Kamla Nehru Memorial Trust & Anr. v. U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 791; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 673
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice N Kotiswar Singh
- Decided
- 30 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7273/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 673 : 2025 INSC 791 Kamla Nehru Memorial Trust & Anr.
v.
U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 7273-7274 of 2025)
30 May 2025 [Surya Kant* and Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh, JJ.] Issue for Consideration The central issue concerns the legality of the cancellation of allotment by Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation (UPSIDC). Whether UPSIDC is responsible for frustrating the performance of the allotment contract; whether the cancellation of allotment of the subject land was procedurally defective and legally untenable.
Headnotes† Allotment of Land – Cancellation of allotment – Legality of – Appellant-KNMT was allotted subject land by UPSIDC – The allotment letter required KNMT to make payments in a scheduled manner – KNMT failed to make payment in a schedule manner – UPSIDC cancelled the allotment of land – The High Court by the impugned order upheld the cancellation of the allotment of subject land – Before the Supreme Court, the appellant-KNMT raised plea that UPSIDC was responsible for frustration of contract and it was also alleged that the cancellation of allotment of the subject land was procedurally defective and legally untenable:
Held: On examination of all the contentions raised by KNMT reveals that none of the alleged acts—non-demarcation, removal of encroachment, or non-delivery of possession—constitute conduct that would frustrate the performance of the allotment terms – On the contrary, the record demonstrates that UPSIDC acted in accordance with prescribed procedures and as per the terms of allotment – In contrast, KNMT failed to fulfil its obligations, particularly regarding the timely submission of documents required for executing the lease deed – Since KNMT failed to furnish the necessary documents in a timely manner, it is itself to blame for the * Author 674 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports non-delivery of possession – As far as cancellation of allotment by UPSIDC is concerned, the dues for the subject land, allotted in 2003, remained unpaid despite multiple communications spanning several years – KNMT not only failed to make timely payments but also sought unwarranted concessions, including waiver of interest and rescheduling of dues – This persistent non-compliance establishes KNMT as a chronic defaulter, while the continued attempts to seek waiver evince a deliberate strategy to avoid payment obligations – UPSIDC’s action in treating KNMT as a defaulter was, therefore, both justified and necessary to preserve the integrity of the allotment process – In light of detailed examination of the contentions raised by the parties, the comprehensive analysis of the factual and legal matrix and the resultant conclusions, the cancellation of the allotment by UPSIDC is upheld. [Paras 16, 17, 25, 35] Legal Notice – Meaning and essential elements:
Held: Expression ‘legal notice’ connotes an unambiguous communication along with legal consequences to a noticee who is alleged to be in default – Illustratively essential elements would include: a) It should contain a clear and concise set of facts which convey the information leading to the relevant circumstances – This element is also fulfilled when reference is made to any earlier communications issued between the concerned parties; b) It should convey the intimation of any impending legal obligation or breach committed by any party; c) It should convey the intention of the party issuing the communication to hold the other party liable to appropriate legal action or charge; and d) The communication in toto must be unambiguous and should not mislead or suppress material information – If issued under a Statute, it must comply with the relevant requirements prescribed therein as well. [Para 23] Administrative Law – Contractual powers of the State – Land Revocation – Judicial intervention:
Held: While it is well-settled that land allotment authorities such as UPSIDC possess the inherent right to cancel allotments upon violation of stipulated conditions, this Court has consistently emphasized that judicial intervention in matters concerning land revocation should be circumscribed to ensure adherence to procedural safeguards – This paradigm underscores the administrative autonomy vested in such authorities while safeguarding allottees’ rights through procedural fairness. [Para 20] [2025] 5 S.C.R. 675Kamla Nehru Memorial Trust & Anr. v. U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited & Ors. Doctrines – Invoking Public Trust doctrine in the allocation of resources:
