Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited (Earlier Known As Andagro Services Pvt. Ltd.) v. Union of India & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 684; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1983
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 14 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 2572/2025
- Sections
- 25, 5, 28, 28AB, 128, 6(1), 80, 256(2), 35
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1983 : 2025 INSC 684 Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited (Earlier Known as Andagro Services Pvt. Ltd.)
v.
Union of India & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No. 2572 of 2025)
14 May 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Ujjal Bhuyan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether by way of the circular dated 30.01.2004 the benefits granted under the statutory notification dated 01.04.2003 could have been curtailed by expanding the exclusionary clause; whether crude degummed soyabean oil imported by the appellant is an agricultural product; what is an agricultural product.
Headnotes† Customs Act, 1962 – s.25 – Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992 – s.5 – Export-Import (EXIM) Policy of 2002-2007 – Show-cause notice was issued to the appellant stating that under the duty free credit entitlement scheme vide notification dtd. 01.04.2003, the appellant was not eligible for benefits on the import of crude degummed soyabean oil as it was an agricultural product, since goods in the nature of agricultural and dairy products were excluded under the said notification – Demand of duty confirmed by Assistant Commissioner – High Court upheld the levy of demand – Plea of the appellant that the benefit given by the statutory notification dtd. 01.04.2003 could not have been whittled down by the departmental circular dtd. 30.01.2004:
Held: 1.1 The department could not, by issuing a circular subsequent to the notification, add a new condition to the notification thereby either restricting the scope of the exemption notification or whittle it down – By way of the circular dtd. 30.01.2004, Board could not have curtailed the benefits granted to the appellant under the statutory notification dtd. 01.04.2003 by expanding the scope of the exclusionary clause ‘other than agricultural and dairy products’. [Paras 33, 36] * Author 1984 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports 1.2 Under the notification dtd. 01.04.2003, exemption is granted when certain goods are imported into India against a duty free entitlement credit certificate issued under paragraph 3.7.2.1(vi) of the EXIM policy – The goods which are exempted from payment of customs duty etc. means capital goods, office equipments (including computer system, software, fax/machine, telephone) and raw materials, components, intermediates, consumables and parts other than agricultural and dairy – Thus, agricultural and dairy products are excluded from exempted goods – Agricultural and dairy products would not be covered by the notification dtd. 01.04.2003 and would be liable to pay customs duty, etc. on merit. [Para 29] 1.3 On the other hand, circular dtd. 30.01.2004 was issued by the Board following a clarification sought by DGFT from the Department of Revenue as to whether the restriction regarding agriculture and dairy products would apply to all products derived from agriculture/ dairy origin – Board clarified that the restriction regarding agriculture and dairy products as specified in the scheme for status holders and service providers shall mean that import of all types of products derived from agriculture/dairy origin including crude edible oil shall not be permitted – Hence, by way of the subsequent administrative circular dtd. 30.01.2004, the excluded goods of agricultural and dairy products as per the statutory notification dtd. 01.04.2003 has been enlarged to include all types of products derived from agriculture/dairy origin including crude edible oil. [Paras 29, 30] 1.4 A circular cannot take away the effect of a notification statutorily issued – Thus, the Board could not have expanded the scope of the expression ‘other than agricultural and dairy products’ as stipulated in the statutory notification dtd. 01.04.2003 to mean and include all types of products derived from agriculture/dairy origin including crude edible oil by way of the administrative circular dtd. 30.01.2004 – If this is accepted, it would amount to rewriting the conditions of exclusion from exempted goods statutorily provided in the notification dtd. 01.04.2003 which is impermissible – Thus, circular dtd. 30.01.2004 insofar it expands the exclusionary clause in the statutory notification dtd. 01.04.2003 has no legal consequence – The process carried out by the appellant using soyabean as raw material and ending in the product crude degummed soyabean oil is manufacturing – Crude degummed soyabean oil is not an agricultural product – Therefore, the appellant is entitled to the benefits under notification dtd. 01.04.2003 – Impugned judgment of the High Court and the order of the Assistant Commissioner are set aside. [Paras 34, 35, 58, 60] [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1985Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited (Earlier Known as Andagro Services Pvt. Ltd.) v. Union of India & Ors. ‘Manufacture’; ‘manufacturing process’ – Test of manufacture – Essential features to constitute manufacture – The process of conversion of soyabean into crude degummed soyabean oil, if amounts to manufacture:
