Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 299; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 377
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 3 Judges: Justice Surya Kant, Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Ujjal Bhuyan
- Decided
- 2 Mar 2025
- Case number
- CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1037/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 377 : 2025 INSC 299 Sharmila Velamur v.
V. Sanjay and Ors.
(Criminal Appeal No. 1037 of 2025)
03 March 2025 [Surya Kant,* Dipankar Datta and Ujjal Bhuyan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether ‘A’ having severe cognitive limitations is capable of making independent decisions; whether best interests and welfare of ‘A’, a US citizen would be served by permitting him to continue residing with Respondent No.4-father in India.
Headnotes† Child and family welfare – Custody matter – Appellant-mother and respondent no. 4-father are US citizens, divorced in US – Appellant was granted permanent legal guardianship of their elder son ‘A’ who suffers from Ataxic Cerebral Palsy, by the US Court – However, while the guardianship proceedings were pending, the Respondent No.4 brought A to India without informing the Appellant – She filed writ of habeas corpus in High Court alleging illegal detention of A – High Court very briefly interacted with A and held that he was consensually living with Respondent No.4 in India, dismissed the petition – Supreme Court doubting the child's capacity to make independent decisions, ordered a medical assessment at NIMHANS, Bengaluru:
Held: NIMHANS, Bengaluru in its Comprehensive Assessment Report held that owing to ‘A’ cognitive and physical limitations, he does not possess the capacity to make well-informed, independent decisions, for his own benefit, on complex subject matter, such as long-term residence – This is also concurred by the report of the Evaluation Committee constituted by the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare (West Hub Developmental Disabilities Program) – Thus, as ‘A’ was assessed to possess the cognitive abilities of an 8 to 10-year-old child, the reasoning assigned by the High Court, * Author 378 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of him consenually living in India is seriously erroneous – ‘A’ cannot make independent, legally-binding decisions on his own – High Court erred in coming to a finding on ‘A’s alleged illegal detention solely based on his perceived ‘independent’ decision to reside in India with Respondent No. 4 – Impugned judgment set aside – ‘A’ to be under the sole custody of the Appellant – Further directions issued. [Paras 21, 23, 41] Expert Opinion – Expert’s report to be given due credence unless strong reasons to disbelieve it – Parties are US citizens, divorced in US – Appellant-mother was granted permanent legal guardianship of their elder son ‘A’ (22 years old) with severe cognitive limitations – Appellant filed writ of habeas corpus in High Court alleging his illegal detention by the Respondent No.4-father – High Court very briefly interacted with ‘A’ and held that he was consensually living with his father in India, dismissed the petition – It did not consider the report of the Evaluation Committee constituted by the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare (West Hub Developmental Disabilities Program) consisting of a Psychologist, a Physician and a Social Worker, to decide whether ‘A’ was living consensually in India:
Held: Even though Courts are well within their rights to come to a finding distinct from an expert’s report, the expert’s opinion cannot be discarded, as a whole without any reason – The dispute before the High Court concerned the sensitive and complex issue of alleged illegal detention of a person with severe cognitive limitations, it ought to have considered and given due credence to the Evaluation Committee’s report which had held that ‘A’ does not possess the capacity to make well-informed, independent decisions, for his own benefit, on complex subject matter, such as long-term residence – If the High Court had any doubt as to the reliability of the report and its conclusions, it ought to have ordered an enquiry through a reputable medical institution – Dismissing all aspects of scientific assessment in a highly specialized and niche area of medicine was misconceived and ill-founded – In the event there is any confusion or doubt regarding a person’s capacity and ability to make independent decisions and if there is a definitive opinion on disability endorsed by a specialist, domain expert, or a doctor, the Court should give due credence to that opinion – If [2025] 3 S.C.R. 379Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. the expert’s report concludes that the mental or physical age of the person concerned is well below the age of majority, there can be no inference of any ‘implied’ or ‘express’ consent to any act which might have a substantive impact on the consenting person – Unless there are strong reasons to disbelieve an expert’s report to this effect, the Courts must be overly-cautious in coming to a finding contrary thereto. [Paras 20, 22] Child and family welfare – Custody matters – Child’s best interest and welfare – Determination – Doctrine of parens patriae – Parties are US citizens – Issue of custody of their elder son ‘A’ suffering from Ataxic Cerebral Palsy – Whether A’s best interests and welfare would be served by permitting him to continue residing with Respondent No.4-father in India: Held: ‘A’, his parents and his younger brother, have resided in the US for two decades and are all US citizens – Having been born and brought up in the US, they are accustomed to the culture, the activities, the language and the schooling there – They know no other way of life and have their roots in the US – Regardless of these commonalities, the brothers share certain unique characteristics which helps them understand, relate to, and lean on each other – Also, A has completed most of his schooling in the US; he has access to long-term specialized welfare services and curriculums; he has a peer group; an established routine; and places to regularly attend for socialization – He is familiar with the language and lifestyle in the US – Also, ‘A’ desires to be in the company of his younger brother, from whom he has been separated for far too long – It cannot be said that ‘A’ has given up his roots in the US and has developed new roots in India, due to which he should not be displaced – In the facts and surrounding circumstances, it is in A’s best interests and welfare to return to the US, where he can complete his schooling and reside with his younger brother, under the appellant’s guardianship. [Paras 35, 38, 39] Child and family welfare – Custody of child – Best interest of child – Comity of courts – Principle of:
Held: The principle of comity of courts and a pre-existing order of a Foreign Court must yield to the best interests of the child, especially when the Court has decided to conduct an elaborate 380 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports enquiry in this regard – Court to take into account all the attending circumstances and the totality of the situation to consider the interests of the child. [Paras 31, 32] Case Law Cited Girish v. Radhamony K. (2009) 16 SCC 360; Suchita Srivastava v. Chandigarh Admn. [2009] 13 SCR 989 : (2009) 9 SCC 1 – distinguished.