Held: The Doctrine emanates from the ancient principle that certain resources (seashores, rivers and forests) are so intrinsically important to the public that they cannot be subjected to unrestricted private control – Rooted in Roman law and incorporated into English common law, this Doctrine recognizes that the Sovereign holds specific resources as a trustee for present and future generations – In the Indian context, the Doctrine has evolved to encompass public resources meant for collective benefit, reflecting the constitutional mandate u/Art. 21 – When a substantial tract of industrial land is allocated without a comprehensive evaluation, it raises critical questions about adherence to these principles – In the instant case, the allocation of 125 acres of industrial land to KNMT without a competitive process fundamentally violated the Doctrine, which demands proper procedure and substantive accountability in public resource allocation – UPSIDC ought to have considered verifiable evidence of economic benefits, employment generation potential, environmental sustainability, and alignment with regional development objectives to demonstrate that the decision serves the collective benefit – The failure to adopt transparent mechanisms not only deprived the public exchequer of potential revenue—as evidenced by the substantial appreciation in the value of such a large tract of land—but also created a system where privileged access supersedes equal opportunity – This betrays the fiduciary relationship between the State and its citizens – The prolonged litigation initiated by KNMT has spanned over fifteen years, unnecessarily burdening the judicial system and impeding the efficient functioning of public authorities – Such protracted disputes highlight the need for more stringent initial evaluation processes to prevent chronic defaults. [Paras 27, 30, 31, 32, 33] Allotment of Land – Transparent allocation of public resources – Public interest – Directions issued by Supreme Court:
Held: i) The State Government and UPSIDC directed to ensure that any such allotment in the future be made in a transparent, non-discriminatory and fair manner by ensuring that such allotment process fetches maximum revenue and also achieves the larger public interest like industrial development priorities, environmental sustainability, and regional economic objectives; and ii) The Subject Land shall also be allotted strictly in accordance with the procedure as illustrated in direction (i) above. [Para 38] 676 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Dilip Singh and Ors v. State of Haryana and Ors. [2018] 12 SCR 608 : (2019) 11 SCC 422; M.C. Mehta v. Kamal Nath [1996] Supp. 10 SCR 12 : (1997) 1 SCC 388; Natural Resources Allocation In re [2012] 9 SCR 311 : (2012) 10 SCC 1; Centre for Public Interest Litigation v. Union of India [2012] 3 SCR 147 : (2012) 3 SCC 1 – referred to.
List of Keywords Allotment of land; Cancellation of allotment; Encroached by third parties; Automatic cancellation of allotment; Defaulted in paying ‘earnest money’; Physical possession of land; Demarcation and handing over possession; Removal of alleged encroachments; Rescheduling the payment; Execution of lease deed; Manual for Marketing and Management of Industrial Areas; Allotment made on ‘as it is where it is’ basis’; Non-demarcation of subject land; Frustration of contract; Contractual powers of state; Adherence to procedural safeguards; Administrative autonomy; Allottees’ rights through procedural fairness; legal notice; Unambiguous communication along with legal consequences; Impending legal obligation; Appropriate legal action; Mislead or suppress material information; Unwarranted concessions; Standards of administrative propriety; Constitutional mandate under Article 21; Doctrine of public trust; Systemic deficiencies in the allocation process. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 7273-7274 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 29.05.2017 of the High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench in WPMB No. 349 of 2007 in MB No. 11055 of 2013 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Maninder Singh, Mahabir Singh, Sr. Advs., Sunil Kumar Jain, Ramraj, Shaantanu Jain, Ms. Rashika Swarup.
Advs. for the Respondents:
K.K. Venugopal, A.N.S. Nadkarni, Sr. Advs., Ms. Ruchira Gupta, Salvador Santosh Rebello, Ms. Pooja Tripathi, Gautam Sharma, Ms. Kritika, Amit Kumar, Abhishek Verma, Ms. Manisha Gupta, Ms. Arzu Paul, Ms. Deepti Arya, Ms. Himanshi Nagpal, Ms. Pooja Gill. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 677Kamla Nehru Memorial Trust & Anr. v. U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited & Ors. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Surya Kant, J.
Leave Granted.
