Chandigarh Administration v. Registrar General, High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Chandigarh and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 786; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1179
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 28 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 7249/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:19 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1179 : 2025 INSC 786 Chandigarh Administration v.
Registrar General, High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Chandigarh and Others (Civil Appeal No(s). 7249-7250 of 2025)
28 May 2025 [Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the High Court of Punjab and Haryana was justified in directing the appellant-Administration for construction of verandah in front of Court Room No.1 and laying of green paver blocks in the kutcha parking, the open area used for parking.
Headnotes† UNESCO World Heritage Site – Construction of verandah, not violation of UNESCO guidelines – High Court of Punjab and Haryana issued mandamus to the appellant to construct verandah in front of Court Room No.1 – Non-compliance, contempt issued – Plea of the appellant that the Chandigarh Capitol Complex which includes the High Court building is a UNESCO World Heritage Site and it may loose such status, if the verandah is constructed without procuring the requisite permissions/approval from the World Heritage Committee,
UNESCO:
Held: High Court justified in directing construction of the verandah in front of Court Room No.1 in alignment with the design of the pre-existing verandahs in front of Court Room Nos.2 to 9 and the same does not violate the UNESCO guidelines – Neither such verandah is a major restoration nor a new construction within the main structure of the High Court building – If required, the administration may seek ex-post facto approval for this minimal protective measure which is considered necessary – Further, the orders for placing green paver blocks and plantation of trees in the open area being used for parking are also upheld – Impugned orders not interfered – Constitution of India – Arts.226, 136. [Paras 39, 34, 45] * Author 1180 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Rajeev Suri v. Delhi Development Authority [2021] 15 SCR 283 : 2021 SCC OnLine SC 7 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India.
List of Keywords UNESCO World Heritage Site; Chandigarh Capitol Complex; High Court building; High Court of Punjab and Haryana; Writ of mandamus; Construction of verandah in front of Court Room; Laying of green paver blocks; Open parking area; World Heritage Committee, UNESCO; Green paver blocks; World Heritage Status of the UNESCO guidelines; Operational Guidelines; World Heritage Convention; Outstanding Universal Value (OUV) of the property; Foundation Le Corbusier, Paris; Parking space for lawyers, litigants; Chandigarh Master Plan, 2031; Sustainable development; Green cover; Ecological balance; Modification in facade/structure of the building.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 7249-7250 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 29.11.2024 and 13.12.2024 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in CWP-(PIL) No. 9 of 2023 With Civil Appeal No(s). 7251-7252 of 2025 Appearances for Parties Amicus Curiae:
P.S. Patwalia, Sr. Adv., Ms. Natasha Dalmia Advs. for the Appellant:
Tushar Mehta, Solicitor General, Ms. Kanu Agrawal, Bhuvan Kapoor, Krishna Kant Dubey, Varun Chugh, Shreekant Neelappa Terdal.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1181Chandigarh Administration v. Registrar General, High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Chandigarh and Others Advs. for the Respondents:
Nidhesh Gupta, Aashish Chopra, Sr. Advs., Ashok Mathur, Ms. Japneet Kaur, Bikram Dwivedi, Manu Bhardwaj, Varun Aryan Sharma, Somiran Sharma.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
1. Heard.
2. Leave granted.
3. Chandigarh Administration 1 is in appeal against the orders dated 29 th November, 2024; 13th December, 2024; 7 th February, 2025; and 21 st February, 2025 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh 2 in a public interest litigation 3 whereby the High Court directed as below:- “Order dated 29th November, 2024 Construction of Verandah in front of Court Room No.1 Submissions Learned Senior Standing Counsel for UT Administration informs that proposed map of the Verandah covering outside of Court Room No.1 has been sent to Archaeological Survey of India for approval: It is also informed that in the 24 th meeting of Chandigarh Heritage Conservation Committee (CHCC) held on 19.09.2024 in-principle proposal was granted for construction of the said Verandah in front of Court Room No.1 subject to contacting Foundation Le Corbusier Paris for sharing the required drawings/data related to this project.
