Mukund K. Pai & Ors. v. Punjab National Bank & Ors
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 1033; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 2148
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.K. Maheshwari
- Decided
- 30 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 9918/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 2148 : 2025 INSC 1033 Mukund K. Pai & Ors.
v.
Punjab National Bank & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 9918 of 2025)
30 July 2025 [J.K. Maheshwari and Vijay Bishnoi, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose as regards to whether Indian Banks Association Clarification and HRMD Circular can override the 2014 guidelines for the purpose of pay fixation of ex-servicemen during re-employment; whether re-fixation as done by the respondent-Bank pursuant to the IBA Clarification is in consonance with the guidelines dated 17.02.2014 and whether the High Court was justified in confirming such re-fixation; and if not, in what manner can the fixation of pay of ex-servicemen may be made on their re-employment and what reliefs can be granted to the appellants-ex-servicemen. Headnotes† Service Law – Pay fixation – Pay fixation of ex-serviceman re-employed in public sector bank – Post-retirement from Indian Navy, the appellants took re-employment with the respondent-bank – Subsequent to issuance of IBA Clarification, the respondent-bank vide HRMD circular re-fixed the pay of the appellants at an amount lower than what they were re-employed at – Appellants filed writ petition – Single Judge of the High Court quashed the order of re-fixation – Division Bench set aside the order passed by the Single Judge – Challenge to:
Held: IBA Clarification and the subsequent HRMD Circular do not override the 2014 guidelines – Refixation done by the bank ignoring 2014 guidelines in applying IBA clarification and the HRMD circular to be quashed – Bank while re-fixing the pay had violated the principles of natural justice and reduced the pay of appellants without hearing them – IBA clarification and HRMD circular are not in consonance with the 2014 guidelines for pay fixation of ex-servicemen and for purpose of fixation of pay, the 2014 guidelines shall prevail over the IBA clarification and HRMD [2025] 7 S.C.R. 2149Mukund K. Pai & Ors. v. Punjab National Bank & Ors. circular – Re-fixation applying IBA clarification and HRMD circular by ignoring the 2014 guidelines not justified – By virtue of passing order of re-fixation, the appellants have suffered civil consequences, thus, without affording an opportunity, re-fixation so done, was in violation of principle of natural justice hence, is set-aside – Bank to apply the 2014 guidelines and re-fix the pay of the appellants on the principles culled out – Recovery and refund, if any, shall stand quashed – Refixation be made afresh – While fixing the pay, in case, the pay of the appellants is reduced from initial fixation, the bank shall observe the principle of natural justice – Guidelines dated 17.02.2014 issued by Department of Financial Services (Welfare) – Indian Banks Association, letter dated 17.05.2018 – HRMD Circular No.413/2018 dated 22.06.2018. [Paras 24-26] Service Law – Pay fixation of ex-serviceman re-employed in public sector bank – Guidelines dated 17.02.2014 issued by Department of Financial Services (Welfare) – cl.2.1, 2.1(ii), 2.1(iii) – Essentials for re-fixation of the pay of an ex-serviceman on re-employment in the public sector bank – Stated. [Para 19] Case Law Cited State Bank of India and Others v. K.P. Subbaiah [2003] Supp. 1 SCR 545 : (2003) 11 SCC 646; Bhagwan Shukla v. Union of India and Others [1994] Supp. 2 SCR 419 : (1994) 6 SCC 154 – referred to.
List of Keywords Re-fixation of pay of ex-servicemen on re-employment; ‘Pay-fixation of ex-servicemen’; Guidelines dated 17.02.2014; Department of Financial Services (Welfare); Indian Banks Association Clarification (IBA Clarification); HRMD Circular; Principles of natural justice; Pay reduction; 2014 guidelines prevail over the IBA clarification and HRMD circular; Recovery and refund.
Case Arising From C I V I L A P P E L L AT E J U R I S D I C T I O N : C i v i l A p p e a l N o . 9918 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 07.02.2020 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in WA No. 2094 of 2019.
