012 containing additional allegations against the respondent alongwith few other documents including anonymous complaints made against the respondent in October 2011;
II. Whether the Central Complaints Committee erred in assuming the role of a prosecutor by putting questions to the witnesses in the course of departmental enquiry and thereby vitiating the disciplinary proceedings; and III. Whether the Central Complaints Committee could be said to have based its findings on mere conjectures and surmises and the case on hand was one of “No Evidence”
Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 – Standing Order No. 1 of 2006 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.474 (Grievances Redressal Mechanism: To Redress Grievances of Women/ Sexual Harassment at Work Place) – Clauses 9 and 10(i) – Sexual harassment at workplace – Lady employee lodged complaint against respondent and subsequently submitted another (second) complaint containing additional allegations against respondent alongwith few other documents including anonymous complaints made against the respondent – Central Complaint Committee, constituted to inquire into the first complaint, also looked into the second complaint – High Court held that the Central Complaints Committee was constituted by the competent authority to only inquire into the first complaint – Correctness of.
Held: Irrespective of whether a prior complaint had already been made to any authority, a complaint regarding sexual harassment could be made under Clause 10(i) of the 2006 Standing Order to the complaints committee as-well – In the instant case, the second complaint had been promptly preferred right after the Central Complaints Committee was constituted and duly before its first hearing – The High Court’s reasoning that as the Central Complaints Committee was constituted on the basis of the first complaint, its scope of inquiry was restricted to its content, is completely erroneous inasmuch as the Central Complaints Committee owed its existence to the 2006 Standing Order and not to the complaint – Moreover, even if it is assumed for a moment that the complaints committee owed its existence to the complaint, Clause 10(i) of the 2006 Standing Order envisages filing of a complaint to the complaints committee i.e., it envisages a situation where after a complaints committee had come into existence, a complaint may be preferred to it – In sensitive matters such as sexual harassment & misconduct, there is an obligation to look into the entire evidence of the complainant that inspires confidence – It would be quite preposterous to hold that the complainant was precluded from making the second complaint before the Central Complaints Committee merely because she had already made one complaint – In the context of the second complaint, the only relevant aspect that required consideration was whether any serious prejudice was caused to the respondent – On facts, no prejudice could be said to have been caused to the respondent even if one believes that he was not asked to plead guilty to the second complaint – High Court mechanically proceeded to set-aside the order of punishment imposed by the disciplinary authority on the ground that there was nothing to indicate that the respondent was asked whether he pleaded guilty to the charges imputed in the second complaint without applying the principle of “test of prejudice” [Paras 49, 50, 55, 56, 65 and 66] Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 – Standing Order No. 1 of 2006 (Grievances Redressal Mechanism: To Redress Grievances of Women/ Sexual Harassment at Work Place) – Clause 10(viii) – Sexual harassment at workplace – Lady employee lodged complaint – Disciplinary proceedings conducted under Rule 14 of the 1965 CCS Rules – Central Complaint Committee constituted by the Competent authority to make inquiry had put questions to the witnesses in a departmental inquiry – Whether the same vitiated the inquiry proceedings – Service Law – Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 – r.14 – Disciplinary proceedings – “Fact Finding” Authority. Held: It is the Inquiry Authority and the Disciplinary Authority who are the fact finding authorities in a disciplinary proceeding – A perusal of r.14 of the 1965 CCS Rules makes it clear that, where a ‘Presenting Officer’ has been appointed by the Disciplinary Authority, such Officer shall present the case in support of the articles of charge. Conversely, what logically transpires from the aforesaid is that, where no presenting officer has been appointed, the duty or role to present the case in support of the articles of charge falls back on the Disciplinary Authority or the Inquiry Authority as the case may be – The power and discretion of the complaints committee to put question to the witnesses is further reflected though implicitly in Clause 10(viii) of the 2006 Standing Order – There appears to be neither any statutory bar nor any logic to restrict the power of the complaints committee to put questions to the witnesses only to the context enumerated in the aforesaid provision – One fails to understand what other purpose the complaints committee which is deemed to be an ‘inquiry authority’ would serve, if it is held that the complaints committee cannot put questions to the witnesses – If s.165 of the Evidence Act, 1872 permits a Judge to put questions to the parties or to the witnesses in order to discover or obtain proper proof of relevant facts and this provision being widely used by the judges throughout the country, how the complaints committee after being equated with a judge UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.476 in a judicial proceeding can be denied that privilege – High Court was not correct in taking the view that the proceedings stood vitiated because the Central Complaints Committee put questions to the prosecution witnesses. [Paras 69,73,75, 77 and 78] Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 – Whether the Central Complaints Committee based its findings on conjectures and surmises – Whether the instant case is one of “no evidence”.
Held: The evidence taken into consideration by the Central Complaints Committee for arriving at the conclusion that the charges were held to be proved would indicate that this was not a case of “no evidence” – Some evidence has come on record to indicate or rather substantiate the allegations of sexual harassment levelled by the complainant – The allegation related to the respondent making unsolicited phone calls to the complainant, although no evidence of the call recordings had been produced to substantiate the same, was rightly accepted by the Central Complaints Committee keeping in mind the background of the case – The findings of the Central Complaints Committee could not be said to be based on conjectures and surmises – The Central Complaints Committed duly noted that the non-availability of the call records was owed to the fact that the inquiry into the complainant’s grievances was undertaken after a lapse of significant time – Moreover, said finding is fortified by the oral evidence of one of the witnesses who deposed that he was aware of the respondent making calls to the complainant. [Paras 94, 95, 96 and 97] Service Law – Disciplinary inquiry – Standard of Proof.
Held: In a disciplinary inquiry, the standard of proof is preponderance of probabilities – The courts must only interfere where the findings are either perverse or based on no evidence at all. [Para 93] Service Law – Disciplinary proceedings – Scope of judicial review. Held: It is well settled that when it comes to disciplinary proceedings, it is the inquiry authority and the disciplinary authority who could be said to be the fact-finding authority and the courts in exercise of their powers of judicial review should not sit in appeal and re-appreciate the evidence or substitute its own findings – The scope of judicial review of the courts is limited only to the propriety of the decision-making process and the fairness of the inquiry procedure. [Para 42] Doctrines / Principles – Principle of “Test of Prejudice” – In Service Jurisprudence – Discussed. [Paras 57 and 58] Doctrines / Principles – Principle of “No Evidence” – In Service Jurisprudence – Discussed. [Paras 79, 80, 86 and 89] Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013 – Historical Background – Statutory Scheme – Discussed. [Paras 31-38] Crime against Women – Sexual harassment – Veracity and genuineness of complaint should be scrutinised to prevent misuse – Duty of the courts.
Held: Sexual harassment in any form at the work place must be viewed seriously – However, the charge of this nature is very easy to make and is very difficult to rebut – When a plea is taken of false implication for extraneous reasons, the courts have a duty to make deeper scrutiny of the evidence and decide the acceptability or otherwise of the accusations – The veracity and genuineness of the complaint should be scrutinised to prevent any misuse of such laudable laws enunciated for the upliftment of the society and for equal rights of people without gender discrimination by anybody under the garb of “sexual harassment”, lest justice rendering system would become a mockery. [Para 2]
LIST OF CITATIONS AND OTHER REFERENCES
State of Haryana and Another v. Rattan Singh (1977) 2 SCC 491; Pravin Kumar v. Union of India and Others (2020) 9 SCC 471 : [2020] 7 SCR 1078; Apparel Export Promotion Council v. A.K. Chopra (1999) 1 SCC 759 : [1999] 1 SCR 117; West Bokaro Colliery (TISCO Ltd.) v. Ram Pravesh Singh (2008) 3 SCC 729 : [2008] 2 SCR 247; B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India & Ors. (1995) 6 SCC 749 : [1995] 4 Suppl. SCR 644; Union of India and Others v. Mudrika Singh (2021) 14 SCALE 509 and Managing Director, ECIL, Hyderabad and Others v. B. Karunakar and Others (1993) 4 SCC 727 : [1993] 2 Suppl. SCR 576 - relied on.
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.478 Vishaka and Others v. State of Rajasthan and Others (1997) 6 SCC 241 : [1997] 3 Suppl. SCR 404; Medha Kotwal Lele and Others v. Union of India and Others (2013) 1 SCC 297 : [2012] 9 SCR 895; Aureliano Fernandes v. State of Goa and Others 2023 SCC OnLine SC 621; State Bank of Patiala and Others v. S.K. Sharma (1996) 3 SCC 364 : [1996] 3 SCR 972; State of U.P. v. Harendra Arora and Another (2001) 6 SCC 392 : [2001] 3 SCR 375; Sakshi v. Union of India and Others (2004) 5 SCC 518 : [2004] 2 Suppl. SCR 723; State of Andhra Pradesh and Others v. S. Sree Rama Rao AIR 1963 SC 1723 : [1964] 3 SCR 25; State of Andhra Pradesh and Others v. Chitra Venkata Rao (1975) 2 SCC 557 : [1976] 1 SCR 521; Union of India v. H.C. Goel AIR 1964 SC 364 : [1964] 4 SCR 718; R. Mahalingam v. Chairman, Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission and Another (2013) 14 SCC 379; Vijay Shankar Pandey v. Union of India (2014) 10 SCC 589 : [2014] 13 SCR 1238 - referred to.
Regina v. Deputy Industrial Injuries Commissioner, Ex parte Moore (1965) 1 Q.B. 456; The King v. Carson Roberts 1908 (1) K.B., 407; French Kier Developments Ltd. v. Secretary of State for the Environment 1977 (1) All ELR 297 and Edward (Inspector of Taxes, Bairstow) (1956) Appeal Cases, 14 - referred to.
Bernard Schwartz’s Treatise on Administrative Law, 1976 Edition, at page 595 – referred to.
OTHER CASE DETAILS INCLUDING IMPUGNED
ORDER AND APPEARANCES
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 6190 of 2023. From the Judgment and Order dated 15.05.2019 of the High Court of Gauhati in WPC No.7876 of 2015.
Appearances:
K. Parmeshwar, Ms. Rekha Pandey, Ms. Vaishali Verma, Ms. Manjula Gupta, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Advs. for the Appellant.