1 Hereinafter, referred to as the ‘CA’ or “appellant”.
2 Hereinafter, referred to as the “High Court”.
3 Civil Writ Petition (Public Interest Litigation) No. 9 of 2023 (O&M). 1182 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports This Court on 13.11.2024 had refrained from issuing any direction in the backdrop of assurance that Chandigarh Heritage Conservation Committee are being consulted and the UT Administration after due consultation shall revert back within 10 days. This Court had passed a preemptory order that in case, the aforesaid assurance does not turn out to be true by the next date of hearing, then this Court will be compelled to issue a writ of mandamus to the UT Administration for construction of verandah in front of Court Room No.1, which is dire need of the hour.
Directions A writ of mandamus is issued to UT Administration to start construction of verandah in front of Court Room No.1 in line with and of the same type as already exists in front of Court Rooms No. 2 to 9, within a period of two weeks and complete the process of construction within four weeks thereafter.
Order dated 13 th December, 2024 Construction of verandah in front of Court Room No. 1 On the last date of hearing, in this regard, a Writ of Mandamus was issued directing the U.T. Administration to start construction of verandah in front of Court Room No. 1 in line with and of the same type as already existing in front of Court Rooms No. 2 to 9 within a period of two weeks and complete the process of construction within four weeks thereafter.
Despite lapse of two weeks from the last date of hearing, no effort has been taken by the U.T. Administration to show that the process of construction has commenced.
As such, this Court directs the Registry to implead Shri C.B. Ojha, Chief Engineer, U.T. Administration as party and on doing so contempt notice be issued against Shri C.B. Ojha to explain as to why contempt proceedings be not commenced and he be not punished for causing contempt of Writ of Mandamus issued on 29.11.2024.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1183Chandigarh Administration v. Registrar General, High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Chandigarh and Others Order dated 7th February, 2025 (As regards Kutcha Parking)
It is informed by learned counsel for the High Court that on the suggestion made by this Court under this head vide order dated 24.01.2025, the Building Committee was unsuccessful in convincing the U.T. Administration to allow green pavers to be laid in the area of kutcha parking with adequate number of trees to be planted so that the green cover can be restored and the vacant space can be used for parking purposes.
This Court is of the considered view that the suggestion made by this Court on earlier occasion for restoration of green cover and simultaneously laying green pavers for parking was not only reasonable but a step towards sustained development.
There is extreme shortage of parking space in the open areas provided for parking behind the heritage building of Punjab and Haryana High Court. On any given hour, during working session of the High Court, about 3000-4000 four wheelers daily visit the High Court out of which at least 2000; if not more, are permanently parked. The existing underground multilevel parking which has three tiers can accommodate only 600 four wheelers while the remaining vehicles are parked in the open parking areas which also fall short and therefore, there is need to use the kutcha parking area which is opposite the three tiers multilevel underground parking.
The green pavers are meant to allow water to percolate down to replenish ground level water and therefore, are much beneficial and eco- friendly as compared to pavements or roads. In this manner, the objection of U.T. Administration that the said area of kutcha parking is earmarked within the capital complex as a green belt/ forest, will also be taken care of and the dire need for parking space can be satisfied. More so, the plantation of at least 200 or more trees in the said kutcha parking is possible to increase the green cover and facilitating the four wheelers to be parked.
1184 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Despite the U.T. Administration having made available the additional parking space of about 200 four wheelers near the junction of Janmarg and Uttar Marg, the said facilitation does not resolve the problem of acute shortage of space for parking within the High Court premises. As such, this Court is constrained to pass the following directions as regards kutcha parking:- Writ of mandamus is issued to the U.T. Administration to lay green pavers in the kutcha parking and plant sufficient number of trees at reasonable intervals with tree guards providing space for parking and allow this kutcha parking to be used for parking of four wheelers visiting the High Court Order dated 21st February, 2025 (Dismissing application seeking recall of order dated 7th February, 2025)
3. From a bare perusal of the aforesaid extract of the order dated 07.02.2025 pertaining to kutcha parking, it is obvious that this Court had dwelt upon all the pros and cons and the acute problem of dire scarcity of space for parking in the High Court premises before passing the said order. This Court had also, taken note of the anxiety expressed by the U.T. Administration that the said area of kutcha parking is notified as a green belt while directing that the kutcha parking space, which is presently denuded of trees, will not only be laid with green pavers, but also plantation of 100 to 200 trees will take place, so that the green belt is preserved and so also the need for parking is catered to.
