Maha Mineral Mining & Benefication Pvt. Ltd. v. Madhya Pradesh Power Generating Co. Ltd. & Anr.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1085; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 528
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi
- Decided
- 9 Sept 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 11726/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 528 : 2025 INSC 1085 Maha Mineral Mining & Benefication Pvt. Ltd.
v.
Madhya Pradesh Power Generating Co. Ltd. & Anr.
(Civil Appeal No. 11726 of 2025)
09 September 2025 [Surya Kant and Joymalya Bagchi, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose whether the decision of the High Court to uphold the appellant-bidder’s disqualification under Clause 5(D) for not furnishing Joint Venture agreement justified; and whether the appellant would have stood disqualified since its washeries had been exclusively committed to the State Mining Corporation. Headnotes† Tender – Notice inviting tender – Clause (5)D and Clause (5)B – Disqualification – 1st respondent invited Tender for coal beneficiation and managing logistics for Thermal Power Project – Appellant and others submitted their bid – However, the appellant-bidder was disqualified during technical evaluation by the Committee due to non-submission of credentials as per Clause No.(5)D of the NIT-non-filing of Joint Venture agreement – Decision of the Committee challenged by the appellant – High Court upheld the disqualification of the appellant by the Committee for non-compliance of Clause 5(D) of the NIT and also held that even if the JV agreement had been submitted, the appellant would have stood disqualified since its washeries had been exclusively committed to the State Mining Corporation – Correctness:
Held: 1st respondent acted contrary to the terms of the NIT and unfairly rejected the appellant’s bid for non-production of JV agreement although Clause 5(D) did not prescribe production of such agreement as mandatory to rely on past-experience of such consortium in which the bidder had a defined proportionate share – Decision of the Committee, upheld by the High Court as per Clause 5(D) liable to be set aside – Issue as regards washery capacity is a contentious one and ought not to have been decided by the High [2025] 9 S.C.R. 529Maha Mineral Mining & Benefication Pvt. Ltd. v. Madhya Pradesh Power Generating Co. Ltd. & Anr.
Court without giving opportunity to the appellant to controvert the same – High Court also lost sight of the fact that the Committee had not adverted to this issue and it was impermissible for it to travel beyond the reasons given by the Committee and disqualify the appellant – Allotment of work order to 2nd respondent has been made subject to the outcome of this proceeding – Matter remand for a fresh consideration whether appellant had requisite spare washing capacity as per Clause 5(B) of the NIT and the validity of the work order in favour of the 2nd respondent in light of such decision – Impugned judgment and order of the High Court set aside. [Paras 20, 21, 24-26] List of Keywords Disqualification; Clause 5(D) of the NIT; Non furnishing JV agreement; Washeries; Tender; Notice inviting tender; Clause (5)B of the NIT; Coal beneficiation and managing logistics for Thermal Power Project; Technical evaluation by the Committee; Non-submission of credentials; Joint Venture agreement; State Mining Corporation.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 11726 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 06.01.2025 of the High Court of Madhya Pradesh Principal Seat at Jabalpur in WP No. 18286 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Narender Hooda, Sr. Adv., Gagan Sanghi, Mrs. Farah Hashmi, Santosh Ghate, Rameshwar Prasad Goyal.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Bijender Chahar, A.S.G., Shyam Divan, Balbir Singh, Arpan Pawar, Sr. Advs., Kartik Seth, Ms. Ranjeeta Rohatgi, Nikhil Nasre, Raghav Sharma, Ms. Aditi Mishra, K.M Abish, Manan, Ms. Shrika Gautam, Himanshu Satija, Harsh Saxena, Chiranjeev Sharma, Pulkit Pawar, Mrs. Neha Mehta Satija.
530 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment
1. Leave granted.
Factual Matrix
2. In response to Notice Inviting Tender 1 dated 17.05.2024, issued by the 1 st respondent for the purpose of run-of-mine (ROM) coal beneficiation and managing logistics from Western Coalfields Ltd.2 (Nagpur area) sources for Shree Singaji Thermal Power Project, Khandwa (Madhya Pradesh), the appellant and two others, namely the 2 nd respondent 3 and one M/s NN Global Mercantile Pvt. Ltd. had submitted their bid.
3. As NN Global Mercantile Pvt. Ltd. could not furnish earnest money deposit, only the appellant and the 2 nd respondent remained in the fray. On 04.07.2024, the Tender Evaluation Committee 4 while referring to Clause 5(D) 5 of the NIT rejected the appellant’s technical bid holding as follows – 1 ID 2024_MPPGC_341576_1, hereinafter referred to as “NIT”. 2 Hereinafter “WCL”.
3 Rukhmai Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.
4 Hereinafter referred to as “The Committee”.
5 Clause 5(D): “Past Experience: Copies of successfully executed orders (including part executed) in the name of bidder for same or similar work {similar work means coal lifting from mines of CIL subsidiaries or SCCL area, coal beneficiation (through wet process), movement of washed coal by road from washery to railway siding and movement of washed coal through Railways with experience in liaisoning with Railways/ CIL subsidiaries or SCCL area, i.e., arranging rakes, dispatches coal from own or leased Private siding or Goods shed Railways siding by loading of washed coal into railway wagons through own arrangement with monitoring the rake movement etc. up to the destination Power house}. Bidder is allowed to use past experience of their previous Consortium or JV (proportionate to its share in that consortium if defined in the Consortium Agreement, otherwise, lead partner if not defined in the Consortium) to meet out the past experience criteria of the tender. The order copies should indicate the above w/ork for 4 Lakh MT (4,00,000 MT) quantity or more in stale Owned Power Generating Companies or Other Captive Power Utilities of PSU or NTPC or Govt. Industries / Departments or Semi Govt. Industries / Departments or PSUs or Nodal Agency of any PSUs in India executed in last five years ending with initial date of opening of bid are to be uploaded. This order execution should be within a period of twelve (12) months. It may be through single or multiple orders (in parallel), but in case of multiple orders; these should be within a single span of time period of twelve (12) months.
