The Reserve Bank of India v. M.T. Mani and Another
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 769; [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1128
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Abhay S. Oka, Justice Augustine George Masih
- Decided
- 23 May 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 13962/2024
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 5 S.C.R. 1128 : 2025 INSC 769 The Reserve Bank of India v.
M.T. Mani and Another (Civil Appeal No. 13962 of 2024)
23 May 2025 [Abhay S. Oka and Augustine George Masih,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration RBI issued Administration Circular No.1 on 14.09.2020 opening a last option for the serving and retiring employees to switch over to pension scheme from CPF scheme. Whether the fixing of the cut off date i.e. 01.07.2020 for grant of pensionary benefits and that too prospectively is in consonance with law or is discriminatory and arbitrary.
Headnotes† Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 – RBI Pension Regulations, 1990 – Contributory Provident Fund – After introduction of Pension Regulations, 1990, RBI gave option to the serving and retiring employees to switch over to pension scheme from CPF scheme in the year 1990, 1992, 1995 and 2000 – Respondent No.1 joined service of the RBI on 14.09.1981 and became a member of the CPF Scheme in operation then for the staff – He got the aforesaid four options in his tenure, however, he chose not to join the Pension Scheme rather continued with the CPF – Respondent retired on 30.11.2014 – After the Government of India rejected the proposal of RBI for another option for CPF optees to switch to the Pension Scheme, respondent no.1 filed writ petition – During the pendency of writ petition, RBI issued Administration Circular No.1 on 14.09.2020 opening a last option for the serving and retiring employees – Thereafter, respondent opted for for the Pension Scheme and in the pending writ petition moved for an amendment to challenge the denial of entitlement to the grant of arrears of pension from the date of retirement – Amendment was allowed – The writ petition was dismissed by the Single Judge of High Court, holding therein that the respondent had well-informed details * Author [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1129The Reserve Bank of India v. M.T. Mani and Another regarding the non-grant of arrears of pension and eligibility for pension from a particular date i.e. 01.07.2020 – Aggrieved, respondent filed writ appeal before the Division Bench of the High Court and same was allowed – Correctness:
Held: Each administrative circular was independent in itself where the competent authority had taken a well-informed, considered, and gauged decision with regard to the applicability, liability and financial implications, apart from the other aspects – Each time, as is apparent, different aspects were taken note of – In some cases, it was provided for retrospective effect, while in others it was restricted to employees up to a particular date, and yet another only to those employees who were in service while on yet another occasion to both ex-employees and in-service employees – What is apparent, therefore, is that on each occasion, there was a specific time frame fixed for giving an option, and the benefit was similarly limiting it to the beneficiaries – The financial burden and the liability are prominent aspects taken into consideration by the Government while granting its no objection to the proposed Scheme – In the instant case, the retrospective financial burden would have resulted in an unjustified liability of over 900 crores for the RBI, which would have led to a financially unsustainable scenario – It is settled that individual hardships cannot justify altering a rule of general application and underscored that the determination of cut-off dates is a matter of policymaking – This function squarely lies within the domain of the rule-making authority, not the judiciary, as courts cannot assume the role of framing or modifying policy decisions in the guise of judicial review – Therefore, it cannot be said that the cut off date, as fixed for grant of pension while refusing its retrospectivity, thereof would be arbitrary or illegal or discriminatory in nature – The Respondent, therefore, cannot be permitted to choose a particular aspect of the Scheme that makes it unworkable, and that too for his own financial benefit – Approbation and reprobation would not be permissible in such schemes – Respondent having once opted for the Scheme cannot be permitted to not accept a part thereof while intending to take the benefit of the Scheme as a whole – Thus, the impugned judgment passed by the Division Bench of High Court is hereby set aside and the Judgment of the Single Judge dismissing the writ petition preferred by the respondent is restored. [Paras 29, 30, 33, 34, 39, 42] 1130 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Law Cited Mohammad Ali Imam and Others v. State of Bihar and Others (2020) 5 SCC 685; State of Punjab and Others v. Amar Nath Goyal and Others [2005] Supp. 2 SCR 549 : (2005) 6 SCC 754 – relied on.
