Geetha V.M. & Ors. v. Rethnasenan K. & Ors.
- Citation
- 2025 INSC 33; [2025] 1 S.C.R. 515
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Bench
- 2 Judges: Justice J.K. Maheshwari, Justice Rajesh Bindal
- Decided
- 2 Jan 2025
- Case number
- CIVIL APPEAL No. 3994/2024
Not a certified copy. Text extracted from the judgment PDF published by the Supreme Court of India. Verify against the certified copy before relying on it. Source: Supreme Court of India, via the Indian Supreme Court Judgments dataset by Dattam Labs (CC-BY-4.0). Retrieved 17 Nov 2026, 12:21 am. Original source ↗
Preview: first 50% of the document.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 515 : 2025 INSC 33 Geetha V.M. & Ors.
v.
Rethnasenan K. & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No(s). 3994-3997 of 2024)
03 January 2025 [J.K. Maheshwari* and Rajesh Bindal, JJ.] Issue for Consideration Whether the option exercised by Directorate of Health Services (DHS) employees to join Directorate of Medical Education (DME) pursuant to a policy decision of the State of Kerala ought to be considered as an option for absorption or a request for transfer under proviso to Rule 27(a) of Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1958 and in that situation, the inter-se seniority of such employees in the DME shall be reckoned from which date. Headnotes† Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1958 – Proviso to r.27(a) – Kerala Service Rules, 1959 – r.36 – Transfer of the appellants-absorbed employees by way of absorption as per the policy decision of the Government of Kerala, if would attract the proviso to r.27(a):
Held: No – The proviso of r.27(a) is merely an exception to the said Rule of maintaining the seniority from the date of appointment in the cases of ‘on request’ and mutual transfer – The exception is not attracted in a case of transfer by way of absorption made in public interest or in administrative exigencies – Transfer of an employee is an incidence of service if it is in public interest – Government is the best judge to decide how to distribute and utilise the services of an employee – However, if employee makes a request due to some hardship and if the authority or the Government on being satisfied, posts such employee as per request, such transfer is not a transfer in public interest as it is on the request of the employee and not in the exigencies of the public administration – In the present case, the transfer was made by way of absorption on the basis of option and not on the basis of request which was in furtherance to a policy decision of the Govt. to abolish the dual control system enhancing the efficiency * Author 516 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports of the administration of medical colleges and attached hospitals thereto giving it to DME withdrawing from DHS – Therefore, the transfer by way of absorption on exercise of option as specified in Appendix I and II contained in G.O. dtd. 25.10.2008 does not attract the proviso to r.27(a) which only deals with the transfer on request or on mutual request – Thus, the action taken in public interest due to administrative exigency even on option is different than the action done on request – Appellants exercised the option for absorption by transfer from DHS to DME in line with the policy decision and thus, it cannot be considered as a case of transfer based on their own request, volition or voluntary choice – Proviso to r.27(a) is not attracted in case of a transfer by way of absorption done by the Department in furtherance to the policy decision of the Govt. – Transfer by way of absorption in public interest cannot be equated with the transfer on request in contingencies as specified in proviso to r.27(a) or applied mutually – Further, seniority of the absorbed employee cannot be disturbed applying the proviso of r.27(a) – Their seniority and inter-se seniority be maintained as per r.27(a) and 27(c) of Part II of 1958 Rules r/w clarificatory letter dated 24.04.2010 with reference to r.8 of Appendix I to G.O. dated 25.10.2008 – Impugned judgment set aside. [Paras 37, 39, 47, 51-53] Words and Phrases – ‘Transfer’; ‘option’; ‘absorb’; ‘absorption’ – Discussed.
Case Law Cited K.P. Sudhakaran and Another v. State of Kerala and Others (2006) 5 SCC 386 – held inapplicable.
Kartar Singh v. State of Punjab, 1989 SCC OnLine P&H 482 – approved.
Books and Periodicals Cited P. Ramanatha Aiyar’s Advanced Law Lexicon, 7th Edition; Corpus Juris Secundum; Merriam-Webster Dictionary; Black’s Law Dictionary.