Shafin Jahan v. Asokan K.M. [2018] 4 SCR 955 : (2018) 16 SCC 368; Sheoli Hati v. Somnath Das [2019] 9 SCR 212 : (2019) 7 SCC 490; Vivek Singh v. Romani Singh [2017] 2 SCR 312 : (2017) 3 SCC 231; Nithya Anand Raghavan v. State (NCT of Delhi) [2017] 7 SCR 281 : (2017) 8 SCC 454; Elizabeth Dinshaw v. Arvand M. Dinshaw [1987] 1 SCR 175 : (1987) 1 SCC 42; Dhanwanti Joshi v. Madhav Unde [1997] Supp. 5 SCR 30 : (1998) 1 SCC 112; Rohith Thammana Gowda v. State of Karnataka [2022] 4 SCR 784 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 937; V. Ravi Chandran (Dr.) (2) v. Union of India [2009] 13 SCR 1022 : (2010) 1 SCC 174; Gaurav Nagpal v. Sumedha Nagpal [2008] 16 SCR 396 : (2009) 1 SCC 42 – referred to.
List of Keywords Custody; US citizens; Ataxic cerebral palsy; Severe cognitive limitations; Cognitive abilities of an 8 to 10-year-old child; Capacity to make independent decisions; Independent, legally-binding decisions; Alleged illegal detention; Habeas corpus; Best interest and welfare of the child; Permanent legal guardianship; Principle of comity of courts; Expert opinion/report; NIMHANS Bengaluru; Evaluation Committee; Joint custody; Cognitive capacity; Doctrine of parens patriae; Guardianship; Severe disability; Autism spectrum disorder. Case Arising From Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction/Inherent Jurisdiction: Criminal Appeal No. 1037 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 09.08.2024 of the High Court of Judicature at Madras in HCP No. 886 of 2024 With Contempt Petition (C) No. 9 of 2025 [2025] 3 S.C.R. 381Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellant:
Ms. V. Mohana, Sr. Adv., Ashim Sood, Mayank Pandey, Anish Gopi, Velpula Audityaa, Ms. Bhavya Pandey, Ekansh Gupta, Ashish Kumar Pandey, Nirmal Prasad, Ribhav Pande, Arun.
Advs. for the Respondents:
Ms. Liz Mathew, Sr. Adv., Aakash Nandolia, Sabarish Subramanian, Lzafeer Ahmad B. F., Sachin Dubey, Dheeraj Nair, Akhil Anand, Ms. Ridhima Sharma.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Surya Kant, J.
Leave granted.
2. The controversy in this case revolves around the custody of Aadith Ramadorai, a twenty-two-year-old citizen of the United States of America (US) who has been diagnosed with Ataxic Cerebral Palsy. This tussle for custody has been elicited by Aadith Ramadorai’s parents—the Appellant and Respondent No. 4—both of whom are also US citizens.
A. Facts
3. It is necessary to understand the factual milieu surrounding the dispute before delving into the consequential legal issues. 3.1 To clarify the relationship between the parties, as previously elucidated, the Appellant and Respondent No. 4 are Aadith Ramadorai’s mother and father, respectively. Respondent No. 1 is the Appellant’s brother, whereas Respondent Nos. 5 and 6 are Respondent No. 4’s parents.
