Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Wel. Ason v. Union of India Through Secretary & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 573; [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2397
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Vikram Nath, Justice Prasanna Bhalachandra Varale
- Decided
- 25 Apr 2025
- Case number
- MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION No. 1290/2022
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2397 : 2025 INSC 573 Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Wel. Ason.
v.
Union of India Through Secretary & Ors.
(Miscellaneous Application No. 1290 of 2022 In Writ Petition (Civil) No. 876 of 1996)
25 April 2025 [Vikram Nath* and Prasanna B. Varale, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Redressal of grievances of the allottees/plot holders.
Headnotes† Housing – Residential colony – Builder purchased approx.235 acres of land in Faridabad, Haryana for establishing a residential colony – In view of the bilateral agreement with the Director, Town and Country Planning, the Builder was required to allot plots in the various categories – Allottees made deposits; however, the Builder/Colonizer did not adhere to the terms and conditions of the allotment agreement – In 1996, allottees filed writ petitions before this Court, writ petition disposed of in 2019 – After the disposal of the writ petition, the Single Member Special Committee appointed in 2016 continued with its exercise of resolving the issues and finally submitted its report in 2023, report was accepted – However, a number of applications had come up by allottees of different categories praying for redressal of their grievances who could not approach the Special Committee in time – On request, Special Committee, agreed to continue to deal with further applications from the defaulters, those already filed or those that may be filed – Pending applications were examined by the amicus curiae as to whether those applications were required to be dealt with by this Court or the Special Committee – Note submitted – Applications that needed to be examined and disposed of by the Special Committee, referred to the Special Committee – Second category of applications consisted of those applications which alleged some grievances before the * Author 2398 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Special Committee or which need to be adjudicated upon by this Court:
Held: Applications examined in detail, appropriate orders issued – Directions issued to State of Haryana to demarcate plots and public facilities in a feasible way to ensure that maximum number of allottees can be accommodated. [Paras 11-43] List of Acts Development and Regulation of Urban Areas Act, 1975.
List of Keywords Residential colony; Colonizer; Okhla Enclave Plot Holders’ Welfare Association; Durga Builder Plot Holder Welfare Association; Plot holders; Plot buyers; Economically weaker sections (EWS); Plots on No Profit No Loss (NPNL) basis; Plots to be sold in open market; Single Member Special Committee; Director Town and Country Planning Department, State of Haryana; DTCP.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Miscellaneous Application No. 1290 of 2022 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 876 of 1996 From the Judgment and Order dated 03.10.2019 of the Supreme Court of India in W.P. (C) No. 876 of 1996 With Diary No(s). 21286 and 26517 of 2020, MA No(s). 981 and 887 of 2022, MA No(s). 1598, 1776 and 1351 of 2023 and MA No(s). 725 and 1221 of 2024 in W.P.(C) No. 876 of 1996 Appearances for Parties Ms. Rashmi Nandakumar, Amicus Curiae, Ms. Yeshmita Pandey. Advs. for the Appellant:
Ranji Thomas, Vipin Sanghi Sr. Advs., Vikas Upadhyay, Rajesh Kandari, Mrs. Ankita Kashyap, Arjun Singh Tomar, Gautam Narayan, Dhanesh Relan, Ms. Asmita Singh, Ms. Brinde Ajmani, Tushar Nair, Anirudh Anand, Punishk Handa, Ajay Jain, Jinendra Jain, Krishna Sharma, Ms. Bijay Lakshmi, M.N. Mishra, Vikrant Singh, Ajay Sharma, Shafik Ahmed, Ajit Kumar Singh, Manoj Kumar, [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2399Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Wel. Ason. v. Union of India Through Secretary & Ors.