List of Acts Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1958; Kerala Service Rules (KSR), 1959.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 517Geetha V.M. & Ors. v. Rethnasenan K. & Ors. List of Keywords Transfer; Transfer by way of absorption; Exercise of option; Absorbed employees; Request for transfer; Transfer on request; Mutual request; Seniority; Inter-se seniority; Directorate of Health Services (DHS); Administrative control of DHS; Directorate of Medical Education (DME); State of Kerala; Primary Health Centres (PHCs); Community Health Centres (CHCs); Taluk Hospitals; District Hospitals; Specialty Hospitals; Policy decision; Public interest; Transfer in public interest; Dual control system; Hospitals; Administration of medical colleges; Administrative exigency; public administration; Clarificatory letter; transfer applied mutually; ‘Option’; ‘Absorb’; ‘Absorption’.
Case Arising From CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Civil Appeal Nos. 3994-3997 of 2024 From the Judgment and Order dated 13.03.2019 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in WA Nos. 1418, 1525, 1527 and 1652 of 2010 Appearances for Parties V. Giri, Jayanth Muth Raj, Sr. Advs., Krishna Dev Jagarlamudi, Alim Anvar, Harshed Sundar, Mohammed Sadique T.A., Advs. for the Appellants.
Jaideep Gupta, Raghenth Basant, Sr. Advs., C. K. Sasi, Ms. Meena K Poulose, Riddhi Bose, Ms. Racheeta Chawla, Ms. Rishi Agarwal, Ms. Sampriti Bakshi, Siddharth Banerjee, Dileep Poolakkot, Ms. Hima Bhardwaj, K. Rajeev, Arvind Gupta, Advs. for the Respondents.
Judgment / Order of the Supreme Court Judgment J.K. Maheshwari, J.
1. The present appeals have been filed impugning the order passed by High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam on 13.03.2019 in W.A. Nos. 1418, 1525, 1527 and 1652 of 2010, reversing the judgments dated 29.06.2010 and 30.06.2010 passed by learned Single Judge 518 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports in W.P. (C) Nos. 4599, 12381 and 14091 of 2010 and W.P. (C) No. 20269 of 2010 respectively.
2. Appellants herein are the employees who were working in the Directorate of Health Services (the “DHS”), later absorbed on furnishing option as demanded, in the Directorate of Medical Education (the “DME”) on account of abolition of dual control system of the staff in medical colleges under the policy decision of the State of Kerala. The rival claims of inter-se seniority between the original employees of DME (hereinafter referred as ‘original employees’) and absorbed employees from DHS in the respective categories of DME (hereinafter referred to as ‘absorbed employees’) made by both were decided by the order impugned.
3. Writ Petition No. 4599/2010 was filed by the absorbed employees contending that they are entitled to retain their existing seniority even on absorption in the DME in terms of Rule 8 of Appendix I of the G.O. (P) No. 548/2008/H&FWD dated 25.10.2008. Since the inter-se seniority of the absorbed employees was yet to be finalized, during the pendency of the said Writ Petition, promotions made to the post of Junior Superintendent and Upper Division Clerks in the DME were cancelled.
4. In the meantime, the Government of Kerala issued clarificatory letter No. 8195/K1/10/H&FWD dated 24.04.2010 (the “clarificatory letter”) indicating that seniority of the absorbed employees shall be reckoned from the date of order of promotion for the promotees and from the date of first effective advice in case of direct recruits. The said clarificatory letter was assailed by filing Writ Petitions Nos. 12381 and 14091 of 2010 by the original employees. The case set out was that once the absorbed employees were transferred after exercising their ‘option’, in terms of G.O. (P) No. 548/2008/H&FWD dated 25.10.2008, to join DME, they must rank junior and be placed at the bottom of the seniority list and their seniority be reckoned from the date of joining in the DME as per Rule 27(a) and Rule 27(c) of ‘Kerala State and Subordinate Service Rules, 1958 (in short “KS&SS Rules”).
5. Learned Single Judge decided the writ petitions of the original and absorbed employees by passing the common judgment and relying upon Rule 8 of Appendix I of G.O. dated 25.10.2008 opined that seniority of staff who opted to join DME will be maintained as per Rule 27(a) and 27(c) of Part II, KS&SS Rules and the clarificatory letter [2025] 1 S.C.R. 519Geetha V.M. & Ors. v. Rethnasenan K. & Ors. dated 24.04.2010. The Writ petition filed by the absorbed employees was allowed and the Writ Petitions of the original employees were dismissed holding that absorbed employees would be entitled to retain their past service rendered in DHS and their seniority in DME shall be reckoned from the date of initial appointment in DHS.
