Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 779; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2726
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 23 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 13104/2024
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2726 : 2025 INSC 779 Sanjay Prakash & Ors.
v.
Union of India & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 13104 of 2024)
23 May 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs) are included in Organized Group-A Service (OGAS); all benefits available to OGAS, if available to the CAPFs.
Headnotes† Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs) – CRPF, BSF, SSB, ITBP and CISF, collectively known as CAPFs, whether included in Organized Group-A Service (OGAS) – All benefits available to OGAS, if available to the CAPFs – Grievances of the appellantsofficers belonging to different CAPFs were non-recognition as OGAS, non-grant of Non-Functional Financial Upgradation (NFFU) and service stagnation because of lateral entry by way of deputation of IPS officers into the higher grades of the respective CAPFs due to which they were unable to get timely promotion – Plea of the appellants inter alia that DoPT had accepted the judgment of this Court in Harananda by issuing OM dtd. 12.07.2019 requiring CRPF and the other four CAPFs to be treated as OGAS for cadre issues and all other related matters; that once the CAPFs are declared as OGAS for all purposes, consequential steps like cadre review and restructuring of the service rules/recruitment rules will follow eliminating lateral entry, like by way of deputation, to posts upto the Senior Administrative Grade level; that Ministry of Finance had accepted the recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission to the effect that eligibility criteria prescribed for promotion to Senior Administrative Grade in various Group-A services should be uniform:
Held: CAPFs are OGAS for all purposes – Government of India has accepted the CAPFs as belonging to OGAS vide the DoPT OM dtd.12.07.2019 – Since, the Central Government has accepted * Author [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2727Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. that CAPFs are included in OGAS, the natural consequences should follow – Eligible officers belonging to the CAPFs have already been granted NFFU following the decision of this Court in Harananda – DoPT OM dtd.12.07.2019 makes it clear that the CAPFs have been treated as OGAS for cadre issues and all other related matters – When CAPFs have been declared as OGAS, all benefits available to OGAS should naturally flow to the CAPFs – It cannot be that they are granted one benefit and denied the other – High Court did not take note of OM dtd. 12.07.2019 while disposing of the writ petitions filed by the appellants vide the impugned judgment – Cadre review to be carried out in all the CAPFs which was due in the year 2021; Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India to give effect to the DoPT OM dtd.12.07.2019; review of the existing service rules/recruitment rules of each of the CAPFs be undertaken; number of posts earmarked for deputation in the cadres of the CAPFs upto the level of Senior Administrative Grade should be progressively reduced. [Paras 37, 43, 45] Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs) – Deputation of IPS officers in each of the CAPFs – Review of policy decision: Held: There are various issues connected with the deployment of CAPFs, including coordinating with the State Governments and the state police force – Central Government in its wisdom has taken the view that presence of IPS officers in each of the CAPFs is vital to maintain the character of each of the CAPFs as a unique central armed force – This is a policy decision – However, this Court cannot also be oblivious of the grievance expressed by officers of the CAPFs – Their dedicated service upholding the security, integrity and sovereignty of the nation while safeguarding borders and maintaining internal security within the country cannot be ignored or overlooked – They discharge their duties under very demanding conditions – They have a grievance that because of lateral entry into the higher grades of the respective CAPFs, they are unable to get their timely promotion – Consequently, there is a great deal of stagnation – Such stagnation can adversely impact the morale of the forces – This also needs to be factored in while considering review of such policy decision. [Para 44] Case Law Cited Union of India v. Harananda (2019) 14 SCC 126; Purushottam Lal v. Union of India (1973) 1 SCC 651; Laljee Dubey v. Union of India [1974] 2 SCR 249 : (1974) 1 SCC 230 – referred to. 2728 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports G.J. Singh v. Union of India, 2015 SCC Online Del 11803; Harananda v. Union of India, 2012 SCC OnLine Del 6001 – referred to.