State of Tripura and Others v. Anjana Bhattacharjee and Others [2022] 11 SCR 14 : (2022) 19 SCC 705; Hirandra Kumar v. High Court of Judicature at Allahabad and Another [2019] 2 SCR 608 : (2020) 17 SCC 401; Himachal Road Transport Corporation and Another v. Himachal Road Transport Corporation Retired Employees Union [2021] 2 SCR 104 : (2021) 4 SCC 502; T.N Electricity Board v. R. Veerasamy and Others [1999] 2 SCR 221 : (1999) 3 SCC 414 – referred to.
List of Acts Gratuity Act, 1972; RBI Pension Regulations, 1990.
List of Keywords Service Law; Pension; Contributory Provident Fund; Pension Scheme; Retirement date; Arrears of pension; Serving and retiring employees; Switch over to pension scheme from CPF scheme; Entitlement to the grant of arrears of pension from the date of retirement; Financial burden; Liability; Retrospective financial burden; Individual hardships; Policymaking; Judiciary.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 13962 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 18.12.2023 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in WA No. 1037 of 2023 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Shyam Divan, Sr. Adv., Ramesh Babu M.R., Nisha Sharma, Yashvardhan Singh, Ms. Anshula Laroriya, Ms. Jagriti Bharti. Advs. for the Respondents:
Yohannan I, Ms. Aishwarya Mary Mathew, Manu Krishnan G. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1131The Reserve Bank of India v. M.T. Mani and Another Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Augustine George Masih, J.
1. In this Appeal, challenge has been raised by the Reserve Bank of India (“RBI”) to the Division Bench Judgment of the Kerala High Court dated 18.12.2023 whereby the appeal preferred by Respondent No.1 against the Judgment of a Single Judge dismissing his Writ Petition for grant of pension with effect from the date of his retirement i.e. 01.12.2014, stood dismissed after he exercised his option as per the RBI Regulations/Circular dated 14.09.2020.
2. The facts are not in dispute and therefore are being referred at the very outset.
3. The employees of the RBI prior to 1990 were governed by the Contributory Provident Fund (“CPF”) and the payment of the Gratuity Act, 1972 (“Gratuity Act”). For the first time, on 29.10.1990, the RBI with approval from its Central Board of Directors introduced the RBI Pension Regulations, 1990. Employees were informed vide Administration Circular No. 6 to the effect that the said regulations would come into effect from 01.11.1990 giving an option to the existing employees to join the said Pension Scheme or to continue with the RBI’s CPF. All new employees who joined on or after 01.11.1990 were to be governed by the 1990 Regulations. It also provided that the employees in service as on 01.01.1986 who retired before 01.11.1990 were also eligible for pension upon refunding the amount of CPF share of the RBI with accrued interest as received by them on their retirement, along with simple interest thereon at the rate of 6%. According to Regulation 31 thereof, employees retiring between 01.01.1986 and 31.10.1990, although eligible to join the Pension Scheme, would receive the pension only from 01.11.1990 onwards, with no arrears for the period before the said date. On 07.02.1992 RBI issued another Administration Circular No. 5 amending the Pension Regulations, 1990 effective from 06.02.1992. Existing employees (excluding those on leave preparatory to retirement) were given a fresh option to switch to the Pension Regulations. Here again, no retrospective pensionary benefits were granted.
1132 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
4. On 14.10.1995, Administration Circular No. 4 providing for another opportunity for existing employees as on 01.11.1992 excluding those on Leave Preparatory retirement to opt for the Pension Regulations. On this occasion, the refund of the CPF contribution made by the RBI and accrued interest was to be effected with 12% simple interest. It was clarified that it was not applicable to employees who had retired before 01.11.1992 making it prospective.
5. Three attempts made by the RBI to give another option to its employees to switch over from CPF to the Pension Scheme did not find favour with the Government of India on 04.02.2002, 26.02.2018 and 05.03.2019. On 14.09.2020, another Administration Circular No. 1 was issued, which allowed existing CPF optees and former employees who were in service on or after 01.11.1997 and retired with CPF to opt for Pension Regulations. This was obviously, subject to the refund of the CPF plus accrued interest amount pertaining to the RBI’s share with 12% simple interest. It is apparent that this Circular was not applicable to employees who had retired before 01.11.1997. A detailed memorandum of procedure for option to be exercised was issued by the RBI on 20.09.2000.