Avijit Roy, Adv. for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT / ORDER OF THE SUPREME COURT
JUDGMENT
J. B. PARDIWALA, J.
For the convenience of the exposition, this judgement is divided in the following parts: - INDEX* A. FACTUAL MATRIX ..................................................................................4 A.1 On-Spot/Preliminary Inquiry Report.................................................6 A.2 Frontier Complaints Committee’s Inquiry Report............................9 A.3 Central Complaints Committee’s Inquiry Report...........................10 A.4 Defence of the Respondent ..............................................................23 A.5 Proceedings before the CAT ............................................................23 A.6 Proceedings before the High Court .................................................25
B. IMPUGNED ORDER PASSED BY THE HIGH COURT .................26
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT .....................29
D. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT ..................32
E. ANALYSIS ..................................................................................................37 E.1 Relevant Statutory Scheme and Case Law .............................38 E.2 Whether the Central Complaints Committee could have looked into the second complaint dated 18.09.2012?................................................................................65 i) Principle of “Test of Prejudice” in Service Jurisprudence .............................................................................71 E.3 Whether the Central Complaints Committee could have put questions to the witnesses in a departmental inquiry?.......81 i) “Fact Finding” Authority in Disciplinary Proceedings ........81 UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL *Ed. Note: Pagination in the Index is as per the original judgment. SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.480 E.4 Whether the Central Complaints Committee based its findings on conjectures and surmises? Whether the case on hand is one of “no evidence”? .......................................87 i) Principle of “No Evidence” in Service Jurisprudence ....87 ii) Standard of Proof in Disciplinary Proceedings ..............95 F. CONCLUSION........................................................................104 The Registry is directed to anonymize the name of the complainant in this Judgment, all orders that have been passed as well as in the records which are publicly available.
1. This appeal is at the instance of the Union of India and others being the unsuccessful respondents before the High Court and is directed against the judgement and order dated 15.05.2019 passed by the Gauhati High Court in Writ Petition (C) No. 7876 of 2015 by which the High Court allowed the writ petition filed by the respondent herein (original petitioner) and thereby set aside the order of penalty of withholding of 50% pension for all times to come, imposed upon the respondent herein in connection with the disciplinary proceedings initiated on the allegations of sexual harassment.
2. We are dealing with a litigation relating to sexual harassment. Sexual harassment in any form at the work place must be viewed seriously and the harasser should not be allowed to escape from the clutches of law. We say so because the same humiliates and frustrates a victim of sexual harassment, more particularly when the harasser goes unpunished or is let off with a relatively minor penalty. However, at the same time, it should be kept in mind that the charge of this nature is very easy to make and is very difficult to rebut. When a plea is taken of false implication for extraneous reasons, the courts have a duty to make deeper scrutiny of the evidence and decide the acceptability or otherwise of the accusations. Every care should be taken to separate the chaff from the grain. The veracity and genuineness of the complaint should be scrutinised to prevent any misuse of such laudable laws enunciated for the upliftment of the society and for equal rights of people without gender discrimination by anybody under the garb of “sexual harassment”, lest justice rendering system would become a mockery. In such circumstances, we have decided to look into this matter closely and in details.
A. FACTUAL MATRIX
3. The respondent herein was serving as the Area Organizer i.e., the Local Head of Office of the Service Selection Board (for short, “the SSB”), Rangia, State of Assam between September, 2006 to May, 2012. In the very same office, a lady employee was serving as the Field Assistant (Lady) (hereinafter referred to as the “complainant”). She lodged a complaint (hereinafter referred to as the “first complaint”) addressed to the Inspector General (for short, “IG”), Frontier Headquarters, Guwahati with one copy each forwarded to the DG SSB, New Delhi, Dy. IG, SSB, SHQ, Tezpur and the Chairperson of the National Women Rights Commission, New Delhi inter alia alleging sexual harassment at the hands of the respondent. The first complaint dated 30.08.2011 reads thus: - “To, The Inspector General, Frontier Hqrs. SSB Guwahati Subject: Regarding information of personal grievances thereof. Hon’ble Sir, With due respect and humility, I the undersigned to draw your kind attention to the following matter.
1. I have joined the office of the A.O Rangia in March, 2009, Since my joining I have been entrusted the task of receiving telephones and Mobiles in the Control Room, CAP, Training, Sports. Then I was the only female employee in the Office.
2. Having just started discharging my duties devotedly the AO Mr. Dilip Paul started teasing me tactically. He started making phone calls to me sometimes at night using unofficial and multimeaninged word. Even he went to the extent of visiting my residence where I stay alone with two of my children as my husband is a state Government employee in Manipur.
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.482
3. Sometimes CAP work needs close working with the officers. Taking the advantage he used to call me in his room and started teasing indirectly and unnecessarily makes me sit for hours. One day he went to the extent of saying “If you want to work happily in my office, then agree to my saying.
4. I have been tolerating his acts since the last two and half years. I could neither inform my husband nor lodge any written complaint against such acts as it will be difficult to give evidence. Unable to bear the situation I have verbally complaint to the then DIG Shri S. C. Katoch over Telephone in May, 2010 about Mr. Paul uncivilized altitude. The DIG did a favour and warned Mr. Paul of severe consequences if he did not stopped misbehaving.
5. Since then, he stopped teasing but instead began torturing me mentally. I have not been entrusted any work and ex-communicated in the office. Throughout the day all I have to do is sit silently in the office. If any of my colleagues talk with me, Mr. Paul would immediately call him and scold him bitterly. Sir, I am now so much depressed and mentally disturbed I have visited to the Doctors many times for which I have taken many medical leaves. Now, I am not in position to work even for a day under him. It also began affecting my family life.
6. In view of the above, I request your kind honour to look into the matter sympathetically and it is also requested to take necessary action against the Shri D. Paul, AO Rangia to get rid of this problem as soon as possible for which I shall remain ever grateful to you.
Yours faithfully, Sd/- 30.8.2011 (Smt. X)
FA (Lady)
A.O. Office, SSB Rangia”
A.1 On-Spot/Preliminary Inquiry Report
4. The Dy. IG, SSB, SHQ, Tezpur held a common “on-the-spot” fact finding inquiry in relation to the first complaint dated 30.08.2011 and recorded the statements of the employees working in the office of the respondent. The respondent was given an opportunity to file his reply to the allegations levelled in the complaints. On 13.12.2011, the “on-the-spot” fact finding inquiry was concluded, and two reports in that regard were submitted to the IG, Frontier HQ, Guwahati.
a) On the first complaint of sexual harassment, the staff members stated that they had not seen anything in the office which could be termed as indirect teasing or harassment to the complainant. The report reads as under: - “To The Inspector General, Frontier Hqrs. SSB Guwahati, Sub: Inquiry on complaints lodged by Smt. X FA(Lady) against Shri D. Paul, Area Organiser, SSB Rangia.
Sir, With reference to Ftr. Hqrs. Ghy. letter No. FG-II/VC- VIG/08(Part)/15293 dt. 01-09-11, I visited the Office of the Area Organiser, SSB Rangia on 1st November, 2011 and enquired into the matter. All the staff available in the office on the date, were summoned one after another individually, but none of them stated to have seen or known Shri Dilip Paul, Area Organiser misbehaving with Smt. X, FA(Lady) in the office. Further most of them stated that due to reasons best known to Shri Paul, Area Organiser, she was not allotted with any work for about 3 months before her release on transfer to Ftr. Hqrs. Ghy. and hence she was often seen depress.
On the other hand, in his written statement Shri Dilip Paul, Area Organiser pointed out that she was found even unfit in any kind of assignment, and therefore, she was not assigned with any work just UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.484 before her transfer i.e. from 18-08-11. But it is also duty of supervisory officer as administrator and manager to somehow motivate his subordinate staff and take work from them.
In the case of Smt. X, FA(Lady), Shri Dilip Paul, Area Organiser, is found to have failed to motivate her and get work from her. Regarding allegation of tactical and indirect teasing and making her to sit in the office chamber of Area Organiser, hours together, none of the staff have stated to have ever seen such situation in the office. Hence the allegation of direct/indirect teasing and harassments to Smt. X, FA(L) by Shri Dilip Paul could not be ascertained. However, since Smt. X referred the case to National Women Rights Commission, New Delhi the matter may be under investigation by them.
Yours faithfully Deputy Inspector General SHQ, SSB, Tezpur”
b) Similarly, as per the report on the anonymous complaints, nothing substantive was found as regards the allegations. The said report further noted that during the inquiry the only thing that surfaced was the occasional rudeness and uncordial inter-personal relations of the respondent with three of his subordinate employees. Accordingly, the respondent was advised to improve his personnel management and administration of the office. The said report reads as under: - “To The Inspector General, Frontier Hqrs. SSB Guwahati.
Sub: Enquiry report on Anonymous Complaint against Shri D. Paul, Area Organiser, SSB, Rangia Sir, With reference to Ftr. Hqrs. Ghy. letter No. FG-II/VC-VIG/08(Part)/5660 dt 08-09-11, I visited Office ·Of the Area Organiser, SSB, Rangia on 1st November, 2011 and enquired into the matter. All the staff present in the office on the date, were summoned one after another individually. I obtained their statements individually and on the basis of the interaction with each of them; I opine as follow:
i) From the statements of the staff it is observed that Shri Dilip Paul, Area Organiser sometimes shout to some of the staff in the office, for the purpose of official work only. No proof has been found regarding use of unofficial language. One or two official stated that the Area Organiser used to be rude and shouted at them on some occasions on matters of official work only.
ii) Regarding passing of TA/DA, MR Bills etc. it is found that these works are going smoothly. There has been no occasion when he took interest of passing his own bill by neglecting that of others.
iii) Regarding granting of leave to staff and passing of bills etc. it is found that no refusal or delay occurred. However, while granting leave sometimes staff position and administrative convenience has been taken in to account.
iv) It is observed that Area Organiser is using his own vehicle to attend office.
v) On the basis of statement given by each staff and from the para-wise reply given by the Area Organiser, it is observed that there is no evidence regarding use of unnecessary slang language by the Area Organiser, to his sub-ordinate staff but at times he used to be rude to get the work done within the time limit, from some of the subordinate staff. It is further observed that there is no cordial inter personal relation between Shri P.B. Gohain, SAO, Shri K. Siga, SAO, Shri J Singh, UDC and Area Organiser, Shri Dilip Paul. Therefore, these officers/officials may be shifted out in order to bring back cordial working atmosphere in the Area Office. At the same time, Shri Dilip Paul, Area Organiser may be advised to improve upon his man management, administration and other official dealings, skills and tactics with his sub-ordinate staffto bring back congenial atmosphere in the office.