3.1 In the considered opinion of this Court, the order passed by this Court on 07.02.2025 facilitates sustained development and, therefore, is rather in the interest of the U.T. Administration and would greatly help in resolving the crisis of acute shortage of parking space in the High Court.
4. Consequently, no ground for recalling of the order dated 07.02.2025 is made out and, therefore, CM-49- CWPIL-2025 in CWP-PIL-9-2023 stands dismissed.”
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1185Chandigarh Administration v. Registrar General, High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Chandigarh and Others
4. Addressing the first issue regarding construction of verandah in front of Court Room No. 1 of the High Court, Shri Tushar Mehta, learned Solicitor General of India, appearing for the CA vehemently and fervently urged that the administration does not have any quarrel in principle with the proposed construction of the verandah in compliance of the order dated 29th November, 2024 passed by the High Court. However, the administration is concerned with imminent possibility of the loss of World Heritage status of the Chandigarh Capitol Complex, which includes the Assembly, the High Court and the Secretariat, designed by the celebrated architect, Mons. Le Corbusier, who planned the entire city of Chandigarh. It is a matter of grave concern to the CA that the High Court building forms part of the UNESCO 4 World Heritage Site, and it may loose its World Heritage status owing to unauthorized deviation/modification in its façade/structure.
5. He submitted that the Chandigarh Capitol Complex which includes the High Court building, was designated as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in the year 2016 as a part of the Trans-Border Serial Nomination for the Architectural Works of Mons. Le Corbusier, which consists of 17 sites spread across 7 countries. As per the applicable guidelines, any proposed changes in the World Heritage Site are to be communicated to the World Heritage Committee, UNESCO in advance and their concurrence is to be sought, failing which, there is a risk of the site losing its World Heritage status.
6. Shri Mehta urged that CA has already communicated with the Foundation Le Corbusier, Paris and the World Heritage Committee, UNESCO, to forward the original maps of the High Court building so that the issue of constructing the verandah can be proactively examined and a considered decision can be taken without posing any threat to the World Heritage status of the High Court building.
7. Shri Mehta submitted that the CA is also alive to the situation that the open area in front of Court Room No. 1 of the High Court building is exposed to the elements. CA does not dispute the fact that litigants and lawyers who use this area have no protection from sun, winds and rain. He urged that it would not cause any harm if the matter could be deferred by a few weeks so as to give some breathing space to the CA for procuring the requisite permissions. 4 United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. 1186 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
8. It was contended that the authorities have been able to procure hand drawn maps prepared by Mons. Le Corbusier wherein there is no provision for a verandah in front of Court Room No. 1 of the High Court building which is an integral part of the World Heritage Site.
9. He thus, urged that the Division Bench of High Court was not justified in exercising its extraordinary writ jurisdiction so as to issue a writ of mandamus directing changes in the façade of the building without waiting for the requisite permissions from the World Heritage Committee, UNESCO.
10. For finding a logical solution to the problem of exposure, the Department of Urban Planning, Indian Institute of Technology (IIT), Roorkee (Uttarakhand) has been requested to conduct Heritage Impact Assessment (HIA) of the proposed verandah and to provide a suitable design which, in turn, would be forwarded to the World Heritage Committee, UNESCO for approval and only thereafter, can the idea of constructing a verandah over the said area can be materialized while protecting the World Heritage status of the Chandigarh Capitol Complex which includes the High Court building.
11. Shri Mehta also drew the Court’s attention to the mail forwarded by the Architect of CA to the Architect at Foundation Le Corbusier, Paris, requesting for the drawing plans of the original building so that the alterations, if any, could be undertaken by adhering to the protocols and guidelines as applicable to the World Heritage Sites and to ensure that the authenticity of Outstanding Universal Value 5 of Chandigarh Capitol Complex of which the High Court building is an integral part, can be maintained.
