Metpalli Lasum Bai (Since Dead) and Others v. Metapalli Muthaih (D) By LRs.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 879; [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1341
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 21 Jul 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 5921/2015
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1341 : 2025 INSC 879 Metpalli Lasum Bai (Since Dead) and Others v.
Metapalli Muthaih (D) by Lrs.
(Civil Appeal No. 5921 of 2015)
21 July 2025 [Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court, manifestly erred while interfering with the well-reasoned judgment of the trial Court and substituting its own findings by reducing the share of plaintiff-LB in the suit schedule properties; whether the view taken by the trial Court was based on appreciation of the evidence and the prevailing legal principles. Headnotes† Suit – Declaration of title – Registered Will – Family settlement – Distribution of the properties – Plaintiff-LB (second wife of MR) filed a suit being original suit no. 2 of 1991 for declaration of her title over the suit schedule properties i.e., the properties which came to her share under the registered Will dated 24.07.1974 executed by MR – Defendant-M (son of MR from his first marriage) set up a case in his written statement that the properties were joint ancestral properties and as MR died intestate in the year 1983, he became the sole coparcener of the Hindu Undivided Family (HUF) – Trial Court decreed suit in favour of plaintiff and declared her to be a true owner of the suit scheduled properties – However, the High Court set aside the trial Court’s judgment and held that the defendant-M was entitled to 3/4th share and the plaintiff-LB was entitled to only 1/4th share in the suit schedule properties – Correctness: Held: 1. The genuineness of the Will is beyond doubt because it not only confers the right and title over a part of the land owned by the Testator, MR to the plaintiff-LB, but it also grants a lion’s share of the property to the defendant-M – Had it been the intention of MR to deprive the defendant-M of the land or if the Will had been manipulated, then the defendant-M could have been left out completely from gaining any benefits under the Will – The view taken by the trial Court being based on apropos appreciation of the * Author 1342 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports evidence and the prevailing legal principles is unassailable in facts as well as in law – The High Court, manifestly erred while interfering with the well-reasoned judgment of the trial Court and substituting its own findings by reducing the share of plaintiff-Lasum Bai in the suit schedule properties – The judgment and decree rendered by the trial Court is, consequently, restored. [Paras 10-12]
2. The Will is a registered document – The defendant-M in his evidence, admitted the signatures as appearing on the said Will (Ext.-A1) to be that of his father, i.e., MR – The Will distributed the properties in defined proportions between the plaintiff-LB, defendant-M and R (widowed daughter of MR) – There is ample material on record to establish that MR anticipated that the relations between plaintiff-LB and defendant-M were not congenial and that is why, in order to avoid future conflicts, he divided his properties by way of a family settlement and bequeathed a share thereof to plaintiff-LB, while leaving the major share to his son i.e., the defendant-M – The distribution of the properties, as per the family settlement (regarding which oral evidence was led), and the registered Will is almost in the same proportions – The Will, is a registered document and thus there is a presumption regarding genuineness thereof – MR admitted the fact that the plaintiff-LB was in possession of 6 acres and 16 guntas of land, which fell into her share as per the Will – In this background, the trial Court was right in holding that MR made a fair distribution of his tangible assets amongst his legal heirs by executing the Will dated 24.07.1974 and so also the oral family settlement. [Para 9] List of Keywords Will; Declaration of her title; Will distributed the properties; Admission of the signatures as appearing on the registered Will; Ancestral properties; Will is a registered document; Presumption regarding genuineness.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 5921 of 2015 From the Judgment and Order dated 23.01.2014 of the High Court of A.P At Hyderabad in AS No. 178 of 1995 With Civil Appeal No. 5922 of 2015 [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1343Metpalli Lasum Bai (Since Dead) and Others v. Metapalli Muthaih(D) by Lrs.
Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Gaurav Agarwal, Sr. Adv., Guntur Prabhakar, Ms. Prerna Singh, Alakh Alok Srivastava.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Guntur Prabhakar, Alakh Alok Srivastava.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. These two appeals arise out of rival claims of the legal representatives of late Metpalli Rajanna over a chunk of land admeasuring 4 acres and 16 guntas located at village Dasnapur.