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.486 Yours faithfully Sd/- Deputy Inspector General Sector Hqrs. SSB, Tezpur”
A.2 Frontier Complaints Committee’s Inquiry Report
5. Simultaneously, a Frontier Complaints Committee comprising of three women members was constituted by the IG, Frontier HQ, Guwahati to inquire into the allegations of sexual harassment levelled by the complainant in her first complaint dated 30.08.2011. The Frontier Complaints Committee upon completion of the inquiry, submitted its report dated 17.01.2012 to the Frontier Headquarters SSB, New Delhi through the IG, Guwahati, stating that the allegations levelled by the complainant could not be said to have been fully established or proved. The Committee further observed that the complainant had lodged her first complaint after a delay of more than two years and had also failed to produce any documentary evidence in support of her allegations. The relevant observations of the Frontier Complaints Committee’s Inquiry Report are reproduced below: - “7) Finding of inquiring authority: - The inquiry committee assembled at FTR HQRs Guwahati on 25.01.2012 to ascertain the fact of the case. The committee has gone through the statements of complainant, charged officer, and the statements of prosecution /defense witnesses but the point raised in the complaint could not be fully established/ proved. The statement given by all the prosecution witnesses are not enough to prove the complaint. She has lodged a complaint after a gap of more than two years. The complainant failed to produce any documentary evidence based on the allegations levelled against the charged officer”
A.3 Central Complaints Committee’s Inquiry Report
6. While the Frontier Complaints Committee’s Report dated 17.01.2012 was pending for consideration, the Ministry of Home Affairs / Competent Authority, constituted another inquiry committee on 06.08.2012 being the Central Complaints Committee to conduct an appropriate inquiry into the complainant’s allegations of sexual harassment.
7. Prima facie, it appears from the materials on record that the Central Complaints Committee had to be constituted, in view of Clause 9 of the 2006 Standing Order. Clause 9 of the 2006 Standing Order envisages two levels of complaints committee; (i) a Frontier Complaints Committee for the “combatised and in-field officers” (ii) a Central Complaints Committee for the “non-combatised officers”. At the time of lodging of the complaint, the respondent was serving as a non-combatised officer i.e., Area Organizer. For such reason, the decision to constitute the Central Complaints Committee had to be taken.
8. On 18.09.2012, the complainant through fax submitted a second complaint containing additional allegations against the respondent (hereinafter referred to as the “second complaint”) along with few other documents including the anonymous complaints made against the respondent in October 2011.
9. Accordingly, the Central Complaints Committee undertook the inquiry, and in the preliminary hearing held on 27.09.2012, it decided to treat the complaint as the charge-sheet in view of the fact that no specific charges were framed against the respondent. The respondent was provided with all the relevant documents including the original copy of the first complaint dated 30.08.2011. After, confirming with the respondent as regards the receipt of all relevant documents, the Central Complaints Committee inquired with the respondent whether he pleaded guilty to the charges or not. The respondent pleaded not guilty and categorically denied the charges levelled against him. The relevant portion of the Central Complaints Committee’s Report reads as under: - “VI. CHARGES WHICH WERE ADMITTED/ DROPPED/ NOT
PRESSED:
Shri Dilip Paul, the charged officer did not plead guilty to any of the allegations made by Smt. X, FA (Lady) vide complaint dated 30.08.2011 framed against him.”
10. The Central Complaints Committee in the course of its inquiry examined in all 20 witnesses produced by the complainant (incl. 5 witnesses who were earlier examined by the Frontier Level Complaints Committee) and 6 witnesses on behalf of the respondent (incl. 1 witness earlier examined UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.488 by the Frontier Level Complaints Committee). Later, the Central Complaints Committee delineated the charges to be inquired by it into 10 distinct points. The points of determination framed by the Committee reads thus: - “VII. CHARGES ACTUALLY INQUIRED INTO AND POINTS
TO BE DETERMINED
The Complaints Committee is aware that aspects of this complaint are implicated in the FIR that Shri Dilip Paul lodged on 26.08.2011 at P.S. Rangia, on the matter of an allegedly threatening message sent to him on his mobile phones by Smt. X’s husband. In the counter-case filed by Smt. X’s husband, similar allegations of sexual harassment have been raised. The Committee has ascertained from the SP Kamrup that both the cases are still pending investigation. Nevertheless, going by what has been stated in the CCS, CCA Rules 14(3), which states that action of prosecution in a court and departmental proceedings can go on simultaneously. The CCS CCA Rules require the fact that the approach and objective in the criminal and disciplinary proceedings are altogether distinct and different, be kept in view, as is laid down by the various Supreme Court rulings to this effect. Accordingly, the Committee decide to proceed with enquiry and submit its findings. Smt. X has alleged that a few months after she joined Area Office, Rangia in April 2009, Shri Dilip Paul, then A.O. Rangia, started making unwelcome sexual advances to her, and that upon her refusal to submit to his advances and his sexually determined misconduct, he withdrew all work from her. She has cited the following incidents as the substance of her complaint.
Point 1: That Shri Dilip Paul would use the pretext of summoning into his room with work-related files in order to make comments of a sexually loaded and personal nature, such as remarks about her personal appearance and her looks, about how he wanted to marry a Manipuri girl like her. He would also boast at times about his sexual prowess and abilities in satisfying women who were unhappy with their husbands. He would also make comments that had a double meaning (of a sexual nature). On such occasions, he would detain her in his office for inordinately long periods. This charge, if substantiated, is admissible under the Vishaka definition of sexual harassment as it involves sexually coloured remarks and other unwelcome physical, verbal or non-verbal conduct of sexual nature. Furthermore, it may also be shown to be discriminatory if it is substantiated that Smt. X believed that her objection to Shri Dilip Paul’s conduct would disadvantage her in connection with her employment and her apprehension that it would create a hostile work environment.
Point 2: That Shri Dilip Paul would stare at her in the workplace, such as the repeated incidents in which he would come out from his office into the room that she was sitting, on the pretext of drinking water. This charge, if substantiated, is admissible under the Vishaka definition of sexual harassment as it involves sexually coloured remarks and other unwelcome physical, verbal or non-verbal conduct of sexual nature. Point 3: That Shri Dilip Paul would attempt to touch her in an unwelcome sexually determined manner in the workplace, such as an incident when, on the pretext of teaching her to operate a laptop, he come close to her and touched her shoulder and body. This charge, if substantiated, is admissible under the Vishaka definition of sexual harassment as it involves physical contact and advances and other unwelcome physical, verbal or non-verbal conduct of sexual nature. Furthermore, it may also be shown to be discriminatory if it is substantiated that Smt. X believed that her objection to Shri Dilip Paul’s conduct would disadvantage her in connection with her employment and her apprehension that if would create a hostile work environment. Point 4: That Shri Dilip Paul would often make her work much beyond office hours, often after 2000 hours. He would then offer to drop here in his vehicle to her home. In general, Shri Dilip Paul would pressure her to drive with him in his vehicle, either when she was returning from work or in the town.
Point 5: That Shri Dilip Paul, on the occasion that Smt. X with other office colleagues had accompanied him to the railway station to book train tickets for the study tour to South India in march 2010, made an unwelcome sexual advance to her in full public view. While she was standing in the queue at the ticket booking counter, Shri Dilip Paul came to stand next to her and putt his arm around her shoulder and tried to hug her close to his body. Shri Dilip Paul said to her that he UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.490 is sending her on the study tour to make her “mind fresh” so that she may forget her previous life and when she returned, begin a new one as Mrs. Paul.
Point 6: That Shri Dilip Paul subjected her to further unwelcome sexually determined conduct by the statements that he made when he came to the railway station to see off the group departing for the study tour. After the luggage had been loaded onto the train, Shri Dilip Paul came into the train compartment and said to Smt. X “tum jaa rahe ho to mari jaan jaa rahi hai. Ham ka saath jaanaa hi acchaa hota. Koi baat nahiin, tum study tour se waapas aa jaaoo, to tum Mrs Paul banogi.” Point 7: That Shri Dilip Paul made unwelcome sexual advances to her outside the workplace as well, where on several occasions, he propositioned her, asking her to leave her husband and marry him on the assurance that he would adopt her children as his own. Since July 2009, Shri Dilip Paul made it a habit to visit her uninvited and she felt unable to refuse entry to her hierarchically superior officer, fearing future discrimination. These visits took place even late at night. Several incidents have been cited in the complaint in this connection. a. That Shri Dilip Paul used to make unsolicited phone calls to her, frequently at night and insisted on speaking to her for long durations, sometime up to half and hour. The phone calls were usually made between 19:00 and 20:00 hours, but occasionally, she also received calls from Shri Dilip Paul as late as 4.30 a.m. The substance of these calls mostly consisted of unwelcome comments of sexual nature with the objective of making her submit to his unwelcome sexual advances.
b. On one occasion, Shri Dilip Paul came to Smt. X’s home at around 4.45 a.m. and insisted that she came out for a morning walk with him. Fearful that if she refused, he would insist on coming into her house at that hour, she accompanied him for a short distance. c. That, on one uninvited visit to Smt. X’s home, Shri Dilip Paul came with a bottle of alcohol and sought to pressure her to join him in drinking. When she tried to get away from him by going to the kitchen, Shri D. Paul followed her and tried to force himself upon her by embracing her. She somehow managed to extricate herself and ran out the house, and remained there until Shri D. Paul left the house.
d. That on his uninvited visits to Smt. X’s home, Shri Dilip Paul showed an unnatural and unhealthy interest in her daughter. He would call the child and draw her to him, and would then attempt to hold her in a very ‘dirty’ manner. On the occasion that this happened, he only let go of the child when Smt. X called the child to her in Manipuri. e. That when Shri Dilip Paul visited her house one evening in April 2010, shortly after her return from the Study Tour to South India, he made unwelcome sexual advances to her by his statement that they would become one in a few days time and that she should stop resisting. He also tried to forcibly embrace her, but she extricated herself and ran into the room that her children were sleeping in. f. That Shri Dilip Paul, during an official trip to Nagrijuli in connection with the Civic Action Programme, made her sit next to him and tried to hold her hand and touch her, all of which behaviour was sexually determined, unwelcome and insulting. Smt. X also stated that there were no eyewitnesses to these acts, as only she ·and Shri Dilip Paul were seated in the middle seat of the car. Point 8: That Shri Dilip Paul began victimising her for her refusal to submit to his unwelcome sexual advances soon after he learnt that she had made a complaint about his misconduct to Shri S.C. Katoch, who happened to be DIG of another area. Smt. X had telephoned Shri S.C. Katoch after the incident reported in point 10, and told him all that had been taking place. She stated that Shri Katoch informed her in a subsequent phone call that she made to him that he had issued a verbal reprimand to Shri Dilip Paul. However, a few days after the incident, Shri Dilip Paul called her into his office and asked her whether she had made a complaint against him to Shri Katoch. Smt. X confirmed to him that she had indeed done so, and to scare him, told him that she had made a written complaint. From that day on, Shri Dilip Paul withdrew all the work that was assigned to her and assigned it to another employee. Thereafter, and for the next three months, Smt. X was made to sit idle in the office.
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.492 Point 9: In late August 2010, Smt. X approached IG S.K. Singhal with a written complaint of sexual harassment in the workplace, which also contained an application for her transfer to Ftr Hqr Guwahati. Shri Singhal asked her to separate the two complaints of sexual harassment in the workplace from the transfer request and issued an order transferring her to Ftr Hqr Guwahati on 1 September 2011. However, the transfer order did not contain directions for the payment of TA/DA and did not provide her any joining time.