Ms. Parul Priya, Ms. Anupama Singh, S. Srinivasa Chary, Varun Mishra, Ram Lal Roy, Rajeev Ranjan, Ms. Purnima Jauhari, Brijesh Jauhari, Harsh Mahan, O. P. Singh, Atul Mahan, Ms. Aparna Jauhari, Kaveesh Nair, Ms. Mahima Mukherjee, Ms. Manisha Ambwani, Ms. Sumita Hazarika, Ms. Mansi Mehta, Chandra Bhushan Prasad, E. C. Vidya Sagar, Ranbir Singh Yadav, Prateek Yadav, Ms. Pratima Yadav, Vikrant Yadav, Mohammed Shahrukh, Ms. Madhu Sikri, P. Narasimhan, P. N. Puri, Mrs. Reeta Dewan Puri, Ms. Smriti Puri, J.S. Marahatta, Bahar. U. Barqui, Aftab Ali Khan, Ms. Sheetal Rawat, Mansur Ali Khan, Rahat Ali Chaudhary, Piyush Sharma, Shivam Dubey, Anuj Kumar Sharma, Md. Shahid Anwar, Sudarshan Rajan, Amit Pawan, S. Rajappa.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Mrs. Aishwarya Bhati, Mrs. Archana Pathak Dave A.S.Gs., Lokesh Sinhal, Sr. A.A.G., D.P. Singh, Vipin Sanghi, Nachiketa Joshi, Sr. Advs., Akshay Amritanshu, Samyak Jain, Ms. Himanshi Sakya, Ms. Drishti Saraf, Ms. Pragya Upadhyay, Nikunj Gupta, Ms. Aakansha, Sanjay Jain, Manu Mishra, Ms. Ruchika Bhan, Iman Khera, Kaushal Yadav, Rajendra Singh Chauhan, Nandlal Kumar Mishra, Onkar Nath Sharma, Ms. Pratibha Jain, Piyush Sharma, Shivam Dubey, Anuj Kumar Sharma, Ms. Rashmi Nandakumar, Sarvam Ritam Khare, Akash Shukla, Kushagra Sharma, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, B K Satija, Sanjay Kumar Tyagi, Mrs. Aakanksha Kaul, Rakesh Sharma, Digvijay Dam, Navanjay Mahapatra, Raman Yadav, Madhav Sinhal, Ms. Sunanda Shukla, Ayush Sharma, Mrs. Suman Lata Katiyar, Ms. N. Annapoorani, P. Parmeswaran, Yash Pal Dhingra, Dr. S. K. Verma, Shailendra Bhardwaj, S. K. Verma, Mrs. Rani Chhabra, Arun K. Sinha, Ms. Sadhana Sandhu, Arjun Sain, Ms. Shikha Sandhu, Ms. Puja Sharma, Shekhar Kumar, Ms. Jaspreet Gogia.
Petitioner-in-person.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Vikram Nath, J.
1. M/s Durga Builders (Pvt.) Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “Builder”) purchased approximately 235 acres of land in Faridabad, Haryana 2400 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports for establishing a residential colony, and obtained licenses from the Director, Town and Country Planning, Haryana under the Haryana Development and Regulation of Urban Areas Act, 1975. It thereafter entered into a bilateral agreement with the Director, Town and Country Planning according to which the Builder was required to allot plots in the following three categories, as detailed below:
(i). 20% of the plots of sizes of 50 sq. mtrs. to 125 sq. mtrs. for economically weaker sections (EWS) at subsidized rates to be determined by the Government.
(ii). 25% of the plots on No Profit No Loss (NPNL) basis having sizes ranging from 125 sq. mtrs. to 225 sq. mtrs. again, at the rates to be determined by the Department.
(iii). Lastly the balance 55 % of the plots were to be sold in the open market at the rates decided by the Builder with a rider that the profit would not exceed 15%.
2. Advertisements were issued, applications were invited, and allotments were made. The allottees made deposits; however, the Builder did not adhere to the terms and conditions of the allotment agreement. As a result, the allottees in 1996 filed petitions under Article 32 of the Constitution of India before this Court, registered as Writ Petition (Civil) No. 876 of 1996.
