Sajithabai and Ors. v. The Kerala Water Authority and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 354; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 789
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Manmohan
- Decided
- 18 Mar 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 1420/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 789 : 2025 INSC 354 Sajithabai and Ors.
v.
The Kerala Water Authority and Ors.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 1420-1422 of 2025)
18 March 2025 [Dipankar Datta and Manmohan,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Matter pertains to the issue as to a person joining as an Assistant Engineer, has option to migrate to either the degree or diploma quota; and the scope of the Kerala Public Health Engineering Service Special Rules, 1960 and the Kerala Public Health Engineering Subordinate Service Rules, 1966.
Headnotes† Kerala Public Health Engineering Service Special Rules, 1960 – r.4(b) – Kerala Public Health Engineering Subordinate Service Rules, 1966 – Promotion – Option to migrate to either the degree or diploma quota – Appellants inducted as Draftsman, promoted to the post of Assistant Engineer on basis of seniority in the Diploma quota under the 1966 Rules prior to the declaration of direct recruitment result in which they also participated – Meanwhile, the respondents directly recruited to the post of Assistant Engineer in the 6% degree quota – Appellant at the stage of entering the service never had the opportunity to opt or choose for the diploma or degree quota – In the seniority list, appellants shown to be senior to the respondents – Appellants then sought promotion to the post of Assistant Executive Engineer – Writ petition by the respondents – Single Judge allowed the same holding that directly recruited Assistant Engineers from the open market and those promoted through the Departmental Quota are considered under separate watertight categories; and that the appellants chose promotion under the Diploma quota and are thus ineligible for further promotion to Assistant Executive Engineer under the Degree quota, as per the governing rules – Division Bench upheld the same – Correctness:
* Author 790 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Held: 1966 Rules and 1960 Rules are separate and distinct rules that govern two separate services comprising different categories of officers – Once a person joins as an Assistant Engineer, the feeder post under a separate service governed by 1960 Rules, then that person irrespective of how he/she has been appointed to that post, has the option to migrate to either the degree or diploma quota, provided he/she has obtained a degree or a diploma – Intent and purpose behind r.4(b) is to give an option to an Assistant Engineer to join either the diploma or the degree quota, as promotion to the next higher post – Special Rules, 1960 deal with a separate service, its r.4(b) has no applicability to a stage prior to an officer becoming an Assistant Engineer – Interpretation by the respondents that r.4(b) and its proviso give an option/choice to choose a diploma or degree stream to only those who while holding the post of Assistant Engineer acquire a degree qualification is erroneous – Proviso which gives the option to such officers to choose the diploma or degree quota means and refers to all the officers holding the post of Assistant Engineer – Impugned judgments passed by the Single Judge and the Division Bench of the High Court set aside. [Paras 16-26, 32] Case Law Cited Chandravathi P.K. and Others. v. C.K. Saji and Others [2004] 2 SCR 330 : (2004) 3 SCC 734 – held inapplicable.
K.P. Varghese v. Income Tax Officer, Ernakulam and Another [1982] 1 SCR 629 : (1981) 4 SCC 173; Bishwajit Dey v. The State of Assam [2025] 1 SCR 281 : Criminal Appeal No. 87 of 2025 – referred to.
Hatzl v. XL Insurance Co. Ltd. (2009) EWCA Civ. 223 – referred to. List of Acts Kerala Public Health Engineering Service Special Rules, 1960; Kerala Public Health Engineering Subordinate Service Rules, 1966. List of Keywords Assistant Engineer; Promotion; Draftsman; Diploma; Degree; Seniority; Educational requirement; Promotion quota; Option to migrate to either the degree or diploma quota; Seniority list; Departmental Quota; Promotion to Assistant Executive Engineer; Feeder post.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 791Sajithabai and Ors. v. The Kerala Water Authority and Ors. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No(s). 1420-1422 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 18.03.2024 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in WA Nos. 2213 and 2206 of 2023 and WA No. 66 of 2024 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
Nikhil Goel, Sr. Adv., Arvinda Babu, Ms. Siddhi Gupta, Ms. Anne Mathew, Bharat Sood, Jai Govind M J, Aditya Roy, P. S. Sudheer. Advs. for the Respondents:
V. Chitembresh, Jayanth Muth Raj, Sr. Advs., Roy Abraham, Ms. Reena Roy, Adithya Koshy Roy, Yaduinder Lal, Ms. Rajni Ohri Lal, Himinder Lal, Nishe Rajen Shonker, Mrs. Anu K Joy, Alim Anvar, Santhosh K, Pradeep Sehrawat.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Manmohan, J.
1. Present Appeals have been filed challenging the common impugned judgment and final order dated 18 th March, 2024 passed by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in W.A. No. 2213 of 2023, W.A. No. 2206 of 2023 and W.A. No. 66 of 2024, whereby the Division Bench of the High Court dismissed the writ appeals filed by the Appellants herein and affirmed the judgment and order passed by the learned Single Judge allowing the writ petition filed by the private Respondents [original writ petitioners in WP(C) 5277/2023].
ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF APPELLANTS
2. Mr. Nikhil Goel, learned senior counsel for the Appellants stated that the present appeals have been filed on behalf of six employees of the Kerala Water Authority who were inducted as Draftsmen-Grade-I. He pointed out that four of these Appellants had joined on various dates in the year 2005, while one had joined in the year 2001 and the sixth Appellant had joined on 13 th February, 2014. He stated that 792 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports the present set of Appellants were promoted to the post of Assistant Engineers on various dates between 2015-16, except the sixth Appellant, who was promoted on 22 nd September, 2018.