Held: To constitute manufacture, the essential features are: i. There must be a process or series of process; ii. The original commodity or raw material undergoes a transformation through the process or series of process; iii. At the end of the process or series of process, a new commodity emerges; iv. The new commodity should have a distinct name, character or use and can no longer be regarded as the original commodity; v. It should be regarded as distinct from the original commodity and recognized as so in the trade – The test is not whether the end product is a consumable product or not – Therefore, the High Court erred in holding that because crude degummed soyabean oil was not further refined and thus, it is not a consumable item; it did not have a distinct identity – This is not the test of manufacture – While there is no dispute that soyabean is an agricultural product, the High Court while endorsing the view of the Assistant Commissioner held that crude degummed soyabean oil is also an agricultural product – Crude degummed soyabean oil is a product different and distinct in character and identity from soyabean, it is not the same thing as soyabean – The process carried out by the appellant using soyabean as raw material and ending in the product crude degummed soyabean oil is manufacturing. [Paras 51, 52, 58] Words and Phrases – ‘Agricultural product’ – Meaning:
Held: Things which have a situs of their production upon the farm and which are brought into condition for uses of society by labour of those engaged in agricultural pursuits as contra-distinguished from manufacturing or other industrial pursuits; that which is the direct result of husbandry and the cultivation of the soil; the product is in its natural unmanufactured condition – Applying the aforesaid test, the view of the High Court that crude degummed soyabean oil is an agricultural product, not concurred with – Crude degummed soyabean oil is not an agricultural product – Therefore, appellant is entitled to the benefits under notification dtd. 01.04.2003. [Paras 56-58] Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992 – Purpose, stated. [Paras 21, 22] 1986 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Union of India v. Delhi Cloth and General Mills Co. Ltd. [1963] Supp. 1 SCR 586 : AIR 1963 SC 791 – followed.
Tata Teleservices Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs (2006) 1 SCC 746; Union of India v. Inter Continental, 2008 SCC OnLine SC 22; Deputy CST v. Pio Food Packers [1980] 3 SCR 1271 : (1980) Supp. SCC 174; Sandur Micro Circuits Limited v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Belgaum [2008] 12 SCR 76 : (2008) 14 SCC 336; Commissioner of Income Tax, Orissa v. M/s N.C. Budharaja and Company [1993] Supp. 2 SCR 185 : (1994) Supp. 1 SCC 280; Jai Bhagwan Oil and Flour Mills v. Union of India [2009] 7 SCR 409 : (2009) 14 SCC 63; Collector of Central Excise, Kanpur v. Mineral Oil Corporation (2015) 14 SCC 64 – relied on.
Commissioner of Income Tax v. Cynamid India Limited [1999] 2 SCR 601 : (1999) 3 SCC 727 – referred to.
P. Narayanan Nair v. Dr. Lokeshan Nair, AIR 2014 Ker 141 – referred to.
Commissioner of Income Tax v. Stanes Amalgamated Estates Ltd. (1998) 232 ITR 443; Essel Mining and Industries Limited v. Union of India (2011) 270 ELT 306 – referred to.
Books and Periodicals Cited Black’s Law Dictionary, Ninth Edition; Supreme Court Words and Phrases, Fourth Edition; P. Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon, Seventh Edition – referred to.
List of Acts Foreign Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992; Customs Act, 1962.
List of Keywords Export-Import (EXIM) Policy of 2002-2007; EXIM Policy; Soyabean; Crude degummed soyabean oil; Conversion of soyabean into crude degummed soyabean oil; Crude degummed soyabean oil not an agricultural product; Distinct identity; New commodity; Manufacture; Manufacturing process; Agricultural product; Agricultural purpose; Raw material; Statutory notification; Departmental circular; Exemption notification; Scope of exclusionary clause expanded; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1987Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited (Earlier Known as Andagro Services Pvt. Ltd.) v. Union of India & Ors. Other than agricultural and dairy products; Crude edible oil; End product; Processing; Export-import; Foreign trade policy; All types of products derived from agriculture/dairy origin; Duty free credit entitlement (DFCE) certificate.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 2572 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 05.08.2019 of the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in SPLCA No. 8596 of 2007 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Vikram S. Nankani, Sr. Adv., Kumar Visalaksh, Hardik Modh, Udit Jain, Mahfooz Ahsan Nazki.
