Bhupinderpal Singh Gill v. State of Punjab and Others
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 83; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 804
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice Dipankar Datta, Justice Manmohan
- Decided
- 20 Jan 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 183/2025
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 804 : 2025 INSC 83 Bhupinderpal Singh Gill v.
State of Punjab and Others (Civil Appeal No. 183 of 2025)
20 January 2025 [Dipankar Datta* and Manmohan, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the impugned order of the High Court, in which the Disciplinary Authority’s order imposing penalty and the order of the Single Judge dismissing the writ petition of the appellant have merged, warrants any interference on any of the grounds available for judicial review; whether the objection by the respondent that limited notice having been issued at the time of admission of the intra-court appeal and the appellant’s grievance being addressed, this Court ought not to enlarge the scope of the appeal has any substance. Headnotes† Punjab Civil Services (Punishment & Appeal Rules, 1970) – r.8 – Disciplinary action was initiated against the appellant-Senior Medical Officer 11 days prior to his retirement alleging that he committed misconduct by proceeding on leave without it being sanctioned; defying the directions of the Election Commission and the higher authorities; not participating in the pulse polio programme; threatening legal action against Senior Assistant of the Civil Surgeon – Disciplinary Authority ordered a cut in pension – High Court modified the punishment – Interference with:
Held: On facts, there is no legal evidence on the basis of which the appellant can be held guilty of the charges that he had proceeded on leave without sanction thereof and did not comply with the orders of his superior officers – The charge as regards the appellant having threatened the Senior Assistant is also not proved – Further, it is the clear finding of the Inquiry Officer that the appellant was not assigned any duty in connection with election duty and pulse polio programme during the period he wished to avail leave to attend court proceedings before the High Court – Insofar as defiance of * Author [2025] 1 S.C.R. 805Bhupinderpal Singh Gill v. State of Punjab and Others Election Commission’s directions by the appellant are concerned, no such written directions were part of the documentary evidence led before the Inquiry Officer – Impugned order of the Division Bench, the order of dismissal passed by the Single Judge as well as the order of penalty passed by the Disciplinary Authority, set aside – Appellant entitled to full pension without any cut, the deduction made so far to be returned as directed – Costs of Rs.50,000/awarded to the appellant. [Paras 38, 39, 42, 45] Practice and Procedure – Limited notice issued at the stage of admission – Enlargement of the scope of petition/appeal during final hearing not barred – Objection by the respondent that limited notice having been issued at the time of admission of the intra-court appeal by the High Court and the appellant’s grievance being addressed, this Court ought not to enlarge the scope of the appeal:
Held: Objection is without any substance – Issuing limited notice at the stage of admission does not bar a Constitutional Court having inherent powers to enlarge the scope of a petition/appeal at the stage of final hearing particularly when enforcement of any Fundamental/Constitutional right is urged by the party approaching it – Any observation that the court makes while entertaining the petition/appeal by issuing limited notice is tentative which cannot limit the court’s jurisdiction to consider the controversy, as raised, in its entire perspective – Whether or not the court would enlarge the scope is, however, a question largely dependent on the facts and circumstances of each case. [Para 19] Disciplinary proceedings/Inquiry proceedings – Punishment orders – Interference with – Principles governing – Discussed – Judicial review – Constitution of India – Article 226. [Para 33] Disciplinary proceedings/Inquiry proceedings – Principles of Natural Justice, discussed – Plea of the appellant that the process of decision-making was vitiated for lack of procedural fairness:
Held: Validity of disciplinary action is to be tested on the touchstone of Articles 14, 16 and 21 as well as Article 311(2), wherever applicable – To test whether interference is warranted, the scrutiny ought to be confined to finding out whether the disciplinary proceedings were conducted fairly; if not, then it has caused prejudice to the charged 806 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports employee – In the present case, the appellant submitted a detailed response to the inquiry report however, his claims were dismissed by a single sentence that the same were not acceptable – This is not part of a fair procedure – Constitution of India – Articles 14, 16, 21 and 311 – Judicial review. [Paras 35, 40] Case Law Cited Union of India v. H.C. Goel [1964] 4 SCR 718 : 1963 SCC OnLine SC 16 – followed.
