Amrit Yadav v. The State of Jharkhand and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 176; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 24
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pankaj Mithal, Justice Sandeep Mehta
- Decided
- 9 Feb 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 13950/2024
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 24 : 2025 INSC 176 Amrit Yadav v.
The State of Jharkhand and Ors.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 13950-13951 of 2024)
10 February 2025 [Pankaj Mithal and Sandeep Mehta,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration The core issues presented for adjudication before this Court in these appeals are:- (1) Whether the advertisement dated 29.07.2010 issued by respondent no. 4 and appointment process carried out in pursuance thereof, was valid in the eyes of law; (2) Whether the direction issued by the High Court vide order dated 12.09.2018 was justified considering the fact that the candidates earlier appointed to the subject posts were neither impleaded as party nor were heard before the issuance of a direction that adversely affected their service.
Headnotes† Constitution of India – Arts. 14 and 16 – Validity of the advertisement dated 29.07.2010 issued by respondent no.4: Held: It is settled that any appointment in violation of the mandate of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India is not only irregular but also illegal and cannot be sustained – It is a trite law that a valid advertisement inviting applications for public employment must include the total number of seats, the ratio of reserved and unreserved seats, minimum qualification for the posts and procedural clarity with respect to the type and manner of selection stages, i.e., written, oral examination and interviews – Further, the position of law is settled that though there is no fundamental right to claim reservation as Articles 16(4) and (4-A) of the Constitution of India are in the nature of enabling provisions only and do not mandate the State or its instrumentalities to provide reservation in every selection process but inspite thereof, the State’s decision to not provide reservation has to be based on some quantifiable data and valid reasoning – In the present case, the advertisement * Author [2025] 3 S.C.R. 25Amrit Yadav v. The State of Jharkhand and Ors. dated 29.07.2010, issued by respondent no. 4 is completely silent on the aspect of total number of posts and the number of reserved quota and general quota posts – This Court is of the view that if the State chooses not to provide reservation, that decision must also be conveyed through the advertisement along with the lists of inclusions – Any appointment made in violation of the statutory rules as well as the mandate of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution would be a nullity in law – Thus, the entire recruitment process initiated for the subject posts, in furtherance of the advertisement dated 29.07.2010, is in violation of both the legal precedents and settled law – Therefore, the advertisement dated 29.07.2010, issued by respondent No. 4 was not a valid advertisement inviting applications for public employment and is thus, a nullity in law. [Paras 19, 20, 23, 24] Principle of Natural Justice – On 12.09.2018, the Single Judge of the High Court had directed the respondent-State to make a fresh panel for appointment to the post of Class-IV employees as per the conditions stipulated in the advertisement dated 29.07.2010 – Same was upheld by the Division Bench of High Court – The candidates earlier appointed to the subject posts were neither impleaded as party nor were heard – Whether the Division Bench of the High Court was correct in directing the respondent-State to prepare fresh panel of selected candidates without giving an opportunity of hearing to the candidates who were likely to get affected by such direction:
Held: The position of law is crystallized on the aspect of compliance with the principles of natural justice in both administrative spheres as well as judicial decisions – It is trite law that the principles of natural justice cannot be applied in any straitjacket formula and it is imperative to understand that there are certain exceptions to their applicability – In the present case, the Division Bench in the first impugned order dated 07.11.2019, had confirmed the directions passed by the Single Judge to the respondent-State to prepare a fresh panel of selected candidates without affording any opportunity of hearing to the candidates, who were earlier declared successful by the respondent-State and were holding the subject posts – Subsequently, the respondent-State relieved the appellant-employee and other candidates selected de hors the rules and terminated their services vide order dated 07.12.2020 – In view of this Court, since the very selection and appointment of the appellant-employee was a nullity in the eyes of law, the 26 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Single Judge committed no error in directing the respondent-State to prepare fresh panel of selected candidates without hearing the candidates who were likely to get affected – In view of the factual scenario, it is clear that if the subject appointments were ab-initio nullity in the eyes of law, it was not incumbent on the Single Judge to pass the order after hearing all the parties that were likely to be affected by such decision, i.e., the candidates who were already appointed on the subject posts including the appellant-employee. [Paras 29, 30, 32] Case Law Cited Renu v. District and Sessions Judge, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi [2014] 2 SCR 537 : (2014) 14 SCC 50; Mukesh Kumar v. State of Uttarakhand (2020) 3 SCC 1; Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. v. CCE [2015] 6 SCR 437 : (2015) 8 SCC 519; Union of India v. Raghuwar Pal Singh [2018] 4 SCR 1012 : (2018) 15 SCC 463; M.P. State Coop. Bank Ltd. v. Nanuram Yadav [2007] 10 SCR 307 : (2007) 8 SCC 264; State of U.P. v. U.P. State Law Officers’ Assn. [1994] 1 SCR 348 : (1994) 2 SCC 204 – relied on.