Advs. for the Respondents:
S. Dwarakanath, Mrs. Archana Pathak Dave, A.S.Gs., Rupesh Kumar, Sr. Adv., Ms. Priyanka Terdal, Siddharth Sinha, Kartikeya Asthana, Rajat Vaishnaw, Gurmeet Singh Makker, Raj Bahadur Yadav, Ashok Panigrahi, Shashank Bajpai, Raghav Sharma. Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Ujjal Bhuyan, J.
This appeal by special leave has been preferred against the judgment and order dated 05.08.2019 passed by the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad (briefly ‘the High Court’ hereinafter) in R/Special Civil Application No.8596 of 2007.
2. On 06.12.2019, this Court had condoned the delay in filing the special leave petition and issued notice. An interim order was passed to the effect that the ad interim protection which was granted by the High Court shall continue to operate. By order dated 12.02.2025, leave has been granted.
3. Relevant facts may be briefly noted.
4. Appellant is a government recognized two star export house and a trading company engaged in the export of rice, sesame seeds, 1988 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports soyabean meal extracts, etc. Earlier name of the appellant was M/s Andagro Services Private Limited but has since been renamed as Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited.
5. Under the Export-Import (EXIM) policy of 2002-2007, which provided for exempting goods when imported into India under a duty free credit entitlement (DFCE) certificate, appellant was granted such a certificate for import of goods having a nexus with the products exported by it under the category ‘67/food products’. Under this duty free credit entitlement certificate (briefly ‘the certificate’ hereinafter), appellant imported crude degummed soyabean oil vide two Bills of Entry dated 26.07.2006 and 27.07.2006 claiming duty exemption on the basis of such certificate. The exemption claimed was in terms of para 3.7.2.1(vi) of the EXIM policy.
6. A show-cause notice dated 30.08.2006 was issued to the appellant by the Office of the Commissioner of Customs, Kachchh Commissionerate stating that under the duty free credit entitlement scheme (briefly ‘the scheme’ hereinafter) vide notification No.53/2003- Cus. dated 01.04.2003, appellant was not eligible for benefits on the import of crude degummed soyabean oil as it was an agricultural product. Since goods in the nature of agricultural and dairy products were excluded under the said notification, appellant was liable to discharge the duties as applicable. Revenue was of the further view that the import made by the appellant should have a nexus with the product group exported. One of the goods exported by the appellant was soyabean meal extract while the product imported was crude degummed soyabean oil; there was no nexus between the two. The notice therefore called upon the appellant to pay all the duties chargeable with interest.
7. Appellant responded to the show-cause notice by filing a reply dated 14.09.2006. Appellant contended that the product imported by it i.e. crude degummed soyabean oil, was not an agricultural and dairy product so as to be excluded from the notification No.53/2003. It was further contended that both the products imported and exported i.e. crude degummed soyabean oil and soyabean meal extract respectively are classified as food products. Therefore, the product imported clearly has a nexus with the product exported by the appellant. Appellant relied upon amended notifications dated 28.01.2004 and 21.04.2004 as well as para 3.2.5 of the Handbook [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1989Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited (Earlier Known as Andagro Services Pvt. Ltd.) v. Union of India & Ors. of Procedures. Appellant explained that through a process of manufacture, the agricultural product soyabean loses its identity and becomes another product called crude degummed soyabean oil which is a distinctly marketable commodity. That apart, appellant contended that it was imported through the Metals and Minerals Trading Corporation (MMTC). Therefore, it was entitled to exemption from duty under the scheme on this score as well.
