Kishundeo Rout & Ors. v. Govind Rao & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 956; [2025] 9 S.C.R. 113
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.B. Pardiwala, Justice R Mahadevan
- Decided
- 8 Aug 2025
- Case number
- SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) No. 22070/2025
- Sections
- 96, 107
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:18 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 113 : 2025 INSC 956 Kishundeo Rout & Ors.
v.
Govind Rao & Ors.
(Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 22070 of 2025)
08 August 2025 [J.B. Pardiwala* and R. Mahadevan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court rightly set aside the order passed by the First Appellate Court by which it had accepted the plea of adverse possession raised by the plaintiffs for the first time in appeal and decreed the suit.
Headnotes† Adverse possession – Plea – Not raised in pleadings, cannot be raised for the first time in appeal – Suit filed by the plaintiffs for cancellation of sale deed, dismissed by trial court – Appeal filed by the plaintiffs – First Appellate Court accepting the plea of adverse possession raised by them for the first time, allowed the appeal and decreed the suit – Second appeal filed by the defendants, allowed by High Court – Challenge to: Held: The foundation for the plea of adverse possession must be laid in the pleadings and then an issue must be framed and tried – A plea not properly raised in the pleadings or in issues at the stage of trial would not be permitted to be raised for the first time at the stage of First Appeal u/s.96, CPC – The plea of adverse possession is always based on facts which must be asserted and proved – A person who claims adverse possession must show on what date he came into possession, what was the nature of his possession, whether the factum of his possession was known to the legal claimants and how long his possession continued and whether his possession was open and undisturbed – These are all questions of fact and unless they are asserted and proved, a plea of adverse possession cannot be inferred from them – Unless the plea of adverse possession has been specifically raised in the pleadings, put in issue, and then cogent and convincing evidence is led on a multitude of points, and an opportunity to refute the case is * Author 114 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports made out by the plaintiff, and availed of by the defendant, the plea of adverse possession cannot be allowed to be flung as a surprise, on an unsuspecting defendant, for the first time in appeal – In the present case, if plea of adverse possession had been taken in the plaint, and if that plea had been traversed by the defendants and then proper issues framed, a heavy burden would have laid on the plaintiffs to lead evidence in support of their hostile claim and a corresponding opportunity of rebuttal would have been given by law to the defendants – The question of adverse possession cannot become the subject matter of adjudication in the absence of proper plea, issue or proof – Petition fails, dismissed. [Paras 19, 29-31] Pleadings – Rule of – Principle of secundum allegata et probata – Effect:
Held: The basic rule of law of pleadings is that a party can only succeed according to what he has alleged and proved, otherwise, on the principle of secundum allegata et probata, a party is not allowed to succeed, where he has not set up the case which he wants to substantiate – Pleadings and proof must correspond – No party should be prejudiced by being taken by surprise by varying the case as originally set up. [Paras 24, 25] Adverse possession – Ordinarily, a question of fact however, in certain cases, it may be a question of law or a mixed question of law and facts – Determination of adverse possession – When can the plea of adverse possession be allowed by the Appellate Court to be taken up for the first time in appeal, stated. [Para 27, 28] Case Law Cited Trojan and Co., Ltd. v. RM. N. N. Nagappa Chettier [1953] 1 SCR 789 – referred to.
Ganda Singh and Ors. v. Ram Narain Singh, ILR (1959) 1 P&H 385; Municipal Board, Etawah v. Mt. Ram Sri and Another, AIR 1931 All. 670; Krishna Churn Baisack and Others v. Protab Chunder Surma, ILR 7 Cal. 560; Ram Singh v. Deputy Commissioner of Bara Banki, ILR 17 Cal. 444; Lachhmi Sewak Sahu v. Ram Rup Sahu and Others, AIR 1944 P.C. 24; Somasundarum Chetty v. Vadivelu Pillai, ILR. 31 Mad. 531; Eshan Chunder Singh v. Shama Chunder, 11 M.I.A; Nepen Bala Debi v. Siti Kanta Banerji, 8 IC 41; Shiro Kumari Debi v. Gobind Shaw Tanti, ILR 2 Cal. 418 – referred to. [2025] 9 S.C.R. 115Kishundeo Rout & Ors. v. Govind Rao & Ors. List of Keywords Plea of adverse possession; Plea of adverse possession raised/ taken for the first time in appeal; Adverse possession plea not raised in pleadings; First Appellate Court accepted the plea of adverse possession; Plea of adverse possession must be laid in the pleadings; First Appeal under Section 96, CPC; Plea of adverse possession is based on facts; Adverse possession is a question of fact; Questions of fact; Question of law; Mixed question of law and facts; Principle of secundum allegata et probata; Pleadings; Rule of pleadings. Case Arising From EXTRAORDINARY APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 22070 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 28.02.2025 of the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi in SA No. 151 of 2022 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Petitioners:
Shekhar Prit Jha, Ms. Tamanna Swami, Anurag Bansal.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order J.B. Pardiwala, J.
