Jyostnamayee Mishra v. The State of Odisha and Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 87; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 834
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.K. Maheshwari, Justice Rajesh Bindal
- Decided
- 20 Jan 2025
- Case number
- SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION (CIVIL) No. 13984/2023
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 834 : 2025 INSC 87 Jyostnamayee Mishra v.
The State of Odisha and Ors.
(Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 13984 of 2023)
20 January 2025 [J.K. Maheshwari and Rajesh Bindal,* JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether an employee in an establishment is entitled to claim promotion on a post for which he does not fall in the feeder cadre and the post is required to be filled up 100% by way of direct recruitment; whether a vacancy meant for direct recruitment can be filled up merely by issuing a circular in the establishment and not by issuing an advertisement calling application from the eligible candidates from public at large.
Headnotes† Sub-ordinate Architectural Service Rules, 1979 – Claim of petitioner for the post of Tracer on promotion basis – Petitioner herein was working as a peon with respondent-State – Petitioner disappointed with the various rounds of the litigation before the Tribunal followed by writ petition before the High Court – Petitioner alleged the discriminatory action of the respondent authorities with regard to her promotion to the post of Tracer as two persons were promoted by communications dated 28.06.1999 from the post of peon to Tracer – Petitioner is claiming violation of Article 14 of the Constitution: Held: The claim of the petitioner has been rejected on the ground that she is not eligible for the post of Tracer – As per 1979 Rules, the post of Tracer is to be filled up to 100% by way of direct recruitment in terms of Rule 5(1)(e) of the 1979 Rules and the method of direct recruitment has been provided in Rule 7 thereof – Undisputedly, the process as provided in the Rules was not followed – The post of Tracer, not being promotional post from the post of Peon, there is no merit in the claim of the petitioner – As far as violation of Article 14 and discriminatory action is concerned, this Court cannot put a stamp on the illegalities committed by the department while perpetuating the same – A litigant coming to * Author [2025] 1 S.C.R. 835Jyostnamayee Mishra v. The State of Odisha and Ors. the Court cannot claim negative discrimination seeking direction from the Court to the department to act in violation of the law or statutory Rules – It is a settled proposition of law that Article 14 does not envisage negative equality – Thus, there is no merit in the petition – In the case in hand there was casualness on the part of the State Authorities while dealing with the litigation – Even before the Tribunal, the petitioner had three rounds of litigation followed by one Writ Petition before the High Court by the State and thereafter this Court – At none of these stages, the relevant statutory 1979 Rules were referred to either in the counter or in the petition – Such conduct is not expected from the State which is the major litigant and the case in hand is an example of unnecessary generation of litigation by the State where the authorities need to circumspect and be more careful. [Paras 30, 31, 33] Sub-ordinate Architectural Service Rules, 1979 – Rules 5, 6, 7 – Post of Tracer – Category to be filled by direct recruitment – Importance of public advertisement – Whether in the instant case, the procedure prescribed in Rule 7 was followed:
Held: From a perusal of the Rules, it is evident that the post of Tracer in all three categories is to be filled up by direct recruitment only, after following the procedure as prescribed – It is not in dispute that the procedure as prescribed in Rule 7 of the 1979 Rules has not been followed by issuing advertisement and inviting application for the post of Tracer – All what is said is that a Circular was issued in the department inviting applications from the Peons for appointment or promotion for the post of Tracer – The Supreme Court in Union Public Service Commission v. Girish Jayanti Lal Vaghela and others, has emphasised the importance of a public advertisement for inviting applications to a post under the State. [Para 22] Case Law Cited Saumya Chaurasia v. Directorate of Enforcement [2023] 15 SCR 848 : (2024) 6 SCC 401; R. Muthukumar & Others v. The Chairman and Managing Director TANGEDCO & Others, 2022 INSC 157 : [2022] 1 SCR 577 : 2022 SCC OnLine SC 151 – relied on.
Union Public Service Commission v. Girish Jayanti Lal Vaghela and Others [2006] 1 SCR 1006 : (2006) 2 SCC 482; Basawaraj v. Special Land Acquisition Officer [2013] 8 SCR 227 : (2013) 14 SCC 81; Kusha Duruka v. The State of Odisha, 2024 INSC 46 : [2024] 1 SCR 604 : (2024) 4 SCC 432 – referred to.
836 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports List of Acts Sub-ordinate Architectural Service Rules, 1979; Orissa Subordinate Architectural Service Rules, 1979.