3.2 The Appellant and Respondent No. 4 got married in Chennai, India on 09.07.2001, as per Hindu rites and customs.
Subsequently, they began residing together in Idaho, US and acquired US citizenship in due course of time. They had two sons—Aadith Ramadorai (Aadith), who was born on 06.06.2003, 382 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports and Arjun Ramadorai (Arjun), who was born on 13.03.2005— from the wedlock. Both the children are US citizens by virtue of their birth and their parents’ citizenship. These children were born with intellectual and developmental disabilities. Aadith has Ataxic Cerebral Palsy, while Arjun has Autism Spectrum Disorder. 3.3 During their marriage, certain irreconcilable differences arose between the Appellant and Respondent No. 4, prompting them to dissolve their marriage by mutual consent through an order dated 12.09.2007, passed by the District Court of the Fourth Judicial District, State of Idaho, US (Idaho Court). While dissolving the marriage, the Idaho Court awarded joint legal and physical custody of the sons, as they were minors at the time. The Idaho Court established the terms of joint custody as follows: (i) Respondent No. 4 would have physical custody of the sons every week from 8:00 am on Friday to 8:00 am on Monday; and (ii) the Appellant would have physical custody of the sons every week from 8:00 am on Monday to 8:00 am on Friday. The Idaho Court divided all holidays equally amongst the parents and further directed them to not disparage each other in the midst of their sons, teachers, care providers, and medical providers. Additionally, neither party was directed to pay child support to the other. Lastly, in furtherance of these directions, the Idaho Court vide Clause 13 of the Supplemental Custody Order expounded that, “Neither parent shall move the children’s residence to a place which will make the ordered custody and visitation schedule impractical or significantly more difficult or expensive without prior written consent of the other parent or an order of the court.”
3.4 Thereafter, in June 2022, following a visit in terms of the Idaho Court’s custody arrangement, Respondent No. 4 brought Arjun back to the Appellant’s home, whereas Aadith continued to reside with Respondent No. 4. It is pertinent to note that by this time, Aadith had already attained majority. This led the Appellant to file a Guardianship Application before the Idaho Court on 30.06.2022, seeking full and permanent legal guardianship over Aadith. In response thereto, Respondent No. 4 filed a Counter-Petition before the Idaho Court on 17.01.2023, contending that Aadith was sufficiently capable and did not require a permanent guardian. [2025] 3 S.C.R. 383Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. 3.5 In due course, during a preliminary hearing on 04.01.2023 before the Idaho Court, the parties’ attorneys laid down mutual terms for them to adhere to until the conclusion of the proceedings. These terms included: (i) meeting with the Health and Welfare Committee within 45 days; (ii) sharing Aadith’s address, phone number, and email address with the Appellant;
(iii) allowing regular in-person contact between the Appellant and Aadith, subject to his comfort level; and (iv) providing advance notice and written itineraries for any foreign travel arrangements involving Aadith, which would be discussed by the parents jointly.
3.6 As per the terms mentioned above, the Appellant and Aadith were scheduled to be interviewed on 17.05.2023 by the Evaluation Committee of the Idaho Department of Health and Welfare (West Hub Developmental Disabilities Program) (Evaluation Committee). The Evaluation Committee’s findings revealed that Respondent No. 4 and Aadith refused to attend the interview/ meeting. A report based on the Evaluation Committee’s findings was sent to the parties and the authorities. Soon after, Respondent No. 4 brought Aadith for his in-person interview with the Evaluation Committee. Accordingly, an addendum dated 25.10.2023 was issued, marking their presence, and concluding that Aadith required guardianship.
3.7 In the interregnum, mediation sessions were scheduled to be held between the parties. However, during this period, the Appellant discovered that Respondent No. 4 and Aadith had left the US to visit Respondent Nos. 5 and 6 in Chennai, India. This rendered the Appellant entirely unaware of their travel and return itinerary. Therefore, she was unable to maintain regular contact with her son.
3.8 While these developments were materialising, parallelly, the Idaho Court appointed the Appellant as Aadith’s temporary guardian on 10.01.2024. Against this backdrop, investigations conducted by the US Federal Authorities and the Idaho District Authorities revealed that during the pendency of the proceedings, Respondent No. 4 obtained Aadith’s passport and left the US on 31.12.2023. On arriving in India, they began residing in Chennai with Respondent Nos. 5 and 6.