6. On filing Writ Appeal by the original employees of DHS, the Division Bench by the order impugned set-aside the judgment of learned Single Judge and observed that once absorbed employees had joined DME on their own request opting for inter-departmental transfer, proviso to Rule 27(a) of Part II of KS&SS Rules, would attract and the seniority of the absorbed employees will be determined with reference to their date of joining in the DME. The said order is under challenge in these appeals.
Factual Background
7. Prior in time, DME was formed w.e.f. 10.05.1983, to manage and coordinate Medical Colleges and Collegiate Hospitals in the State of Kerala. Hospitals attached to medical colleges were under the control of the DME, while Primary Health Centres (PHCs), Community Health Centres (CHCs), Taluk Hospitals, District Hospitals and Specialty Hospitals were under the control of DHS. Before formation of the DME, medical colleges were operated independently but under the administrative control of DHS and the ‘Principal’ was the head of the department. After formation of DME, the authority of Principal was transferred to DME, however, the ‘nursing, paramedical, and ministerial staff’ associated with hospitals and affiliated institutions continued to remain under the administrative control of DHS which also included the power of appointment. This resulted in ‘dual control’, where even though administrative authority of the medical colleges and collegiate hospitals was shifted to DME, but the staff continued to remain under the control of DHS, due to which significant delay and administrative difficulties were being faced in ensuring timely assignment/posting of Staff Nurses, Nursing Assistants, Technicians, Attendants, Cleaning Staff, and other categories of Paramedical Staff at Medical College Hospitals and affiliated institutions. Additionally, Superintendents of Medical Colleges and Heads of Clinical Departments were encountering tremendous hardship to maintain discipline amongst staff inter-se departments. Resultantly, it posed as an extreme impediment for the Government of Kerala to ensure smooth functioning of both the Departments.
520 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports
8. Elaborating on further challenges, particularly regarding appointments, majority of the hospital staff was appointed either by the DHS or the District Medical Officer. Although Hospital Superintendents had the power to initiate disciplinary action, yet the power for appointments, transfers, promotions, and discipline for these employees continued to remain with the DHS or District Medical Officer. Identifying the issues, the Government of Kerala formed several committees that recommended elimination of dual control system in Medical Colleges as a corrective measure, aimed for benefiting the public at large. To cite few examples, as per Indian Medical Council regulations, “All the teaching hospitals shall be under the academic, administrative and disciplinary control of Dean / Principals of Medical Colleges or Medical Institutions”; as per State Planning Board’s Working Group report on Health, Nutrition and Sanitation on 10th Five Year Plan (2002 – 2007), the Principals / Superintendent of Medical Colleges have no administrative or disciplinary control over the staff. Therefore, all the above categories of paramedical and ministerial staff in Medical College Hospitals and attached other hospitals have to be appointed directly by DME and the existing staff must be given freedom to opt for either DHS or DME and all new appointments must be done separately.
9. Further, the ‘Estimates Committee’ (1998 – 2000) of Kerala Legislature in its 28 th Report recommended that the employees working in the Medical Colleges such as Nurses, Paramedical Staff are to be bifurcated from DHS and are to be brought under the control of DME and the existing staff should be given an opportunity to exercise option. Subsequent thereto, ‘Estimates Committee’ (2001 – 2004) of the Kerala Legislature reiterated that employees working in medical colleges shall be brought under the control of DME and staff which at present is in existing control of DHS should be afforded an opportunity to furnish options either of DHS or DME. The State Government after examining the recommendations in public interest accorded sanction to abolish the dual control system for the Staff attached to the Medical Colleges and Hospitals and brought them out from the administrative and disciplinary control of DHS by issuing the G.O. (MS) No. 124/2007/H&FWD dated 01.06.2007.
10. While according sanction, the State decided to ask for the options from existing employees of the DHS to move to the posts which stood transferred to DME. The relevant clauses of the said G.O. for understanding are quoted herein below – [2025] 1 S.C.R. 521Geetha V.M. & Ors. v. Rethnasenan K. & Ors. "1. The sanctioned posts of all categories of staff (except doctors in Primary Health Centres who are appointed by the Health Services Department) such as Nursing, Paramedical and Ministerial Staff in the hospitals under the Director of Medical Education will stand shifted to the service of Directorate of Medical Education w.e.f. 01.06.2007.
2. The employees of the Health Services Department now working against these shifted posts shall be treated as on deputation to the Directorate of Medical Education, until further orders.