3. In 2016, this Court, vide order dated 27.01.2016, appointed Mr. Justice Vikramjit Sen, retired Judge of this Court, as a single member Special Committee. The Special Committee was constituted to resolve each and every issue involved in the said matter. The Special Committee had been appointed considering the magnitude of the issues raised and finding that it would be difficult for this Court to itself deal with such a large number of objections from hundreds or thousands of allottees with valid claims. The Special Committee formulated its mechanism to deal with the pending issues and also set up a Scrutiny Committee to identify and verify the claimants. The Scrutiny Committee comprised of five members and was chaired by the Senior Town Planner, Faridabad. It also had representatives from the plot holders’ associations.
4. Later the Special Committee sought directions from this Court on four issues, as contained in its communication dated 11.10.2018. The said four questions were answered by this Court while disposing [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2401Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Wel. Ason. v. Union of India Through Secretary & Ors.
of the writ petition vide judgement and order dated 03.10.2019. Pursuant to the said judgment, the Special Committee continued with its exercise of resolving the issues and finally submitted its report dated 16.01.2023. The said report was accepted by this Court vide order dated 11.07.2023. The Special Committee thereafter tendered its resignation on 05.09.2023, on the premise that it had completed its exercise and submitted its report in January 2023, which had been taken on record and accepted by this Court vide order dated 11.07.2023. However, the fact remained that in the order dated 11.07.2023 itself it was noted that a number of applications had come up by allottees of different categories praying for redressal of their grievances who could not approach the Special Committee in time. Applications have been filed praying that this Court may request the Special Committee to consider these applications and submit a further report. Further several applications have been filed raising grievance that their claims had been wrongly rejected or not considered by the Special Committee.
5. Ms. Rashmi Nandakumar, learned amicus curiae appointed by this Court was requested to find out as to whether the Special Committee would accept the further inquiry as required by order dated 11.07.2023.
6. Finally, in the order dated 23.07.2024, it was noted that the Special Committee, comprising Justice Sen, had kindly agreed to continue to deal with further applications from the defaulters, those already filed or those that may be filed. In the said order, this Court had requested Justice Sen to continue to chair the Committee until further orders of the Court. However, before proceeding to refer the matter to the Special Committee, this Court had required all pending application to be examined by the learned amicus curiae as to whether those applications were required to be dealt with by this Court or the Special Committee. Pursuant thereto, the amicus curiae submitted its note giving a brief summary of the applications and also categorising them based on whether they should be taken up by the Special Committee and or they were to be taken up by this Court for disposal.
7. We have heard learned amicus curiae, Ms. Rashmi Nandakumar, and learned counsel appearing for the applicants and have perused the material on record. The following is the list of applications that needs to be examined and disposed of by the Special Committee as such same are being referred to the Special Committee: 2402 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports S.
No.
I.A. No. Name of the Applicant (s) Name of the Advocate on Record A. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. No. 1290/2022
1. IA No.
93906/2021 Prem Singh Rawat (Permission to File Impleadment)
Ram Lal Roy 1.1 IA No.
93909/2021 Prem Singh Rawat (Intervention/Impleadment)
Ram Lal Roy 1.2 IA No.
93912/2021 Prem Singh Rawat (Exemption from filing O.T.)
Ram Lal Roy 1.3 IA No.
93918/2021 Prem Singh Rawat (Clarification/Direction)
Ram Lal Roy
2. IA No.
154562/2022 Jagat Singh & Anr.
(Intervention/Impleadment)
Ranbir Singh Yadav 2.1 IA No.
154529/2022 Jagat Singh & Anr.
(Appropriate Orders/ Directions)
Ranbir Singh Yadav B. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. (D) No. 21286/2020
1. IA No. 24/2021 Ranjana Sethi (Intervention Application)
Kaushal Yadav
2. IA No. 25/2021 Ranjana Sethi (Directions) Kaushal Yadav
3. IA No.
113403/2022 Banarasi Prasad (Intervention Application)
Rakesh Kumar Singh 3.1 IA No.