List of Keywords Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF); Border Security Force (BSF), Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB); Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP); Central Industrial Security Force (CISF); Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), Central armed force; Organized Group-A Service (OGAS); Service stagnation; Lateral entry; By way of deputation; Deputation; Deputation of IPS officers into CAPFs; Policy decision; Cadre review; Service rules of CAPFs; Recruitment rules of CAPFs; Senior Administrative Grade level; Non-Functional Financial Upgradation (NFFU); Sixth Central Pay Commission; Group-A executive cadre.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 13104 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 27.07.2020 of the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in WPC No. 12751 of 2019 With Civil Appeal Nos. 13105, 13106, 13107, 13108 and 13110 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Dushyant Dave, Guru Krishna Kumar, Shyam Divan, K. Parameshwar, Sr. Advs., Ms. Preetika Dwivedi, Abhisek Mohanty, Vishnu Shankar Jain, Abhishek Puri, Sahil Grewal, Ankur Chhibber, Ms. Surabhi Gupta, Mrs. Reeta Dewan Puri, P. N. Puri, Nishanth Patil, Rishav Ambasta, M. V. Mukunda, Himanshu Gautam, Lokesh Sharma, Chinmaya K Bhatt, Madhup Kumar Tiwari, Yashaswi Sk Chocksey, Rajesh Kumar, Mukesh Kumar, Ms. Amrita Pandey, Anuradha Pandey, Kishan Gautam.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Mrs. Aishwarya Bhati, A.S.G, Ms. Supriya Juneja, Ms. Aakanksha Kaul, Amit Sharma B, Raghvendra S Srivastava, Adit Khorana, Ms. Swati Ghildiyal, Rajat Nair, Navanjay Mahapatra, Padmesh Mishra, Rajesh Kumar Singh, Arvind Kumar Sharma, Ms. Shreya [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2729Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. Jain, Abhijeet Singh, Sriram Krishna, Nitin Bhardwaj, Satyam Thareja, Ms. Vasundhara Nagrath, Shaurya Katoch.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
Substantive grievance in all the civil appeals being identical, those were heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment and order.
2. All the civil appeals arise out of the common judgment and order dated 27.07.2020 passed by the High Court of Delhi (High Court) disposing of the following writ petitions:
(i) W.P.(C) No. 12052 of 2019 (Tarun Kumar Banjaree & Ors. Vs. Union of India & Ors.);
(ii) W.P.(C) No. 12751 of 2019 (Sanjay Prakash & Ors. Vs. Union of India & Ors.);
(iii) W.P.(C) No. 12875 of 2019 (Mahendra Singh Deo Vs. Union of India & Ors.);
(iv) W.P.(C) No. 13014 of 2019 (Radha Mohan Meena & Ors. Vs. Union of India & Ors.); and
(v) W.P.(C) No. 13588 of 2019 (Sudhir Kumar Singh and Ors. Vs. Union of India & Ors.).
3. It may be mentioned that the above five writ petitions were filed before the High Court by personnel belonging to different services viz. Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF), Border Security Force (BSF), Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB), Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP) and Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), collectively known as Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs). In all the five writ petitions, the following reliefs were sought:
(i) for a direction to the Union of India in respect of each of the CAPFs to fill up all the additional posts created pursuant to the cadre review (CR) of the year 2016 as per the existing recruitment rules which provide for certain percentage of posts 2730 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports at each level upto Senior Administrative Grade being filled up by way of deputation;
(ii) for a direction to the respondents to amend the recruitment rules of each service i.e. CAPFs by including various attributes as required by the Office Memorandum dated 19.11.2009 issued by the Department of Personnel and Training, Government of India (DoPT) read with the related Office Memoranda dated 24.03.2009, 24.04.2009, 15.12.2009 and 08.05.2018 by providing that all posts upto Senior Administrative Grade should be filled up by way of promotion only and not by way of deputation;
(iii) thereafter, to conduct cadre review of Group-A officers of each cadre by treating each service as Organized Group-A Service
(OGAS).
4. In support of the prayers made, appellants relied upon the report of the Sixth Central Pay Commission, OM dated 19.11.2009 of the DoPT and the decision of this Court in Union of India Vs. Harananda 1 by which the decision of the High Court in G.J. Singh Vs. Union of India 2 has been affirmed.