Maneka Gandhi v. India [1978] 2 SCR 621 : (1978) 1 SCC 248; Madhyamam Broadcasting Ltd. v. Union of India [2023] 10 SCR 595 : (2023) 13 SCC 401 – referred to.
List of Acts Punjab Civil Services (Punishment & Appeal Rules, 1970); Constitution of India.
List of Keywords Disciplinary proceedings; Disciplinary action; Disciplinary authority; Inquiry Officer; Election Commission; Election duty; Leave without sanction; Pulse polio programme; Senior Medical Officer; Senior Doctor; Civil Surgeon; Orders of the superior officers not complied with; Inquiry report; Serious misconduct; Cut in pension; Full pension; Principles of Natural Justice; Vengeance; Public servant; Leave; Limited notice issued at the time of admission; Intra-court appeal; Lack of procedural fairness; Judicial review of the decision of the Disciplinary Authority; Prejudice.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal No. 183 of 2025 From the Judgment and Order dated 19.04.2022 of the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh in LPA No. 600 of 2021 Appearances for Parties P. S. Patwalia, Sr. Adv., M/s. Bakshi & Associates, Advs. for the Appellant.
Ms. Nupur Kumar, Adv. for the Respondents.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 807Bhupinderpal Singh Gill v. State of Punjab and Others Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment Dipankar Datta, J.
Facts
1. The appellant was at the twilight of his long career of 34 (thirty-four) years in public service. At the relevant time, he was holding the post of Senior Medical Officer, CHC, Dirba, District Sangrur, under the Health and Family Welfare Department, Government of Punjab 1 . Eleven days prior to the appellant’s retirement on superannuation on 31 st March, 2017, he was served with a charge-sheet dated 20 th March, 2017 in connection with disciplinary action that was proposed against him under Rule 8 of the Punjab Civil Services (Punishment & Appeal Rules, 1970).
2. The charge-sheet alleged that the appellant had committed misconduct by (i) not complying with the direction of the Election Commission;
(ii) proceeding on leave without sanction thereof; (iii) failing to take part in the pulse polio programme and giving threats for legal action to the Senior Assistant of the Civil Surgeon, Sangrur2 ; and (iv) not complying with the orders of the superior officers.
3. Consequent to pendency of the disciplinary proceedings, an order was issued on 31 st March, 2017 refusing the appellant extension of service; instead, the appellant was relieved of his duty and made to retire on 31 st March, 2017 (afternoon). It was recorded in the said order that such retirement would not affect the disciplinary proceedings pending against the appellant; also, if any amount is recoverable from him, the GoP would have the right to recover such amount.
4. Almost a year lapsed, since the charge-sheet was issued to the appellant, without any development. As late as on 23rd February, 2018, a retired bureaucrat (a member of the Indian Administrative Service) was appointed as the Inquiry Officer.
5. The appellant, despite not having responded to the charge-sheet, diligently participated in the inquiry before the Inquiry Officer. While 1 GoP 2 Civil Surgeon 808 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports refuting the charges levelled against him, the appellant crossexamined the two witnesses produced on behalf of the prosecution in support of the charges. The appellant also furnished an explanation vis-à-vis the incidents before he proceeded on leave. Upon purported consideration of the evidence led by the prosecution and the explanation furnished by the appellant, the Inquiry Officer submitted a report of enquiry concluding as follows:
“Keeping in view the above, all the charges No. 1 to 4 levelled in the charge-sheet against Sh. Bhupinder Singh Gill. Service No. 3674, Senior Medical Officer (Retd) are proved, but so far as the matter of giving threat to take legal action against the Assistant of the office of Civil Surgeon that is not proved.”