8. Appellant was granted a personal hearing on 08.12.2006.
9. Thereafter, order-in-original dated 09.01.2007 was passed by the Assistant Commissioner (Gr.-VII), Customs House, Kandla (briefly ‘Assistant Commissioner’ hereinafter) whereby the demand of duty to the tune of Rs.1,00,38,321.00 raised in the show-cause notice was confirmed. In the process appellant has been denied the benefit of duty free credit entitlement.
10. This came to be assailed by the appellant before the High Court by filing a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India which was registered as R/Special Civil Application No.8596 of 2007.
11. A Division Bench of the High Court vide judgment and order dated 05.08.2019 (impugned judgment) dismissed the writ petition by upholding the levy of demand. After pronouncement of the judgment, on the prayer made on behalf of the appellant, the Division Bench of the High Court extended the interim relief which was granted earlier in the writ proceeding for a period of four weeks.
12. As noted above, this Court while issuing notice had granted interim relief extending the interim protection granted by the High Court.
13. Learned senior counsel for the appellant at the outset submits that the benefit given by the statutory notification bearing No. 53/2003- Cus. dated 01.04.2003 could not have been whittled down by the departmental circular No. 10/2004-Cus. dated 30.01.2004. He submits that in terms of the notification, the goods imported into India by importers covered by the duty free credit entitlement certificate were exempted from payment of whole of the customs duty and additional duty. As per definition of the word ‘goods’ in the said notification, only agricultural and dairy products were excluded. Crude degummed soyabean oil imported by the appellant is not an agricultural product. However, the department relied upon the circular to contend that any product derived from agriculture or having dairy origin would 1990 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports not be permitted to avail the benefit under the duty free entitlement scheme. High Court committed a manifest error in placing reliance on the circular. The circular could not have narrowed down the scope of the exemption by enlarging the exclusionary clause.
13.1. Learned senior counsel submits that since the expression ‘agricultural product’ has not been defined in the notification No. 53/2003, its meaning has to be ascribed in terms of commercial parlance. In the said notification, agriculture and dairy products were excluded from the exemption to payment of customs duty and additional duty. However, the circular expanded the exclusion by adding the words ‘any product derived from agricultural origin’. Thus, the circular had gone beyond the scope of the statutory notification which is not permissible.
13.2. Learned senior counsel has pointed out that Director General of Foreign Trade (DGFT) subsequently issued public notice No. 42/2004-2009 dated 06.01.2025 permitting importers to import all types of edible oil classifiable under Chapter Heading No. 15 through the State Trading Corporations (STC) and MMTC.
13.3. Assailing the impugned judgment, learned senior counsel submits that High Court fell in error in holding that crude degummed soyabean oil imported by the appellant is an agricultural product since it is derived from soyabean which is admittedly an agricultural product. He has painstakingly explained the process of manufacture of crude degummed soyabean oil from soyabean and submits that by no stretch of imagination, the same can be said to be an agricultural product. Through a manufacturing process, a distinct commodity or product is manufactured i.e. crude degummed soyabean oil which is clearly a distinct commodity. This aspect was overlooked by the High Court. He also adverted to the expression ‘agricultural product’ and submits that since it has not been defined in the EXIM policy, the common parlance test should be applied and the dictionary definition should be referred to. He submits that agriculture has been defined to mean the science and art of cultivating the soil, harvesting crop and raising livestock. While soyabean is certainly an agricultural product, crude degummed soyabean oil, even [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1991Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited (Earlier Known as Andagro Services Pvt. Ltd.) v. Union of India & Ors. if not refined and not fit for human consumption, cannot be termed as an agricultural product.
13.4. Learned senior counsel asserts that the process of extraction of crude degummed soyabean oil from soyabean amounts to manufacture. In this connection, he has placed reliance on the Central Excise Act, 1944.