1. Delay condoned.
2. This petition arises from the judgment and order passed by the High Court of Jharkhand dated 28.02.2025 in Second Appeal No. 151 of 2022 by which the Second Appeal filed by the respondents herein (original defendants) came to be allowed thereby set asiding the judgment and order passed by the First Appellate Court, i.e., District Judge II, Deoghar in Civil Appeal No. 64 of 2018 preferred by the petitioners herein (original plaintiffs)against the judgment and decree passed by the Civil Judge (Sr Div) IV, Deoghar in Title Suit No. 35 of 1999 dated 18.08.2018.
3. For the sake of convenience, the petitioners shall hereinafter be referred to as the plaintiffs and the respondents herein shall hereinafter be referred to as the defendants.
116 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4. The plaintiffs instituted Title Suit No. 35 of 1999 in the Court of the Civil Judge, Deoghar and prayed for the following reliefs: “That under the above facts and circumstances the plaintiff prays for following relief for a decree declaring that the Sale deed bearing no. 256 is bogus, in operative and as such fit to be cancelled. As such fit to be cancelled, And for confirmation of possession.
In the event of this dispossession pending the suit then for recovery of possession.
(ii) for permanent injunction restraining the defendant from claiming herself as the owner of the suit property on the basis of the forged and fabricated sale deed.
(iii) for the cost of the suit.
(iv) for any other relief or reliefs which the plaintiff may be deemed entitled to.”
5. In the Title Suit referred to above the trial court framed the following issues:
I. Is the suit, as framed, maintainable?
II. Is the suit barred by limitation?
III. Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of the parties? IV. Whether the sale deed dated 03.02.1997, vide no. 256, executed by Sudama Devi, is illegal and without valuable consideration?
V. Whether the sale deed dated 03.02.1997 was managed by playing fraud/misrepresentation and undue influence upon Sudama Devi?
VI. Whether Sudama Devi did not pass her right., title and interest in the suit property to the defendant?
VII. Whether the possession of suit property was not given to the defendant after the execution of alleged sale deed dated 03.02.1997?
VIII. Is the plaintiff entitled for reliefs as claimed? X. Whether there is any cause of action for filing the suit ? [2025] 9 S.C.R. 117Kishundeo Rout & Ors. v. Govind Rao & Ors.
6. The suit ultimately came to be dismissed vide the judgment and decree dated 18.08.2018 while answering the issue nos. (i), (ii), (iii) and (ix), the trial court recorded the following findings: “9. As per above discussion, I have already found that plaintiffs have not succeeded to prove their case that sale deed no. 256 dated 03.02.1997 was managed by playing fraud, misrepresentation and due influence upon Sudama Devi and also failed to prove that the possession of suit property was not given to the defendant after execution of alleged sale deed and as such the suit filed by the plaintiffs against the defendant is not maintainable in its present form and there is no valid cause of action for the present suit. Hence, the aforesaid issues are also decided against the plaintiffs. Therefore, it is, hereby.”
7. The plaintiffs being dissatisfied with the judgment and decree passed by the trial court dismissing the suit preferred First Appeal in the court of the District Judge, Deoghar being the Civil Appeal No. 64 of 2018.
8. The First Appeal came to be allowed, and the suit instituted by the plaintiffs came to be decreed. While allowing the First Appeal, the First Appellate Court recorded the following findings: “7.4 During the course of argument this court has made a query to the Ld. Counsel for the respondents as to whether after dispossession his client/s came in repossession of the suit property, to which there was no satisfactory reply. The counsel verbally submitted that his clients were temporary dispossessed for a day or two and there after they regained the possession of the suit property. What is evident from W.S is that dispossession from suit property by the plaintiff came to the knowledge of the defendants on 06.07.2000 or 07.07.2000 and the W.S was filed exactly 11 days after that, and in the said W.S there is mention of dispossession of the defendants. Further from the date of evidences of DW-1 and DW-2 it has come out that evidence of DW-1 was tendered in the court on 29.04.2011 and his cross-examination was finally completed on 30.06.2011. Further the evidence of DW-2 was tendered in the court on 06.05.2011 and she was cross-examined on 05.08.2011, 29.08.2011, 8.11.2011 and 118 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports finally it was completed on 09.02.2012. Further additional evidence of DW-2 was file do 16.04.2015 and her crossexamination was completed on 05.06.2015.
7.5 Further from the appreciation of affidavit and corresponding crossexaminations, this court could not find out a single instance wherein the defendants have averred that they have regained their lost possession of the suit property mentioned in schedule B. Rather it is an admitted fact that defendant has lost possession of suit property on 07.07.2000.