3. For the sake of convenience, the genealogical table of the parties is reproduced hereinbelow: - “Metpalli Ramanna (died pre-1949)
Metpalli Rajanna (died in 1983)
First Marriage (with Narsamma, who predeceased Rajanna)
Muthaiah (D1, died in 2014)
Rajamma (D2, died during appeal)”
No Children Second Marriage (with Lasum Bai, Plaintiff, died 2015)
4. Facts in a nutshell relevant and essential for disposal of the appeals are as below.
4.1. The original land holder i.e., Metpalli Ramanna died intestate prior to 1949. The total landed property owned by Metpalli Ramanna is described below: - 1344 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Survey Nos. Village Description of Properties 28 Dasnapur Ac. 12-32 Guntas Dry Land.
6 Mavala Ac. 1-25 Guntas Wet Land.
9 Mavala Ac. 1-13 Guntas Wet Land.
1/84 Savaragaon Ac. 2-34 Guntas Dry Land.
Total 18 acres 06 guntas
4.2. Metpalli Rajanna, the legal heir of Ramanna married Narsamma and from their wedlock, two children, namely, Muthaiah 1 and Rajamma were born. Narsamma died during the lifetime of M.Rajanna who contracted second marriage with Lasum Bai 2 who did not bear any child. M. Rajanna expired in the year 1983 and his daughter Rajamma also died intestate on which, a dispute over the right to property arose between plaintiff-Lasum Bai on the one side and defendant-Muthaiah on the other.
4.3. As per the plaintiff-Lasum Bai, M.Rajanna anticipated the disputes between her and his son from the 1 st marriage i.e., defendant-Muthaiahand to avoid the same, he made an oral family arrangement distributing his properties as below: - Lasum Bai (2 nd wife of M. Rajanna)
1. Sy. No. 28 of Dasnapur Village-Ac.6-16 Gts out of Ac.12-32 Gts.
2. 1/3 rd portion of Sy. Nos. 6 & 9 Mavala Village, out of Ac. 2-38 Gts.
3. Cattle shed bearing Panchayat No. 3-4 situated at Savaragaon Village.
Muthaiah 1. Sy. No. 28 of Dasnapur Village-Ac.6-16 Gts out of Ac.12-32 Gts.
2. 1/3 rd portion of Sy. Nos. 6 & 9 Mavala Village, out of Ac. 2-38 Gts.
Rajamma (widowed daughter)
1. Sy. No. 1/84 of Savaragaon Village, Ac.
2-34 gts.
2. 1/3rd portion of Sy. Nos. 6 & 9 Mavala Village., out of Ac. 2-38 Gts.
1 Hereinafter, referred to as “defendant-Muthaiah”.
2 Hereinafter, referred to as “plaintiff-Lasum Bai”.
[2025] 7 S.C.R. 1345Metpalli Lasum Bai (Since Dead) and Others v. Metapalli Muthaih(D) by Lrs.
4.4. M. Rajanna also executed a registered Willin favour of plaintiff- Lasum Bai recognizing the share of defendant-Muthaiah in the joint family properties. The said Will was registered on 24 th July, 1974.
4.5. The case set up on behalf of plaintiff-Lasum Baiin the suit was that she was granted the rights over 6 acres 16 guntas from the chunk of land in Survey No. 28 of the Village Dasnapur which was located towards the north of the undivided plot of land whereas, defendant-Muthaiah was granted 6 acres 16 guntas of land towards south of the said plot. The said plot is the bone of contention between the parties.
4.6. Admittedly, the plaintiff-Lasum Bai sold two acres of land from her purported share to one Sanjeeva Reddy vide registered sale deed dated 27 th August, 1987. The said registered sale deed was never questioned before any forum and remain sun challenged. The plaintiff-Lasum Bai had entered intoanother agreement on 15 th July, 1987, for selling her remaining 4 acres and 16 guntas landlocated in Survey No. 28 of the Dasnapur Village 3 to one Janardhan Reddy.
4.7. Aggrieved by this agreement, defendant-Muthaiah filed an injunction suit being Original Suit No. 101 of 1987 seeking an injunction against plaintiff-Lasum Bai and to restrain her from selling the properties which came to her share under the registered Will including the plot admeasuring 4 acres 16 guntas. Vide judgment and decree dated 6 th July, 1990,the said injunction suit was decreed in favour of defendant-Muthaiah. However, it was clearly recorded in the judgment of the District Munsif, Adilabad that the title of plaintiff-Lasum Bai was not being examined in the said injunction suit and it would be open for her to file a separate suit for declaration of title since she was claiming ownership over the plot in question.
4.8. Accordingly, plaintiff-Lasum Bai filed a suit being Original Suit No. 2 of 1991 for declaration of her title over the suit schedule properties i.e., the properties which came to her share under the registered Will 4 .