1. The work execution certificate by the customers along-with self-attested un-priced copies of aforesaid work order(s) should be submitted.
2. For Past performance certificates - If worked with MPEB/ MPSEB/ MPPGCL in past for similar work, then it is mandatory to provide Satisfactory Performance Certificate for the same. Failing this, the offer shall not be considered.” (emphasis supplied)
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 531Maha Mineral Mining & Benefication Pvt. Ltd. v. Madhya Pradesh Power Generating Co. Ltd. & Anr.
“As per Clause No. 5(D) “Past experience criteria” of NIT, bidder is allowed to use past experience of their previous Consortium or JV (proportionate to its share in that consortium if defined in the Consortium Agreement, otherwise, lead partner if not defined in the Consortium) to meet out the past experience criteria of the tender. The firm has used the credentials of their consortium M/s Hind-Maha-Mineral LLP for meeting out the past experience criteria. However, Agreement of the Consortium/ JV is not submitted to substantiate the share of the bidder in that consortium. Bidder is disqualified due to non-submission of credentials as per Clause No. (5)D of the NIT.”
4. Appellant challenged the decision of the Committee before the High Court of Madhya Pradesh. 6 Appellant contended neither Clause 5(D) nor any terms of the NIT expressly required a bidder who was relying on past-experience of a previous consortium or joint venture 7 to produce the JV agreement itself to demonstrate its proportionate share in the consortium. In terms of Clause 5(D) it had submitted a work execution certificate from Maharashtra State Mining Corporation 8 which inter alia stated that the appellant was 45% Joint Venture/Consortium Partner of M/s. Hind Maha Mineral LLP vide the JV agreement dated 02.12.2019 and had executed similar work in respect of WCL command for the period 05.03.2021 to 05.03.2024. It was further clarified the JV agreement had been submitted before MSMC.
5. In case of doubt, 1 st respondent could have verified the correctness of the certificate from MSMC or called upon the appellant to furnish the JV agreement. On the contrary, the 1st respondent arbitrarily rejected the technical bid on the ground the JV agreement had not been furnished.
6. 1st respondent contradicted such stance and contended in the event any bidder was seeking to rely on past-experience of a previous consortium/JV, submission of the JV agreement was implicit in 6 Writ Petition No. 18286/2024.
7 Hereinafter referred to as “JV”.
8 Hereinafter referred to as “MSMC”.
532 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Clause 5(D) of the NIT. Further, Clause 8.1 provided that if the bidder did not submit the desired documents as per NIT at the time of submission of the bid, he shall not be allowed to submit documents subsequently and its bid is liable to be rejected on account of incomplete documents. Clause 8.1 of the NIT unequivocally states that – “Instructions regarding shortfall documents:-
(i) The bidders not submitting all the desired documents as per NIT/Tender Document at the time of submitting bids, shall not be allowed to submit documents subsequently and their bids shall be rejected on account of incomplete documents. Thus, no “shortfall window” for submission of shortfall documents shall be created by MPPGCL in the e-tender.
(ii) Accordingly, Clause No. 1.15 (VII) “Verification of credentials/PQR” of the Standard Bid Document (SBD)
so far as it relates to “Shortfall of document” window shall not be applicable.
(iii) Any condition elsewhere mentioned in the NIT/Tender Document for submission of Shortfall Document shall not be applicable.
(iv) However, techno-commercial clarifications (if required) shall be obtained through e-mail/physical form from the bidders”
(emphasis supplied)
The said clause is further fortified by circular no. F-3/25/2015/13/10 9 issued by the Government of Madhya Pradesh on 29.11.2023. 9 Circular dated 29.11.2023: “It has come to the notice of the department that bidders are being allowed to participate in the bid process with incomplete documents. Bidders are allowed to submit the balance documents in due course of time and meanwhile some of the bidders back out of the bidding process, allowing a few number of bidders to participate in the bidding process and quote non-competitive rates which results in financial loss to the Power Companies. It has therefore been decided that bidders not submitting all the desired documents as per NIT/Tender document at the time of submitting bids, should not be allowed to submit documents subsequently and their bids should be rejected on account of incomplete documents. If required, even fresh bid can be called to get competitive rates. As directed, it is request to please ensure the bidding process to make it more transparent and fair.” (emphasis supplied)
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 533Maha Mineral Mining & Benefication Pvt. Ltd. v. Madhya Pradesh Power Generating Co. Ltd. & Anr.
7. Appellant was fully aware of the requirement to furnish the JV agreement to demonstrate its proportionate share in the consortium in order to rely on the past-experience of such previous consortium/JV. In fact after the closing date, by email dated 05.07.2024, the appellant purportedly submitted a JV agreement dated 06.09.2019, which however did not correspond to the JV agreement dated 02.12.2019 referred to in the certificate issued by the MSMC. Be that as it may, such subsequent submission of document was impermissible as per Clause 8.1 of the NIT read with circular dated 29.11.2023 and the technical bid was rightly rejected for submission of incomplete document.
8. During the pendency of the writ petition, 2nd respondent was declared as the successful bidder and was impleaded in the proceedings. During hearing, the JV agreement dated 02.12.2019 was placed on record. Written submissions were also submitted on behalf of the parties.
Findings of the High Court
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.