12. Regarding the issue of the green paver blocks for creation of parking space in the open area near the High Court building as directed by the Division Bench, it was the contention of Shri Mehta that this open area is part of the green belt under the Chandigarh Master Plan, 2031 and can be used for planting trees only and no deviation is permissible under the Master Plan. Shri Mehta urged that the importance of vertical greenery in the city of Chandigarh cannot be understated and if the green paver blocks as proposed in the impugned order dated 7 th February, 2025 are affixed on this 5 Hereinafter, referred to as “OUV”.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1187Chandigarh Administration v. Registrar General, High Court of Punjab and Haryana, Chandigarh and Others open space, the very character of the green belt area will be altered irreversibly thereby eliminating any possibility of restoring vertical green cover on the said land.
13. Shri Mehta urged that the CA is taking proactive measures to sort out the issue of providing parking spaces for the lawyers and other visitors to the Court Complex and it has proposed to plant sufficient number of trees with green guards on the subject land area at regular intervals thereby providing green cover for the vehicles to be parked in that space.
14. Shri Mehta further submitted that the writ petitioner had earlier sought a mandamus for the construction of multi-level parking on the aforesaid open area. However, during the 45 th Session of the World Heritage Committee, UNESCO at Riyadh Conference, a recommendation was made on 6 th October, 2024 that the said project shall be suspended in view of the negative impacts resulting from the HIA reports, which recommended finding alternative solutions for ensuring that the OUV of the property is not impacted.
15. Shri P.S. Patwalia, learned senior counsel appearing as Amicus Curiae, also supported the submissions advanced by learned Solicitor General, Shri Tushar Mehta. He submitted that the very same proposal was put up in the year 1956 when the then Chief Justice turned down the suggestion of the Superintending Engineer of the Capitol Project, Chandigarh to construct an additional verandah in front of Court Room No. 1. He urged that the administration retracted the said proposal on the instructions of the Chief Justice and thus, no deviation is permissible. The decision once taken at the appropriate level cannot be reviewed in exercise of the writ jurisdiction.
16. Shri Nidhesh Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the High Court administration, has supported the impugned orders. He urged that as per paragraph 172 of the Operational Guidelines for the Implementation of the World Heritage Convention 6 , relied upon by the CA in its additional affidavit dated 5 th May, 2025, restriction is placed on major restorations or new constructions which may affect the OUV of the property. The convention requires that notice should be given, as soon as possible, before drawing up the basic 6 For short “Operational Guidelines”.
1188 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports documents for specific projects and before making any decisions ‘that would be difficult to reverse’, so that the Committee may assist in seeking appropriate solutions and ensure that the OUV of the property is fully preserved.
17. Shri Gupta submitted that the Court Room Nos. 2 to 9, which are in the same alignment as the Court Room No. 1, already have a pre-existing verandah which is 12 feet high and provides wholesome protection from sun, winds and rain, etc. to the stakeholders, i.e., the litigants, lawyers, etc. who frequent the High Court premises. The proposal to construct a verandah in front of Court Room No. 1 was approved by the Division Bench after extensive deliberations and taking opinions from experts. The proposed verandah would be exactly in sync and alignment with the pre-existing verandah in front of Court Room Nos. 2 to 9 and will not have any adverse impact on the OUV of the World Heritage Site. He urged that paragraph 172 of the Operational Guidelines only provides that any major restorations or new constructions which may affect the OUV of the property and are irreversible should be undertaken after due approval from the World Heritage Committee, UNESCO.
18. Shri Gupta submitted that the verandah proposed to be constructed cannot be said to be a permanent structure which cannot be removed. Hence, the additional verandah cannot be termed to be a structure which can never be removed and the decision is not irreversible.
19. Shri Gupta further referred to the letter dated 17th May, 1956 placed on record by the CA along with the additional affidavit dated 5 th May, 2025 wherein it is clearly provided that the construction of the additional verandah in front of Court Room No. 1 similar to the verandah in front of the smaller Court Rooms i.e., Court Room Nos. 2 to 9 had been proposed by Chandigarh Administration and refers to a suggestion made by the Architect Mons. Le Corbusier. The proposal was forwarded to the High Court and the then Chief Justice acting in his personal capacity turned down the proposal on the ground that it would cause disturbance in the Court work as people would collect in front of the main Court Room i.e., Court Room No. 1 and chat.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.