384 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 3.9 By virtue of this, the Appellant, on 31.01.2024, filed an online police complaint with Respondent No. 2. She then authorized her brother, Respondent No. 1, to act on her behalf to retrieve custody of Aadith. Thereupon, on 05.02.2024, the Appellant lodged a complaint with the NRI Cell in Chennai. In furtherance thereto, the Police Authorities in Chennai were able to retrieve Aadith’s passport number, along with the last known address and contact details of Respondent Nos. 5 and 6. However, Aadith and Respondent Nos. 4 to 6 remained untraceable. 3.10 Concurrently, in the guardianship proceedings pending before the Idaho Court, an Emergency Order came to be passed on 22.02.2024, directing Aadith to return to Boise, Idaho within 72 hours. When this direction was not followed, the Idaho Court proceeded to decide the Guardianship Application in favour of the Appellant, consequently appointing her as Aadith’s full and permanent guardian on 09.04.2024. This order was passed after duly hearing parties’ testimonies; and after reviewing the report dated 17.05.2023 and addendum dated 25.10.2023 issued by the Evaluation Committee.
3.11 Despite the decree passed by the Idaho Court, Aadith’s whereabouts remained unknown to the Appellant. This prompted the Appellant to file H.C.P. No. 886/2024 before the High Court of Judicature at Madras (High Court) through Respondent No. 1, inter alia praying for the issuance of a Writ of Habeas Corpus directing Respondent Nos. 2 and 3 to retrieve custody of Aadith from Respondent Nos. 4 to 6 and to handover his person to Respondent No. 1.
3.12 During the proceedings, the High Court interacted with Aadith and posed multiple questions to him. Based on the answers tendered, the High Court, vide its judgment dated 09.08.2024, primarily determined that there was no illegal detention because:
(i) Aadith was capable of understanding the questions posed by the High Court; and (ii) He was happy and willing to reside in Chennai with his father and his paternal grandparents (Impugned Judgement). On 09.09.2024, the US Consulate General, Chennai revoked Aadith’s passport.
3.13 Thus, aggrieved by the High Court’s decision, the Appellant preferred the instant appeal.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 385Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. 3.14 This Court, in the course of this appeal, passed the order dated 16.12.2024, issuing certain interim directions: (i) Respondent No. 4 was directed to facilitate video calls between the Appellant and Aadith in the evening between 7:00 pm and 9:00 pm IST. The call duration was to be for a maximum of 30 minutes; (ii) Upon the Appellant’s arrival in India, Respondent No. 4 was directed to handover temporary custody of Aadith to her; (iii) While Aadith was under the temporary custody of the Appellant, she and Respondent No. 4 would ensure that he gets his medical treatment regularly and preferably, in adherence with the recommendations of specialists in the US; (iv) Respondent No. 4 was permitted to contact Aadith daily while he was under the temporary custody of the Appellant; and (v) The Appellant and Respondent No. 4 were directed to consult the best doctors in Chennai for continued treatment of Aadith.
3.15 In the meantime, Aadith, in a purported exercise of his own free will, filed two interlocutory applications in the instant appeal. They are I.A. No. 301117/2024 and I.A. No. 301051/2024, seeking to be impleaded in the matter and seeking directions to keep the order dated 16.12.2024 in abeyance till 07.01.2025, respectively. These applications were accompanied by signed affidavits, stating that Aadith was fully conversant with the facts and circumstances of the case and that the applications had been prepared in consonance with his instructions.
3.16 Simultaneously, being dissatisfied by Respondent No. 4’s noncompliance with the order dated 16.12.2024, the Appellant preferred the captioned Contempt Petition. She sought to allege that despite the clear instructions enumerated in the order dated 16.12.2024, the Appellant was not allowed to interact with Aadith on video call. Further, upon her arrival in Chennai, Respondent No. 4 refused to hand over temporary custody of Aadith. In fact, he ceased all communication with her. When the Appellant arrived at their flat on 24.12.2024, she was permitted to interact with Aadith for roughly 30 minutes, forcing her to cut short her time with her son and leave the flat without obtaining temporary custody of Aadith.
3.17 Respondent No. 4 brought Aadith for medical assessment to the Institute of Mental Health, Kilpauk in Chennai on 25.11.2024. 386 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports On Respondent No. 4’s request, Aadith was examined and an Observation Report was prepared, which recorded as follows: “Mr. Aadith Rajson Ramadorai 21 years, male was registered in the Institute of Mental Health, Chennai – 10 on 25.11.2024. He was subsequently examined on 29.11.2024, 02.12.2024 and 09.12.2024 at his request and the request of his father.
Detailed history was obtained from his father.
Physical examination, mental status examination and psychological assessment were done. He has a history of developmental delay since childhood.
On psychometry, he has an Intelligence quotient (IQ) of 54, which is suggestive of mild intellectual disability (50% disability).
