Indira Devi v. Veena Gupta & Ors.
- Citation
- 2023 INSC 593; [2023] 10 S.C.R. 372
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka
- Decided
- 4 Jul 2023
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9833/2014
- Sections
- 23, 15
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:28 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
A B C D E F G H 372 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
INDIRA DEVI
v.
VEENA GUPTA & ORS.
(Civil Appeal No. 9833 of 2014)
JULY 04, 2023
[ABHAY S. OKA AND RAJESH BINDAL, JJ.] Deeds and Documents – Sale deed – Whether the vendor can assign the right contained in a sale deed to get the property registered back or the right being personal cannot be assigned – Held: No implied prohibition of transfer or assignment can be inferred in a document – Condition of right to repurchase in sale deed will not be personal to the vendor unless the terms in the documents specifically state so – Such a right can always be assigned and the contract containing such condition shall be enforceable – The only exception being that such a right should not be personal in nature – In the present case, there was no term in the conditional Sale Deed which debarred its assignment to any other person – The clause only mentioned regarding right of repurchase – The option was given to the vendors with the obligations on the vendee – No error in the judgment of the High Court – Contract.
Dismissing the appeal, the Court HELD: The condition of right to repurchase in sale deed will not be personal to the vendor unless the terms in the documents specifically state so. Such a right can always be assigned and the contract containing such condition shall be enforceable. The only exception being that such a right should not be personal in nature. The assignment of obligations in a document is not possible without the consent of the other party. No implied prohibition of transfer or assignment can be inferred in a document. The benefit of contract is assignable in cases where it does not make any difference to the person on whom the obligations lies, to which of two persons he is to discharge. If the facts of the case in hand are considered, there is no term in the conditional Sale Deed which debars its assignment to any other person. The clause only mentions regarding right of repurchase. The option is given to the vendors with the obligations on the [2023] 10 S.C.R. 372 : 2023 INSC 593 A B C D E F G H vendee. The right to repurchase in the present case has been assigned by KLS (now deceased) in favour of respondent no.1 who is none else than his daughter-in-law to whom other properties have also been gifted. Even the argument raised by counsel for the appellant that such an assignment of a right cannot be treated as a gift as consideration money is involved, is also noticed and rejected for the reason that the executor of the Gift Deed i.e KLS (now deceased) had transferred his right to repurchase the property in favour of respondent no.1. That right could always be assigned by him with whatever conditions attached to it. Further in the suit filed, he was also a plaintiff, who died later. No error in the judgment of the High Court. [Paras 21-24][385-G-H; 386-A-E] Bhoju Mandal and Ors. vs. Debnath Bhagat and Ors.
1963 Supp (2) SCR 82 – held inapplicable.
T.M. Balakrishna Mudaliar vs. M. Satyanarayana Rao and Ors. (1993) 2 SCC 740 : [1993] 2 SCR 888; Shyam Singh vs. Daryao Singh (dead) by LRs and Ors (2003)
12 SCC 160 : [2003] 5 Suppl. SCR 784 – relied on.
Kapilaben and Ors. vs. Ashok Kumar Jayantilal Sheth, through POA Gopal Bhai Madhusudan Patel and Ors (2020) 20 SCC 648 – referred to.
Sakalaguna Nayudu v. Chinna Munuswami Naykar AIR 1928 PC 174 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [1963] Supp (2) SCR 82 held inapplicable Para 6 (2020) 20 SCC 648 referred to Para 6 [1993] 2 SCR 888 relied on Para 8 [2003] 5 Suppl. SCR 784 relied on Para 8 CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 9833 of 2014.
From the Judgment and Order dated 26.09.2013 of the High Court of Patna in SA No.123 of 2000.
INDIRA DEVI v. VEENA GUPTA & ORS.
A B C D E F G H 374 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
Sanjay R. Hegde, Sr. Adv., Farrukh Rasheed, Ashish Sharma, Abu Bakr Sabbaq, Mahesh Kumar, Advs. for the Appellant. Yadav Narender Singh, Rahul Shukla, Ms. Eshita Baruah, Ms. Sayantani Basak, Ms. Kanchan Dahiya, Ms. Bachita B. Shukla, Rahul Pratap, Advs. for the Respondents.
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
RAJESH BINDAL, J.
1.The appellant herein has challenged the order dated September 26, 2013 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Patna in Second Appeal No. 123 of 2000.
