Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1108; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 794
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Manoj Misra, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 12 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11418/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 794 : 2025 INSC 1108 Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v.
Mandeepa Enterprises and Others (Civil Appeal No. 11418 of 2025)
12 September 2025 [Manoj Misra and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the Division Bench of the High Court fell in error in directing respondent nos. 2 to 4 to allow rectification of the financial bid of respondent no.1 by treating the amount offered by it as the per day figure and on that basis to compute the total amount for the entire contractual period of 1095 days.
Headnotes† Tender – Electronic bid – A notice inviting electronic bid was issued for engaging complete Road User Fee (RUF) collection operator for RUF collection from commercial vehicles (nonpassenger) at designated locations – The contract period was for 1095 days – On opening of financial bids, it was found that appellant-Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited was the highest bidder with the quoted amount of Rs. 91,19,00,000/- (for 1095 days) and respondent no. 1 was the lowest bidder (H4) at the offered amount of Rs. 9,72,999/- – Respondent no. 1 made a request to respondent no. 4 to change the rate offered by it by treating the same as per day offer and on that basis, figure would stand at Rs. 106,54,33,905/- – Prayer was rejected – Writ petition – Single Judge of the High Court dismissed the writ petition – However, the Division Bench of the High Court allowed the appeal by directing respondent nos. 2 to 4 to evaluate the Bill of Quantity (BOQ) rate of respondent no. 1 by treating Rs. 106,54,33,905/- as the amount for the entire contractual period of 1095 days instead of Rs. 9,72,999/- which was treated to be a per day figure – Correctness:
Held: Clause 4 of the notice inviting electronic bid lays down the eligibility criteria for participation in bid – Clause 4(g) specifically * Author [2025] 9 S.C.R. 795Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Others says that any change in the template of BOQ will not be accepted under any circumstances – Division Bench of the High Court has interpreted this clause in a broad way to include rectification of bona fide mistakes in quoting BOQ rates by the bidders – This provision is meant to empower the notice inviting authority to seek clarification or further information regarding any document filed by a bidder – This cannot be interpreted so broadly as to include rectification of the BOQ rates which is governed by Clause 4(g) of the notice inviting electronic bid putting a complete embargo to any change in the template of BOQ; the prohibition is specific: change in the template of BOQ will not be accepted under any circumstances – The view of this Court is fortified by the item rate BOQ of respondent no. 1 entered into figure for 1095 days – Therefore, though the contention of respondent no. 1 is that it had made an inadvertent mistake in quoting the BOQ rate of per day figure instead of the total contract period of 1095 days, a closer scrutiny would however belie such contention – Allowing respondent no. 1 to rectify such mistakes after finalization of the financial bid would be highly improper as it would have the effect of unsettling the entire tender process – The Division Bench of the High Court clearly fell in error in directing respondent nos. 2 to 4 to allow rectification of the financial bid of respondent No. 1 by treating the amount offered by it as the per day figure and on that basis to compute the total amount for the entire contractual period of 1095 days – Also, non-impleadment and consequential non-hearing of the appellant by the High Court, has vitiated the impugned judgment and order – Thus, impugned judgment and order dated 23.02.2024 passed by the Division Bench of the High Court cannot be sustained and is hereby set aside and quashed. [Paras 29-32, 43, 45] Case Law Cited West Bengal State Electricity Board v. Patel Engineering Company Limited [2001] 1 SCR 352 : (2001) 2 SCC 451; Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa [2006] Supp. 10 SCR 606 : (2007) 14 SCC 517; Afcons Infrastructure Limited v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corporation Limited [2016] 3 SCR 551 : (2016) 16 SCC 818; CIDCO v. Shishir Realty Private Limited [2021] 13 SCR 190 : (2012) 16 SCC 527 – relied on.
Johra v. State of Haryana [2018] 14 SCR 970 : (2019) 2 SCC 324; M/s. ABCI Infrastructures Private Limited v. Union of India, 2025 796 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports INSC 215; [2025] 3 SCR 128;Subodh Kumar Singh Rathore v. Chief Executive Officer [2024] 7 SCR 532 : 2024 SCC Online SC 1682 – referred to.