5. At the outset, let us examine the report of the Sixth Central Pay Commission which was of March, 2008. The report indicated that mandate of the Sixth Central Pay Commission was not only to evolve a proper pay package for the government employees but also to make recommendations rationalizing the governmental structure with emphasis on accountability, responsibility and assimilation of technology etc. The Sixth Central Pay Commission recommended that the next cadre review exercise should take into consideration its recommendations. The report indicated that despite recommendations of the earlier Central Pay Commissions and cadre reviews carried out earlier, all the services still had a great degree of stagnation at the level of Senior Administrative Grade. Thereafter, the Sixth Central Pay Commission made certain recommendations to ensure service progression of officers belonging to General Civil Services (GCS) Group-A which are not part of any Organized Group-A Service (OGAS) having individual recruitment rules. As a matter of fact, as
1 (2019) 14 SCC 126
2 2015 SCC Online Del 11803 [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2731Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. per the report of the Sixth Central Pay Commission, Group A civil posts in the Central Government can be broadly categorized into two: those classified as GCS Group A and OGAS.
6. The aforesaid recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission were accepted by the Government of India. DoPT considered a number of representations concerning attributes and definition of OGAS on whom the benefit of Non-Functional Financial Upgradation (NFFU) was conferred. DoPT also considered several representations by personnel belonging to General Civil Services (GCS) Group-A claiming the status of OGAS and conferment of the benefit of NFFU.
7. This led DoPT to issue OM dated 19.11.2009 observing that the difference between an OGAS and other services/cadres had not been fully appreciated. Therefore, to remove any doubt, DoPT through the said OM dated 19.11.2009 spelt out the attributes of an OGAS. Relevant portion of the OM dated 19.11.2009 of the DoPT reads as under:
(i) The highest cadre post in such services is not below the level of Rs. 37400-67000 plus Grade pay of Rs. 10000 (SAG);
(ii) Such services have all the standard grades namely, Rs. 15600-39100 plus Grade pay Rs. 5400 (JTS), Rs. 15600- 39100 plus Grade pay Rs. 6600 (STS), Rs. 15600-39100 plus Grade pay Rs. 7600/Rs. 37400-67000 plus Grade pay of Rs. 8700 (JAG/NFSG) and Rs. 37400-67000 plus Grade pay of Rs. 10000 (SAG);
(iii) At least 50% of the vacancies in Junior Time Scale (JTS) in such services are required to be filled by direct recruitment;
(iv) All the vacancies above JTS and upto SAG level in such services are filled up by promotion from the next lower grade;
(v) While a service may comprise one or more distinct cadre(s), all such cadres should be governed by composite Service Rules facilitating horizontal and vertical movement of officers of a particular cadre at least upto SAG level. The cadre posts of an Organised Service expressly belong to that service. The posts not belonging to any service 2732 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports are classified as General Central Service and, therefore, an Organised Group A Service cannot have posts/grades classified as General Central Service; and
(vi) Such a service consists of two distinct components, namely Regular Duty Posts and Reserves. The Reserves are generally of four types, viz. (i) Probationary Reserves,
(ii) Leave Reserve, (iii) Training Reserve and (iv) Deputation Reserve. The various types of reserves are usually created and accounted for in the Junior Time Scale.
Note: The existing Organised Group A Services have evolved over a period of time and may have minor deviations owing to their respective functional requirements. The services already declared as such need not, however, be reviewed.
2. The above are certain basic attributes of an Organised Group A Service. There is, however, nothing to suggest that the services/cadres fulfilling these criteria would be automatically conferred the status of an Organised Group A Service. An Organised Group A Service is one which is constituted consciously as such by the Cadre Controlling Authorities and such a service can be constituted only through the established procedures.
8. Members of the CAPFs also represented that each of the CAPFs is an OGAS and, therefore, members of the CAPFs were entitled to the status and benefits associated with an OGAS including the benefit of NFFU. However, representations of the CAPFs were rejected.
9. This led to filing of a batch of writ petitions before the High Court. Vide the judgment and order dated 03.09.2015 High Court allowed the writ petitions (G.J. Singh Vs. Union of India). Respondents were directed to issue requisite notification granting the benefit of NFFU to the appellants within eight weeks.
10. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and order of the High Court, Union of India preferred civil appeals before this Court. Several other civil appeals were also filed by the Union of India against similar judgments and order of the High Court including the judgment and order dated 04.12.2012 in Harananda Vs. Union of India3. 3 2012 SCC OnLine Del 6001 [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2733Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.
11. All the civil appeals came to be disposed of by this Court vide the judgment and order dated 05.02.2019 in Harananda (supra). There were two groups of appeals. One group pertained to declaration of Railway Protection Force (RPF) as an OGAS within a definite timeframe with further direction to extend all the benefits conferred on OGAS to RPF. The other set of appeals dealt with the grievance of CAPFs relating to rejection of the request for grant of NFFU in respect of which the High Court had directed the respondents to issue requisite notification granting benefit of NFFU as recommended by the Sixth Central Pay Commission.
11.1. Insofar the first group of appeals are concerned, this Court examined the OM dated 20.11.2003 of the DOPT and considered as to whether under the said OM an ‘in principle’ decision was taken for constitution of the RPF as an OGAS. High Court had treated the said OM as an ‘in principle’ decision for constitution of the RPF as an OGAS, thereafter directing further steps for cadre restructuring of RPF and also to finalize the service rules with reference to the RPF as an OGAS. This Court noted that from the judgment and order of the High Court it was evident that the same was a consent order. This Court further noted that it was never disputed by any of the respondents that the OM dated 20.11.2003 was not an ‘in principle’ decision of the DOPT for constitution of the RPF as an OGAS. Therefore, this Court held that it was not open to the Union of India to challenge the judgment of the High Court whereby further direction was issued by the High Court that necessary cadre structure of RPF as also the service rules should be finalized with reference to RPF being an OGAS. This Court affirmed the aforesaid judgment and order of the High Court and also found that even on merits, Union of India had no case. This Court declared that RPF was rightly treated and considered as an OGAS and that the High Court was fully justified in directing Union of India and others to take further steps for cadre restructuring of the RPF and to finalize the service rules with reference to the RPF being an OGAS.
11.2. Insofar the second group of appeals are concerned, this Court noted that the High Court had allowed the challenge 2734 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of the appellants by quashing OM dated 28.10.2013 and the related letters whereby their request for grant of NFFU was rejected whereafter the High Court directed the respondents to issue requisite notification granting the benefit of NFFU as recommended by the Sixth Central Pay Commission to the appellants belonging to the CAPFs.
11.3. This Court noted that the issue in the aforesaid appeals was non-grant of NFFU to the appellants serving in CRPF. NFFU was being denied solely on the ground that CRPF is not an OGAS. According to the respondents out of the six attributes which are required to be considered for treating and/or considering an organization as an OGAS, CRPF did not satisfy attributes (iv) and (vi) and also on the ground that the Sixth Central Pay Commission did not recommend grant of NFFU to CAPFs.
11.4. This Court examined the above controversy in the following manner:
23.5. So far as the submission made on behalf of the appellants that CAPFs are not an Organised Group A Services as they do not satisfy two attributes out of six attributes is concerned, it is required to be noted that the OM dated 19-11-2009 specifically notes that there may be certain “minor deviations” from the attributes listed therein and also to the extent wherein it states that even if the listed criteria are fulfilled, the same would not automatically confer the status of an Organised Group A Service. Thus, as rightly observed by the High Court in the impugned judgment and order, fulfilling/compliance of the attributes shall not be given too much weightage while deciding on the status of CAPFs.
23.6. At this stage, it is required to be noted that while considering the case of ITBP, the Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance, Government of India, it has been referred to in the additional affidavit of the Director, DoPT that since ITBP has no proper structure it is not possible to compare it [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2735Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. with other Organised Services like BSF, CRPF. Thus, the Government itself has itself admitted way back on 21-10-1986 that BSF and CRPF are Organised Services and have, in fact, used them as examples of Organised Services. At the cost of repetition, it is to be noted that thereafter the Government has, through its own process, classified the BSF, CRPF and ITBP as being on a par with each other in the 1986, 1993 and 2010 Monographs, wherein the aforesaid CAPFs have been shown as a part of the same Group A Central Civil Services.