3. The existing employees of Health Services Department will be given an opportunity to exercise opinion (sic)
to move to the posts transferred to the Director of Medical Education. A committee will be constituted under the Chairmanship of Secretary (Health), with Director of health Services, as Convener for discussions with service organizations regarding rules for exercising of option, the arrangements to be made in the Health Service Department due to the transfer of these posts, promotion and other service matters and for submitting recommendations to Government.
4. The appointing authority of the transferred categories of posts (except last grade service posts) will be Director of Medical Education. The Principal will be the appointing authority of last grade service posts.
5. (i) The appointment to the category / post of Nursing Assistant now transferred to Directorate of Medical Education shall be made by direct recruitment and the special rules will be changed accordingly. The Director of Medical Education will submit proposals for qualification for direct recruitment to the post of Nursing Assistant.
(ii) However, the existing vacancies of Nursing Assistants are to be filled up by promoting the eligible Hospital attendants after giving them training. Direct recruitment as per 5 (i) above shall be done only to 522 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports the remaining vacancies, after giving promotion to all the eligible Hospital – Attendants.
(iii) Considering the acute shortage of staff, the Last grade service special rules shall be deemed to be modified in the public interest in the case of Directorate of Medical Education only and the Principals are permitted to make temporary appointment through Employment Exchange to all the vacant posts in the categories of Nursing Assistant and Hospital Grade – I and II, except the vacancies to be kept apart for promotion of eligible hands in these posts.
(iv) The Secretary (Health) is authorized to obtain remarks from PSC if required for the implementation of any of the above decisions and submit proposals.
(v) The steps to transfer of budget allotment for salary and other items from Director of Health Services to Director of Medial (sic) Education will be taken up in consultation with Finance Department.”
xx xx xx xx
11. From the aforementioned G.O., it is also evident that State actively intended to identify the issues and decided to address them involving all the stakeholders. After extensive deliberations with all, the Government of Kerala by G.O. (Ms.) No. 163/07/H&FWD, dated 16.07.2007, constituted a Committee under the Chairmanship of Additional Secretary (Health) to resolve the issues related to abolition of dual control system. A meeting was convened on 10.10.2007 with all the stakeholders inviting their views and suggestions. During the meeting, highlighting the recommendations of the Estimates Committee (1998-2000) and Estimates Committee (2001-2004), consensus was reached to implement the same. After extensive discussions, the committee framed the ‘Draft Rules’ for options, ‘Draft Option form’, and the qualifications required and method of appointment for the categories other than the common categories in DHS and DME, which were required to be absorbed.
12. The Government of Kerala vide G.O. (Rt.) No. 1273/08/H&FWD, dated 07.04.2008, and G.O. (Rt.) No. 2321/08/H&FWD, dated 05.07.2008, also nominated Administrative Officer, Kerala Heart Foundation along [2025] 1 S.C.R. 523Geetha V.M. & Ors. v. Rethnasenan K. & Ors. with Nodal Officers from DHS and DME to coordinate and oversee the implementation of abolition of dual control system. Based on the aforesaid, the Committee submitted the ‘Draft Rules’ and also the ‘Draft Form of option’ to the Government for consideration and approval.
13. Having considered these recommendations, the State Government issued G.O. (P) No. 548/2008/H&FWD dated 25.10.2008, partially modifying the G.O. dated 01.06.2007 and directed that all the ministerial staff, nurses, paramedical staff, including last grade staff under the establishment of DHS working with the DME, shall be brought under the administrative control of the DME, subject to furnishing options as specified in the rules contained in ‘Appendix I’ and form contained in ‘Appendix II’.
14. Appendix I of the G.O. dated 25.10.2008 is titled as ‘Rules for filing option by the staff, on abolition of dual control systems’. Rule 8 therein governs the seniority of staff who have opted for the DME. This Rule is central to the present dispute and extracted for ready reference below – “…..8. The seniority of the staff opted to Department of Medical Education will be maintained as per Rule 27(a)
and Rule 27(c) of Part II, KS & SS Rules.”
15. Appendix II of the said G.O. was for option which is in shape of a form required details of the employee and declaration. The declaration is relevant, which is extracted hereinbelow for ready reference – “ DECLARATION I, …. hereby opt to be absorbed / continued in the Department of Medical Education and if my option is accepted, I will not put forth any claim in future to return to Health Services Department under any provisions.
