Pratibha Manchanda & Anr v. State of Haryana & Anr
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 612; [2023] 10 S.C.R. 411
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice C.T. Ravikumar Code of Criminal Procedure
- Decided
- 7 Jul 2023
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1793/2023
- Sections
- 438
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H
PRATIBHA MANCHANDA & ANR.
v.
STATE OF HARYANA & ANR.
(Criminal Appeal No 1793 of 2023)
JULY 07, 2023
[SURYA KANT AND C.T. RAVIKUMAR, JJ.] Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 – s. 438 – Anticipatory bail – Rejection of – Appellants’ case that they had possession over the subject land and they never sold the subject land to anyone nor have they ever executed any power of attorney (GPA) in favor of any third party – However, appellants learnt that the accused persons had approached the halqa patwari to sanction mutation of the aforesaid land – It was alleged that the application for mutation was based on a forged and fabricated sale deed dated 24.02.2022 – Appellant also learnt that the said sale deed was based on yet another, purportedly, forged and fabricated GPA dated 18.09.1996 – FIR registered against respondent no.2 and other accused persons u/ss.406, 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120-B of IPC – Respondent no.2 fearing arrest filed an application for anticipatory bail before the Sessions Judge but the same was dismissed – However, the High Court granted anticipatory bail to the accused – On appeal, held: According to respondent no.2, what transpired in 1996 was sale of the subject land through GPA – However, regardless of obtaining all the rights over the subject land, respondent no.2 never informed the Revenue/local authorities that he had purportedly ‘purchased’ the subject land through a GPA – The ownership of the land always remained in the name of the appellants in the revenue record – A portion of subject land was acquired by the government after execution of the 1996 GPA and compensation was paid to the appellants – Respondent no.2 neither objected to the payment of such compensation nor asserted his title over the land, which he normally would have done had he possessed any rights over it – Respondent no.2 failed to show payment of consideration to the appellants – Sale deed was executed without mentioning PAN number or deducting TDS – It is also unclear that when subject land was situated in Gurugram district, why the GPA was registered in Kalkaji [2023] 10 S.C.R. 411 : 2023 INSC 612 A B C D E F G H 412 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
– There are overwhelming prima facie evidences to indicate that the version of events provided by respondent no.2 , the buyers of property and Sub-registrar should be viewed with scepticism – A thorough investigation is required by the investigating authorities – Therefore, custodial interrogation of respondent no.2 and other accused required – Order of the High Court granting bail set aside. Bail – Anticipatory Bail – Purpose – The relief of Anticipatory Bail is aimed at safeguarding individual rights – While it serves as a crucial tool to prevent the misuse of the power of arrest and protects innocent individuals from harassment, it also presents challenges in maintaining a delicate balance between individual rights and the interests of justice and striking a balance between safeguarding individual rights and protecting public interest – While the right to liberty and presumption of innocence are vital, the court must also consider the gravity of the offence, the impact on society, and the need for a fair and free investigation.
Allowing the appeal, the Court HELD: 1. The relief of Anticipatory Bail is aimed at safeguarding individual rights. While it serves as a crucial tool to prevent the misuse of the power of arrest and protects innocent individuals from harassment, it also presents challenges in maintaining a delicate balance between individual rights and the interests of justice. The tight rope lies in striking a balance between safeguarding individual rights and protecting public interest. While the right to liberty and presumption of innocence are vital, the court must also consider the gravity of the offence, the impact on society, and the need for a fair and free investigation. The court’s discretion in weighing these interests in the facts and circumstances of each individual case becomes crucial to ensure a just outcome. [Para 19][421-E-G]
2. In light of Respondent No. 2’s own contention, what transpired in 1996 was the sale of the Subject Land through the GPA. Upon reviewing a copy of the alleged 1996 GPA presented to the court, the Appellants relinquished all crucial rights pertaining to the Subject Land. These rights include possession of the land, handling water, sewer, electricity, power connections, and other services related to the property, paying lease payments A B C D E F G H and other dues, making additions or modifications to the existing structure with required permissions, renting out the land, issuing receipts, and managing tenant-related matters. Furthermore, the Appellants granted authority for selling, disposing, or transferring the land, entering into agreements, and receiving consideration on behalf of the principal. However, regardless of obtaining all the rights over the Subject Land, Respondent No. 2 does not appear to have ever informed the Revenue/local authorities that he had purportedly ‘purchased’ the Subject Land through a GPA. The ownership of the land always remained in the name of the Appellants in the revenue record and no application for change of mutation, etc. was moved by the 2nd Respondent. At a very belated stage, after the execution of the alleged 1996 GPA, a portion of the Subject Land was acquired by the Government and compensation in this regard was paid to the Appellants.