113409/2022 Banarasi Prasad (Appropriate Orders/ Directions)
Rakesh Kumar Singh C. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. (D) No. 26517/2020
1. IA No.
18180/2021 Gokul Singh Negi (D) Through His LRs.
(Permission for Intervention)
Vikas Upadhyay 1.1 IA No.18181/2021 Gokul Singh Negi (D) Through His LRs.
(Intervention Application)
Vikas Upadhyay [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2403Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Wel. Ason. v. Union of India Through Secretary & Ors.
1.2 IA No.126167/2020 Gokul Singh Negi (D) Through His LRs.
(Appropriate Orders/ Directions)
Vikas Upadhyay 2 IA No.18167/2021 Sudha Rawat (D) Through Her LRs.
(Permission for Intervention)
Vikas Upadhyay 2.1 IA No.18169/2021 Sudha Rawat (D) Through Her LRs.
(Intervention)
Vikas Upadhyay 2.2 IA No.126186/2020 Sudha Rawat (D) Through Her LRs.
(Appropriate Order/ Directions)
Vikas Upadhyay D. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. No. 981/2022
1. IA No.
159218/2021 Ratnesh Bansal Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Welfare Association (Appln. for Impleadment)# Jinendra Jain 1.1 IA No.
159217/2021 Ratnesh Bansal Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Welfare Association (Permission to file Impleadment) ‡ Jinendra Jain 1.2 IA No.
97865/2021 Ratnesh Bansal Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Welfare Association (Appropriate Orders/ Directions)
Jinendra Jain # Ed. Note: “(Appln. for Impleadment)” instead of “(Permission for Intervention)” in terms of subsequent corrigendum.
‡ Ed. Note: “(Permission to file Impleadment)” instead of “(Intervention/Impleadment)” in terms of subsequent corrigendum.
2404 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports E. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. No. 1776/2023
1. IA No.
86736/2023 Smt. Harshi Negi (Intervention/Impleadment)
Purnima Jauhari 1.1 IA No.
86749/2023 Smt. Harshi Negi (Clarification/Direction)
Purnima Jauhari 1.2 IA No.
130009/2023 Smt. Harshi Negi (Permission for Impleadment)⁑ Purnima Jauhari F. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. No. 725/2024
1. IA No.
18997/2024 Bir Pal Singh (Appln. for directions) $ Varun Mishra 1.1 IA No.
18995/2024 Bir Pal Singh (Appln. For impleadment) § Varun Mishra 1.2 IA No.
29271/2024 Bir Pal Singh (Permission for Impleadment)
Varun Mishra
8. The above applications are primarily from those allottees who could not approach the Special Committee before the cut-off date notified by the Special Committee for various reasons but claimed to have raised various disputes. The Special Committee will carve out its own procedure, which could be the same as before or modified as the Special Committee may decide.
9. The second category of applications consists of those applications which alleged some grievances before the Special Committee or which need to be adjudicated upon by this Court. The list of these applications is given hereunder:
⁑ Ed. Note: “(Permission for Impleadment)” instead of “(Permission for Intervention)” in terms of subsequent corrigendum.
$ Ed. Note: “(Appln. for directions)” instead of “(Intervention/Impleadment)” in terms of subsequent corrigendum. § Ed. Note: “(Appln. For impleadment)” instead of “(Appropriate Orders/Directions)” in terms of subsequent corrigendum.
[2025] 4 S.C.R. 2405Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Wel. Ason. v. Union of India Through Secretary & Ors.
S.
No.
I.A. No. Name of the Applicant (s) Name of the Advocate on Record A. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. (D) No. 21286/2020
1. IA No.
99521/2020 Durga General Plot Holders Welfare Association (Permission)
Gautam Narayan 1.1 IA No.
99522/2020 Durga General Plot Holders Welfare Association (Permission for Intervention/ Impleadment)
Gautam Narayan 1.2 IA No.
99524/2020 Durga General Plot Holders Welfare Association (Clarification of the Order dated 03.10.2019/Direction)
Gautam Narayan 1.3 IA No.