Supreme Infrastructure India Limited v. Rail Vikas Nigam Limited, 2012 SCC Online Delhi 616 – referred to.
List of Keywords Tender; Electronic bid; Road User Fee (RUF); Highest bidder; Lowest bidder; Bill of Quantity (BOQ); Rectification of bona fide mistakes; Non-impleadment; Non-hearing of party.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11418 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 23.02.2024 of the High Court at Calcutta in MAT No. 93 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Kavin Gulati, Sr. Adv., Monish Panda, Anmol Jassal, Jatinder Bir Singh, Ms. Amrita Singh, Krishna Kumar Singh.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Anurag Soan, Akshay Saxena, Ritu Raj, Ms. Kanika, Ayush Mishra, Ms. Nandini Sen Mukherjee, Tuhin, Ms. Niyati Pathak, Tuhin. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
This civil appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 23.02.2024 passed by a Division Bench of the High Court at Calcutta (High Court) in MAT No. 93 of 2024.
2. Be it stated that MAT No. 93 of 2024 was filed by the respondent No. 1 as an intra-court appeal against the final order dated 03.01.2024 passed by a learned Single Judge of the High Court dismissing the writ petition, WPA No. 29001 of 2023, filed by respondent No. 1. [2025] 9 S.C.R. 797Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Others
3. Respondent No. 1 had filed the aforesaid writ petition assailing the action of respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4 (State of West Bengal and its officials) refusing to treat respondent No. 1 as the highest bidder by permitting it to rectify its financial bid after the bidding process was over. After observing that there was no scope for interference, learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition.
4. Aggrieved by such dismissal, respondent No. 1 preferred an intracourt appeal which was registered as MAT No. 93 of 2024. According to the Division Bench, the error in quoting the figure by respondent No. 1 was inadvertent; instead of quoting the price for the entire contract period of 1095 days, respondent No. 1 had uploaded per day amount of the Bill of Quantity (BOQ) of Rs. 9,72,999.00. Division Bench further observed that respondent No. 1 had promptly sought for correction of the error immediately after reopening of the price bids. Therefore, the Division Bench allowed the writ appeal vide the judgment and order dated 23.02.2024 by setting aside the order of the learned Single Judge, further directing respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4 to evaluate the BOQ rate of respondent No. 1 by treating the amount offered by respondent No. 1 as the per day amount and then on that basis to compute the total amount for the entire contract period of 1095 days. However, the Division Bench was of the view that an opportunity should be granted by the tendering authority to the other bidders as well to match the price of respondent No. 1 and thereafter to take a final decision with regard to the award of contract.
5. It is this judgment and order which is under impugnment in the present proceeding.
6. At the outset, relevant facts may be noted.
7. A notice inviting electronic bid No. 7 of 2023-24 dated 17.10.2023 was issued by the Superintending Engineer and Project Director, Project Implementation Unit – I, Public Works (Roads) Directorate, Government of West Bengal for engaging complete Road User Fee (RUF) collection operator for RUF collection from commercial vehicles (non-passenger) at designated locations on few roads in the State of West Bengal. In this case, we are concerned with the following work: RUF Collection with HNETC System Integration and Transaction Acquiring services at Fee collection plaza under NETC programme through NPCI approved acquirer bank including engagement of required man power for 798 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports operation of Road User Fee collection plaza for Dankuni Chandannagar Mogra in Hooghly district SH 13.