Point 10: Smt. X has also complained that the now-quashed enquiry into her complaint of sexual harassment in November 2011 did not provide her sufficient time or opportunity to submit additional documents and produce additional witnesses relating to the past history of the accused. She has also stated that she was not afforded the right of cross-examination of Shri Paul, or a chance to rebut his alleged false statements. After the completion of the thereafter quashed enquiry, she was not also provided a copy of the enquiry report. In her deposition as well as the written submissions made to the Complaints Committee, she also pleaded that due cognizance be taken of the fact that, as a woman employee of the SSB, she was entirely unaware of that a Complaints Committee mechanism for dealing with complaints of sexual harassment was in place, and that as a complainant, she had the right to submit a request for either her own transfer or the transfer of the defendant. She has also queried whether the promotion of Shri Dilip Paul on 11 September 2012 to the rank of DIG is maintainable when a complaint of sexual harassment in the workplace against him was pending.”
11. While the Central Complaints Committee’s Inquiry was still pending, the Ministry of Home Affairs i.e., the Competent Authority vide its order dated 30.11.2012 annulled the Frontier Level Complaints Committee’s Inquiry Report on the ground that, the Chairperson of the said Frontier Level Complaints Committee was of an equivalent rank as that of the respondent and the same was in violation of the statutory provisions, more particularly the Standing Order No. 1 of 2006 (Grievances Redressal Mechanism: To Redress Grievances of Women/Sexual Harassment at Work Place) (for short, “the 2006 Standing Order”).
12. Clause 9(1) of the 2006 Standing Order mandates that the chairperson of the inquiry committee must be senior in rank to the delinquent / charged officer and reads as under: - “9. COMPLAINT COMMITTEES
1. Chairman of committee should be senior to the officer / official against whom the complaint is made.
xxx xxx xxx “TO : I) SO(ADMN), FTR HQR GUWAHATI
II) DR- K.S. DEVI, CHAIRPERSON, COMPLAINT
COMMITTEE, FTR HQR GUWAHATI
FM : AD(PERS-m), FHQ NEW DELHI REF. FTR, HQR GUWAHATI LETTER NO.GF-II/VC-VIG/ O8(PART)/3270 DATED 17.02.2012 REG. SUBMISSION OF INQUIRY
SUBMITIED BY THE CHAIRPERSON OF THE COMPLAINT
COMMITIEE DR. K.S. DEVI ON 17.01.2012 ON COMPLAINT OF
SEXUAL HARASSMENT MADE BY SMT. X, FA (LADY) FTR HQR
GUWAHATI AGAINST SHRI D.PAUL, AO RANGIA NOW DIG, FTR
HQR SILIGURI (.) IT IS OBSERVED THAT AS PER SOP ON SEXUAL
HARASSMENT THE CHAIRPERSON OF THE INQUIRY SHALL
BE ONE RANK ABOVE OF THE GOVT. EMPLOYEE AGAINST
WHOM HIS COMPLAINT IS MADE (.) IN THE SAID INQUIRY
THE CHAIRPERSON AND SH. D.PAUL AGAINST WHOM THE
COMPLAINT/INQUIRY WAS MADE WERE IN THE SAME STATUS
AND IN THE MEAN TIME SHRI DILIP PAUL WAS ALSO PROMOTED
TO THE RANK OF DIG (.) AS SUCH THE INQUIRY REPORT DATED
27.01.2012 OF SEXUAL HARASSMENT AGAINST SHRI D.PAUL,
THE THEN A.O. NOW DIG WHICH WAS CONDUCTED BY THE
BOARD UNDER BELOW STATUS CHAIRPERSON AS PRESCRIBED
IN THE STANDING INSTRUCTIONS IS HEREBY CANCELLED BY
THE COMPETENT AUTHORITY ALONGWITH BOARD (.) FTR.
HQR GUWAHATI IS REQUESTED INFORM ALL CONCERNED
ACCORDINGLY(.)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------- UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.494 NO. 20/SSB. P-III/2011(4)-11606
DATED. THE 30.11.2012
SD/- 30/11/2012 ASSITANT DIRECTOR (PERS-M1)”
13. The Central Complaints Committee submitted its inquiry report on 28.12.2012 to the Ministry of Home Affairs, wherein after recording its findings on the aforesaid 10 points, held the charges of sexual harassment against the respondent to have been proved. The committee concluded its report with the following recommendations being reproduced below: - “XI. RECOMMENDATIONS The Complaints Committee finds that the charges of sexual harassment in the workplace have been well proven. Moreover a perusal of the charged officer’s defence statement, in which Shri Dilip Paul attempts to slander and assassinate the complainant, alone speaks volumes about his respect for women. In view of its findings, the Complaints Committee makes the following recommendations:
1. That Shri Dilip Paul be given exemplary punishment for his sustained sexual harassment of Smt. X in the form of dismissal from service, and he be stripped of promotion to DIG and the Police medal awarded to him.
2. That Smt. X be reimbursed for the TA/DA that was denied to her in her transfer to Ftr Hqrs Guwahati.
3. That Smt. X be provided a copy of the Complaints Committee report.
4. That the SSB implement on a war-footing its standing order 1/2006 by organizing regular workshops for women employees to sensitise them about the nature of sexual harassment and their rights as women employees, as well as the procedures detailed by the said order. Members of the Complaints Committees instituted by the SSB should regularly tour the various divisions and area offices of the SSB for such meetings.
5. Further, regular workshops must be held for senior officers of the SSB to sensitise them with regards to their role and responsibilities regarding the implementation of the standing order 1/2006.”
14. On 16.01.2013. the respondent was provided with the Central Complaints Committee’s Inquiry Report and was asked by the Disciplinary Authority to submit his reply / written representation, which was submitted by him on 30.01.2013. The Inquiry Report along with the written representation of the respondent was forwarded by the Ministry of Home Affairs in accordance with the relevant rules to the Union Public Service Commission for the purpose of seeking advice on the penalty that was proposed to be imposed.
15. The order imposing penalty passed by the Disciplinary Authority reads thus:
“GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIR
DIRECTORATE GENERAL, SSB
EAST BLOCK-V, R.K. PURAM
NEW DELHI – 110066
Date 05.01.2016 Order No. 14/SSB/PERS-I/2013(1) 69-79 WHEREAS, a complaint of sexual harassment at workplace was made by Smt. X, FA (Lady) vide her complaint dated 30.08.2011 against Shri Dilip Paul, Area Organiser who had superannuated from government service on 31.03.2013 as DIG.
AND WHEREAS, Ministry of Home Affairs being the disciplinary authority in respect of Group ‘A’ Officers vide their UO No.20/SSB/Pers. III/11 (4)/Pers.III dated 06.08.2012 had appointed Smt. B. Radhika, Joint Director, CCTNS-II, NCRB, New Delhi as Chairman of the Complaint Committee to enquire into the said complaint of sexual harassment against Shri Dilip Paul.
AND WHEREAS, the Chairman of the complaint committee had handed over the complaint of sexual harassment dated 30.08.2011 UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.496 submitted by the Complainant to Shri Dilip Paul, DIG during the course of 1st hearing of enquiry held on 26.09.2012 at New Delhi.
Shri Dilip Paul, DIG had denied the allegations of sexual harassment levelled against him by the complainant.
AND WHEREAS, the complainant had levelled various allegations of sexual harassment against the said Shri Dilip Paul, Area Organiser (now retired DIG), which are summarised here as under –
(a) That the said Shri Dilip Paul started teasing her tactically. He started making phone calls at night using unofficial and multi-meaning words. At times, he would visit her residence, when she was alone. Further, he would summon her into his room in his official capacity and would make her sit for hours. That the said Shri Paul on one pretext or the other used to make personal contact with her body.
(b) That repeatedly, he used to tell the complainant that if she kept him satisfied by cooperating with the sexual activities, she shall be protected from all corners.
(c) That in one of the incident, when he had visited her residence, he had entered the kitchen and embraced her.
(d) That he repeatedly proposed marriage to her.
(e) That the said Shri Paul had many a times tried to outrage her modesty.
(f) That she had complained against the Officer to the then DIG Shri S.C. Katoch, who had also warned the officer to desist from doing such activities.
(g) That during the course of the proceedings, some additional allegations were also levelled.
On these allegations, the Complaint Committee examined all the relevant witnesses in presence of the accused. The accused was afforded all the opportunities of defense.
AND WHEREAS, Smt. B. Radhika, Joint Director, CCTNS-II, NCRB, New Delhi, Chairman of the complaint committee submitted the inquiry report dated 28.12.2012 to the disciplinary authority i.e. Ministry of Home Affairs. The Inquiry Officer in its findings has proved all the charges levelled against the Charged Officer.
AND WHEREAS, in terms of DoP&T OM No. 11013/2009-Estt.
(A) dated 03.08.2009, the report of Complaint Committee is to be treated as the enquiry report under the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 and the disciplinary authority is to take action on that report as per the procedure prescribed in Rule 14 of CCS (CCA) Rules 1965.
AND WHEREAS, a copy of enquiry report after its acceptance was served upon the Charged Officer, Shri Dilip Paul, DIG for making his representation vide Memo No.14/SSB/Pers-1/2013(1)/437-39 dated 16.01.2013. The Charged Officer had submitted his reply vide letter dated 30.01.2013 denying all the charges levelled against him. AND WHEREAS, the representation of the accused officer on the inquiry report was examined and considered by the Disciplinary Authority, whereafter the advice of Union Public Service Commission regarding quantum of punishment to be imposed upon the charged Officer vide letter No.14/SSB/Per.I/2013 (1)/Pers-III dated 26.04.2013 was sought.
AND WHEREAS, the Union Public Service Commission vide its letter dated 22.08.2013 has advised imposition of penalty of withholding of 50% (fifty percent), of monthly pension on permanent basis. The gratuity amount, if not otherwise, required may be released to him. AND WHEREAS, Charged Officer Shri Dilip Paul, Ex-DIG had filed an OA No. 181/2013 before the Hon’ble CAT Bench Guwahati challenging there under constitution of Central Complaint Committee and its report dated 28.12.2012. Hon’ble CAT Guwahati vide its interim judgment dated 28.06.2013 had imposed STAY on operation of enquiry report dated 28.12.2012 of Central Complaint Committee. The said OA was disposed by Hon’ble CAT, Guwahati vide its judgment dated 03.07.2015 directing therein to complete the disciplinary proceedings within four months from the date of receipt of the order.