6. The report of the Inquiry Officer was furnished to the appellant vide a memo dated 7th September, 2018 and his comments were sought. By his reply dated 9th September, 2018, the appellant sought to highlight the infirmities in the inquiry report and prayed that the disciplinary proceedings be dropped.
7. The Principal Secretary of the Health and Family Welfare Department, GoP3 , passed a final order dated 11 th October, 2019 upon purported consideration of the charge-sheet, the evidence led in course of the inquiry by the prosecution, the defence of the appellant, the inquiry report and the response of the appellant thereto. He ordered a cut in pension based on the observations/findings made by him. The contents of the said order will be noticed at a later part of this judgment. Proceedings beFore the high court
8. The order of the Disciplinary Authority dated 11 th October, 2019, ordering a cut of 2% pension with cumulative/permanent effect, was challenged by the appellant in a writ petition4 before the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh 5 . A single Judge of the High Court, vide judgment and order dated 26 th February, 2021, dismissed the writ petition.
3 Disciplinary Authority
4 CWP-34272-2019 (O&M)
5 High Court [2025] 1 S.C.R. 809Bhupinderpal Singh Gill v. State of Punjab and Others
9. Aggrieved thereby, the appellant presented an intra-court appeal 6 . The Division Bench of the High Court by its judgment and order dated 19 th April, 2022 allowed the appeal in part by modifying the punishment imposed upon the appellant by the Disciplinary Authority. Instead of the penalty of 2% pension cut with cumulative/permanent effect, the same was altered to 2% pension cut for a period of 5 years whereafter the appellant was made entitled to full pension upon “completion of five years period from the date the inflicted punishment has been effected”.
the challenge
10. This appeal, by special leave, mounts a challenge to the said judgment and order dated 19th April, 2022 of the Division Bench of the High Court, although partial relief was granted thereby to the appellant. contentions oF the Parties
11. Mr. Patwalia, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant, contended that having regard to the materials on record it is clear as crystal that the appellant did not commit any misconduct warranting punishment. According to him, the disciplinary proceedings were initiated by the respondents to teach the appellant a lesson for having questioned their actions before the High Court in several proceedings. Reference was made by him to proceedings instituted by the appellant before the High Court alleging contempt against some of the high- ranking officials of the GoP. In pursuance thereof, the respondents had to cough up in excess of Rs. 3,00,000/- (three lakh) to the appellant, of which he had been illegally deprived. Our attention was further invited to the evidence led on behalf of the prosecution as well as the specific defence taken by the appellant to demonstrate the perversity in the findings of the Inquiry Officer as well as the order of penalty passed by the Disciplinary Authority.
12. Mr. Patwalia also submitted that the appellant having been in public service in excess of three decades without blemish, the governmental action of initiating disciplinary proceedings a few days prior to his retirement and imposing on him the unwarranted penalty of ordering of a cut in pension, which is the source of his sustenance in the winter years of his life, is absolutely arbitrary apart from smacking 6 LPA No. 600 of 2021 (O&M)
810 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports of mala fide, which the High Court failed to take note of. He, thus, prayed that the orders of the Disciplinary Authority, the Single Judge and the Division Bench be set aside and all benefits be restored in favour of the appellant to which he was legitimately entitled.
13. Per contra, appearing for the respondents, Ms. Nupur, learned counsel contended that inquiry was conducted by the Inquiry Officer by granting reasonable, sufficient and adequate opportunity to the appellant to defend himself. There has been no breach of principle of natural justice in proceeding against the appellant and rightly, the appellant has not so alleged. The findings returned by the Inquiry Officer are based on legal evidence and the order of the Disciplinary Authority imposing penalty demonstrates application of mind to the materials on record. Thus, no interference is called for.