Place: Signature:
Date: Name and Designation”
xx xx xx xx
16. In furtherance of the G.O. dated 01.06.2007 and G.O. dated 25.10.2008, an ‘Option Cell’ with officers from DHS and DME both was constituted to scrutinize the option forms submitted by the existing 524 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports employees from DHS. After scrutiny, 3072 options against 6022 transferred posts were found valid, and the list of 3072 employees ‘seniority wise’ and ‘category wise’ was forwarded by DHS for switching them to DME. In continuance, State Government vide G.O. (P) No. 56/2009/H&FWD dated 27.02.2009, directed that 6022 posts under DHS establishment will be ‘shifted’ to DME. It was also made clear vide Order No. PLA1-2462/05/DHS dated 28.02.2009 that lien of the employees whose names were forwarded shall stand transferred from DHS to DME.
17. In the meantime, since the model code of conduct for the General Elections of 2009 came into effect from 02.03.2009, therefore, the said two G.O.s mentioned above could not be implemented. After elections and on formation of new Government, in supersession of the previous G.O.s dated 27.02.2009 and 28.02.2009, the G.O. (P) No. 167/2009/H&FWD dated 17.06.2009 was issued directing that 3096 posts in 57 categories will be forthwith transferred to the DME, and the DHS will issue orders transferring those employees category wise and station wise. As such, the employees of DHS included in the list be continued in DME, as per their options. The employees of DHS not included in the list of DME were allowed to continue on deputation as per G.O. 01.06.2007 until further orders.
18. In the meantime, clarifications were sought by the DME about fixation of seniority of staff who opted for DME from DHS. The State Government vide its clarificatory letter dated 24.04.2010 clarified that the seniority of the staff who opted for DME, will be reckoned as per Rules 27(a) & 27(c) of Part II, KS&SS Rules, i.e., as per date of order of promotion in case of promotees and as per date of first effective advice in case of direct recruits (entry cadre) in the respective categories in the DHS.
Relevant Rules
19. In reference to the various G.O.s, the KS&SS Rules referred above are also relevant, therefore, extracted here as under – “27. Seniority – (a) Seniority of a person in a service, class, category or grade shall, unless he has been reduced to a lower rank as punishment, be determined by the date of the order of his first appointment to such service, class, category or grade.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 525Geetha V.M. & Ors. v. Rethnasenan K. & Ors. Explanation – For the purposes of this sub-rule, “appointment” shall not include appointment under rule 9 or appointment by promotion under Rule 31.
This amendment shall be deemed to have come into force with effect on and from the 17th December, 1958, but shall not affect the seniority of any member of a service settled prior to the date of publication of this amendment in the Gazette:
Provided that the seniority of persons on mutual or interunit or inter-departmental transfer from one Unit to another within the same Department or from one Department to another, as the case may be, on requests from such persons shall be determined with reference to the dates of their joining duty in the new Unit or Department. In the case of more than one person joining duty in the same grade in the same Unit or Department on the same date, seniority shall be determined, –
(a) if the persons who join duty belong to different unit or different departments, with reference to their age, the older being considered as senior, and
(b) if the persons who join duty belong to the same category of post in the same department, in accordance with their seniority in the Unit or Department from which they were transferred…….
(b) (This sub-rule is not relevant for the case)
(c) Notwithstanding anything contained in clauses (a)
and (b) above, the seniority of a person appointed to a class, category or grade in a service on the advice of the Commission shall, unless he has been reduced to a lower rank as punishment, be determined by the date of first effective advice made for his appointment to such class, category or grade and when two or more persons are included in the same list of candidates advised, their relatives seniority shall be fixed according to the order in which their names are arranged in the advice list:
526 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports Provided that the seniority of candidates who have been granted extension of time to join duty beyond three months from the date of the appointment order, except those who are undergoing courses of study or training which are prescribed as essential qualification for the post to which they are advised for appointment, shall be determined by the date of their joining duty:…….”
20. From contextual perusal of Rule 27(a), the seniority of a person will be determined from the date of the order of his first appointment to such service, class, category or grade. Proviso to it deals with the contingency where an employee asks for transfer mutually or interunit or inter-departmental from one unit to another within the same Department or from one Department to another as the case may be. On such transfers, the seniority of the person who requested, shall be determined from the date of joining and as per clause (a) and (b) of the said proviso.
21. Thus, accompanying proviso only contemplates determination of seniority when transfer as specified therein has been sought mutually and on request. It is relevant to clarify that the language of the proviso does not deal with the transfers of employees due to administrative exigencies or their transfer by way of absorption under the policy decision of the Government bifurcating the dual control system of the staff.