2. These appeals have been preferred by the Kamla Nehru Memorial Trust (KNMT) against the final common judgment and order dated 29.05.2017 passed by the High Court of Allahabad at Lucknow Bench (Impugned Order), whereby it upheld the cancellation of allotment of land admeasuring 125 acres situated in the Utelwa Industrial Area, Jagdishpur, District Sultanpur, Uttar Pradesh (Subject Land) by the Uttar Pradesh State Industrial Development Corporation (UPSIDC).
3. The crux of the dispute pending before us relates to the legality of the decision of cancellation of allotment of the Subject Land by UPSIDC. However, it would be apropos to discuss the factual matrix before delving into the analysis pertaining to the alleged procedural irregularities in the cancellation of allotment of the Subject Land. A. FActs
4. In this vein, the sequence of events has been briefly adduced as follows:
4.1. KNMT is stated to be a charitable trust incorporated in the year 1975. It resolved in March, 2003 to purchase land for the purpose of floriculture. Accordingly, on 10.07.2003, KNMT submitted an application and deposited earnest money amounting to INR 62,600/- for allotment of the Subject Land for the aforesaid purpose.
4.2. UPSIDC, in an uncharacteristically swift manner, accepted the application of KNMT and allotted the Subject Land vide allotment letter dated 18.09.2003 (Allotment Letter). The allotment was made conditional upon compliance with certain terms, the relevant provisions of which are reproduced below: “xxx xxx xxx 3.You shall deposit at this office an amount of Rs. 12,02,187.50. (Earnest Money of Rs. 62,500.00 678 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports has been adjusted) towards reservation money in respect of the above plot latest by 18-10-2003.
This amount (together with Earnest money) is approximately equal to 10 percent of the total premium of the plot at the provisional rate of Rs. 25.00 per sq. mtr. and locational charges @ Rs. Nil per sq.
mtr. for first five acres and is subject to adjustment according to actual measurement of the plot. If the above amount falls short of the amount equal to 10 percentage of the total premium according to actual measurement, the balance will be deposited by you within seven days of the receipt of demand from us.
If the payments are not made as stipulated above this allotment will stand automatically cancelled/and the whole amount of the Earnest Money deposited by you will stand forfeited to this corporation, even if the area of the plot either exceeds or is less than the area of 20% or less of the area applied for. However, if the area of the land allotted either exceeds the area applied for or falls short of the applied for by an area more than 20% of it, the Earnest Money will not be forfeited if this allotment is not accepted, provided intimation is sent to us in this respect by the date stipulated above.
Note: - the premium herein is provisional and is liable to be enhanced in accordance with the provisions of Licence Agreement/Lease Deed.
xxx xxx xxx 5.The remaining 90% of the provisional premium shall have to be paid by you in 8 equal half yearly installments each of which will be due for payment on 1st day of January and 1st day of July each year.
The first installments of each payment will fall due for payment on 01.01.2006. The second and subsequent installments of the premium will fall due on 1st day of July and 1st day of January each year.
An interest at 15.00% per annum shall be charged on the outstanding (balance) premium with effect [2025] 5 S.C.R. 679Kamla Nehru Memorial Trust & Anr. v. U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited & Ors. from the date of allotment and will be payable along with installments of premium as stipulated in clause 3 above subject to a rebate of 3.00% per annum and payment on or before the prescribed date and if there are no arrears of dues. The amount of the balance premium and the interest due on it from time to time shall remain first charge on the land and the building and machinery erected thereon till it is (they are) paid in full.
Note: - the premium mentioned herein is provisional and is liable to be enhanced in accordance with the provisions of licence agreement/Lease Deed.
xxx xxx xxx
9. The plot has been allotted on as it is where it is basis and leveling etc, if any, is to be undertaken by you at expenses. You will pay to the U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Ltd. Within 30 days from the date of the demands made by this corporation from time to time such recurring fee in the nature of service and/or maintenance charges as determined by this corporation. In case of default you will be liable to pay interest @15.00% p.a. on the amount due.
xxx xxx xxx
13. You will have to take over possession of the land executing the lease deed within 30 days from the date of inviting you to do so or within 3 months from the date of this letter whichever is earlier.”