State of Karnataka v. Umadevi [2006] 3 SCR 953 : (2006) 4 SCC 1 – referred to.
List of Acts Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Article 14 of Constitution; Article 16 of the Constitution; Validity of advertisement; Appointment process; Opportunity of hearing; Violation of the statutory rules; Principle of Natural Justice. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 13950-13951 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 24.11.2022 and 07.11.2019 of the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi in LPA No. 305 of 2022 and LPA No. 26 of 2019 respectively With Civil Appeal Nos. 13952, 13955, 13953 and 13954 of 2024 [2025] 3 S.C.R. 27Amrit Yadav v. The State of Jharkhand and Ors. Appearances for Parties Dr. Rajiv Nanda, Sr. Adv., Brajesh Pandey, Sandeep, Samindra Kumar Tripathi, Sunil Kumar, Manish Kumar Vickkey, Kanchan Kumar Jha, Rajeev Kumar Shrivastava, Paramhans Sahani, M/s. Brajesh Pandey & Associates, Anilendra Pandey, Advs. for the Appellant.
Jayant Mohan, Karma Dorjee, Ms. Adya Shree Dutta, Ms. Pallavi Langar, Ms. Pragya Baghel, Sujeet Kumar Chaubey, Anilendra Pandey, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Mehta, J.
CIVIL APPEALS NO(S). 13950-13951 OF 2024
1. The present appeals by special leave, are preferred by the appellant, 1 assailing the following two judgments rendered by the Division Bench of the High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi 2 : i) Judgment dated 7 th November, 2019 in LPA No. 26 of 2019, whereby the learned Division Bench dismissed the intra-court appeal preferred by the respondent-State against the common judgment of learned Single Judge in WP(S) No. 6709 of 2017 and other connected petitions, 3 who vide order dated 12 th September, 2018, had directed the respondent-State to make a fresh panel for appointment to the post of Class-IV employees as per the conditions stipulated in the advertisement dated 29 th July, 2010. (Hereinafter, referred to as “first impugned order”). ii) Judgment dated 24 th November, 2022 in batch of Letter Patent Appeals, 4 whereby, the learned Division Bench dismissed the intra-court appeals (one amongst them filed by the appellant- 1 Hereinafter, referred to as “appellant-employee”.
2 Hereinafter referred to as “High Court”.
3 WP (S) Nos. 789 of 2018, 1257 of 2018, 1278 of 2018, 1342 of 2018, 1638 of 2018, 1757 of 2018, 544 of 2018, 1007 of 2018, 1915 of 2018, 1926 of 2018, 1893 of 2018 and 7047 of 2017. 4 LPA Nos. 305 of 2022, 197 of 2022, 185 of 2022, 186 of 2022 and 201 of 2022. 28 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports employee) against the judgment dated 9 th March, 2022 passed by the learned Single Judge who vide common order passed in batch of writ petitions, 5 had refused to interfere with the order of termination issued by respondent-State. (Hereinafter, referred to as “second impugned order”).