125990/2020 Durga General Plot Holders Welfare Association (Permission to File Additional Document/Facts/Annexures)
Gautam Narayan
2. IA No.
3385/2021 Durga Builder Plot Holders Welfare Association (Intervention/Impleadment)
Sanjay Jain 2.1 IA No.
160786/2024 in IA No.
3385/2021 Durga Builder Plot Holders Welfare Association (Permission to File Additional Documents/Facts/Annexures)
3 IA No.
42882/2021 Early Hearing Application Piyush Sharma 3.1 IA No.
98167/2022 Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Welfare Association (Directions)
Piyush Sharma 3.2 IA No.
76802/2023 Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Welfare Association (Appropriate Orders/Directions)
Piyush Sharma 3.3 IA No.
234313/2023 Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Welfare Association (Necessary Action/Directions)
Piyush Sharma 2406 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
7. IA No.
47032/2024 in IA 3385/2021 Durga Builder Plot Holder Welfare (Regd.)
(Permission to raise Averments/ Facts/Documents)
Sanjay Jain B. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. No. 981/2022
1. IA No.
223046/2023 Smt. Shanta Rani & Ors.
(Intervention/Impleadment)
Sarvam Ritam Khare 1.1 IA No.
146281/2023 Smt. Shanta Rani & Ors.
(Intervention/Impleadment)
Sarvam Ritam Khare 1.2 IA No.
22945/2023 Smt. Shanta Rani & Ors.
(Directions)
Sarvam Ritam Khare C. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. No. 887/2022
1. IA No.
68538/2022 M/s S.K. Land and Finance Ltd.
(Permission for Intervention)
Manisha Ambwani 1.1 IA No.
68540/2022 M/s S.K. Land and Finance Ltd.
(Intervention/Impleadment)
Manisha Ambwani 1.2 IA No.
68548/2022 M/s S.K. Land and Finance Ltd.
(Clarification/Direction)
Manisha Ambwani D. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. No. 1351/2023
1. IA No.
101040/2023 Raja Ram Prajapati & Ors.
(Permission for Intervention)
Aftab Ali Khan 1.1 IA No.
101041/2023 Raja Ram Prajapati & Ors.
(Intervention/Impleadment)
Aftab Ali Khan 1.2 IA No.
101050/2023 Raja Ram Prajapati & Ors.
(Clarification/Direction)
Aftab Ali Khan E. List of the I.As. filed in M.A. No. 1598/2023
1. IA No.
129575/2023 N R Chauhan (Permission for Impleadment)
Manisha Ambwani 1.1 IA No.
66516/2023 N R Chauhan (Appropriate Orders/Directions)
Manisha Ambwani 1.2 IA No.
66513/2023 N R Chauhan (Intervention/Impleadment)
Manisha Ambwani [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2407Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Wel. Ason. v. Union of India Through Secretary & Ors.
F. List of I.As filed in M.A. No. 1221/2024
1. IA No.
146968/2024 Ms. Kiran Bala Nair (Application for Permission)
Aftab Ali Khan 1.1 IA No.
226306/2023 Ms. Kiran Bala Nair (Intervention/Impleadment)
Aftab Ali Khan
10. We will now deal with above applications one by one. I. IA. No. 99521/2020, IA No.99522/202, IA No.99524/2020 in M.A.(D) No.212286 of 2020
11. The first category of IAs has been filed by Durga Builder Plot Holder Welfare Association of plot buyers that form a part of the General/ Open category, who claim to have purchased plots from the Colonizer by making full payment at market rates. IA No. 99521 of 2020 is for permission to file impleadment application. IA No. 99522 of 2020 is an application for impleadment. IA No. 99524 of 2020 is for clarification/ modification in the order dated 03.10.2019. IA No. 125990 of 2020 is for filing additional documents.