3 Hereinafter, referred to as “disputed property”.
4 Hereinafter, referred to as “suit schedule properties”. 1346 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4.9. Defendant-Muthaiah set up a case in his written statement that the properties were joint ancestral properties and as Metpalli Rajanna died intestate in the year 1983, he became the sole co-parcener of the Hindu Undivided Family (HUF).
4.10. Plaintiff-Lasum Bai based her claim on the registered Will dated 24 th July, 1974 which was marked as Ext.-A1. She examined two witnesses in support of her case. Defendant-Muthaiah appeared and deposed as DW-1 and in his statement, he made some significant admissions. The relevant extracts from his deposition are quoted hereinbelow: - “Chief Examination:
My grandfather Ramanna performed my marriage and the marriage of my elder sister 2 nd defendant.
2 nd defendant is a widow and she is residing with me. There were no divisions of the properties during the life time of my father. My father and myself were residing jointly. Myself and my father were jointly cultivating the properties mentioned by me. My father did not execute any will. My father had not shown any will to me, 2nd defendant and to the villagers. I am presently residing in Savaragaon village. Since 12 years I am living separately from plaintiff. We are living separately because my wife, is not on good terms with the plaintiff. My father in order to save the family from disputes allowed my mother plaintiff to cultivate some part of the agricultural lands. In Dist. Munsiffs court, Adilabad I filed a suit against the present plaintiff and in that suit, she came forward with the plea that my father had executed a will. My father had not executed any will. The will is a got up document. I have five daughters. 3 of them are married. In order to meet the expenses of my daughters marriage I converted the land at Dasnapur into plots and (sic) I sold about 10 plots @ Rs. 5,000/- to Rs. 7,000/ per plot. The size of the plot is 40 to 50 feet. The contention of the plaintiff that she is cultivating Dasnapur land and Mavala land is not correct. She has given those [2025] 7 S.C.R. 1347Metpalli Lasum Bai (Since Dead) and Others v. Metapalli Muthaih(D) by Lrs.
lands on batai basis to others. Cattle, gold, silvers, cart and Nizam coins and other movable properties is with my mother i.e. plaintiff. Her claim that my father had executed a will deed in her favour and that she is the rightful owner of all the properties is not true. When my father allowed the plaintiff to cultivate the lands to avoid family disputes as state of my father’s health was not good.
Cross Examination for the plaintiff:
…… My father allowed me to cultivate half of the land on the Southern side. My father asked her to cultivate 4 guntas of land in Mavala and asked me to cultivate 6 guntas in Mavala. My father made this arrangement on the date of his death (Arrangement relating to my cultivation on the Southern side and the plaintiff on the Northern side in Mavala village). My father did this arrangement in the presence of elders. There were no elders witness again says. I do not know whether my father made arrangement about 20 years back asking my mother to cultivate half of the land in Dasnapur on Northern side…….
I have sold plots in Dasnapur on the southern side which were under my occupation. It is true that plaintiff sold 2 acres of land in Northern portion of Dasnapur land to one P. Sanjeeva Reddy under registered sale deed. Those 2 acres of land is in possession of Sanjeeva Reddy even before I filed the suit. The 3rd defendant has been cultivating 4 acres 16 guntas in Dasnapur village which was in possession of the plaintiff since (sic) the time of my filing the suit in Munsiff’s court. My mother has not sold Ac. 4-16 guntas to Janardhan Reddy 3rd defendant…..
I have come to know that patta for the land in Dasnapur to the extent of half is in the name of the plaintiff. This I came to know after filing the suit in Munsiffs office. I came to know that she filed Pahanies 1348 [2025] 7 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports in the Munsiffs court when I filled the suit in the court, I came to know that she filed Pahanies in the Munsiffs court when I filed the suit in that court, showing that she was holding patta to the extent of half. I have shown myself as pattadar to the extent of half of the entire extent of the southern side. .......
My father literate. I can identify the signature of my father. The signatures shown to me in Ex.
A-1 signatures in all the sheets (6) are that of my father.”
(Emphasis supplied)
4.11. The suit filed by plaintiff-Lasum Bai came to be decreed by the District Judge, Adilabad 5 vide judgment and decree dated 15 th November, 1994 with the following pertinent findings: i. That the plaintiff-Lasum Bai had established her case that M. Rajanna had executed the Will (Ext.-A1) in a sound disposing state of mind.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.