8. The contract period is for 1095 days. While the annual potential collection was pegged at Rs. 21.60 crores, the earnest money deposit/ bid security was fixed at Rs. 25,00,000.00. As per Clause 2 of the notice inviting electronic bid, there would be two bids: technical bid and financial bid, both of which would have to be submitted concurrently duly digitally signed in the website of the West Bengal Government. Clause 3 mentioned that the rates should be quoted both in words and in figures in specific format i.e. BOQ. In case of any discrepancy between words and figures, the rate quoted in words would be treated as the actual rate offered. After bidding, the selected bidder will be the H1 bidder who will offer the highest remittance for the contract period and will make necessary agreement with the condition that the accepted bid amount over the stipulated period will have to be deposited in advance as per payment schedule to the government account in lieu of RUF collection right.
9. Clause 4 lays down the eligibility criteria for participation in the Bid. Clause 4(g) is very specific. It says that any change in the template of BOQ will not be accepted under any circumstances. Clause 4(g) reads thus:
Any change in template of BOQ will not be accepted under any circumstances.
10. The date and time schedule of the tender process as provided in Clause 9 was as follows:
9. Date & Time Schedule:
Particulars Date & Time
1. Date of Publishing NIT & Tender Documents 17/10/2023
2. D o c u m e n t S a l e / Download Start Date 18/10/2023 from 10.00 a.m.
3. Pre Bid Meeting with the intending bidders 03/11/2023 at 1.00 p.m.
at the Conference Hall of PWD at Nabanna, 8th Floor, 325, Sarat Chatterjee Road.,Howrah- 711102.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 799Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Others
4. B i d S u b m i s s i o n / Upload Start Date 08/11/2023 from 3.00 p.m.
5. B i d S u b m i s s i o n / Upload End Date 22/11/2023 upto 3.00 p.m.
6. Date of opening of Technical Proposals 24/11/2023 at 3.00 p.m.
7. D a t e o f o p e n i n g o f F i n a n c i a l B i d / Proposals To be notified at the time of publishing List of Technically Qualified Bidders in the web portal only.
11. Instructions to Bidders is part of the notice inviting electronic bid. Clause 5 thereof deals with submission of bids. It clarified that the notice inviting bid was of two bid system: (i) technical and (ii) financial, both to be submitted concurrently in the portal. Bidders who would be technically pre-qualified in respect of technical and financial eligibility/capability criteria would only be permitted to participate in the financial bidding. Bidders were required to submit online in two folders for each work, one being technical proposal and the other being financial proposal. It was clarified that at the time of uploading bid, care should be taken so that during evaluation, all the documents required to be submitted by the bidders are found in a neat, clear and in a readable format, otherwise the bid might be treated as cancelled. The instructions to bidders also clarifies that technical proposals will be opened by the Bid Inviting Authority (BIA) or by the Bid Evaluation Committee, and thereafter to upload the summary list of technically qualified bidders. Heading of sub-clause B is bid evaluation. As per sub-clause B(v), in the course of evaluation, the notice inviting authority may seek clarification/information or additional supporting documents or original hard copies of documents already submitted and if these are not produced by the bidders within the stipulated time frame, their proposals will be liable for rejection. Clause 5B (v) of the Instruction to Bidders is as follows:
v. While evaluation the Notice Inviting Authority may summon of the bids and seek clarification/information or additional supporting documents or original hard copies against any of the documents only, which are already submitted/uploaded to the web portal and if these are not 800 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports produced by the intending Bidders within the stipulated time frame, their proposals will be liable for rejection.
12. The following seven bidders had participated in the present tender process. These seven bidders are as follows:
1. Ainul Hoque
2. SK Nasir.
3. Mandeepa Enterprises
4. RMN Infrastructures Limited.
5. M/S GVR Infra Projects Limited.
6. Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways India Ltd
7. Eagle Infra India Ltd.
13. Tender evaluation was carried out by a five-member screening committee for bid evaluation on 06.12.2023 which was constituted vide G.O. No. 3410-PW/O/E-1/2M-17/2017 dated 18.09.2017. After evaluation of the technical bids by aforesaid committee, it was found that out of the aforesaid total seven bidders, only four numbers of bidders were found to be technically qualified. Three bidders were found to be non eligible and declared as disqualified. The short listed four bidders are as follows:
(i) Ainul Hoque
(ii) Mandeepa Enterprises
(iii) Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited
(iv) Eagle Infra India Limited It was mentioned that financial bids would be opened on 08.12.2023 at 06:30 pm.