List of Keywords Promotion; Direct recruitment; Peon; Tracer; Rule 5(1)(e) of the Subordinate Architectural Service Rules, 1979; Article 14 of Constitution; Casualness on the part of the State Authorities; Discriminatory action; Illegalities committed by the department; Negative equality. Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 13984 of 2023 From the Judgment and Order dated 12.10.2022 of the High Court of Orissa at Cuttack in WPC(OAC) No. 18463 of 2017 Appearances for Parties Anand Swain, Siddhartha Chowdhury, Advs. for the Petitioner. Shibashish Misra, Adv. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Rajesh Bindal, J.
1. This Court had been called upon to examine the validity of an order passed by the Court below where the parties failed to produce proper documents or annexed incorrectly typed documents. This does not happen in isolation, rather is a routine, which sometimes results in miscarriage of justice in case the issues are not examined in detail with proper assistance of the parties, especially the State where it is party to the lis. It may also put the Court to ridicule.
2. The challenge in the present petition is to the order of the High Court 1 dated 12.10.2022 passed in Writ Petition 2 filed by the State 1 High Court of Orissa at Cuttack 2 Writ Petition Civil (OAC) No.18463 of 2017 [2025] 1 S.C.R. 837Jyostnamayee Mishra v. The State of Odisha and Ors. where the order passed by the Tribunal 3 dated 08.01.2016 in an application 4 filed by the petitioner was set aside.
3. An interesting issue which arises is as to whether an employee in an establishment is entitled to claim promotion on a post for which he does not fall in the feeder cadre and the post is required to be filled up 100% by way of direct recruitment? Another important issue is whether a vacancy meant for direct recruitment can be filled up merely by issuing a circular in the establishment and not by issuing an advertisement calling application from the eligible candidates from public at large?
4. The petitioner herein was working as a peon with respondent-State. She was appointed as such in the year 1978. The petitioner filed a representation dated 07.01.1999 to be appointed to the post of Tracer.
5. While the said representation was pending, the petitioner filed O.A. No.628(C) of 1999 before the Tribunal at Cuttack. The same was disposed of at admission stage vide order dated 26.03.1999, directing the respondent therein to dispose of her representation within these months from date of receipt of order. Pursuant to this, vide letter dated 05.07.1999 respondent communicated to the petitioner that the post of Tracer will not be filed up on promotion from the lower category of post since it is not a promotional post and vacancy of Tracer will be filed up in due course by conducting the interview.
6. The petitioner filed another application bearing O.A. No.l126(C) of 2002 before the Tribunal inter alia seeking for the intervention of the Tribunal against the discriminatory action of the respondent authorities with regard to her promotion to the post of Tracer. The said O.A. was later transferred to the Principal Bench of the Tribunal at Bhubaneshwar and was registered as O.A. No.742 of 2009.
7. Learned Tribunal vide order dated 27.09.2010 disposed of the said O.A. directing the respondent to consider the case of the petitioner along with similarly placed Class-IV Employees for their promotion to the post of Tracer against available future vacancy within a period of three months from the date of communication of the order. 3 Orissa Administrative Tribunal, Bhubaneshwar 4 O.A. No.1696 of 2010 838 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
8. Vide order dated 23.11.2010, passed in compliance to the order of the Tribunal dated 27.09.2010 passed in the Application 5 filed by the petitioner, her representation for appointment on the post of basic level Tracer was rejected due to ban on recruitments imposed by the Finance Department 6 .
9. In the third round of litigation, in the Application 7 filed by the petitioner before the Tribunal impugning the order dated 23.11.2010, vide order dated 08.01.2016, the respondent was directed to promote/ appoint the petitioner on the post of Tracer against any vacant post. In case no post is available, then the last person so promoted, after the direction was issued in the earlier O.A. filed by the petitioner, be reverted. Strangely enough to note here that no person was impleaded as party, who may be affected by the order passed by the Tribunal in case benefit is given to the petitioner. A Review Petition bearing R.P. No.28 of 2016 preferred by Respondent therein, was rejected vide order dated 28.02.2017.
10. Aggrieved against these orders passed by the Tribunal, the State preferred Writ Petition No.18463 of 2017 before the High Court. The argument raised was that the petitioner was not eligible for the post of Tracer in terms of paragraph 3(d) of the Letter No.4775 dated 26.02.1980 issued by the Works Department. Hence, she was not found to be eligible. The orders dated 08.01.2016 and 28.02.2017 passed by the Tribunal were set aside. As the retiral benefits had been extended to petitioner for the post of Peon, the High Court disposed of the Writ Petition accordingly.