After the disposal of the case by the Hon’ble CAT and vacation of the interim directions of the Hon’ble Court, a copy of UPSC advice dated 22.08.2013 was served upon the Charged Officer vide Memorandum UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.498 No.14/SSB/Pers-1/2013(1)/9923-24 dated 04.08.2015, which was duly acknowledged by the Charged Officer. The Charged Officer vide his letter dated 25.08.2015 had submitted representation against the UPSC advice. All the relevant issues have been accordingly examined by the Ministry of Home Affairs being the Competent Disciplinary Authority. The issues agitated by the Charged Officer were found devoid of merit by the Disciplinary Authority. Accordingly, the charge of sexual harassment of a woman at work place levelled against the Charged Officer has been proved beyond shadow of doubt by a Committee headed by Jt. Director, NCRB, which has been upheld by the Disciplinary Authority.
NOW, THEREFORE, after careful consideration on the findings of inquiry report, UPSC advice, written submission of Charged Officer and other related records of the case, the President of India has come to the conclusion that justice would be met if the penalty of “withholding of 50% (fifty percent) of monthly pension on permanent basis” is imposed upon the Charged Officer Shri Dilip Paul, the then Area Organiser, now Ex-DIG, SSB.
ACCORDINGLY, the aforesaid penalty is hereby imposed upon Shri Dilip Paul, Ex-DIG who had superannuated on 31.03.2013. The gratuity amount, if not otherwise required may be released to him.
(By order and in the name of the President)
Sd/- (Vandan Saxena)
Assistant Director (Pers-I)”
16. It appears that during the pendency of the disciplinary proceedings, the respondent superannuated on 31.03.2013 as Dy. IG, Frontier Headquarters, SSB, Ranidanga, Siliguri, Darjeeling, West Bengal, and subject to the final outcome of the disciplinary proceedings, he was granted provisional pension without retirement gratuity.
A.4 Defence of the Respondent
17. It is the case of the respondent that the complainant had preferred one application in August, 2011 with a request to transfer her from the Rangia Office to the Frontier Headquarter Guwahati. The request for transfer was made on the ground that the complainant needed to look after her ailing mother-inlaw. However, her application was rejected by the IG, Frontier Headquarters on 24.08.2011 on the ground of non-availability of corresponding vacant post. It is the case of the respondent that on the very next day, he received a message on his mobile phone which read as follows; “I am hubby of one of your lady staff, wait and watch the end of your career.”
18. According to the respondent the message was forwarded by the husband of the complainant as she harboured a grudge on the misconception that it was the respondent who was instrumental in getting her transfer application rejected.
19. It is also the case of the respondent that he had lodged the first information report at the Rangia Police Station being Case No. 348 of 2011 in connection with the threats administered to him by way of a telephonic message.
A.5 Proceedings before the CAT
20. The respondent preferred OA No. 181 of 2013 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati (CAT), assailing (i) the constitution of the Central Complaints Committee vide order dated 06.08.2012 (received via fax dated 03.09.2012), (ii) cancellation of the Frontier Complaints Committee’s Inquiry Report vide order dated 30.11.2011 (received via Memorandum dated 10.12.2012 of the Frontier, Headquarters, SSB, Guwahati) and the
(iii) Central Complaints Committee’s Inquiry Report dated 28.12.2012. The reliefs which were inter-alia prayed for by the respondent in the captioned OA are reproduced below: - “8. Relief(s) sought for:
The Hon’ble Tribunal be pleased to. set aside and quash the impugned -
(i) FAX message dated 03.09.2012 (Anexure-11) and the constitution of the Central Legal Complaint Committee under the Chairperson Smt. S. Radhika, IPS there under;
(ii) Memorandum dated 10.12.2012 (Annexure-16) and cancellation of the enquiry report of the Frontier Level Complaint Committee there under, and UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.500
(iii) the Enquiry report dated 28.12.2012. (Annexure-17) of the · Central Complaint Committee.”
21. The CAT, Guwahati vide its final judgement & order dated 03.07.2015 dismissed the said OA No. 181 of 2013 observing that the Frontier Complaints Committee had not been constituted as per the 2006 Standing Order, and as the disciplinary proceedings were still pending, it refrained from expressing any opinion in regard to the Central Complaints Committee’s Inquiry (except expressing some reservations on the issue of penalty recommended therein) and directed that the disciplinary proceedings be completed within 4-months. The relevant portion reads as under: - “61. Undisputedly, the Chairperson of the Frontier Level Complaint Committee was Junior in the rank to the applicant, inasmuch as the applicant got promotion in the rank of Area Organizer on 22.12.2005, whereas the Chairperson was promoted to the rank of complainant, which is not prescribed as per Standing Operating Procedure of the department. The fact that the Chairperson of the said committee was junior to the applicant was not unknown to the respondents and the respondents knowingly constituted the Frontier Level Complaints Committee with a Chairperson junior to the applicant and therefore there was no valid reason to annul the report of the FLCC.
62. We are unable to accept the said submission by expressing that if there is a procedural irregularity even accrued unknowingly or unfortunately that could not be encouraged when we go into the proper adjudication of the matter. The Central Complaint Committee by going to the thorough enquiry by giving opportunity to the applicant and others with due examination as well as cross examination with the witness culminated into the opinion.
xxx xxx xxx
64. We have given our thoughtful consideration in the matter by taking into account the entire conspectus of the case, to the conclusion on the point that the consideration of Central Complaints Committee as per law laid down and in terms of the guidelines which has been duly followed by the department by taking care of the earlier observation by giving our view that the Frontier Level Standing Committee findings was not as per SOP reason as already given. We are not finding any infirmity in the enquiry apropos sexual harassment of the women in work place and to that context, we are not giving any findings or any opinion.
xxx xxx xxx
66. However, respondents are directed to complete the Departmental Proceedings within four months from the date of receipt of the order. …”
A.6 Proceedings before the High Court
22. Aggrieved with the aforesaid, the respondent preferred writ petition being WP (C) No. 7876 of 2015 before the Guwahati High Court challenging the judgement and order dated 03.07.2015 passed by the CAT, Guwahati.
23. During the pendency of the said writ petition, the Ministry of Home Affairs vide its Order dated 05.01.2016 referred to above held that the charges of sexual harassment levelled against the respondent stood duly proved and after due consideration of the respondent’s representation and the advice of the UPSC imposed a penalty of withholding 50% of the monthly pension on permanent basis.
24. In such circumstances referred to above, the respondent amended his writ petition pending before the Gauhati High Court and challenged the final order of penalty dated 05.01.2016 in addition to the original reliefs prayed before the CAT, Guwahati.
B. IMPUGNED ORDER PASSED BY THE HIGH COURT
25. The impugned judgment of the High Court is in three parts. In other words, the High Court allowed the writ petition and set aside the order of penalty on three grounds: -
(i) First, the High Court took the view that the Central Complaints Committee was constituted by the competent authority to inquire into only the first complaint dated 30.08.2011, however, the Central Complaints Committee during the course of its inquiry also looked into the allegations levelled in the second Complaint dated UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.502 18.09.2012 which it could not have. The relevant observations on this issue read as under: - “41. What is important to note is that a complaint dated 18.09.2012 along with five Annexures was submitted by Smt. X to the Chairperson of the CCC and copy of such complaint was also made available to the petitioner. In the inquiry report the above fact is not mentioned. It also does not appear that the said complaint was brought to the notice of the disciplinary authority. The CCC was mandated by the authority to inquire into the complaint dated 30.08.2011. However, it is manifest from the inquiry report that the complaint submitted on 18.09.2012 was also taken into consideration. It is noted by the CCC in the report under the heading “VI. Charges which were admitted/dropped/ not pressed” that the petitioner did not plead guilty to any of the allegations made by the complainant in her complaint dated 30.08.2011. Though the copy of the complaint dated 30.08.2011 was furnished, the same was not given in the form of articles of charge. The requirement of the officer proceeded against to be formally asked whether he pleads guilty or not would, according to the understanding of the court, is not an opportunity to such officer only to answer the same in a mono-syllable. To give meaning to the word “formally”, a real and effective opportunity has to be granted to the officer concerned to make his comment in writing in response to the complaint. Apparently, no such opportunity was afforded. There is no indication that in respect of the complaint dated 18.09.2012, the officer was even asked as to whether he pleads guilty to the allegations made therein or not.
xxx xxx xxx
43. Clause 10(ii) of the Complaint Mechanism provides that complaint shall contain all the material and details concerning the alleged sexual harassment. What were the allegations in the complaint filed on 30.08.2011 after the petitioner had filed an ejahar on 26.08.2011 1 have already been taken note of. A perusal of the above ten points would go to show that Point Nos. 1 to 6, 7 (b) to (f), 9 and 10 are no way connected to the complaint dated 30.08.2011. Two inquiries had also taken place and, after more than a year later, after lodging of the complaint dated 30.08.2011, another complaint with many allegations was submitted to the Chairperson of the CCC on 18.09.2012. In our considered opinion, the CCC could not have entertained such a complaint for the purpose of a disciplinary proceeding in absence of entrustment in terms of Standing Order.”
(Emphasis supplied)
(ii) Secondly, the Central Complaints Committee while conducting the inquiry, could not have assumed the role of a prosecutor by putting questions to the witnesses. According to the High Court, the same vitiated the inquiry proceedings. The relevant observations on this issue are as under: -
45. Perusal of the order-sheets, more particularly, the orders dated 26.11.2012, 27.11.2012, 28.11.2012 and 10.12.2012 go to show that the committee asked questions to the prosecution witnesses and examination-in-chief was done by, the committee. Prosecution witness, Mr. S. C. Katoch, who was cross-examined by the complainant, in his statement had stated that the complainant had made only one call on his mobile and that she had mentioned that the petitioner is harsh in his office work and had given her duty in control room for which she is to sit in the control room after office hours. He had, in other words, negated the assertions made in the complaint that she had informed about sexual harassment meted out by the petitioner. The CCC, however, noted that it appeared that Shri Katoch had pre-judged the complaint as untrue. When his evidence was that there was no complaint of sexual harassment, there was no occasion for the CCC to opine that he pre-judged the complaint. He was also put fifteen questions by the CCC, which was styled as “examination-in-chief”. …
46. It is noticed that the prosecution witnesses were also put questions by the CCC, which is evident from the report of the CCC under the heading “V. Examination of witnesses”, wherein the CCC itself recorded that CCC had conducted the examination-in-chief whenever it felt necessary. Thus, it is evident that the CCC also played the role of prosecutor, which vitiates the proceeding.”