6. Respondent No. 1 joined service of the RBI on 14.09.1981 and became a member of the CPF Scheme in operation then for the staff. During his entire service tenure, until he retired as Manager on 30.11.2014, Respondent No.1 got four options to switch over to the Pension Scheme, starting from 01.11.1990 till 14.09.2000. He chose not to join the Pension Scheme rather continued with the CPF. As a matter of fact, on retirement, he was paid the entire dues of CPF and Gratuity.
7. It appears that Respondent No. 1 filed a Writ Petition before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam on 14.02.2020, after the Government of India rejected the proposal of RBI for another option for CPF optees to switch to the Pension Scheme on 05.03.2019. He sought a direction to the RBI to allow him to exercise the pension option as per the 1990 Regulations, and to grant him pension benefits with effect from 30.11.2014, his date of retirement, along with 12% interest on arrears.
8. During the pendency of the Writ Petition, the RBI proposed to the Government of India to grant a final chance for remaining CPF [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1133The Reserve Bank of India v. M.T. Mani and Another optee employees, both serving and retired, to opt for the Pension Scheme. No objection was conveyed by the Government to the RBI’s proposal on 26.06.2020, for the CPF optees who were in service from 01.11.1990 till 15.11.2000.
9. This permission for the change of option was allowed to the employees subject to refund of the CPF amount with accrued interest as received from RBI on retirement and simple interest as may be decided by the RBI. RBI issued Administration Circular No. 1 on 14.09.2020 opening a last option for the serving and retiring employees who were in Bank service as on 01.11.1990 (the date of introduction of the Pension Scheme) and continued as on 15.11.2000 (the closing date of the last chance given to the employees to exercise pension option). This fresh option for switching over from CPF to Pension Scheme would be subject to certain terms and conditions which were to be specified as per the detailed instructions to be issued in this regard separately by the RBI. However, in this Administration Circular No. 1 itself it was clarified that the eligible employees and the family members would be entitled to draw monthly pension/family pension with effect from 01.07.2020 and no arrears of pension will be paid for the period prior thereto. The payment of pension was made prospective w.e.f. 01.07.2020. It was further clarified that this option was not applicable to the employees who joined bank service on or after 01.01.2012 and were governed by the National Pension Scheme (NPS). Detailed instructions were issued by the RBI on 18.09.2020. The relevant portion thereof reads as follows: “Please refer to Administration Circular No. 1 dated September 14, 2020 regarding opening of option for pension.
2. The employees who were in the Bank’s service as on November 1, 1990 and continued as such on November 15, 2000 are being offered a last opportunity for exercising their option for switching over form Contributory Provident Fund (CPF) to pension scheme under RBI Pension Regulations, 1990 (Pension Regulations), covering the categories, viz. serving employees, retired employees and eligible family members of deceased employees; as under:
(i) Serving employees of the Bank who had earlier chosen not to be governed by Pension Regulations and continued 1134 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports to retain CPF option, subject to transfer of amount of Bank’s contribution to Provident Fund with accrued interest to be credited to the RBI Gratuity and Superannuation Fund (Pension Fund).
(ii) Retired employees of the Bank who had earlier retained CPF option, subject to refund of amount of Bank’s contribution to Provident Fund with accrued interest paid to them at the time of their retirement, along with simple interest @3% per annum calculated from the date of receipt of the amount by the employee till the date of refund to the Bank.
(iv) Option for switch-over from CPF to Pension under the Pension Regulations, once exercised, shall be irrevocable.
(v) The option shall not be applicable to employees who joined service on or after 01.01.2012 and are governed by National Pension System.
4. Retired employees:
(i) Eligible Retired employees, as mentioned at Para 2(ii) above, shall exercise their option for joining the Pension Scheme in FORM -1 (R) (copy enclosed) within 90 days from the date of this circular i.e. on or before close of business hours on December 17, 2020. On exercising the option, they shall refund to the Bank in lump sum, within 90 days from the date of this circular i.e. on or before close of business hours on December 17, 2020, the Bank’s contribution to Provident Fund and accrued interest thereon paid to them at the time of their retirement along with simple interest @3% per annum calculated from the date of receipt of the amount by the employee till the date of refund to the Bank.