Respondent No. 2 neither objected to the payment of such compensation nor asserted his title over the land, which he normally would have done had he possessed any rights over it. It would be incongrous to accept transfer of ownership rights in an immovable property merely on execution of a power of attorney. [Para 20][422-A-F]
3. A certified copy of this GPA is said to have been relied upon to execute the disputed sale deed. The Court fails to understand or comprehend as to how a bona fide purchaser could pay crores of rupees as sale consideration to a person who neither possesses documents showing ownership and title nor has original GPA of the true owner(s) of the property being sold. The fact that the sale deed was allegedly executed without mentioning the PAN Number or without deducting TDS, underlines the dubious nature of this transaction. The Court is equally intrigued at the behaviour of the Registering Authorities and their acceptance of the conveyance deed in the absence of these formalities being completed. The Sub-Registrar and his officials were obligated to verify the ownership rights before registration of the sale deed. As per the Appellants’ claim, the prior original sale deeds of the land are still in their possession. The fact that the vendee agreed to pay such massive sums of money to Respondent No. 2 without obtaining the original records as of PRATIBHA MANCHANDA & ANR. v. STATE OF HARYANA &
ANR.
A B C D E F G H 414 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
now casts a shadow over the legitimacy of the transaction. [Para 21][422-G-H; 423-A-B]
4. It is also unclear why, given that when the Subject Land is situated in Gurugram District, the GPA in relation to the property was registered in Kalkaji, New Delhi. It raises some suspicion regarding the genuineness of the GPA. There is, thus, overwhelming and clear cut prima facie evidence to indicate that the version of events provided by Respondent No. 2, the buyers of the property, and the Sub Registrar, should be viewed with scepticism. These parties, prima facie, appear to be acting in concert with each other and might be hands in glove, with the ulterior motive of duping the absentee land-owners. This angle requires thorough consideration by the investigating authorities. The Appellants have seemingly fallen prey to a well-orchestrated conspiracy hatched to rob them of their highly valuable property. In such cases where the victims of a crime, on account of their old age and geographical distance, are unable to secure justice on their own, it falls upon Courts and the State to carry out their solemn duty to ward off injustice and restore the faith of one and all in the rule of law. [Para 23][423-E-G]
5. The facts of the case speak for themselves and an element of criminality cannot be ruled out at this stage. Whether or not the alleged offences were committed by Respondent No. 2 and his co-accused in active collusion with each other can be effectively determined by a free, fair, unhampered and dispassionate investigation. In the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case, custodial interrogation of not only Respondent No. 2 but all other suspects is, therefore, imperative to unearth the truth. Joining the investigation with a protective umbrella provided by pre-arrest bail will render the exercise of eliciting the truth ineffective in such like case. The Court, as mentioned, also skeptical, suspicious and incredulous about the verification process of the 1996 GPA carried out by the Sub- Registrar, Kalkaji, New Delhi. Hence, the conduct of the officials of Sub-Registrar Office, Kalkaji, New Delhi is also required to be examined to take the investigation to its logical conclusion. [Para 28][424-G-H; 425-A-C] A B C D E F G H Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia v. State of Punjab (1980) 2 SCC 565 : [1980] 3 SCR 383; Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2018) 7 SCC 731 : [2018] 6 SCR 825 – followed.
Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra (2011) 1 SCC 694 : [2010] 15 SCR 201 – relied on.
Case Law Reference [2010] 15 SCR 201 relied on Para 17 [1980] 3 SCR 383 followed Para 17 [2018] 6 SCR 825 followed Para 18 CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Criminal Appeal No.1793 of 2023.
From the Judgment and Order dated 31.05.2022 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CRM-M No.24093 of 2022. Saket Sikri, Gautam Kazanchi, Ajaypal Singh Kullar, Vikalp Mudgal, Advs. for the Appellants.
Ms. Bansuri Swaraj, A.A.G., Maninder Singh, Anupam Lal Das, Sr. Advs., Dr. Monika Gusain, Raktim Gogoi, Kartikeya Singh, Vaibhav Tomar, S. Vinod, Shivam Pal Sharma, Rakesh Kumar Singh, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
SURYA KANT, J.
1. Application seeking permission to file the SLP is allowed. Leave Granted.
2. The instant appeal arises from a judgment of the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh (hereinafter, ‘High Court’) dated 31.05.2022, whereby the High Court allowed the petition filed under Section 438 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter, ‘Cr.P.C’) and granted anticipatory bail to Respondent No. 2 in FIR No. 113 of 2022, dated 16.03.2022, registered at PS Badshahpur, district Gurugram, under Sections 406, 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120-B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter, ‘IPC’).
PRATIBHA MANCHANDA & ANR. v. STATE OF HARYANA &
ANR.
A B C D E F G H 416 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
A. FACTS
3. The abovementioned FIR was lodged by the Appellants against Respondent No. 2 and other co-accused individuals, namely, Shel Narang, Bhim Singh and Vinod. According to the contents of the FIR, the Appellants are senior citizens who were owners and had possession over the land bearing rect. No. 55, Killa No. 3/1 (7-9), 4/1 (7-13), measuring 15 Kanal 2 Marla, situated within the revenue estate of Village Begampur Khatola, Tehsil Kadipur, District Gurugram (hereinafter, ‘Subject Land’) for over a period of 30 years. The Appellants claim that they never sold the Subject Land to anyone nor have they ever executed any power of attorney (hereinafter, ‘GPA’) in favor of any third party. The area has, in their version of events, always been unequivocally under their possession and has never been ceded in any form or fashion to people outside the family.