He is able to do simple work on instructions. He is able to travel to familiar places alone. He is capable of living with the assistance of his family members.
He will require support for making major decisions in life like property management.”
3.18 Subsequently, this Court, vide order dated 08.01.2025, directed that Aadith will reside with his younger brother, Arjun, and the Appellant in Bengaluru, during the pendency of these proceedings. Respondent No. 4 was permitted to visit and interact with his sons for 3 hours every day. Further, the Appellant and Respondent No. 4 were directed to take the sons for medical assessment to the National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences (NIMHANS), Bengaluru, arguably one of the best institutes in the country. The doctors at NIMHANS, Bengaluru were requested to give their expert opinion as to whether Aadith is in a position to make independent decisions. The report so prepared was ordered to be submitted before this Court in a sealed cover.
3.19 It seems that the parties substantially complied with the order dated 08.01.2025, particularly the directions concerning custody, as Aadith has been residing with his younger brother and the Appellant in Bengaluru ever since. In continued compliance with the above order, Aadith and his brother were brought to [2025] 3 S.C.R. 387Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. NIMHANS, Bengaluru on 13.01.2025 by their parents. They were duly admitted as in-patients on 14.01.2025.
3.20 From 17.01.2025 to 29.01.2025, Aadith was examined by the Department of Clinical Psychology at NIMHANS, Bengaluru. He was administered 7 tests namely, the Vineland Social Maturity Scale (VSMS), the Vineland Adaptive Behaviour Skills – 3 (VABS), the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale – IV India Edition, the Binet Kamat Test of Intelligence (BKT), the Comprehension Subtest from Malin’s Intelligence Scale for Indian Children (MISIC), the Theory of Mind/False Belief Tests (Anne and Sally Test; Matchbox Test), and the Delayed Discounting Task. The test findings are reproduced below:
“SOCIAL AND DAILY ADAPTIVE FUNCTIONS Vineland Social Maturity Scale (VSMS)
The VSMS was administered to assess his socioadaptive functioning. The patient’s social age was found to be 7 years, which corresponds to an SQ of 47, which suggests Moderate level of disability in current socio-adaptive functioning, corresponding to 75% disability. As Mr. Aadith has motor disabilities and that would have affected his overall VSMS score, an attempt was made to adjust the score by removing the scores related to motor components from VSMS. This showed his score as 53 (Impairment-adjusted SQ); which indicated Moderate disability in socio-adaptive functioning according to the VSMS score classification of revised Gazette of India notification. However, the gazette notification was mainly for intact VSMS score (i.e. not for Impairment-adjusted SQ). Hence, the interpretation of Impairment-Adjusted SQ to be done with caution.
It should be noted that VSMS is standardized in India several decades ago and might not adequately reflect his current level of socio-adaptive functioning, for mainly 2 reasons. One the patient is born and brought up in the US, and that the standardization was done long time ago. However, the limitations 388 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports if has an influence would have caused their score to inflate, rather than bring down. Despite these limitations, his scores still showed that he has Moderate level of disability in social and adaptive functioning.
Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale – 3 (VABS – 3)
– Comprehensive Form The VABS-3 test was administered to assess his adaptive behavior. The patient obtained a standard score of 38 on the Communication domain, and 47 on the domain of Daily Living Skills, both suggestive of deficits of ‘Moderately low’ level in these domains. His ability on the domain of socialization showed significant disability as well as a sub-domain scatter, where his coping skills related to social domain was significantly lower compared to the other domains of socialization such as interpersonal relationships, play and leisure. He obtained a total sum of domain standard scores of 100 corresponding to an Adaptive Behavior Composite (ABC) of 34, suggestive of ‘Low’ level of Adaptive Behavior on the current assessment.
INTELLIGENCE TESTS:
Binet Kamat Test of Intelligence (BKT)
On BKT, the patient’s basal age and terminal age were found to be 6 years and 14 years respectively.
His prorated mental age obtained is 10 years. His prorated intelligence quotient (IQ) is 63, indicating Mild level of disability in intellectual functioning. Similar to VSMS, BKT has been standardized in Indian Population, several decades ago and intelligence value obtained is through ratio method. Considering this, the obtained IQ can be said as an inflated value, given that Mr. Aadith has been born and bought up in USA. Despite this, he has obtained a prorated IQ of 63, which is in the Mild Intellectual Disability range.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 389Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale IVINDIA Edition
(WAIS-4 INDIA )
On WAIS-4 INDIA , his Verbal Comprehension Index Score was calculated to be 75. The perceptual Reasoning Index was 53, the Working Memory Index (WMI) was calculated to be 47, and the Processing Speed Index was 45. This yields a full-scale IQ (FSIQ) of 53. This score falls in the range of Mild Intellectual Disability. WAIS-4 INDIA as the name implies is standardized for Indian population.
