The Secretary to Government Department of Health & Family Welfare & Anr. v. K.C. Devaki
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 389; [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1133
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, Justice Manoj Misra
- Decided
- 25 Mar 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 4356/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:20 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 3 S.C.R. 1133 : 2025 INSC 389 The Secretary to Government Department of Health & Family Welfare & Anr.
v.
K.C. Devaki (Civil Appeal No. 4356 of 2025)
25 March 2025 [Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha* and Manoj Misra, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Issue arose for consideration that whether the transfer or reappointment of a government employee from one post to another impact his/her seniority in the new post, and if so, is such seniority contingent upon whether the transfer was made in public interest or at the employees own request.
Headnotes† Service law – Seniority – Transfer or reappointment of government employee from one post to another – Impact on seniority in the new post – Seniority, if contingent upon the transfer made in public interest or at the employees own request – On facts, the respondent-staff nurse’s request to change her cadre to First Division Assistant on medical grounds – On acceptance of the request, and on acceptance of the consent letter to be placed below the last person in the transferred post, issuance of the orders of posting changing the cadre of the respondent from Staff Nurse to First Division Assistant– Respondent continued in the new position for 18 years, and thereafter, the seniority list was released – Challenged by the respondent on the ground that the seniority must be fixed as per the initial appointment as Staff Nurse in 1979 and not on the basis of the entry into the new cadre in 1989 as First Division Assistant – Application allowed by the tribunal – Said order upheld by the High Court – Correctness: Held: Invocation of r.16 of the 1977 Rules is an exception – However, if the power is exercised, it would operate notwithstanding anything contained in the 1977 Rules or other rules and reason * Author 1134 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports for exercise for such a power must be evidenced in the written text of the record – Officer who by bodily infirmity is permanently incapacitated can be appointed to the new post in relaxation of the existing Rules, such appointment shall not be lower than the one he holds – Prescription that such an officer cannot be appointed to a post lower than that held by him or her can be waived or deviated from if the officer himself consents for the same – On facts, the High Court erred in treating transfer made at the request of the officer on medical grounds as equivalent to transfer in public interest – Respondent accepted the appointment after consenting to be placed below the last person in the transferred post, which position is recorded in the order of 1989 itself, the seniority has to be with effect from 1989 only – Decision of the government in issuance of final seniority list granting seniority w.e.f. 1989 is in consonance with r.16 of the 1977 Rules and r.6 of the 1957 Rules which specifically provide that where transfers are made at the request of the officer, the employee shall be placed below all the officers borne in that class in the transferred post – Tribunal as well as the High Court erred in directing the appellant to grant seniority to the respondent in the cadre of First Division Assistant with effect from the date in which the said respondent has entered service in the cadre of Staff Nurse instead of 1989, when she was appointed in the new cadre of First Division Assistant – Impugned order set aside – Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977 – r.16 – Karnataka Government Servants (Seniority) Rules, 1957. [Paras 13, 20-22, 24, 25] Service Law – Transfer – Transfer made in public interest and transfer made at the request of the officer – Difference between: Held: Purpose of transfer, considerations that weigh, the consequences that follow a transfer made in public interest, as against a transfer made at the request of the officer, vary substantially – Purpose and object of transfer in public interest is to ensure effective and efficient administration – It is founded, sourced, and rooted in administrative exigencies and nothing else – On the other hand, where a transfer is sought at the request of the officer and if the government is satisfied with the genuineness of the request, it may accept the request and direct transfer – This is fairness in action as governmental power accommodates, as it must, human needs and vulnerabilities – However, this kind of [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1135The Secretary to Government Department of Health & Family Welfare & Anr. v. K.C. Devaki transfer, does not partake the character of a transfer made in the public interest – If a government employee holding a particular post is transferred on public interest, he carries with him his existing status including seniority to the transferred post – However, if an officer is transferred at his own request, such a transferred employee will have to be accommodated in the transferred post, subject to the claims and status of the other employees at the transferred place, as their interests cannot be varied without there being any public interest in the transfer – Subject to specific provision of the Rules governing the services, such transferees are generally placed at the bottom, below the junior-most employee in the category in the new cadre or department – Rationale in assignment of such seniority is to avoid heartburn of existing employees in the transferred cadre. [Paras 15-19] Case Law Cited State of Karnataka v. Sri. K. Seetharamulu, W.P. No. 65474 of 2010 dated 17.09.2010 – disapproved.
State of Himachal Pradesh and Ors. v. Raj Kumar and Ors. [2022] 15 SCR 847 : (2023) 3 SCC 773; Geetha V.M. v. Rethnasenan K. [2025] 1 SCR 515 : 2025 SCC OnLine SC 35; K.P. Sudhakaran v. State of Kerala [2006] Supp. 2 SCR 291 : (2006) 5 SCC 386; Surendra Singh Beniwal v. Hukam Singh [2009] 6 SCR 880 : (2009) 6 SCC 469; M K Jagadeesh v. The Registrar General, High Court of Karnataka, Writ Appeal No. 1263 of 2007 – referred to. List of Acts Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977; Karnataka Government Servants (Seniority) Rules, 1957.