(Emphasis supplied)
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.504
(iii) Thirdly, the Central Complaints Committee could be said to have based its findings on surmises and conjectures. The High Court recorded that the case was one of “No Evidence”. The relevant observations on this issue are under:
“47. With regard to Point No. 7(a), the CCC had recorded that it had noted that no witness examined by it had specific knowledge of the events listed in, wrongly recorded as 5(a) - (f). It should have been events listed in 7(a) - (f). Events at 7(a) pertain to allegation of making unsolicited phone calls at unearthly hours and, that too, for long duration. No call records were produced. However, CCC accepted the allegations by merely holding that the committee saw no reason what gain the complainant would have in fabricating the allegations and that it is understandable that no woman would be expected to confide matters of sexual nature even to her female colleagues. The CCC is to record its finding based on evidence on record and not on surmises and conjectures. It will be worthwhile to recall that the prayer of the complainant for a transfer was rejected on 24.08.2011 and based on a threatening message issued by the husband of the complainant on 26.08.2011, the petitioner had lodged the ejahar on 26.08.2011. These aspects were, however, not weighed by the CCC.”
(Emphasis supplied)
26. The High Court accordingly, allowed the writ petition vide its Impugned Judgment and Order and set-aside the penalty of permanently withholding 50% of the pension imposed upon the respondent.
27. In such circumstances referred to above, the appellant is here before this Court with the present appeal.
C. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE APPELLANT
28. Mr. K. Parmeshwar, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant in his written submissions has stated thus: - “I. There has been no violation of the principles of natural justice as the Respondent was given an opportunity to defend himself at every stage of the case.
a. It is submitted that the Central Complaints Committee was constituted to look into the allegations made against the Respondent as prescribed under Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965.
b. The said Committee conducted its first hearing on 26.09.2012 at 10:00 am. The Respondent was served with all the relevant documents including the complaint dated 20.08.2011. Further, the list of ‘witnesses to be examined’ submitted by the Complainant on 18.09.2012 was also supplied to the Respondent. The Respondent appeared and submitted that he will provide the name of his counsel within an hour. Therefore, on his request, the proceedings were adjourned to 2 PM. At 2 PM, he submitted an application seeking 30 days’ time for engagement of counsel. The Committee after taking into account his request granted one week’s time to provide name of his counsel in order to complete the proceedings within the stipulated time period.
c. It is important to mention that the next date of the hearing was fixed for 26.11.2012 i.e., after 2 months. When the Respondent was enquired about the name of his counsel, he submitted before the Committee that he will represent himself and cross-examine the witnesses and he himself examined as many as 11 witnesses. Thus, the Respondent participated in the enquiry proceedings and chose to defend himself despite sufficient time being given.
d. The allegation made by the Respondent that the Complainant submitted a list of witnesses later on 18.09.2012, which the Committee could not look into is misconceived. It is submitted that the Complainant can’t be denied to produced witnesses to provide her claim and that too, even before the preliminary hearing was conducted by the Committee on 26.09.2011.
e. The allegation raised by the Respondent that he was not informed of the charges in the form of a ‘charge-sheet’ is frivolous as he was supplied with the copies of all the complaints and all other relevant documents. This goes to show that he was well acquainted with the nature of allegations levelled against him and knew what he had to state in his defence. Given the above position, non-framing of the articles of charge cannot be said to be detrimental to the interest of the Appellants herein. UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.506 f. Therefore, it is submitted few infirmities here and there would not vitiate entire proceedings unless it is shown that some prejudice has been caused to the Respondent as has been held by this Hon’ble Court in State of U.P. v. Sudhir Kumar Singh, 2020 SCC OnLine SC 847 (Para 39). In the present case, adequate opportunity was afforded to the appellant not just by the Committee, but also by the Disciplinary Authority and the Appellate Authority before taking any action against him. Therefore, this was not a case of “no opportunity” or “no hearing” but a case of “adequate opportunity” and “fair hearing” afforded to the appellant before imposing a penalty of withholding 50% pension amount.
II. No prejudice has been caused to the Respondent due to non-supply of the Reports submitted in pursuance of an on-spot enquiry and Frontier Level Complaint Committee.
a. It is submitted that the first alleged inquiry dated 13.12.2011 was pursuant to conducting of an on-spot enquiry and by the very nature of it, is summary in nature and not an inquiry of the nature envisaged in Vishaka & Ors. v State of Rajasthan & Ors, (1997) 6 SCC 241 line of cases and the SSB Standard Operating Procedure on sexual harassment. Therefore, it cannot be equated with a disciplinary enquiry.
b. It is relevant to note that before the report of on-the-spot enquiry was submitted, Frontier Level Complaint Committee (FLCC) was already constituted. The FLCC submitted its report on 17.01.2012. However, the same was cancelled by Memorandum dated 10.12.2012 on the ground that the Chairperson of the FLCC was not an officer who was senior to the petitioner against whom the complaint was made as required under Rule 9(b)(a) of the Departmental Standard Operating Procedure on Sexual Harassment. The said decision was conveyed to the Respondent vide Memo dated 10.12.2012.
c. Further, it is submitted that even if in the FLCC reports no allegations were found to be proved against the Respondent, same would not have any material bearing on the facts as the said report were subsequently annulled by the competent authority and a fresh committee was constituted as per the rules.
III. The punishment imposed is proportionate to the offence committed by the Respondent.
a. It is submitted that this Hon’ble Court in a number of cases has held that the High Court while exercising its powers under Article 226 would not interfere with the quantum of punishment unless it shocks the conscience of the court.
b. Further, it has been held in catena of cases that scope of judicial review in case of misconduct and imposition of penalty under the service jurisprudence is limited as to whether the charges have been established on the basis of a fair enquiry. The scope is limited to the decision-making process, not the decision per se. This Hon’ble Court in a recent judgment Aureliano Fernandes vs State of Goa 2023 SCC OnLine SC 621 while pondering upon the extent to which a High Court can interfere with respect to the departmental proceedings and findings thereof, observed the following:
“62…Disciplinary Authority is the sole judge of facts and once findings of fact, based on appreciation of evidence are recorded, the High Court in its writ jurisdiction should not normally interfere with those factual findings unless it finds that the recorded findings were based either on no evidence or that the findings were wholly perverse and/or legally untenable. The Court is under a duty to satisfy itself that an inquiry into the allegations of sexual harassment by a Committee is conducted in terms of the service rules and that the concerned employee gets a reasonable opportunity to vindicate his position and establish his innocence.”
c. The Respondent herein was a member of the disciplined force and was holding a significant post at the time of commission of offence. He harassed the Complainant continuously for a period of more than 2 years despite warning issued by his superior. He did not stop despite the warning and started torturing the Complainant by not giving her work and making her sit idle till late in the night. Having superannuated during the pendency of the proceedings before the disciplinary authority, the Respondent superannuated on 31.03.2013 as DIG. In such circumstances, it is submitted that the punishment UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.508 imposed by the disciplinary authority for withholding 50% of monthly pension is proportionate to the offence committed by the Respondent.”
D. SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT
29. Mr. Avijit Roy, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent in his written submissions has stated thus: - “1. The Hon’ble High Court in para 25 of the its judgment (Page -39 of SLP) rightly held that the scope of judicial review in case of misconduct and imposition of penalty under the service jurisprudence is circumscribed as the court is only required to examine as to whether the charges have been established on the basis of a fair enquiry as the Hon’ble High Court was also conscious of the fact that judicial review is not against the decision but the decision making process.
2. It is relevant to mention here that Rule 15 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, more particularly sub-rule 1 and 2 of Rule 15 imposed a categorical restriction on holding of a 2nd and further statutory inquiry. But in the instant case, in spite of the fact that the sole respondent was exonerated from the alleged complaint by three successive enquiries i.e. i) the Fact Finding enquiry, ii) first the statutory enquiry conducted by the duly constituted Frontier Level Committee and iii) a second statutory enquiry (in fact it was 4th enquiry in the series which includes inquiry on the basis of another anonymous complaint) by the Central Complaint Committee was instituted. Subject matter of all the facts were on the same set of allegations.”
3. That, this Hon’ble Court in Vijay Shankar Pandey-Vs-U.O.I. and another, reported in (2014) 10 SCC 589, held as follows:- “26. It can be seen from the above that the normal rule is that there can be only one enquiry. This court has also recognized the possibility of a further enquiry in certain circumstances enumerated therein. The decision however makes it clear that the fact that the report submitted by the enquiring authority is not acceptable to the disciplinary authority, is not a ground for completely setting aside the enquiry report and ordering a second enquiry.”
4. Further, in K.R. Deb-Vs-The Controller, Central Excise, Shillong reported in [1971 (2) SCC 102], this Hon’ble Court has laid down that a 2nd enquiry is not permissible under the statutory provision of the Rule 15(1) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The above decision was reiterated by this Hon’ble Court in U.O.I –V- Shri K.D. Pandey & Ors, reported in [2002 (10) SCC 471].
5. The above quoted decisions of the Apex Court conclusively mandate that – (1) A second enquiry is not permissible, and (2) It is the correctness of the conclusion recorded in the enquiry report which determines the legality of the conclusions and not the mere technical flaws. These principles are fit to be extrapolated in the instant case.
6. That, the complaint dated 30.08.2011 contained only 2 (two) allegations, but the Central Complaint Committee extrapolated the allegations to as many as 10 nos. incorporating therein the newly added exaggerated versions of the complainant and delved into those, thus travelling beyond the allegations in the complaint dated 30.08.2011 and overstepping its jurisdiction in violation of procedure laid down in CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
7. The Hon’ble High Court in para 41 of its impugned judgment (Page 54 of the SLP) rightly observed that a complaint dated 18.09.2012 along with five Annexures was submitted by Smt. X (Complainant) to the Chairperson of the Central Complaint Committee (CCC) and copy of such complaint was also made available to the sole respondent. In the inquiry report the above fact is not mentioned. It also does not appear that the said complaint was brought to the notice of the disciplinary authority. The Hon’ble High Court rightly held that the Central Complaint Committee (CCC) was mandated by the authority to inquire into the complaint dated 30.08.2011. However, it is manifest from the inquiry report that the complaint submitted on 18.09.2012 was also taken into consideration. It was also noted by the Hon’ble High Court that the CCC in the report under the heading “VI. Charges which were admitted/dropped/not pressed” that the petitioner did not plead guilty to any of the allegations made by the complainant in her complaint dated 30.08.2011. Though the copy of the complaint dated 30.08.2011 was furnished, the same was not given in the form UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.510 of articles of charge. The requirement of the officer proceeded against to be formally asked whether he pleads guilty or not would, according to the understanding of the court, is not an opportunity to such officer only to answer the same in a mono-syllable. The Hon’ble High Court held that to give meaning to the word “formally”, a real and effective opportunity has to be granted to the officer concerned to make his comment in writing in response to the complaint. Apparently, no such opportunity was afforded. There is no indication that in respect of the complaint dated 18.09.2012, the officer was even asked as to whether he pleads guilty to the allegations made therein or not.