However, given the norms differences between Indian and US population, the obtained scores by Mr. Aadith if referred to Indian norms will yield a higher score, compared to US norms. It should be noted that despite this, his score is in the Mild Intellectual Disability range.
Malin’s Intelligence Scale for Indian Children (MISIC) – Comprehension Subtest On the MISIC subtest of Comprehension, the patient obtained a raw score of 05, corresponding to a test quotient of 62, indicating Mild levels of disability in comprehension. Again, relatively similar to in VSMS and WAIS-4 INDIA , the MISIC is for children up to the age of 16 years and the norms are for Indian children. Despite this his score is in the disability range.
PERSPECTIVE TAKING and DECISION MAKING:
Theory of Mind/False-Belief Tests Theory of mind was tested using Anne and Sally test False-Belief – Matchbox test.
The patient performed poorly on both Anne and Sally and Matchbox tests, where he could not attribute mental states (beliefs, intents) to others. That is, on test, he spontaneously, did not view that the others have their own thoughts/beliefs independent of himself.
390 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Delay Discounting Task:
Delay Discounting Task primarily assesses decision making and impulsivity. In this task Mr. Aadith performed poorly in the second trail itself, where he preferred significantly smaller reward – immediately, forgoing significantly larger reward – at a delay of one month. For example, when presented with the patient a hypothetical scenario of choosing between 10 INR now or 100 INR after a month, he said 100 INR after a month. However, with the follow-up questions of choosing 20 INR now or 100 INR after a month, he answered 20 INR now.
He could not answer the subsequent questions and had difficulty understanding the value of money.
COMMENTS ABOUT INDEPENDENT DECISION
MAKING:
• Decision Making for Daily Living Activities:
As observed on VABS-3 and VSMS, the patient is capable of carrying out basic daily activities, such as brushing his teeth with an electric toothbrush, adjusting water to the appropriate temperature for bathing, and selecting suitable clothing based on the weather. He can also spread sauces or jam using a table knife, change clothes with large buttons, put on shoes without laces, and use certain kitchen appliances, such as bread toaster and a microwave oven, under supervision.
However, he struggles with independent self-care when left alone and has difficulty performing more complex tasks. He faces challenges using a manual toothbrush, handling a knife to cut fruits, and independently seeking medical attention as needed. Additionally, he would have difficulty operating household appliances safely, such as a vacuum cleaner, iron, or power tools.
While he is able to tell time using the digital watch, he struggles with reading an analog clock. Furthermore, [2025] 3 S.C.R. 391Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. he has difficulty exercising discretion and judgment in higher-level activities, such as traveling alone to unfamiliar places or setting and achieving long-term goals that require planning over two years or more.
Impression: Independent Decision-making ability is adequate for basic activities but inadequate for higher-level activities.
• Decision Making for Financial Safety:
When asked to make payments or explicit purchases, the patient shows responsibility with a small amount of money. He is careful about this and uses it as directed. However, he has not able to make independent decisions with regard to monetary aspects in relatively higher values.
He has also been observed to have difficulty differentiating currency values and providing the correct change. When asked which currency had a higher value, 100 INR or 500 INR, he chose 100 INR.
The same error was observed when questioned about US currency. Additionally, he struggled with basic mathematics, such as addition and subtraction.
For instance, when given a scenario where 50 INR was spent on ice cream, and 100 INR was handed to the shopkeeper, he could not determine the correct return amount. He also had difficulties performing similar other simple, mental calculations of verbal in nature, involving two-digit numbers about subtraction, multiplication, and division.
Financial safety and related aspects were to have significant deficits.
Impression: He cannot make independent decision in financial aspects.
• Decision Making for Socialization:
On VABS-3, it was observed that the patient can recognize emotions and express his feelings through 392 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports words. He shares toys and possessions voluntarily without being prompted and takes turns naturally while playing games or sports. Additionally, he can join a group when verbal and nonverbal cues indicate he is welcome and adjusts his behaviour to avoid disturbing others nearby.
However, he struggles with playing complex games that involve rules and has difficulty imitating intricate actions hours after observing them, such as shaving, vacuuming, or hammering nails. He also faces challenges in modulating his speech appropriately in terms of loudness, speed, and excitement to match the conversation. Engaging in discussions on topics that do not interest him is difficult, as is initiating conversations by discussing subjects relevant to others. He also struggles to pick up on indirect cues or hints in conversations and has difficulty providing additional explanations to ensure his message is understood.