2.The facts of the case available on record are being noticed here. Kaleshwar Prasad Singh was inducted as a tenant in the property in question by late Kishori Lal Sahu who was the exclusive owner thereof. He along with his son executed a conditional sale deed dated 5.8.1977 in favour of Indira Devi d/o Kaleshwar Prasad Singh. It was mentioned in the sale deed that vendors were in dire need of money, hence, with the consent of family members, conditional sale deed was being executed in favour of the vendee for a total sale consideration of 5000/-. The condition in sale deed was that in case the vendors return the full consideration amount to the vendee by July, 1984, the vendee would return the property by means of a registered sale deed at the cost of the vendors. In case, the vendors fail to pay the consideration money within the stipulated time, the vendee will become exclusive owner of the property. Till then the vendee would not deal with the property in any manner whatsoever.
3.Late Kishori Lal Sahu executed a registered gift deed dated 14.02.1983 in favour of his daughter-in-law, Veena Gupta w/o Gopal Prasad. The description of the property was detailed out in the Gift Deed, wherein it was stated that the executant was old and the beneficiary was taking care of him, hence the properties are being gifted to her. Number of properties were gifted. It was mentioned therein that the property as mentioned at column no. 5 therein was transferred to Indira Devi by way of registered sale deed dated 5.8.1977, which can be purchased back by Veena Gupta from Indira Devi.
4.The vendors were ready and willing to return 5000/- to the vendee to get the sale deed registered back in their name but the vendee A B C D E F G H was not agreeing to the same. The civil suit was filed by the respondent no.1 along with Kishori Lal Sahu (now deceased) in 1983. The prayer in the suit was for a direction to the appellant to accept 5000/- as consideration money and execute sale deed in favour of respondent no.1 in respect of the house as mentioned in the suit. On failure, decree be passed directing appellant to register the sale deed in favour of the respondent no.1, the first plaintiff and as a consequence, the plaintiffs be put in possession of the property in question. In the alternative, the prayer was that there is a relationship of landlord and tenant between Kishori Lal Sahu (non deceased), the second plaintiff and Kaleshwar Prasad Singh, the first defendant. A decree of eviction be passed in favour of the plaintiffs on the ground of personal necessity and non payment of rent and the possession be got delivered. The Trial Court vide judgment dated 27.9.1986 dismissed the suit. The judgment and decree of the Trial Court was upheld by the lower appellate court vide judgment and order dated 27.1.2000. In second appeal filed by the respondents, the judgments of the courts below were reversed by the High Court vide judgment dated 26.09.2013. The High Court framed the following substantial questions of law:
“(i) Whether the courts below committed error in dismissing the suit of the plaintiff on wrong approach and on consideration of an issue which was not material for the purpose of adjudication of the suit?
(ii) Whether the courts below committed error in not considering the main issues involved in the suit regarding character and construction in respect of the deed impugned?
(iii) Whether the courts below committed error in not considering the issue of merger of tenancy to the ownership as is relevant in the deed of sale?”
ARGUMENTS OF THE APPELLANTS
5.The argument raised by the learned counsel for the appellant was that late Kishori Lal Sahu executed the conditional sale deed along with his son in favour Indira Devi on 5.8.1977. He had no right to assign his right to repurchase the property, to any third party, the right being personal to him. Even otherwise there was no clause in the sale deed in terms of which such right could be assigned to anyone else. It was further submitted that the Gift Deed by which the property was given to INDIRA DEVI v. VEENA GUPTA & ORS.
[RAJESH BINDAL, J.] A B C D E F G H 376 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
Veena Gupta cannot be termed as Gift Deed as there was consideration for transfer of the property in question as she could get the property in question only on payment of the consideration money mentioned in the sale deed. It was further submitted that from a perusal of the plaint, it is not evident that the plaintiffs were always ready and willing to fulfil the condition as mentioned in the conditional sale deed as they had no money available with them. Further, the stand taken by the appellant in the written statement was that late Kishori Lal Sahu was not keeping good health, hence the Gift Deed executed in favour of Veena Gupta was not a valid document.
6.In support of the plea that the right as conferred in the sale deed being personal, could not be assigned, reliance was placed upon the judgments of this Court in Bhoju Mandal and Ors. vs. Debnath Bhagat and Ors.1 and Kapilaben and Ors. vs. Ashok Kumar Jayantilal Sheth, through POA Gopal Bhai Madhusudan Patel and Ors2. It was further argued that multiple reliefs having been claimed in the suit, the same was not maintainable as on the one hand, the claim was for specific performance whereas on the other hand, the plea of tenancy was also raised.