Factual Matrix: -
2. The Deputy Commissioner, Palamu 6 published an advertisement dated 29 th July, 2010, inviting applications for appointment to the post of Class IV employees.7 The language of said advertisement is germane to the controversy at hand and the same is extracted below: - “Date: 29 July 2010 (Ranchi)
Last Date of application submission 21/8/2010
OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT MAGISTRATE PALAMU
DISTRICT, NAZARAT BRANCH
Collectorate Palamu (Information related to making the fourth panel)
Instructions for appointment to the post of class IV employee Advertisement Number 1 Vacancy for the grade IV post - the eligible and interested candidates are invited to apply in subscribed application form to the vacant posts of Class IV category by sending application to the appropriate offices of the State Government in Palamu District on schedule date.
It will be mandatory to the candidate in list of the category to submit the certificate along with the application in printed form before the District Nazarat Branch, Palamu Collectorate till the last date for submission of application. 5 WP(S) Nos. 4440 of 2020, 187 of 2021, 4132 of 2020, 2219 of 2021, 4358 of 2020, 4363 of 2020, 4405 of 2020, 4407 of 2020 and 2244 of 2021.
6 Hereinafter referred to as “respondent no. 4”.
7 For short “subject posts”.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 29Amrit Yadav v. The State of Jharkhand and Ors. After the last date, the application will not be considered without the eligible proof of deprivation.
Applicants are instructed to appear in the examination on the basis of admission eligibility, the cycling test of the qualified candidate will be held on schedule to qualify in compulsory basis. The date of examination will be announced later.
The complete details with terms and conditions to apply for the post in application are as follows.
1. Name of the post - IV Grade
2. Educational Qualification - VIII Passed
3. The candidate should must be eligible in cycling (there the cycle test should be organized to qualify on compulsory basis)
4. The candidate should be in sound health (should be compulsory to submit the medical fitness certificate obtained within last 6 months)
5. The candidate over to the maximum age should not be consider to apply.
6. The applicant for general category is eligible to apply other than the candidate in schedule caste and schedule tribe cast in age relaxation in between 18 to 27 years and for backward class / extremely backward class should be eligible to apply in age of 18 to 28 years and for female candidate in unreserved and other backward and scheduled and Scheduled Tribe Caste should apply with age relaxation 18 to 40 years.
7. The candidate belong from the local areas should be given to preference, will be eligible to apply and the candidate working in government offices should be in preference to apply from the date of publication of the advertisement in status of weightage calculation. For which weightage will be given for service. It will be mandatory for the daily wage to submit the certificate obtained or from the employer.
8. Preference will be given to local applicants.
30 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
9. No traveling allowance will be given to the candidates appearing in the final examination.
10. The emplacement will be effective for one year from the date of publication.
11. It is only related to the preparation of advertisement panels.
12. Instructions given from time to time to the district by the Jharkhand Government in this context should be applicable.
13. Information will be provided in the Devanagari script prescribed letter form and educational and other qualification proofs, eligible age certificate, reservation certificate, caste certificate issued by the employment office, disability certificate issued by the civil surgeon of the district (if the applicant is disabled) and residence certificate, caste proof issued by the eligible sub divisional officer / appropriate office by the Government of Jharkhand, It is mandatory for the candidate to attach the photocopy of the certificate (issued within six months) from the concerned authority including two passport size photographs should must be submit.
14. It will be mandatory to attach a bank draft of Rs.100 in the name of Deputy Collector, Palamu Secretariat along with 10x10 size envelope.
15. The decision of the District Selection Committee regarding panel creation will be final.
16. The entire recruitment process will be completely transparent. And all action will be taken according to the rules of the government. Therefore, under the public interest, even in your own interest, the broker should not come under the influence of the middleman. The candidate is warned to do not approach or recommend at any level. If any such attempt is detected, the form will automatically be canceled and legal action will be taken against the candidate.
Sd/- The Deputy Commissioner Palamu”
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 31Amrit Yadav v. The State of Jharkhand and Ors.