7.6 what is astonishing to see is that neither a separate suit to reclaim the lost possession of suit property is filed by the defendants nor any counter claim to reclaim the lost possession is filed in their W.S. This means that the defendants have not claimed their lost possession of the suit property since 07.07.2000. Rather the information petition was filed in the court in that regard and same is exhibited by them as Exhibit-E. Further as per article 65 of the schedule in Limitation Act, 1963, the period of limitation as provided by statute for filing of suit for possession of immovable property or any interest therein based on title is 12 years, from the date when the possession of the plaintiff becomes adverse to the defendant. Further from the conjoint reading of section-3 R/w 27 of the Limitation Act, the right and remedy both are extinguished on the expiry of period of limitation as provided by the statute. 7.7 Since appeal is continuation of the suit, the Court while sitting under appeal can make additional issues from the material on record, in order to adjudicate the matter finally and also to avoid multiplicity of proceedings between the parties. Therefore this court is making an additional issue and adjudicating it without taking further evidence as everything is admitted in the record of the trial court. The additional issue is “whether the possession of the plaintiff became adverse to the defendants despite the facts that defendants have registered sale deed in their favour and whether such adverse possession has made the defendant herein remedy-less to oust plaintiffs from the suit property ?”
[2025] 9 S.C.R. 119Kishundeo Rout & Ors. v. Govind Rao & Ors. 7.8 Further no evidence is required to adjudicate the additional issue, because everything is available on record, Before we proceed further, it is pertinent to quote the law laid down by apex court in RAVINDER KAUR GREWAL AND OTHERS v/s MANJIT KAUR AND OTHERS AIR 2019 SC 3827. It was held that “ there is absolutely no bar for the perfection of title by way of adverse possession whether a person is suing as the plaintiff or being sued as a defendant. The statute does not define adverse possession, it is common law concept, the period of which has been prescribed statutorily under the law of limitation Art. 65 as 12 years. Law of limitation does not define the concept of adverse possession nor anywhere contains a provision that the plaintiff cannot sue based on adverse possession. It only deals with limitation to sue and extinguishment of rights. Once the right is extinguished another person acquires perspective right which cannot be defeated by reentry by the owner or subsequent acknowledgment of his rights. The adverse possession requires all the three classic requirements to coexist at the same time, namely, nec-vi i.e. adequate in continuity, nec-claim i.e. adequate in publicity and nec-precario i.e. adverse to a competitor, in denial of title and his knowledge. Visible, notorious and peaceful so that if the owner does not take care to know notorious facts, knowledge is attributed to him on the basis that for due diligence he would have known it.” the old concept of the law the adverse possession can only be used a shield and not as sword, as be overruled by the Hon’ble Court in the aforesaid Judgment. And the Appellate court while sitting under appeal has unfettered powers under section 107 R/w 96 of the CPC to appreciate the entire record on law and facts.
7.9 In the present case, it is an admitted fact by the defendants that they are not in possession of the suit property since 07.07.2000 and since that day the plaintiff have forceful possession against the defendant and which is within the knowledge of the defendants. Despite having title documents of the property no efforts were made by them to evict the trespassers/plaintiff and reclaim the lost 120 [2025] 9 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports possession. Even if it is presumed that the suit is dismissed against the plaintiff’s and sale deed which is sought to be declared void is held valid and legal, then also it would not make any difference because the defendants have lost their right as well remedy to get evicted the plaintiffs and reclaim possession of the property, even on basis of title. Merely holding a sale deed would not do anything in their favour. Neither any separate suit is filed to reclaim the possession nor any counter claim in the present suit is alleged to reclaim the lost possession and it cannot be said that defendants were not aware of the illegaladverse possession of the plaintiff. Therefore, plaintiffs adverse possession ripened against the defendants. To avoid multiplicity of proceedings this court is proceeding thereunder.
7.10 Further, in the present case: the Original plaintiff who has claimed that she did not receive even a single farthing has expired during the pendency of the suit.
She did not come as plaintiff witness and except her no one would have rightly deposed and substantiated as to whether she received sale consideration or not. And had she been alive, the defendant would have got the chance to cross-examine her. In the present case, the scenario is bit different. The original plaintiff could not give her evidence and as such that could not be rebutted by defendant. Whatever evidence the plaintiff gave can only be hearsay evidence, and as such the same fall short to qualify as direct evidence. Further, the documentary evidence of defendants superseded the oral evidence advanced by plaintiffs in all respects. Therefore this court declares the sale deed of the plaintiff as valid document and also the transactions done between the parties. BE THAT IT MAY BE SO; as discussed earlier the adverse possession of the plaintiffs have already ripened against the defendants in year 2012, only w.r.t to property which is alleged to be forcefully taken by them and not against the other properties. As per settled law, such adverse possession in light of aforesaid Judgment has given rights to the original plaintiff’s (through her heir) to retain such [2025] 9 S.C.R. 121Kishundeo Rout & Ors. v. Govind Rao & Ors. property (on which there is adverse possession) in their own name.
7.11 Accordingly, the suit of the plaintiff is decreed in their favor only for the suit property mentioned in schedule B of the plaint. Further for properties mentioned in Schedule A of the plaintiff, it was alleged that those properties were already sold by the plaintiff to some other persons and despite that those persons being necessary parties were not made parties to the suit by the plaintiff or by the defendants, therefore suit of the plaintiff can be decreed only with respect to schedule B property. For rest of the properties mentioned in other schedules the suit is dismissed on merits, for want of necessary parties.
8. There shall be no order as to costs, parties to bear their own costs. Office to call for Sherestadar report for deficit court fee, if any and then after compliance, Office to make Decree and file be consigned to records after due compliance.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.