8. That, the Hon’ble High Court at para 43 of its judgment ( Page 70-71 of the SLP) rightly held that few points of allegations are no way connected to the complaint dated 30.08.2011. The Hon’ble High Court held that two inquiries had also taken place and, after more than a year later, after lodging of the complaint dated 30.08.2011, another complaint with many allegations was submitted to the Chairperson of the CCC on 18.09.2012. Accordingly the Hon’ble High Court rightly held that the CCC could not have entertained such a complaint for the purpose of a disciplinary proceeding in absence of entrustment in terms of Standing Order.
9. That, the Hon’ble High Court at para 44 & 45 of its judgment (Page 71-74 of the SLP) rightly held that the orders dated 26.11.2012, 27.11.2012, 28.11.2012 and 10.12.2012 go to show that the committee asked questions to the prosecution witnesses and examination-in-chief was done by the committee. Prosecution witness, Mr. S.C. Katoch, who was cross-examined by the complainant, in his statement had stated that the complainant had made only one call on his mobile and that she had mentioned that the sole respondent is harsh in his office work and had given her duty in control room for which she is to sit in the control room after office hours. He had, in other words, negated the assertions made in the complaint that she had informed about sexual harassment meted out by the sole respondent. The CCC, however, noted that it appeared that Shri Katoch had pre-judged the complaint as untrue. When his evidence was that there was no complaint of sexual harassment, there was no occasion for the CCC to opine that he pre-judged the complaint. He was also put fifteen questions by the CCC, which was styled as “examination-in-chief”
10. That, the Hon’ble High Court at para 46 of its judgment ( Page 74 of the SLP) rightly held that the prosecution witnesses were also put questions by the CCC, which is evident from the report of the CCC under the heading “V. Examination of witnesses”, wherein the CCC itself recorded that CCC had conducted the examination-in-chief whenever it felt necessary. Thus, it is evident that the CCC also played the role of prosecutor, which vitiates the proceeding.
11. That the Hon’ble High Court at para 47 of its judgment (Page 75-76 of the SLP) rightly held that the CCC had recorded that it had noted that no witness examined by it had specific knowledge of the events listed in. The Hon’ble High Court observed that events alleged pertain to allegation of making unsolicited phone calls at unearthly hours and, that too, for long duration. No call records were produced. However, CCC accepted the allegations by merely holding that the committee saw no reason what gain the complainant would have in fabricating the allegations and that it is understandable that no woman would be expected to confide matters of sexual nature even to her female colleagues. In this regard, the Hon’ble High Court correctly held that the Central Complaint Committee (CCC) ought to have recorded its finding based on evidence on record and not on surmises and conjectures.
12. That, it may be mentioned here that the sole respondent was most decorated officer in his cadre in SSB. He was awarded by the President of India for his exemplary services. He was a recipient of Indian Police Medal, DG’s Disc with Commendation (2 times), Best Performing Officer in SSB (Best Area) for 04 consecutive years from 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012, recipient of various appreciations in each month from all senior controlling officers including DG of SSB. Now after putting in 35 glorious years of service in SSB, he has been victimized and forced to proceed on superannuation without a single penny from the department. Even his personal accumulation under different heads has also not been sanctioned to him. The sole respondent is still deprived of his retiral benefit like gratuity and others as the gratuity due to UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.512 him cannot be withheld as the nature of allegation is not related any financial issues and there was no order by any quarter about any such withholding of his retiral benefit. Moreso, the Punishment order dated 05.01.2016 (@ page 447-453 of Vol-II of present SLP) passed by the Authority concerned clearly directed that the gratuity amount shall be released to the sole respondent and the said order of release of gratuity by the respondent authority is not opposed or assailed by the petitioner authority. However, till date no Gratuity amount was released to the sole respondent. Due to such order, commutation value of pension has also not been paid till date.
13. Sole respondent is the victim of circumstances as there was never any blemish in his entire service career and he was exonerated in all first three inquiries on same allegation. That too with a type of punishment which was not at all recommended by the Central Level Complaint Committee. Surprisingly, the authority on same allegations instituted 4th inquiry and imposed penalty just to victimize the sole respondent for reasons best known to them. The sole respondent was the unfortunate victim of interdepartmental rivalry and he was traumatized due to unproved allegations and his innocence was upheld time to time by the first three inquiries and same was discussed in detail by the Hon’ble High Court at para 40, 43, 46 and 47 of the impugned judgment while rightly setting aside the impugned order of penalty. (Page no.-54, 70-74, 75-76 of the SLP)
14. The contention of the petitioner authority that the penalty of withholding of 50% of pension is just and sufficient. In this regard, the sole respondent submits that when all three inquiry reports exonerated him and even Hon’ble High Court acquitted him all his charges and set aside the impugned order of penalty then the sole respondent has proved his honesty and agitating his case for his reputation and honour as a decorated retired officer as DIG of SSB apart from unjustified penalty withholding 50% of pension.”
E. ANALYSIS
30. Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and having gone through the materials on record, the following four questions fall for our consideration: - I. Whether the Central Complaints Committee committed any egregious error in looking into the second complaint dated 18.09.2012?
II. Whether the Central Complaints Committee committed any egregious error in putting questions to the witnesses in the course of the departmental enquiry and thereby vitiating the disciplinary proceedings?
III. Whether the Central Complaints Committee could be said to have based its findings on mere conjectures and surmises? Whether the case on hand is one of “No Evidence”?
IV. Whether the High Court committed any egregious error in passing the impugned judgment and order?
E.1 Relevant Statutory Scheme and Case Law
31. Before adverting to the rival contentions canvassed on either side, we must look into the statutory scheme relating to the complaints of sexual harassment.
32. Sexual harassment is a pervasive and deeply rooted issue that has plagued the societies worldwide. In India, it has been a matter of serious concern, and the development of laws to combat sexual harassment is a testament to the nation’s commitment towards addressing this problem. Sexual harassment has existed in India for centuries, but it was only in the latter half of the 20th century that it began to gain legal recognition.
33. The turning point against the growing social menace of sexual harassment of women at work place could be traced back to the pathbreaking decision of this Court in Vishaka and Others v. State of Rajasthan and Others reported in (1997) 6 SCC 241, whereby this Court recognized sexual harassment at the workplace as a violation of a woman’s fundamental right to equality and dignity. The relevant observations are as under: “1. This writ petition has been filed for the enforcement of the fundamental rights of working women under Articles 14 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India in view of the prevailing climate in which the violation of these rights is not uncommon. With the increasing awareness and emphasis on gender justice, there is increase in the UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.514 effort to guard against such violations; and the resentment towards incidents of sexual harassment is also increasing. The present petition has been brought as a class action by certain social activists and NGOs with the aim of focusing attention towards this societal aberration, and assisting in finding suitable methods for realisation of the true concept of “gender equality”; and to prevent sexual harassment of working women in all work places through judicial process, to fill the vacuum in existing legislation.
2. The immediate cause for the filing of this writ petition is an incident of alleged brutal gang rape of a social worker in a village of Rajasthan. That incident is the subject-matter of a separate criminal action and no further mention of it, by us, is necessary. The incident reveals the hazards to which a working woman may be exposed and the depravity to which sexual harassment can degenerate; and the urgency for safeguards by an alternative mechanism in the absence of legislative measures. In the absence of legislative measures, the need is to find an effective alternative mechanism to fulfil this felt and urgent social need.
3. Each such incident results in violation of the fundamental rights of “Gender Equality” and the “Right to Life and Liberty”. It is a clear violation of the rights under Articles 14, 15 and 21 of the Constitution. One of the logical consequences of such an incident is also the violation of the victim’s fundamental right under Article 19(1)(g) “to practice any profession or to carry out any occupation, trade or business”. Such violations, therefore, attract the remedy under Article 32 for the enforcement of these fundamental rights of women. This class action under Article 32 of the Constitution is for this reason. A writ of mandamus in such a situation, if it is to be effective, needs to be accompanied by directions for prevention, as the violation of fundamental rights of this kind is a recurring phenomenon. The fundamental right to carry on any occupation, trade or profession depends on the availability of a “safe” working environment. Right to life means life with dignity. The primary responsibility for ensuring such safety and dignity through suitable legislation, and the creation of a mechanism for its enforcement, is of the legislature and the executive. When, however, instances of sexual harassment resulting in violation of fundamental rights of women workers under Articles 14, 19 and 21 are brought before us for redress under Article 32, an effective redressal requires that some guidelines should be laid down for the protection of these rights to fill the legislative vacuum.
xxx xxx xxx
7. In the absence of domestic law occupying the field, to formulate effective measures to check the evil of sexual harassment of working women at all workplaces, the contents of international conventions and norms are significant for the purpose of interpretation of the guarantee of gender equality, right to work with human dignity in Articles 14, 15 19(1)(g) and 21 of the Constitution and the safeguards against sexual harassment implicit therein. Any international convention not inconsistent with the fundamental rights and in harmony with its spirit must be read into these provisions to enlarge the meaning and content thereof, to promote the object of the constitutional guarantee. This is implicit from Article 51(c) and the enabling power of the Parliament to enact laws for implementing the international conventions and norms by virtue of Article 253 read with Entry 14 of the Union List in Seventh Schedule of the Constitution. Article 73 also is relevant. It provides that the executive power of the Union shall extend to the matters with respect to which Parliament has power to make laws. The executive power of the Union is, therefore, available till the Parliament enacts legislation to expressly provide measures needed to curb the evil.”
(Emphasis supplied)
34. This Court in Vishaka (supra) further embarked on an innovative judicial process for the effective enforcement of the basic human right of gender equality and guarantee against sexual harassment and abuse by laying down the essential principles for preventing and redressing sexual harassment, including the creation of internal complaints committee at workplaces, awareness programs, and punitive measures against the offenders. These guidelines now popularly known as the ‘Vishaka Guidelines’ set a foundation for the development of comprehensive legislation on sexual harassment. The relevant observations are as under: - UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.516 “16. In view of the above, and the absence of enacted law to provide for the effective enforcement of the basic human right of gender equality and guarantee against sexual harassment and abuse, more particularly against sexual harassment at work places, we lay down the guidelines and norms specified hereinafter for due observance at all work places or other institutions, until a legislation is enacted for the purpose. This is done in exercise of the power available under Article 32 of the Constitution for enforcement of the fundamental rights and it is further emphasised that this would be treated as the law declared by this Court under Article 141 of the Constitution.
17. The GUIDELINES and NORMS pre-scribed herein are as under: HAVING REGARD to the definition of “human rights” in Section 2(d) of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.
TAKING NOTE of the fact that the present civil and penal laws in India do not adequately provide for specific protection of women from sexual harassment in work places and that enactment of such legislation will take considerable time, It is necessary and expedient for employers in workplaces as well as other responsible persons or institutions to observe certain guidelines to ensure the prevention of sexual harassment of women:
1. Duty of the Employer or other responsible persons in workplaces and other institutions:
It shall be the duty of the employer or other responsible persons in workplaces or other institutions to prevent or deter the commission of acts of sexual harassment and to provide the procedures for the resolution, settlement or prosecution of acts of sexual harassment by taking all steps required.