12. The applicants state that their claims originate from the conveyance deed between its individual members and the Colonizer. They refer to the orders dated 23.11.2000, 15.07.2015 passed by this Court and the order dated 04.10.2018 passed by the Special Committee stating that these Orders clarify that they relate to the EWS and NPNL categories specifically and do not apply to the General Category (Category 3). Following submissions have been advanced on their behalf:
12.1 Since the General Category Plot Holders have paid the market price, the parameters regarding multiple plots cannot be made applicable to them. The Applicants were affected by the conditions laid down vide procedural order dated 07.05.2016 regarding one allotment to one family.
12.2 The procedural order of the Special Committee referred to above sets out the criteria to be followed by plot holders for eligibility that form the basis of scrutiny. The general category plot holders made a prayer before the Special Committee to modify these conditions to remove restrictions on multiple holdings by eligible applicants from the same family. The 2408 [2025] 4 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Special Committee vide procedural order dated 04.10.2018 amended its order dated 07.05.2016. The paragraph referring to the same is extracted below:
“6. After discussion with Shri, Sanjeev Mann, DTP Faridabad, it is directed that the Scrutiny Committee shall not insist on an affidavit from the Claimant affirming that the Colonizer has neither sold the plot allotted to them to any third party nor created nay Third-Party right over the same’ The Scrutiny Committee is further directed that it should not refuse to scrutinise any claim or to disentitle any person who has paid the full sale consideration only on the ground that multiple claims applications have been filed by members of the same family.”
12.3 It appears that when the matter was taken up by this Court, this order was not brought to the notice of the Court. Therefore, the order of this Court dated 03.10.2019 sets out the conditions laid down in Procedural Order dated 07.05.2016 for all categories of applicants.
12.4 Since general category allottees were allotted plots as per market rates, it would be unfair to limit the eligibility of general category allottees with respect to multiple claims from one family.
13. Considering the submissions advanced and the observations made by the Special Committee in its procedural order dated 04.10.2018, this Court is inclined to modify the order dated 03.10.2019 to the above extent and permit those general category allottees who were found ineligible in the first round due to holding multiple plots within one family to participate in the second round of scrutiny. It is ordered accordingly. The IA No. 99524 of 2020 is allowed. Other IA’s viz IA No. 99521 of 2020, IA No. 99522 of 2020 and IA No. 125990 of 2020 stand disposed of.
II. I.A. No. 3385/2021 in M.A (D) No. 21286/2020;
I.A. No.160786 of 2024 in I.A. No. 3385/2021.
14. I.A. No.3385 of 2021 pertains to an application of impleadment filed by Durga Builder Plot Holder Welfare Association (Regd.) which [2025] 4 S.C.R. 2409Okhla Enclave Plot Holders Wel. Ason. v. Union of India Through Secretary & Ors.
represents claimants who booked plots in the NPNL category and paid both the plot and development charges. I.A. No.160786 of 2024 has been filed to place additional documents. The applicants contend that the Colonizers breached the agreement as they initially sold more land than the sanctioned plots allowed for the NPNL category and subsequently, plots were sold to the General category in sizes smaller than prescribed, further violating the agreement. This default has created an extraordinary situation with more claimants than available plots.
15. The Applicants have also objected to plots being allotted to members of the same family. This application is for impleadment and no direction has been prayed for. This IA does not require any orders as we have already allowed their application for classification in the order dated 03.10.2019. Therefore, this I.A. stands disposed of.
III. I.A. No. 42882 of 2021 in M.A (D.) No. 21286/2020
16. This IA was filed praying to fix an early date for hearing in M.A. (D.) 21286/2020. The I.A. stands disposed of as it has been rendered infructuous.
IV. I.A. No. 98167 of 2022 in M.A. (D.) 21286 of 2020
17. This IA was filed seeking the intervention of this Court to expedite the submission of the report of the Committee. Since the Special Committee has completed the exercise of identification of eligible allottees, this IA has become infructuous and accordingly stands disposed of.
V. I.A. No. 76802 of 2023 in M.A. (D.) 21286 of 2020
18. This is an application filed by Okhla Enclave Plot Holders’ Welfare Association praying for the following reliefs:
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.