Furthermore, he would have difficulty planning activities that require coordinating multiple elements, such as organizing a birthday party or a group outing. He also lacks the ability to navigate social situations safely, such as going out with peers in the evening without supervision, social media, and identifying harmful relationships or situations. This includes difficulty avoiding or exiting situations where he might be bullied, coerced into illegal activities, or taken advantage of sexually or financially.
Impression: Independent decision making in simple social and close group/family/home aspects is adequate, but anything beyond is inadequate.
• Decision Making for Occupation:
It was observed that the patient can sometimes complete routine household tasks when instructed, [2025] 3 S.C.R. 393Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. use basic tools or utensils, and draw simple shapes and objects with pencils or crayons.
However, he would have difficulty engaging in small remunerative work, such as making simple garments, performing minor repairs, taking the initiative in occasional tasks like housework, or assisting in child care. Additionally, he would struggle with creative activities, including making useful items, raising pets, writing simple stories or poems, or creating basic paintings.
He also faces challenges in performing responsible routine chores appropriate for his age, such as assisting with household tasks, caring for a garden, cleaning a car, washing windows, setting the table, or fetching water. Furthermore, as observed on VABS-3, he would have difficulty maintaining a job for at least one year, even if it required only 10 hours of work per week.
Impression: Decision-making in very basic occupational skills is adequate and beyond that it is inadequate.
OVERALL IMPRESSION:
Considering his intellectual disability, which is at the Mild disability level, and all the other findings mentioned above as well as considering his spontaneous verbalizations mentioned above; we are of the opinion that Mr. Aadith is functioning at the level of about 8 to 10 years old child in general. Given this, any complex decisions that exceeds the capacity of an 8-to 10-year-old, he would not be able to make informed decisions by himself; and even if he makes, those decisions would be made without considering all the options and repercussions that come with decision making.”
3.21 During his stay at NIMHANS, Bengaluru, on 22.01.2025, the Department of Speech Pathology and Audiology assessed 394 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Aadith’s speaking abilities. Their findings, as enumerated in the handwritten report, are as follows:
“Phonology:
• Omission of [‘l’] in initial, medial, and final position. • Substitution of [‘l’] with [‘r’] in initial, medial, and final position.
• Substitution of [‘t’] with [‘s’] in initial, medial, and final position.
Morphosyntax:
• He uses simple, compound sentence structure in sentences and in conversation.
• He consistently uses morphological markers such as bound morpheme, inflectional morpheme, free morphemes.
• He uses suffix, prefix to change tense.
• He uses singular and plurals in sentences and in conversation.
• He compares and contrasts.
• He uses verbs to nouns in conversation and sentences.
• He uses adjectives to describe objects.
• He uses negations in the form of ‘No’.
• He can formulate questions (what, who, where).
• He uses conjunction in conversations, sentences.
• He produces errors in free sentences.
• He uses time formation such as past tense, future tense.
• He uses singular possessions and plural possessions in conversation and in sentences.
• He uses adverbs (here, there).
• He uses affixes (ing format to describe).
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 395Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. Semantics:
• He understands abstract words.
• He understands meaning of words based on context and interprets multiple meanings.
• He understands idiomatic expression.
• He understands sentence structure to interpret.
• He can understand simple meaning from a story but has difficulty in understanding complex meanings.
• He can understand jokes and reacts to it.
• He has difficulty in understanding figurative language.
• He has difficulty in understanding inference from a complex scenario when given.
• He had difficulty in understanding complex false beliefs and assumptions.
• He has difficulty in understanding complex synonyms, antonyms.
• He can answer to simple ‘wh’ questions but has difficulty in answering complex ‘wh’ questions.
Intelligibility: AYJNIHH rating scale level 02.
Impression: Inadequate speech and language and developmental dysarthria 2° IDD & CP.
Advice:
• Speech and language intervention.
• Attend DT session in department.
• Counselling.
• Follow up during next visit to NIMHANS on Mon/ Tue/Wed/Fri @ 8:30 am.”
3.22 On 03.02.2025, the Department of Clinical Psychology administered the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) to Aadith, 396 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports to assess his understanding of interpersonal relationships. The findings of this test are reproduced below:
“Behavioural Observations:
The patient came to the interview willingly. His attention could be aroused and sustained. Patient was cooperative and interested in the testing throughout the session. He was able to comprehend the instructions adequately.