10.1 We are constrained to note at this stage that the Rules namely Sub-ordinate Architectural Service Rules, 1979, (hereinafter “1979 rules”) as framed in exercise of powers conferred under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India and notified in the official Gazette on 25.07.1980 vide notification No.4773- E-IXR-1/80-E were sought to be referred by the learned counsel appearing before the High Court as Letter No.4775 dated 26.02.1980 issued by the Works Department, and without perusing the proper document, even the High Court has referred those in the judgment in the same manner. 5 O.A. No.742 of 2009 6 Office Memorandum No.10954 dated 14.03.2001.
7 O.A. No.1696 of 2010 [2025] 1 S.C.R. 839Jyostnamayee Mishra v. The State of Odisha and Ors.
11. Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the High Court, while accepting the Writ Petition of the State, had wrongly quoted paragraph 3(d) of Letter No.4775 dated 26.02.1980 in which the qualifications for the post of Tracer have been mentioned. The qualification as per paragraph 3(d) required is the experience of 02 years in tracing from blue printing or a certificate of draftsmanship from the Industrial Training Institution. Learned counsel argued that the petitioner possesses the qualification as she had undergone the course of Tracer Training of 03 months with Institute of Survey and Mining Technology, Bhubaneshwar for which a certificate was granted on 22.09.1997. The petitioner is fully qualified for the post, but she was not called for the interview, and the findings are erroneous. It is the case of the petitioner that there being an error apparent on record regarding qualification, as such the impugned order passed by the High Court deserves to be set aside and that of the Tribunal be restored.
12. It was further argued, earlier the petitioner was called for interview for the post of Tracer in the year 1991 but was not successful. Thereafter, she was again called for interview on 16.03.1999 which was postponed. Other similarly placed employees, namely, Mr. Lalatendu Rath and Ms. Jhinarani Mansingh were promoted as Tracer from the post of Peon, vide order dated 28.06.1999. Hence, looking at the discrimination also the petitioner’s case deserves to be considered.
13. On the other hand, the stand taken by the learned counsel for the respondent was that the petitioner is not eligible for promotion from the post of Peon to the post of Tracer as per the letter dated 26.02.1980. It is argued that the case has rightly been considered and finding no merit therein, the High Court had set aside the order passed by the Tribunal.
14. A perusal of the document annexed as Annexure P-2 along with the petition gives it a color of statutory rules but not typed in a proper manner. During the course of arguments, learned counsel for the parties were asked to apprise the Court about the relevant statutory rules applicable for recruitment/promotion for the post of Tracer.
15. Learned counsel for the State had produced a copy of the Gazette Notification and the typed copy of 1979 Rules. While referring to the aforesaid Rules, the submission was that the petitioner does 840 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports not have a case made out for promotion because the Rules do not permit promotion to the post of Tracer as the petitioner is not qualified for the post of Tracer. She neither has experience nor a certificate of draftsmanship from an Industrial Training Institute. The certificate sought to be produced by her pertains to “ ‘Tracer’ Training Course” which is not the qualification prescribed in 1979 Rules. On query by the Court as to whether the post is to be filled by way of promotion, learned counsel for the State was not able to refer to any Rule even though Rule 5(1)(e) of 1979 Rules clearly provides that all posts of Tracers in Categories I, II and III shall be filled in by direct recruitment. He submitted that for filling up the post on direct recruitment, a notice was published in the department and applications were invited and in pursuance of that, the application of the petitioner and earlier by way of similar process, other candidates were considered. The prayer is for dismissal of the petition.
16. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the paper book.
17. The case in hand is a glaring example of casualness on the part of the parties to produce proper documents before the Court. The statutory rules dealing with the post in question, are being termed as letter of department. Even the High Court in the impugned judgment has referred to the same as a letter of the Works Department, failing to appreciate the contents thereof which are in the form of statutory rules.