List of Keywords Seniority; Promotion; Transfer; Transfer on medical grounds; Transfer in public interest; Transfer made at the request of the officer; Consent to take seniority below last person; Employment defined as status; Request of change of cadre; Reappointment of a government employee; Impact on seniority in the new post; Staff nurse request to change her cadre to First Division Assistant on medical grounds; Seniority list; Officer by bodily infirmity permanently incapacitated; Effective and efficient administration. 1136 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 4356 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 25.10.2021 of the High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru in WP No. 42244 of 2019 Appearances for Parties Advs. for the Appellants:
V. N. Raghupathy, Raghavendra M. Kulkarni, Ms. Mythili S, M. Bangaraswamy, Venkata Raghu Mannepalli, Shiv Kumar, Ms. Vaishnavi.
Advs. for the Respondent:
Himanshu Chaubey, Siddharth Garg, Himanshu Chaubey, Srijan Sinha, Ms. Lihzu Shiney Konyak, Srajan Yadav.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha, J.
1. Leave granted.
2. Does the transfer or reappointment of a government employee from one post to another impact his/her seniority in the new post, and if so, is such seniority contingent upon whether the transfer was made in public interest or at the employees own request? This is the short question that has arisen for our consideration.
3. The fundamental principle underlying the relationship between the State and its employee is that it is governed by administrative rules, rather than contractual agreements. In view of the power of the State to modify the terms and conditions of services by unilaterally amending the Rules, this kind of employment is defined as status. 1 1 State of Himachal Pradesh and Ors. v. Raj Kumar and Ors., (2023) 3 SCC 773 declared the consequence of status as, “(iii) The hallmark of status is in the legal rights and obligations imposed by laws that may be framed and altered unilaterally by the Government without the consent of the employee.
(iv) In view of the dominance of rules that govern the relationship between the Government and its employee, all matters concerning employment, conditions of service including termination are governed by the rules. There are no rights outside the provision of the rules.” [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1137The Secretary to Government Department of Health & Family Welfare & Anr. v. K.C. Devaki Therefore, when grievance of an employee is brought to a Court or a Tribunal, the primary question is about the Rule that governs the services. At this stage there is no value judgment about the executive action, unless of course when the Rule itself is challenged on the ground of invalidity or arbitrariness. So, we simply look at the Rule that governs the services and determine whether the action is in consonance with the mandate of the Rule.
4. The Rules that govern the service of the respondent are the Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977 2 and Karnataka Government Servants (Seniority) Rules, 19573 . The context in which interpretation and application of these Rules are to be found in the facts of the case, which, to the extent that they are relevant for our consideration, are as follows.
5. The respondent was appointed as a Staff Nurse in the Department of Indian System of Medicine and Homeopathy, State of Karnataka in the year 1979. She submitted a representation to the government and requested to change her cadre to First Division Assistant on medical grounds. Following her request, the government sought opinion of the Director of the Department who asked the respondent to appear before the medical board for examination. The board submitted its report on 22.04.1985 indicating that the respondent was in fact suffering from bronchitis and that she will not be able to carry out the duties of a Staff Nurse.
6. Following the decision of the government accepting her request change of cadre, the respondent was asked to submit a consent letter, which she did on 03.06.1985 indicating that “with reference to the above subject, I hereby give my consent for the offer to change designation to clerical nature of work in the pay scale of Rs.630-1200 and to take seniority below the last person”. Accepting her consent to be placed below the last person in the transferred post, orders of temporary posting, followed by final order dated 19.04.1989 was issued by the government changing the cadre of the respondent from Staff Nurse to First Division Assistant on medical grounds and to take the position below the last candidate. The relevant portion of the order is as under:
2 Hereinafter referred to as the ‘1977 Recruitment Rules’. 3 Hereinafter referred to as the ‘1957 Seniority Rules’. 1138 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports “PROCEEDINGS OF THE KARNATAKA GOVERNMENT Subject: Change in cadre to Smt. K.C. Devaki from the post of Staff Nurse to First Division Assistant post on medical grounds-reg.
In the letter dated: 8.7.85 read at (1) above, the Director, Department of Indian Systems of Medicine and Homeopathy, Bengaluru has stated that Smt. K.C. Devaki, Staff Nurse, Sri. Jayachamarajendra Institute of Indian Medicine, Bengaluru has requested for cadre change on medical grounds and the Medical Board has recommended in this regard. Along with the copy of the same, he has recommended for cadre change from the post of staff Nurse to First Division Assistant post.