3. Pursuant to the issuance of the above advertisement, an examination was conducted on 5th November, 2017. Subsequently, respondent No. 4 issued a press release8 dated 9th November, 2017, stating that before the final panel of selected candidates is prepared, the candidates would be required to remain present in the District Establishment Section, Palamu for the purpose of counselling. Upon completion of the counselling process, the District Education Officer9 vide office order 10 dated 9 th March, 2018, issued appointment letter to the successful candidates, including the appellant herein. Meanwhile, an FIR11 came to be registered at Police Station Daltonganj Town, District Palamu alleging rampant corruption and mass scale cheating in the examination conducted for the subject posts on 5 th November, 2017.
4. Aggrieved by the publication of the list of successful candidates, some non-selected candidates preferred writ petitions 12 before the High Court which came to be allowed vide order dated 12 th September, 2018, directing the respondent-State to prepare a fresh merit list as per the marks obtained in the written examination conducted on 5 th November, 2017, without counting the marks awarded to the candidates in interview. The learned Single Judge opined that the appointment was not carried out in accordance with the stipulations made in the advertisement dated 29 th July, 2010, as there was admittedly, no provision for interview in the advertisement which was conducted by the respondent-State. The learned Single Judge further observed that the respondent-State had acted de hors the rules and regulations while preparing the merit list by taking into account the cumulative marks obtained by the candidates in written examination as well as the interview.
5. Aggrieved, the respondent-State preferred an intra-court appeal13 assailing the aforesaid order of the learned Single Judge. The Division Bench vide first impugned order dated 7th November, 2019, dismissed the appeal and upheld the order dated 12 th September, 2018, passed by the learned Single Judge. Pursuant to the aforesaid 8 Memorandum No. 842 of 2017.
9 Hereinafter, referred to as “respondent no. 5”.
10 Memo no. 399.
11 FIR No. 382 of 2017.
12 Supra note 3.
13 LPA No. 26 of 2019.
32 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports direction of learned Single Judge, respondent No. 5 vide office order dated 7 th December, 2020, relieved the appellant-employee and other candidates who were purportedly selected de hors the rules and terminated their service.
6. The appellant-employee and other similarly aggrieved candidates assailed their termination order by preferring writ petitions 14 before the High Court seeking issuance of a writ to reinstate them in service. The learned Single Judge vide order dated 9th March, 2022, dismissed the batch of writ petitions, holding that no case for interference was made out as admittedly, the respondent-State had changed the rules of the game by introducing the interview round in the selection process after the ball had been set rolling. The learned Single Judge further held that the respondent-State had prepared the fresh panel of selected candidates in compliance with the direction of the High Court in WP (S) No. 6709 of 2017 and other analogous petitions,15 which stood affirmed in the first impugned order and hence, the termination orders were valid in the eyes of law.
7. Aggrieved, the appellant-employee and other similarly situated candidates preferred a batch of intra-court appeals 16 assailing the order dated 9 th March, 2022, passed by the learned Single Judge. The learned Division Bench, vide order dated 24 th November, 2022, dismissed these appeals and held that as the decision with respect to preparation of fresh panel of selected candidates had attained finality in view of the judgment of the Coordinate Bench, the respondent- State was justified in issuing the order terminating the services of the appellant-employee and other similarly situated candidates for being less meritorious.
8. Aggrieved, the appellant-employee has approached this Court by way of these appeals by special leave assailing the impugned orders passed by the learned Division Bench of the High Court. Submissions on behalf of the appellant-employee: -
9. Learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant-employee strenuously contended that the appellant-employee was duly selected 14 Supra note 5.
15 Supra note 3.
16 Supra note 4.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 33Amrit Yadav v. The State of Jharkhand and Ors. and has been appointed to the subject posts, purely on merit, vide Memorandum No. 399 dated 9th March, 2018, issued by the competent authority. There was no allegation of fraud or misrepresentation on the part of the appellant-employee while seeking the appointment on the post in question.