2150 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Gautam Narayan, Sr. Adv., Liju V Stephen, James P. Thomas, Mrs. Indu Susan Jacob, Ravi Sagar, Ms. Asmita Singh, Ms. Asmita Singh.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Dhruv Mehta, Sr. Adv., Rajesh Kumar Gautam, Anant Gautam, Deepanjal Choudhary, Ms. Likivi Jakhalu.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Order 1) Leave granted.
2) The instant appeal has been preferred by the ex-servicemen, challenging the impugned order dated 07.02.2020 1 , whereby the writ appeal was allowed and the order dated 11.04.2019, 2 allowing the writ petition was set-aside.
3) The appellants after their retirement from Indian Navy, were reemployed with the respondent-bank as Single Window Operator-A (SWOA) in the Clerical Cadre. The discord between the parties arose when the respondent-Bank re-fixed the pay of the appellants at an amount lower than what they were re-employed at. This was challenged before the Single Bench in the writ petition, which was allowed, however in appeal, the judgment of the Single Bench was set-aside by Division Bench. Hence, the present appeal. 4) The facts in brief are that, post-retirement from the Indian Navy, the appellants were re-employed with the respondent-Bank in between 2015-2017. On re-employment, appellants nos. 1-4 were initially allowed to draw a basic pay of Rs. 40,710/- and appellant No. 5 was of Rs. 34,160/-. Subsequently, the Indian Banks Association, vide letter dated 17.05.2018, (hereinafter, “IBA Clarification”), issued a clarification regarding ‘pay-fixation of ex-servicemen’ advising that maximum basic pay for ex-servicemen be fixed at Rs. 31,540/-. In this view, the respondent-bank vide HRMD Circular No. 413/2018 dated 1 passed by Division Bench of Kerala High Court in W.A. No. 2094/2019. 2 passed by Single Bench in WP (C) No. 26946 of 2018.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 2151Mukund K. Pai & Ors. v. Punjab National Bank & Ors. 22.06.2018 (in short “HRMD circular”), directed that the pay-fixation of all ex-servicemen/ex-commissioned officers be made accordingly. Thereafter, vide letters dated 24.07.2018 and 25.07.2018, basic pay of all the appellants was re-fixed at Rs. 31,540/-.
5) Being aggrieved, the appellants challenged the re-fixation before the Single Bench of the High Court, inter-alia asking the following reliefs: “a. To call for the records leading to Exhibit P21 to P25. b. To issue a writ of Certiorari setting aside Exhibit P21 to P25.
c. To declare that Exhibit P20 is not applicable to Petitioners for the purpose of fixing Petitioners pay.
d. To declare that Petitioner No. 1 to 5 are entitled and eligible to the pay initially fixed by the 1 st respondent as per Exhibit P15, 16, 17, 18 and 19 respectively in consonance with the Exhibit P1 and other relevant statutory provisions. e. To issue a writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate writ order or direction directing the 1 st Respondent to refund the amount deducted from the salary of Petitioner No.1 to 5 in furtherance of Exhibit P21 to P25 respectively.
AND
f. Pass such other orders as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit to grant in the circumstances of the case.”
6) The assertion of the respondent-Bank is that the pay fixation of appellant nos. 1 to 4 was inadvertently made at the 27th stage of the cadre and that of appellant no. 5 at 22 nd stage at the time of reemployment. The pay scale beyond 20 th stage is applicable only to the employees who have reached stagnation. In compliance with the HRMD circular, the pay of the appellant was re-fixed to the 20 th stage of the cadre with a basic pay of Rs. 31,540/-. Additionally, the basic pay being drawn by the appellants at the time of re-employment was exceeding the minimum of the scale of pay of the General Manager in the respondent-Bank and was in contravention to Clause 2.1(iii) of the guidelines3 dated 17.02.2014 (in short “2014 guidelines”) 3 Guidelines for fixation of pay of ex-servicemen/ex-ECOs/SSCOs, re-employed in Public Sector Banks etc. on or after 01.01.2006 – guidelines, regarding.