23.7. From the impugned judgments and orders passed by the High Court, it appears that by passing the impugned judgments and orders and holding that CAPFs are Organised Group A Central Civil Services, the High Court has considered the report of the Second Administrative Reform Committee which included in Table 4.1 a list of all Organised Group A Central Services in the Government of India in which the Paramilitary Forces such as BSF, CISF, SRPF and ITBP are shown at Sl. Nos. 22 to 25 respectively and the source at the bottom of the Table is stated to be the DoPT itself.
23.8. Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances and the material on record, which came to be considered by the High Court in detail, it cannot be said that CAPFs do not constitute Organised Group A Central Civil Services/Group A Central Civil Services.
11.5. Thus, this Court opined that it cannot be said that CAPFs do not constitute OGAS. Insofar the other ground that was urged that CRPF is denied NFFU because the Sixth Central Pay Commission did not grant NFFU to CAPFs, this Court held thus:
24. Now, so far as another ground on which CRPF are denied NFFU that the 6th Central Pay Commission did not grant NFFU to CAPFs is concerned, it is required 2736 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to be borne in mind that the Central Pay Commission, as such, is not authorised to define “Organised Services” or to grant such status to any service. The recommendations would be made by the Central Pay Commission on the basis of the information submitted to it by the various Departments. It appears from the material on record that right from 1986 onwards, in various Monographs CAPFs were included in the list of Group A Central Civil Services. The Government took “U” turn and a stand was taken that CAPFs are not Organised Group A Central Services and, therefore, on the basis of such a stand, the Department must have given the information to the Central Pay Commission and, therefore, the 6th Pay Commission did not recommend NFFU to CAPFs.
Therefore, merely because the 6th Pay Commission did not recommend to grant NFFU to CAPFs — Group A Officers in PB-III and PB-IV, the Group A Officers in PB-III and PB-IV cannot be denied NFFU, which otherwise is granted to all the Officers of Group A Central Civil Services.
11.6. Therefore this Court held that merely because the Sixth Central Pay Commission did not recommend grant of NFFU to CAPFs, the same could not be denied.
11.7. Thereafter, this Court held that the High Court was fully justified in directing the respondents to issue requisite notification granting NFFU to the CAPFs and concluded as under:
24.2. Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances and the objects and reasons of the grant of NFFU as recommended by the 6th Pay Commission, when the High Court has observed and consequently directed that the officers in PB-III and PB-IV in the CAPFs are Organised Group A Service and, therefore, entitled to the benefits recommended by the 6th Pay Commission by way of NFFU and thereby has directed the appellants to issue a requisite notification granting the benefits of NFFU as recommended by the 6th Central Pay Commission, it cannot be said that the [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2737Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. High Court has committed any error which calls for the interference by this Court. We are in complete agreement with the view taken by the High Court.
12. Relying on the decision in Harananda (supra) and seeking parity with RPF, the related writ petitions were filed before the High Court seeking the reliefs as indicated above. High Court noted that it did not find any discussion or consideration by this Court on the aspect of the need for deputation at some posts in CAPFs or the qualifying term on each level of the cadre. Therefore, High Court concluded that Harananda (supra) was not concerned with elimination of deputation existing in CAPFs but was concerned solely with grant of NFFU. High Court was of the view that no direction could be issued for restructuring of the recruitment rules of the CAPFs by complying with attributes (iv) and (vi) of the DoPT OM dated 19.11.2009. For this, High Court relied upon the contention of the appellants in the earlier round of writ petitions that notwithstanding CAPFs not fulfilling the said attributes they were entitled to the benefit of NFFU. Besides that High Court also found that there was no similarity between RPF and other CAPFs. As such, question of discrimination did not arise. High Court further noted that respondents had set out numerous reasons justifying deputation in CAPFs but appellants did not seek any relief on that ground. Therefore, High Court refrained from adjudicating on this issue.