[Sic]
4.3. After allotment, KNMT inspected the Subject Land and asserted that it was encroached upon by third parties, seeking demarcation by the relevant State Authorities. Simultaneously, KNMT defaulted in paying the ‘reservation money’ by the prescribed date of 18.10.2003. Responding to this default, UPSIDC, vide communication dated 04.11.2003, granted an extension until 17.11.2003 for payment along with interest, 680 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports while clearly stipulating that non-compliance would result in automatic cancellation of the allotment.
4.4. KNMT deposited the reserve amount through two demand drafts dated 17.11.2003 and requested that UPSIDC not levy any interest until physical possession of the Subject Land was granted to it. UPSIDC, vide letter dated 11.12.2003, categorically rejected the aforesaid request by stating that the same was violative of its policy. Thereafter, UPSIDC afforded KNMT a three-day window to provide its unconditional consent to preserve the validity of the allotment.
4.5. Subsequently, KNMT, admittedly, vide letter dated 15.12.2003, responded to UPSIDC’s communication, confirming payment of the interest amount while simultaneously expressing discontent regarding the levy of such interest and requested UPSIDC to reconsider its decision. Ultimately, after multiple correspondences, this issue was finally resolved vide letter dated 07.01.2004, whereby KNMT accepted the conditions of the Allotment Letter. Appellant No. 2 (official of KNMT) thereafter explicitly agreed to the original terms and conditions, including to deposit the reservation amount along with requisite interest, for completion of allotment of the Subject Land. Concurrently, it bears emphasis that KNMT wrote several letters seeking demarcation and handing over of possession of the Subject Land after the removal of alleged encroachments. However, no action was allegedly taken in respect of these communications.
4.6. Soon thereafter, vide letter dated 21.02.2004, UPSIDC apprised KNMT of a policy change, whereby KNMT was directed to execute the lease deed prior to delivery of possession. Accordingly, KNMT was required to furnish the necessary documents and make requisite payments for the execution of the lease deed within 15 days, failing which UPSIDC cautioned that it would proceed with cancellation of allotment of the Subject Land.
4.7. Notably, the Allotment Letter required KNMT to make payments in a scheduled manner. KNMT nonetheless failed to pay the instalments and requested rescheduling of the same vide letter dated 11.03.2005. UPSIDC, in response, assured them of consideration of their request and, in the interim, directed [2025] 5 S.C.R. 681Kamla Nehru Memorial Trust & Anr. v. U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited & Ors. them to pay the lease rent and also to provide the necessary documents for the execution of the lease deed.
4.8. UPSIDC, on 01.07.2005, approved the request for rescheduling the payment and directed KNMT to pay the total amount of INR 1,44,27,313/- in ten instalments over a period of 5 years along with 15% interest starting from the date of issuance of the aforesaid letter, which reads as follows:
“Please refer your undated letter on the above subject by which you requested to reschedule the total amount of your plot and sought permission to pay the first installment in July 2005. In this connection, you are informed that according to your request, the approval of the headquarter has been issued to reschedule the total amount of Rs.1,44,27,313=10 paise to be paid in 10 six monthly installments including 15°/o interest and the first installments of 10% amounting to Rs.
14,42,731=35 paise is payable by 01.07.2005. The balance 90 % amount is to be paid in six monthly
(a) further installments including the interest. You are therefore requested to please arrange to deposit the first installment of the amount of Rs. 14,42,731=35 paise as early as possible.”
[Sic]
4.9. However, KNMT failed to adhere to the aforesaid schedule as well and, having defaulted in payment, UPSIDC issued a notice dated 14.12.2005, thereby mandating it to deposit a sum of INR 39,76,404.85/- (inclusive of interest and the previous pending amount). KNMT, conversely, continued to request UPSIDC to handover possession and to reconsider the decision to levy interest.