2. Definition For this purpose, sexual harassment includes such unwelcome sexually determined behaviour (whether directly or by implication) as: a) physical contact and advances;
b) a demand or request for sexual favours;
c) sexually coloured remarks;
d) showing pornography;
e) any other unwelcome physical, verbal or non-verbal conduct of sexual nature.
Where any of these acts is committed in circumstances whereunder the victim of such conduct has a reasonable apprehension that in relation to the victim’s employment or work whether she is drawing salary, or honorarium or voluntary, whether in Government, public or private enterprise such conduct can be humiliating and may constitute a health and safety problem. It is discriminatory for instance when the woman has reasonable grounds to believe that her objection would disadvantage her in connection with her employment or work including recruiting or promotion or when it creates a hostile work environment. Adverse consequences might be visited if the victim does not consent to the conduct in question or raises any objection thereto.
3. Preventive Steps:
All employers or persons in charge of workplace whether in the public or private sector should take appropriate steps to prevent sexual harassment. Without prejudice to the generality of this obligation they should take the following steps:
(a) Express prohibition of sexual harassment as defined above at the workplace should be notified, published and circulated in appropriate ways.
(b) The rules/regulations of government and public sector bodies relating to conduct and discipline should include rules/regulations prohibiting sexual harassment and provide for appropriate penalties in such rules against the offender.
(c) As regards private employers steps should be taken to include the aforesaid prohibitions in the standing orders under the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Act, 1946.
(d) Appropriate work conditions should be provided in respect of work, leisure, health and hygiene to further ensure that there is no hostile UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.518 environment towards women at workplaces and no woman employee should have reasonable grounds to believe that she is disadvantaged in connection with her employment.
4. Criminal Proceedings:
Where such conduct amounts to a specific offence under the Indian Penal Code or under any other law, the employer shall initiate appropriate action in accordance with law by making a complaint with the appropriate authority.
In particular, it should ensure that victims, or witnesses are not victimized or discriminated against while dealing with complaints of sexual harassment. The victims of sexual harassment should have the option to seek transfer of the perpetrator or their own transfer.
5. Disciplinary Action:
Where such conduct amounts to misconduct in employment as defined by the relevant service rules, appropriate disciplinary action should be initiated by the employer in accordance with those rules.
6. Complaint Mechanism:
Whether or not such conduct constitutes an offence under law or a breach of the service rules, an appropriate complaint mechanism should be created in the employer’s organization for redress of the complaint made by the victim. Such complaint mechanism should ensure time bound-treatment of complaints.
7. Complaints Committee The complaint mechanism, referred to in (6) above, should be adequate to provide, where necessary, a Complaints Committee, a special counsellor or other support service, including the maintenance of confidentiality.
The Complaints Committee should be headed by a woman and not less than half of its member should be women. Further, to prevent the possibility of any undue pressure or influence from senior levels, such Complaints Committee should involve a third party, either NGO or other body who is familiar with the issue of sexual harassment. The Complaints Committee must make an annual report to the Government Department concerned of the complaints and action taken by them.
The employers and person-in-charge will also report on the compliance with the aforesaid guidelines including on the reports of the Complaints Committee to the Government department.
8. Workers’ initiative Employees should be allowed to raise issues of sexual harassment at workers’ meeting and in other appropriate forum and it should be affirmatively discussed in employer-employee meetings.
9. Awareness:
Awareness of the rights of female employees in this regard should be created in particular by prominently notifying the guidelines (and appropriate legislation when enacted on the subject) in a suitable manner.
10. Third-party Harassment:
Where sexual harassment occurs as a result of an act or omission by any third party or outsider, the employer and person- in-charge will take all steps necessary and reasonable to assist the affected person in terms of support and preventive action.
11. The Central/State Governments are requested to consider adopting suitable measures including legislation to ensure that the guidelines laid down by this order are also observed by the employers in private sector.
12. These guidelines will not prejudice any rights available under the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993.
18. Accordingly, we direct that the above guidelines and norms would be strictly observed in all work places for the preservation and enforcement of the right to gender equality of the working women. These directions would be binding and enforceable in law until suitable legislation is enacted to occupy the field. These writ petitions are disposed of, accordingly.”
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.520
35. This was followed by another decision of this Court in Medha Kotwal Lele and Others v. Union of India and Others reported in (2013) 1 SCC 297, decided on 19.10.2012, wherein this Court anguished by the failure of the Union & State Governments in complying with the Vishaka guidelines, more particularly, the constitution of the complaints committee, issued a writ of continuing mandamus to ensure due compliance of the guidelines. The relevant observations are reproduced below: - “43. As the largest democracy in the world, we have to combat violence against women. We are of the considered view that the existing laws, if necessary, be revised and appropriate new laws be enacted by Parliament and the State Legislatures to protect women from any form of indecency, indignity and disrespect at all places (in their homes as well as outside), prevent all forms of violence— domestic violence, sexual assault, sexual harassment at the workplace, etc.—and provide new initiatives for education and advancement of women and girls in all spheres of life. After all they have limitless potential. Lip service, hollow statements and inert and inadequate laws with sloppy enforcement are not enough for true and genuine upliftment of our half most precious population—the women.
44. In what we have discussed above, we are of the considered view that guidelines in Vishaka (Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, (1997) 6 SCC 241 : 1997 SCC (Cri) 932) should not remain symbolic and the following further directions are necessary until legislative enactment on the subject is in place:
44.1. The States and Union Territories which have not yet carried out adequate and appropriate amendments in their respective Civil Services Conduct Rules (by whatever name these Rules are called) shall do so within two months from today by providing that the report of the Complaints Committee shall be deemed to be an inquiry report in a disciplinary action under such Civil Services Conduct Rules. In other words, the disciplinary authority shall treat the report/findings, etc. of the Complaints Committee as the findings in a disciplinary inquiry against the delinquent employee and shall act on such report accordingly. The findings and the report of the Complaints Committee shall not be treated as a mere preliminary investigation or inquiry leading to a disciplinary action but shall be treated as a finding/report in an inquiry into the misconduct of the delinquent.
44.2. The States and Union Territories which have not carried out amendments in the Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Rules shall now carry out amendments on the same lines, as noted above in para 44.1 within two months.
44.3. The States and Union Territories shall form adequate number of Complaints Committees so as to ensure that they function at taluka level, district level and State level. Those States and/or Union Territories which have formed only one committee for the entire State shall now form adequate number of Complaints Committees within two months from today. Each of such Complaints Committees shall be headed by a woman and as far as possible in such committees an independent member shall be associated.
44.4. The State functionaries and private and public sector undertakings/organisations/bodies/institutions, etc. shall put in place sufficient mechanism to ensure full implementation of Vishaka (Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, (1997) 6 SCC 241 : 1997 SCC (Cri) 932) guidelines and further provide that if the alleged harasser is found guilty, the complainant victim is not forced to work with/ under such harasser and where appropriate and possible the alleged harasser should be transferred. Further provision should be made that harassment and intimidation of witnesses and the complainants shall be met with severe disciplinary action.
44.5. The Bar Council of India shall ensure that all Bar Associations in the country and persons registered with the State Bar Councils follow Vishaka (Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, (1997) 6 SCC 241 : 1997 SCC (Cri) 932) guidelines. Similarly, the Medical Council of India, Council of Architecture, Institute of Chartered Accountants, Institute of Company Secretaries and other statutory institutes shall ensure that the organisations, bodies, associations, institutions and persons registered/affiliated with them follow the guidelines laid down by Vishaka (Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, (1997) 6 SCC 241 : 1997 SCC (Cri) 932). To achieve this, necessary instructions/circulars shall be issued by all the statutory bodies such as the Bar Council of UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.522 India, Medical Council of India, Council of Architecture, Institute of Company Secretaries within two months from today. On receipt of any complaint of sexual harassment at any of the places referred to above the same shall be dealt with by the statutory bodies in accordance with Vishaka (Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, (1997) 6 SCC 241 : 1997 SCC (Cri) 932), guidelines and the guidelines in the present order.” (Emphasis supplied)
36. The relevant statutory rules, applicable to the case on hand, are the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 (for short, “the 1964 CCS Rules”) and the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 (for short, “the 1965 CCS Rules”) enacted in exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 and Clause 5 of Article 148 of the Constitution of India.
37. Part VI of the 1965 CCS Rules contains the relevant provisions relating to the disciplinary proceedings and imposition of penalties for government servants in the central civil services and posts and Rule 14 therein stipulates the ordinary procedure and process for imposition of major penalties.
38. Pursuant to the decisions of this Court in Vishaka (supra) and Medha Kotwal Lele (supra) referred to above, the CCS Rules underwent several amendments whereby new provisions specifically dealing with sexual harassment came to be inserted, more particularly Rule 3C in the 1964 CCS Rules along with a new Proviso to Rule 14(2) of the 1965 CCS Rules. The said provisions conjointly made sexual harassment punishable with major penalties and specifically made the Vishaka Guidelines applicable to the disciplinary proceedings in relation to complaints of sexual harassment. The said provisions are enumerated below: - “3C. Prohibition of sexual harassment of working women.
(1) No Government servant shall indulge in any act of sexual harassment of any woman at any work place.
(2) Every Government servant who is incharge of a work place shall take appropriate steps to prevent sexual harassment to any woman at the work place.
Explanation. - (I) For the purpose of this rule, –
(a) “sexual harassment” includes any one or more of the following acts or behaviour (whether directly or by implication) namely –
(i) physical contact and advances; or
(ii) a demand or request for sexual favours; or
(iii) making sexually coloured remarks; or
(iv) showing pornography; or
(v) any other unwelcome physical, verbal or non-verbal conduct of a sexual nature.
(b) the following circumstances, among other circumstances, if it occurs or is present in relation to or connected with any act or behaviour of sexual harassment may amount to sexual harassment:-
(i) implied or explicit promise of preferential treatment in employment; or
(ii) implied or explicit threat of detrimental treatment in employment; or
(iii) implied or explicit threat about her present or future employment status; or
(iv) interference with her work or creating an intimidating or offensive or hostile work environment for her; or
(v) humiliating treatment likely to affect her health or safety.
(c) “workplace” includes:-
(i) any department, organisation, undertaking, establishment, enterprise, institution, office, branch or unit which is established, owned, controlled or wholly or substantially financed by funds provided directly or indirectly by the Central Government;
(ii) hospitals or nursing homes;
(iii) any sports institute, stadium, sports complex or competition or games venue, whether residential or not used for training, sports or other activities relating thereto;
UNION OF INDIA AND OTHERS v. DILIP PAUL [J. B. PARDIWALA, J.] SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 13 S.C.R.524
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.