18. To put the record straight, we reproduce in the table below, the relevant Rules as published in Official Gazette and the one placed in the paper book before the High Court and this Court. Counsel’s True Typed Copy Orissa Government Gazette The 26th February, 1980 No.4775 E-IRA-1/80-E- In exercise of the power conferred by the provision to Article 309 of the Constitution of India. The governor of Orissa in pleased to make the following rules for the regulation or recruitment. Promotion and other condition of service or this or this is a subordinate architectural service namely:
The 26th February, 1980 No. 4773-E-IXR-1/80-E. – In exercise of the powers conferred by the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the Governor of Orissa is pleased to make the following rules for the regulation of recruitment, promotion and other condition of service of the Orissa Subordinate Architectural Service, namely:- [2025] 1 S.C.R. 841Jyostnamayee Mishra v. The State of Odisha and Ors. Method of Recruitment and Condition of Service Rules, 1979.
1. Short title and commencement
(1) these rules may be called or a Subordinate Architectural Service Rules, 1979.
2) They shall come into force at once.
Provided that nothing in these rules shall be constructed as affecting or invalidating appointments already made or orders already issued by the competent authority & all such appointments and orders shall be deemed or have been made or issued under these appropriate provisions of these rules Method of recruitment and condition of service Rules, 1979.
1. Short title and commencement-(1)
These rules may be called the Orissa Subordinate Architectural Service Rules, 1979.
2) They shall come into force at once:
Provided that nothing in these rules, shall be construed as affecting or invalidating appointments already made or orders already issued by the competent authority and all such appointments and orders shall be deemed to have been made or issued under the appropriate provisions of these rules.
2. Definition:
a) Department means Govt. in Works Department.
b) Government means Govt.
of Orissa c) S e r v i c e m e a n s O r i s s a Architectural service (Non- Gazetted) consisting of Architectural Draftsmen, Head Draftsmen, Asst. Architectural Draftsman and Tracers under the Roads and Buildings Wing d) State means State of Orissa
2. Definition- (a) ‘Department’ means Government in Works Department.
(b) ‘Government’ means Government of Orissa.
(c) ‘Service’ means the Orissa A r c h i t e c t u r a l S e r v i c e ( N o n gazetted), consisting of Architectural D r a f t s m a n , H e a d D r a f t s m a n , Assistant Architectural Draftsman and Tracers under the Roads & Buildings Wing.
(d) ‘State’ means State of Orissa.
2. Position of the service- The service shall consist of following categories of officials, namely.
C a t e g o r y - I : A r c h i t e c t u r a l Draftsmen, Asst. Architectural D r a f t s m e n , Tr a c e r s i n t h e Architect Branch in the office of the Chief Engineer Roads and Buildings.
3. Composition of the service-The service shall consist of the following categories of officials, namely:- Category I – Architectural Draftsman, Assistant Architectural Draftsman, Tracers in the Architect Branch in the office of the Chief Engineer, Roads & Buildings.
842 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Category-II: Head Draftsmen, Asst. Draftsmen & Tracers in the Drawing Branches in the office of the Chief Engineer, Roads and Buildings.
Category-III: Draftsmen and Tracers in the office of the Superintending Engineers and Executive Engineers under Roads and Buildings Wing.
Category II – Head Draftsman, Assistant Draftsman and Tracers in the Drawing Branches in the office of the Chief Engineer, Roads & Buildings.
Category III – Draftsman and Tracers in the office of the Superintending Engineers and Executive Engineers under Roads & Buildings Wing.
4. Recruitment The recruitment to the service shall be made-
(a) by direct recruitment in accordance with the Rules 5 and 7.
(b) by promotion of officials already in service in accordance with the Rule 6.
Direct Recruitment And Percentage Of Recruitments.
1.
a) 50 percent of the vacancies, shall be filled in direct recruitment to the post of the Architectural Draftsman under Category I on a result of competitive test to be conducted by the appointing authority.
b) 50 percent of the vacancies shall be filled in by direct recruitment i n t h e p o s t o f A s s i s t a n t Architectural Draftsmen under Category I on a result of a competitive test to be conducted by the appointing authority c) 50 percent of the vacancies shall be filled in by direct recruitment in the post of Assistant Draftsmen under Category II.
d) 50 percent of the vacancies shall be filled in by direct recruitment in the post of Draftsmen under category III.
5. Direct recruitment and percentage of recruitment (1)(a) 50 per cent of the vacancies, shall be filled in by direct recruitment to the posts of Architectural Draftsman under category I on a result of competitive test to be conducted by the appointing authority.
(b) 50 percent of the vacancies shall be filled in by direct recruitment i n t h e p o s t o f A s s i s t a n t Architectural Draftsmen under Category I on a result of a competitive test to be conducted by the appointing authority
(c) 50 percent of the vacancies shall be filled in by direct recruitment in the post of Assistant Draftsmen under Category II.