13.5. Even otherwise, it is submitted that the Handbook of Procedures (Vol. I) was amended by the DGFT through public notice No. 40/2002-07 dated 28.01.2004 in terms of the powers conferred on him under the EXIM policy of 2002-2007. By the said notice, para 3.2.5 was inserted which clearly stated that agricultural products under Chapters 1-24 of ITC (HS) were not allowed to be taken into consideration for computation of entitlement under the duty free credit entitlement scheme. Thereafter, DGFT further amended para 3.2.5 by way of public notice No. 42/2004-2009 dated 06.01.2005 whereby DGFT allowed import of items to be covered under the scheme except the items specifically excluded. By way of the said public notice, DGFT allowed the import of all types of edible oil classifiable under Chapter Heading 15 of ITC (HS) classification of export and import items but only through STC and MMTC. In the instant case, appellant had imported the crude degummed soyabean oil on 26.07.2006 through the MMTC. Therefore, on this ground also appellant is entitled to the benefit of the scheme.
13.6. Learned senior counsel also submits that the imported good i.e. crude degummed soyabean oil has clear nexus with the product group exported by the appellant. As per the license under the scheme, the import should have nexus with the product exported. Appellant exported food products like nonbasmati rice, sesame seeds, white sugar and soyabean milk extract which are clearly food products having been allotted respective numbers under the Standard Input Output Norms (SION). The good imported is crude degummed soyabean oil which is also a food product and clearly has a nexus with the exported product. This aspect has been dealt with by the Bombay High Court in Essel Mining and Industries Limited Vs. Union of India. However, learned senior counsel pointed out 1992 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports that this decision is subject matter of a pending special leave petition before this Court. In fact, this Court vide order dated 08.01.2025 declined the request for tagging of the present appeal with the special leave petition assailing the Bombay High Court judgment in Essel Mining and Industries Limited (supra) as the High Court has held that the same would have no application.
13.7. In any view of the matter, learned senior counsel submits that the order of the Assistant Commissioner dated 09.01.2007 and the impugned judgment are wholly unsustainable in law. Those are liable to be appropriately interfered with by this Court.
14. Per contra, learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the respondents submits that the precise question involved in the present appeal is whether appellant was entitled to exemption from customs duty, additional duty and special additional duty in terms of the notification No. 53/2003-Cus. dated 01.04.2003. He submits that while dealing with this issue, the condition mentioned in the notification would have to be read in terms of the EXIM policy 2002-2007, as amended from time to time. He has referred to a subsequent notification bearing No. 38 dated 21.04.2004 whereby the EXIM policy was amended by insertion of Note 7 which clearly stated that agricultural products falling under item 1-24 of ITC (HS) will not be allowed for import under the scheme.
14.1. It is submitted that import of crude degummed soyabean oil is in the nature of an agricultural product or a product of agricultural origin. It is not eligible for benefits under the scheme in terms of notification No. 53/2003. He asserts that permitting import of such a product which is otherwise an agriculture product would amount to subverting the tariff barrier.
14.2. Controverting the contention of the appellant that the product imported is not agricultural in nature, learned Additional Solicitor General has referred to the impugned judgment of the High Court which held that extraction of oil from soyabean does not strip it of its agricultural identity.
14.3. Referring to the two Bills of Entry, learned Additional Solicitor General submits that appellant itself classified the imported product under Custom Tariff Heading (CTH) 15071000 which falls under Chapter 15 of the Indian Trade Classification [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1993Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited (Earlier Known as Andagro Services Pvt. Ltd.) v. Union of India & Ors. (Harmonized System) (already referred to as ITC (HS)). This chapter specially covers animal or vegetable fats and oils, prepared edible fats and animal or vegetable waxes. This clearly shows that the product imported falls under Chapter 15 of ITC (HS) and, therefore, not allowed for import under the scheme.
14.4. Learned Additional Solicitor General submitted that appellant was exporting non-basmati rice (E/38), sesame seeds (E/93), white sugar (E/52/79) and soyabean meal extract (E/42) as food products. Such goods exported by the appellant did not have any broad nexus with the imported product i.e. crude degummed soyabean oil. Therefore, the benefit under notification No.53/2003 was rightly denied to the appellant.
14.5. He has also referred to the impugned judgment where the High Court has held that the test report clearly demonstrated that crude degummed soyabean oil was not fit for direct human consumption unless refined. Hence, benefit of public notice No. 42/2004-2009 dated 06.01.2005 through which import of edible oil was expressly permitted would not be available to the appellant.