4. On 28.02.2022, Appellant No. 2 went to Patwar Bhawan, Gurugram to obtain revenue papers for the Subject Land. He discovered there only that a person named Bhim Singh Rathi had approached the halqa patwari to sanction mutation of the aforementioned land. The application for mutation was, as per the Appellants, based on a forged and fabricated sale deed bearing vasika No. 11493 dated 24.02.2022 (hereinafter, ‘2022 Sale Deed’). After looking into the matter further, Appellant No. 2 learned that the said sale deed was registered in the office of Sub-Registrar Kadipur, District Gurugram and was executed by Respondent No. 2. The execution in question was based on yet another, purportedly, forged and fabricated GPA bearing Vasika No. 13907 dated 18.09.1996 (hereinafter, ‘1996 GPA’), registered in the office of Sub- Registrar-V, South East Delhi.
5. The Appellants, as alluded to earlier, have adopted the stance that they never executed or registered any GPA in favor of Respondent No. 2, nor are they even acquainted with him in any form or fashion. Instead, both the 1996 GPA and the 2022 Sale Deed were completely fraudulent documents created by Respondent No. 2 and the remaining co-accused named in the FIR, in collusion with other officials at the Sub-Registrar’s office. These actions were carried out in complete subterfuge and without any involvement of the Appellants.
6. The Appellants claim that they are in possession of the original sale deed for the Subject Land, and a true copy of it was attached to the A B C D E F G H complaint. Upon examining the 2022 Sale Deed, it was apparent to them that the accused had failed to provide a PAN Number, which is mandatorily required for a valid sale deed. Furthermore, there was no mention of the 1% amount of Tax Deducted at Source (hereinafter, ‘TDS’) being deposited, which also forms part of the requirements for execution and registration of a sale deed.
7. The complaint also mentioned the current market value of the Appellants’ land, measuring 15 Kanal 2 Marla, as being approximately not less than Rs. 50 crores. However, in the 2022 Sale Deed, the sale consideration was shown as an abjectly low and meager amount of Rs. 6,60,62,500/-, which was significantly below its actual asking price. Moreover, the Appellants had not received even this miniscule amount even if the 2022 Sale Deed was hypothetically considered to be valid. Thus, this document was clearly created by Respondent No. 2 and the co-accused in collusion with the witnesses, the scribe, and officials of the Sub-Registrar Tehsil Kadipur, District Gurugram, with the unholy intention to wisk the property away from the the complainants and place it under the possession of the accused.
8. Accordingly, the First Information Report was registered at Police Station, Badshahpur, Gurugram, and an investigation was initiated. Respondent No. 2, fearing arrest if he were asked to appear before the Investigating Officer, filed an application for Anticipatory Bail before the Additional Sessions Judge, Gurugram.
9. The Additional Sessions Judge, Gurugram, dismissed Respondent No. 2’s application for anticipatory bail in an order dated 23.05.2022, while observing that:
i. Respondent No. 2 was accused of allegedly forging a GPA and executing the 2022 Sale Deed. The original 1996 GPA was still to be recovered by the police. Several questions pertaining to the whereabouts of the 1996 GPA, the execution of the sale deed, the payment of sale consideration, sanctioning of the mutation, and the relationship between Respondent No. 2 and the Appellants, were all to be ascertained;
ii. The allegations against Respondent No. 2 were serious, and filing a civil suit did not absolve them of criminal liability. Anticipatory bail was to be granted only in exceptional PRATIBHA MANCHANDA & ANR. v. STATE OF HARYANA & ANR. [SURYA KANT, J.] A B C D E F G H 418 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
circumstances, as a person under pre-arrest bail may not disclose all the relevant facts under questioning, due to the safeguard provided under Section 438 of the Cr.P.C.
Custodial interrogation of Respondent No. 2 was necessary for a thorough investigation, given all the outstanding points of inquiry that remained pending.
10. Aggrieved, Respondent No. 2 filed an application for Anticipatory Bail before the High Court. The High Court, vide impugned order dated 31.05.2022, allowed the application and granted him Anticipatory Bail. The High Court, inter alia, observed that: i. The dispute involves the validity of the 1996 GPA and the misappropriation of the purported sale consideration. Civil suits have been filed regarding the ownership and possession of the property already and a handwriting expert’s report was crucial in determining the authenticity of the signatures; ii. The High Court acknowledged the pendency of ongoing civil suits and suggested that the validity of the 1996 GPA’s execution could be determined by the civil court, and did not need to be a determinative factor in the proceedings for anticpatory bail;
iii. Prima facie, it seemed that the involvement of the criminal justice system, initiated by the Appellants, might be an attempt to settle certain transactions and resolve ongoing disputes between them. In this background, to ensure that justice was done for both the Appellants and Respondent No. 2, directions were issued for them to provide their specimen signatures. The handwriting expert was tasked with comparing the writings and signatures to assess their similarity.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.