On examining the proposal in detail, an instruction has been given vide the Government letter dated: 11.2.86 read at
(2) above to issue a cadre change order after determining whether the cadre changing employees are eligible or not to perform the duties prescribed to changed post.
As per the Government letter dated: 11.2.86, vide O.M.
dated: 24.4.86 Smt. K.C. Devaki, Devaki, Staff Nurse, Sri. Jayachamarajendra Institute of Indian Medicine, Bengaluru has been appointed temporarily for three months at the post of First Division Assistant at Government College of Indian Medicine, Mysuru, so as to examine her performance.
Thereafter continued in the same post, till now.
Vide letter dated: 3.12.88 read at (4) above, it is reported that Smt. K.C. Devaki, Staff Nurse, is performing duties satisfactorily temporarily in the post which is to be cadre changed and passed the departmental examinations prescribed for the said post. As per rule..16(a) of the Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977, while changing from one cadre to another cadre, educational qualification, prescribed for the post to be cadre changed should be attained. But, since Smt. K.C.
Devaki did not attain degree, clarification has sought whether cadre could be changed as per the Government Letter No. HFW 158 PIM 84, dated: 11.2.86. Since it is not mentioned in General Recruitment rule 16(a) (111) about [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1139The Secretary to Government Department of Health & Family Welfare & Anr. v. K.C. Devaki minimum eligibility and since the Director has stated that Smt. K.C. Devaki has performed satisfactorily as First Division Assistant for three years, the Government has decided to change the cadre of Smt. K.C. Devaki from the Staff Nurse post to First Division Assistant.
Government Order No. HFW 536 PIM 88, Bengaluru, dated: 19.4.1989 On examining the proposal in detail, the Government has ordered by changing the cadre of Smt. K.C. Devaki /from the post of Staff Nurse to First Division Assistant post as per rule 16(a) (111) of the Karnataka Civil Services (General Recruitment) Rules, 1977, subjecting to following conditions:- 1) She shall be passed departmental examination prescribed to the changed post within 2 years from the date of cadre change.
2) In the cadre of changing, she shall get the service seniority below the last candidate on that date.
3) No any travel allowance is available to her.
4) Hereafter such cadre change could not be given to her in her service.”
7. The Government of Karnataka, the appellant herein, submits that the respondent continued in the new position as First Division Assistant at the place as was accepted by her from 1989 to 2007. However, when the seniority list was released in 2007, she approached the Karnataka Administrative Tribunal 4 challenging the final seniority list dated 01.10.2007 on the ground that her seniority must be fixed as per her initial appointment as Staff Nurse on 05.01.1979 and not on the basis of her entry into the new cadre on 19.01.1989 as First Division Assistant.
8. The Tribunal allowed the Original Application by following the decision of the High Court in the State of Karnataka v. Sri. K. Seetharamulu 5. 4 Hereinafter referred to as the ‘Tribunal’.
5 W.P. No. 65474 of 2010 dated 17.09.2010, hereinafter, ‘K. Seetharamulu’ 1140 [2025] 3 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports The writ petition filed by the State of Karnataka challenging the decision of the Tribunal was dismissed by the order impugned before us. This is how the State is in appeal. We heard Mr. V. N. Raghupathy, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the State and Mr. Siddharth Garg for the respondent.
9. Analysis: The factual background, as indicated hereinabove clearly establishes that the change of cadre from Staff Nurse to First Division Assistant occurred due to a request by the respondent and the same was considered under the 1977 Recruitment Rules. To consider whether the final seniority list dated 01.10.2007 is legal or not, we need to examine the mandate of Rule 16 which is extracted herein for ready reference:
“Rule 16. Relaxation of rules relating to appointment and qualifications:- Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules or the rules of recruitment specially made in respect of any service or post, the Government may, for reason to be recorded in writing-
(a) appoint to a post-
(i) an officer of the Defence Services, an All India Services or a Civil Service of the Union, or the Civil Service of any other State;
(ii) an officer holding a post of an equivalent grade by transfer or by deputation from any other service of the State for recruitment to which these rules apply:
Provided that appointment by transfer under this sub-clause shall not be made unless the officer has passed the examination prescribed under the Karnataka Civil Services (Service and Kannada Language Examinations) Rules, 1974 for the post to which he is proposed to be transferred.
Provided further that where it is necessary in public interest to appoint an officer belonging to a service where has no equivalent grade, an officer holding a post in the next lower grade in [2025] 3 S.C.R. 1141The Secretary to Government Department of Health & Family Welfare & Anr. v. K.C. Devaki such service may be appointed by deputation for a period not exceeding two years.
Provided also that no such appointment shall be to a post which is equivalent to or higher than the next promotional post to such officer in such other service.
(iii) an officer who by bodily infirmity is permanently incapacitated for the post which he holds;
Provided that appointment under this sub-clause shall not be:-
(1) to a post lower than that held by such officer save with his consent;
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.