14.6. Referring to the submissions of the appellant that the circular No. 10/2004-Cus. dated 30.01.2004 could not have exceeded the statutory notification, he submits that notification No. 53/2003 excluded agricultural products. The specific exclusion of all agricultural and dairy products was explained by the circular No. 10/2004-Cus. dated 30.01.2004. The circular did not add anything new but merely clarified and articulated what was implicit in the notification.
14.7. He, therefore, submits that there is no merit in the appeal which is liable to be dismissed.
15. Submissions made by learned counsel for the parties have received the due consideration of the Court.
16. Since the genesis of the present lis is the show-cause notice dated 30.08.2006 issued by the Assistant Commissioner, Kandla, it would be appropriate to initiate the analysis therefrom. The show-cause notice referred to the factum of importation of crude degummed soyabean oil falling under CTH 15071000 chargeable to appropriate 1994 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports tariff duty by the appellant. However, the appellant filed two Bills of Entry dated 26.07.2006 and 27.07.2006 claiming benefit of the notification bearing No.53/2003-Cus. dated 01.04.2003 i.e. exemption from payment of various customs duties on the basis of the license issued by the DGFT for duty free import of goods specified in the license. After referring to the said notification and the amendments carried out thereto, the Assistant Commissioner observed that in view of exclusion of agricultural and dairy products from the ambit of ‘goods’ covered by the said notification, the import did not appear to be eligible for the benefits under the scheme since the imported good i.e. crude degummed soyabean oil was in the nature of agricultural product. The Assistant Commissioner further observed that as per the pre-condition sheet attached to the license issued by the DGFT, the imported product must have a nexus with the product group exported. The export group name indicates 67/food products. Included in the said group of export was soyabean meal extract, whereas the product imported was crude degummed soyabean oil which did not appear to have a nexus with the exported product. Therefore, appellant was called upon to show-cause as to why the duties chargeable/leviable for imported goods should not be charged under Section 28 of the Customs Act, 1962 (‘the Customs Act’ hereinafter) on the goods imported duty free and hit by the exclusion clause of the notification bearing No.53/2003. Appellant was also called upon to show cause as to why interest at appropriate rate on the aforesaid duties should not be charged under Section 28AB of the Customs Act.
17. Appellant responded to the aforesaid show-cause notice by way of reply dated 14.09.2006. Appellant submitted that the product imported by it clearly did not fall within the scope of the term ‘agricultural and dairy product’ and cannot be excluded from the benefits of the notification bearing No. 53/2003. The exclusion was only with respect to agricultural products falling under Chapter Heading 1 to 24 of ITC (HS). Crude degummed soyabean oil imported by the appellant can by no means be said to be an agricultural product. Thereafter, appellant explained the various stages in the process of manufacturing of crude degummed soyabean oil. It was submitted that crude degummed soyabean oil was a completely different marketable commodity having an identity distinct from soyabean. While soyabean is an agricultural product, crude degummed soyabean oil manufactured therefrom cannot be called an agricultural product. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1995Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited (Earlier Known as Andagro Services Pvt. Ltd.) v. Union of India & Ors. Therefore, the exclusion of agricultural product vide the notification bearing No.53/2003 would not apply to crude degummed soyabean oil. The process of extraction of crude degummed soyabean oil from soyabean amounts to manufacture. Crude degummed soyabean oil is clearly a commodity distinct from soyabean. Hence, crude degummed soyabean oil cannot be classified as an agricultural product and therefore the exclusion of agricultural product would not apply to crude degummed soyabean oil. Appellant also asserted that the imported product i.e. crude degummed soyabean oil is classified as a food product under SION; so also one of the exported products i.e. soyabean meal extract. In view of clarifications issued by the DGFT from time to time, the product imported clearly has a nexus with the product exported by the appellant. In the circumstances, appellant contended that there was no basis whatsoever for demanding any duty from it. Appellant had rightly claimed the benefit of notification bearing No.53/2003. Therefore, the Assistant Commissioner was requested to drop the show-cause notice.