14. Accordingly, forty eight hours after declaration of technical evaluation, financial bids of the four technically qualified bidders were opened electronically as per the e-tender mechanism. On such opening, it was found that the appellant Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited was the highest bidder with the quoted amount of Rs. 91,19,00,000.00 (for 1095 days). It was also found that respondent No. 1 was the lowest bidder (H4) at the offered amount of Rs. 9,72,999.00. Details of financial bid evaluation are as under: [2025] 9 S.C.R. 801Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Others BOQ Summary Details Tender Title: WBPWD/PW(R)/SEPD/PIU-I/NIB-07 OF 2023-24, SI-3 TENDER ID: 2023_WBPWD_595358_3 Sheet Name SI.
No.
Bidder Name Amount Bid Rank BoQ1 1 Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways India Ltd.
911900000.00 H1 2 Eagle Infra India Ltd. 783899999.00 H2 3 Ainul Hoque 652176525.00 H3 4 Mandeepa Enterprises 972999.00 H4
15. Since much hinges on this, we may extract the item rate BOQ of respondent No. 1 which is as under:
Item Rate BoQ Tender Inviting Authority: Superintending Engineer & Project Director, Project Implementation Unit-I.
Name of Work: RUF Collection with HNETC System Integration and Transaction Acquiring services at Fee collection plaza under NETC programme through NPCI approved acquirer bank including engagement of required man power for operation of Road User Fee collection plaza for Dankuni Chandannagar Mogra in Hooghly district SH 13.
Contract No: SL No. 3 of eNIB No. 07 of 2023-2024 of S.E. & PD/PIU-I Name of the Bidder/Bidding Firm/Company: Mandeepa Enterprises
PRICE SCHEDULE
(This BOQ template must not be modified/replaced by the bidder and the same should be uploaded after filling the relevant columns, else the bidder is liable to be rejected for this tender. Bidders are allowed to enter the Bidder Name and Values only)
NUM
BER# TEXT# NUM BER# TEXT# NUMBER# NUMBER# TEXT# SL.
No.
Name of the road on which Road User Fee Plaza is situated Qua ntity Units Amount of Road User Fee in Figures To be entered by the Bidder for 1095 Days Rs. P
TOTAL
AMOUNT
(in figures)
exclusive of all taxes
TOTAL
AMOUNT
In Words 802 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
1. RUF Collection with HNETC System Integration and Transaction Acquiring services at Fee collection plaza under NETC progr-amme through NPCI approved acquirer bank including engagement of required man power for operation of Road User Fee collection plaza for Dankuni Chandannagar Mogra in Hoogly district SH 13.
(Scope of work as per terms and condition laid down in the NIB)
1 Nos 972999.00 972999.00 INR Nine Lakh Seventy Two Thousand Nine Hundred & Ninety Nine Only Total in Figures 972999.00 INR Nine Lakh Seventy Two Thousand Nine Hundred & Ninety Nine Only Quoted Rate in Words INR Nine Lakh Seventy Two Thousand Nine Hundred & Ninety Nine Only
16. After the financial bids were opened and became public, respondent No. 1 made a request to the tender committee vide e-mail dated 13.12.2023. The e-mail was accompanied by an affidavit stating that the amount offered was per day rate and that the said figure should be worked out for the total contract period of 1095 days in which event, the offer of respondent No. 1 would stand at Rs. 106,54,33,905.00 [2025] 9 S.C.R. 803Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Others for the contract period. The tendering authority was requested to treat the figure of Rs. 9,72,999.00 as a typographical error and the figure offered by respondent No. 1 should be read as 106,54,33,905.00. The authority was further requested to consider the same keeping higher revenue in mind.
17. It appears that vide communication dated 20.12.2023, respondent No. 4 rejected the prayer of respondent No. 1 stating that such request for correction of financial bid was not possible to be entertained as it would impeach the sanctity of the tender process.