(ii) The duly filled in FORM-1 (R) (copy enclosed) along with details of family duly filled in Form 4 (copy enclosed) shall be submitted by the retired employee at the Regional Office/Central Office Department from where he/she retired. x x x x x x
(vi) Pre - November 1, 2012 retirees will be eligible for revision of pension, prospectively i.e. from July 1, 2020, [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1135The Reserve Bank of India v. M.T. Mani and Another without payment of any arrears, as per the method indicated in circular CO HRMD No. G. 84/ 18491/21.01.00/2018- 19 dated March 7, 2019 read with letter CO HRMD No.
27412/21.01.000/2018-19 dated June 26, 2019.
(vii) Eligible retired employees who have exercised their option for pension and refunded Bank’s contribution to Provident Fund and accrued interest thereon, along with simple interest @3% per annum as per para 4(i) above will be eligible for full pension from July 1. 2020 upto the date they opt for commutation of pension.
x x x x x x ix) On commutation of pension, retired employees will draw the basic pension reduced to the extent of commuted portion of pension. In such cases, full pension will be restored fifteen years after the date of commutation of pension.
(x) Failing to deposit amount of Bank’s contribution to Provident Fund and accrued interest thereon, along with simple interest @3% per annum as at para 4(i) above within the stipulated time by the retired employee, will render the option for pension exercised by him/her as invalid. Any request for extension of time limit for refund of Provident Fund amount shall be rejected forthwith by respective RO/COD, without reference to Central Office.
(xi) After completion of all formalities, eligible retired employees will start drawing pension with effect from July 1, 2020. No arrears of pension will be paid for the period prior to July 1,2020.”
10. A perusal of the above instructions for implementation dated 18.09.2020 makes it amply clear that all the employees who were eligible to switch over from the CPF Scheme to the Pension Scheme and who now opted for the Pension Scheme were required to refund the amount of Bank’s contribution to the Provident Fund with accrued interest, along with simple interest at the rate of 3% per annum, calculated from the date of receipt of the amount by the employee from the Bank till the date of refund thereof. The option had to be exercised, and the refund was also to be made to the Bank on or 1136 [2025] 5 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports before 17.12.2020. Commutation of pension was also permitted at the option of the employees. It was specifically so noted and mentioned that the retired employee would start drawing pension with effect from 01.07.2020, and no arrears of pension would be paid for the period prior thereto.
11. Respondent No. 1 on the issuance of the said Administration Circular No. 1 dated 14.09.2020, followed by the detailed instructions for implementation dated 18.09.2020, opted for the Pension Scheme, and the said Pension Scheme had been made applicable to him under which he is admittedly receiving monthly pension. The said Respondent, in the pending Writ Petition moved for an amendment to challenge the denial of entitlement to the grant of arrears of pension from the date of retirement. The said clauses of the Administrative Circular, as well as detailed instruction circular, were challenged to that limited extent, with a prayer for issuance of a writ of mandamus to the RBI to award 12% interest on arrears due to the petitioner by allowing him arrears with effect from the date of his retirement i.e. 30.11.2014.
12. The said amendment was allowed by the High Court on 18.03.2022, and an amended Writ Petition was filed. Upon the RBI filing a Counter to the amended Writ Petition, the Single Judge of the High Court proceeded to decide the Writ Petition, dismissing it vide Order dated 04.04.2023, holding therein that the Respondent had well-informed details regarding the non-grant of arrears of pension and eligibility for pension from a particular date i.e. 01.07.2020. Having accepted the same and taken benefit thereof, it was not open to the Respondent to challenge a part of the said Scheme.
13. Upon dismissal of the writ petition, the Respondent preferred a writ appeal which was allowed by the Division Bench on 18.12.2023 entitling the Respondent to pension benefits from the date of his retirement i.e. 30.11.2014, on the grounds that in the earlier administrative circulars, whenever an option had been granted to the serving or retired employees, they were entitled to arrears of pension as well. Denial of such arrears of pension from the date of retirement was held to be discriminatory and arbitrary at the hands of the RBI. A direction was further issued to the RBI to pay the pension benefits within one month from the date of the Order, failing which, it would attract interest at the rate of 6% per annum until realization. [2025] 5 S.C.R. 1137The Reserve Bank of India v. M.T. Mani and Another
14. The rationale and the reasoning put forth by the Division Bench was that the Respondent, to be eligible to opt for to the Pension Scheme, had to refund the contribution of the bank along with accrued interest with 3% simple interest from the date of the receipt of the said amount till its deposit. The amount having been refunded along with interest, entitled the employees to the benefit of pension from the date of retirement.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.