12.1. High Court thereafter considered the OM dated 19.11.2009 as well as the related OMs and noted that OM dated 19.11.2009 was not for amendment of the recruitment rules of any service. Moreover, as per the said OM, CAPFs did not qualify as OGAS. Referring to the decisions in G.J. Singh (supra) and Harananda (supra), this Court observed that members of CAPFs have been held entitled to the benefit of NFFU. High Court held that recruitment rules of CAPFs are not required to be amended as a consequence of the said judgments. OM dated 15.12.2009 was in reference to the earlier OM dated 24.03.2009 whereby guidelines were issued for amendment of service rules/ recruitment rules to incorporate the changes arising out of the Sixth Central Pay Commission recommendations including bringing uniformity in eligibility criteria across all OGAS for promotions. Besides directing initiation of action for amendment of service rules qua eligibility criteria for promotion to Senior 2738 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Administrative Grade level and Higher Administrative Grade level, this Court noted that CAPFs are being treated as OGAS but only for the purpose of NFFU. Neither from the judgment of the High Court in G.J. Singh (supra) nor of this Court in Harananda (supra), a directive to declare CAPFs as OGAS for all purposes whatsoever is discernible. Adverting to the DoPT OM dated 24.04.2009, High Court was of the view that the said OM was also on the subject of granting NFFU to OGAS in furtherance of the Sixth Central Pay Commission recommendations.
12.2. It was thereafter that the High Court considered the DoPT OM dated 08.05.2018 which was in reference to the earlier OM dated 31.12.2010 as per which recruitment rules should be reviewed once in five years with a view to affecting such changes as have become necessary to bring the recruitment rules in conformity with the changed position with further direction to immediately undertake the exercise for review of existing service rules/recruitment rules which had not been amended in the last five years.
12.3. Insofar challenge to cadre review is concerned, High Court declined to enter into the said controversy because as per the OMs dated 31.12.2010 and 08.05.2018, cadre review is required to be carried out in every five years; the last cadre review being carried out in the year 2016. The next cadre review was due in the year 2021. Therefore, High Court was of the view that all that was required to be done was to issue a direction to the respondents for carrying out the next cadre review in which an opportunity of hearing should be given to the cadre officers of CAPFs. Accordingly, all the writ petitions were disposed of in the following manner:
(I) By permitting the members of each Central Armed Police Force to, if so desire, make comprehensive representation(s) to the Ministry of Home Affairs, for amendment of the respective Recruitment Rules of each Central Armed Police Force including qua Cadre Structure, Residency, Deputation etc.
(II) By directing the Ministry of Home Affairs to, in compliance of the DoPT OMs dated 31 st December, 2010 and 8 th [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2739Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. May, 2018, immediately undertake the exercise for review of existing Recruitment Rules of each Central Armed Police Force, also taking into consideration the representation(s), if any, received from the members of the Central Armed Police Forces and after giving them an opportunity of being heard and to place its decision in this regard before the Department of Personnel and Training.
(III) By directing the Department of Personnel and Training to, immediately on receipt of decision from the Ministry of Home Affairs qua review of Recruitment Rules of respective Central Armed Police Forces, take necessary action thereon;
(IV) By permitting the petitioners to make comprehensive representation(s) qua each Central Armed Police Force to the Department of Personnel and Training, qua the Cadre Review due in the year 2021 including as to the terms of reference if any thereof.
(V) By directing the Department of Personnel and Training to ensure timely commencement of Cadre Review exercise due in the year 2021 and to, in the terms of reference qua Cadre Review for Central Armed Police Forces, consider incorporating the representation(s), if any, made by the members of each Central Armed Police Force and the decision of the Ministry of Home Affairs qua the review of Recruitment Rules of each Central Armed Police Force.
(VI) By directing that the entire exercise aforesaid be concluded on or before 30 th June, 2021.
13. When the related special leave petitions were filed, this Court vide the order dated 27.10.2020 had issued notice and stayed the impugned directions. Thereafter, learned Chamber Judge passed an order on 28.06.2021 granting leave to the officers belonging to the Indian Police Service (IPS) for being impleaded in the related batch of special leave petitions. Vide the order dated 05.11.2024, leave was granted.