3. He stated that the two private Respondents – Mr. Anoop VS had joined service directly as an Assistant Engineer on 08th May, 2017, while Ms. Bindu S had joined service on 02 nd March, 2005 as an Assistant Engineer, but availed leave without pay during her probation period and rejoined only on 18 th October, 2015.
4. He stated that the present dispute arises out of the seniority lists dated 20th April, 2022 and 14th February, 2023 whereby the Appellants were shown to be senior to the Respondents.
5. He stated that the learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition no. 5277/2023 filed by Mr. Anoop VS and Ms. Bindu S (the private Respondents) relying on an erroneous interpretation of the Kerala Public Health Engineering Service Special Rules, 1960 (hereinafter the ‘Special Rules, 1960’) which, according to the Appellants, do not apply up to the stage of promotion or appointment to the post of Assistant Engineer. He submitted that appointment to the post of Assistant Engineer is solely governed by a separate set of Rules called the Kerala Public Health Engineering Subordinate Service Rules, 1966 (hereinafter the ‘Subordinate Service Rules, 1966’). He submitted that the Special Rules, 1960 require employees to exercise an option, i.e. for their further promotions, whether they want to be included in the ‘degree quota’ or the ‘diploma quota’. According to him, the fundamental error in the impugned order was that this requirement was read into the Subordinate Service Rules, 1966 as well, despite a similar provision not being present in the 1966 Rules. He contended that employment in Kerala Water Authority is governed by two different sets of Rules.
6. He further stated that in accordance with the Subordinate Service Rules, 1966, an Assistant Engineer could either be appointed through direct recruitment or promoted from the post of a Draftsman in a 60:40 ratio. According to him, out of the 60% (sixty per cent) quota for direct recruitment, 6% (six per cent) had been carved out for in-service Draftsmen with an engineering degree. Further, the educational requirement for 40% (forty per cent) promotion quota was set out in the Schedule, according to which an employee must possess a diploma. Pertinently, for a Draftsman holding an [2025] 3 S.C.R. 793Sajithabai and Ors. v. The Kerala Water Authority and Ors. engineering degree, there was no requirement of giving an option as to the category in which the appointment as Assistant Engineer was sought – the 6% (six per cent) in-service direct recruitment or the 40% (forty per cent) promotion.
7. He stated that insofar as the Appellants were concerned, it was not in dispute that they all had obtained an engineering degree much prior to their promotion as an Assistant Engineer. However, the Appellants had also applied for direct recruitment in the 6% (six per cent) in-service quota and despite being included in its Select List, the Appellants had declined their appointments as they had already been appointed in the 40% (forty per cent) promotional category before the declaration of results of the recruitment exam in the 6% (six per cent) quota.
8. Mr. Nikhil Goel, learned senior counsel stated that the Appellants having been promoted were governed for their future promotions to the post of Assistant Executive Engineer by the Special Rules, 1960. He emphasised that what applied to the Appellants or any other candidate seeking promotion to Assistant Executive Engineer was Rule 4(b) of the Special Rules, 1960. Since he laid special emphasis on Rule 4(b) and its proviso, the same are reproduced hereinbelow: - “4……
(b) [Vacancies in the category of Assistant Engineers shall be filled up from among those in categories 1 or 2 in the Kerala Public Health Engineering Subordinate Service in the ratio of 4:1 between—]
(1) Persons possessing any of the qualifications mentioned in item (i) or in Section A in item (ii)
of the Annexure, and
(2) Those possessing any of the qualifications mentioned in Section B in item (ii) of the Annexure or those possessing the S.M.T.
Overseers certificate, every 5th vacancy being allotted to the latter and the rest to the former.
A person who while holding [any of the posts in categories 1 and 2 of the Kerala Public Health Engineering Subordinate Service] passes Sections A and B of the A.M.I.E. (India) Examination shall be eligible for promotion as Assistant 794 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Engineer against the quota allotted for those possessing the qualifications mentioned in item (i) or Section A in item
(ii) of the Annexure only after the claims of all those who, on the date of his passing the A.M.I.E. (India) Examination, possessed the qualifications mentioned in item (i) of the Annexure have been considered:
Provided that it will be left to the option of such persons to continue among [those] possessing the qualifications mentioned in Section B in item (ii) of the Annexure and claim promotion against the quota allotted to them.”
9. He submitted that the aforesaid proviso would apply only once the Appellants were seeking promotion to the post of Assistant Executive Engineer. He stated that the method by which the Appellants became Assistant Engineer was not covered by this proviso. He pointed out that it was on this basis that the seniority list had been correctly drawn up by the Respondent authority.
10. He submitted that the learned Single Judge while deciding the challenge to the seniority list had held that there was a requirement of giving an option between the Direct Recruitment Quota (degree quota) and the Promotion Quota (diploma quota) even for the purpose of Subordinate Service Rules, 1966. According to him, this was the solitary finding based on which the writ petition of the private Respondents had been allowed.
11. He submitted that the learned Division Bench in the impugned order had added one more reason while upholding the judgment of the learned Single Judge, i.e. the Special Rules, 1960 did not permit switching by a person who had obtained appointment as an Assistant Engineer under the diploma quota to that of degree quota.
ARGUMENTS ON BEHALF OF PRIVATE RESPONDENTS
12. Per contra, Mr. V. Chitambaresh, learned senior counsel for the private respondents stated that the Appellants herein declined the offer of appointment in the 6% (six per cent) degree qualified draftsmen earmarked for in service candidates though they were included in the ranked list. He emphasised that the Appellants chose to get promoted from the category of Draftsmen as diploma holders (promotion quota). He submitted that the Appellants who were [2025] 3 S.C.R. 795Sajithabai and Ors. v. The Kerala Water Authority and Ors. appointed in the diploma quota could not thereafter switch over to the degree quota for further promotion.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.