18. Thereafter, respondent No. 1 filed a writ petition before the High Court seeking the following reliefs:
a) Leave under Rule 26 of the Rules relating to petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to move the writ petition before service of copy of the petition be granted to the petitioner to move the writ petition before service of copy thereof, in view of extreme urgency as narrated hereinabove;
b) A Writ of Mandamus directing the respondents and each of them esp., the respondent No. 3, to rescind and/or cancel and/or withdraw the letter rejecting the prayer of the petitioner to amend the rate quoted by the petitioner in the bid in respect of the tender process being Annexure “P-1”to the petition forthwith;
c) A Writ of Mandamus directing the respondent No. 3 to allow the petitioner to amend and/or rectify the petitioner’s bid in respect of the tender process dated 17th October, 2023 being Annexure “P-1” hereto by quoting the rate for 1095 days instead or one day treating the same as bonafide and inadvertent mistake of the petitioner and then to consider the bid of the petitioner in the financial bid upon rectification of the same in terms of the prayers of the petitioner made in the letters and documents submitted by the petitioner on 13.12.2023, 15.12.2023 and 20.12.2023 in respect of the tender process dated 17th October, 2023 being Annexure “P-5”, “P-6” and “P-7”· hereto;
d) A writ of Certiorari calling upon the respondents and each of them to certify and transmit all records in respect of 804 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports tender having Memo No. 590-R/PIU-I dated 17th October, 2023 being notice inviting Electronic Bid No. 07-2023-24 by the Superintending Engineer/ Project Director Unit-I Public Works (Roads) Directorate being Annexure “P-1”
hereto and all subsequent letters and correspondences being Annexure “P-2” to “P-8” hereto to this Hon’ble Court so that conscionable justice may be done by quashing and/ or setting aside the letter of rejection by the respondent No.3 dated 20th December, 2023 being Annexure “P-8”
hereto and by directing the respondent No. 3 to allow the petitioner to rectify and/ or amend the bid for 1095 days and further process the bid of the petitioner upon such rectification in the financial bid of the said tender process being Annexure “P-1” hereto;
e) A Writ of Prohibition prohibiting the respondents and each of them, esp., the respondent No. 3 from indulging any further non-action and/or inaction in allowing the petitioner from rectifying the bid of the petitioner for l095 days and from further taking any steps for issuing the Letter of Acceptance (LOA) to the H-1 bidder in respect of the said tender process being Annexure “P-1” hereto;
f) Interim order directing the respondents and each of them, esp., the respondent No. 3 from proceeding further in the tender process being Annexure “P-1” hereto including issuing the Letter of Acceptance (LOA) to the H-1 bidder in respect of the tender process being Annexure “P-1”
hereto till the disposal of the writ petition;
g) Ad-interim order of terms of prayer (f) above;
h) Rule NISI in terms of prayers (a), (b), (c), (d), (e), (f) and
(g) above;
i) Costs;
j) Such further or other order or orders be passed and/or direction or directions be given as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper.
19. The writ petition was registered as W.P.A. No. 29001 of 2023. A Single Bench of the High Court dismissed the writ petition vide the order dated 03.01.2024 by holding as under:
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 805Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Others
8. Bona fides cannot be attributed to the petitioner;
rather, the petitioner was grossly negligent, since the price schedule indicated in the BOQ, which found place even in the bid of the petitioner itself, clearly showed that the amount of Road User Fee in the figures was to be entered by the bidder for 1095 days.
Even after knowing the same and being aware of the various amounts involved by way of annual potential collection and bid security, the petitioner committed the error which it did.
9. After the financial bid was opened, the petitioner wrote to the tender issuing authorities. If such an opportunity is to be given to a particular bidder, the same would upset the entire tender process and, as rightly argued by the respondents, would make the tender process opaque and arbitrary.