2740 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
14. While appellants in Civil Appeal No. 13104 of 2024 (Sanjay Prakash and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.) are officers belonging to Group-A executive cadre of the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), appellants in Civil Appeal No. 13106 of 2024 (Mahendra Singh Deo and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.) are officers belonging to the Border Security Force (BSF). Similarly, appellants in Civil Appeal No. 13107 of 2024 (Tarun Kumar Banjaree and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.) are officers belonging to the Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP). Appellants in Civil Appeal No. 13105 of 2024 (Sudhir Kumar Singh and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.) are officers belonging to the Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB). Appellants in Civil Appeal No. 13108 of 2024 (Radha Mohan Meena and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.) are officers belonging to the Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF). Finally, appellants in Civil Appeal No. 13110 of 2024 (Dr. Jyoti Prakash Sharma and Ors. Vs. Union of India and Ors.) are serving as Assistant Commandants in the CRPF.
15. As already noticed above, grievance of the appellants are identical though they belong to different CAPFs. Their grievance primarily relates to declaration and treating the CAPFs as OGAS and thereafter to extend the benefits available to officers belonging to OGAS like grant of NFFU, cadre review, service rule parity by amendments of the respective recruitment rules providing uniform promotional avenues. Core of the grievances of the appellants as it appears, are non-recognition as OGAS, non-grant of NFFU and service stagnation. The grievance is focused on the existing recruitment rules which provides for lateral entry into their respective services by way of deputation to various posts by officers belonging to the Indian Police Service (IPS), in the process resulting in complete stagnation in their service careers. Their contention is that once the CAPFs are declared as OGAS for all purposes, consequential steps like cadre review and restructuring of the service rules/recruitment rules will follow eliminating lateral entry, like by way of deputation, to posts upto the Senior Administrative Grade level. According to them, because of IPS officers occupying posts upto the Senior Administrative Grade, their promotional prospects are being hampered leading to stagnation in the service hierarchy.
16. Mr. Dushyant Dave, learned senior counsel, while opening the arguments on behalf of the appellants in Civil Appeal No. 13104 [2025] 5 S.C.R. 2741Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors. of 2024 submitted that in Harananda (supra), this Court has unconditionally held that Group-A executive cadre of CISF as well as other CAPFs are OGAS. Once they are declared as OGAS, all the attributes of the cadre ought to be uniformized in the subsequent cadre review in accordance with the OM dated 19.11.2009 which specifically states that cadre posts of OGAS expressly belong to that service; therefore, no deputation is allowed in such a service.
16.1. He further submits that finding of the High Court that Group-A executive cadre of CISF and the other CAPFs are OGAS only for the purpose of grant of NFFU is not only erroneous but is contrary to the entire reasoning of this Court. There is no conditional or limited finding of this Court that the said services are to be treated as OGAS only for the purpose of grant of NFFU. He also refers to the clarificatory order of this Court dated 18.10.2019 holding that CAPFs as well as RPF must be treated as OGAS.
16.2. According to him, if the view of the High Court is accepted then it would not only mean overruling the judgment of the High Court itself in G.J. Singh (supra) but also of this Court in Harananda (supra). In fact, in Harananda (supra), this Court held as follows:
23.8. Considering the aforesaid facts and circumstances and the material on record, which came to be considered by the High Court in detail, it cannot be said that CAPFs do not constitute Organised Group A Central Civil Services/ Group A Central Civil Services.
16.3. Mr. Dave, learned senior counsel, extensively referred to the report of the Sixth Central Pay Commission and emphasized that mandate of the Sixth Central Pay Commission was not only to evolve a proper pay package for the Government employees but also to make recommendations rationalizing the governmental structure with a view to improving the delivery mechanisms for providing better services to the common man. On the evolution, growth and structure of OGAS, the Sixth Central Pay Commission observed as under:
An organised Group A Central Service represents a group of posts belonging to a distinct functional area arranged in a hierarchical order and pyramidal 2742 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports manner representing different grades or levels of responsibility. These responsibility increases with each senior level. At the time of the Second Central Pay Commission (CPC) in 1957, there were 6 Group A non-technical Services (then called Class I Services). Over the years, more of these Services were organised to manage and run a particular Branch of the Government, or a department, which is many cases was an operative role. As a result, the officers belonging to these Services develop domain expertise in their particular branch. At the same time, as officers of these services grow in their cadres, they have to shoulder higher responsibilities relating to both policy formulation and general administration. Consequently, Organised Central Services have a very good talent pool, which has both the experience of general administration policy formulation and extensive knowledge of their area(s) of specialization.