10. It was submitted that pursuant to the valid appointment of the appellant-employee, he has satisfactorily served the respondent-State for two and a half years and has also completed his probation period. Further, the learned counsel urged that as the appellant-employee has become over-age for other Government jobs, a sympathetic view ought to be taken by setting aside the termination order dated 7 th December, 2020 issued by respondent No. 5.
11. He further contended that the Division Bench grossly erred in issuing a direction to the respondent-State to prepare a fresh panel of selected candidates without impleading the affected persons, such as the appellant-employee, as a party in the proceedings and thus, violated the principles of natural justice. The non-selected candidates who had filed the writ petitions had voluntarily refrained from appearing in the counselling process, and hence, they lacked locus to challenge the recruitment process.
12. Learned counsel concluded his submissions by imploring this Court to take a sympathetic view and to accept the appeals, set aside the impugned judgments, quash the termination order dated 7 th December, 2020, and direct the respondent-State to reinstate the appellant-employee in service.
Submissions on behalf of the respondent-State: -
13. Per contra, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent- State contended that the impugned judgments do not suffer from any infirmity or illegality. He contended that the fresh panel of selected candidates, was prepared by the respondent-State in compliance with the direction of the High Court vide order dated 12 th September, 2018. Once the appointment of the appellant-employee was found to be de hors the law, he cannot claim a preferential right of continuing in service as against the candidates who were admittedly higher in merit.
14. Learned standing counsel further contended that the case of the appellant-employee suffers from gross delay which remains 34 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports unexplained as he is laying challenge to judgment 17 of the Division Bench dated 7 th November, 2019 after a period of more than 3 years. As such, the appellant-employee is not entitled to any relief. On these grounds, the learned Counsel for the respondent-State implored this Court to dismiss the appeals and affirm the impugned judgments.
Issues: -
15. We have given our thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced at bar and have carefully gone through the impugned judgments and the material placed on record.
16. The core issues presented for adjudication before this Court in these appeals are: -
(1) Whether the advertisement dated 29 th July, 2010 issued by respondent No. 4 and appointment process carried out in pursuance thereof, was valid in the eyes of law?
(2) Whether the direction issued by the High Court vide order dated 12 th September, 2018 was justified considering the fact that the candidates earlier appointed to the subject posts were neither impleaded as party nor were heard before the issuance of a direction that adversely affected their service?
Discussion and Analysis: - Issue No. 1: Whether the advertisement dated 29th July, 2010 by respondent No. 4 and appointment process carried out in pursuance thereof was valid in the eyes of law?
17. To adjudge the validity of the recruitment process and the appointments made thereunder for the subject posts, we deem it fit to consider the terms and conditions of the advertisement dated 29th July, 2010, issued by respondent No. 4 on the touchstone of the precedents of this Court so as to find out whether the same was in conformity with law or not.
17 First impugned order.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 35Amrit Yadav v. The State of Jharkhand and Ors.
18. A three-Judge Bench of this Court in Renu v. District and Sessions Judge, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi,18 discussed in detail the requirements of a valid advertisement and observed thus:- “16. Another important requirement of public appointment is that of transparency. Therefore, the advertisement must specify the number of posts available for selection and recruitment. The qualifications and other eligibility criteria for such posts should be explicitly provided and the schedule of recruitment process should be published with certainty and clarity. The advertisement should also specify the rules under which the selection is to be made and in absence of the rules, the procedure under which the selection is likely to be undertaken.
This is necessary to prevent arbitrariness and to avoid change of criteria of selection after the selection process is commenced, thereby unjustly benefiting someone at the cost of others.”
(emphasis supplied)
19. Thus, the advertisements which fail to mention the number of posts available for selection are invalid and illegal due to lack of transparency. This Court further expounded in Renu(supra) that any appointment in violation of the mandate of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India is not only irregular but also illegal and cannot be sustained. It is a trite law that a valid advertisement inviting applications for public employment must include the total number of seats, the ratio of reserved and unreserved seats, minimum qualification for the posts and procedural clarity with respect to the type and manner of selection stages, i.e., written, oral examination and interviews.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.