22. So far as Rule 27(c) is concerned, it deals with the relative seniority of the employees, by which the inter-se seniority of the employees appointed to a class, category or grade shall be fixed according to the order in which their names are arrayed in the first advice list for his appointment to such class, category or grade. For clear understanding, we can say the order of recommendations in the selection list by Commission or Selection Board, at the time of their selection, shall be relevant for maintaining the relative seniority as specified in the final advice memo of the Commission or Board as the case may be.
Findings recorded by learned Single Judge reversed by the Division Bench
23. The absorbed employees succeeded before learned Single Judge. The Court referring to Rule 8 of Appendix I of the G.O. dated [2025] 1 S.C.R. 527Geetha V.M. & Ors. v. Rethnasenan K. & Ors. 25.10.2008, held that seniority of the staff opted for joining DME will be maintained as per Rules 27(a) and 27(c) of Part II, KS&SS Rules and they will be entitled to get seniority including their past service under the DHS in terms of the aforementioned rules. The relevant findings are reproduced for ready reference as under – "5. It was thereupon that WP(C) No. 12381/10 and 14091/10 were filed by persons, who were employees of the DME. According to them, on exercising option and coming over to DME, the optees should rank junior most in seniority, and therefore, the clarification, as contained in Ext. P5 referred to above is illegal.
Therefore, the only question that arises is whether the optees of DHS who have come over to DME are entitled to retain their seniority for their prior service in DHS.
6. In my view, the issue can be answered with reference to Clause 8 of Appendix I of Ext. P1 order dated 25/10/2008, which provides that seniority of staff opted to Department of Medical Education will be maintained as per Rule 27(a) and Rule 27(c) of Part II KS&SSR. This precisely is what is reiterated in Ext. P5 and this order does not introduce anything which is not provided in Ext. P1. Clause 8 of Appendix 1 of Ext. P1 is also not under challenge in WP (C) Nos.
12381/10 or 14091/10. If that be so, necessarily, optees like the petitioners in WP(C) No.4599/10 and the additional party respondents in WP(C) No.
14091/2010 are entitled to seniority for their prior services under the DHS in terms of Rules 27(a)
and (c) of Part II KS&SSR.
xx xx xx xx
9. In view of the above, the challenge against Ext. P5 order referred to above dated 24.04.2010 raised in WP(C) Nos. 12381/10 and 14091/2010 will stand repelled. The claim of the petitioners in WP(C) No.
4599/10 for maintaining seniority for their service prior to exercising option, is upheld, in view of Clause 8 of Appendix 1 of Ext. P1 Government Order dated 528 [2025] 1 S.C.R.Digital Supreme Court Reports 25/10/2008 and Ext. P5 dated 24.4.2010 referred to above. The Directorate of Medical Education is directed to finalise the inter se seniority list of the optees and the existing employees of the Department in accordance with law and as expeditiously as possible.
24. Being aggrieved, the original employees filed Writ Appeal, which was allowed and the Division Bench vide impugned judgment set aside the order of the Single Bench. The findings as returned by Division Bench are reproduced below for ready reference – “The dual control system of hospital staff attached to the Directorate of Medical Education and Directorate of Health Services was abolished by Government Order dated 25.10.2008 and clause 8 of Appendix I of thereto is as follows:
“8. The seniority of the staff opted to Department of Medical Education will be maintained as per Rule 27(a) and Rule 27(c) of Part II, KS&SSR”.
2. Many employees in the Department of Health Services opted for transfer to the Department of Medical Education and necessarily therefore the proviso to Rule 27(a) of Part II of KS&SSR extracted below applies:
“Provided that the seniority of persons of mutual or inter unit or inter departmental transfer from one unit to another within the same department or from one department to another, as the case may be, on request from such persons shall be determined with reference to the dates of their joining duty in the new unit or department”.
(emphasis supplied)
3. The seniority of those employees who have opted from the Department of Health Services can only be determined with reference to the dates of their joining duty in the Department of Medical Education. The fact that they have given their option for an inter-departmental transfer indicates that it was on their request attracting the proviso to Rule 27(a) of Part II of KS&SSR.
[2025] 1 S.C.R. 529Geetha V.M. & Ors. v. Rethnasenan K. & Ors.
Continue reading
Sign in and become a member to continue reading this judgment and every other document in the library.
Members read the full text, download where permitted, and keep notes and bookmarks.