(d) 50 percent of the vacancies shall be filled in by direct recruitment in the post of Draftsmen under category III.
(e) All posts of Treasures under categories I, II, and III shall be filled in by direct recruitment.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 843Jyostnamayee Mishra v. The State of Odisha and Ors. e) All posts of Treasures under categories I, II, and III shall be filled in by direct recruitment.
f) The competitive test for all these three categories of post shall be separated from each other and shall be conducted by the appointing authorities
(f) The competitive test for all these three categories of post shall be separated from each other and shall be conducted by the appointing authorities.
(2) A candidate for direct recruitment to the service shall not ordinarily be under twenty-one years of age and over twenty-five years of age on the 1st August of the recruitment year of recruitment.
Provided that the maximum age-limit in case of a candidate belonging to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes shall be 28 years and in case of candidate already in Government service, shall be 35 years. Preference may be given to the ex-Military personnel.
3) (a) A candidate for the post of Architectural Draftsman under category I shall be a pass in Intermediate in Architecture (recognised course) or two years study in any recognised School or College of Architecture with 3 years’ experience in an Architect’s Office or passed in Draftsman course in any technical institution with five years’ experience in Architect’s Office.
(b) A candidate for the post of Assistant Architectural Draftsman under category I, shall have two years study in any recognised School or College of Architecture with one year office experience in an Architect’s Office or passed the Draftsman course in any technical institution with two years’ experience in any Architect’s Office.
844 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports
(c) A candidate for the post of Assistant Draftsman under category II and Drafts- man, category III, shall be matriculate with a certificate of passed Draftsmanship from Industrial Training Institution.
d) Candidates for the posts of Tracer under categories I, II and III shall be matriculates with experience of two years in tracing from blue printing or a certificate of Draftsmanship from Industrial Training Institution.
4) A candidate must not have more than one spouse living and further in case of lady candidate, she must not have married a person who has a wife living:
P r o v i d e d t h a t t h e S t a t e Government may if satisfied that there are special reasons for doing so exempt from the operation of this clause.
2. A candidate for direct recruitment to the service shall not ordinarily be under twenty one years of age and over twenty five years of age on the 1st August of the recruitment year of recruitment.
Provided that the maximum age limit in case of Candidate belonging to scheduled castes and Scheduled Tribes shall be 28 years in case of candidate already in government service shall be 35 years. Preference may be given to the EX- Military personnel.
6. (1) Promotion and percentage of promotion-(a) 50 per cent of the posts of Architectural Draftsman, shall be filled in by promotion from among the suitable Assistant Architectural Draftsman working in Architect Branch.
(b) All posts of Head Draftsman, shall be filled in by promotion from among the suitable Assistant Draftsman working in the Drawing Branch.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 845Jyostnamayee Mishra v. The State of Odisha and Ors.
(c) 50 per cent of the posts of Assistant Architectural Draftsman shall be filled in by promotion from the Tracers working in the Architect Branch.
d) 50 per cent of the posts of Assistant Draftsman shall be filled in by promotion from the Tracers working in the Drawing Branches.
(2) No official shall ordinarily be eligible for promotion to the service-(i) Unless he passes the departmental test to be prescribed for the post held by him at the time of promotion, (ii) Unless he maintains a good record of service which will be judged on the basis of C. C. Rolls.
(3) The period of probation shall be one year in case of officials appointed by promotion which shall count from the date on which they join their new posts.
(4) The appointing authority may extend the period of probation for such further period as he may deem fit and if after the extended period of probation, the promotee is found unsuitable he may be reverted.
3.
a) A candidate for the post of architectural draftsman under Category I shall be a pass in Intermediate in Architecture (recognized or college of A r c h i t e c t u r e w i t h 3 y e a r s experience in an Architect’s officeror passed in Draftsman course in a Technical Institution with fiveyears experience in an Architect’s office.
7. Method of recruitment for direct candidate- (1) Direct recruitment to the service shall be made by a competitive test to be prescribed and conducted by the Chief Engineer, Roads & Buildings in consultation with Government Architect.
846 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports b) A candidate for the post of A s s i s t a n t A r c h i t e c t u r a l Draftsman under Category I shall have two years of study in any recognized school or college of Architecture with lyear office experience in an Architect’s office or passed the Draftsman course in any Technical Institution with two years of experience in any architect’s office.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.