16.4. After observing so, the Sixth Central Pay Commission made the following recommendations:
The Commission, accordingly, recommends that the post of Additional DIG should be merged with that of DIG in the pre-revised pay scale of Rs.16400-20000.
Further, all posts up to the rank of DIG should, henceforth, be filled by promotion from amongst the officers of the respective CPMFs. Fifty percent of the posts in the grade of IG/equivalent and above should be allowed to be filled on deputation with the remaining posts being filled on promotion of the eligible officers.
16.5. Recommendations of the Pay Commission were clear and unambiguous, he submits. All posts upto the rank of Deputy Inspector General (DIG) should be filled up by promotion from amongst the officers of the respective CAPFs. Not more than 50 percent of the posts in the grade of Inspector General (IG)/ equivalent and above should be allowed to be filled up on deputation with the remaining posts being filled up by way of promotion from amongst the eligible officers.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 2743Sanjay Prakash & Ors. v. Union of India & Ors.
16.6. Mr. Dave submits that Government of India, Ministry of Finance (Department of Expenditure) had accepted the recommendations of the Sixth Central Pay Commission on 29.08.2008 to the effect that eligibility criteria prescribed for promotion to Senior Administrative Grade in various Group-A services should be uniform.
16.7. He submits that once the Central Government has made a reference to the Central Pay Commission in respect of Government employees and it had accepted the recommendations, then it is bound to implement the recommendations in respect of all Government employees. If it does not implement the recommendations qua certain categories of employees then it commits a breach of Article 14 and Article 16. In support of such submission, he has referred to and has placed reliance on a decision of this Court in Purushottam Lal Vs. Union of India 4 .
16.8. Regarding the effect of an office memorandum, Mr. Dave has referred to a decision of this Court in Laljee Dubey Vs. Union of India 5 , more particularly to paragraphs 16, 17 and 18 thereof.
16.9. In this connection, he has placed reliance on various OMs by the DoPT dated 24.03.2009, 24.04.2009, 19.11.2009 and 15.12.2009, whereby and whereunder all the Central Government Ministries and Departments were directed to amend the existing service rules and to grant NFFU status with effect from 01.01.2006.
16.10. He submits that while the Ministry of Railways had complied with the judgment of this Court qua RPF, the other ministries have been found to be remiss in doing so.
16.11. Mr. Dave further submitted that on 12.07.2019 respondent No. 4 had issued an OM concluding as under:
The RPF and Group A Executive Cadres of the following CAPFs having been treated as Organised
4 (1973) 1 SCC 651
5 (1974) 1 SCC 230
2744 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Group A Service (OGAS) by this Department for cadre review and other related matters accordingly:
(i) Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF)
(ii) Border Security Force (BSF)
(iii) Central Industrial Security Force (CISF)
(iv) Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP)
(v) Shashstra Seema Bal (SSB)
16.12. In view of the above, first respondent is under an obligation to implement the said OM.
16.13. Mr. Dave finally submits that it is a fit case where all the civil appeals should be allowed and the respondents be directed to forthwith implement the judgment of this Court in Harananda (supra) as well as the OMs including the OMs dated 19.11.2009 and 12.07.2019 and thereafter grant all the consequential benefits to the appellants and similarly placed officers including grant of NFFU with effect from 01.01.2006, cadre review and amendment of the respective recruitment rules providing for 100 percent promotion upto the level of Senior Administrative (SAG) and 50 percent upto the level of Higher Administrative Grade (HAG). Making an impassioned plea, Mr. Dave submits that more than 18,000 officials of CAPFs have been fighting this litigation and waiting for justice since 2009. They are performing their duties in the service of this country under most demanding and hostile conditions. Over 153 of them have laid down their lives for defending the unity and integrity of this country while discharging their duties. It is unfortunate that the Central Government has been found wanting in respect of granting relief to the appellants as highlighted above.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.