2152 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports issued by Department of Financial Services (Welfare). As such, it was contended that the Bank was justified in their action of re-fixation. 7) Heard the learned counsels for the parties at length and perused the material placed on record. It is not in dispute that 2014 guidelines govern the re-fixation of pay of ex-servicemen on re-employment. As such, learned Single Judge as well as Division Bench both have interpreted those guidelines vis-à-vis the applicability of the IBA Clarification and the HRMD circular in the present matter. 8) Learned Single Judge, considered the question whether last scale of ex-servicemen need to be protected in re-employment and while interpreting the 2014 guidelines, opined that the IBA Clarification cannot override the 2014 guidelines. Learned Single Judge appraised as under – a) As held by Apex Court’s in ‘State Bank of India and Others Vs. K. P. Subbaiah’ 4, the intention of the government was to ensure that the ex-serviceman at the time of employment in the public sector bank does not get an amount as pay lesser than what he was drawing while in defence service.
b) The aggregate of re-employed pay and pension on reemployment of ex-servicemen should not exceed the minimum of the scale of pay of the General Manager in the Bank. c) The instructions and clarifications issued by an Association like IBA cannot supersede the orders/instructions/guidelines issued by the Government of India, especially when it is by way of a benevolent welfare measure.
With the above, the learned Single Judge allowed the Writ Petition and by quashing the order of re-fixation, directed the Bank to disburse the arrears of withheld salary within a period of two months. 9) On filing of the Writ Appeal, the Division Bench on re-appraisal of the 2014 guidelines, set-aside the order passed by the learned Single Judge while noting as thus – a) That the IBA guidelines cannot override the instructions of the Government of India. A combined reading of Sub-clause (ii) &
(iii) of 2014 guidelines, makes it clear that during pay fixation
4 (2003) 11 SCC 646
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 2153Mukund K. Pai & Ors. v. Punjab National Bank & Ors. of ex-serviceman re-employed in public sector banks, his 1ast pay drawn has to be protected, however such pay fixed, plus the pension drawn should not exceed the minimum of the scale of pay of the General Manager.
b) The pay of the appellants was fixed at the maximum of the scale of the Clerical cadre, which is at Rs. 31,540/- with D.A. of Rs. 14,382/-; which totals to Rs. 45,922/-. The Bank was obliged to pay to the appellants the amount last drawn by them at the time of their discharge from the Indian Navy, subject to the limit of the pay on re-employment added to the pension, which comes to Rs. 81,438/- [Rs. 45,922 + 35,516], which is above the minimum of the time scale of pay applicable to the General Manager, i.e., Rs. 76,520/-.
c) In such circumstances, the order passed by the learned Single Judge was set-aside.
10) Learned counsel for the appellants has emphatically contended in the lines of observations made by learned Single Judge and urged that in light of provisions contained in 2014 guidelines, re-fixation of their pay and the subsequent reduction in their salary is wholly unjustified, therefore the judgment passed by the Division Bench is liable to be set-aside. In support of this contention, reliance has been placed on the judgment of this Court in K.P. Subbaiah (supra). 11) Per contra, Mr. Dhruv Mehta, learned senior counsel and Mr. Rajesh Kumar Gautam, learned Advocate on Record for the respondent- Bank, have submitted that the interpretation as made by the Division Bench is in consonance with the spirit of the 2014 guidelines, rightly accepting the fixation done by the Bank. The judgment of the learned Single Bench has rightly been set-aside by the Division Bench, and no interference is called for by this Court.
12) After considering the submissions of learned counsel for both the parties, the following questions fall for our consideration:
(i) Whether in the facts of the present case, IBA Clarification and HRMD Circular can override the 2014 guidelines for the purpose of pay fixation of ex-servicemen during re-employment of ex-servicemen?
(ii) Whether re-fixation as done by the respondent-Bank pursuant to the IBA Clarification is in consonance with the guidelines 2154 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports dated 17.02.2014 and whether the High Court was justified in confirming such re-fixation by impugned judgment?
(iii) If not, in what manner can the fixation of pay of ex-servicemen may be made on their re-employment? And what reliefs can be granted to the appellants?
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.