10. The petitioner, with its eyes open, participated in the bid and quoted an erroneous amount. As such, the petitioner ought to suffer for the same and take responsibility therefor. Even if the petitioner’s bid, if taken to be for 1095 days, would far exceed the next highest bid, such opportunity cannot be given to the petitioner to rectify its error after the entire bidding process was over and the financial bids of all the bidders were opened. Such chance, if given to the petitioner, would be contrary to every known principle of fairness pertaining to tenders and would amount to a special favour being extended to the petitioner for no particular reason.
11. Thus, there is no scope of interference in the tender process.
20. Aggrieved thereby, respondent No. 1 preferred a letters patent appeal before the Division Bench of the High Court which was registered as MAT No. 93 of 2024. Vide the judgment and order dated 23.02.2024, the Division Bench of the High Court observed as under:
8. * * * * * Thus, in the light of the above undisputed factual position we are of the considered view that the Tender 806 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Inviting Authority had sufficient leverage and play in the joints to seek for any clarification or information during the entire evaluation process and sub-clause
(b) of clause 5 of the Instruction to Bidders is not restricted to the stage of evaluation of the technical bid along but it encompasses the evaluation of the entire tender right from the stage of inception till the issuance of work order. This interpretation is proper interpretation that should be given to the said clause or else it would put shackles on the right of the Tender Inviting Authority. The explanation offered by the appellant is acceptable and the appellant’s offer is Rs.16 crore over and above the highest offer which is now come to the light after the financial bid has been opened.
9. For the above reasons, the appeal is allowed and order passed in the writ petition is set aside and the writ petition is allowed and the respondents are directed to evaluate the appellant’s BOQ by taking the amount of Rs.106,54,33,905.00 for the period of 1095 days as called for in the tender notification.
10. Since admittedly the affidavit for correction of the bid document was submitted after opening the financial bid, this Court feels that an opportunity is to be granted to other bidders to match the price quoted by the writ petitioner. The Tender Inviting Authority shall call upon all the bidders who were found to be technically qualified including the petitioner and after evaluating the bids of all such bidders and after giving opportunity to the other bidders, who are found technically qualified, to match the corrected figures quoted by the writ petitioner shall take a final decision with regard to award of the contract in question.
21. It may be mentioned that both before the learned Single Judge as well as before the Division Bench, appellant was not arrayed as a party respondent, though on evaluation of the financial bids, it was found to be the highest bidder (H1).
22. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and order dated 23.02.2024, appellant preferred the related special leave petition. By order dated [2025] 9 S.C.R. 807Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Others 27.05.2024, this Court granted permission to the appellant to file the special leave petition. While issuing notice, this Court also stayed the impugned judgment and order dated 23.02.2024. Thereafter, the matter was heard on 08.08.2025 when leave was granted.
23. Mr. Kavin Gulati, learned senior counsel for the appellant submits that after the financial bids were opened, appellant was found to be and was declared as the highest (H1) bidder by the tendering authority on 13.12.2023. Admittedly, respondent No. 1 sought rectification/ correction of its financial bid only after the financial bids were opened and only after the appellant was declared as H1. The tendering authority was fully justified in rejecting the request of respondent No. 1 for rectification/correction of its financial bid.
23.1. Learned Single Judge was justified in observing that if the opportunity as sought for by respondent No. 1 is allowed, the same would upset the entire tender process. Learned Single Judge had rightly observed that respondent No. 1 had participated in the tender process with its eyes wide open and had quoted an erroneous amount. Even if its bid taken for the entire contract period exceeds the highest bid, such opportunity for rectification cannot be given to respondent No. 1 to rectify its error after the entire bidding process was over and the financial bids of all the tenderers were opened. If this is accepted and respondent No. 1 is given such an opportunity, it would be contrary to every known principle of fairness pertaining to tenders and would amount to a special favour being extended to respondent No. 1 for no particular reason. Learned senior counsel submits that the view taken by the learned Single Judge is the correct view and should not have been interfered with by the Division Bench in a letters patent appeal.