18. After considering the reply of the appellant to the show-cause notice and upon hearing the appellant, order-in-original dated 09.01.2007 was passed by the Assistant Commissioner. After analyzing the notification No.53/2003, Assistant Commissioner held that in view of exclusion of agricultural and dairy products from the scope of ‘goods’ covered by the said notification, appellant was not eligible for the benefits under the scheme on the import of crude degummed soyabean oil which is in the nature of agricultural product arising out of a product of agricultural origin. The importer has therefore to discharge the duties as applicable. The Assistant Commissioner referred to para 3.7.5 of the EXIM policy and also observed that goods allowed to be imported under the scheme should have a broad nexus with the product group exported. For the purpose of import entitlement under the scheme ‘broad nexus’ would mean goods imported with reference to any of the products in the product group exported within the overall value of the entitlement certificate. The name of the export group indicates 67/food products. Goods exported by the appellant included non-basmati rice (E/38), sesame seeds (E/93), white sugar (E/52/79) and soyabean meal extract (E/42) while the product imported was crude degummed soyabean oil. Hence the imported good did not appear to have any broad nexus with the product group exported. Therefore, the Assistant Commissioner concluded that appellant did 1996 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports not appear to be eligible for the benefits under the scheme on the import of crude degummed soyabean oil. The said good is excluded from the purview of the notification bearing No.53/2003. Therefore, it was declared that appellant would have to discharge the duties as applicable on merit. Consequently, a demand of duty to the tune of Rs.1,00,38,321.00 was raised against the appellant further ordering that interest at the appropriate rates on the aforesaid demand of duty would also be recoverable under Section 28AB of the Customs Act.
19. Though the order-in-original dated 09.01.2007 was an appealable order under Section 128 of the Customs Act, appellant assailed the same before the High Court by filing a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The challenge made in the writ proceedings was to the order-in-original dated 09.01.2007 as well as to the circular bearing No.10/2004-Cus. dated 30.01.2004 whereby the exclusionary clause in the notification bearing No.53/2003 was expanded to include all types of products derived from agriculture/dairy origin within the term ‘agriculture and dairy products’.
19.1. High Court did not non-suit the appellant on the ground of alternative remedy but proceeded to hear the challenge on merit. By the impugned judgment and order dated 05.08.2019, High Court held that the basic ingredient of crude degummed soyabean oil is soyabean which is admittedly an agricultural product. According to the High Court, the process which is undertaken to convert soyabean into crude degummed soyabean oil though may be termed as a manufacturing process but what is to be seen is that soyabean as an agricultural product is a primary product which undergoes a simple operation so as to make it more usable or saleable. It can in no way be said to acquire a distinct identity. Soyabean on extraction of oil does not lose its identity. According to the test report, unless the crude degummed soyabean oil is refined, it cannot be used for human consumption. Therefore, the High Court rejected the contention that in view of the process undertaken soyabean acquires a distinct marketable identity is without any merit. Finding of the Assistant Commissioner that crude degummed soyabean oil is an agricultural product cannot be faulted.
19.2. Insofar the challenge to circular No.10/2004-Cus. dated 30.01.2004 is concerned, High Court observed that the EXIM [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1997Noble Resources and Trading India Private Limited (Earlier Known as Andagro Services Pvt. Ltd.) v. Union of India & Ors. policy stated that agricultural products would not be allowed for imports. When a clarification was sought for by the DGFT, the said circular was issued clarifying that all products derived from agriculture/dairy origin are not permitted to be imported.
19.3. High Court also did not find fault with the view taken by the primary authority that the imported goods i.e. crude degummed soyabean oil had no nexus with the product group exported. What was exported was not soyabean refined oil after undergoing chemical modification but was only soyabean meal extract which had no nexus with the imported product i.e. crude degummed soyabean oil which is again not a refined oil fit for human consumption. Therefore, even though crude degummed soyabean oil might have been imported through the MMTC, that would not be of any help to the appellant. Therefore, High Court affirmed the order of the Assistant Commissioner dated 09.01.2007 denying the benefit of the scheme to the appellant under notification No. 53/2003-Cus. dated 01.04.2003 in respect of the subject Bills of Entry.
20. Before we examine the correctness or otherwise of the view taken by the High Court, it would be apposite to have an overview of the relevant legal provisions, statutory or otherwise.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.