Summary of Test Findings:
The patient’s stories were reasonably imaginative content. Although he described what was given in the pictures he was able to attribute thoughts and feelings to the characters. The predominant theme that emerged from the stories was one of a family unit enjoying various activities together such as eating, going for a hike, planning a feast in others’ home or inviting guests over. The stories also indicated how one has to learn and behave during various interpersonal conflicts. He showed good problem solving skills such as adequate communication with others during conflicts, rethinking one’s actions and consequences.”
3.23 Thereafter, on 05.02.2025, the Department of Psychiatric Social Work prepared the Psychosocial Assessment Report after studying parameters such as Aadith’s living arrangements throughout the years, his education, training, occupation, and future plans. Further, exhaustive interviews were conducted with the Appellant and Respondent No. 4, individually, to determine their perspectives on parenting, expectations from Aadith, plans for his future, and opinions about the other parent. The findings are extracted as follows:
“Upbringing and living arrangements: From birth to 2 years of age, the client lived with his parents in Boise City, Idaho, U.S., till their separation in 2005. From 2005 to 2007, as per the temporary orders by the Idaho court, the client and his younger brother [2025] 3 S.C.R. 397Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. stayed with their father for one whole week in a month, while the remaining 3 weeks were spent with their mother. After the parents’ divorce in 2007, the living arrangement changed; the children would stay with their mother from Monday to Thursday, and their father from Friday to Sunday, and both houses were 5 to 7 miles apart. The vacations were equally spent with both parents separately, taking into consideration the father’s nature of the job. This practice continued till 2017-2018, after which the mother requested an alternative week arrangement and thus, from 2018 to 2021, the client and his younger brother stayed with each parent on alternate weeks of the month.
During their stay with the father, he took care of all the needs of the children by himself including supervision, feeding and self-care, while the mother had assistance with the same. The mother reported that both children were cared for by the father, and she didn’t notice any behavioural changes in the client during their stay with the father. Up to 2019, both parents had equal joint custody, physical and legal custody of the client. In 2019, Idaho court granted the mother the legal custody of both children while both parents shared the physical custody till 2021 when the client became an adult.
The client and his younger brother stayed with their mother from 202l to 2022, when the father returned to India to care for his parents, which the mother was also aware of. The father came back to the U.S. in 2022 to meet the client and his brother; the client lived with his father independently from 2022 to 2024 in the U.S. In January 2024, the client came to India with his father to stay with his grandparents and lived here since then.
Education: The client started schooling at the age of 5 years. From the beginning, he followed the Individual Education Plan (IEP). The client attended an integrated school with special schooling and standard classes. From middle school onwards, 398 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the client attended classes under the supervision of a special educator. He completed his 12th class and diploma in 2022 instead of 2021 as his mother decided to extend the training for individual living skill training and job skill training.
Training attended: The client attended the Infant- Toddler Programme for 3 years (birth to 3 years of age), followed by training in the Head Start programme till 5 years of age. These programmes were provided mainly to address the client’s developmental delay and physical difficulties. In addition to the special training and physical therapy, speech therapy, and occupation therapy from his school, the client also attended professional handwriting training at home (Handwriting without Tears programme) for 3 years during elementary schooling, physical exercise in parks and once a week half-day social skill training through exposure to social gatherings from 2017 onwards, which his mother supervised. During the client’s stay with his father, the client was informally trained by his father on quick loop-back therapy, a form of physiotherapy for 5 years. In addition to that, the father would take the client for 1 to 2-mile walking. From 2013 to 2017, under a club, the client was trained in swimming and physical activities to gain strength and gait training.
Occupation: The client worked for one year as a Patient Coordinator at a dental clinic in North Carolina, which had been owned by his paternal aunt. Following this, the client did a six-month internship as a Hospitality worker, during which he travelled alone using a special transportation service arranged by InReach. The client attended Skill-based vocational training for 3 months in India under the Department of Adult Independent Living at the National Institute for Empowerment of Persons with Multiple Disabilities, Chennai. During all these periods, the client maintained good relationships [2025] 3 S.C.R. 399Sharmila Velamur v. V. Sanjay and Ors. with his colleagues and clients, and there were no complaints against him.
Citizenship and related concerns: The client is a U.S. citizen by birth and was registered with the Overseas Citizen of India (OCI). The OCl certificate was issued on 29.03.2011, allowing the client multiple entries to India for a lifetime.
Plan: During the client’s stay in the U.S., he visited India five times and stayed in India for a total of 1 year and 6 months. The client reported that he wishes to stay and spend time with his younger brother, complete his independent living skill training, and start his own business in the U.S.
Observations • Both parents have expressed willingness to provide the client with emotional, physical, and financial support throughout his future.
• Both parents have a stable support system, including financial and physical resources.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.