4.10. Following the continued non-compliance, UPSIDC issued a final notice dated 13.11.2006, calling upon KNMT to deposit an amount of INR 68,49,869.20/- as well as to submit the necessary documents for execution of the lease deed. The notice stipulated a deadline of 10 days, failing which the allotment of the plot would be cancelled as per the terms of the Allotment Letter. The relevant portion of the notice is as follows:
682 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “…. Now last and final notice is hereby given to you to please submit an amount of Rs. 68,49,869.20 accrued upto 30.6.2006 and submit the desired documents within TEN DAYS from the date of this letter failing which allotment of plot shall be cancelled as per Clause No. 15(a) & (b) of allotment letter dated 18.9.03 and the money deposited by you shall stand forfeited.”
4.11. In response, KNMT, without making the payment, vide letter dated 04.12.2006, repeated its earlier request to hand over the possession of the land after demarcation and sought removal of the encroachment. UPSIDC replied on 13.12.2006, stating that possession of the land could only be handed over after execution of the sale deed. The letter also underscored KNMT’s failure to deposit the requisite documents for execution of the lease deed or any amount except the reserve amount since 2003. In this light, UPSIDC finally declined KNMT’s representation. The letter dated 13.12.2006 elucidated that: “In this regard, it is informed you that the above said land was allotted to you in September, 2003 thereafter you have deposited only 10% amount of allotment.
Later on in the year, 2005 the re-schedulement was made on your request, but despite that no payment has been made by you till today, only writing for marking. As per the rules of the Corporation, the possession of the land can be given after due payment and execution of lease deed. Neither you have made payment nor have submitted the requisite documents of lease deed. You have only taking time by way of unnecessary correspondence.
You had been requested to get execute the lease deed after making due payment so that the possession can be given to you. But, the aforesaid actions, you by not making the payment of dues and execution of lease deed, you want to evade the matter by making unnecessary correspondences. Hence, the representation submitted by you is declined.”
[Sic] [2025] 5 S.C.R. 683Kamla Nehru Memorial Trust & Anr. v. U.P. State Industrial Development Corporation Limited & Ors.
4.12. Feeling aggrieved, KNMT assailed the letter dated 13.12.2006 before the High Court through Writ Petition No. 349/2007 (MB) (First Writ). Meanwhile, the allotment of the Subject Land was cancelled vide the order dated 15.01.2007, which was also challenged by KNMT by amending the First Writ Petition.
4.13. The High Court, vide interim order dated 13.02.2007, restrained UPSIDC from making any fresh allotment of the Subject Land.
4.14. Ultimately, the High Court disposed of the First Writ vide order dated 27.05.2009 with a direction to restore the allotment in favour of KNMT, subject to certain conditions, including completion of all formalities in accordance with the Allotment Letter and revalidation of demand drafts.
4.15. Aggrieved, UPSIDC challenged the order dated 27.05.2009 before this Court vide SLP (C) No. 14680/2009, wherein the matter was remitted back to the High Court with the following observations:
“It is apparent from the impugned order that the respondents challenged the cancellation order dated January 15, 2007 by filing a petition for amendment in the writ petition. Admittedly, the Court, without discussing the validity of the order dated January 15, 2007, decided the matter in favour of the respondents and directed to restore the allotment and revalidate the demand drafts of ‘91,27,139.65 and to execute the lease deed in favour of the respondents.
Learned counsel for the parties accept that the High Court ought to have given reasons regarding validity of the order of cancellation dated January 15, 2007 before passing the impugned order.
In the circumstances, we are of the view that the case should be remitted to the Division Bench of the High Court for its decision on merits.
We, accordingly, allow this appeal, set aside the impugned judgment and order dated May 27, 2009, and remit the case to the Division Bench of the High Court for its decision on merits expeditiously.”
684 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4.16. It is pertinent to note that, in the interregnum, UPSIDC allotted the Subject Land to M/s Jagdishpur Paper Mills Ltd i.e. Respondent No.3, which was challenged by KNMT before the High Court through another Writ Petition bearing Misc. Bench No. 11055/2013 (Second Writ). The High Court therein directed the parties to maintain status quo with regard to the Subject Land. UPSIDC challenged the said interim order dated 27.11.2013 by means of SLP (C) No. 7952/2014 wherein vide order dated 07.04.2017, this Court directed the High Court to expeditiously adjudicate both the Writ Petitions filed by KNMT.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.