ARGUMENTS OF THE RESPONDENTS
7.On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the only relief pressed by him is at serial no. 1 in the suit i.e. with reference to the specific performance with possession. It is a case in which late Kishori Lal Sahu, father-in-law of Veena Gupta, had executed the Gift Deed in her favour pertaining to his properties including the property in question. It is specifically mentioned in the Gift Deed that Veena Gupta can take possession of the property sold to Indira Devi by purchasing the same from her. She will have all rights available to her which late Kishori Lal Sahu had. As per the condition in the sale deed, the property could be repurchased in case 5000/- were paid to Indira Devi up to July, 1984. The amount was offered to Indira Devi, however, when she refused to accept the same, civil suit was filed. As the appellants were not accepting the consideration, during the pendency of the civil suit an application was filed in March, 1984 seeking permission to deposit 5000/- in the Court. On permission being granted by the Court, the amount was deposited in Court on April 29, 1984. Hence, there was 11963 Supp (2) SCR 82
2 (2020) 20 SCC 648
A B C D E F G H compliance of the condition laid down in the sale deed for getting the property back. The right to get the aforesaid property back was assigned by late Kishori Lal Sahu to the respondent no.1 vide registered gift deed. The error committed by both the courts below in dismissing the suit was corrected by the High Court.
8.To counter the argument raised by the learned counsel for the appellant that the right being personal to the deceased late Kishori Lal Sahu, could not be assigned, reliance was placed upon judgment of this Court in T.M. Balakrishna Mudaliar vs. M. Satyanarayana Rao and Ors.3 and Shyam Singh vs. Daryao Singh (dead) by LRs and Ors4. It was submitted that such a right is not personal and the same can always be assigned. In any case, it was not assigned in favour of any third party rather it was by the father-in-law of Veena Gupta in her favour, as he was getting old. It was in the family only. He further submitted that Special Leave Petition bearing SLP(C) No. 5910 of 2014 filed by Rajmani Devi & Ors. against Veena Gupta, respondent no.1 herein challenging the same judgment on the issue of default in payment of rent on the part of original defendants was dismissed by this Court on 21.02.2014. 9.Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
DISCUSSION
10.The primary issue which requires consideration in the present appeal is as to whether the vendor can assign the right contained in a sale deed to get the property registered back or the right being personal cannot be assigned.
11.The contents of the documents placed on record would be relevant to appreciate the issue. The relevant clauses in the conditional sale deed are extracted hereinbelow: - “That the vendors after taking confident of the vendee about the right title of the vendors and possession executed the conditional sale deed on valid consideration of Rs.5,000/ {Rupees five thousands} only and handed over the full right title and possession to the vendee St. Indira Devi having left no concern with the property. The vendors were out of the purview of Land Calling Act.
3 (1993) 2 SCC 740
4 (2003) 12 SCC 160
INDIRA DEVI v. VEENA GUPTA & ORS.
[RAJESH BINDAL, J.] A B C D E F G H 378 SUPREME COURT REPORTS [2023] 10 S.C.R.
That the conditional sale deed is being executed on condition that if the vendors would return the full consideration money to the vendee by July 1984 then the vendee would return the same by means of registered sale deed at the cost of the vendors and the vendors fail to return the consideration money within the stipulated time the vendee would be full owner of the property till then the vendee would neither execute any deed of conveyance to others with respect to the land would mortgage the land nor would became the guarantor over the land nor would take loan over the land, if it would have been done it would be illegal. The vendee would also neither change the physical feature of the house nor the vendee would be entitle to pay the rent to the state of Bihar. If the vendors intend to return the consideration money to the vendee within the stipulated period the vendee would execute a sale deed in favour of the vendors (failing which/the vendors would deposit the full consideration money in the court and the right title of the vendee would be seized and in that case the vendee would bear the cost of the damages. If the vendee would be dispossessed from the afore said land or part thereof on account of some legal complication the vendors and their legal heirs would be liable to pay the full consideration money -A with damages to the vendee. The vendee would acquired full right title over the afore said land after the expiry of stipulated period and the vendors would have no option or right there after to interfere with respect to the right title and possession of the vendee and the vendee would have been on liberty to mutate his name in place of vendors and utilize the land as per her choice if any interference is made by the vendors or their heirs would be illegal by the court and the vendors would be entitle to bear the cost and damages”.
(emphasis supplied)
12.The relevant clauses in the Gift Deed are extracted hereinbelow:- “I, the executant, am in possession of the above-mentioned property. I am in old age now and God knows when this life will come to an end. That beneficiary of this document is the Potehu (daughter-in-law) of the executant. She takes care of me, the executant and I am happy with her care. Therefore, I have decided A B C D E F G H to gift my entire property to her and make her owner of my all the properties like me.
……..
Only some property, as mentioned at column No. 5, has been given to Smt. Indira Devi through sale deed dated 5.8.1977. No other document regarding these properties has been executed. …… She can also take the possession of property sold to Indra Devi and Malti Devi by purchasing the same from her. Now she will get all the rights which I was enjoying till date in respect of abovementioned property.”
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.