14. Our attention was drawn by Ms. Nupur to the order dated 28 th July, 2021 issuing notice on the intra-court appeal. According to her, limited notice was issued to the effect that 2% cut in pension could have been for a limited period and not with cumulative/permanent effect. Relief having been provided by the Division Bench by the impugned order, she concluded by submitting that the appellant can have no cause for any further grievance.
the issues
15. The broad issue emerging for decision is, whether the impugned order of the High Court, in which the Disciplinary Authority’s order imposing penalty and the order of the Single Judge dismissing the writ petition of the appellant have merged, warrants any interference on any of the grounds available for judicial review. Besides, we are also tasked to decide the objection that limited notice having been issued at the time of admission of the intra-court appeal and the appellant’s grievance being addressed, this Court ought not to enlarge the scope of the appeal.
analysis
16. We have perused the documents on record including the inquiry report and other relevant materials.
17. At the outset, we propose to deal with the objection raised by Ms. Nupur.
18. It is true that limited notice was issued by the Division Bench while admitting the intra-court appeal. However, a reading of the impugned [2025] 1 S.C.R. 811Bhupinderpal Singh Gill v. State of Punjab and Others order does not reveal that the Division Bench while disposing of such appeal considered the sole point on which limited notice was issued; on the contrary, arguments were advanced by the parties on similar lines as advanced before us and after noting the rival claims, the Division Bench proceeded to dispose of the appeal by holding as follows:
“In the present case also, the petitioner has put in service of 34 years and not an iota of material has been brought on record to even remotely suggest that the writ petitioner had been a trouble maker or undisciplined employee or habitual of absenting himself from work without permission. On the contrary, the factors that ostensibly appear to have influenced the competent authority have also been candidly pleaded and brought on record i.e. actively pursuing litigation in which the highest authority of the department i.e. Principal Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department, Punjab was as such a party respondent by name, as contemnor, in COCP No.2304 of 2013 titled ‘Dr. Bhupinder Pal Singh Gill vs. Smt. Vini Mahajan and others’. No material has been brought to our notice that the aforesaid factual aspect was ever denied or refuted or appropriately dealt with, at the time of imposing the punishment.
Keeping in view the above discussion, the material available on record, ratio of the judgments referred to and the peculiar facts and circumstances, we are of the considered opinion that the punishment inflicted on the writ petitioner being a 2% cut in pension, in perpetuity, even if the finding with regard to the charges is left untouched, is disproportionate to the misconduct and is sufficient to shock the conscience of the Court. Thus, the writ petitioner does not deserve to be treated any differently and as such taking a consistent view, the present appeal is liable to be allowed partly and the order of punishment deserves to be modified accordingly. Therefore, the ends of justice would be met if the impugned punishment is modified to be for a limited specific period other than being in perpetuity i.e. with cumulative effect. None the less, the same would still act as a deterrent for other employees to discharge the duties in a proper manner and remain careful to follow all instructions issued from time to time.
812 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports Accordingly, the order dated 26.02.2021 and the order dated 28.04.2021 passed by the writ Court are set aside and the order dated 11.10.2019 (Annexure P-13) passed by Principal Secretary, Punjab Government, Health and Family Welfare Department, imposing 2% cut in pension with cumulative/permanent effect, is modified to that of 2% cut in pension for a period of 5 years. Consequently, full pension would be restored on the completion of give years period from the date the inflicted punishment has been effected.”
(emphasis supplied)
In view of the approach adopted by the Division Bench in examining the contentious issues arising before it, we consider the objection of Ms. Nupur to be without substance.
19. Even otherwise, issuing limited notice at the stage of admission does not bar a Constitutional Court having inherent powers to pass such orders as the justice of the case before it demands to enlarge the scope of a petition/appeal at the stage of final hearing. Any observation that the court may choose to make while entertaining the petition/appeal by issuing limited notice ought to be regarded as tentative. Such observation cannot limit the court’s jurisdiction to consider the controversy, as raised, in its entire perspective. Whether or not the court would enlarge the scope is, however, a question which is largely dependent on the facts and circumstances of each case. If the court seized of the petition/appeal considers that the justice of the case before it demands enlargement of the scope, notwithstanding that a limited notice had been issued earlier, the court’s powers are not fettered particularly when enforcement of any Fundamental/Constitutional right is urged by the party approaching it. We, therefore, see no reason to accept the objection of Ms. Nupur and show the appellant the door at the threshold.