23.2. Mr. Gulati submits that in the proceedings before the learned Single Judge, appellant was not made a party respondent though it was the highest (H1) bidder. Though the relief claimed by respondent No. 1, if granted, would have adversely affected the appellant, this issue did not arise because the learned Single Judge did not accept the contentions of respondent No. 1 and had declined to interfere with the tender process.
23.3. However, in the intra-court appeal before the Division Bench, respondent No. 1 again did not array the appellant as a party 808 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports respondent. Division Bench took the view that the tendering authority had sufficient leverage and play in the joints to seek any clarification or information during the tender evaluation process. Learned senior counsel submits that the Division Bench had interpreted Clause 5B(v) of the Instructions to Bidders erroneously to hold that the tendering authority had the discretion to seek any clarification or information at any stage of the tender process right from the stage of inception till issuance of the work order and thereafter to hold that any other interpretation would put shackles on the functioning of the tendering authority. Learned senior counsel submits that the aforesaid view taken by the Division Bench is palpably erroneous having the effect of unsettling the entire tender process. Clause 5B(v) of the Instructions to Bidders cannot be given such a broad interpretation. Referring to Clause 4(g) of the tender conditions, he submits that it is clear therefrom that change of Bill of Quantity (BOQ) would not be accepted under any circumstances. If the view of the Division Bench is accepted, there would be no finality attached to a tender process which in turn would impeach the sanctity of the tender process itself.
23.4. Learned senior counsel further submits that the final direction of the Division Bench directing the tendering authority to evaluate the BOQ of respondent No. 1 not at Rs. 9,72,999.00 which it held to be per day figure but to accept respondent No. 1’s BOQ at Rs. 106,54,33,905.00 for the entire contract period has changed, the entire complexion of the tendering process thereby rendering the position of the appellant wholly untenable despite being declared as the highest (H1) bidder by the tendering authority. This direction of the Division Bench entails adverse civil consequences upon the appellant. Despite being so, the Division Bench did not deem it appropriate to get the appellant impleaded in the appellate proceedings. Consequently, no notice was issued or opportunity of hearing granted to the appellant by the Division Bench before disposing of the intra-court appeal. This is in clear violation of the principles of natural justice.
23.5. According to him, the reasoning adopted by the Division Bench is highly questionable. Division Bench has taken the [2025] 9 S.C.R. 809Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Limited v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Others view that if the BOQ amount of respondent No. 1 is read as Rs. 106,54,33,905.00, the difference between the amount quoted by respondent No. 1 and what is being offered by the H1 bidder i.e. the appellant would be about 15 crores and this additional amount would enure to the benefit of the state exchequer. He submits that collecting higher revenue is only one facet of public interest. The other aspect, which is more important, is that because of the avoidable litigation instituted by respondent No. 1, the State could not timely start the contract work. As a result, it lost considerable amount of revenue. However, this aspect of the matter was overlooked by the Division Bench. He reiterates that if the view taken by the Division Bench is accepted then there would be no finality to a tender process.
23.6. Learned senior counsel to buttress his arguments has submitted a compilation of judgments. Additionally, he has also placed reliance on few other judgments. The decisions relied upon by learned counsel for the appellant are as under:
(i) West Bengal State Electricity Board Vs. Patel Engineering Company Limited1
(ii) Jagdish Mandal Vs. State of Orissa2
(iii) Afcons Infrastructure Limited Vs. Nagpur Metro Rail Corporation Limited 3
(iv) Johra Vs. State of Haryana4
(v) M/s. ABCI Infrastructures Private Limited Vs. Union of India5
23.7. Finally, learned senior counsel submits that whether on account of violation of the principles of natural justice or on the point of unduly interfering with a tender process, the impugned judgment and order of the Division Bench cannot be sustained. Therefore, the same is liable to be set aside and quashed.
1 (2001) 2 SCC 451
2 (2007) 14 SCC 517
3 (2016) 16 SCC 818
4 (2019) 2 SCC 324
5 2025 INSC 215
810 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.