20. Having dealt with the objection, it is now time to consider the merits of the appellant’s claim and decide the broad issue.
21. The appellant applied on 27th January, 2017 for availing leave on 28th , 30 th and 31 st , January, 2017 to attend proceedings pending before the High Court. Since the details of the proceedings have been noted by the Division Bench and the same have not been disputed by the respondents, we refrain from referring to it here.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 813Bhupinderpal Singh Gill v. State of Punjab and Others
22. The case of the prosecution was that the appellant had proceeded on leave without the same being sanctioned, defying the directions of the Election Commission and the higher authorities, and without participating in the pulse polio programme.
23. The allegation levelled against the appellant was sought to be established by the prosecution by examining two witnesses, (i) a clerk (PW-1) in the office of the Civil Surgeon and (ii) a senior assistant (PW-2) in the branch office of the Director, Health and Family Welfare.
24. Referring to the records, PW-1 gave a statement that the appellant proceeded on leave on 27 th January, 2017 without getting his casual leave sanctioned and without handing over charge of his post to anyone. The appellant was informed of non-sanction of his leave by the Senior Assistant in the office of the Civil Surgeon on telephone to which the appellant responded by saying that he be not harassed by making phone calls and also that since he has no duty for the pulse polio programme, he would take legal action. Reference was then made by PW-1 to a letter dated 06th January, 2017 of the Secretary, Health and Managing Director, Punjab Health System Corporation, Punjab 7 to the effect that grant of leave was closed due to Election Code in Punjab and that directions had been made by the appropriate authority of the Election Office, keeping in view the Election Code, that leave be not granted to any officer/official; however, despite knowledge of the same, the appellant had proceeded on leave.
25. In course of cross-examination, PW-1 stated that no call detail is available regarding the telephonic message purportedly given by the Senior Assistant to the appellant and it is only the Senior Assistant who would be in a position to throw light because PW-1 did not have any record of conversation. It was also admitted that on cancellation of leave, separate letter was not written to the appellant; also that, as per the record, no duty had been assigned to the appellant in the pulse polio programme from 29 th January, 2017 to 31st January, 2017 or by the Election Commission. The letter dated 6th January, 2017 of the M.D., PHSC did not prohibit grant of leave to Senior Medical Officer; however, it prohibited grant of leave to specialist Doctor/General Medical Officer and para-medical staff, and leave to them could only be granted in special situations upon obtaining the
7 M.D., PHSC
814 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Supreme Court Reports approval of the Director, Health. PW-1 reiterated, while responding to a question as to the time when leave of the appellant was cancelled, that the Civil Surgeon cancelled the leave on 27 th January due to Election Code and pulse polio programme but that there is no record regarding time. He also admitted the absence of any Government Order requiring communication of non-sanction of leave through telephone and not in writing. He was unaware as to whether the appellant had been charge-sheeted for keeping him away “from the fruits of extension in service”.
26. As PW-2, the Senior Assistant produced a document dated 30 th January, 2017 (Ex.PW/2/1) of the Civil Surgeon which was addressed to the Additional Chief Secretary (Health) conveying that the appellant proceeded on leave on 27 th January, 2017 without such leave being sanctioned, without informing anybody and without handing over charge to anybody. Further, PW-2 stated that due to Election Code “the leave were closed” and that the Senior Assistant of the Civil Surgeon had informed the appellant regarding cancellation of leave on telephone owing to Election Code and pulse polio programme from 29th January, 2017 to 31 st January, 2017.
27. In course of cross-examination by the appellant, PW-2 admitted that in the letter of the Civil Surgeon, being Ex.PW/2/1, call record of the Senior Assistant, call details and confirmation of calls made are not available.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.